Best Shop Vac (BATTERY POWERED)? Milwaukee, Dewalt, Ridgid, Makita, Ryobi, Bosch, Hart

[@ProjectFarm]

Here's the list of products reviewed. More details in the video description. Thank you! Ridgid: amzn.to/3szlR3Z Milwaukee: amzn.to/3qxjEEl Bosch: amzn.to/39KFygG Makita: amzn.to/3qt47VQ DeWalt: amzn.to/38SvWko Ryobi: amzn.to/39IfIcS

[@thigbreezy]

on Amazon at least, Rigid vac has gone up from video price to $144, buck cheaper than Milwaukee

[@gallerypikachu3192]

Everything is like double or triple the price

[@Ranveer_Singh_sangha03]

This is not a just a youtube channel For many of us your channel is Honest product review without paid reviews by corporates thugs

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks!

[@codyh9913]

@@ProjectFarm could you do a video on “mechanics tools” I would like to know if it’s worth spending $150 for one snap on ratchet vs $10 on a harbor freight? Thank you for the excellent content in your videos

[@Melicoy]

@@ProjectFarm Dont you EVER get threats from companies you test? TELL US !!!!!

[@adamsterdam9049]

@@ProjectFarm VIDEO IDEA: Best compact knife sharpener (primarily for outdoors)

[@connorpeck4962]

@@codyh9913 it isn't! I use matco and gear wrench ratchets at work, they break alllllll the time. My personal ratchets are all husky, and they ROCK.

[@NoTengoIlusiones]

This man deserves a prize from Consumers Associations for independence and quality of tests.

[@AnonymousAkira]

Consumer Reports: "Excuse me, sir, may we use some of your content please?"

[@Therealestrunnerluda]

He is biased sometimes. Also only using one product is not really a thorough review

[@jong2359]

This man transcends Consumer Associations, which have all been bought out by major corporations. An award from them would be like receiving a macaroni art project from the neighbors kid.

[@abstring]

Absolutely!

[@sekou3758]

@@Therealestrunnerluda What?

[@TheClearSight]

You are growing and growing, and i am sure some manufacturer really fear your videos when their products are tested, and since you are unbiased and super honest and completely transparent with your testing and the methods you set up, they cant do anything to stop that. The value of your channel is underrated!

[@ProjectFarm]

Thank you!

[@dragitliltoy93]

The manufacturers will do something to get ahead of competitions by updating their products like brushless because of your videos! I appreciate it very much! Please can you do the update of portable vacuum with brushless or new update version? I watched some of your videos. I enjoy and thank you for being honest and great compared to different products.

[@bendgeddes]

Fear exactly! Project Farm is like a tornado for marketing departments! Meanwhile, we win. 👍

[@Ritalie]

This is one of his best tests, because the test is designed to measure the function of the vacuums, instead of trying to break the vacuums. I really love when these reviews show the real world practical features, instead of just trying to break the tool.

[@Ozarkwild]

Great video. Recommendation.. Please compare cordless handheld vacuums, such as those used for car vacuums.

[@legendarypillow1450]

I still vividly remember the first video I’ve watched of project farm’s. It was pf testing epoxies to see which one was the best brand. From that point forward, I’ve never believed any marketing claim until it was confirmed by project farm. 100% honest, unbiased, and above industry standard testing. I thank you Todd, and the pf channel for delivering high quality reviews to help the consumer make the best choices. 👍

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks so much and being a dedicated viewer all these years!

[@Lucas_sGarage]

Me too

[@IlieJanau]

Me to 👍

[@millanferende6723]

@@ProjectFarm Yeah man you are awesome! You are a standard for product testing now! :) For the future, please try to also compared products with exact same attachments, if they come with different attachments (such as this shop-vac) 11:36. The attachments can easily be changed by us and so it will be good to know which products are better in a 1 to 1 comparison. Thank you so much!

[@mr.animation5259]

I love the way he makes videos, no-nonsense. Constant flow of info, never a boring moment

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks!

[@angryduck4561]

I love his content, it's absolutely fantastic, I've been binging it. But I'm pretty convinced he's the zodiac killer.

[@ethansprojects7399]

@@angryduck4561 why? Lol

[@angryduck4561]

@@ethansprojects7399 The way he methodically does everything, does leave a single step out. Everytime same way, he's also been quoted saying that the reciprocating saw is his favorite tool. Soooooo lmao

[@tripleo4255]

I think what you guys are really trying to say is that you love his editing style lol it IS enjoyable and caters specifically well to people with no patience or attention span

[@0blivioniox864]

Now this is how you're supposed to review products. You've earned my sub.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for watching and subscribing.

[@Squince01]

Welcome to the club, go and check out some of his other vids, he does great work! I really liked the grease gun episode do to my work requirements, I now own a Milwaukee grease gun.

[@loganbuckner6962]

He's the best there is!!

[@jgetscensored7837]

He’s a SOLID reviewer. Welcome to the channel.

[@gdhammr8113]

You absolutely WILL NOT regret that subscription! This man literally provides the best testing videos on KZbin!

[@TERRORoftheLORD]

*Suggestion* At the end of the video, flip through the competition charts all in a row, so we can compare the traits we are looking for.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for the suggestion.

[@Bigtwinman]

Or better yet a link to go download and print out the charted results would be fantastic

[@Chris.Rhodes]

A google doc would work

[@CloudslnMyCoffee]

Yes!

[@FriendsFade]

A star system would also be great

[@yenb86]

This is my absolute favorite KZbin channel. This guy doesn’t mess around. He’s smart, thorough, and to the point. Consistent with these qualities in every video. Amazing.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks!

[@jayjanyh2932]

Here are Project Farm's charts at... 05:55 = Noise 06:50 = inches of water lifted 08:01 = Air Speed (suction) 09:08 = Battery Run Time (minutes) 10:48 = large particle filter count 12:37 = Sand removal/lift time (sec) 13:57 = Sand remaining in carpet (grams) 14:56 = Water removal time Purely based on performance (not price, due to battery and charger not included with some models)...1st = Ridgid, 2nd = Milwaukee, 3rd = Dewalt, 4th = Bosch, 5th = Hart, 6th = Ryobi 7th = Makita

[@Pkripper-67]

Doing the Lords work I see.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for watching!

[@jayjanyh2932]

@@ProjectFarm Great application of Passion, in your voice on this one.

[@jtown1bb]

What if you don't factor battery and charger?

[@kellyr8230]

What's the name of the rigid model? Is it 36138?

[@onlinename8066]

me: this is the best channel on youtube. project farm: WE'RE GONNA TEST THAT!

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks and thanks for watching!

[@Grant_Woodford]

It has already been tested and proven!

[@mohamhead9701]

New Motto: "Been there, tested that"

[@Aldo-zp8wk]

@@ProjectFarm ..no thank you sir!

[@eggs712]

I'd love to see a test of flex, hardness, and tip strength of pry bars.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for the video idea.

[@doalex2085]

Don’t forget to add a ironworker sleever bar in the contest!!! Money 💰

[@eggs712]

@@doalex2085 Agreed, I like my Mayhew sleever bar and Martin spud wrench, but I'm curious to see them compared to other USA made versions

[@steverone7623]

@@eggs712 I bought a “hyper tough” 2’ prybar, and son of a gun that sucker works great for its size, I was shocked. I spent $8 on it...

[@wilsonwichman4847]

Great idea

[@Aaron-514]

When ever I start considering tools and garage equipment, I refer to the Project Farm reviews. Very respectable and honest testing. Lots of other aircraft mechanics I know trust these reviews.

[@codylee1682]

You literally compressed an hour long video, into 15 minutes. That's phenomenal. Thank you for the amazing videos. Keep up the great work

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks, will do!

[@Mumblix]

"I have absolutely no interest in buying a cordless shop vac." (Proceeds to spend 15 minutes and 24 seconds in rapt attention.)

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for watching!

[@shonhaines1995]

I agree. I have virtually every Ryobi 18V cordless tool (green, I had Craftsman 19.2 when Ryobi was still blue) made and added some repeats as they move to brushless. Plus, I have started to get some 40V yard tools to supplement my gas powered tools. My point isn't about all of my tools, just that I am, in a way, stuck with a certain line that I have come to really like and appreciate. However, that doesn't stop me from being completely enthralled with these tests. I guess I am rooting for Ryobi but it is just generally cool to see the level of effort put into the test... the prep work, attention to detail and total scope is always top notch.

[@thisbetterman]

if you are on one of these platforms, i highly recommend it. It is so easy to use one of these vs pulling out the 12/16G behemoth for small jobs. QOL score for this tool is very high.

[@danielbelmont5323]

Ever since I've bought my milwaulkee shop vac my big ridged vac doesn't really leave my garage unless I have a big demo to do. Nothing fun about bringing a big lunky SV up to a third floor bumping into doorways ect just to clean up after a few window installs.

[@Nevir202]

Same, TBH

[@o0Avalon0o]

I didn't know these even existed, but I can trust this channel to have an incredible eye for detail.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thank you very much!

[@kameljoe21]

Ridgid also has a 9 gallon cordless shop vac as well.

[@Tammybabyoda]

I love how fast you moved through the comparisons! Straight and to the point!

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks!

[@15farcry]

The way you tested the vacs by cleaning sand off the carpets for 1 minute and weighing the remaining amount of sand you were able to extract was total genius! Keep up the quality content!

[@ProjectFarm]

Thank you!

[@jdelapaz14]

Hopefully it was a new piece of carpet for every vacuum. Should weigh the sand in the vacuums, after vacuuming with no filter

[@ianpoague2886]

Now this is an accurate and fair test. I see you took in to consideration about using the same ah battery’s in each tool.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thank you very much!

[@_welcometoreality_5272]

No duh this is project farm bro haha

[@jonschumacher9225]

@@ProjectFarm I agree about batteries only -for fairness. However, it would have been interesting to know if the Dewalt performed better when plugged in. I bought one for a friend 2 Xmas ago... To my dismay I guess :(

[@mlindholm]

@@jonschumacher9225 I have one. No, it really doesn't...its simply has consistent performance, as the voltage never drops. It's nice as a backup, or if you don't NEED it to be cordless during a particular use.

[@machscga6238]

He should actually do two test for run time... He should do a runtime with the battery it was sold with... And a second run time test with a common AH battery so all the vacs could be tested with a 2ah or a 4ah... That would be the most fair test.

[@MrJoeE1970]

The run time under load is almost a perfect reversal of the inches of lift test. Makes sense the ones that create the higher vacuum would also run out of battery first.

[@wedding_photography]

The proper test would be how much stuff can a vacuum suck in on one battery charge.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for sharing.

[@cup_and_cone]

@@wedding_photography This is a good point, because if you're cleaning a car, half the time the vacuum is running you're not actually sucking anything, you're just repositioning the tool and moving around.

[@publicmail2]

Blocking air is not under full load vs moving full amount of air.

[@framergod69]

i have a raft of battery's so run time is unimportant i can put in a fresh one i can't make the vac work better

[@eulachonfish]

Was looking for one of these vacs and already leaning towards Ridgid, your video makes it a no brainer!

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks! Glad to hear!

[@djosbun]

This has to be one of your top 10 best videos. You had me at full attention from beginning to end. Your test processes were superb!

[@ProjectFarm]

Thank you!

[@Airplane_Willy]

@@ProjectFarm I would make one suggestion though on vacuum tests. Weigh the sand before putting it in the carpet. Then weigh what is inside the vacuum. The difference is what they couldn’t pick up. Only suggesting this because you can’t reliably get all sand out of the carpet for comparison.

[@WickedTimeFox]

@@Airplane_Willy or weigh the carpet before and after! I think his test was reasonable enough though as his results followed the same patterns as in other tests.

[@isaiahboyd6068]

A video on home vacuum cleaners would be so helpful, measured like these are. Brands could be Shark, Bissel, Dyson, etc. They all claim to be the best. You could also compare corded and cordless.

[@LazorVideosDestruction]

I agree, we are needing a new vacuum cleaner as our current one is quite old and overheating. Knowing which one has the best value would be very helpful

[@danilo352]

Ditto.

[@jonahdodd567]

Vacuum Wars youtube channel has extensive reviews done on nearly every type of vacuum just FYI.

[@diesistkeinname795]

I just use my cordless shop vac at home as well.

[@bonivuselderheart2716]

@@diesistkeinname795 I've used mine in a pinch when the normal vacuum has failed, but they are not good for cleaning large amounts of carpet due to the lack of a beater brush.

[@Andrew_Head]

If you don't mind a suggestion, when displaying graphs, if you could say "lower is better" or "higher is better" it would definitely give people a quick way to understand the graph at a glance. Just my two cents. Love your videos!

[@yankeered5625]

Agreed some of the graphs gets confusing

[@DoubleTripleOGfromtheset]

Watch the whole video so he gets more money, and don't scroll through for the answers. He is very specific if you watch AND listen

[@narancs5]

The best is the first coloumn in the graph.

[@lickmikehunt]

this comment proves how stupid ppl are lol

[@CybekCusal]

😂 I don't have any trouble understanding

[@wicked.orlando]

Man love this testing, very extensive and helped me choose which one I want to buy, going with the Ryobi seems to be mid level, and since I have Ryobi gear makes the most sense, however I would have thought the Milwaukee and Dewalt would have come out on top overall. I have never seen anyone put through this much effort to do comprehensive testing like this, very much appreciate your time and effort.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks!

[@goldensands7113]

I have a video suggestion: expanding foam insulation. I see this stuff used more and more for just about everything. Would be great to know how each brand stacks up against various conditions - cold, hot, moisture, dryness, etc.

[@gus473]

If this becomes a test, I hope UV degradation is part of it! (Like the windshield wiper test!) Sunlight seems pretty hard on most expanding foam, but the dark colors have worked better for us...! ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

[@davidturk6170]

If I understand correctly, the two types of expanding foam; open cell and closed cell. Also would like to understand the different offerings within a single brand. Thanks!

[@no-eb2xx]

@@gus473 You insulate the insides so it shouldn't be exposed to UV. Well some houses have insulation outside to prevent moisture getting in, but you can use different kinds of insulation outside. I think foam is more an interior thing.

[@nwhome9615]

@golden sands you beat me to it! That was my next suggestion lol

[@ProjectFarm]

Great suggestion! Thank you.

[@heierlu]

Would love to see a showdown of electric pressure washers.

[@saliston]

I second that. the big brands against a couple of the amazon Chinese knock offs.

[@Dextermorga]

What big brands 🤣? There is only Kärcher. My only problem with Kärcher in the US they are selling only old models

[@Iosis6]

Man that is great idea!

[@schlowe2003]

Came here to post this very comment. Considering picking up a Ryobi because of the good ratings.

[@cmbmaxeffort7528]

Dewalt has a cordless pressure washer. Not really worth buying though.

[@DanComputerMan1991]

Me with the Dewalt vacuum. "I'm gonna pretend I didn't see that."

[@rrpalk]

Ya I only opened my eyes for the run time test 😂

[@diyoutube6061]

lol atleast it makes up for shitty performance with run time one big benefit it has he didnt mention is the ability to run 120v i wonder if that would improve its performance

[@ImTheJoker4u]

Put it on Craigslist/FBMP, sell it to some poor sap who hasn't seen this yet, use the money towards a Rigid😉

[@dakotahardin4630]

@@diyoutube6061 he mentioned that and said that it was a nice feature that the Dewalt had, but this test was for the cordless capabilities so it wouldn't make much sense to test that feature unfortunately.

[@randallweaver7034]

@@diyoutube6061 My Dewalt vac runs faster(& better performance) on a fully charged 20V battery than on 120V. I only use 120V on a long project that doesn't require much vacuum.

[@KIrvin_The_Scholar]

Man, I wish you could review damn near everything on YT. Very detailed & informative.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks!

[@KIrvin_The_Scholar]

@@ProjectFarm do you have any videos comparing handheld battery piwered vacuums for car cleaning? If not is there 1 you would recommend?

[@dexdex6408]

I'm not looking at the reviews anymore... Only project farm.. Thanks

[@ProjectFarm]

Thank you very much!

[@consaka1]

Smart choice since many review sites are completely biased.

[@commodorenut]

I love the variety and thorough barrage of tests. How he thinks up all of these clever test methods is truly amazing.

[@ollydavis5702]

I’ve not found a single channel on KZbin other than this one, that provides such unbiased information, so good definitely glad I subscribed

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks! Thanks for watching and subscribing!

[@del-boysnostalgiatvads7416]

You do the lawnmower huh, ???

[@marcowens3522]

@@del-boysnostalgiatvads7416 huh?

[@reginalb124]

Very much appears that the Bosch, Dewalt, and Makita sacrificed some air speed and suction for a more restrictive air filter. Does a better job filtering, but slows them down. Ryobi and Hart had tons of suction, but almost no filtering. Milwaukee and Rigid had a nice balance. There's no free lunch.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for the feedback.

[@ayliniemi]

Dewalt had the worst suction, best longevity. Maybe it just runs slower. The best suction had the worst battery preformance.

[@spenceranderson4045]

That's because the motor is too weak in the dewalt compared to the others so it's drawing alot less power

[@glennc1490]

Love your videos. As a retail manager in a DIY store, I use your results regularly when advising customers. The only thing I have to say about this one, is the oops about calling these "Shop Vacs" That is a brand name. They are "Wet/Dry vacs", and many companies make them.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks!

[@kennethscofield4565]

I have watched several of your videos but today I subscribed, love how quick and concise without all the extra jibber jabber!

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for watching and subscribing!

[@PetrosArgy]

Give it a while and you'll become a Patron too! I did! It's well worth the money to get reviews of this caliber!

[@LycanWitch]

You've tested motor oils, however what about oil filters? See which ones are constructed the best, doesn't collapse, extras such as has metal mesh or quality of the material, oil flow or just simply which held up best between oil changes.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for the video idea.

[@ryugo7713]

Man I can only imagine how much time and effort you put into these videos and I’m just here to say that I appreciate you!

[@ProjectFarm]

I appreciate that! Thanks so much!

[@chrismcginn2]

Yes! Very nice to see this breakdown like this.

[@InsaneDuckOutdoors]

I work in an enviroment where many items you test are used daily. I find myself almost daily referencing your studies. It has been useful information for me more times than I can count.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks! Glad to hear!

[@nich6089]

2 idea for videos are: 1 testing rotary tools like dremel’s. 2. Multimeters for Accuracy, Speed, features.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for the video ideas.

[@TheReal1953]

I've been using Dremel rotary tools since the 60's. Always been good bang for the buck.........but if you really want to see what high speed rotary tools can do, you step up to Foredom with a hand piece. Then your Dremel tool becomes a toy.

[@angelamcmahon]

Love this idea.

[@mitri5389]

@@TheReal1953 dremel has always been over priced, today they sell much cheaper rotary tools like what wen has to offer and if you need something bigger, a die grinder is whats needed.

[@TheReal1953]

@@mitri5389 Have you ever tried a Foredom product with a hand piece?

[@paranoidjay]

The weekend has been made, thank you for another fine video.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thank you very much!

[@rodmandealerman3297]

I couldn't agree more! Stress-free viewing at its *finest* !

[@montgomeryfitzpatrick473]

As a plumber, the Milwaukee cordless shopvac completely changed my life when I got it a year ago. Still going strong with daily use

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for sharing.

[@donhappel9566]

I'm on my second Milwaukee vac. I like the square shape as it stores easily in my van. It's even tough enough to serve as an occasional step stool to reach a bit higher though I wouldn't recommend doing so often or if you're a 'fuller figured gentleman'. However I find the suction is barely adequate. I cannot run a filter or it simply doesn't have enough lift to pull much stuff up. I work on yachts, so the compact size is nice for maneuvering around delicate woodwork and the like and it's not so heavy that it's unwieldy when full of water, but I sure do wish it performed closer to a full size corded vac. I think Milwaukee has the tech to do it based on their bigger M18 batteries, but this hasn't been a priority. I also wasn't surprised to see Ridgid do well given their track record with corded vacs.

[@TheRabbitHaze]

@@donhappel9566 Have you tried putting a bigger battery in it? I use a 12ah battery in mine and I can definitely notice an increase in suction as well as a longer run time.

[@goaheadmakeourdayscooterpe9644]

A cordless shop vac completely changed your life? OK.

[@ethics3]

@@donhappel9566 You mean " FAT " ? Far too much PC these days

[@hendertuckyrebels2050]

The Hart vacuum does have the ability to be used as a blower, it's in the manual. You twist the hose off and plug the side that usually takes the attachments into the blower port (referred to as the exhaust in this video). I frequently use the blower option for helping dry the mats in my truck after washing them and getting the water out of the crevices after a car wash.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for the feedback.

[@mantisushi]

@@ProjectFarm Ryobi does as well, uses the utility tool on the exhaust side of the vacuum

[@iamtwatson]

How about a laser level, especially testing to see what kinds are visible outside for measuring the grade in my yard....

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for the video idea.

[@Silentroller93]

Hart: This vacuum really sucks. Project Farm: We’re going to test that.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for watching.

[@tavismacdonald7759]

The ingenuity and prep he does in making these tests and videos is just great, anytime i get an ad i can skip i dont, because I'm pretty sure they give him more money the longer someone watches. And he deserves it.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks so much!

[@tavismacdonald7759]

No worries ma man

[@palehorse1511]

For being one of the 2 lowest priced vacs, The Ryobi exceeded my expectations and was consistently ranked 3rd, right behind the Rigid and Milwaukee. Not bad!

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for the feedback.

[@palehorse1511]

@@ProjectFarm No problem, buddy. Very informative comparison and thorough tests. Excellent approach to the subject. Very well done, in my opinion.

[@TheExtremaz]

The test with the sand was very impressive! I would never have thought about that! This channel is so amazing with all the testing being done in such a correct manner.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thank you!

[@B1238534]

When your looking for the most bang for your buck for most anything just look up project farm Great testing an honest answers PERIOD!!!

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for the nice comment!

[@brokentinsel]

I got into a few Ryobi tools specifically because of reviews about their cordless shop vac. I use it to clean up after small jobs and I love it. I have a handyman business and most of the time I just need to clean up after small messes. For the price I feel like you can't beat it.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for the feedback.

[@electronicsNmore]

You didn't miss much. :-) More than likely the best cordless shop vac testing video on YT. A++

[@ProjectFarm]

Thank you very much!!

[@ethics3]

@John Flower you got a cracked windshield as well?

[@andie_pants]

Just noticed the check by your name so I took a peek at your channel. Looks like good stuff, think I'll check out a few after this!

[@TsunauticusIV]

Every video he does is likely the best in its category. Not many other channels are doing such in depth testing with rather scientific methods. If anybody knows of any other comparable channels... drop the channel name.

[@ophirb25]

If there is a comparison that I believe it, it is his comparisons, on any product. Simply great.

[@tylaroverturf]

I wonder how the new Milwaukee cordless vacuum that just came out would compare to the old one and the others in this video.

[@xXGOTCRABSXx537]

Still not as good as the rigid.

[@jc5495]

Its not a true wet dry. It is suction wise much stronger than my dyson v6 animal

[@robv489]

I am genuinely very impressed with the amount of effort you put into all of your testing, keep up the great work.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks, will do!

[@willmurray5819]

Since I’m using it primarily as a portable dust extractor and already tons of LXT tools, Makita is still the winner. Things like my health and runtime matter the most to me. Also, $150+ works out to be a much lower price considering I already have so many Makita batteries and would need to purchase multiple batteries in addition to a charger to go with one of the “faster” vacuums. Anyway, thank you for doing the lords work.

[@TheCharleseye]

Or just buy a battery adapter for about $20.

[@mc1703]

Are battery adaptors ok for tools like this? I have used them to make my Makita battery work on a Ryobi 18g nailer but I'm more nervous about doing that in tools which run continuously. I thought I read somewhere that the makita's battery protection doesn't work when fitted to an adaptor but I might be mistaken.

[@leestroble4927]

I love my Ridgid vac and I’m happy to see it did well in the shootout! The only thing I don’t like about it is that it tips over easy with its narrow base, but it has tons of power to suck the sand out of the carpet of my boat. Great video as always!!

[@ProjectFarm]

Thank you very much!

[@leofortey7561]

I too have one. Tipy indeed! With great power comes high consumption... I had to purchase the 5Ahr battery to have it work long enough to do the task I need it to do. I wonder if the 9Ahr battery will fit under the hood.

[@YoDoneSa]

The most I love about this channel versus a lot of channels is the purity and honesty and unbiased opinion and dedication in getting near perfect results. Because of your videos I choose the best tool for the best price and value. Keep up the good work.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks, will do.

[@chasemartin4450]

I'd love to see how Milwaukee's new brushless packout vacuum compares to these

[@Ryan-cw5jv]

That's how you properly review products. Excellent editing, voice volume and content!! This will be my go to review site for info on products that I do not already own. Thanks and keep up the great work.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks, will do!

[@risunokairu]

“I need a trowel.” “Ok, sure, I can help you find that. What kind of concrete project are you working on?” “I’m pouring sand into carpets.”

[@connorh4141]

*Company makes a bold claim* Project Farm: "WE'RE GONNA TEST THAT!" Company: *Shakes in fear*

[@ProjectFarm]

I hope manufacturers keep making bold claims. It makes things much more interesting when they do. lol

[@goldenpun5592]

I've started commenting on random ads i see that if Project farm hasn't tested it I don't want it XD

[@fiouable]

Oh yeah, Ryobi shakes in fear jackass.

[@andrewstewart8704]

@project farm love your videos! I wonder if your videos help keep manufactures specs honest 👍😉

[@MrSGL21]

couple of job openings tomorrow at dewalt and Makita.

[@josee.4475]

I'd like to see a review on click torque wrenches. The price range is all over the place. I'm interested in a low cost accurate torque wrench for the weekend warrior. I looked through your past videos and didn't see anything on torque wrenches. P.S. Thanks for all the great content you provide.

[@ProjectFarm]

You are welcome! Thanks for the video idea.

[@moretackle1]

I am always concerned about torque wrench accuracy especially when they get older.

[@grahamdeere9475]

agreed

[@Georgethe2nd]

I second the torque wrench test

[@dizzcorn1000]

This would be an awesome video. Putting Snap-On against Harbor Freight/Tekton.

[@Penguin545]

I have the Dewalt vac and have been plenty happy with it- sad to see it underperform a lot of tests here. I will point out that it has the ability to run off dual voltages- 20V DC and 120 AC which is a really handy feature I think.

[@therealdojj]

My in laws are waiting to talk to me in the other room I'm told them "Give me 20 minutes"

[@ProjectFarm]

lol. I like your priorities. Nice!

[@Iowagrown123]

Living dangerously. 😂😂

[@TheMcdrewb]

Lol

[@RichieCat4223]

My in laws are in the other room, that has a door that says "This way out!" Lol.

[@Iowagrown123]

@@JC-uq5gi I made a steak, the day I got divorced. 😂

[@coopernovak183]

At this point this guy has a backup of everything on the farm

[@saschaschneider6355]

He probably needs to buy a second farm soon, just so he can store everything he's bought for testing

[@ProjectFarm]

lol Thanks for watching!

[@phillipmccarter7471]

I just wonder what happens to all these tools and stuff he tests that lasts through the testing.

[@Skinflaps_Meatslapper]

@@phillipmccarter7471 I was actually thinking the same thing....what in the world does he do with all of the other products he tests? I mean, some of them he obviously tests to destruction, but many of them are perfectly good after these vids. He probably has a section of his shop that looks like a harbor freight store...

[@kamilem4487]

@@Skinflaps_Meatslapper Which trash press is the best? We're gonna test it!

[@joelwallace9199]

I’ve never seen such unbiased and fair testing. This channel is simply amazing

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks so much!

[@GRJCLyon]

I'm finding this video 2 years after it was posted and it's extremely helpful. I hate that Dewalt sucks because I have multiple batteries for it. It seems the power being awful is what kept the battery lasting the longest. There's no point in having a vac that has almost zero suction running longer. LOL. The Milwalkee is the overall smart choice here. Thank you for this video.

[@ProjectFarm]

You are welcome! Glad it was helpful!

[@Brandonjraw]

If you ever do another cordless vacuum test, milwaukee just came out with a new brushless version.

[@Studio23Media]

Kobalt has a brushless one also

[@TheCamaro5]

Isn’t it the pack out version

[@kevinmonzel]

@@TheCamaro5 correct, the new M18 fuel brushless vac is packout compatible.

[@kevinmonzel]

I wanted to see the Milwaukee M18 Fuel Packout Vac too. Milwaukee already did well, I wonder how much better their Fuel brushless version is in these tests.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for the suggestion.

[@GSDadd]

Your reviews are concise yet thorough, no BS, and just darn good. Earned a subscriber here. As far as this specific review, just further confirms Dewalt’s brand continued to take a beating to the many available choices. They need a new product line manager to get back in the game across many tools.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks! Thanks for watching and subscribing.

[@GSDadd]

@@ProjectFarm Now I’m binge watching your videos. My wife does NOT thank you 😅

[@doccrane3143]

@@GSDadd 😆 😂 😆 😂 😆 😂

[@amyperri3488]

Thank you for this!! I own a pontoon rental company and was in desperate need of a cordless shop vac for when water, bugs, and debris get in the compartments under seats. I wasn’t sure which to choose. Your video was a tremendous help!

[@ProjectFarm]

You are welcome! Glad to hear!

[@peteragurkis3590]

One thing of note: when plugging the end of the vacuum, it doesn't actually increase the load on the motor it decreases! Counter intuitive for sure but you notice the RPM actually increases when the end is plugged, how is this possible? I thought the same thing. Turns out that when no air can enter, none can really leave either, so the vacuum gets a nice happy air pocket that begins to rotate with the motor and cause less drag thus the RPM increase, really irrelevant factoid for the experiment due to the fact that all vacuums were treated equally so the results are still good, but just had to throw that out there because when I learned that I was a bit surprised.

[@muazqamar]

Thank you! Now that I think about it, it makes sense. If I hadn't read your comment, I doubt that I would've known this. You taught me something today

[@n0aimChris]

Would love to see a video of everything behind the scenes. From planning, camera/studio set up, bloopers to what you do with the extra tools and items tested etc. As always thanks for another great video

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for the suggestion.

[@watchyourtonex6989]

I would like to see that also

[@kitosugiarto1590]

Love to see that.

[@der_pinguin44]

Can't believe I'm saying this, but holy shit, Rigid did amazing!

[@narlycharley]

Have you used their power tools? I’ve only had good luck and they have just as much power as the overpriced yellow and red tools. You can’t beat the LSA either.

[@HariSeldon913]

It clearly didn't win, but I thought the Hart did really well for being easily the cheapest.

[@txmits507]

@@HariSeldon913 wasn't that much cheaper than ridgid.

[@ab_ab_c]

@@HariSeldon913 Yeah---especially when you realize that the Rigid is 105$ & it doesn't come with a battery & a charger...He should have included the total price with all of the required attachments, imo.

[@kenhurley4441]

Yep,,,, when it's "Rigid" you can do more with it!

[@jonthecomposer]

This calls for my vacuum paradox: If your vacuum sucks, it doesn't suck. If your vacuum doesn't suck, it sucks. You're welcome :)

[@jonthecomposer]

@@isaackvasager9957 I'm here all week lol

[@YoSpiff]

If it were an android in a Star trek episode, it would self destruct.

[@rlb2444]

One of the best equipment reviews I haver seen. Organized, no BS, detailed and quick.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks!

[@cybernoob101]

Love how I just subscribed to have you upload within a minute!!!!! Thank you for all your tests and especially your non-bias transparency :) we all love you

[@ProjectFarm]

Awesome! Thanks for subscribing and many more videos are on the way!

[@engineeringawesome2183]

Surprisingly my cordless vac is the tools I use the most. Now I can’t imagine not having one. Great Video!

[@queerdor]

I was wondering how useful it cordless one is. Like how offen do you need to vacuum where you cant plug in a cord

[@goldenpun5592]

We got a shark cordless from my gf's parents for Christmas and I definitely love being able to just grab and go for little things and I can vacuum the whole house on a charge... But I don't think it's quite as strong as a corded vacuum in sucking power... which makes sense

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks! Thanks for sharing.

[@adamguinn8305]

So much nicer cleaning up with the Milwaukee cordless at the end of the day than a broom or corded vac.

[@gamebredduramax71]

@@queerdor could be good for vacuuming your vehicles out so you don’t have to drag a big extension cord around

[@tsnipe28]

i really wish you added ridgid into more of your tool comparisons... I've had great results but would love to see them side by side against some better competition

[@michaellee8815]

This might be the best, clearest, most thorough no bs test I’ve ever seen. Subscribed. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

[@ProjectFarm]

Thank you very much!

[@Jakevrana]

Yet another solid gold video, I know you have seen it in the comments but I’d like to piggyback and say your fair comprehensive testing is amazing. Keep up the great work!!!

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks so much!

[@shawnnorton7731]

As always Todd does a excellent job, the videos are professional and concise. I can’t imagine how much time is involved to produce a 15:24 minute video. The one thing I would have liked would have been a comparison with a high quality corded shop vac as a control, still a great video, thanks Todd and keep up the excellent work!

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks so much, will do!

[@stephenchiappetta3427]

I don't know what's more impressive, the products you test, or the test setups you use 🤣👍

[@ProjectFarm]

Thank you!

[@kristoferbrown8007]

Amazing comparison video, as well as video time tags. Made it very easily it consume the information I was after. Thank you!

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks and you are welcome!

[@richellestruve5737]

Thank you now I can make an informed decision

[@2down4up]

Having used the Milwaukee cordless vacuum extensively I can honestly say that, at least for my needs, the cordless vacuums work in a pinch but they’re no replacement for a true plugged in shop vacuum.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for the feedback.

[@donhappel9566]

I agree 100% Mine is better than not having a vacuum and the square shape stows easily in my van and it easy to handle without risking banging it into delicate finishes, but it's a far cry from my corded Ridged in the shop. I was somewhat surprised to see it performed near the top of the pack. There's no way I can use a large corded vac for my work (I work on yachts so need both wet and dry as well as compact and portable) but it would be interesting to see how similar size corded vac compare as a reference. I feel that with the larger capacity M18 batteries available they could do a lot more.

[@HariSeldon913]

It's a pity there wasn't a quick test thrown in to see if the DeWalt performed any better in corded mode than cordless.

[@andrewt9204]

@@HariSeldon913 I'm pretty sure it's going to be the same performance, the AC is converted to DC to run the same motor. It's actually likely hampered by the AC cord inclusion as making an AC/DC converter to deliver the same amps as the battery is expensive. If they would have made it battery only, they could have used a more powerful motor. But still I agree with you, would have been nice to see the test anyway.

[@protectnor]

Just a suggestion for testing how much sand is left in the carpet, measure the weight of the carpet before and after since it would be almost impossible to remove all of the sand from the fibers.

[@radish6691]

Thank you! I actually stopped watching when I saw his seriously flawed methodology for that test.

[@somejoe7777]

It's true, you can't remove all of the sand during the shaking, but the test is still valid because all of the carpet is the same, and he spent the same amount of time shaking each carpet to remove the sand. So you can assume that of the sand that's left in each carpet after vacuuming, the shaking results in a portion of the sand that's shaken out and a portion that's retained in the carpet, and this ratio is equal for all tested vacuums. Thus, the measured portion of sand is still representative of how much the vacuum left behind and can still be used to rate the vacuums against each other. A better way to conduct this test, however, would be to weigh the sand applied to the carpet, make sure each vacuum is empty before starting the test, vacuum for 1 minute, then empty the contents of the vacuum's dirt container and weigh it. Subtraction will then tell you exactly how much sand is left in the carpet.

[@cranbers]

I agree also with the removal test for sand from the rubber matt with the gaps maybe use the same end attachment.. Since of course the huge open ones are going to be less effective then the small attachment, suction would be more concentrated.. but it wouldnt test the vacuum and would rely more on attachment type ( maybe its relevant since it came with that ?) I dont know. ( 3 inch wide one vs a 5 inch?) Also the water test, some cleaned out the water jar, others had inch or two water left before he stopped it, maybe test one at a time and empty jar so no water was left.

[@protectnor]

@@somejoe7777 I own a carpet cleaning business, and I know how difficult it is to remove sand from carpet with a truck mount, let alone a small shop vac.

[@xureality]

@@cranbers maybe on the sand from the rubber mat test he could do a second pass with the other brands since with rigid you're going to be dragging the hose around twice to clean the same amount of area as the other brands

[@davidp2888]

Cordless shop vacs exist? I was today years old when I learned this. lol

[@ProjectFarm]

Hi David, I have to admit that the top brands performed much better than I had anticipated. Hope you have a great week!

[@TechGorilla1987]

Bee-keepers have been using cordless 'shop-vacs' for removing bees for a couple of years at least. They are no-kill bee vacs to rehome hives.

[@gimking]

My Milwaukee cordless is indispensable. Ended up buying a second for at home.

[@dewaltman9377]

Wow

[@Edzhjus]

Portable washing machines and similar technology also exist. 🙄

[@Badenhawk]

I'm always a little glad I hitched my wagon to Ryobi. Very good budget tools and usually end up in the middle region of your bar graphs. Which, for someone like me is just fine.

[@joek7761]

Wow, two surprises for me after watching another one of your great informative videos. First one is. The two winners is all I ever purchase. Second is the disappointment in paying big bucks for quality name products that do not produce as we would expect. Thanks again for making these videos.

[@ProjectFarm]

You are welcome!

[@paulnorman8274]

Sucking air through a tight filter, will always kill performance. The "quality name" brands have HEPA filters, which more than make up for whatever benefit brushless motors etc. provide. You get the benefit of cleaner exhaust, which is really nice. Also, the Rigid uses a 1 7/8 hose. Bigger than the rest. Which helps quite a bit with airflow. All in all, the Rigid looks extremely well designed for the specific task of professionally cleaning cars: You exhaust to the outside, it flows lots of air and has great rounded ergonomics for moving in and around tight spots. For inside use, a HEPA filter starts becoming more important. Although I have to say the Rigid performed very well on the small particle test as well. The Rigid's made in Mexico, rather than Asia. That _may_ mean those who design and build them are both closer to end users who give feedback, so they are more likely to focus on the important stuff. Versus the others, who are likely built in giant, Chinese contract factories where noone involved even know, much less care, what they are building half the time.

[@Loebane]

This is the first test I've seen where the Dewalt not only isn't near the top, but is actually lagging behind in the tests.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for the feedback.

[@powertools2375]

Did notice that too....I’m invested in DEWAlt but doesn’t look like a good option.

[@chanhmilner2670]

We got those dewalt vacs at work, they suck

[@Budderb0yloves]

@@chanhmilner2670 Well. They are suppose to right?

[@chanhmilner2670]

@@Budderb0yloves no pun intended

[@daviddavid5880]

Love this channel. One thing: I can't overstate what a selling point the Ridgid lifetime warranty on batteries is. A very big deal that might be worth a mention. Thanks.

[@ProjectFarm]

Great point!

[@doccrane3143]

Never heard that before to bad I've already got so much dewalt and Milwaukee stuff.

[@Chinookman]

…yet super lame their design doesn’t nest the hose and attachments. Makes it a deal killer for me to buy 4 of them for my warehouse spills cleanups.

[@rage801]

I purchased the Ridgid a few months ago and it's got a dustpan feature. I don't know if this version does or not but it's actually very helpful. Just leave the hose attached to the vacuum it plugs in on the opposite end and there's a port at the bottom and you can sweep up debris right to the bottom of the vacuum, it's very handy

[@dallinhunter7385]

I've said it before and I'll say it again, your testing methodology and rigs are phenomenal.

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks so much!

[@TheBrokenLife]

I've had the Ryobi for a few months now and use it as a dedicated "inside the house" Shopvac for dusting and doing baseboards and such. For what it cost, I'm not at all displeased with it. One thing I will say is that if you're planning on using one of these the way I do (walking around with it the entire time, hence why cordless is awesome), give plenty of consideration to the weight of the one you select. I was surprised to see the Ryobi is on the lighter end of the options because it doesn't feel like it after about 15 minutes. I wish it came with, and I may add, some sort of sling mounts so you can put a shoulder strap on it. I have a regular corded 2 gallon shopvac and I swear the cordless "feels" like weighs about twice as much. Never even noticed the weight of the corded one until I bought the cordless. Also... Gotta love the PF sand table getting progressively messier with each passing test. ;)

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for sharing!

[@ThatDudeArvai]

Every other shop vac sucking water: Meh The Rigid shop vac sucking water: C O N S U M E

[@hdezn26]

Now someone should get a Kirby and see what sucks faster?!

[@28fabianz1]

@@hdezn26 *Monica Lewinsky has entered the chat

[@hdezn26]

@@28fabianz1 This may sound messes up but I heard that one of my cousins can out suck Monica.... Don't ask on how I know , but was told by someone . . .

[@waff_emo_legend4849]

Other brand cordless vacuum *HAS LEFT THE CHAT*

[@gophop]

@@28fabianz1 Kamala Harris has entered the chat.

[@trailerwookie]

I'd love to see a final graphic at the end of these videos showing the results of all the tests for quick reference!

[@leonhill8447]

^this^

[@ejej6934]

I was wondering if the info could be put into a PDF for download, but I don't know if youtube has that option.

[@Kharnellius]

@@ejej6934 Yes, I've been wanting the same!

[@cranbers]

@@ejej6934 I saw he has a link to a spreadsheet online so maybe he could put a word document with a summary of each device with his review that would be handy.

[@ejej6934]

@@cranbers Thanks, I checked it out. He sure loves to test fuel treatments: 14 videos! And 9 videos testing glues... and 14 for motor oils....

[@elonmust7470]

I went for the DeWalt. These vacuums are all more than powerful enough to get the jobs one would want to do with such units, done with ease. Such jobs are all ones that I want maximum air cleaning due to being in my vehicles or home. Thanks for taking the work out of buying stuff!!!

[@ProjectFarm]

You are welcome!

[@elonmust7470]

After a year I don't like the dewalt any longer. It's falling apart & the filters are hard to get without ordering from the web. Which inevitably yields knockoff junk,....

[@stevebstslr]

A huge note of thanks for a thorough & inventive test drive of cordless shop vacs. I have always been happy with my corded Ridgid vacuums & was leaning toward their cordless model already, but some reviewers have complained about limited battery life. For the price, and the outsize performance according to your test, I don't mind buying an extra battery for my new cordless Ridgid, thanks to your evaluation. One small note: I will be using my cordless vac outside in the rain, and I was trying to notice which models had a protective battery compartment v those with the battery left exposed. Same with the location & weather-resistance of the various power switches. Great job, and thanks again!

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks and you are welcome!

[@ankitkumarxciii]

None of the tools I see on this channel is available in India but I still watch them completely. I just love how much help this gentleman is for the consumers in North America.

[@JoelEmmanuelThornton]

You could start a similar channel to help people in your area.

[@Hankie1111]

In europe too! 👍

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks so much!

[@gregs7947]

Would love to see a video comparing different OBDII code reader and scan tools!

[@ProjectFarm]

Great suggestion! Thank you.

[@stans5270]

@@ProjectFarm Since an OBDII comparison would be not only comparing different readers, you would need an assortment of car manufacturers to be tested against. Perhaps a car swap meet or a county fair would provide the variety of autos needed.

[@undeadninja199]

I was relatively surprised at how the budget brands did with the competition. They may have relatively fell short of the competition, but I feel for the price they performed relatively well. Great video as always PF!!

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks so much! Thanks for the feedback.

[@thisisfun887]

Well for only $25 more you could get the rigid

[@Aphony66]

And yet again Todd makes the choice so much easier. Whilst the Rigid or AEG in Australia, was the clear winner, I have already decided to stick to Milwaukee. The Milwaukee came in a close second and did well enough for me to maintain my core branded tooling. Thanks for an excellent video once again Todd.

[@nogamblinge2671]

Lol same thinking process and justification

[@cadenswain158]

Same. Ill buy the Milwaukee since I'm already in their ecosystem with several tools and batteries. Especially since the Milwaukee came in 2nd.

[@joshuabarrera61]

honestly the extent of your testing on things is great and is much appreciated for someone trying to get a good shop going on a budget. Definitely earned a sub

[@ProjectFarm]

Thank you! Thanks for watching and subscribing!

[@malibumaali]

id say its between the ryobi and the rigid, slight edge to the ryobi for having the tool holders built in and i already have their batteries

[@ProjectFarm]

Thanks for the feedback.

[@dougprentice1363]

And if battery technology changes, ryobi designs thier batteries to be backward compatible. Save a ton with Ryobi.

[@masterx11a]

Man that battery part is a killer. I'm getting the dewalt, one of the most expensive and least performing because I have their batteries >.< in their defense tho I think they made the right call going for run time and ergonomics as it's not meant to replace my full size.

[@Xyphren]

@@masterx11a Yep. as a Car vac the Dewalt is nice and Portable and Much more quiet. you don't need a TON of power to vac Floor mats and seats, I have the Ryobi. and compared to the older handheld vacs or Stick vacs of the past this thing rocks. Honestly whatever system you already have is fine, each of these vacs are great.

[@WondererofConfusion]

@@masterx11a I run Dewalt and Ryobi for a reason.

[@ernestwalden3894]

Hast actually did better than what I would've thaught. I might have to take a trip to wallmart. Thanks for doing this test. It was extremely helpful. Hats off to you sir ☺👍

[@ProjectFarm]

Thank you!