Mad World - Vintage Vaudeville - Style Cover ft. Puddles Pity Party & Haley Reinhart

Mad World - Vintage Vaudeville - Style Cover ft. Puddles Pity Party & Haley Reinhart
Download the song: pmjlive.com/madworld
Experience PMJ Live: www.pmjtour.com
Shop PMJ Music/Merch: www.shoppmj.com
Follow Us On Spotify: www.pmjlive.com/pmjspotify
Sign up to get videos to your inbox: www.pmjlive.com/newsletter
Puddles is back to deliver his take on the Tears for Fears / Gary Jules classic, "Mad World." What he didn't count on, however, is that Haley Reinhart would stop by to cheer him up...
--------
Follow The Musicians:
Puddles - vocals
www.puddlespityparty.com
/ puddlespityparty
/ puddlespityparty
Haley Reinhart - vocals
/ haleyreinhart
/ haleyreinhart
Jonathan Richards - bass
www.jonathanrichardsmusic.com/
Chip Thomas - drums
/ chipfunky
Scott Bradlee - piano & arrangement
KZbin: / scottbradlee
Facebook: / scottbradleemusic
Instagram: / scottbradlee
Twitter: / scottbradlee
Scott's Book: smarturl.it/outsidethejukebox

[@sleuth2077]

I love how she was perfectly hiding behind him in the beginning. So cute.

[@ihateyouall7026]

sleuth 2077 she 5'2 so it was probably easy

[@dannyevans9012]

She's adorable ❤️

[@ArcticArsenal]

I think she was in his pocket.

[@algirdascici815]

You forgot to say "SPOILER ALERT" :(

[@MundMoriginal]

So glad they didn't miss that opportunity!

[@judeymoody701]

can we just appreciate puddles real quick because most comments are about how amazing haley was (which she REALLY WAS) but REALLY HE KILLED THAT FIRST VERSE, HIS VOICE SOUNDED LIKE BUTTER

[@jeepmanxj]

He is a wonderful vocalist. His voice will calm even the most restless spirit.

[@bubblegum2741]

nice profile

[@judeymoody701]

bubblegum 𝐧 𝐨 𝐢 𝐜 𝐞.

[@christopherkovach8636]

Damn that clown can sing😇

[@michaelpedersen7752]

Puddels are a given. he are just great!!

[@litalhaupt]

No one’s talking about the clown?! He puts so much in his voice. I know haley is amazing, but puddle’s voice gives so much to the words. BOTH of them singing together is just fantastic

[@The_AmazingAndBeautifulMan]

YES

[@EnochDark]

Done been talkin' bout him! ICP? NOPE. PUDDLES? YEP.

[@DaveDexterMusic]

yeah it's just you, you're the only one who noticed, he wasn't actually hired for being an amazing professional singer with a fascinating stage approach, he just walked in. no-one ever talks about him

[@aybolit6666]

Mike Geier's facial expressions deserve special praise.❤

[@kathiereilly1]

Long time Puddles fan.

[@travwein]

Puddles' restraint here almost makes it easy to miss his brilliant performance, but he's just letting Haley do her mesmerizing thing. I can't get enough of that voice of hers.

[@lylamilbery7253]

She sounds so vintage oml

[@geniftz5045]

omG itS mY aEsthEtiC I'm sorry its just... iM so UnIquE and QuIRky!

[@st4rmonii]

@@geniftz5045 Why u waffling fam

[@mattb.9578]

@@geniftz5045 ????

[@zero-ec2fy]

andre she meant that she sounds like an old singer from the past, we don’t usually hear people sing like that anymore :(

[@greenmr2655]

Geni FTZ ok?

[@PatHaskell]

The way he pulls his volume back when she joins in, to allow her to shine... just amazing!!!

[@VortexMagus]

This is one of my favorite parts. Puddles is a great front singer, but he's also generous enough to let Haley take the spotlight and take over the mic. It makes the contrast between his smooth, silky tenor and her striking, smokier tones even stronger.

[@johnedlin2658]

Yeah I was really excited when I found this. They are two of my absolute favorites to listen to and I knew them together would be good

[@Noway00141]

Pat Haskell yessss

[@mr.nobody9697]

Oh please! She needs no one to pull back for her to shine. Her voice is absolutely incredible.

[@gregmikulewicz2038]

His ability to share the spotlight is amazing. Like the product is more important than anyone's ego. So rare.

[@neslock]

The opposite and conflicting emotional vibes given off by Haley and Puddles here are just amazing.

[@tkcdac]

She seems so whimsical and the anthesis of what Puddles is portraying. This is reality. The awake mind knowing destruction, and the folly of those who just simply do not care.

[@PuddlesPityParty]

oh hello, y'all!

[@mikemd6155]

My good man.. Nice to see people actually pop in and comment.. Fantastic voice you got there sir.. Keep it up and hope you are well.. 🤡🤡

[@ChristineT314]

Haley Reinhart is 5’2 Puddles Pity Party is 6’8

[@andersnielsen6044]

So 5'2 is love in numbers.. ;)

[@oliviawaller7052]

A fucking unit

[@lorenamcgovern]

Awesome

[@iancurlyfries837]

Olivia Waller In awe at the size of this lad. Absolute unit

[@stormcatcher117]

He's a big clown

[@Babybat213]

I didn't even know it was possible for me to fall in love with a voice.... her voice she so... pretty? Beautiful? Gorgeous? Stunning?

[@gabijohnston4108]

ok satan

[@yeonjune8534]

I know right

[@alex-cz7uf]

i agree with satan

[@Babybat213]

@@yeonjune8534 shhh

[@Babybat213]

@Gremy Saint you think I exercise??? Ha!

[@ZealTroublemaker]

The little choreography bit is so freaking cute every single time.

[@bobjohnson8169]

I can only say Puddles has given me great comfort! I thank him for that. Puddles, thank you, I can’t offer you anything but my sincere gratitude!

[@enotj]

why do i like this better than the og

[@profballerz]

you talking about the tears for fears one?

[@ioncekilledamanwithmyshoe]

sherry stoopid let‘S not go that far, because it’s pretty good.

[@corinnemodesti3798]

sherry stoopid tears for fears are bad? Ok

[@xxkiaraxx5251]

Bro same

[@asshole94]

It's better than the tears for fears version, and not quite as depressing as Gary's version. Yeah, I said it like we know him.

[@sapphire1569]

her voice sounds like an instrument and i mean that in the best way possible

[@obamessiah]

Her voice doesn't sound like an instrument, it IS and instrument.

[@TheBluesnbob]

A voice can be an instrument!

[@bibir6170]

Yes, her voice is definitely an instrument kzbin.info/www/bejne/p5Wxg3SIqrqod6s

[@reina4969]

It's absurd. I just stare at her like, "how is that possible".

[@bluemagician9724]

Time to drop her into the Absolute

[@nicholasfeiock4952]

I want puddles to sing at my funeral. He would be the only one in attendance.

[@agirlforgod6955]

Gimme your parlour address. Watch me mourn the loss of a good person. *I dare you.*

[@lonniehawkins582]

Can we Skype the funeral ? That counts right ?

[@agirlforgod6955]

@@lonniehawkins582 oh yah totally

[@lonniehawkins582]

@@agirlforgod6955 a girl for God is that saying a girl with God in her life or something else .

[@agirlforgod6955]

The Lord God Almighty, my dear Lonnie 😊

[@TheUnclefester13]

Two voices on the opposite ends of the emotional spectrum set against each other creates a tension that it so strange it’s cute. Especially the contrast of size and character of the two. Love this version.

[@sanay1313]

Haley AND Puddles??! What is this, some kind of dream?

[@Aminorat]

+SanaySK Better than the ones where you are dying?

[@austingarcia5022]

+SanaySK My thoughts exactly. All of my favorite songs on the channel are with Haley or Puddles. Having them both is awesome, though I think she outshined a little bit. It was cool to see him overcome his anxiety and get that close to another person, but he was still a little quiet, and aside from the first part he's barely audible against her voice.

[@crimeslime5419]

Exactly what I thought!!!! They're so awesome together too.

[@aestevalis0]

+SanaySK The only thing that could make it better is if they were performing one of my favorite songs. Oh, wait...

[@LRBeforeTheInternet]

+SanaySK It's a mad world. :)

[@lnt_9666]

the woman’s voice omg

[@leefithian3704]

Yes !

[@queenvrook]

Boy, are you not wrong!

[@blankspacebv-p7190]

it sounds just all the old voices from like the 80s or something

[@floreamihai3852]

@@blankspacebv-p7190 way before that lol this is like 40s jazz.

[@ctgguy2732]

@@floreamihai3852 yeah

[@muzza4238]

Haley is amazing but how good is Puddles !!! Brings his voice perfectly down to melt into Haleys. Such a pro!!

[@tuneteenth]

Tears for Fears: childhood Gary Jules: teen years This version: adulthood and funeral!

[@Endye__]

When I see puddles pitty party i feel bad for him bc he seems so sad I hope he’s ok!

[@ihateyouall7026]

Bobbi Paccio look up Mike Geier. He's fine, this is just a persona.

[@brooke4842]

It’s just a character he plays he’s not actually that depressed all the time

[@asshole94]

It's just a gimmick to sell records. Like gangsta rap.

[@harper1738]

YOUR PFP IS JACK GRAZER AHSHEBS

[@DctorSkillz1]

Hi. It's me, sad clown from video. I'm ok.

[@MrNickDemos]

This whole thing literally feels like a fever dream.

[@Pulvrk1n-ti5hp]

IKR

[@mpw8883]

With my health, every so often i have ‘moments’ where I hallucinate not only visually but audibly as well.....the last time it happened, i swear i saw and heard these two: i should add that the day i post this comment (23rd march 2021) is the very first time i’ve experienced a performance of theirs

[@brendanmuller7301]

@@mpw8883 We're all fragments of your imagination bro wake up please ashley misses you so do i

[@angelramirez936]

Just like the movie it's famous for lol

[@brendanmuller7301]

@@angelramirez936 never heard of the movie what movie

[@mrzed.1018]

Love Puddles This guy deserves way more respect and way more recognition

[@scottdecker1803]

Couldn't agree more.

[@hyramchepoofniac8121]

they both do.

[@paleskowitzz]

​@@hyramchepoofniac8121 this. ^^

[@andrewnichols1240]

I'm a member in this world too. Riding along with these two lovely beautiful artists and I'm holding on cause never know when nature will hit the breaks!! This video has a sound base

[@user-qb5wy5dg8w]

waw, she sings like she doesn't make any effort at all. it's like the way she talks! amazing

[@DENicholsAutoBravado]

And if I heard right, she did that in her first take! She was like, let's do that again. And they said no. I think we got it! It was either on this one or the first one when she joined the Jukebox and sung a solo. She was like, I just got off work and I wasn't feeling it, lol. Nope. She rocked our world.

[@vids1900]

@@DENicholsAutoBravado where'd you hear that? I'd love to get some behind the scenes on how these are made

[@kateluvshugz]

I thought the same thing. I cant figure out if she has just practiced so much that it looks effortless after so much work and practice like a baseball player who has been batting for 10 years or if she just happens to be able to be able to sing like that like it's nothing. Probably the first one

[@melissadana7829]

@@Mega Traum Nope. Live.

[@benbiberger4744]

if you are an arab,it is not allowed to you to hear music,if you dont want to burn in hell. I read this in the holy Qu`ran

[@TheDukeofDan]

Everyone keep in mind Haley is not particularly short, she's just next to Puddles the 6ft 8 absolute unit

[@johnkess2174]

Haley is 5'2"

[@Kay_The_Coffee_Weirdo]

I'm 5'4" and Puddles towered over me when I saw him. He's so attentive and sweet tho.

[@ninavinterova9875]

she's 154 cm, for everyone who doesn't participate in the mess of measuring people by their stinky feet.

[@Ginkoman2]

@@ninavinterova9875 Pahaha. that was a painful nose exhale. Also 6""""""8'''''''' is 207 cm

[@ninavinterova9875]

@@Ginkoman2 we're talking about Haley tho

[@buzzyfuzzsaw]

Mr. Puddles, I don't think I've seen a face as emotive as yours since Lon Chaney. Astonishingly, your voice is moreover as expressive on an order of magnitude. I am awestruck by your ability to express on so many levels.

[@AmberS-V]

This is not only audibly amazing, but the two of them performing together is absolutely adorable.

[@honey_no_thanks9480]

Everyones talking about haley (legit the prettiest voice) but puddles honestly smacked, the way his voice went so nicely and his talent is so beyond, like i cant even describe it, its just awesome! He's awesome! :)

[@aaaaaaaalina8014]

Its nice

[@hahakamoo5125]

Honey_ No_Thanks both are awasome😍

[@gloom1830]

you used smacked wrong lmao

[@izzybitsyspider03]

@@gloom1830 I was looking for this 😂

[@bewell4743]

That's very true! Well said! 🎶👍🏼🎶

[@alex-cz7uf]

I LOVE HER VOICE WHEN SHE FIRST STEPS IN OMG here are free loops 0:43 0:43 0:43 0:43 0:43

[@subliminalowll]

Alexandra THE WAY SHE SINGS “kinda Funny” I’m literally screaming

[@lethality3589]

@@subliminalowll deadassss sameee💖💘💕😤

[@oilheart8503]

OMG YESSS🙈🙈🙈🙈🙈🙈😳

[@kaii4741]

1:11 is better

[@nohentrich2390]

Meeee tooooooo

[@rutlegs]

The way their voices blend... absolutely beautiful.

[@elcoach8931]

I v seen this clip many times as the expression at Puddles face, eyes body is so endearing and fascinating. An endless joy to watch subtility and grace in the intrepration of this song by two complete opposite caracters, that merge voices and blend without loosing identity. All of the sadness is compensated by love and friendship, so even the world is a mad place, there is a hope for clowns to survive.

[@sieliestschonwieder1987]

The mixture of them both - puddles' deep melancholy and Hayley's charismatic energy - created a bonbon. The band is wonderful, too. Great job! Thank you!

[@TheWalker10]

Damn, was that straight from a vynil record? Cause I swear, Haley's voice sounds like she's coming straight from the '50s; she's got that smooth yet slightly raspy sound... *shivers* And let's not forget Pity Party's complete performance that makes him loook like he's straight from some 20's black-and-white masterpiece, with all the raw emotion pouring out of him. The whole thing is just... Damn.

[@patriciamorrison7905]

I'm screaming, the whole performance just I love it so much

[@grittyfaithgrittyfacts]

His Friends call him Puddles the Clown. Only his lawyer calls him Mr. Pity Party

[@olstar18]

Love their work. I have both their lp's and really hoping they release a third soon. This past holiday I also made a bit of a mistake. I let my cousins daughter listen to it on my record player and now she is asking for a turntable.

[@elanor8909]

olstar18 that's so sweet! she has good taste!

[@20ksubscriberswithoutanyvi93]

-Koko the clown

[@bunnylittle4319]

Lyric: All around me are familiar faces Worn out places, worn out faces Bright and early for the daily races Going nowhere, going nowhere Their tears are filling up their glasses No expression, no expression Hide my head, I wanna drown my sorrow No tomorrow, no tomorrow And I find it kind of funny I find it kind of sad The dreams in which I'm dying Are the best I've ever had I find it hard to tell you I find it hard to take When people run in circles it's a very, very Mad world, mad world Children waiting for the day they feel good Happy birthday, happy birthday And I feel the way that every child should Sit and listen, sit and listen Went to school and I was very nervous No one knew me, no one knew me Hello, teacher! Tell me, what's my lesson? Look right through me, look right through me And I find it kind of funny I find it kind of sad The dreams in which I'm dying Are the best I've ever had I find it hard to tell you I find it hard to take When people run in circles it's a very, very Mad world, mad world Enlarging your world Mad world

[@ritatodd1070]

WOW very profound

[@miska6742]

I was looking for this comment lol Thanks

[@ProAnnabelle-ge6sl]

❤❤❤😢😮🎉❤❤❤

[@wealthyblackman2655]

I listened to this and failed to grasp it fully the first time... CAME BACK AND LISTENED A HUNDRED TIMES.... EXCELLENT JOB AND BEAUTIFUL PERFORMANCE!

[@tommytran8880]

They look like a girl and her invisible “imaginary” friend that protects her from bullies and anyone that would harm her, but is also a big softie and is scared of mice nd shit

[@pablodavidclavijo4609]

You pitch that to Pixar and you make millions

[@MoikeOI]

Bruh 😂 gold

[@jiznimore]

genius

[@GinDragon]

That movie is called Drop Dead Fred.

[@tommytran8880]

GinDragon Nice! I’ll check it out, probably, at some point.

[@TheAaron3dg]

The vocal arrangement here is one of the most beautiful sounds on this earth. Mr. Puddles and Haley knocked it out of the park!

[@3dpprofessor]

Still coming back to this every time I hear a different version of this song. No other version compares.

[@chrisstephens4203]

There is something truly captivating about Puddles and his voice/demeanour. I absolutely Love Haley's voice and style ever since I saw her cover of Creep but Puddles voice genuinely makes this cover so addictive. Thanks for this to all involved.

[@Royal_Vengeance]

The voice of that girl is just pure gold . Very entertaining funny take on a pretty depressing song. Well done !

[@shannonk.362]

Anthony Savoie I feel bad for anyone who has to do a duet with her, she completely steals the show & leaves the other person in the dust; even someone as talented as Puddles.

[@Royal_Vengeance]

Julien ROUX Boy that escalated quickly.

[@jazzybaby2391]

Julien ROUX Excuse you sir? Could you sing better than Haley in any of the songs she's done? No so sit down and think about what the word respect means please and thank you. 😆

[@jazzybaby2391]

Julien ROUX That wasn't what I was saying but ok whatever makes you happy man

[@jazzybaby2391]

Julien ROUX I'm saying you can't bash anyone else's talent if you can't do any better yourself. It's a Moral. I can't insult on someones dancing skills in a video if I knew I couldn't do any better. So if you wanted to say something about Haley's voice as an opinion you could have done it with more respect that's all.

[@osmeelohi1302]

Haley Heinhart, one of the best femme voices that I ever heard.

[@Robindalmiras]

Both are amazing!

[@iamnotelissa]

A voz dessa moça é muito perfeita

[@cycomisfits]

Tem outras 2 musicas do postmodern jukebox com ela cantando que são incriveis. Creep do Radiohead e don't speak do no doubt. Se por acaso ainda não assistiu, assista!

[@cycomisfits]

E também tem a all about the bass com ela, morgan james e ariane savalas. É muito boa e muito diverdida.

[@biancavitoria3981]

Totalmente 💘

[@Lonpone]

I love how they put this together. Puddles slowly shrinks into himself in this song and the facial expressions he uses makes him seem childlike and insecure. Haley popping out gives a lot of expression to the idealization of suicide and how robust and intimidating everyday life would be to Puddle's character.

[@danielmiller3596]

You need to see his show. It’s an interesting emotional experience.

[@michaelgarrow3239]

Go see a professional.

[@Lonpone]

@@michaelgarrow3239 Did you not listen to the song? Its about suicide. Appreciation of art is not a sign of mental disturbance. If it were everyone who liked Romeo and Juliet would be considered unhinged.

[@michaelgarrow3239]

Adam - you see it as about suicide. That is fine though. I liked the song too.

[@leannezezeski-sass2773]

@Michael Garrow the song was actually written about suicide

[@mykuromi3563]

I like this version better then the original

[@kenhendryx]

Nothing beats the original Tears for Fears

[@mykuromi3563]

Kendall Hendryx the original is good, but I’m a sucker for old sounding music. Plus I like clowns.

[@ilovetwice5]

Same

[@Cohemotgus]

Tears for fears original or Gary Jules original?

[@mykuromi3563]

Cohemotgus the cover- this video.

[@ZTheLastViking]

When I turn this up loud enough in my car it almost sounds like I can sing.

[@gazepskotzs4]

Lol, or with headphones i really almost believe that. I know that i am actually terrorizing my neighbours😅🤣😂🤣😅!

[@ZTheLastViking]

@@gazepskotzs4 I had my headphones on and thought I was getting good so I decided to record it on my phone. That was a huge reality check and very uncomfortable to listen to. xD

[@lonniehawkins582]

I was two Cars over , nope not even almost . Lol

[@lonniehawkins582]

That's what that was , thought somebody ran over a 🐈 cat .

[@I_Kan]

😆😆

[@Spammyguy712]

Two of my favorite PMJ performers. It doesn't get any better.

[@postmodernjukebox]

+Dean Webb If you love Puddles, check out our album, Top Hat on Fleek, featuring two of his songs, in addition to many more gems! itunes.apple.com/il/album/top-hat-on-fleek/id1055767866?app=itunes&ign-mpt=uo%3D4

[@claemiller]

+PostmodernJukebox hey is it possible to get a hard copy of your guys albums

[@ICBIGFOOT150]

+claemiller you could download t then burn onto a CD :)

[@jaredfranco5121]

+Dean Webb agreed

[@Spammyguy712]

Just bought 4 seats for your Orlando concert! Can't wait to see you in October!

[@yesterdaysMagician]

The little dance makes me smile, it's so cute

[@spencerjarvis2899]

Goosebumps from her voice every single time.

[@kurtmcfc1629]

not only a magical vocal performance by both.. but they really sold the story with the body language.. Special talents for sure.

[@caraciliento7817]

the way she said “and i find it kinda funny” omgggg 😍😍 0:43

[@imanihudson4118]

is no one gonna talk about that cute ass dance they did????

[@Anarchy-Is-Liberty]

I was to busy!!!

[@angelafields8319]

The restraint that Puddles had to use so his movements wouldn't overpower Haley merely due to the size difference... So adorable and in keeping with his meek yet powerful voice and presence.

[@Ease54]

I'd prefer to discuss the cute ass and the dance separately.

[@dshiwota]

Slightly less scared of clowns after watching this.

[@Daniel-rl9cv]

This is one of the best collaborations Puddles has ever done I think. It shows how he can really work his voice very differently than his typical large grand sound that he’s known for wow wow wow both of them wow🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰

[@Arclight1988]

I think I was most surprised by how well their two voices melded together. With her high pitch you could easily lose a deeper tone, yet you can tell easily when they are both singing. Prolly my favorite rendition of this song.

[@JaPowClips]

This whole thing is Gold - Haley's voice, Puddles singing, the arrangement and staging, all of it, Gold. But Puddles eyes while Haley sings her solo part, that's 24 Carat right there. Guy's a genius.

[@AsIfInteractive]

Totally. He's right there.

[@josht9518]

"Can I sing now-... n-no? now-... o-o-ok just keep going... I-I guess" LOL Didn't notice till you mentioned it.

[@alanyoung6847]

Wow... I have listened to so many versions of this sing over the past few months. It is good medicine which sometimes brings tears, somehow builds resolve, but this is the first time it has brought joy. Brilliant. I think in its own weird way it truly brings out the deep complex intent of the songwriter...

[@ravenknight6363]

Puddle is so and Haley work so well together. It give me shiver listening to them singing together....

[@shawnpeacock1037]

She has a ridiculously great voice

[@Annikahae]

It’s almost to good to handle

[@mohamedmohamud3639]

Damn right oyee

[@cjmmjc2131]

Simon said it correctly.... He voice was too mature and seasoned for American Idol.

[@Dalter33081]

She sounds like she should be singing in the 20's or 30's. I like her voice.

[@etaidade3983]

she is

[@ricefarmer8292]

Etai Faz I don't think you understood what he meant

[@theycallmesomething4532]

Dalter33081 Judging by her attire, I'm guessing that's her gimic (Like Puddles is supposed to represented sad clown).

[@thulsakhan]

HALEY's "Gimmick" is that she is the most gifted singer ever!

[@thulsakhan]

Sorry if it seemed that way, but it has nothing to do with you, I will always use all caps for HALEY, her singing, her voice, her artistry, means that much to me, I always have used all caps for her and I always will.

[@Ryan-ye3cz]

Both did an amazing job!!! Haley is one of the best singers ever I love her music and Puddles is amazing himself! Together they blew this song out of the park!

[@hankf616]

Since this was originally released, I’ve probably watched it 100 times, and never get tired of it. A truly spectacular performance.

[@ninjabuttocks]

Came for Puddles, stayed for small lady with pretty voice.

[@bamadoctj]

Yeah!

[@rantenki]

She ain't tiny... He's just 6'8" plus a hat!

[@bottomsugatrash9934]

Her name is Haley Reinhart

[@radioaktiv7841]

Puddles is just giant

[@samuelmendoza9356]

and with a nice hat

[@jamesfrankel7827]

This duo is such a spectacularly shining duet of talent, I'd listen to their album. Please please, create one.

[@ZealTroublemaker]

Agreeeeeed!! I’d listen to it on repeat like I do this song!!!

[@simonjones3845]

What a superb duo he has the voice of a sad angel, she a sassy whiskey drinker, so rich and beautiful.

[@ivorellarackley4401]

One of the best videos of PPP imo. Between the hiding, the voice play and the casual hand holding? I love it. Thanks PMJ!

[@boijorzee]

Her voice has ranges from buttery smooth to brassy and abrasive in a matter of seconds. Classy!

[@majdoulinkhadiri9532]

boijorzee yess

[@murmansqurman7108]

Wat

[@danielchenault533]

check Hailey in PMJ's "All About That Bass"

[@illus1ve]

She brings the trumpet-esque sound. Brassy.

[@humdrummer]

Check out Haley's version of creep. Best version ever

[@agnesbian467]

Esse cover é simplesmente a coisa mais linda que já ouvi

[@isalisa_4943]

Yes sim

[@Ana-he2bi]

Sim

[@sla_boy143]

Siiim

[@musicplaylist2371]

Uhum

[@evelynfelix3072]

Sim

[@hugohackenbush1554]

There are not enough superlatives to describe just how perfect this is ❤️❤️🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿🇬🇧

[@m1kmik]

Their voices suits and compliments each other very well!! Aaaaaaa just chef's kiss 👌👏👏👏

[@ganasde65]

The clown makes Haley look like a hobbit :D Amazing as always.

[@AlexandreKarpov]

+shadow light Big Mike Geier would make pretty much anyone look like a hobbit )

[@diegom-a7970]

a beautiful hobbit :p

[@abelosorio7687]

+shadow light hahahah this guy is huge!! :O

[@vect0rwolf]

+Diego M-A redundant :D

[@ehhorvath13]

+shadow light Plus she is in high heels!

[@kenbeech4940]

His facial expression when he's not singing are just so good. Even with his make up and conveys his sadness while she sings the song in a different upbeat feel and sound.

[@Carstuff111]

5th time listening to this....and I STILL tear up with joy, this is such a beautiful version of this song!

[@Kelekona_808]

Love the juxtaposition of the joy/innocence and sorrow/harsh reality of the vocal parts in this video. Really glad I found this and I thank you all for sharing it!

[@Liesmith424]

As the saying goes: "behind every sad clown, is a tiny singing woman". It really makes you think.

[@sallybluefox3537]

Puddles is amazing, his expressions... Movements... Just awesome

[@charlesmcwhirter1326]

Her singing takes me back to a time and place that I’ve never been.

[@broceollomon]

That moment when Haley walks out from behind Puddles though.

[@DanGolag]

I went back to an earlier point to see if I could spot her, nothing doing. She's completely hidden.

[@DanielA-ub1ts]

Gal Dagon not completely

[@solamon77]

You can see her shadow. That's about it. You'd never notice it though if you weren't already looking for it.

[@gpnulife]

Yeah it was so child-like. Shirley Temple style!

[@dafuqmr13]

If she's born somewhere in 10's or 20's She would be a Legend in Jazz

[@natvan5869]

I am not the walrus or she would of been told to stay where a woman should, the past wasn't kind to ladies

[@fulanitx]

nat van not the past, MEN.

[@jaden_bricker]

nat van-Not in the twenties, actually. You know, when they got all their rights.

[@nathanpitman4547]

well....we ARE in the "10's or 20's"... ;)

[@momtenjillian987]

On loop 4ever. The nuance makes me shiver. Very cool 🌞

[@buffybufff]

WHY I DIDNT KNOW ABOUT THIS VERSION OF THE SONGGGG!! THAT WOMAN'S VOICE IS LIKE HEAVEN

[@TheBeckybw]

Her voice is enchanting and then mixed with his make this song ever so perfect!

[@kingofbachatax]

Yet it's so touching

[@Canal2Playerz]

Their voices are just perfect. This music gives me chills! Dammm!

[@mrbobawesome]

Stunning version. Let's take a moment to appreciate how great this song is that it adapts so well to other styles so well.

[@harryhartley1466]

I am just hypnotized by Haley Reinhart. Her voice is amazing. Her mannerisms are so enchanting. I have watched this video like a hundred times. After watching so many with my eyes glued to Haley, I changed my focus to Puddles. Look at his facial expressions. Very emotive and expressive. I think this video is perfection. I love it. The best. Interestingly, not everyone sees it. Hmmm...

[@davemath9103]

I agree with all that you say. I regard this as one of Haley's top performances. And PMJ is a genius and this is an amazing duet .. kudos to Puddles.

[@jamesbryan1644]

I completely agree with you. And have watched this many times. She is sooo fine.

[@walley2637]

I came for Puddles and then saw Haley...i could watch them all day long.

[@czntrm]

Such a perfect blending and contrast! Someone said Puddles' voice is like butter, and I say Haley's is like strawberry jam... in other words, they're like a strawberries and cream combination. 🍓🍦🍰👍🏻

[@julieporter7805]

It's like a visual interpretation of bipolar with Hayley representing mania and Puddles representing depression.

[@angelita895]

A voz dessa mulher-- 🛐🛐🛐🛐🛐

[@anne6063]

Sim

[@samilly3711]

@@anne6063 sim

[@cyberconfuse]

A voz dessa mulher emoji orando?

[@anne6063]

@@cyberconfuse kakakakakaka

[@madu_ferreira]

Simm

[@PhotoOwl]

The way Haley Reinhart stepped in was just simply epic. I love her classic American "jazz voice"

[@b.bailey8244]

I am completely charmed by you, Puddles (Haley, too) - great duet, superb musicians. Loved it all.

[@Eduarda-dx1rl]

Essa versão é bem melhor do que a original.🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷

[@ajotabe7867]

A voz dela é satisfatória

[@pitozitos]

Sim vdd

[@Eduarda-dx1rl]

@@ajotabe7867 Simmm-

[@mariaritanunezcassiano6820]

Mas essa é a original "_"

[@bicalh6662]

@@mariaritanunezcassiano6820 a original é do mad world

[@lyneae3786]

Does Puddles have any idea how good they sound together? I mean, they each are amazing separate, but it is just great to hear them together, especially with this particular music genre.

[@retalbtaylor370]

These two were made to sing together! Simply brilliant! Love him alone or with others, no way has he even remotely been even a tiny bit bad at what he does! Always brings it to the HILT!

[@Arkioshi]

I never remembered any memories up untill i was 7.. but god i distinctly remember 5 year old me being absolutely astounded hearing this cover

[@martyweiner6525]

The nuance in Haley's vocal harmony is a kaleidoscope of unfolding joy. And of course, Puddles rocks.

[@monkeyapo8516]

You have quite a way with words! o.O

[@EiferBrennan]

Marty Weiner That was beautifully put, sir.

[@vixeylazer5796]

These 2 need more together. The pitiful clown act next to a top hat wearing, peppy little woman. Very carnival like. Their voices go together as well.

[@beauzeller5097]

Vixey Lazer yes I too would very much like to see them do all the songs. Like ALL the songs ever

[@EmuPlaysMinecraft]

I know it’s a few months late, but she’s not a little woman

[@consistentinconsistency3867]

101 Easybakes You're wrong. She is quite a little woman. 5'1, to be exact. That is considered short by most standards. Or average, at best.

[@R_L_M]

😎

[@danielchenault533]

Indeed, they contrast each other very well on several levels

[@pamelamaccabee637]

Beautifully done. Great duet. Puddles sings withvsuch a wide variety of people. Loved her performsnce, too.

[@theralphster8492]

I remember Tears for Fears bringing this out, brilliant song and band, love this version, compared to 1982 it really is a mad world...

[@joshuaboudreau5258]

Watched this video like 20 times and I still get goosebumps. What a well paired vocal duo

[@lightofheavens943]

I swear she has sweet vinyl crackles integrated into her voice somehow...

[@purselmer5931]

OMG, that describes it perfectly. What a beauty of a voice.

[@kugelblitz2001]

It's an amazing magic trick - when Haley starts singing, the tall clown just disappears!

[@judas30]

+CtrlZED Brother? Is that you?

[@_cykra]

+judas30 almost thought you two were the same person xd

[@crybaby_styles_panicatthec2419]

+judas30 loooool

[@griffgoldstein6378]

Her voice just drowns out Puddle's voice.

[@Q1307]

I see what you did there ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)