Producer Reacts to LOONA Chuu "Heart Attack"

In this episode the Producer checks out the fun music video "Heart Attack" by LOONA member Chuu!
SEND US STUFF!
FOT MEDIA
PO BOX 552
LOS ALAMITOS
CA 90720
Help support Form of Therapy by subscribing to us on Patreon! www.patreon.com/formoftherapy
Subscribe to Form of Therapy for more future Reaction videos & let us know in the comments down below what else you'd like to see!
#이달의소녀 #LOONA #하슬 #이브 #츄 #HaSeul #Yves #Chuu #HeartAttack #MV #BlockBerry #BlockBerryCreative
Follow us & stay up to date
Facebook: formoftherapy
Twitter: formoftherapy
Instagram: formoftherapy
Follow the cast
@formoftherapy

[@lenacarey2333]

For people doubting the video's gayness: the actual description of Chuu's video explicitly says that she is in love with Yves. No heterosexuality detected!

[@luthientinuviel101]

EXACTLY LIKEEEE

[@yooian]

The description also says it is portrayed as a more cute and less serious romance, and later interviews with Chuu says it’s more like an idolizing of someone. I don’t think she’s gay but damn that video tho

[@thedarkestpath7464]

@@yooian they're not talking about Chuu herself but what the song is portraying. Of course we don't know whether Chuu is gay or not, that's her personal life, but it's been made clear that in the video at least, her feelings for Yves are romantic.

[@ammaranuar2544]

lol you people are cringy as fuck. its about friendship love, not lesbian love

[@hifzakhan9919]

Horen LastTeacher I think you should read the description for the video first like it literally says it

[@denn1se]

"it was one kiss away from being a 19 rated video" LET HEART ATTACK BREATHE

[@KittyPikaChu]

let heart attack breathe honey the irony am crying

[@Anmari97]

OMG HAHAHAHAHA

[@twicengg2139]

galaxywish ”Let heart attack breathe” HJDHDHSJ

[@emjay5753]

AHSHSHSHS LET HEART ATTACK BREATHE ADKFHLJSDJ I CANTT

[@xsomili5501]

@Décal- come at me becauz korea

[@Jonawtawn]

Long live the lesbian era.

[@taytayluvr]

why.. is there no replies

[@heonilover680]

@@taytayluvr because this simple comment left thousands of people *speechless*

[@miaa1762]

@@heonilover680 agreed

[@largemarge857]

The L in loona stands for lesbian.

[@sonicdash6513]

The L in LBGT also stands for Loona 😄

[@kev.ng.11]

Actually the L is the "N" consonant in Korean, which stands for "N... -yep, this group is full of lesbians"

[@nozomiac]

Bảo Nguyễn Kim I thought the N stood for “Not Straight”

[@bycoco03]

@@nozomiac nah fam the word str8 is banned in this household

[@lmreve]

So.. *L* esbian/ *L* BGT *O* verload *O* verpowering *N* ot straight *A* nd talented beautiful fantastic woman? Aka *LOOΠΔ* ?

[@mcbearsan16]

I laughed so hard at your reaction. "This was super gay." Man do I love the yyxy sub unit. Each song is a treasure.

[@ammarn94]

All four song is about "knowing about yourself" new: Loving yourself Heart Attack: Knowing yourself One & Only: Knowing yourself, loving yourself and embracing it Egoist: Literally loving yourself, and letting go of someone else to love yourself more. Such a powerful subunit

[@ariannainlove]

IT’S FINALLY HERE OMG! I’m so excited to see your reaction. Fun fact: Heart Attack was one of the most played songs at this year’s pride in Seoul... An LGBTQ anthem indeed.

[@LanaBellaVargas]

Arianna Sope i love stanning the gays' girl group

[@aorieedx2096]

Arianna Sope omg

[@kylepop4371]

As a gay man, it makes me SO HAPPY to hear that! Loona are representing us!

[@_linlin_]

Arianna Sope Idk if you know, but in Mexico ( I think) there were hundreds of posters that had "STAN LOONA" all over them. ❤

[@user-im9km4ou9y]

Ciellistium was in Chile 💕

[@orbitprincess]

In my opinion the strongest LOONA solo, Chuu has one of the best voices in LOONA (along with Haseul). Very underrated.

[@biazacha]

And she still young tho (18 if I'm not mistaken), is really impressive!

[@tristecherie7464]

she hasnt even debuted yet to be even rated :p

[@Otaku-gf7iq]

Duchess Gummybuns She’s the main vocal of yyxy so she has very good vocals

[@am4775]

Triste Cherie she has a solo song so we can judge her vocals from there

[@hojokarens]

even though she hasn't debuted, she has a LOT of predebut material because she did a lot of covers and she even sang the opening for a kids show

[@toadthemushroom8134]

This video is the definition of confident gay vs panicked gay

[@christinavilla6343]

This was the song that got me into Loona. It's still my favorite, and Chuu is definitely my bias. The song, the video, her voice, it all just tugs on my heart so much.

[@ze5858]

Christina Villa Same! It randomly played on spotify and honestly, it was the best thing that happened to me.

[@justthetruth3950]

How is this coment from a week ago if the video was posted an hour ago, I'm so confused

[@ze5858]

Banana Milkshake Maybe because this was a stream? Idk either 😂

[@Otaku-gf7iq]

Christina Villa YAS!!! I have no chance with her cause she gay tho(maybe).T-T I WILL SUPPORT MY GAYBY MATTER WHAT!

[@Haiii_itsnanda]

ME TOOO!!!!!!! everything you said represents me XD

[@chwonkim3774]

YOU ARE ENTERING THE GAY ERA OF THE LOONAVERSE PD. DID YOU KNOW THAT A LOT OF BANNERS WERE PUT UP SAYING "STAN LOONA" DURING THE PRIDE WALK IN CHILE?

[@mmahoho]

I LOVE MY COUNTRY KSKDKF

[@garu_0402]

i love this fandom

[@valerie8679]

This is my top favorite LOONA song, hands down, some people may say it's basic but I don't care honestly the vocal work on this one along with the Broadway-esque instrumentals and just the whole theatrical feeling the song gives off make it a masterpiece in my eyes. It's also the song that got me into LOONA, so it holds a special place in my heart.

[@joiceraiana]

valerie It's basic on purpose . This song is clearly made to show off Chuu's powerful vocal

[@pokerface4848]

Why did I cry at your comment this is so perfect I can't stop

[@valerie8679]

Poker Face LMAOSJSI your comment becomes even cuter with that username/profile picture.

[@pokerface4848]

valerie Awww thank youu

[@clementinemesich638]

It was my first song by them and the only kpop song I found on my own (my friend gives me a bunch to listen to) and it will always be my favorite

[@aziraphaleluvr]

"IT WAS SUPER GAY" Me. Exactly what I said. And I love it 😂💓

[@lilanet7453]

Chuu aside (Cuz we all agree she's so precious and talented and cute) This video is one of my favorites cuz it has so so many art references and stories references. it's so well done and i love how we can see the actual research BBC did for this video.

[@toadwi]

for a girl so smol she can bELT HER LUNGS OUT she's highkey my fave loona vocalist

[@xsomili5501]

Shes really powerful. Black belt

[@TomsMusicCorner]

Chuu invented strong vocals. Ok seriously, she has a surprisingly strong voice, for me the most powerful girl in Loona, not only based on vocals. If you watch loonaTV than you know what I mean. The first video with her was like „Oh another shy girl“ but then someone rewired this girl, switched on the power button and now she is THE power girl. Her personality is so bright. It’s unbelievable how she turned the game again. The first change in Loona was Kim Lip, Yves was a new era (ofc, she is supposed to be in the third subunit) but Chuu is special. Heart Attack is so powerful, her voice is powerful, also the meaning of the song is powerful and ofc there is more to recognize than gayness. Almost everything is symbolized and not easy to understand. I think we all need a whole encyclopaedia to understand everything... but maybe it’s not the goal to solve the puzzle, maybe puzzling itself is the goal.

[@theguy1318]

I'm honestly thinking about getting into loona because of her. I'll have to see what the ot12 debut sounds like and go from there.

[@TomsMusicCorner]

Even if OT12 doesn't convince you (who knows?) they have tons of good music. Even one of the Big3 with a two years old group with billion of fans can't reach them. There are so many genres, even the fandom is fighting against each other what concept is better (lol).

[@theguy1318]

See, i'm a Red Velvet stan so that's what is interesting about Loona, because they have that diversity in genres like Red Velvet. But the thing with loona is i haven't had the time to check out any of their music execpt for Odd Eye Circle and some of the newer stuff. (I think i like the Odd Eye Circle stuff because i come from EDM) I've really like the yyxe EP that came out as well. I'm just saying that i'll have to see what the group as a whole does before i stan, i'll still listen too their music it's just i won't probably stan if i don't like the way OT12 is gonna go. Because i don't think i could stan a group if i only like some of the sub-groups/songs.

[@TomsMusicCorner]

You are here. Watch PD's reaction to all their music. I'm sure PD will not delete the videos soon. You have all the time you need ;)

[@theguy1318]

I probably will, but once i get off work lol, i'm on break rn. (LUNCH)

[@Rawrmuffin0]

1:58 omg its so cute this video is heavily inspired by the tale/book 'the little match girl' which is about a poor girl during christmas time trying to sell matches during christmas eve. she starts to use them bc she's so cold and also starts looking into shops/home windows at family dinners, dreaming of wealth/warmth/happiness and at the end her dead grandma takes her into the sky and shes found frozen to death?????? haseaul is supposed to represent the grandma waking chuu up after she died dreaming of a life with yves through the windows. she then walks away towards more independence (shown with her leading go won during hi high tbh T.T)

[@SYEJ92]

i'm surprised he didnt recognize Haseul at the end, haha

[@astra4796]

I'm surprised I didn't notice Haseul there

[@user-wd1mp8zz3o]

Wait what? When??

[@Valerybr02]

。。。 at the end.. when Chuu was on the floor and Haseul woke her up

[@threedott7162]

Okay so what i noticed was haseul at the end and she was wearing the same outfit from a previous mv (forgot the name) but its with heejin and hyunjin and it was a Christmas themed song. also shot in London anyways she wakes chuu up with the outfit and present bags. In the bg, Carol 2.0 can be heard echoing woopwoop

[@barelyjelly9558]

Three Dott the video with 2jin is probably Carol

[@caskerbox]

UWU

[@minaminari5834]

CHUUWU

[@yerination8531]

chuuwuraiah carey

[@Noctis198]

Almost forgot how good the song and video were.

[@gegenothadid]

YESSS FINALLY OUR GAY ANTHEM

[@shannondaniel5544]

‘it was SUPER GAY’ that’s how i like my gay

[@IsabellaKayful]

YES MY BIAS BBY

[@seafarer_]

i saw chuu’s teaser photos and heard her name and thought she’d be just a visual but BOY WAS I WRONG

[@Robalexe]

Chuu and "just a visual" should never be in the same sentence ever

[@squeeneytodd]

To me, this and Heejin's Vivid have the most personality to them.

[@yeekies85]

SqueeneyTodd heejin and chuu suit their songs perfectly but the other girls become different people out of the mv lmfao stan duality

[@1207wishes]

don’t forget about kiss later, y’all

[@hoangnam3710]

idk but eclipse and singing inn the rain suit mrs kim lip and mrs jinsoul too

[@solenekygo]

I was shopping and I heard this song in H&M ! I live in France so I was very surprised, but also very happy to hear it ! I low key did the choreography in the fitting room 😂

[@Withintassy]

It is really gay and I love it haha

[@mr.inazumaorihama1218]

Withintasy me @ ur profile picture

[@ej1250]

Her runs and adlibs are the best in the group

[@Robalexe]

Her vocals are undeniably the best in the group in every category besides maybe head voice cuz Haseul

[@synchrohalo]

Did you catch that Seventeen's Very Nice moment at around 1:03 ? :D Heart Attack and Very Nice are both made by the same production company and it's cool how they both have that confetti-feels-explosion scene BTW I can't wait for you to see Jeonghan's solo hehehehehe

[@blhanddrawing4870]

The way the green apple turned red when her love was accepted HSJSJSJJX

[@blhanddrawing4870]

@Sieger yeah :( i feel like thats what happened, but i prefer being dreamy ksksksksks

[@CoachAndrewV]

this solo is what got me hooked on Loona. Finding a kpop song in the more traditional "pop" style that portrays emotion is quite rare, in my opinion.

[@ggkpopcurator6292]

The gayest and cutest penguin ever.

[@lenaambersilver1372]

YES YES I WAS SOO HYPED FOR THIS AND FINALLY I WASN'T DISAPPOINTED SOMEONE APPRECIATED THE GAYNESS NOT MANY REACTORS EVEN POINTED OUT HOW GAY IT WAS THE ONLY ONE THAT COMES INTO MY MIND IS JRE AND I ABSOLUTELY LOVE HOW MUCH YOU APPRECIATE THE EMOTION THIS IS MY FAVORITE SONG BTW

[@partiallynever]

I love how PD was so speechless during the MV because MOOD

[@jameskiismissingadrevenue336]

chuu is definitely number 1 on the vocal list in loona. her vocals are amazing she has so many good elements

[@baizhuhooters8084]

The s in Loona stands for straight

[@olivias364]

are you caught up with the story loona is going for? because there's actually a looot of symbolism here. like with the book yves is reading (aphrodite means death), the apples, the colour of the apples, the penguins, haseul waking chuu up afterwards....

[@pandora789]

FINALLY I'M SO EXCITED THE GAY LEGEND IS HERE

[@a2-2b-9s]

Fun fact: BBC wrote in the description that the song is more a child-like crush than a serious romance but it doesn't change the fact that Chuu (Loonaverse and real life xD) has a big damn crush on Yves. :D

[@braincabbage]

this song and music video made me fall in love with Loona tbh, it was the first I saw and the gayness and emotion made me a fan

[@VitorSantos-fp6qw]

Chuu

[@Aquamoustaches]

I was so excited but I wish you talked about how strong her vocals

[@babykay7929]

J It wasn’t that strong.

[@BananaMilk98]

It really is. People need to stop discrediting Chuu's vocals when she clearly has excellent tone and vocal technique.

[@Aquamoustaches]

chuuchuu THANK YOU ! Just because she has that stage name and cute appearance people assume that she doesn’t have amazing vocals ugh

[@babykay7929]

chuuchuu PD do not usually comment on vocals, if you’ve noticed or if you have been following his reactions a for a long time. He’d rather comment on the composition or the instrumentals of the songs he’s reacting to. He’d comment on vocals at times if he thinks it’s outstanding but in Heart Attack he didn’t even noticed the vocals. I’m not discrediting Chuu’s talent, I just don’t find it as strong as people claim it to be.

[@BananaMilk98]

I see. Maybe have a listen to One Way by yyxy if you have time. Since it's a ballad, you can hear the vocals better without loud instrumentals. Another one is Frozen. What makes it amazing is that girlie recorded it while she had a cold.

[@josefimg1967]

3:13 , the moment he realized this was home of sexual antics

[@kylepop4371]

It’s my fave Loona MV. It has a beautiful story, the beat can feel childish but it has so much charm and like you said, Chuu sings it with such emotion.

[@luffythecat1291]

i was listening to a loona playlist on spotify and this was the song that got me actually interested in them!! and when i watched the mv after i was pleasantly surprised lol

[@valeriasalis9403]

"it was one kiss away from being a 19 rated video" one of the bestest quotes since 2018

[@KittyPikaChu]

and chuuriana grande

[@lifelaviee]

This is my favourite LOONA song, simply for the chorus. I love that they substitute the mediant chord with a Major chord. Usually the third degree of the scale is Minor, but they decided to use a more chromatic melody. So substituting a Major chord in let there be a chromatic approach to the next chord. This makes a silly playful kind of melody. Then at the end they do that descending, dramatic, fall from the relative minor, which leads right into a satisfying ending "You! Attack my Heart~". Add to that, the last iteration gets a classic whole step Disney key change! This song has a lot going on harmonically and I love it.

[@nicoles.8793]

LMAO i love his reaction at 3:12

[@jessisascorpio]

Everyone forgets New was gay too 😔 not as gay as this song but yves x vivi ship deserves better

[@valerie8679]

yves x vivi kinda came out of nowhere and i still don't really see the reason behind them? but ya new is certainly overlooked in terms of gayness.

[@jace3154]

we don’t get much yvevi content in loonatvs whereas ychuu is frequent due to promotions but :-/ anyways new remains gay as hell

[@Fran_Fuentes]

Chuuriana Grande

[@emmajohanna5551]

I know alot of kpop fans hate when other people have the same biases but with us chuu stans were all just sweet lesbians that like our other lesbians. Stan loona😂

[@maidarlindear]

4:52 Right? I thought the same thing the first that I watched it, Yves biting the strawberry and Chuu looking at her (almost like a crazy person, in the window part lol) just took by surprise haha!!

[@joiceraiana]

The shock on PD's face during the entire video was priceless 😂😂😂

[@Coco-tg2pl]

OMG I've been waiting for this my whole life

[@LeylaKaratas]

YESSSSS my all time favorite Loona song!

[@lakestk9654]

Rated 19 and up only

[@rosie-td1bf]

I’VE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS REACTION

[@natalyuhh]

AAAAHHHH YAY IVE BEEN WAITING

[@elfhchan]

Queen of clean vocals = Chuu

[@lunetothemoon]

Waiting forever for this!!

[@bungeegumlove333]

idk how it’s possible but i fall in love with this song more and more every time i hear it

[@izabela3298]

finally!! welcome back!

[@Planet_Bebe]

Oh my gawd am I going to have to stan now??!

[@MoisaJWroy]

YESSSS

[@allahbless2278]

This mv made me an automatic chuu bias and still am,her vocals are amazing

[@eye-shah]

YASSS IT’S HERE AHHHH CHUU IS MY QUEEN I LOVE HER SO MUCH

[@grimmjowjeaguerjaquez5065]

Im literally OBSESSED with this song AND this video, i watch it every single day lol

[@ITouchYou4TheLulz]

As much as I fervently stan Queen Lip as my uncontested Loona bias, Chuu definitely has the over-arching vocal technique that I have spent years WAITING for K-pop idols to have. It's so hard to find idols with a truly unique and distinguishable sound. I find that many of their vocals tend to be very simple (even appointed vocalists), albeit nice and pretty, however the restrained technique is so common that it doesn't excite me anymore. It might just be cultural differences and varying standards of taste, but it's like many of them are afraid to incorporate more complex techniques that could aid in establishing a name among SO MANY other groups, especially in the advent of G4 and even G5 K-pop. There is no implication that in the totality of so many idols that none can sing (tho there are some questionable vocals), but it's so refreshing and inspiring when I do find one. When you analyze Chuu's vocals, everything about it seems natural and unforced: her runs, the way her voice slightly cracks at the end of strong not sequences, the way she moves from range to range, her tone, her vibrato (which idols tend to stay away from for some reason?). JUST LISTEN TO SEESAW; BITCH KNOWS SHE IS GOOD. Loona in general has done such a good job at creating a foundation unlike any other group beyond the cookie-cutter visuals and synchronized dancing that is the essence of K-pop. I feel like all of Loona have the potential to sing well, with a few being more exceptional than the others (Haseul, Queen Lip, Jinsoul, and Yves). It might also just be a product of Chuu practicing and developing her voice before her official debut, and as FUCKING BITTER as I am at her for dethroning Kim from 2nd-most-watched solo debut, Chuu's voice is really an objective standout. Homegirl better werk.

[@Robalexe]

BBC being shit at vocal training doesn't help either. Chuu was a trainee for only one month before debut, she knew how to sing since before joining. She can sing in every way really well, as evidenced especially by her solo album last year. I know you made this comment six years ago, but since then vocal standards have improved lately in girl groups, with groups like Nmixx, Aespa, BabyMonster, Billlie, Kiss of Life, Purple Kiss etc.

[@anomic77]

the details of this song are amazing!

[@ainawbu]

AAAAA im so glad u liked it chuu’s my baby!!

[@loonatuna3561]

Its just a coincidence but the light band in the background shows the colors of some of the LOONA members 😏

[@cza1898]

"It was somehow gayer than Bad Boy by Red Velvet" Lmao 😂

[@romanenko4752]

YES, THANK YOU

[@meykatherine]

I was waiting for this 🤣

[@rcj.queenie7122]

Finally I've been looking at his page the entire week. This and egoist what I wanted to see.

[@NanaNoms]

Rcj. Queenie same

[@MD-so6cz]

finally it's chuwu time

[@guppy8073]

I actually got into loona recently through chuu, having seen her pictures on tumblr and developing a massive crush on her and then!!! I find out her solo song is like this and fall even more in love, wow. Hoping to see more from her in the future C:

[@aishazafirah2]

i just started listening to this a few days ago and suddenly this happened along with many other stuff considering Loona. it happened so many times with so many songs

[@katiekawaii]

Hands down my favorite video.

[@Dinomater_]

I've been waiting for this lmao

[@MIXANDMTCH]

chuwu

[@jameskiismissingadrevenue336]

jax ....fucking genius

[@takahiroyamazaki5812]

Confused PD is such a mood

[@krybaby6009]

4:51 I FUCKING DIED WHEN HE SAID THIS IT WAS SUPER GAY KFJDJDJDJDB let's be real, heart attack by chuu is our lesbian anthem

[@knifeson2136]

all bow to our wlw queens

[@analuv99]

FINALLY YESSSS💗💗💗💗

[@gemmafeltovich6130]

i think the song and video were both very well produced and it would have been a great track no matter what, but chuu's voice is so perfect for this song. she's a really great singer-- not only technique wise (which is also true, especially with her good pitch, resonance, breath, etc.) but she has the ability to imbue intense emotion into her voice that isn't easily taught. TLDR chuu's voice makes me feel things and i'm love her

[@jonginsito]

"this was super gay" *YES*

[@Mad_orange]

oh wow.. the mv is so fun and i got goosebumps on bridge.. i... i like it.

[@akanjisgf]

FUCK I LOVE THIS SONG

[@BLEHHH]

GAY INDEED! I heard Heart Attack playing during San Francisco's pride. (also a group performed Girl Front too) the L in Loona stands for lesbians!

[@tuanasakin6989]

I feel like when you first watch this without having a clue what the Loonaverse is or what the meaning behind the mv is you get really confused but when you understand it just clicks. Idk if that made sense but yea

[@niahelmee6890]

FINALLY!!! a reaction to loona chuu's solo ❤❤❤❤❤

[@girlalmighty7116]

MY BABYYYY FINALLY

[@akanjisgf]

THIS IS THE BEST SONG I HAVE EVER HEARD!!!!!!

[@yelimk2454]

omg finally ♡

[@user-rm3ci3wl3e]

I really really like that song too

[@taylor1324]

my favorite loona song!!

[@qweasdzxc2422]

SHES SO CUTE

[@k4n0np0l]

I like how in each video (more obv in yyxy's) you can see them bring in things from other girl's MVs

[@chuuayu]

Re upload ?. But anyway this is my most favorite loona song so far and I've been waiting for you to react to it. Thank you PD