Premier VS Mary Maxim - The Results will Shock You - Yarn Vs Yarn #1

[@emilymatienzo5922]

Thanks to Bag-O-Day Crochet, I can read a pattern out of a book. Knowledge is empowering, and she is such a good teacher.

[@SusanHumeston]

I never wondered before what makes a yarn "anti=pilling" and here is what I learned. Shorter fibers make more pilling probabity. Longer fibers like silk are virtually pill free. So that includes natural fibers as well as man make fibers. There are 3 different chemicals applied to yarn to make it "anti-pilling". Each chemical makes the fibers smoother, but some chemicals work better than others. I would imagine that no matter how chemical is applied, it eventually washes out and you are left with the "naked" yarn. I will be looking this up more. I have been wearing sweaters all my life and, as a young girl, I HATED pilling. I bought my sweaters, not knowing how to knit or crochet at that time. I loved the look of a new sweater, but it didn't last. I had various yarn shavers with batteries to get the pills off and that works for awhile. My thinking is that the better AND LONGER the fiber, the less pilling that will occur. Very interesting video - not what I expected!! Crystal rules!!

[@TheWovenSoul]

Thanks for that 😊 very interesting!

[@florenceanderson9681]

It's tutorials like yours that makes learning to crochet so much enjoyable and interesting 🧶🪡✂️! Thank you for the enlightening 👌🏾!

[@ChrsitineBressette]

I gotta say.I watch quite a few different tutorials with different people.And I think Crystal explains everything the best. I like to give other people a chance as well. I also like the info that we got about all the different types of yarns😊 😊😊😊

[@susani.-partyonwithyarnandcroc]

Thank you for all you do. I have learned so much since joining your channel 3 yrs ago. You have given me the confidence to try new things and to believe in myself. I don't have anyone at home to encourage me to continue to crochet and that made me doubt myself. You and the friends I made on the YT streets have helped me continue to crochet and try new things. ❤

[@Rizuzua]

You got this 🤗

[@lindagraves3117]

@susani.-partyonwithyarnandcroc I second that! I don't have a soul to show or converse with. I wanted to take some of the things I have made to a farmers market to try and sell. Because of Crystals' awesome tutorials, I feel confident enough to try to sell some things. I have a crap ton. Thank you Crystal 🌹🌹

[@susani.-partyonwithyarnandcroc]

@@lindagraves3117 That is wonderful. Hope all goes well at the farmers market. Please let me know how it goes. 🤗

[@jackieschneider7354]

Thank you Crystal. I enjoy comparisons. Both look good so I would probably be confident using either yarn. Although Mary Maxim keeping its shape is definitely an advantage.

[@grannyt6819]

Very surprising the difference between size just in the initial crochet. I like the Mellowspun. It looks drapier, which I really like in yarn items. Fun comparison and very interesting. Thanks, Crystal!

[@pamelarogers6143]

Wow results were different than I expected.

[@GASophie]

I love Premier but I use Mary Maxim, too. Depends on the project. I love that you do this for us !!!

[@sharoncarty5096]

You have made me more aware of the quality of yarns. Thank you. Knowledge really is power. Bless you Crystal.

[@sandielovescrocheting8300]

I love your yarn reviews. It helps me decide what to expect from yarns that I haven't used before.❤❤❤❤❤

[@Laceycrochet]

Me too. I’ve 100% trusted Crystal’s judgement and experience with yarns for years and years now 💜🇬🇧

[@preciousbeautyj1043]

Good morning Crystal. I’ve both yarns, haven’t used the Mellow Spun yet but I’m truly surprised. Thanks for the review w/swatches washed n dried.

[@fairyGrandmother]

Hey Crystal!! I have a hooded sweater that I knit my daughter over 20yrs ago made from mellow spun. I still have it! Even though she is 27 now. ( I was hoping for a grand to come along and wear it!) Oh well theres always hope! I love the mellow spun yarn!!! TFS Hugs!

[@LisaT_]

Thank you… great! I just bought the colors from Mary Maxim for your Jacob’s ladder. Happy. Happy. AND got a deal. ❤

[@9875z]

to avoid the chemicals used for anti-pilling, a cup of vinegar added to washing machine cycle will also work.

[@ceciliawilds6973]

Thank you , love both company’s but premiere is my fav

[@michelleromano6722]

Thank you Crystal! I never know what yarn is best to buy👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻💜

[@nelsaf365]

I had that same dilemma, Premier AP or MM’s MS. Thanks for going beyond by washing and drying.

[@jessmakingit]

Love this video and would like to see more like this. I love to see the differences and similarities in yarns. I also like that you leave it to the viewer to decide what they are looking for in a yarn. Thank you so much!

[@marilynjones7461]

Thank you for this video. I just ordered the MM yarn for a sweater that a friend has commissioned. She wants it In black so I’m hoping it washes nice after I’m done making it. I’ve made 3 sweaters in MM yarn and I love working with it. Also, I got it on sale for $3.99 a skein and a $10.00 off coupon on my order. Great price

[@grannyt6819]

Nice. I love the comparison videos. Pretty colors.

[@joelleburgess3962]

Thank you for making this comparison.

[@AnaNicole1225]

Now I understand Anti-Pilling so much better, Thank you, Crystal ~☆~ ✨️ ❣️ ✨️ ~☆~

[@starwarsgirl076]

🎉Very informative. Thank you for the comparison Crystal.💙🎉

[@gioiacasterline4835]

Thanks, Crystal, for all the great info on the yarns.

[@KarenGarrick-q4y]

Keep doing this type of evaluation; it's very educational. Good idea, Crystal!❤❤

[@Gloria_Diaz]

These are two of my favorite DKs. Thank you for the comparison.

[@DawnRaeB]

I love that you did this comparison. I have never seen Mary Maxim yarn. But I have wondered how the Premiere anti-pilling yarn compares to others.

[@DianneMc]

This is very interesting and informative. Thank you for the comparison!

[@bunnygaffney2765]

I absolutely love both of the yarns .just have to do different projects for each yarn. The MM is si perfect for a baby sweater .and I've used Premier for a lap blanket

[@raphelleguy6529]

Love the comparison videos.

[@judyeng9822]

I’ve never used the Mary Maxim yarn but I have the premier! Thank you for sharing the differences! Will have to try Mary maxims now! God Bless. Take care. Love you. ❤️🙏😇

[@shadowpebs]

Great to see the way the yarn turns out after washing. Thanks for sharing!

[@bethtisdalestaton7250]

Good Morning Crystal 🌻💖😊! Wow, I am very surprised also & Thank You so much for this comparison Video 💖💖💖😊!

[@pamelahunter987]

Great comparison test. Thanks, Crystal. ❤

[@maryannbryant8775]

Great video. A little surprised with the anti pilling and the fuzz. The Mary Maxim I like better. Thanks for doing this video Crystal😊 Did either one of these colors run in the wash?

[@jarrettd74]

Thank you for the knowledge and the time that you put into all of these yarns for us! I would have thought that the Premier would have come back a lot stronger than the Mary Maxim! Just as shocked as you are!

[@IAMvlagattuta]

Very cool comparison. Thanks Crystal. I do use both also. I do have more splitting with the Mary Maxim but not horrible.

[@lindachandler2293]

My late husband had trouble with his feet. The diabetic socks didn't work well for him, so I got the premier anti pilling yarn and made him several pairs of socks to fit his feet. They never pilled and they were easy to darn, so I really like that yarn.

[@ChristineWilloughby]

Surprising results. Thanks for the review. Love your consistant content. Your knowledge is so helpful❤

[@lisakirk9686]

Make MORE of these. I learn tons! Please! Thank you! 😂

[@donnaroach73]

Very helpful Crystal! Thank you!

[@chelinfusco6403]

When I tried the Mellon Spun, I was very happy with the results. It is wonderful for garments. It makes a great fabric.

[@LadyValkyri]

Super surprising result as far as the fuzzing! Huh! Hugs

[@aidasoto8443]

Ty Crystal ❤❤❤❤❤

[@DianEnglish56]

Hi Crystal, Thank you for doing the side-by-side review of the Premier and Mary Maxim yarns. 🧶🫂

[@katherinefilz]

Thanks for doing this comparison. Its nice to see the before and after wash. Helps make picking a yarn a little easier.

[@marlenataylor8758]

This comparison certainly was a surprise, thank you

[@cherylhunt3077]

Love this type of review. It really is appreciated to know how different yarns wash up and dry. Thank you for the reivew.

[@bjbaar3]

I’m surprised! Thank you for doing the comparison!

[@Crochetedbymichi]

I really enjoy working with the anti-pilling. I haven’t tried the mellowspun yet but it’s on its way. Your videos are always so educational. I have learned so much about yarns from you ❤

[@barbaracabrera207]

Good video!!! TFS! Austin TX USA

[@kimhumbert9335]

I really enjoy learning about these yarns

[@lashelieaboone5274]

Thank you for showing the various differences in the yarn. You really do educate as you show yarns. Thank you so much for all you do.

[@NJgrandma]

Thanks for taking the time to do this comparison. I’ve used the Premiere Yarn, but have never bought any MM. I’m wondering if the anti-pilling treatment would have a better effect on the yarn after MULTIPLE washings. However, I might consider trying the MM. thanks again!

[@karenh2890]

I'm wondering the same thing. Maybe Crystal could do a few more washings?

[@cherylsmith5307]

Interesting results. I appreciate your doing this comparison and test. It's really helpful when deciding on which yarn to use and whether or not to put it in the washer and dryer. Thanks!!! 💜🥰

[@darthlaurel]

I remember the first time I got mellowspun. I was really impressed with it and I've been buying it ever since.

[@mareencope8421]

Thanks for the review. It makes choosing what to buy much easier.

[@tracylg13]

Thank you Crystal, love these comparison videos.

[@sharonrose1226]

Thanks for the comparison. I have quite a bit of both MM and Premier in my stash!

[@debrahill7519]

Thanks for the review. It has been many many years since I’ve ordered from Mary Maxim - going to order from them soon.

[@mommamimaashouse9511]

I’m a Mellowspun girl. Love it! 😍

[@HookingGoodCreationsbyTinaC]

Crystal, you are a natural teacher. Thank you for your wisdom ❤

[@meandmymacaw2735]

wow, I would rather have it look good after the wash than before. I think I would buy the Mellowspun . I have purchased the anti-pilling a few times but now I definitely am trying out the Mary Maxim now that I see the results. Great video. Thanks Crystal, this was a real eye opener for me.

[@wendyschmidt4339]

thank you for your all nt the first nancial hit to help us❤ You are appreciated 🙏🏼🌷

[@lindal3451]

Thanks Crystal, I'm like you use both yarns and was disappointed in the anti pilling. 😮😮😮

[@joannegonzalez9931]

WOW!! great información 😊 thank you 💖💯

[@Irishhrtge]

Thanks for testing the yarns for us

[@judymckinstry8130]

I do love your honest reviews. Thank you!

[@twistedparent]

This is why it's important to do a swatch.

[@stephaniegill8392]

I find these types of videos interesting and very entertaining, thanks.

[@theresasatterfield2828]

Wow! I'm surprised with the results as well. I love these videos. So informative. 🧶💚

[@marlenemahn1245]

I was shocked that I could see the fuzzing on the premier before you even zoomed in, but couldn't see the fuzzing on the mellow spun until you zoomed in. I was really surprised how much fuzzing there was on the premier after only one wash and dry. Thanks for sharing!

[@Pammy_Yolo]

I've never bought anti pilling yarn. I figured it was probably a gimmick. I do love the MM mellow spun yarn. ❤ Ty for sharing your knowledge with us! You have taught me so much since I found your channel. ❤❤❤

[@LisaBrook-rx2qj]

Thanks for the video. I find sometimes the cheaper yarns are the better yarns. It's a judgement call when you go to buy yarn.

[@cherylelinsmith743]

I like the look of the Premier sample, looks neater. When I tried to do the brioche stitch scarf with the Mandala sparkle yarn it looked sloppy, messy. Yarn store owner said to do it in worsted wool yarn but, instead of using size 8 needles to use size 6. It's working out really nicely, and much neater. That's amazing the premier after washing doesn't look as nice, but if it's not washed it still looks neater.

[@traceyfreeman5784]

Thanks for the comparison video. I have been wanting to try the Premire anti pilling, now I’m sure I will now for sure.😊

[@barbaraking9966]

Thank you for sharing i was a little surprize about the permier but they still look ok

[@snipchick]

Mary Maxim Mellowspun DK is one of my favorite yarns to work with, and the price is right, especially when it's on sale. I've made a few blankets from it and they wash and dry so nicely. I haven't used any anti-pilling yarns, so thanks for the comparison Crystal.

[@RosegarlandCreations]

Thankyou for sharing Crystal, Incredible outcome; xx

[@maryb8150]

The difference in how they worked up is why, when you are making garments that are size-dependent, you always, always, always do a gauge sample.

[@danamiceli4948]

Very informative - thank you Crystal

[@judyhodge2362]

Such valuable information thanks Crystal ❤️ appreciate all you do!

[@seaside2001]

This is a very helpful video. Thanks Crystal.👋

[@Kobisashi]

Nice comparison! I haven't tried the Mellowsun but now I 2ant to make something with 8t. THank you for testing.

[@roxannapurcell7305]

Thank you for this review Crystal. Have a wonderful day!😊🧶❤️

[@tormakhmariajulia955]

Thanks for the review Crystal

[@KellyAnneCalabrese-si6wb]

👋 Crystal! I have been paying extra for the anti-pilling. 😮 Thanks for this comparison. I will have to change my habits again...lol Definately something to think about. 🌞

[@glendahumphrey4412]

Thank you, love them both also

[@HeidiCauble-Peoples]

Thank you. Very helpful ❤

[@laurakirk3481]

Thank you so much for this! I’d like to see what happens after they’re washed and dried several times.

[@Debbie2004]

Thank you mary maxi is cheaper for me to have delivered than premiere yarns as i live in Canada. This is amazing information to know.👍🇨🇦

[@CrochetLove-lw2ey]

A thorough review. Thank you.

[@patking7853]

Interesting and knowledgeable analysis

[@MaryBethTola]

Very informative comparison. Thank you.

[@donnabierema2215]

Thanks Crystal. I think i will use mary maxim. 😊😊😊😊i do lime premeir though.

[@sharon742p]

Thanks for the review. I have only used the Premier AP worsted, so no experience with the DK.

[@ChristinesCraftTable]

Great information! Thank you! Nice thorough review.

[@seawrightstudios]

I have definitely found Premiere's "anti-pilling" yarn does pill in the washer and dryer. I just hand wash my items and lay them flat to dry or block them

[@KathyAmbrogio]

Thanks for the great info on the comparison

[@wendybell6988]

Sadly way more piling than I expected from Premier. But except for blankets i now hand wash the few garments i have made and that seems to keep them safe thank you for sharing Crystal