Primus Shocked After Drummer QUITS Abruptly

[@Boyitellyouhwhat]

I remember an interview with him in modern drummer way back when he talked about having serious struggles with depression. I hope Tim is ok. He’s the reason I started playing in 93.

[@BrottenGuy]

I’ve never done much research into Primus’s band members. Never been a HUGE fan of them. Like them. But, you get what I mean. Anyway…that’s not my point. Was just a preface. I was going to say that it SOUNDS like he battles with Depression, to me. I myself am diagnosed with Bipolar Disorder. So, I quite understand depression very well firsthand. I hope he does find some “peace”, in this. I am also a professional Graphic Designer & visual artist. I’ve been battling a bad bout of Depression, for 3 YEARS now. (Quite possibly longer.) I’ve not done ANY meaningful artwork, in that time. I know it’d HELP me really, if I would just do it. It’s just…getting up & taking a shower can be difficult most days. That ITSELF is an accomplishment. Anyway…sorry I’ve rambled a bit, & this isn’t supposed to be about me (at least not trying to make it that way). Just trying to say I can relate; & that’s why that was my first thought, as I was watching some of this. Pure speculation really. But, seeing your comment..? Yeah; pretty much confirms it, to me. So, thank you for that insight.

[@onionheadguy7094]

Yeah that's a big red flag for depression I hope he's ok.

[@fubar1217]

He's a big influence in my early playing as well and was always my favorite Primus drummer....to me, it isn't Primus if it isn't Tim. It sounds like it's a pattern with how many times he's left the band so I wonder if the touring schedule is a little too hectic and they need to have longer breaks for him to recharge. Anyway, I also hope he's ok and finds help if needed.

[@apollyon7617]

If he loses interest in playing he's depressed and or ill/in the depths of something. That shouldn't be understated. Man's getting old. Don't ignore the signs.

[@crustinagohard9049]

Agreed

[@SilverKnife0311]

Guessing he has some personal things going on... If he can't or wont then that is his desicion. I can think of a few that roll with them..

[@CynicAtheist]

Anhedonia

[@TheBadSpoon]

I doubt they're ignoring the signs. Les and others have known Tim for well over 30 years. People talk. Also, Tim's a genius. Many are prone to catching a bit of the sads due to their tendency to over-contemplate as well as chase perfectionism tooth and nail.

[@muriloninja]

100% there is far more to that than “I lost my passion for playing”.

[@Kevin-db3dm]

Being in a band is harder than most people think. I didn’t have the success Primus did but being a musician for 20+ years it’s kinda shitty. Playing the same shit night after night and living on the road sucks. I understand

[@neilpatrickhairless]

Yeah it's no different than waiting tables or cleaning toilets for that long and basically being homeless the entire time even when you have money for the touring. I did it for a year and don't miss that shit or the people at all.

[@neilpatrickhairless]

I can enjoy playing music at the house, making it a job was the worst decision ever because honestly, I quit even playing music for fun at home in private for a long time because of it. That was a year. I personally know bands who have toured non stop for almost two decades while an actual war goes on in their country.

[@P.B.andJam]

I always think about how Madonna must hate singing Like a Virgin, or even worse all those old Black Metal bands must get sick and tired of playing thier own material and genre after 20 or 30 years

[@clayfoster8234]

Plus primus isn’t a kid on the make but a legacy band in many ways just grinding out a check on a tour bus. Personally, when I was 22 it was the only thing I wanted to do. But now that I’m 50 I like to wake up in my own bed, drink the coffee brand I like, if I’m sick I don’t have to get out of my PJ’s, etc. Like, there’s a reason every band says their favorite tour was the first one…

[@alldayidreamaboutsteak551]

Neil Patrick who f cares mate.

[@dkidder1367]

no hate, drumming is physically demanding, and at a certain age, people want to chill out, stay home, smell the roses. If he wasn't happy, I support him. The truth is, some members just get tired of the songs. It's true, but may not be in this case, just a possibility. I'm glad he listened to his heart. I wish him the best.

[@sean_heisler]

Could not agree more and nobody would disagree with anything you said. Full stop. This is the third time he’s done this though and that’s part of the conversation is all.

[@robbiematthews168]

My dad was a long time drummer, he’s getting back issues and has a colostomy bag for his stomach and liver..he still has love for music even though he’s not all pyshically there..

[@slipknotpurity00]

Well he basically ghosted them other than 2 brief emails, I mean it could have been handled better. Tim is a beast though, Frizzle Fry one of the best records ever.

[@BP-ct2rn]

Amen

[@rachel.darling]

I was thinking the same thing. He’s sick of playing the same songs.

[@JasonSmith-we5ls]

I feel Herb here, went through something real similar last year. Played most of my life and one day driving home from practice I said that’s it, and it was. The fire in the belly is a real thing. There are hundreds of stone cold killers out there that could hold it down. We’re gonna miss Herb tho

[@michaelmenkesOZSKIB]

I hope herb is okay.

[@user-vr2tx4tt6b]

I agree.

[@ProfessionalImbicile]

Me too,he is one of my favorite drummers.

[@johnhasso8908]

Herb is great.

[@KalebMorrow30]

Im willing to bet les did something to piss him off

[@SunsetStarship]

Yep. I played for years in bands and, one day, I just looked out and didn't care anymore. Understandable.

[@LB00146]

Same..it happens sometimes to some people as we get a bit older. It just doesn't make us feel the same way it used to. But I'm happy still, I just don't have the passion to play anymore.

[@American_Made]

it's just growing up and finding things that are more important. Like having a family. That is what herb is wanting to get back to. the road sucks.

[@DonnyOsmosis]

It happens to so many. Tommy Lee, Phil Collins, Buddy Rich. The road can be such a downer, too.

[@jeremydickerson1049]

He lost his passion enough said...

[@clicheguevara5282]

Same. I quit playing live a couple years ago and I don't miss it one bit. I just want to write and record. I don't need the attention of strangers and never did in the first place.

[@JPGenergy]

Thank god I saw them in 22 when they were doing the rush set

[@RobRockit]

Me too!! Great show on a beautiful night in Indy

[@GlennJimenez]

Sick what did they play

[@raoulduke3770]

@@GlennJimenezFarewell to Kings album

[@anthonyjones2153]

Saw them in LA at the Greek theater 😎 great show

[@XBret64]

I saw them on that tour too in MO, such an awesome show! I wish they'd play in Springfield again but alas. I have a video of them opening on that tour

[@JettHowler]

Best wishes herb..hope to see you back one day 🤘🤠🤘🎶🥁

[@WordDustNYC]

It's a tough life and for drummers, age is not your friend. Drummers are related to Athletes in many ways. Especially for music like Primus, the fact that he made it this far is a blessing....

[@kevincarey1453]

I agree. I'm impressed that so many are still "doing it" into their 50s and 60s. Saw Nicko w/ Iron Maiden last week. You could tell he was pacing himself.

[@C5drummer]

Thank you to Tim for being such an amazing drummer. If you've given it all you've got, we appreciate all your hard work. For me, that's good enough! The most important thing is to be well.

[@johnnykallio861]

BRAIN 🧠 💯 I Think He Would At This Point Get The PRIMUS Flowers He Deserves ✌️😎 Best Wishes Tim✌️😎🙏

[@JBmusicart]

They want someone different.

[@foodog777]

Brain would be the logical choice. These open call auditions rarely work out. We’ll see…

[@jmfs3497]

Honestly, it's normal to take breaks... not like one month, but needing a year off from all the business side of music is important. It's practices, promotion, recording, writing, and touring. It's more than a full-time job. The down time isn't really a day off. It's still thinking and planning all the other stuff. A 2-week staycation doesn't cut it. You need an entire year if you've been doing everything else non-stop for a couple years.

[@DonnyOsmosis]

I love his playing. I used to dream of cutting a record with him one day. Wish him the best in his next chapter!

[@aschule5684]

Tim is a most impressive drummer this is very sad.

[@SkyNetGeneral-]

He is my #1

[@oldskool7796]

That’s herb the ginseng drummer.

[@stevezilla68]

THREE FOUR!

[@mikenoface]

@@Evi1penguin5 boomb booooom.....

[@CreativeWarrior-]

@@stevezilla68 Best part of Jellikit!!

[@SkyNetGeneral-]

@@stevezilla68epic

[@SimonB.]

Understandable. Being a musician for a living isn't the same thing as making music in a band with friends just for fun. It's work. And on top of that you live on the road. I couldn't imagine doing that. You probably start to hate what you once loved. Like anything you do over excessivly

[@JonnySublime]

Primus is a drummer’s wet dream. I guess you never just know what people are going through. Bring on Danny Carey!!!!!

[@GlennJimenez]

Oof what a great choice But he’s not nuts. They need someone with chops but he has to be nuts.

[@sebg2086]

no please not him

[@drumsofviolence]

No not Danny. Hes amazing but its not his Forte.

[@careful...Icarus]

Lombardo

[@JonnySublime]

@ I feel like anything is his forte

[@Ruleof2Review]

Watch he dropped out to join As I Lay Dying.

[@Boyitellyouhwhat]

💀

[@djpetenice]

Then they can change the band name to As I Lay Crying

[@MateuszJagocha]

Hahaha gold xD

[@vorpalblades]

As Herbs Lay Drying

[@KoRnBaL19]

Tim Alexander is my all-time favorite drummer. I've been a fan of Primus since I stole Pork Soda on tape. Tim has had heart issues in the past. I hope he needs rest or is retiring from stage. I do not want to read dtr that he ended it all. Tim's contributions have uplifted me for 30 years. My most sincere BEST for him. You're music has been medicine brother! If you need some...please seek it out. Deepest respect and concern, to my favorite drummer.👊🫶

[@sisto5266]

Plot twist: slipnkont announces Eloy has been “let go” and announces a new surprise drummer to be announced soon…

[@Demention94]

Lol

[@CaptSpaulding239]

He’s touring with Suicidal Tendencies right now but he will be on the Slipknot bus soon 😂

[@Aardquark777]

Eloy is new drummer for Primus

[@dubsmith7]

I got my money on Bryan Mantia.

[@adrianskinner5676]

Danny great fit but I would love one last tool albumn

[@bbailey2480]

He did not want to hear Maynard tell any more boring stories😂

[@TopHatTapes]

maynard ruined primus

[@aquabot]

@bbailey2480 🤣🤣🤣

[@Danny-wv8ec]

MPGA Maynard sucks, what a tool.

[@vicaldama9314]

Tool sucks and not like Primus sucks but really sucks

[@hotlanta35]

Primus without Tim sucks

[@SuperStrik9]

Wish Herb the best. I'd like to see Primus get Brain back. Love Brown Album and his playing on it.

[@nicholasmichael68]

Brown album was Brian Mantia.

[@Michael-u5q]

​@nicholasmichael68 Brian mantia is "brain" 🧠 great drummer great energy. Buckethead should join too😅

[@nicholasmichael68]

@Michael-u5q Great drummer! Not quite as fluid as Tim though...

[@Oborowatabinostk]

Brown Album is so underrated

[@philbis2774]

At his age i love that he listened to his heart

[@TheGarageBandSyndicate]

I'm so glad to have seen them and met them this summer.

[@joshsteffen]

I love Primus and play drums

[@adams115]

Youre hired

[@aggcavan943]

Weird because, I play drums and I love Primus!! Looks like your chocolate is in my peanut butter.

[@CarlWalkerDrums]

Me too! Plus I really do suck! 🥁

[@TheAqualegend]

Do your Lars impressions while auditioning, you'll get the job instantly.

[@coda1587]

Do it Josh no balls

[@mranonymous1966]

My heart goes out to Herb and the band. My guess is there might also be an underlying injury/pain issue which can weave into depression especially as an older dude on drums. It's depressing to feel your body decline. I'm speaking from experience because I just had to "abruptly" leave my drumming position with a band called The English Beat in the UK(The Beat feat. Ranking Jr) because after 5 months of physical decline and pushing through shows, I woke up with a completely numb arm, back and stomach pain on level 9, and shitting blood.....I'm healing up and rehabing and recovering but the touring days are behind me for sure. I wish Herb well and the band success in their new chapter!!!

[@Arturo-p1g4y]

Herb, may you live a long and satisfying life. With love from Louisville, KY. God bless you, brother.

[@somepeoplesay2157]

Danny is such a beast! King Crimson, Tool now Primus. Herb is awesome too, hopefully he is ok

[@keithmcduffie7182]

Much RESPECT and APPRECIATION to Tim Alexander for his years as drummer with Primus!!! I saw them Live for the first time performing with FISHBONE in Los Angeles during the early 90's and was TOTALLY blown away!!! If he doesn't feel the passion anymore than he's not going to cheat the band or the fans with a halfhearted effort. I noodle with a drum set for "Cardio" work out but I couldn't image the physicality of having to play that Primus Catalog over the years. THANK YOU, TIM ALEXANDER!!! 🥁👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

[@okboomer1340]

I'm a 60 year old drummer. Never tasted big time fame, but played for a lot of bands for a lot of years in my youth into middle age. My fingers now have arthritis, my shoulder hurts, and I just don't have the same passion to play the way I used to. It takes a lot of energy to play the drums for years. I can relate to Herb. However, It is infinitely more fun than my plan B realtor day job. hahaha...Grumpy realtor out.

[@jas_bataille]

Guys, drumming is more than just "physically demanding". Professional touring drummers are athletes, full stop. Just in rehearsal I can go over 2 hours straight playing, take a 10 min break and back for an hour, another break and the whole set again... I burn much more calories than I would on a non training day. A study estimated that a pro drummer burn up to 1500 calories on those 3 or 4 hours arena rock shows which this kind of band have been stuck playing for decades. That's as much as pro football (soccer) playe on an average game!!! All my teachers had major injuries either tennis elbow, carpal tunnel syndrome, etc Drumming at this level is music as well as a professional sport. That's just the truth. The drummers I know who successfully tour and change location for TV shows every year or so are gym MANIACS. Not gymbros, gym RATS. People who will take a run in the forest on New Year's eve at midnight. Seriously. I'm not even close to this level and yet the physicality is insane. We almost lost Dennis Chambers from Funkadelic a few years ago, and he's not playing heavy music per see. Look at Kenny Aronoff who's arguably the busiest drummer in the world! Dude is FIT fit!!!

[@zachscott4867]

Danny is such a great person and what a gracious offer, stand up human and people should pay attention to that example.

[@drummer78]

It’s not easy being a drummer as the band lives or dies on your playing every show night. Granted Tim is one of the best but if he is going through a tough time with mental or physical health, it can show in drumming. Some drummers are just built to play regardless of how they feel but others have their playing and “sense of mission” severely impacted when they don’t feel right. I think Tim might be one of those types who can only play well when he feels well about the world..about his well being. I completely get it.

[@mayadog2497]

Quitting and responding by email only sounds worrisome. I hope finds his peace in a happy healthy way. I know several musicians, that after a life time of playing, just woke up one day and were done and moved on.

[@UnderScoredd]

Hope Herb remains well 🙏

[@redhotchilifan98]

Unfortunately I’m not suprised. Minus his health issues the last few years lately he just looked miserable while playing. So I believe him when he says he lost his passion he just didn’t look happy while playing.

[@NateB1976]

They need to get Dave Lombardo. I know he’s been filling in for bands in the past and is one of the best of all time.

[@stan1418]

I agree......wondering if Dave would want the gig, as Slayer/Suicidal are different styles from Primus......

[@diegomayfield4751]

thats what i said . Dave is the only drummer I respect as much as herb . Dave and Herb are the best drummers in my opinion .

[@plasticoflamingo2952]

@@stan1418 Have you heard Philm? Dave has many tricks up his sleeve, that most people aren't aware of. He really is a GREAT drummer! I think he'd work in Primus. If not, there's always Jay Weinberg.... or Max, his dad, 73 and still a beast, lol. Seriously, though.

[@stan1418]

@@plasticoflamingo2952 Oh yeah.....completely agree. He's capable of many styles for sure. Love Max's son as well

[@neilpatrickhairless]

Lombardo even has a friend in the fold when it comes to Primus.... Mike Patton

[@soundhaus6404]

Tim is an insane drummer! So powered and explosive!! He always be remembered as an incredible dynamic monster drummer!!

[@russellhoyt588]

I guess this set list and drum stick of his I got at their Buffalo show last August just became even more valuable to me (a long time Primus fan) since they're from what turned out to be his 12th from last show with the band.

[@cfjelde]

I feel like Herb has always dealt with something mentally. Not a spotlight guy, maybe? I've gotten some (in a small way) attention in life and been okay with it but I mostly don't like anyone focusing on me. I feel like he might be like that. A guy that's great at what he does but might not want "all the rest." Maybe not depression or anxiety but a struggle to want to be 'in that game.' I admire when guys like Herb step out. F-the outside world. Always do what's good for you, for whatever reason it might be.

[@clayfoster8234]

Most musicians will tell you that at times you do lose the passion for it. Add on top of that, Herb is nearly 60yrs old, and he’s already seen the world. I think most of us can understand that there comes a point where the thought of living one more day out of a suitcase in Tulsa Oklahoma or Orlando florida makes you want to buy a rickety stool and 6’ of rope. Living on the road is great when you’re a 22 yr old kid. But at 60 it’s just a grind….

[@sean_heisler]

Seems to be Tim’s MO now. Always wondered if he battles mental health issues. Well, Danny is the best technical fit, but there’s Jay and Brain as well.

[@crustinagohard9049]

Agreed. Certainly seems like there's mental health issues.

[@Thurgor_Supreme]

Unless something tragic happens to a Tool member, Danny will never be anything more than a fill-in. Also you're forgetting Paulo Baldi

[@JazzDrummer1946]

I played in a nyc area bar band for 37 years. Only did 60-70 shows a year (including wedding's, birthday's, etc) but it was taxing. Fun. Very taxing. Our longest travels were to NJ and LI. I could see how touring for decades could wear you down.

[@natjonestower3035]

I saw them a couple months ago and actually noticed that Herb was checked out. His drumming seemed a little blander than usual, and when they were done he just got up, put his sticks down, and walked away with I could best describe as a look of apathy on his face, maybe a hint of disgust. I love the guy, but if it starts becoming a job you don't want anymore, best to walk away.

[@travismaxwell9805]

There is more to life than touring and playing and that is all your life is at that point. I quit something similar years ago. Money is nothing when your life is empty and you have no off time to fill it. Combine that with the fact that the band “was shocked”. I am sure the signs were there, but so much energy is needed for the next show that people don’t have time to notice. To me though, losing the original drummer is a band killer. I can’t stand to hear someone try to play someone else.

[@marsstubblefield]

He's not the original drummer

[@Stevedrums741]

Sometimes people have had enough for whatever reason. I hope his health both physical and mental health is solid. But otherwise, drumming is as physical an endeavor as being an athlete. I wish him well.

[@BneiAnusim]

Some musicians DO NOT LIKE TOURING! 😉

[@friedrudibega6384]

It’s not fun anymore.

[@cambranson]

I gather that's why Bill Bruford didn't want to do the BEAT tour. Totally sick of touring

[@Nirvanablue89]

It’s sad, but Jay Lane needs to come back.

[@robertjamesonmusic]

Or Brain

[@XMattingly]

Primus should just wish Herb the best (they did), and make sure whoever they recruit will be able to hammer all of their music and get out there every night with a smile on their face. 😎 I hope Herb’s OK; really appreciate his decades of awesome musicianship. ✌️

[@rockerbob949]

I’d LOVE to play with Primus. I think most drummers would jump at the opportunity

[@robbiematthews168]

I’m a drummer and I’d die to audition for them..!

[@HighlanderNorth1]

✔️ Me too..... Unfortunately, those guys told me I was "too good a drummer" for Primus. Dammit, that's the same thing that happened in the 70s when I auditioned to replace Rush's original drummer! Even the guys in Dream Theater said I was "too good" when I auditioned to replace Mike Portnoy. Sometimes it really sucks to be "too good a drummer". Nobody wants to hire you! 🥁

[@chriskitchen4772]

@@HighlanderNorth1 I know exactly what you mean, I was told the same thing. Gotta get a new garbadge can lid, the old ones trashed.😊

[@stebsg3566]

Not surprised but dang, he was my favorite primus drummer.

[@bfranco1519]

Herb, I support your decision! Do what’s best for you. You don’t owe anyone anything…

[@russellhoyt588]

It sucks that he left, but if it's truly what he felt he had to do, all the more power to him.

[@bojo6607]

I got to meet Tim at some hotel in Orlando FL in the 90s , oddly enough in a hot tub in the middle of the afternoon . We were there for some family affair, there were tour buses out front and. I asked him if he was with the band and he told me he was the drummer of a band called primus they were on tour with Fishbone. As a drummer myself, I realized exactly who he was started talking drums with him . He was the nicest guy ever and an invited me back to Sound check to see his kit. I denied because I was going to a bat mitzvah 😢 for some girl I was dating. Either way I'm married for 28 years to that girl and he has quit the band three times. Who knows what the future holds? that's my story about Tim (Herb) Alexander.

[@PressuredSpeechBand]

Hope his mental health is doing well. Remember Tim music helps us feel the emotions we need!

[@PANIC_aka_PinD]

I am a Jay Lane fan but no matter what I wish Primus success.

[@SenorSerpico]

Damn… missed the chance to see Herb. Well, Primus ain’t what it used to be. Not sure what the Chocolate Factory crap was or their mediocre last album. Be honest, Herb and Ler don’t get the recognition that Les does. Probably got tired of playing the same stuff. Love Primus and grew up on it but Herb creates and it hasn’t been the same. Thanks Herb for some of the best drumming of the past and present centuries!

[@colinburroughs9871]

the Choclate Factory gig was... weird, in the way Primus would. Don't need to listen to the record, but the show was something else

[@remember_Pat_Tillman]

Met him once in KCMO. He was very stand offish. Never cracked a smile once on our 10 minute conversation.

[@jordanbrown6501]

Danny saving the day. Exactly why so many look up to him.

[@MkVIIIMaus]

As drummer that has toured it can be difficult, especially if you have a hard time mentally being on stage in front of hundreds if not thousands of people. After my second tour with the band I was in I decided that I could only be comfortable in the studio. That decision formally ended my career.

[@stevepeterson5943]

I drummed for thirty years, it's thrilling and rewarding yes, but exhausting too. At the time i quit, I'd been "done" for two years. It's so much vibration and the frequencies take their toll, look at poor Neil Peart : ( RI P. I play bass now at home, for fun but just the thought of hitting a metal cymbal near my head gives me PTSD. I wear earplugs constantly now, while driving, when i put away clanging dishes (hurts!) even all night while I sleep. I miss it, but had a blast : )

[@Studio42dotCom-Real]

I haven't really followed Primus for years, partially because I simply lost the passion to do audio engineering in 2016, so I get it. I now do a little here and there as part of my day job, just enough to resolve any cravings. I hope they can find a new permanent member. That will NOT be an easy task.

[@brosch91]

There's a reason Bob Seger wrote the song; "Turn the page" now I personally have never toured in a band, but I do know that our dreams and motivations change as we get older. When you turn what you used to consider a fun hobby into a career, given enough years, most people will fall out of passion for that old hobby. There are always the exceptions out there who will try to tour until they physically can't do it anymore like Ozzy Osbourne, but certainly not everybody can. I wish Herb the best!

[@raddastronaut]

We wish you well herb. Jay Lane…PLEASE!!!! I love Danny playing with Primus tho. Who wouldn’t? He’s the king.

[@heartdisciple]

Herb was so good. i'll never forget his early snare sound

[@birdsoffir]

Maybe Les has become intolerable. I love Primus music but I’ll never see them live again because Les is toxic to me. I wouldn’t want to play in that environment either.

[@scottjohnston3098]

D.C. filling in is pretty sweet, get well soon Herb

[@dippitydoinit]

Tim is awesome and I hope he's doing well.

[@pfkmsandiego]

thanks! ✌&❤

[@johndoh2121]

Their latest record is awesome, I played it particularly loud. I will repeat that again soon.

[@thedude007]

Really Sad Tim are one of the greatest for me i remember meeting him in Montréal great guy who seem love to play and make the sound evolution but they can bring back Brian "Brain" who are awesome too so long life to primus ✌🏾

[@andrewsm00]

Primus and Danny though? Damn!

[@michaelbahr7957]

Mike Mangini is available and ranks somewhere around top 3 drummers alive

[@helicopterthreesixteen6573]

This would be beyond amazing! Best wishes to Tim!

[@CharlesPlassard]

Happy you can read!

[@JasonMcclintick]

will always be my favorite primus drummer

[@ShawnxEdge]

Drummers are grossly underpaid and undervalued and it’s also the most physically taxing position in a band. It’s easy to lose interest.

[@HerbieBancock]

How many times can you realistically sit there and listen to a Primus song? Two or three, tops.

[@greenmonkeys8mybrain515]

Bummer, I’m one sad Primustoneian ,Hope all is well

[@d3rksgreasyreview]

Tim is the reason I'm a drummer. If he don't want to do it....cant hold it against him. But he's a total legend!!!! I love Primus! Primus SUCKS!!!!

[@TheBazingaBoat]

As a drummer who has played for the Primus cover band "Primussy", I was disappointed in Herb's playing at Sessanta this past year and I could tell something was amiss. He does make some badass new age ambient music though. I hope he gets back into that.

[@doctoribanez]

They should have a contest on KZbin to find the world's greatest drummer. It would be big . It definitely won't find the greatest, but it sure would give a chance to a lot of guys to be seen .

[@MatChew75]

He started playing at 24 years old he's 60 now he had open heart surgery I understand where he's coming from he's just in a place where he doesn't want to play anymore he wants to find a new path in life and his family his mental health his physical health is more important to him than playing in the band. It may have not been the best way to give the news to the band but that's his way of doing things he's very introverted and standoffish person a lot like Neil Peart. He left a heartfelt letter and you know if that's how he wants to do it I understand it. I mean he's been more to me as a drummer than any drummer the past 30 years he has had more influence on my drumming than any drummer the past 30 years honestly in my mind I don't think there's been a better drummer the past 30 years than him and there's nobody that's closer to Neil peart's drumming than he is after seeing him when Primus did the tribute to rush and Neil Peart for farewell to Kings. I saw him during Charlie and the Chocolate Factory and thm during the desaturating seven I also saw him in 1991 during Frizzle fry I saw him in 1992 for sailing the Seas of cheese and in 93 or 94 for pork soda so I've seen these guys a lot through my life and every time it's been an exceptional experience and I take every show to heart and I'm saddened to hear the news but I'm happy that he's in the place he wants to be and I know this has happened to him before but you know touring can touch people in different ways and you know I think his body in his health is more important to him and of course it's Wife and Kids then the band is. and his body is starting to give and all human bodies react differently to the Grind of human life especially when you're a drummer and you know he wants to take a step back and I wouldn't be surprised if he comes back with another band later on and I know it probably hurts Larry and les that he couldn't come to them and tell them this but it probably in his mind he probably didn't want to express all this in front of the other guys this is kind of the way he does things. sometime in the future he probably will come to them and spill his heart to Larry and les in person and tell them how he really feels about the situation and his drumming has never suffered I thought after he had a renewed beginning after his last heart attack he had and he had the open heart surgery that you know his drumming has never been better and he had a renewed sense of playing that I've never seen in him before especially in the last show I saw them during the saturating 7 tour and for The Rush tribute he was absolutely mind-blowing and if that's the last time I got to see these Tim Alexander with Primus then so be it. It couldn't have been a better experience watching him grow as a drummer and my own self grow as a drummer. I couldn't have seen them at a better time in their career and for such a poignant moment in their lives to pay tribute in respect to Neil Peart and rush and and another thing too I got to see a drum off that Danny Carey and Tim Alexander did it was actually a concert to pay respects to a friend of theirs that had cancer it was a benefit concert and Primus was there playing a show and half the guys in tool were there and Danny and Tim did a drum off and it was amazing I mean I don't think either one of them is better than the other but I would give the edge to Tim Alexander and he's everybit as talented as any drummer out there and I love his drumming I love him as a person and my greatest memory of them is when they opened up for Rush in 1992 at UNO Lakefront Arena in New Orleans during the sailing the season of cheese tour and for Rush roll the bones tour that was the absolute highlight of my life and I'm glad I've got to experience him and he is still like I said more influential to me as a drummer and as a human being than any drummer has been the last 30 years of my life and I've been truly blessed to experience him live so many times through his career and herb Alexander the ginseng drummer you will be missed love you brother and take care of yourself take care of your family and enjoy life brother and Primus will move on and find somebody else like Jay Lane. But he will be missed I spent the better part of 30 to 35 years looking up to him as a human being and as a drummer and it sad me to see him go but you have to respect his wishes and what he wants in life. And Danny carries got too much going on right now as a drummer and honestly I don't think he'll be drumming too much longer he's in his sixties as well but like I said he has a lot going on and if he does play with Primus it will be for a short time if he even does that all. You can't replace greatness like that all you can do is keep going Primus will find somebody but they will never find a drummer quite like Tim herb Alexander the ginseng drummer.

[@jaywinger79]

I always got the sense that, after his first stint with Primus and leaving in 1995, that his periodic involvement afterwards was more about financial involvement and security rather than about a joy of drumming. I have no direct evidence of this, but even his playing during the second and third stints never seemed to contain the same energy as during the original incarnation. It was subtle perhaps, but I think that I could detect that lack of satisfaction in his overall playing and vibe. He probably just got to the point where he felt that he had enough security and didn't want to spend the rest of his active days doing touring and such.

[@TheNecessaryEvil]

Probably finally realized how tarded it was to release an album acting like you knew everything about the Rona. 😂☕️

[@shadowstalker1515]

If Brain isn’t busy, give him the sticks. And don’t boot him when Herb wants the sticks for a minute

[@freddiemossberg7204]

Should be an easy fit right considering he was drumming for them before.

[@joncasity6099]

It's Herbs whenever he wants....Brain can fill in but it's not really his seat

[@shadowstalker1515]

@@joncasity6099 Herb burnt his seat and no longer deserves (or wants) it. Brain is the loyal one who’s respectfully stepped in and aside every time he was asked. Never turned his back on his brothers, so the seat has been his since 1996 as far as I’m concerned. Also, he’s a pretty good drummer for a pseudo Mexican 😜

[@neilpatrickhairless]

Tim Alexander doesn't owe Primus or anyone else shit, let's get that sorted out from the jump lol

[@shadowstalker1515]

@@neilpatrickhairless Exactly, and neither does Primus

[@ThedrumMachine78]

One of the best drummer that exist in the world. His creativity and groove is insane.

[@kevindudley9617]

I have been a massive Primus fan since 1991. Without Herb, it is not truly Primus in my eyes.

[@milroyfilpott8452]

It's probably hard being an incredible drummer perpetually stuck in the shadow of one of the greatest bassists of all time. Whatever the reason, I hope he takes care of himself and finds his happiness and hopefully his passion for music again

[@zedcar7326]

Get Brain behind the kit again

[@fess04]

could be burnout or feeling under appreciated. i hope not . but the backline alot of times is taken for granted. particularily in rock and roll. still in a power trio difficult to know whats goin on here. wish him the best for decades of great fantastic playing.

[@ComradeDaveH]

As much as i wouldnt mind Carey playing primus shows, it would be awesome to let an unknown take the throne. New musicians are the life blood of music.

[@BATMAN7666]

Well Danny Carey filled in For Tim on 2014 Riot Fest set. The Octopus can do magic maybe again? I have footage of it on my channel. It was Amazing

[@RockFeed]

would be so sick

[@Sebastian-hj4fu]

Green Naugahyde is so UNDERRATED. One of their best releases, but also Brown album, Antipop. Tim has only one fantastic release with Seas of Cheese.

[@alanlund8922]

Obviously, the guy has his reasons for leaving the band. Why Les and Larry are obliviously completely at a loss why Tim is leaving, I respect the fact that Les and Larry have respected his decision and are moving on without him. Personally, whatever his personal reasons for leaving, I wish Tim nothing but the best in moving forward with his life away from Primus and I am grateful for all of his contributions to Primus's success over the years.

[@Marklennon]

Glad I saw them last year

[@RottenPopReviews]

What's Jay Lane up too?

[@yellowdog2181]

He’s been playing with Dead and co and with anything Bob Weir does as well

[@wastelander138]

We were shocked in the UK when they put a tour on and within a few weeks abruptly cancelled sighting "logistic reasons." Shouldn't they have figured out those "logistic reasons" before getting folks to buy tickets?

[@American_Made]

pretty sure Heb has found that after you have kids your priorities change and things that mattered when you were single no longer mean anything.

[@barefootarts737]

When an artist isn't feeling it, there is nothing left to do.