Postmodern Jukebox "Mad World" ft Puddles Pity Party REACTION & ANALYSIS by Vocal Coach/Opera Singer

[@TheCharismaticVoice]

We just released merchandise! Check out the full line-up here: thecharismaticmerch.com

[@michaelclark6283]

I think Adam lambert sings this song the best.

[@rcinsley]

Scott Bradlee is a genius, but hiding Haley (who is 5' 2") behind "Puddles" (who is 6' 8") took this performance to another level of creativity!

[@CyberBeep_kenshi]

Just so funny, she's on heels and has a hat and still barely comes to his shoulders lol. And he stands hunched too :)

[@awg6397]

I had to watch that over and over before I realized she was there the whole time

[@rcinsley]

@@awg6397 I had watched this MANY times...and tried VERY hard to see some tiny bit of Haley...but it wasn't until Elizabeth pointed it out that I saw the shadow to the left!

[@stempo1]

Having stood next to Puddles I can tell you the guy is a giant.

[@campbellsoup93]

'Creative' would be hiding the tall one behind the short one.

[@TheSyncos]

Puddles has an amazing amount of power to his voice. I find it incredible how restrained he was in this performance to essentially take a supporting role for Haley. Also, an incredible twist to see the 6'8 guy dressed as a clown take the straight man role here, laying down a buttery-smooth canvas for Haley to paint with ALL the colors.

[@involunteer]

Yes! The restraint is exactly what I appreciate about this. He supports her and gives her the space to do her flourishes. Very refreshing to hear when so many singers think they always need to go all out on everything.

[@tedharvick9010]

A very apt description, kudos

[@TheComicBookJoker]

@@involunteer Absolutely this. A skilled singer knows how to use many colors in their voice. A truly gifted singer also knows when to limit themselves to one or two. Puddles is truly gifted.

[@BaskingInObscurity]

My introduction to Puddles was a video clip from an audition episode of "___'s Got Talent" or "The X Factor" or some such show. Not really my thing, but he's certainly very talented and clever, deserving a lot of respect for his craft.

[@skyelyte1699]

It was pretty clear the song was intended to be a duet and Haley totally upstaged Puddles. I think he responded to that by taking the supporting role and it showed total class on his part. She is a skilled vocalist so as I see it she showed arrogance and a pretty inflated ego to stomp all over Puddles in vocals. This could have been one of the best duets ever, but Haley backed Puddles down to a back up singer. It was very disappointing.

[@oftcrash]

My wife has a fear of clowns, but she bought us tickets to see Puddles anyway. This was before he was on TV, so it was a really small venue, and we were no more than 15 feet away from him. I had never seen a literal jaw drop before that moment he started singing, but from then on, the only clown my wife doesn't fear is Puddles.

[@heatherjelliott]

Good to hear! As someone who is also terrified of clowns I was not excited for this video lol

[@Wiley_Coyote]

He's the ONLY non evil clown. The only good one I tell you!

[@bobkitten8150]

We saw him too! It was so much fun!

[@oftcrash]

His live show is amazing. The KZbin videos are great, but they only provide a glimpse of his hilarious physical comedy.

[@davidantell2855]

He puts on a great show.

[@tfkoincognito]

This is a woman that loves music. I love watching her expressions as she experiences it. Its much like how an empath shows someones emotions. And i love how the articulates herself.

[@deanchampion6777]

YES!!!

[@Kokuswolf]

Indeed!

[@JHB1984]

i'm really surprised that you didn't react to "Haleys and Morgans"+ cover of "All About That Bass": kzbin.info/www/bejne/l33Ri2SEhtJlq80 (yet) cheers

[@sinkler123]

Yes ! +1 to this.

[@TheCharismaticVoice]

There's still time! This comment just needs more upvotes. ;-)

[@musickf]

Yes, she needs to see this. It's just amazing.

[@galadballcrusher8182]

@@TheCharismaticVoice and i m still also waiting for the little mermaid medley by Voiceplay. I promise you ll gonna love it, so much amazing stuff in it...

[@fermio]

This would be wonderful!!

[@LadyAerys]

Scott Bradley does all the arrangements for PMJ it's his baby basically. I'm very happy to hear you give props to the arrangements, not many people do that and it's a shame, he's brilliant and deserves credit!

[@ATrainHC]

I saw Puddles a couple of years back and they actually told the crowd to record video. I was front row and he came off the stage while singing "Unchained Melody", took my phone, and recorded himself singing while walking around then gave me phone to a random person and did the same with her phone. At the end of the song about a dozen of us had to meet by the stage to get our phones back. :-P It was the most FUN concert I've been to.

[@charlietipton8502]

How funny! And so typucally Puddles.

[@GODHATESADOPTION]

Ra the rugged man does this too

[@jackoff1826]

Great fun of a concert he does. I was lucky enough to have attended one.

[@Nerex7]

Now imagine someone meets their SO that way. What a story to tell

[@ATrainHC]

@@Nerex7 I'm pretty sure I ruined any chance of that two days ago. Oh, well. :-P

[@RaistlanCE]

I don't like clowns, and I love Puddles. He performed at my company holiday party 9 years ago, and I was in awe of his height and his voice.

[@WeAreTheInsurgents]

Singing aside, I just wanna say that you as a content creator are one of the most pleasant and adorable people I've ever seen. I only saw your videos for the first time yesterday from the Opera 2 reaction and you're just so inviting and friendly. You engage your audience so well and it feels like watching the video with a friend. Your reactions don't seem fake or exaggerated either; you truly appreciate the talent and analyse their techniques instead of just filling the video with wows and shocked faces. It's so wholesome and the type of content that's needed right now.

[@TheCharismaticVoice]

Thank you. I needed this comment.

[@WeAreTheInsurgents]

@@TheCharismaticVoice No worries, keep making great content!

[@mikemclaughlin3306]

Agree..... I watch a lot of reactors, but yours is the only one I wait for...... doesn't hurt that you do that adorable nose crinkle.....but your content never disappoints me.

[@charlietipton8502]

I agree. Seeing her enjoying music is like watching a child experience chocolate for the first time. Such charming facial expressions of wonder. Then she pauses the video and tosses out insightful comments. I might know I enjoy the song, but she then points out aspects that allow me to enjoy it even more. I love that she also has the production toolbox. And now she adds dance?!?!?!

[@RaptorValen]

Perfectly said! I got here from the jinjer reactions and she's so genuine and adorable like an excited little sister lol.

[@Ayoosi]

This song has literally made me cry. It triggers emotions I can't describe. Both their voices hit me somewhere ethereal and deep

[@dtktrucker]

Puddles is an interesting one. His cover of Lordes “Royals” is really good.

[@forgalzz7]

And Chandelier, and Team, and All The Small Things, and Viva La Vida ... and that's only the PMJ ones.

[@TheRealWinsletFan]

I never really liked the original "Royals", but his version is sublime.

[@Gizmo42Rodeo]

That's the one that introduced me to Puddles. And the only version of the song I've ever listened to. I still play it once in a while when I need a Puddles fix.

[@chadfalardeau5396]

@@TheRealWinsletFan Wierd Al's Foil is better

[@TheCharismaticVoice]

I was really surprised by this. There will be more Puddles coming!

[@roguemerlin1969]

Puddles, Chandelier on America's got Talent 2017. He starts out as a silent mime and every jaw dropped in the whole audience, judges included, when he started to sing. Most people don't know his name, he is just Puddles Pity Party.

[@davidgraham5242]

there was a comment on the song that took the vid to a new level for me, They look like a girl and her invisible “imaginary” friend that protects her from bullies and anyone that would harm her, but is also a big softie and is scared of mice

[@cirrustate8674]

Exactly! It fits perfectly.

[@Cha0sRising90]

This comment is an amazing view into singing in character!

[@billmilligan7272]

Funny. I had thought about this the other way -- she's the imaginary friend, socially adroit where he's awkward, protecting him from the Mad World. It's why she pops out of nowhere!

[@rmar127]

@@billmilligan7272 I do like that interpretation.

[@RhamanaChan]

I like the idea they're two parts of the same soul, Puddles is the true feelings and emotions hidden deep down and Haley is the 'face' that he puts on to show other people, 'coping' and being cheerful, with the dark humor and jokes, talking about how they want to die like its the best thing that could happen for them.

[@inkycap13]

I like the way that the two singers interacting altered the emotional context of the original song. It didn’t feel flippant to me, rather it felt like what it feels like when friends with different emotional problems use their relationship to balance each other. The world is mad, he is depressed, and she is nervously manic. Together however he can support her by anchoring her in the moment when she looses herself and she can pull him into motion when he is stuck in the mire. The world is mad, but each time they sing it together it is sweeter and more light hearted than the last. I don’t know, maybe I’m reading to much into it.

[@QuirkyUncleDave]

Been anxiously waiting for Puddles to make an appearance on the channel, so I'm very much looking forward to this.

[@forgalzz7]

Although I feel he gets a bit upstaged by Haley in this one. I hope she will do some Solopuddles in the future.

[@QuirkyUncleDave]

@@forgalzz7 Yes, this definitely doesn't show off his full range, but hopefully is a good introduction and gateway to more of his work.

[@TheCharismaticVoice]

You are welcome, DAVE! ;-)

[@ptr250]

The magic behind PMJ is Scott's arrangements and his ability to match vocalist with the sound he is trying to achieve.

[@Ephem13]

Haley feels like Puddles emotional support in this performance. Like an extra layer they put in, the extrovert helping the introvert be comfortable. Literally everything about these two contrasts in this video.

[@muhammadzaini5728]

I like being introvert.. Extrovert just noisy 😒

[@MarkBtvd]

I really liked how the two interacted: the dance moves, holding and swinging hands, and the hug at the end for examples. I think it added to the emotions of the story.

[@57WillysCJ]

Someone 5'2" can easily hide behind someone 6'8". Mike Geier stays solidly to his Puddles persona when he is in costume and Geier treats him as a separate person. That takes work. Haley's voice is reminiscent of the club singers of the era she portrays.

[@treetopjones737]

Puddles wonders why people bring up this Mike Geier person a lot. 😉

[@yourhandlehere1]

The Puddles are deep. His voice keeps going where you don't expect.

[@urielpappilon]

JFYI - when referencing "original", keep in mind that Donnie Darko version of Mad World by Gary Jules is a cover as well. Original version was performed by Tears For Fears and sounds quite different

[@Neflhim]

What's kind of amazing is that when Curt Smith did the song on an episode of Psyche, he used Gary Jules' arrangement.

[@mikeabney2527]

I had no idea this was a tears for fears song

[@kenkeep69]

The Hurting by Tears for Fears is an amazing album...one of my favorites

[@katherinemorelle7115]

I’ve found that while I dislike the original Tears for Fears songs, I usually really love the covers of their songs. So thanks to TfF for writing songs that are covered so well.

[@MrFinikyfrank]

I love TFF but, I think Gary's version really set the bar for the song.

[@TheCharismaticVoice]

Want to support or hang out with me and the community? Join our Patreon. We have an amazing Discord, do 2 live chats per week (usually), play video games, get behind the scenes footage and content, masterclasses, polls and pick content for me and this channel, and soon to be merch deals. It’s a ton of fun, and I hope to see this community grow! www.patreon.com/thecharismaticvoice

[@TheNZMuppet]

Hi,I'm only just getting into your videos after watching your version of reacting to Sound of Silence I'm not sure if you have done Puddles doing Hallelujah,but I honestly think it's the best cover done of it....all the others put me to sleep but Puddles makes you want to hear it

[@yojimbeau]

Thank you for this analysis. I only recently discovered PMJ/Puddles/Haley. I knew I loved this adaptation, but it's nice to hear why. As a fellow baritone, I love what Puddles can do with his voice, but, honestly, Haley steals the show and my heart. So amazing/adorable/angelic. One of the things that struck me about this duet is the juxtaposition of the big, sad clown and the light-hearted pixie. As you mentioned and other commenter said, he's so very intense and sorrowful, while she's more like his Jiminy Cricket, taking it all in stride. But, again, thank you so much for posting your reaction to this amazing song.

[@luismartinez6421]

I'm amazed that no one pointed: 1. Puddles didn't blink a single time... I would love to see her reaction after noticing this 2. The reason of having the word "vaudeville" on the song's title... Haley coming out from behind is a simple but very well performed "vaudeville trick" 😁

[@amyrsh9067]

He blinks when you do, so you just don't see it.

[@damnedtolive9121]

I almost feel like when puddles starts to dance in sink with her, the personna of "Puddles" hates the whole concept, but then he perfectly uses tonality to convey his feelings, as if to say, "I'll do this, but everything still sucks."

[@cruxshadow333]

been a Puddles Pity Party watcher (and listener with Post Modern Jukebox , Puddles does a brilliant version of Lorde's "Royals") so looking forward to this.

[@Arzie81]

Chandelier is also brilliant showcase of Puddles&PMJ collaboration.

[@zackmarkham4240]

They compliment each other so perfectly! This is still one of my fave Post Modern Jukebox covers!

[@DanKaschel]

I didn't have the same impression. They both sounded great separately but I felt they had trouble blending. I also didn't find that there were enough through-lines to give the song a sense of cohesion. It was interesting but not one I'd come back to. Adam Lambert did a mad world cover a while ago that I like far better.

[@antanis]

Hes 6'8" and shes 5'2", No wonder she can hide behind him. I never realized how tall he was when watching the talent shows hes in.

[@vidpie]

Haley was on American Idol ten years ago. I never thought about her being short because she performed big.

[@sle517]

Haley is such a dynamic vocalist. She shines in every song she sings. I love your expert opinion. I really enjoy this cover as well.

[@magaisacult2023]

One of the best You Tube comments I ever read! "Most singers sing in print, Haley sings in cursive!"

[@davidaubin3449]

I found this about six months ago and can’t get it out of my head, I have never enjoyed music so much.......there is so much to listen to and hear. The facial expressions on both of them are just as incredible as the sound of their voices. look how she looks down when puddles grabs her hand, perfect! I love it, they are perfect!

[@LittlestAswell]

Coming from a person who is extremely TERRIFIED of CLOWNS, Puddles is a different story. His makeup & costume does not terrify enough like most clowns do. But a couple years ago my boyfriend and I watched his AGT audition that was on my recommended and we REALLY liked his voice. It is so smooth! So we ended up on a Puddles binge for an hour or so listening to many of his covers. You have been missing out. His covers on his channel are really good too. MAD WORLD is one of my favorite songs by the original artist "Tears for Fears". I grew up in the 90's listening to 80's music a lot. And Tears for Fears is one of my favs from that era. It hurts my music soul when most ppl only reference the darker version, which don't get me wrong is beautiful & Adam Lambert did a great cover, but the original is a bit faster with great music parts that truly make you feel a little "Mad". lol just putting that out there since it is my fav song of "Tears for Fears". kzbin.info/www/bejne/q2K9p4OJpbGreck

[@judeg.8101]

I love music but I know nothing about the how. I find myself looking closer at the screen and listening to you explaining things and going so much deeper than I ever had. And giving me insight as to why I feel the way I do listening to it. Thank you..

[@jamesstipe4275]

You explain sound with beauty most can't express

[@TheCharismaticVoice]

Aww, thank you James!

[@laszlokaestner5766]

Hayley's singing overall but in particular during the 3/4 sections is one of the most beautiful sounds I think I have ever heard.

[@juan193]

Puddles gave me chills when he sang Chandelier by Sia. I believe he was on one of those * Got Talent shows and he did impress the judges!

[@DanceMonkeychg]

But then the next episode they cut him because they (especially Simon Cowell 🙄) said his second performance wasn't different enough from the first one, as if they expected him to go "Okay, that's enough of this clown crap, for this next song I'm gonna be a cowboy".

[@vidpie]

@@DanceMonkeychg Simon rejected Haley Reinhart in S9 of American Idol. It was the last season before he started X-Factor, so he might have had a conflict of interest. Lee Dewyze won that year. His hometown shares a border with Haley's hometown (in the Chicago area).

[@DanceMonkeychg]

@@vidpie Forgive me, I don't pay enough attention to Simon Cowell's comings and goings (Thank God) to understand the conflict of interest part of your comment.

[@ExaltedDuck]

They cut him because the show is totally fake. They know who the finalists and probably even winner will be before the first episode is shot. The early rounds usually debut one or two acts each episode that will make it to the finale, several that would have no hope of advancing, one or two that are good but just not good enough, one or two that have emotionally compelling backstories (sometimes the actual finalists do), and one or two that are established and talented but not well known. They're basically ringers to keep the show interesting. If there's a really highly talented act that gets cut in the first one or two rounds, they were probably already professionally performing and scouted for paid appearances on the show and are just there to spice things up for the audience.

[@cgyrask]

When Simon cut him, he did so to create drama for the show, and was almost pleading for Howie to defend him in order to keep Puddles in the running, but Howie didn't follow Simon's lead.

[@Chasmodius]

"I feel it's kind of funny, I feel it's kind of sad" This perfectly encapsulates the archetype of the clown. They put so much thought into the arrangement, the vocal performances, and the physical performances -- and somehow managed to blend them all into something where each supported the other and built upon it... ! So much artistic effort.

[@rebel200794]

PMJ never use pitch correction. Everything is done live and raw.

[@cornelrebegea1451]

Yeah, what in the world is she talking about.

[@adaddinsane]

Damn right. What an outrageous comment.

[@Endtimescoming]

because most places she hears music from do use pitch correction and perhaps she doesn't realize that PMJ has the integrity to never do that.

[@hippieslacker6466]

Haley's voice is so big, i nearly forgot there was a 6'8" clown standing center stage. Amazing rendition of this song, so well done

[@CelticArmory]

Puddles has a very rich baritone. He used to perform at Teatro Zinzani in Seattle, WA. His Puddles character is interesting because he never talks, just sings.

[@tric5122]

Anything Puddles does w/PMJ is money, but you should find the video of him walking into a cafe and singing to a live, unsuspecting crowd

[@rainbowwarrior6452]

Puddles is 6'8" tall. It's perfectly possible for a shorter woman to hide behind him when he's in costume and not moving. He's enormous.

[@audunaa1494]

I really like Puddles` mix of come sail away/let it go, and "crazy train". he got a wonderful powerful voice

[@nikolaykalenikov3654]

That was a performance of PMJ, I have not seen before and I am very thankful I did. Furthermore, that is the first time I got to listen to Puddles and that was quite the experience. His voice is amazing. It has depth, clarity and can relate emotion very very well. His body language and facial expressions were also on point. Definitely need to hear more from him on the channel. As for the performance overall, it was unsurprisingly great and very creative, especially the moment in which Haley appeared. I believe there is no need to say it, but Haley is ridiculously good and for me is one of the best in the world. The way she plays with her voice in some many different ways is such a joy to listen to. As for recommendations, more PMJ would always be a welcome addition to the channel. And since most people know how great Haley and Morgan are (which is true and I would be delighted if Elizabeth chooses their version of "Dear Prudence"), I would pick Robyn Adele Anderson or Ariana Savalas as great options as well.

[@michaelpayne9710]

You should react to his cover of "Chandelier" by Sia, from America's Got Talent, next

[@Nepafarius]

Puddles' voice is clarified butter. Rich yet clear.

[@jalkabre5904]

Doesn't get much better than Haley and Puddles together. Love how they did this song.

[@damnedtolive9121]

You have perfect mastery over your facial expressions to convey what you want the audience to feel. I'm guessing it happened along side your vocal training. Killer job.

[@NotContinuum]

I feel like Haley's voice overwhelmed Puddles. She has such a strong voice and timbre that it can drown out others. He was definitely toning it down and I don't think things were as balanced as they could have been.

[@peeceejay]

I've always felt this too

[@TravisLackey]

Totally agree.

[@stephenseay3878]

I actually enjoyed the contrast of their voices. I sort of know what you mean but I also liked the difference and found similarities in a disassociated sense.

[@LetholdusKaspyr]

@@stephenseay3878 Your point is good, but at the same time, the vocal mixing is off. She's great, but I want to hear him, too, and I can't.

[@5-opreacher688]

I know absolutely nothing about voice control and singing however I love watching your videos because your love for music is so obviously apparent in your expressions, smiles, and giggles.

[@Gizmo42Rodeo]

His version of Hallelujah live at the SF Regency Lodge Ballroom is one of my favorites.

[@scottlkahler]

“I could watch this over and over and over...”. Yes. :). I have watched this WELL over a hundred times. I love them both.

[@lucas.tamaki]

Nice! Looking foward to see more Puddles in this channel. He's incredible!

[@andyf7027]

I'm IN LOVE with your love of music and could just watch your facial expressions endlessly.

[@timothyhites7016]

She’s absolutely beautiful

[@lazaruschernik18]

THANK YOU FOR REACTING TO PUDDLES! Puddles is a Pacific Northwest Institution. You HAVE to react to his version of "When I'm Down". It's epic and heart-wrenching.

[@BuzZzKiller]

Always loved Puddles, since he was on America's Got Talent. He's really subdued in this duet. He usually comes through with a more operatic style.

[@BumbleJones]

I love Puddles so much. After this one, be sure to check out his performance of "I (Who Have Nothing)" at Paste Studios. So much character, he's too good. kzbin.info/www/bejne/p5Lal32Vf9mNldE

[@Wiley_Coyote]

I love that one. Also if you've never seen it, you must see the Houston Public Media performance of "I Started A Joke".

[@coilte]

This is a great performance

[@Kay_The_Coffee_Weirdo]

Puddles does 90% covers, but he has a few originals. There's one called "All The World is Asleep Tonight". Could ya? 😄

[@bmeyerkc]

Puddles is perfect, not sure if intentional or not. But when Haley is singing 'Happy Birthday' Puddles is mouthing it like he wishes he could say happy birthday to someone.

[@donnaw3026]

Perfectly intentional. He's acting out her lines. Watch his face and how he cringes a little when she sings "very nervous" and "no one knew me". Completely in the moment.

[@Xiph1980]

Okay, I'm only halfway through, so you might've commented on it already and I'm too impatient, but in the moments Haley sings, especially her first two blocks, Puddles' facial expressions are utterly amazing! You can just see him going through a variety of thoughts, confusions, and emotions! 😀

[@davemath9103]

Which makes me think she just popped up as a part of his thoughts or a dream to tell him to lighten up, do not take things quite so seriously. Maybe he knew her character in another life or is similar to someone he knew in the past.

[@linkbloodelf9833]

Puddles rocks. His version of bridge over troubled water is amazing.

[@KingMidas1983]

Excellent cover, definitely a good video to watch if you need a cry

[@EyMannMachHin]

Thank you for introducing me to PMJ. I kind of have lost my touch to modern musik in the last 10 years, simply because I found more musik I like and can not hear possibly again in it's entirety in the rest of my lifetime. Also most music from that time also does not speak to me at all.. I guess I'm becoming a boomer... And I'm really sorry you were raised on the Donnie Darko version which is the one by Gary Jules, which is good enough, if you want to wallow in your own depression for a while. Please dial back 20 more years to get to the 1983 original by Tears for Fears, same lyrics, speaking to my teenage angst but the music did really ramp that up into a kind of rebellion saying "Yeah! The world is rubbish, if you want to change it get your own arse up". And that is exactly, the same kind of feeling this piece puts it to me.

[@trevorwhiteman8056]

Love Puddles. Check out his version of Disturbs version of Sound of Silence.

[@Daremo6969]

That and Crazy Train was crazy good.

[@SirValiant2022]

Yes is version of Sound of Silence is a must to be seen

[@tattoou1222]

So Puddles does a version of Disturbed's version of the Simon & Garfunkle song Sound of Silence then?

[@kwebb121765]

@@tattoou1222 LOL!

[@sumotode]

You mean his version of the Simon & Garfunkle song Sound of Silence. Disturbs is a cover, the original is better imo.

[@Matt-vv7fl]

Post modern jukebox has SO many talented musicians that they collaborate with. I only discovered them fairly recently and I just love their stuff.

[@BruderTux]

live recording in the room is Scott's thing since he started this project. Same audio is also used for the CD releases.

[@skyskimmer]

One of the most interesting and creative covers I have ever heard. They balance and compliment each other so well.

[@RVingwithG]

I found Puddles a few years ago and I wish he would do more.. HE IS KING! !

[@rh5563]

One of my favorites! Puddles and Hailey are gold in this one. 👍👍👍

[@MushyUndTingly]

You should watch Puddles on AGT where he sings "Chandelier." It's magnificent.

[@martythetrimmer]

Of all the reviews I watch, not only of this song but of many others, yours I enjoy the most! Some reviewers just waffle on, your comments come across as more knowledge based and technical. I love watching your facial expressions, you can tall what you are thinking before you pause the video and comment. Your excitement and passion for music is infectious! There are so many of your reviews I could mention, but not on this fantastic songs page!!

[@mathewdelamere1]

they're version of All the Small Things shows off puddles range much more and the depth he can pull in his voice. i'd recommend that one for a watch.

[@DK_Son]

Her voice is stunning. I'm so thrown off by it. It's cute, and strong, and childish, and controlled, and just everything amazing. I love how she sends her voice off somewhere that you just don't just expect. And how after the little swingy dance moves, how she jumps up an octave, or whatever you'd call it, from around 11:43. I'm still a music noob so saying she jumped up an octave might be wrong. And I love your videos!

[@kevinwright8340]

Puddles Royals is an amazing example of his talents.

[@Godspeed1756]

I love Puddles. Been a fan since 2013. First song I heard was his cover of Royals. I can't hear it any other way after that.

[@alia3768]

Yes, Royals, done by Puddles is very good. His version of Gilligan's Island is hilarious.

[@Testibus00]

I went to a show a year or so ago and about half way through Puddles came out as an unannounced special guest. Americas oldest living drag queen, Darcelle, then read Twas the Night Before Christmas...we all had tears in our eyes.

[@kchez5586]

Some other Post Modern Jukebox home runs are, Miche Braden doing the best rendition of Sweet Child 'O Mine EVER & Nicole Atkins' version of Heros by Bowie.

[@chuckschillingvideos]

Sorry, but no. Heimatdamisch owns Sweet Child O' Mine and they're never giving it back. kzbin.info/www/bejne/rZPWdo2wnKiqo6s

[@auralfixxation6702]

Puddles has an amazing voice. His vibrato is so silky. For a real stand out though, check out his version of "Losing My Religion" by REM. It takes a song well known and reinterprets it into a far more emotional song. Gives the lyrics a whole new feel.

[@johnnyho8833]

You just Got to do "All About That Bass" with Hayley, Morgan, & Ariana with PMJ.

[@resurrecsean]

And don't forget about Casey!

[@patrickdoyle9369]

Haley and puddles are so good together... I love this version.. They both have so so much cool talent..

[@grejen711]

This song is so sooo dark and so cheery at the same time. Fascinating.

[@caylahtaikoi]

It’s been a long time since I’ve been in a formal vocal class/around other trained vocalist, and I currently work as a singer for a band. I’m now binge watching your videos because it’s therapeutic to hear the terminology and see someone relate to singing in a way I haven’t seen or heard in years. It’s like talking with an old friend who gets it. So thank you for the content! 💕

[@CyberBeep_kenshi]

Yesss i suggested puddles a few times, he is an incredible singer. His channel is full of gems.

[@kambido890]

This is a song that give me tears every time. Haley's part, "was in school no one knew me" .. well, everyone knew me, but i cry every time. And haily hits it

[@josephkrafft7006]

Daaaaaang! Thanks to Elizabeth I've spent hours down the puddles rabbit hole. dude is legit ! I'm now a fan of another style of music. 😊😎

[@amyrsh9067]

Welcome to the Party.

[@ericshanks5399]

This is where we come from. 40 years ago stylings like this we're not novel. This is how working musicians did things. And yes, it's "Wow!" It always has been. Peace.

[@RevZ06]

Been waiting for this for almost a year. I wish it was hallelujah tho. Or Chris Cornell when I'm down

[@mtneerace]

His version of Hallelujah is one of the best I've ever heard! ❤️

[@amyrsh9067]

When I'm Down is amazing!

[@Engineer284]

I am a PMJ fan. I sort of stumbeld on to Charismatic Voice 3 days ago. Now I have watched many previews and love every one of them. You make music fun to watch because you are fun to watch. Love the expresions and the pure joy you show in reviewing the music video's. I am now a big fan of Charismatic Voice. Thank you.

[@MrJest2]

"How is she completely hidden behind him?!?" Well, there's a reason he's called (when he's not being Puddles) 'Big Mike". 🤪

[@snicky58]

Puddles concerts are so much fun! I haven't seen Haley live yet but I hope I will someday. This arrangement is so great -- the way Haley comes in and jazzes things up is epic.

[@spr1ngcactu5]

That feeling of rich chocolate melting in my mouth, but instead it’s in my ears

[@mustangmike53]

Elizabeth - I just shared your PJM-Creep reaction with a friend over zoom. I love Haley and that performance, and your reaction video is easily the most fun of all the ones I've watched. The reason I thought to share your video is that earlier today I was watching Anna Netrebko & Elīna Garanča sing Offenbach's Barcarolle and found myself wondering how you would react to their duet. I find it an incredibly beautiful and moving piece and love their performance. I first heard the Barcarolle in the 1998 film Life Is Beautiful and loved it so much I bought the Opera CD and then tickets to a performance of the Opera. It can still move me to tears. When I saw you react to yourself at the Queen Elizabeth I knew you'd be expert on the subject and it would make me so happy to hear what you think about it. I put a link below - it appears to be a video of a studio recording session, as opposed to a performance before an audience. Thanks for doing what you do. Mike kzbin.info/www/bejne/ZqaTfmd5gtZqq6s

[@classicgmr]

I can't believe I'm going to miss the stream on this one! I absolutely love Puddles Pity Party and what he does with his covers. Enjoy this one!

[@TheCharismaticVoice]

We missed you! I hope you're there for the next one then.

[@karenmccabe2167]

So glad to see you covering this! His name is Mike Geier! He's from Atlanta, I used to see him with the Kingsized Orchestra - they were an Elvis tribute band/show. Absolutely amazing, look them up! He has an incredible voice!

[@wtglb]

One of my FAV Puddles songs is “Palms” written by Sxip Shirey, it’s here on YT, so heartfelt and a great video ♥️♥️♥️♥️

[@joeb4142]

I would have never seen this performance if you hadn’t featured it. The only words I can think of to describe it are amazing and a virtuoso performance. If I hadn’t heard your commentary I would have missed a lot. Thank you for opening my eyes and ears!

[@CyberBeep_kenshi]

The handholding reminds me of Moonraker somehow with jaws and his gf:-)

[@jakedee3188]

lol

[@thekpmckay]

You are the most authentic "voice coach" reviewer on KZbin. I love and appreciate your perspective. Thanks.

[@bertjones3010]

Puddles is 6' 7" Haley 5' 2" Puddles name is Mike Geier

[@b.bailey8244]

That was exquisite! I love Puddles and this combo of these two singers and how they worked together on this amazing arrangement was magic.