PORCUPINE TREE - HATESONG (HD)

Filmed at the Park West, Chicago, USA, 11-12 Oktober 2005

[@sebastiencamire2755]

Mr. Gavin Harrison on drums, ladies and gentlemen.

[@JackSchitte]

Mr. Gavin Harrison is worth the price of admission alone and I have never been one to center on any drummer before but he demands your attention.

[@sebastiencamire2755]

Randolph the frog & jack you sir reminded me that I haven't listened to this masterpiece today. Thank you ;) Gavin Harrison (and all the others on this stage) are straight up musical geniuses.

[@JackSchitte]

Sébastien Camiré glad to be of service. You are spot on about their talent. I found them about 2 years ago and haven't been able to get enough. Steven is amazing and has quite the history but I like this group he has assembled the most.

[@sebastiencamire2755]

Randolph the frog & jack Yes Porcupine Tree is definitely my favorite band. Their music is so tight and wonderfully structured and executed. Steven is my favorite individual artist, I've seen him twice since the release of Hand. Cannot. Erase. and both shows were fantastic, deep and flawless really (too young to have seen Porcupine Tree though ):

[@tawodiusdi8152]

Randolph the frog & jack I had given up on new bands. Gone were the likes of King Crimson, Genesis, YES, etc etc. then several years ago I find Mr Wilson and company. Thank you Rock God's. A musicians band to be sure. Talent, creativity, beauty, structure. If Mozart were alive today this is the band he'd be listening to.

[@brentcrude8565]

I love how Steven and Gavin are having an all-out, brutal sonic battle of sorts, while Colin and Richard are just super chill and doing their thing on the side. And yet somehow the whole thing stays as tight as Swiss clockwork. It's ridiculous.

[@tronlady1]

bloody bang on description of PT tbh :o)

[@shrondigerscat]

much better the live version . give some credit to bass player Mr. Colin who also wrote this masterpiece with steven wilson.

[@petarpavasovic6333]

Colin is an amazing musician! Very underrated unfortunately...

[@sixstringer3783]

He has the most rippin tone I friggin love his bass playing 🤘

[@tanmaybhonsale4221]

The talent shown by each member is outstanding. Brilliant performance!

[@antarikshray5064]

hi bro just found your comment! xD

[@electronicsandroboticsclub750]

@@antarikshray5064 lmao and i just found yours xD

[@ZendelWashington]

@@electronicsandroboticsclub750 proud to be new to this

[@aviavanish]

Meet Gavin Harrison, PhD. Mathematics and a part-time Drummer.

[@ronniekatashan]

Do you have a source on that?

[@nicolasriveros943]

@@ronniekatashan i think he was joking pal

[@kostaslemis9600]

hahahhahaha

[@prajolkansakar2937]

Loll loll

[@prajolkansakar2937]

@@nicolasriveros943 hahahah

[@dante666jt]

God was on drums \,,/ !

[@chiragmoily5802]

Yes!

[@666kiffbeast]

+Jeswin Thomas oh fucking YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS lets rock

[@adrian5b]

he was also singing

[@nickneveskalos]

I hate it when people compare Gavin Harrison and God. I mean he is good and all, but he is no Gavin Harisson

[@BaritoneRocks]

Neal Peart was not on drums, but a demigod was. :)

[@bencarrier2345]

That kids face at 4:29 is priceless... His face was getting melted....

[@MallikaMenon]

This is better than most love songs, lol

[@TheRickrockin]

Indian dekh k tumara muh ban jayega but thanks for apriciating the music.hope you have a good day 3 years later.. :-)

[@razorguy13396]

good one @Mallika

[@madhurjyadeka5569]

Lol selena gonez probably thinking about her song " Lovesong"

[@5micky2]

These guys believe in what they're doing. Total immersion in sonic drama.

[@DanielVerberne]

Well put!

[@ZendelWashington]

realer than real

[@dualiwolf5988]

6:47 GAVIN YOU ARE A GOD

[@Ujjwal772]

+Duali Wolf OMG! That was orgasmic

[@Glokmahr63]

+Duali Wolf Totally thought he saw a smudge or something while Colin was fiddlin'. Had to watch it again to be sure, haha.

[@pmancer]

haha just cleaning my drums didnt really hear the sound but it was definitely not what a normal man would do probably feasible proof that god exists

[@Azerty42069]

@@Glokmahr63 Gavin has a very methodical and precise way of drumming .. Unsure if this was on purpose for the very subtle noise it made, or if it's just for fun, either way this guy is an octopus.

[@EllipticGeometry]

@@Azerty42069 It’s one of Gavin’s licks. Joking aside, it’s actually a distinctive part of his vocabulary. It pops up now and then.

[@eleazarestrella6111]

I'm really impressed how this version is much better than studio version.

[@Eleventhearlofmars]

Wow, Gavin knows his way round his kit, some of the time signatures in his drumming are astounding 😳

[@GravelLeft]

I love that first guitar solo because he's just fucking around, it sounds so crazy and desperate, but it fits the song, I think I can hear his anger and frustration

[@RonLeite]

Man..thats song is full master piece...great bass !

[@nghivmai]

Hatesong is such a Greatsong.

[@rickmorse9884]

Wilson's cacaophonic guitar solo truly embodies everything that hatred is: it makes no sense in its irrationality.

[@pinheadguy68]

PT is amazing but having John Wesley on guitar and backup vocals is just brilliant imo

[@michaelclark7602]

I agree they should have asked him back

[@MrThebigcheese75]

Yep, from what I've seen of the latest gigs which I sadly could not make, just didn't seem as good without him. Not saying bad, maybe also Edwin should be asked back. I'm always watching or listening to the Tilberg sets.

[@Aditya-K-Balu]

Hats off to Steven Wilson’s stage presence. King of progressive rock. Gavin Harrison: the way he drum fills using just sticks. What a genius!

[@LeHieu-ex5dx]

I'm just a normal guy in a far-away corner of the world. And I must say that this performance is just fucking amazing. Too bad that I know about Steve Wilson and Porcupine Tree a little late.

[@ZendelWashington]

lol same

[@talalalmuslemani9359]

They started touring again, this is your chance to see them live

[@christelswift5461]

P.T. Are musician's musicians. Absolutely epic writing as well as tightly wound, perfect collaboration on the part of every band member make indelible live performances and infinitely enjoyable albums. In short...these guys fucking rock in the most pure, transcendental and innovative sense!!!

[@deepsky2115]

I like how the drum beat breaks at 07:56 into a normal one for 3 bars and then switches back to the songs normal rythm, EPIC!

[@lilymuu]

I'm a bit late, but I just wanted to say that's actually not even a typical 4/4 beat: Gavin is utilizing "metric modulation" there to give the _illusion_ that he's playing a straightforward beat. In reality, starting on count 4 (with a snare drum hit), Gavin actually begins playing eighth-note triplets over the rest of the band--they don't shift subdivisions. He's playing triplets on the ride and using the bell to create a quarter-note pulse by accenting every other hit; this is what gives the illusion that he's playing a basic 4/4 beat along with everyone else. But that's the catch: The pattern he's playing _is_ a basic 4/4 beat, it's just not played in the way that you would expect it!

[@RachitGupta01]

I love Colin Edwin ! He is always so happy playing his bass ! Look at 5:30 :D

[@texasnewt]

Obvious contentment!😊

[@134reini1969]

Gavin´s drumming is ridiculous, otherworldly, phenomenal, and cannot be described with words...

[@DanielVerberne]

I love how in the verse structure, Steven's chugging riffs are rock/bluesy, yet that single chord Barbieri plays either side of it makes it much darker.

[@manco828]

Not bluesy, Steven Wilson specifically has said he doesn't like blues music.

[@Sebastian_ignasi0]

+manco82 the fact that he doesn't like that style, doesn't mean he can't use some of its characteristics as a tool to write his own songs, if you have listened to blues you will see how the way that's used the pentatonic scale in here, added to the wah pedal and the picking, sounds bluesy

[@DanielVerberne]

Thankyou Sebastian, yes, it does sound bluesy, even if it isn't Steven Wilson's preferred genre. Blues is the basis of much of western music, of course.

[@massimilianorock70sdigiampietr]

+sebastian I agree with your thinking, right analysis and I hope it is enjoyed our friend ... bravo!

[@user-im3pq3tj8e]

No dominant chords, no blue note... How does this sound bluesy at all?

[@EllenCoxBrainiac]

I love Steven's amazing solo work, but damn I miss PPT and the amazing killer rock masterpieces!!!!

[@samerkamal3328]

Ellen Cox he's a bitch the man who once said one of the wonders of the world is going Down IKNOW destroyed the most beautiful thing

[@samerkamal3328]

Ellen Cox check out his latest he is doing utter bullshit

[@madams4992]

Still my favorite showcase of Gavin’s talent

[@fosgate375]

I'm always left speechless after watching this.

[@Nate-ne2dl]

I see a lot of people talking about gavin, but hot damn, Steven is playing like a fking god as well!

[@kumaranthirukumaran8337]

Actually Steven dominated the whole song ,but Gavin fillings and drumming skills the best

[@SebastianMartinez-sj4cj]

It's amazing how this band is so unknown yet so fucking amazing it defines logic lol

[@anesthetized7053]

+Sebastian Martitinez its truly strange.... so many amazing moments that i wish i could share with other people

[@SebastianMartinez-sj4cj]

+B White I know I've tried spreading the tree around and got some family and friends to enjoy them I wish they would play shows in the US

[@SebastianMartinez-sj4cj]

+Maria Diaz couldn't have said that better I never viewed it from that perspective before but makes more sense people with good taste in music unite!!!

[@harrymannbachstudios957]

+Sebastian Martitinez *defies? sorry can't help it. >.

[@SebastianMartinez-sj4cj]

+Porky Bean Studios Lmao!!! I didn't even see that!

[@alexanderroxborough2732]

Never seen such crazy time signatures on those drums... Gavin is a God. Been one of my favourite tracks for years, and this version of it is by far the very best I've ever ever heard.

[@edurojas845]

There is a solo battle going on there between Steve and Gavin.

[@BTBAM819]

Wow, I am loving Gavin Harrison more and more as time passes... 2:19 ... I never heard a fill like that...

[@absinghhhh]

Ren amazing catch man! I loved that part to be honest!!! Gavin's awesome!👌🙌🤟

[@duckface524]

3:30 love how they reprise the Don't Hate Me riff, always made sense since the two songs are kinda like parallels

[@sab-ali]

That piece in the middle which starts at 3:32 made me forget who i was or where i was.

[@MohitVermaqwerty]

This band is so amazing live, you get the feeling of true electric music. Guitar+vocal is god level. Song's lyrics are amazing .

[@hugorezende199]

Masterclass from Gavin Harrison...making pure art. i always laught and jaw drop by the groove on this song

[@leehendri2371]

Its amazing how they can make this kind of playing look casual,incredible!

[@bratishpoddar2328]

What a performance

[@jerryboone1093]

Listening and watching once again and Gavin is kicking my ass...once again.

[@RaushanVerma07]

I love the way they carry themselves on stage!!

[@tl4340]

Jesus, that drumming. Gavin just boggles the mind.

[@Saul-Wolfden]

The drums are my favorite part of this song.

[@gaffed1]

I'll say it again. Gavin Harrison is bad ass. And I love Stevens lead guitar on this track!

[@aabhishek4911]

Man i so wanna see Gavin and Danny carey have a duel ... shit worth dying for .

[@Prizzy999]

Gavin that licks his finger and swipes it on the drum to make that particular sound is mindblowing, seriously. What a song and what a live performance from the whole band, epic!!

[@mrnoname3692]

Gavin Harrison is the drum god himself. Best Progressive drummer ever. The double bass drumming parts at 8:25 are so fast, its unbelieveable. Dave Lombardo best drummer? I disagree!

[@ThrawnTheater]

Such an amazing guitar tone at 5:20

[@wookieblaster]

ThrawnTheater BadCat amps kick ass!

[@kmg1100]

As a drummer, I find this music very inspiring!

[@rishabhsinghsolanki8375]

Mr. Colin Edwin on Bass, ladies and gentlemen.

[@silverdy357]

Gavin's tom hit at 0:12 is the most epic part of this performance

[@omairsh8]

Steven's such a great guitarist

[@AestheticBlazes]

There is all Music and There is a thing called Porcupine Tree 🌲! Different level !

[@satyavarma4630]

After Pink Floyd its Porcupine Tree who play muuuuusic

[@divyankmauria9165]

I came to Chicago in 2012 and have lived here since. 7 years too late!

[@tronlady1]

Awwwwwwww man! I’ve loved this band for over 25 years but don’t ever remember seeing this footage? This performance is completely off the scale! I’ve come to think of this as one of the lesser albums and it’s awesome! Also I can’t remember SW ever being that good on guitar!! I miss Colin Edwin though he was a big part of their sound.

[@FranciscoBurrola]

I love how at some point of the song John Wesley just walks out of the stage to leave the band giving their best.

[@fsgm5178]

this song kept on influencing me since i cudnt even like vids in utube i owe my life nd future career to these men these r my family

[@mgtowvalues]

At the very end, you saw the bass player protect the drummer, waiting for the signal to throw out the life line and bring the drummer back-on-to the beat to then immediately end the song, the guitar and keys trusted all would be well. Such care.

[@iys6890]

I could listen to this song every day!

[@jerryboone1093]

Damn....Colin and Gavin got that groove down. BAD ASS!!!!

[@dylansantos5958]

Pure musicianship!

[@ManiEADG]

8:12 ... break that fucking rhythm apart, Gavin!

[@neonblack211]

Love Love how the bass offsets a quarter (?) note for the bridge and the finish, beautifully done

[@Algrad87]

you can hear Mad Season in this song, especially in the final part! Great great piece!!

[@HystrixLignum]

Oh man, how much i love this!

[@dziolo666]

I love hatesong!

[@Stevesupcom]

This is what Porcupine Tree is. Throwback but better.

[@MrNarcan]

Interpretazione magistrale!

[@Stevesupcom]

Perfect Song. Great everything!

[@sebbimon]

2:17 Gavin fucking Harrison, ladies and gentlemen... #1 Prog drummer!!

[@dawncroy]

I can’t stop watching this.

[@joshuavideogames]

so awesome, might be my favorite by them!

[@noesalas5804]

Wow, I'm absolutely speechless, this is music for the mind, food for my soul. I'm glad not all is lost in a world where so much is synthetic. Gavin makes me never want to stop practicing on the kit. Anyone know if they well ever play again, any tour dates?

[@gabrielesoddu5435]

I'm afraid they won't be touring again anytime soon, they've been on hiatus since the last tour after The Incident. Good news is, Steven Wilson is touring now to support his last album, Hand. Cannot. Erase., and Gavin Harrison is going to release a whole album of re-imagined PT songs, I don't know if he's going to tour but I really hope so. Anyway, we're all waiting for them to come back!

[@SamGHLR]

Gabriele Soddu i've heard steven wilson was planning on a porcupine tour in summer 2016 , after his solo album tour.... is it too good to be real ?

[@gabrielesoddu5435]

Well, if you go on Classic Rock Magazine channel on KZbin you can find some recent interview with very specific question about the future of Porcupine Tree. When questioned, Steven just said that he hasn't immediate plans of coming back to the band in an immediate future, though he's left the door open and he's still in contact with all of the guys in PT. So, I don't think there has been talk about a 2016 tour but... Who knows! I'm pretty sure it's gonna happen someday!

[@temporarymomentary]

Not gonna happen. Maybe in 2020.

[@Manicblues227]

nene noe well for the sake of music and my hearing, I hope they return. thanks for the info my fellows.

[@5996699]

i always feel love when i listen to their musik (:

[@fedesxxxxxx]

oh boy here we go again to rewatch all PT live performances :D

[@richardgifford8953]

Just mind blowing!!!

[@ChroniquesEnImages]

Magnifique version !

[@rajatgaur4993]

If drumming is porn. Gavin Harrison is the Johnny Sins of this department.

[@iamcraiger]

Great tune... hopefully they'll release new material some day... its been a long time!

[@BogdanEchoMilosevic]

Unreal. Gavin is ridiculously incredible.

[@4ndr_s]

this version of hatesong is just great.

[@DanielVerberne]

Love how the guitar + bass parts are straight-ahead rock; but Richard Barbieri's part adds those crucial minor chords, giving a darker flavour. Also, Gavin's drumming always amazing - love the tight playing all around!

[@Rochito]

Está interpretación es magistral!

[@rickkent6016]

Awesome, love it

[@cedricproper5256]

Unforgettable.

[@LoyalLady318]

Upper echelon Musicians not many in USA have ever heard, or heard of.🖖

[@pachatsebastien]

oh my GOD !! so good!!

[@gazbertrum88]

Stunning...

[@AAAAnonymus]

Deserves a Trillion Views

[@spytiriga]

Dark narcotic solo! Great musicians!

[@user07767]

This is not only Gavin beeing out if everything... this is a prototype for how you should behave while creating live music. Absolutely mindblowing.

[@AndresRenePR]

What a fucking beast playing the drums.

[@ashtoast]

even in the rural country like mine...we njoy this song \m/

[@mastergamer1127]

Best show or band ever!!!

[@Nicci175]

Very good drummer and guitarplayer! Damn!

[@adrian5b]

what a great version

[@madams4992]

This song is so fucking awesome. Gavin is unreal !

[@mystiic_]

hell yeah those two as guests with these guys would be a show to see!

[@richardhuffman8903]

Simply the best!!!!

[@wellwhatsgoingonhere]

why can't I stop watching this?