The Confused History Of Qutub Minar or Vishnu Stambh? || Project SHIVOHAM

[@rr-jp7kg]

Please be aware that there is no such thing as " Islamic Architecture". These people simply adopted the local architecture of the land they were invading. If challenged on this point, simply ask them, which part of their belief system or chapter deals with architecture? You will get your answer.

[@dhruvbhardwaj8762]

Exactly, they used local people. That's why Taj Mahal has lotus petals, nagas etc

[@footjn532]

@@dhruvbhardwaj8762 What is below the Tajmahal

[@shekharparentage9329]

@@footjn532 shivlinga

[@st.mephisto8564]

This is bullshit discourse really. By that logic No architecture is purely uninfluenced by the surrounding cultures. Islamic Architecture is an entire subject altogether, read up on it. I don't know if there's any scriptural basis for it in Qur'an (Moslems can correct me on that), not everything has to have a scriptural basis to be used. We are imposing a Hindu standard on Islam because Hindu scriptures like Garuda Purana do dwelve on how to construct a temple and Vigraha etc.

[@debuojha1033]

Disappointed by the research..... Then why Ganesh idols are depict surrounding , Just fir previous it' was some Indic structure after destroy or demolished then rebuilding over a new islamic one 🤔🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻😔

[@Vedicgargi]

This is true, even DELHI HIGH COURT has accepted this fact that this whole complex was once a hindu temple.. 🤯🤯🤯😓

[@Manish_8565]

Yes it is but research has shown in this video is factual and true. Muslim invaders does demolished our temples and converted into inslamic buildings but this one is not Pavitra Vishnu Stambh this is some another hindu temple.

[@Vedicgargi]

@@Manish_8565 I know that but the fact is: this was/is a hindu temple...

[@rishann]

You could find remains lying there It is like pointing the obvious

[@unbeastable957]

source?

[@itsmechinmoyb]

@@unbeastable957 google, wikipedia, youtube, or you can go and see the remains too, mfs were in a hurry that they werent even able to destroy hindu structures completely XD JaiShreeRam

[@harshavikramaraos7211]

Sir, I have one question. If you see the nearby structures in the complex that houses the Qutub Minar, you see many temples converted to mosque by placing a dome on top, and defacing and plastering the temple pillars to look like a Islamic structure. It was done in such a haste that they did not even bother to complete it. When such is the case around the minar, how can we rule out the fact that a STHAMBHA may also have undergone the same treatment to look like a MINAR. Using raw materials from a destroyed temple is different from altering the existing temple to look like an Islamic Structure

[@gb-universe-9001]

Good question; well put 👍🏽👏🏽.

[@grsumathi]

True. Need answers.

[@prabhatsingh5234]

One question why iron pillar is in front of qutub minar amd have same shape even ration of iron pillar and minar is same whole dimention is same like a mini model

[@Prasannakumar-yk7bf]

I think Qutab Minar is of Islamic origin. However there is evidence to show that this Minar was built in an ancient Hindu Complex, there is no doubt it. The Iron pillar was moved to this palace from another place and the Hindu complex was desecrated and repurposed to build the Minar.. All this was done to show the supremacy of Islam and to crush Hinduism.

[@coolfreaks68]

Probably the Muslims destroyed a temple that existed in that place and used the rubble to erect the minar. The minar may be Islamic, but the stones were taken from a Hindu temple.

[@pavankr1]

But, there are evidences where the rocks fell off and there were Sanskrit slokas as well. The rocks were inverted and Islamic verses were inscribed on it.

[@prabhatsingh5234]

One question why iron pillar is in front of qutub minar amd have same shape even ratioo of iron pillar and minar is same whole dimention is same like a mini model

[@dhruvbhardwaj8762]

@@prabhatsingh5234 yes, exact accurate dimensions. Turks tried to destroy that iron pillar but they couldn't. Also they tried to erase Sanskrit verses on it

[@rmkrshn1887]

Pvm mn -- yes you are right, So called Kutub Minar was built by Samudra gupta's son or grandson back in 3rd century B.C. Mauryas were Ruling during 16th Century B.C. to 13th Century B.C., & Chanakya belonged to 16th Century B.C. Alexander's contemporaries were Gupta Chandra Gupta & his Powerful Son Samudragupta, who went onto conquer whole of India from balochistan - bactria to Gangasagar & from Gilgit - Baltistan to Kanyakumari. It is exactly this glory of King Samudragupta was inscribed on the iron Pillar & this iron Pillar talks about constructing Vishnu Dhwaj on a hill called Vishnu Pada. It is clear that Vishnu Dhwaj is Kutub Minar built in memory of Samudragupta.

[@abhishek6719]

​@@rmkrshn1887 totally correct bro.. Vishnu dhwaj cannot be iron pillor but kutub minar(vishnu stambh) because for 7 meter they will not write high dhwaj. Simple yar.

[@DiatomAlgae]

Many questions are unanswered in the video: 1. All the Minars in India, Afghanistan, etc., were built AFTER 711 CE, i.e., after Arab attacks on India. So is it not possible that the Turks learnt how to build minars from Indians? 2. The other Minars, Kutlug Timur and Khosrogerd are very plain, only the Jam minar has some ornamentation. Could they have been weak copies of the Vishnu Stambh or inspired by it. 3. What is the height of each of these minars. 4. Do the other minars, outside India have Lotus, Bells, etc. or are these unique to Qutub Minar / Vishnu Stambh?

[@rishitsrivastava7428]

If seen from top it is a lotus with 27 petals for 27 nakshatras, this host has no idea

[@DiatomAlgae]

@@rishitsrivastava7428 There were 27 temples near Qutub Minar / Vishnu Stambh. Where exactly were these? All in one area or Around the Stambh, in a circle, etc?

[@HarshaJSM]

​@@DiatomAlgae nakshatras means sections of time or star systems at specific locations in space. There are 27 nakshatras or star maps so maybe these 27 petals are pointing them.

[@MedhamshMaringanti]

Yeah, this is so much true. I have visited the Qutub Minar, what I can say is that Qutub Minar is a islamic construction but it is built in a Hindu temple complex after desecration. I have seen some Lord Ganesha idols on some corners and the complex seems much like a Hindu architecture. What I could understand is the Iron Pillar might be the Dhwaja Sthambha present in that temple. Edit 1:- Haha, I didn't realise that you would talk even about Iron Pillar. I typed my comment around 9 min into the video.

[@captainvenom7252]

Yes that's exactly what i find true..

[@sushmakitu]

And that stupa also.. which was rebuilt on Vishnu stupa by our indian architectures that is why they used our indian mathematics for construction..

[@prabhatsingh5234]

One question why iron pillar is in front of qutub minar amd have same shape even ration of iron pillar and minar is same whole dimention is same like a mini model

[@shiningstar3393]

THEY TAKES LOTUS ,AND OTHER SYMBOLS OF HINDUS BECAUSE ANIMALS, birds symbols are not allowed according to Islam

[@MedhamshMaringanti]

@@prabhatsingh5234 bhai, first of all that is not right infront of qutub minar. It is to a side (diagonally). Also, saying Iron pillar is similar to Qutub Minar then it should be noted that Iron Pillar belongs to 5th century. That time Islam wasn't even born. There are not many similarities between these two structures except for the fact that they both are cylindrical. This Iron pillar is present in the temple complex, Qutub minar is outside the temple complex, if you go there you can clearly see the difference in Indian architecture and the arabic architecture. Eh:- On the pillars of the temple complex, the underside of the little domes present there in the temple complex. On the contrary the arabic architecture is also present and the dome shape and the design on the borders of the entrances are different. Hope this answered your question. *Qutub minar could have copied Iron Pillar but not the other way round because it is not even possible.

[@eternalthoughts-wu5lo]

Dear Project sivoham Please watch sangam talks video he has explained the asronomical significance of Qutub minar..it seems to be very logically correct arguement

[@MyShreehari]

Dear, you need to study more on this topic. You are doing a good job and detailed study. But, with few examples saying that Qutub minar is not a Vishnu stambh is a stupid argument. You are not talking about the structure in detail. I think you need to bring more videos on the History of this great architecture. Speak about Qutubuddin time, Mathematical relation between Garuda Shambha and Vishnu Stambha. Speak about the area nearby. Speak about the pasting of Arabic letters, Speak about the material used for it. Speak more about the structure. Don't do think that after seeing this structure going towards the sky, ghori built it? Lot of things are to be searched.

[@amitclick99]

And he just compared qutub minar with some minars in Afghanistan and iran..but might be possible those minars are also built up on Vedic/santan structures as Afghanistan was also part of india back then and iran was also influenced by indian culture..if these minars were symbol of islams then why these kind of minsars are not exist in Arabian countries..

[@padmajad.693]

Moreover where it is specified that the minar was built by Islamists that too with in 4 years of their regime, that too when their capital was Lahore why Delhi.

[@filmmakernumberone]

This video stands out from other videos. While not falling to either camp if one really wants to ascertain, need to look at all aspects. The very assertive tone without talking about the Ganesha idol found & the fact that the entire area is part of a larger Hindu/Jain temple is surprising. I haven’t heard about this structure being an observatory earlier. On the point of not destroying , we have many examples from Kasi to Ayodhya where most of temple was kept and Islamic conquerors build structure on top and around it. So that argument is the weakest point in the video.

[@RVSGangotri]

I agree. Praveen Mohan ji has placed srond arguments in favour of how Qutub minar is ONLY Hindu monument kzbin.info/www/bejne/gpbRpGCXnriLp8k Iron Pillar - kzbin.info/www/bejne/aqGZpYV8qZeFgrc

[@aastha1905]

Also he explained what a minar is then why will someone built something like a light house where there are no sea or major rivers? There utterly unscientific.

[@somnath1235]

I had seen Praveen Mohan's video on qutub Minar there he showed one thing that the bell and floral pattern of the ruins of the temple is same as the bell and floral pattern of the Qutab Minar... Is there something in that??

[@knowledgehub5916]

Praveen mohan is very spectacular

[@rmkrshn1887]

Somnath - this video Is funded by breaking India forces, Cultural marxists disguised as hindutwa elements. Sort of double agentgiri , gandhigiri. If proper archeological excavations are done we will even discover Samudragupta's inscriptions & even Dharmaraja's. This fellow is merely repeating a lie multiple times without any scientific approach much akin to their JNU ustads Satish Chandra, Romilla Thapar, Bipin Chandra, Irfan Habib, Arjun dev., Their days of glory are gone.

[@mradventurer8104]

yes If I remember correctly he showed Hindu statues/images. How can he skip discussing that and not even visit the place and make fotographs?

[@rex6rocks]

I've seen them as well, this guy is just talking about "Vishnu stambh" conspiracy only. So his bias is blocking him from fully covering this topic. God knows what video he watched 😂

[@ehmneh5841]

Just watch Qutub minar video by Praveen Mohan ji. He went there physically and did a detailed video

[@rmkrshn1887]

Ehmneh - There is no comparison with Sri Praveen Mohan. This team is a disguised marxists trying to continue their Sabotage of Hindu history, this time in the guise of hindutva vaadis.

[@RC_Official_007]

I follow Praveen mohan...an appropriate explorer of Ancient temples...

[@JsjwjwHwhwhw]

Yes, that video shows all the evidence that the tower is not an islamic structure.

[@samratashoka9629]

Best Deepavali Gifts this year: 1. India win over pakistan 2. Rishi Sunak becomes the 1st Hindu PM 3. Ayodhya Deepotsav becomes a Grand Success 4. Isro launches multiple satellites

[@varunmanjunath9123]

5. Uttarakhand and Uttar Pradesh governments have started making UCC drafts

[@samratashoka9629]

@@varunmanjunath9123 Good!

[@blackvenom2945]

Pls don't skip ads. It will help Project Shivoham financially. 🕉🚩🙏

[@Satishkumar-ny6xv]

For the videos related to hindu Dharmam Google provides ads for more than one minute sometimes for more than three minutes ... For other useless videos Google ads will be short so that we can't skip

[@anonymouscoder7791]

5:20-> Why would they make a mosque in a temple.... Same reason

[@dalitnahipehlehinduhu6569]

To destroy the cultural ethos of india and to turn in it into a Islamic nation... So far 60000 ancient temples were demolished by islamic invaders

[@raghavneema8849]

But then why are there bells drawn on the qutub minar when Quran says bells are bad What about the Iron pillar infront of the qutub minar There are still lots of broken idols which represent original indian culture I strongly used to believe that Qutub minar is Vishnu stumbh Please do answer my question 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@raghavneema8849]

Okay i got answers in rest of the video

[@prabhatsingh5234]

@@raghavneema8849 One question why iron pillar is in front of qutub minar amd have same shape even ration of iron pillar and minar is same whole dimention is same like a mini model

[@raghavneema8849]

@@prabhatsingh5234 There was a temple there before any islamic structure and they destroyed the whole temple complex and then they created qutub minar

[@prabhatsingh5234]

@@raghavneema8849 why ironnpillar is ditto same as qutub minar, thier size ratio is also same amd dimention also same, andniron pillar is a hindu pillar, both are same maybe both are hindu site

[@russianmig2968]

First of all Bell is strictly haraam in islam.. This is vishnu islam

[@12440jayjay]

Among all your videos(Project SHIVOHAM) I think this video on Qutub Minar is off beat! I wonder what inspired you to make it??

[@Aravind-xm7gg]

I think his allegiance to Truth and not to propaganda made him make this video. Kudos to the author 👏🏼

[@AshwinSriram]

This is really good - a factual presentation with good comparisons. As a student of Jyotisha I appreciate the references towards the end. In my youth I didn't believe in Jyotish but fate had other plans for me and made me realise the beauty and depth of Jyotish as I grew up. I thank Bhagavan for guiding me towards it.

[@MsLizzie50]

Kindly recommend good source in English

[@AshwinSriram]

​@@MsLizzie50 - If you are looking to learn Jyotisha in Engish then the best books available in the market currently are written by Sarajit Poddar. You can find his books on Amazon. I know the author personally and can vouch for his depth of learning on the subject. He is truly brilliant. If you are completely new to the subject of Jyotish I would suggest you look up Sarajit's book titled "Jyotish: A Guide to Self-Discovery". His other books (i.e. series of books) are meant for those who are already familiar with the basics of the subject. So you can check them out if you are familiar with the basics. There is also another author called Robert Svoboda - he too has written an English book that serves as a good primer for Jyotish. You can look that up as well. His book is titled "Light on Life: An Introduction to the Astrology of India." I hope this helps.

[@nvsk9124]

@Ashwin Sriram plz share your mail id🙏🏻

[@rmkrshn1887]

¤ Ashwin Shriram - I bet you too belong to the mercenary gang of Shivoham, given the task of discrediting Hindu glory & glorifying Desert rattle snakes culture. I can see through your pretentions of a hinduphilia.

[@daneshwarihammond2446]

Why then Kutub minar contain sanatandharma symbols under Arabic script ? Like bells , chains, lotus . There are Minars across Hindustan on which either a loud speaker is placed for Quran to be heard across that region or from height one can see around the region.

[@manojtrivedi5461]

It is astronomical observation spot..

[@amitclick99]

I am also open to take any truth..but you didn't provide sufficient proofs,based on qutub minar's in depth architecture to prove your theory

[@pratibhapose7423]

The research is really very shallow and concluded in a rush. You can always express it as your opinion. How can you be so judgemental about mentioning this issue as a propaganda when your knowledge on this subject can also be limited?

[@JB-nd3cf]

Agree to everything on astronomy you shared and disagree everything about the qutub Minar you mentioned. Not sure about astronomical observatory or Vishnu Stambh term, but it is certainly a Hindu structure. If you would have search a bit more, the iron pillar was established by Chandragupta during Gupta period in Delhi with the help of great mathematician Varahamihir. Also, the complex was called Maharaj Prithviraj Chauhan temple till the independence, saw an old image of that complex. Moreover, it itself written there that it has been built over Hindu-Jain temples. So, we have enough reasons to call it a Hindu structure.

[@bharusiva477]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/gpbRpGCXnriLp8k

[@JB-nd3cf]

@@bharusiva477 thanks but I've already watched it.

[@bharusiva477]

@@JB-nd3cf Hope Project Shivoham also watches ))

[@kR_kh]

Absolutely right

[@rmkrshn1887]

@@bharusiva477 - Project Shivoham is Marxists in hindutva disguise. They are traitors. They came here to mislead, not to find truth

[@vigneshs6129]

Sadhguru says there are 16 parts to the mind, but only elaborates on 4 of them, could u make a video on the 16 parts. And what does our shastra say about way one can sharpen ones intellect and enhance ones ability to recollect what is needed for the situation from our memory. Thank you for all the effort u have put in the making of every single one of your video and wish the best for u. 🙏

[@gauravjoshimechg8130]

If you really want to know, don't watch videos, just practice yoga, some day you will realiase what he says. You can learn simple practices of hatha yoga like 1. Ang mardana 2. Yogasan By any Isha Hatha yoga teacher

[@rishavburnwal6676]

You should daily practice the Panchakshara Mantra Japa by Sadhguru everyday and believe me you will experience the difference within in 2 months if you practice it to perfection.

[@gauravjoshimechg8130]

@@rishavburnwal6676 please don't do any japa without initiation.

[@TAPAS29]

Very conveniently put together to push your theory.!!? - The main entrance of minar is facing north, not according to Islamic architecture. - The chain and bells and lotus designs are exactly same as on surrounding demolished temples around…how!??😂 - Bells are forbidden in Quran…and you are saying “so what” if they are carved?! Are you seriously serious!? Show me a proof of 🔔 carved on any non-converted mosque anywhere in the world? - So basically you are telling me that the 50 feet diameter spot of minar was left behind by the “ancient temples ( 27 of them) people” for its construction!??😂 - Also the king Kutubudin was so smart that he didn’t even carve his name on minar even though he made it!? 😃 There is his name carved on one of surrounding converted mosque. - King Kutubudin was there for around 4 years and the minar took 20 plus years to built!? The so called minar was constructed in stages by different Islamic rulers and there are many proof of that. - The iron piller- Garuda stambha itself is a proof that this structure has something to do with lord Vishnu.! - The Islamic verses are full of grammatical errors and more, that tells you it was done later to convert the existing structure. There are many many more points like that you didn’t consider selectively or may be conveniently to push your theory..!? Disappointed at your loco logic!!? Cheers😊

[@vidyadharbusam6067]

all the other minars you showed clearly plane cones and has no decoration. but this minar has edges and curves just like geometry that you mentioned in jyothishyam, why? and why did they decorate sooo much with Arabic texts where other minars(light tower as claimed) don't have anything like that?

[@TAPAS29]

Not only that …. Why it has Hindu carvings as mentioned by this guy bells and lotuses etc..!?

[@rmkrshn1887]

Vidhyadhar - Please don't trust this shivoham project. They are paid traitors. Even the Minar you find in Afghanistan must belong to Hoary Hindu past, as Afghanistan had Hindu kings as late as 980 A.D.

[@sreekalakamalanandan2293]

Just curious, why no such islamic structures in place where Islam originated? And why islamic invaders built these structures in these places only?

[@ravitejakvns8542]

I appreciate all your videos, but I need more convincing with your theory in this particular video. I have personally visited the minar complex. The following are some unanswered questions: 1) Why are the materials used in the construction of various surrounding temples and Qutub minar the same? 2) No Muslim construction has bells in surface carvings. Why does the Qutub minar have bells decorated in the same pattern as surrounding temples? 3) History says the minar was constructed as a victory symbol during 1199-1220. To celebrate whose victory and on whom? 4) It was depicted that the minar was constructed for 21 years, but Qutbuddin ruled that place just for four years !! 5) The entrance of minarets has to face East, but why does only this particular minaret entrance face North? 6) Various partially damaged temples surround the minaret. It is a surprise how the building material is conveyed into the center of the complex to construct 240 feet of giant structure and its foundation without making a way !! 7) Why did Sayyid Ahmed Khan (subordinate judge & Archaeologist) has given a technical note before the British quoted this construction as a Hindu monument? Reference: link.springer.com/chapter/10.1057/9780230119000_8. If we just see the Wikipedia page (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qutb_Minar) with all other minarets, it might be convincing. But we need to check facts and possibilities in a technical way. I am not sure this is Vishnu sthambha, but we don't have solid proof to quote it as a minaret either.

[@punchar4161]

Sir., you, Dhruv Rati and Ravish Kumar would make a great trio. Thanks

[@LordofKings-Raj]

3 idiots 😂😂😂😂

[@eternalthoughts-wu5lo]

This is the shallowest video documentary made by you. Architectural details of even the Ghor Minar are UnIslamic. there is every possibility that all 4 minars were built by Vikramaditya 500BC .Please dont be in a hurry ...Please remove this video for now and after reading the architecture of all 4pillars you can make a video on this specific minar

[@narrativegatherer3128]

Nah fam, the invaders built Qutub Minar on top of our temples. That's why we see Hindu elements there. Just like the case of Ram Mandir!

[@dalitnahipehlehinduhu6569]

The bell & lotus carvings of demolished temple are identical with the carvings of lotus &bell carvings of minar ..how is this possible??😭

[@eternalthoughts-wu5lo]

@@narrativegatherer3128Qutub minar was not built on top of any mandir a mosuqe was built by razing hindu and Jain temples adjacent to qutubminar. ASI has put up a board with these facts there. please observe HD photographs of minars of Iran Afghan also and you will find many Hindu motifs on all of them. even those minars were works of Hindus

[@minivictor1193]

Very much correct as ancient India extended to all these places

[@SinghFromIndiaBharat]

Echoing my thoughts. Thanks @eternalthoughts

[@russelschuster8036]

I wonder why your channel is not growing. It should be topmost recommended channel in India and anyone who wants to know more about us from anywhere in the world.

[@hsram1985]

Kutub minar is a druv stamb vishnu nabhi precession of the earth. 27 temples are 27 Nakshatras. Qutub minar is brahma rising from the nabhi of Vishnu. Kutub minar was a temple of Brahma.

[@consultantglobaltech479]

John Irwin and Carlyle provided strong evidences to show this structure existed before Aibak, but his boss Alexander Cunningham silenced them didn't give the credit for their research

[@aviralomar3760]

Look, I have a "LOGICAL" argument from the Upanishads about Qutub Minar and why it is a hindu structure. kzbin.info/www/bejne/b3bOlYpulpeSbJo This is a episode from Upanishad Ganga (one of the most spiritual serials of India) and this episode is about Varahmihira, I would recommend watching full episode but crucial conversation is between Varahmihira and Gupta King of that time at time stamp 15:00 here both of them disscus about the so called Iron Pillar and Qutub Minar which are reffered as Memorial for Chandragupta and Vedshala respectively. Qutub Minar is also called as Dhruv Stambha because it is believed that Dhruv, a devotee of Vishnu attained enlightenment here. And it has some connections with the Dhruv Star or the Pole Star. And another point is about the tilt of the Qutub Minar, It is tilted about a scientific and specific angle so that it produces no shadow on a very auspicious event. (I am not so much sure about this argument) I am not opposing you but I want logical answer to these questions because I still think it is Vishnu Stambha.

[@rmkrshn1887]

Aviral Omar - Varaha Mihir was in the court of Sakari Vikramaditya of Ujjain, not in the Guptas' Court which was in pataliputra. Later guptas merged into the great Sakari Vikramaditya's Mission to Expel Sakas from Bharat.

[@aviralomar3760]

@@rmkrshn1887 I was also confused about this thanks but it is of a Hindu King either Guptas or Vikramaditya

[@AJAYSINGH-ns1vv]

@@aviralomar3760 vikramaditya of ujjain is first and most famous vikramaditya of India but history is distorted and he is now considered as a legend but he is truly best king in kaliyug.

[@aviralomar3760]

@@AJAYSINGH-ns1vv true

[@ringostarr1038]

Qutub Minar has bells, which is Haram in Islam, since their propaganda believe bells are used by their fictional Shaitan. The Minar entrance faces North, not East, also Haram. There are several other problems with your proposition. Praveen Mohan has done a detailed credible study on this structure. Better refer to him.

[@pranavsuhag]

Please try the book written by architect, Genesis Of Time: Unveiling the Hidden History by Abhishek Singh. This will definitely clear your doubts.

[@pungavaD]

Although I admire your work but in this case it's very shoddy work on your part. How could you miss the fact that the "stambha aka Qutub Minar" has the following properties: 1. The entire complex had 27 temples (nakshatras ?) 2. There are windows in the minar at exactly between every 13th and 14th steps ( deg of nakshatra in one rashi, where rashi divides 360 deg in 12 parts) 3. The storeys obey the fibonacci series (meru prastaar) 4. It is tilted to an angle such that during summer solstice it has no shadow, which isn't possible for straight objects in Delhi. While having no moon shadow at every 27th day. Muslims believed earth is flat (hardcores still believe the same) atleast during 1100-1200 CE period then how come they are calculating the solar and lunar motions? Besides what they have to do with the 27 nakshatras? It should be noted that astrology is haram in islam.

[@bobroy3746]

Can you make a video about the true origins of Taj Mahal and Humayan tomb. Some historians say these structures don't have the typical Mughal architecture.

[@kiannkan]

Watch Dhruv Rathee’s video on TAJ MAHAL. No it was not a shiv temple. 👍

[@007Sanoop]

Please research & do a video on "River Culture (Making permanent river paths and land areas, for long-term peaceful accommodation of human civilization without floods or other natural calamities, and as a water resource)" in Bhaaratham. For eg, River Ganga by Bhageeratha.

[@TheRamrocks]

Honestly...this is one of the most under researched and unconvincing videos from project shivoham

[@saimadhuri9255]

Disppointed with this video. Atleast you must have watched Praveen mohan's video , He gave much detailed information. Strongly disagree with this video

[@dalitnahipehlehinduhu6569]

Once again a wonderful video but i didn't got a exact answer.. .the thing is that lotus and bell carvings of demolished temple and the bell&lotus carvings on minar are same.how can this possible if it is islamic.and there are some proofs coming from old Indian texts that varahmihira was using this to study about Sun's trajectories & positions ☀️...i think in the name of unbiasedness u got biased to British and islamic texts..

[@playhard719]

This is great video once again, can you do a video on how idea of calculus evolved in India from Aryabhatta to Madhava of Kerala, how this culture of mathematics created genius like Srinivasa Ramanujam even in as late as early 19th century, and how and why exactly mathematics in India stopped evolving

[@playhard719]

@Tustin jrudeau I am a Chinese dude

[@playhard719]

@Tustin jrudeau Dude I was joking I mean my name is literally most Tamil name that you can find

[@playhard719]

@Tustin jrudeau That's view of very few people who are so loud because they are in power, and control of media, in reality most people are ignoring of our past but there is no negativity among common people but simply because they are taught the wong history

[@AshwinSriram]

@Tustin jrudeau - I am a Tamilian as well. I am a Sanatani and a Bharatiya before anything else. Don't fall for the whole Dravidian-Periyar-Leftist propaganda - only those people attached to state politics and are brainwashed by that powerful ecosystem push this anti-Hindu agenda and they are usually loud (I mean political parties own TV channels in the state). Most common people in TN don't think of themselves as separatists (most common people are not anti-Hindu). If you spend some time living in TN you will see most (common) people are devoted to Hindu culture and Hindu gods in many different ways. You will see them wearing namam, going to temples, practicing Hindu rituals like house warming (Grahapravesam) and even keeping Sanskrit names for their children (my name is Ashwin which has its roots in the name Ashwini Kumaras - a Hindu deity referenced in the Vedas and Puranas). It is just that the history that is taught in the state promotes the aryan-dravidian theories and promotes certain periyar-driven agendas which create some friction in the minds of our youth (especially the educated class). It will take some time before we see change in the state. But don't count us out. Many Indians have become colonised by our British imposed education system so the same has happened in the south also - unfortunately Dravidianism still has an audience in TN but that is changing slowly thanks to voices like Sai Deepak emerging. Give it more time.

[@rmkrshn1887]

Tamilselvan - This a not a great video. He tried to fool us into thinking that Project Shivoham is a Patriotic venture. No, it is not. He tried to gain our confidence by making some remarks on calculs & under it's shadow tried to Rob Vishnu Sthambh from our Cultural heritage. Bloody Collaborator, much like Duratma Gandhi

[@mayureshponkshe9325]

A claim without evidence can be dismissed without evidence. And its true to this Shivoham's statement too. It can't be baseless since someone declared its baseless. It's accepted by scholers that The scripture over the Minar has multiple mistakes and not true to as specified in invaders Book. They openly state its invaders Religion's / Islam's ability power ( Kuwwat e Islam ) to destroy Hindu Jain Dharma. Why and how long to portrait A shame on us.

[@avishekmukhopadhyay6086]

Your first video which i couldn't agree with. You did not give enough explanation about the underlying floral design "below" the quranic verses, how is that even possible?? Bells are considered devil in the quran, how to explain that ?? And how do you explain the tilt of the minar for which no shadow is formed on 21st June every year !! Am sorry not fully satisfied by this video !!

[@malganis2084]

To , Project Shivoham Team, I am watching all your contents and they are very informative and clarified with reference to actual source. In this video, regarding 7 days a week against 9 planets in Sanatana science....i want to emphasize that each planet gets 21 hours a day ( Mon to Sun ) and for Raghu - Ketu which is considered one entity ( even after the head was cut by Vishnu during amruta distribution) gets 1.5 hours each everyday which is known as Raghu kaalam and Yamagandam . It means 3 hours x 7 = 21 hours a week for Raghu- ketu as well. So with this theory all the 9 planets gets 21 hours in a week . ( 8+9 th planet as one entity). This theory is also from Jyotisha.

[@nandhi108]

Your well researched video alongside the ancient wisdom is the Sacred Sthallum Stambh Sengol of Mother India. Grateful Divine Brother!

[@DALIT-INFIDEL-HINDUTVA]

One can agree that the ugly Kos Minar mile markers in Northern India are probably built by the invader marauders Apparently, around 300 BC (western indology), Ashoka installed mud pillars up to Kabul, then the 16th-century Pashtun ruler Sher Shah Suri introduced improved brick pillars plastered over with lime at every kos. The minars thus came to be called as kos minars, though!.

[@rishikeshvashishtha7347]

Just tell me one thing how was this massive structure was built within 4 years. As khilji only ruled for 4 years in Delhi Secondly,those Indian who built the jain temples , why would they leave a massive space in the middle of complex so that one day khilji can come and conveniently built qutub minar.

[@tommyabhinav8048]

How to support your channel sir. Add a payment option. We need more off this content of this or even higher quality.

[@tej7282]

I've heard the argument that bells are the symbol of satan in Islam.. is this true? If yes how do you explain those on qutub minar...

[@purabi123]

But why would they need a lighthouse in a place where there is no ocean nearby? Makes no sense. Also these is a temple ruin just next to it. We have seen how Babri majid was build and now the gyanvaapi so it will be wrong to totally reject it was never. Hindu structure.

[@lundfakhri448]

This is not an Islamic structure, it has bells which is banned in Islam, made of material of near by temple structures, with structures added sloppily to cover up Hindu art on the structure. We know 100% it is part of near by Hindu temple structure. We just do not know what kind of Hindu structure it was.

[@parvathamma1]

Whatever jyotishya shastra etc... You are talking, do you think These barbaric invaders has any knowledge on anything else like science, art and architecture, other than Violence, treacherous behaviour?

[@charithacaraboppa3674]

no words how much i adore this guy he always gives clarity to my teenage confused brain

[@manoranjandutta989]

Who demolished 27 Jain temples as accepted by ASI?

[@hsram1985]

These 27 temples are 27 Nakshatras. Qutub minar is a druv stamb vishnu nabhi precession of the earth with 27 Nakshatras. It is a temple of Brahma rising from Nabhi of Vishnu.

[@Pange1969]

As a young girl living in Delhi we always went to all those tombs and minerals in Delhi to see as a part of tourist attraction. Innumerable times we roamed this historical spots with every guest who visited but upto now we were convinced of it’s Islamic past. Thank you Shivohom what an eye opener sharing asap with my grandchildren 🙏🏼

[@yogi_bharateeyudu]

Great work....! Project Shivoham ! ✅👏🙏💪🇮🇳📢📣🕉🚩

[@kasturipillay6626]

Even if its Islamic, q.m. it's still made on foundational features and infrastructure pertaining to ""Hinduism ". DEFAULT means. 🤨

[@kasturipillay6626]

Why are there bells .?? Muslims don't believe in bells or jyotish.

[@kasturipillay6626]

This was the worst video you made. It's a disappointment to us and Sanathana Dharma.. 😥😥😥😥

[@kasturipillay6626]

You need to do more research.

[@kasturipillay6626]

Remove this video 😔

[@MukeshSingh-fg7hw]

This channel normally gives informative and valuable videos. But this qutub minar video lacks depth and looks focusing only on summarizing that it is qutub minar only, just by rubbishing vishnu Shambh theory. Facts and example quoted by video are hardly relevant and shallow, indicating lacking own research on such a serious subject. I hope video makers themselves are not carried away by any propaganda. Such shallow contents are Not expected from a prestigious channel like this.

[@KingHari010]

How all those barbarians who cannot build a decent house for themselves in their own land suddenly became the art lovers and built such archetectural wonders immediately stepped on indian soil ?I thought shivoham also becoming islamoeham day by day!otherwise they must answer one question - why this art lover who built kutub minar in india was an illiterate and less of creativity in his hoemtown.

[@kuttapi3255]

True

[@rmkrshn1887]

¤ No doubt shivoham is a cryptomarxist

[@GodessKali]

They just came for the loot. They just polished and gave their name. Why a destroyer will construct something? Even if they built , they built it with Indian labour and construction material. We have every right on it. They came for loot. They were looters nothing else. So no need to glorify them.

[@playhard719]

I don't think he glorified anyone he just stated facts

[@ravish05]

Interesting. Would be good to hear from you on the taj mahal - tejo mahalaya controversy.

[@samueljones621]

Sorry, I might be missing something but o.o Where are the pictures & evidence that show that this structure was not built over a non-islama structure of religious import, like the Islamist desert pagan converts, have a history of doing. o.o

[@vineethsingh3126]

We need same video on TAJ MAHAL history please 🙏

[@TheMagicofJava]

Surely the seven 'planets' used in the days of the week comes from the Plotemic system? I don't want to discount the contribution of Indian astromony on Hellenic learning, simpy to suggest a direct link via the Hellenic to the Roman.

[@mirdulamadhu320]

Set aside that high definition pictures in google. Did you go visit and examine the structure from top to bottom?

[@gauravjoshimechg8130]

@projectshivoham, I am great fan and admirer of your work. But you should watch video made by Praveen Mohan on the same topic. Pranam.

[@pumelofest6427]

I appreciate your efforts as always. But for this one I still have my doubts. And like the Sanatan Sanskriti we all can have our own journey to truth. Maybe I will choose to walk further on until I get satisfaction. Thank you for your efforts as always!

[@rmkrshn1887]

Pumelo Fest - Yes you are right. Please explore further & don't get trapped in colonial historiography which had a dubious purpose of instilling inferiority among Hindus so thar the colonials may have a smooth Unchallenged Rule. You will find tonnes of evidence going back to 10000 B.C, 20000 B.C. or even ancient period, not only of Indian history but world history. Bloody Romans & Arabs destroyed ancient cultures ¤

[@bmpanchakshari7162]

I am a regular viewer of ur videos In this video Don't come to the conclusion without referring to many books and videos which are very much available in net. You have come to the conclusion that it is an islamic monument if it us so why there ia ganesh idol lotus petals bells and other carving on it when these invaders dont believe in idol worship and decorating with idols is haram in islam how could it be possible to carve the idols and bells. Why there is a lotus carving there on the top Leave all of the above do visit the qutub minor and observe the monument clearly and come the conclusion, our religion is at stake not because of the other faiths but coz of our people with left idiology think themselves liberals with some facts and show themselves the great intellects. As you said it needs un biased study with detailed study Indian influence was up to middle east under vikramaditya The reason why we are findi g shivalinga ganesh narasimha idols still in iran and other countries

[@meenakshiogirala]

I am not convinced by the arguments made on Qutub Minar because all these other minar containing countries are a part of akand Bharat and there was a comment about King Vikramaditya therefore I am not convinced but the Jyotishyam part is your signature content no negative feedback on that.

[@hemanomula517]

What is the explaination of bells? From what I hear, for them bells are evil. Then why would they carve bells? Also what about Taj Mahal then?

[@Devi1_rideR.s]

It doesn't make sense, the invaders couldn't properly clear some temples, around that area, which they tried to convert by putting domes,and neither they knew about these rocks or how to construct using these after invading India. And just coz of that there are minarets as well in other parts, it doesn't proof that they have built it. There should be proper ASI surveys and excavations to get to the point, coz there was a large spreaded temple at that place before.

[@HridaySanatani]

Even if it's islamic it is still anti Bharat which needs to be demolished and a bhavya mndir is needed to be constructed there

[@indian3256]

Sir I admire your research Please give some explanation on broken hindu temple and ideal near by qutub minar

[@barnalibhatt373]

You have tried to establish your own point of view based on British books and Islamic evidences which are not at all trustable or genuine. Islamic and British invaders would not mention the truth about Sanatan Dharma, Sanatanis n Bharat in any evidence which was made by them manually. Like Ram Janmabhumi, Kashi etc this Kutub Minar matter will be resolved in Court, not by you or by us. Till date Bharatiya workers are doing middle East constructions , even Burj Khalifa is made by a Bharatiya engineer n Bharatiya workers. Thank you 🙏

[@eternalthoughts-wu5lo]

Endi Anna. Turakala nunchi mootalu emina andaaya? Architectural marvels always have a purpose and philosophy,cultural motifs and symbols of that culture.Please carry out your study on those lines.

[@kasturipillay6626]

Where is your other comment. Did you delete?

[@kasturipillay6626]

Sorry I see it. But it doesn't appear here.

[@satyarthi9]

Can you explain how qutub minar is built because according to archeologists it's different parts were built by different emperor in different time, You said bells and lotus can't prove it's hindu monument then how come we find the same pattern in pillars of destroyed temples adjacent to it? Just look at the quality of construction of minar and rest of complex, if they can build such a beautiful minar then why the remaining part was so filthy or poorly constructed? But I must say,Alia minar was definitely work of these invaders

[@bikashsarker494]

Read the book "genesis of Time".

[@nimmalanithinreddy5165]

What is your explanation on Ganesh statues which are in Qutub Minar?

[@ramcharanPhirangi]

1. One of my muslim friend who is a quran teacher told me that bells in Islam are called 'satan bells'. How can those bells carved on the qutub minar which is being called a sacred Islamic structure? and as you see the Qutub Minar's nearby demolished temples's pillars, you can find the same decorative bells patterns. How can you miss those things in the video? 2. And in my reaserch, I came to know that a Muslim professor who came from saudi examined qutub minar and declared that most of the Arabic phrases carved on qutub minar have spelling mistakes and grammer mistakes. His name sarts with Syed. Most importantly they are carved on some lotus garments which were older than arabic carvings. 3. And the most silliest part in your video is that as the name minar is used for the pillar, u say that qutub minar is a light house built by mughals. I appreciate the explanation of 'minar' origins. But that doesn't satisfy the usage. Minars in Islam are used to announce the prayer by lighting or by big sounds. We all know that muslims will have 5 prayers per day which is a good habit. Atleast 5 O clock in the morning and evenings we hear the prayer in mics. How can you expect someone to climb the Asia's tallest tower and light a fire or make a sound 2 times a day? Please compare the heights of original Islamic Minars with Qutub minar. Finally, you are the one who came up with a made-up story while criticizing other explanations. Please do research more before spreading a message. The biggest wonder is you missed a simple logic of bells. You lack the basics for explaining about Qutub Minar. You just wanted to show your false secularism. Your channel has the amazing number of subscribers. That means you have more responsibility. Please make a good use of it. 'Let us not call it Vishnu stumb' is okay. 'Let us not call it a sacred islamic stucture too'. 🙏🙏🙏

[@poonamsharma-ju5df]

Absolutely ...shud b more responsible

[@venkatranganmc9679]

Everything around the minar is a temple. Maybe this was remodeled from a part of the temple, but definitely Islamic handiwork on the minar. It is not possible for invaders from that time to have the architectural knowledge to design such high structures. Whether Iran or Afghanistan, all had sanatani monuments at that time.

[@TheAnilsarkar]

If the mongols and turks had the ability to build such long structures why didn't they build it in the countries they were originally from? Secondly, these structures seem to be only present in the countries which were once part of Bharat, coincidence? Thirdly, they tried replicating the structure right in front of the original but what happened, coincidence? Fourth, they claim that this structure was built to establish the prowess of islam, then what was the purpose of making a way to reach to the top? There are much more arguments already laid out by other people so I haven't included them in my argument. It may not be Vishnu Stambha but it's not an islamic structure either.

[@SanSha2100]

No dear, it is simply impossible that it was built by anyone other then ancients. The duplicate can be seen just opposite to this Stambh which is not even childish but idiotic. These kind of constructions needs highly evolved and perfectly balanced humans may be just short of enlightened if not enlightened.

[@dhruvbhardwaj8762]

I do not agree to your video. I request you to do more research on this. Those verses on Qutub Minar don't make any sense. Also the iron pillar which has Sanskrit inscription is exactly 1/10th of minar. The gate of minar opens up towards north which is not the direction of mecca but followed by hindus

[@mohandasbhat7265]

I have got two questions to you 1. You don't believe in Astrology. Then how Panchanga has been pin pointing exact time of eclipses and times of sunrise and sunsets for the last thousands of years? 2. NASA has confirmed that Sun's movements through summer and winter Solsitis in the shape of figure 8.

[@mohandasbhat7265]

...and if a big figure 8 is drawn inthe North of the minar, the shadow of the tip of minar falls on this path throughout the year, showing Mahanakshatra one after another. Is it not Science??

[@mohandasbhat7265]

I haven't received any response from Shivoham for my questions. You used the word "conspiracy" many times with out studying the scientific aspects. I am preparing a video to show the Qutab Minar can be used as an Astronomical Observator

[@mohandasbhat7265]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/rJDFdpeVnbOharM

[@billssingh9825]

Even the tour guides who have served all their life there validate about a Hindu architecture for the earlier levels and the foundation

[@manojtrivedi5461]

It is a Hindu monument altitude height and place and angel were selected.. on certain day of the year at given time you cannot see the shadow of the minar ..

[@AJAYSINGH-ns1vv]

Make a video on vijay stambh built by rana kumbha in chittodgad Rajasthan.

[@ragas93]

The explanation on week days and their names is just mind blowing! Thank you!

[@yogsahyog845]

Last hindu shahi king of Afghanistan was Maharaj Jaipal who made all heritage, the evidence is available in पर्शियन muslim literature who praised him as golden period of all time in Afghanistan

[@SourabhAgarwaliitg]

I like your videos as they are well read and backed by research. However I would like to point out here that the theory you put for days of the week vs orbital speed is not correct. speed of Venus is higher than Jupiter and Sun don't fit between Saturn and moon. That being said, it would be interesting if you can make a video on how 7 days of week came into existence in Indian culture. there is surely no mention of "vaar" in either Ramayan or Bhagwat puran.

[@shivashishjhariya3476]

Only one question. What will you say about residue of temples, residue of hindu deity and statues in the campus of qutub minar?

[@geetacanpadee884]

It’s mind boggling to know that hundreds of years ago there were brains that formulated extraordinary knowledge like jyotishyashastra.

[@rmkrshn1887]

Geeta Canpadee - Trying to sabotage Vishnu Dhwaj by pretending to love jyotish shastra,

[@parvathamma1]

Nobody claiming it's scientific observatory. It's a victory pillar. There is no relationship to jyotish shastra and your claim it as it's a islamic structure doesnt make any sense.

[@historiadegauda3740]

You also made a video on Feroze Minar in Pandua. That too is not an Islamic structure. It is taught as an Islamic structure in West Bengal curriculum.

[@vporwal]

I have been following his video for some time, but slowly I see him turning into “secular” mindset, first he started stating that zero is not just an Indian concept, but many other civilization had it,… now this about Qutub minar. And then he has the superiority attitude and asks the audience to just dismiss the “conspiracy” idea that QM is not an Islamic structure.. and he quotes a British text to validate it. He never gave any explanation on why bells and the other Hindu patterns and Ganesh and how come in middle of all the temple complex this is built, etc… he never gave any counter arguments, just showed similar minar during that time… did it not occur to him that even the other minars may have been built by some hindu kings since hindu civilization had influence in the whole north India till the Arab world and had scientific and mathematical exchanges in 1st and BCE? I like his videos, but this one was not thought through and seem like he is trying to become more “secular”

[@srinivasprs]

Such an intricate investigation on the facts. Appreciate your efforts. Thank you for saving sanathana dharma. Take a bow.

[@_manohar]

If looked deeply it is a satirical video, Simply want to say that why would there be such constructions in ancient India. Not criticising. (Not a translation of my telugu comment).

[@shivprasadjoshi5280]

I wonder how a Sultan who ruled only 4 years, mostly was busy with various aggressive battles, managed to construct such a huge tower, and nobody else could do that again ever.... I wonder, I wonder..... Please update and make a new video, also go there and investigate the sculptures.

[@jhansirani5281]

So it is built on top of the reminiscence of hindu temple.

[@bhotla]

Sir, I kindly refer you to the book "Genesis of Time' written by Abhishek Singh which sheds fresh light on this topic. I appreciate all your videos and watch them with interest.

[@freshminds9229]

Praveen mohan proved it as a hindu structure

[@cyti007]

Don’t agree with your analysis, watch video of Chitra katha channel on Qutub minar for more information, please correct your mistake, you are credible voice