Prophet Muhammad (S) Married a 9 Years Old? Historical Analysis.

00:00 - Beginning
01:15 - Introduction
08:05 - Frequent use of "the Age of Aishah" to attack Islam
11:18 - Different ways Muslims approach this topic
14:50 - The authenticity of the hadith in question
15:50 - Hisham bin Urwa and the presence of multiple chains of this narration
27:35 - Age of Asma (the sister of Aishah)
32:15 - Absence of criticism pertaining to this marriage
40:20 - Orientalists on the age of Aishah
42:30 - Prideaux's book against the Prophet and no criticism on this issue
47:20 - Modern historians on marriages in pre-modern societies
1:09:35 - Age of consent in William Blackstone's "Commentaries on the English Law"
1:14:05 - Why is this issue raised today?
1:16:30 - Is it pedophilia?
1:22:00 - Summary
1:22:55 - Are we obliged to do it today?
Support our work: / adnanrashid
PayPal: [e-mail]
Follow Adnan Rashid on social media:
Facebook: / mradnanrashid
Twitter: / mradnanrashid
Contact: [e-mail]

[@MrAdnanRashid]

Please see some important links below for further information relevant to this topic: discover-the-truth.com/2013/09/09/age-of-consent-in-european-american-history/ www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-24976929 www.euronews.com/2017/09/02/which-eu-country-has-the-most-teenage-mothers www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2014/jul/08/lower-age-consent-14-1979-home-office-report www.nhs.uk/live-well/sexual-health/stages-of-puberty-what-happens-to-boys-and-girls/ islamqa.info/en/answers/124483/age-of-the-mother-of-the-believers-aaishah-may-allah-be-pleased-with-her-when-the-prophet-blessings-and-peace-of-allah-be-upon-him-married-her www.islamic-awareness.org/polemics/aishah.html yaqeeninstitute.org/faraz-malik/the-age-of-aisha-ra-rejecting-historical-revisionism-and-modernist-presumptions/#.XO6eJ9NKiRs Note: this lecture highlights the historical nuances as to the age of consent in medieval societies. Laws and social norms in medieval societies differed to ours. This lecture does not encourage marriage with younger females (of any particular age) in any shape or form. All listeners are advised to follow the law of the land in this regard.

[@SaqiUddin]

The Hadees are 100% authentic and the scientific method applied to ensure they are authentic is EXCEPTIONAL, and has never eve been done to a corpus before. Here Adnan Rashid tells us how Bukhari himself did not take hadees from this man who was deceiving his Donkey. Mashallah, this is the pinnacle of the Scientific method! Shame on Islamophobes!

[@siphors]

@@SaqiUddin Phobia: an extreme or irrational fear of or aversion to something. I don't question mohammed's integrity as a 'pattern of conduct', because I have any phobia towards him/islam. E.g I don't think people (some) were questioning president trump's conduct in office bcs they had some kind of phobia towards him. It's bcs whoever occupies that office is expected to behave in a certain way only.

[@sosdododo5653]

@@siphors you are nothing but a bunch of hater let me tell for your information the beloved prophet was gifted from God because he is a prophet not like us and aisha was very happy leaving with the prophet,its been hurt you while who was been married happy, what is your problem here you just wasting your time

[@davidalbert5425]

@@khalidrahmani6323 you seem the one who have little interest in understanding the Qur’an because you're too lazy to go through all the sources or to accept something that you don't like! Qur’an only followers never existed before they only popped up in the 20th century trying to throw all the scholarly works 14 century of scholarly work out the window! Farid al-bahraini will soon publish his book on the Qur’an only type of people, so I hope you will learn something new.

[@thetruthwithproof8802]

Please Note The Complete & Perfected islam told us 👉🏼 ``Whoever wears an amulet has committed shirk ( Masnud Ahmed 16969 ) WHY HAVE PE0PLE DECIDED TH0SE TAWEEZ WITH QURAN VERSES ARE NOT SHIRK ❓ As we know asking the Dead for help is SHIRK If l was to claim asking the dead for help is not SHIRK because this dead person is going to ask ALLAH to help us will PEOPLE agree with this ❓ WHEN PE0PLE ASK THE DEAD TO ASK ALLAH FOR HELP, THE PEOPLE CALL IT SHIRK WHEN PE0PLE USE A TAWEEZ TO ASK ALLAH TO HELP, WE DO NOT CALL IT SHIRK WHY D0 WE USE A DIFFERENT RULE F0R THE TAWEEZ ❓

[@BloggingTheology]

Brilliant! Thanks Adnan.

[@paynedv]

Look everyone it's Blundering Theology! You should become Christian Deo volente

[@just-some-muslim]

@@paynedv Look everyone it's keyboard warrior! You should become Muslim *inshallah*

[@wudafek8561]

@@paynedv lmao your triggered from a simple comment

[@davidalbert5425]

@Blogging Theology it would be great if you mention some of these quotes and important points by Adnan on your channel. God bless you!

[@sunnysleep7850]

Bacharino i bet u got really excited, dreaming of celestial bachabazi boys 👦

[@theDayOf]

I remember when I first became muslim, a friend right away mentioned the age of Aisha as the greatest problem in islam. I had no idea what to say then, but now it is clear and I will never, inshaAllah, fumble for words if this issue is brought up again.

[@redrobin2682]

Asselamu walleikum brother glad to see u learning from this beneficial lecture may Allah reward you

[@bennevis1956]

Aiesha ( ra) was married young probably age 12, but her marriage was not consummate until later, She Aisha ( ra) fought in battle this was at age 15+ , Also this is from hadith & not mentioned in Qur'an. We are also to believe that Jesus PBUH mother was married at around 12 years of age to Joseph. And Rebecca was married at 3? In Bible. King Richard married a 12 year old French princess. Of course it is not the norm nowadays. But there were several reasons why they did these in them days.

[@kf-ot6vw]

@@bennevis1956 yes, haven't yet watched the whole video but apparently girls back then matured early. The hard life of the desert and lifestyle caused girls to hit puberty early as opposed to now.

[@shaheedbhaghatsingh3974]

@@bennevis1956 U gullible M $ l m she was 6 when married to Mooohomod and the marriage was consumated when she was 9. Authentic sources like the hadiths prove this kid

[@shaheedbhaghatsingh3974]

U gullible M $ l m she was 6 when married to Mooohomod and the marriage was consumated when she was 9. Authentic sources like the hadiths prove this kid

[@jna21]

Watched this video already long ago,was thinking about rewatching it and BOOM,he uploaded it again Mashallah. What a coincidence.🤣

[@z_mystic]

Why are you spaming???

[@SaqiUddin]

The Hadees are 100% authentic and the scientific method applied to ensure they are authentic is EXCEPTIONAL, and has never eve been done to a corpus before. Here Adnan Rashid tells us how Bukhari himself did not take hadees from this man who was deceiving his Donkey. Mashallah, this is the pinnacle of the Scientific method! Shame on Islamophobes!

[@ohana_is_family]

@@SaqiUddin Adnan's use of the hadith to confirm that Aisha was 6 or 7 at marriage and 9 at consummation is correct. His method of trying to depict "The West" as marrying very young (at puberty) is vile propaganda without any basis. Objections against Muhammed having intercourse with a 9 year old are related to the risk of harm to the 9 year old over whom he had a duty of care. The fact that Sharia base itself on Muhammed's Example and set the minimum Consent to Marriage Age at 9, kept betrothal at any age with Option of Puberty with the ability to allow consummation preceding Option of Puberty is just legalized child-rape. Sadly some still promote these inhumane and cruel practices. Muslim Skeptic - kzbin.info/www/bejne/lXbPYmaPjdyFeq8 "what the practice really is of marryyi...of an older man marrying, or or having sex with this 9 year old and or 10 year old pre-pubescent girl." We are free to reject Muhammed and Islamic Law.

[@nanashi2146]

@@ohana_is_family "The fact that Sharia base itself on Muhammed's Example and set the minimum Consent to Marriage Age at 9" Prove the claim that the Shari'ah has codified this minimum consent law please

[@ohana_is_family]

@@nanashi2146 I cannot include links but BBC news Prdominantly Sunni Turkey "Turkish child marriage religious document sparks anger" Published 3 January 2018. "It said that, according to Islamic law, the beginning of adolescence for boys was the age of 12 and for girls the age of nine. On the same website, it said that whoever reached the age of adolescence had the right to marry.". In Shia Iran Irann news-wire site: The plight of Iran’s little brides - Report on child marriages Adena Nima by Adena Nima January 31, 2019 in Human Rights ""The so-called “child spouse” bill, introduced into parliament in 2016, proposed an absolute ban on the marriage of girls under age 13 and an absolute ban for the marriage of boys under 16 ….. Nourozi said that according to the sharia laws, Qom jurisprudence and Iranian and Lebanese experts, a girl goes into puberty at 9 years of age and can be considered as fit to marry...........................According to statistics ...............2014, 40,000 children married including 176 children who were under the age of 10." " Ascent to felicity is available in archive dot org. “after the age of adolescence.118” Note 118 That is, puberty. Legally, the minimum age of puberty for girls is nine lunar years (about eight years and nine months on the solar calendar) (Hadiyya 43; Maraqi 'l-Falah 1:200; Bada’i‘1:157). So , both Sunni and Shia islam have 9 lunar years as the Minimum age where a girl can consent to marriage.

[@TheMuslimApologist]

This topic has been beaten to the death and still Islamophobes will make a fuss out of it. BTW Rebekah was married off to Isaac when she was three years old, according to the Bible.

[@crossectionable]

I've always wondered about that. Can you give me the verse?

[@richman8082]

In Judaism batsheba had a child when she was 6. In Judaism the marriage at the age of 3 was possible.

[@ChimaAlaebo123]

@@richman8082 are these pedophiles the perfect example for mankind?

[@TheMuslimApologist]

@@crossectionable You can watch this explained here: kzbin.info/www/bejne/d4XNpn6GorFjldk

[@crossectionable]

@@TheMuslimApologist I was asking for the verse in the Bible. Can you give that to me?

[@drmuscles3129]

I am never apologize being a Muslim ... I am blessed .

[@arifmunshi6833]

But are you brave enough to wash your feet in the sink in a public toilets though???

[@drmuscles3129]

@@arifmunshi6833 can you explain what is your perpose to write this

[@arifmunshi6833]

@@drmuscles3129 it is called a joke!

[@17lobb]

Blessed? Lol what a joke. Allah is a lie my friend

[@commandar88]

@@17lobb my friend, why reject reality?

[@alirt4254]

Muhammed (pboh) is best human

[@abdulrahaman0157]

Pbuh

[@TheMedicalLad]

ﷺ

[@crossectionable]

That he is the best of the humans whom married a 6 year old and had s ex with her at 9 and married the wife of his adopted son? That leaves out the rest of us, doesn't it? So yeah.

[@instagramaccount96]

‎ﷺ

[@crossectionable]

@Borsalino Kizaru Brianna was 3 years old when she married the son of Knut lol

[@arifmunshi6833]

If Allah intends goodness for a person, He gives him the understanding of the religion. May Allah bless you and all the ummah with goodness.

[@apophenic_]

So Allah intends evil for those he doesn't provide understanding for? What a circular logc, completely mindless. Completely evil if from any other God, but from this one it's okay? No, those who already want to believe in Allah will regardless of logic. That's what you mean.

[@zaiedchaalali1939]

@@apophenic_ Allah knows who deserves guidance and in which moment is best to give it to his creation

[@nurizzatul2154]

@@apophenic_ Allah has already said in the Quran , if you don’t know something , ask the people who has those knowledge . 🥰 If you are not searching for knowledge , how can you blame Allah while Allah has already show the path . And Allah knows who deserves his guidance . Allah knows who are the ones seeking his path in getting ilmu /knowledge . Allah knows the intention . 🥰 Allah give human being choice in this world . He has shows his guidance and gave us the blessing of ‘prayer’ or ‘solat’ and ‘du’a’ to remember him . 5 times a day , in Fatihah we say “guide us to the straight path” . 🥰 Inshaa Allah ❤️

[@apophenic_]

@@nurizzatul2154 I already have. Now I know, and I know your God is a homicidal liar. Not even real, but an entity like a corporation that only exists in the minds of those benefitting from it, or those too ignorant to know they are being taken advantage of.

[@nurizzatul2154]

@@apophenic_ ?😅

[@DJ-Art-Morris]

MashaAllah tabarakAllah br. Adnan Rashid, JazakAllah khayr for shedding so much light on this subject. It’s very much needed. Shared with my people’s. BarakAllahu feek akhi.

[@muhammadfarooq5710]

Masha Allah, Adnan bai , an eyeopener conversation.

[@rbo3193]

I love adnan and think he’s brilliant for Islam this fella loves his faith ♥️ Im a protestant christian and can appreciate good muslims ♥️ keep it up brother and lots of love 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿✝️

[@bodmas5370]

Jazakumullahu Khairan for this wonderful work done!

[@odeebob7826]

May Allah reward you brother Adnan with the highest level in Jannah 🤲

[@That_Guy01]

SubhanAllah Ustaad. I love your video and benefit from them so much MaaShaAllah. I loved the video you made describing your life and journey; hearing you speak about that journey really helped me with my own personal life too MaaShaAllah so Jazakallah Ustaad for everything. May Allah reward and bless you and all your loved ones 🤲🏼Aameen ❤

[@gggsayian535]

Great video!

[@waqqaas]

May Allaah bless you brother Adnan with a long life with health and prosperity, ameen; we need you to continue with such content in order to de-colonize the mind of Muslims. JazaakAllaahu khairan and maashaaAllaah tabarakAllaah. To each and every single Muslim brother and sister who watched this, especially if you are young, consider adding this to a playlist, so that whenever someone insults Muhammad (SAW), we can, without showing our emotions, just forward this video to the ignorant and hateful.

[@Salman..777]

What a great presentation May Allah reward you

[@nebatabduyusuf9496]

Jezak Allahu kheir you all 🤲 May Allah reward you in this world and hereafter 🤲 such important and informative video. If you can upload it in part of also another set it will easily watch a lot of people. When it is longer a lot of us we don't finish it. Cuase this is very important for all Muslim to know. Jezak Allahu Khair

[@Harris.S]

Thanks my brother for the great. May Allah bless you and your family always ❤️

[@vito9072]

The problem is that the prophet Muhammad is supposed to be the Moral guide at all times for the entire humanity. In the same way, he revealed that 'alcohol' (which was actually wine since alcohol is a general term that encompasses different chemicals for different use such as methanol for surgical medicine) is banned or that femicide was banned as this was practiced at the time. So the argument that it was acceptable at the time and hence it is okay then one wonders why the prophet was correcting the behavior of the so-called Arab pagans. The Pagans could have told the 'prophet' that his new moral teachings were modernity at the time and dismiss the prophet as a liberal moralizer! Also, if no one told the prophet it was wrong that should not be an issue as it was the prophet who was the teacher and the one who was receiving the revelation from the creator and it was the duty of the prophet to correct their ways the same way he corrected them on the use of 'alcohol'. Finally, Adnan is completely dishonest in comparing the 'prophet of God' who had communication with the creator(who is said to have objective morality) to Victorian England people who had no revelation from the creator and had supposedly no objective moral guidance.

[@nessimbencheik8308]

For 1400 years he was never accused of pedophilia at the time by his detractaires (Jews and Christians or idolaters) Why?? History explains it by itself, as in the 11th century, the queen of Leon and Casille Urracque1 was married at the age of 8, Philippe Auguste II in the 12th century married Isabelle at the age of 10. Juana, Queen of Sicily, married William II at the age of eleven, the Princess of Navarre in the 13th century married the King of France Philip IV the Beautiful at 11 years old. In the 14th century Princess Isabelle de Valois married Calais Richard II was married at the age of 8, St Augustine married a girl aged 10. And the list is long. Moreover, why criticizes the prophet Muhammad PBUH when we know that the Virgin Mary was 12 yo married with Joseph the carpenter, 90 yo and Isaac 40 yo with rebecca between 3 and 10 yo according your biblical exegesis if you go to France now, there is no more age of consent since 2016. It is the judge who will decide the act of consent if there is an issue. This is why the french senate tried to legiferate for an of 13 yo. Why 13 yo? on what basis?

[@vito9072]

@@nessimbencheik8308 So you are comparing the rightly guided prophet of the creator of the universe to these people who are from Europe?! Prophet Muhammad according to Islam revealed the correct guidance and objective morality from Allah, supposedly the true creator of the universe. So if the prophet had objective morality, then how comes he continued the misguided practice of the Arab and other pagans and white European Christians? Is marrying a 9 year old Halal? Why did Adnan accept modern liberal morality today then criticize it has having no basis? Why the hypocrisy?

[@nessimbencheik8308]

@@vito9072 Adnan never accept the modern liberal moral. I think you have misunderstood. kings and queens mary at young age If a marriage is signed then the marriage is valid with the authorities and with God because they were above all Christians. Let's take the example of Urraque Ire de León. born in 1081 and married in 1090 with Raymond de Bourgogne (v.1059-1107), count of Galicia They had a first child named Sancho Alfónsez, born in 1093 So she was 9 when she married and was consummated at 12. If you want more example, don't hesitate.

[@vito9072]

@@nessimbencheik8308 You are missing the point completely, the prophet was being given the so called objective morality from the all wise and perfect creator. Why are you mentioning the names of misguided white people from Europe and placing them next to prophet Muhammad on equal terms. I thought Islam taught that the prophet was the best example for mankind to follow. Then how comes the likes of Urraque Ire de León are compared on an equal level to the prophet? What happened to the prophet revealing the correct path or way that believers should follow? Was European white men part of the correct guidance to humanity? This shows that the so called objective morality from Allah is completely fake news!

[@nessimbencheik8308]

@@vito9072 did queens and kings receiving the blessing from the pope or the church?

[@legend5735]

We love you adnan Keep em coming

[@SaqiUddin]

The Hadees are 100% authentic and the scientific method applied to ensure they are authentic is EXCEPTIONAL, and has never eve been done to a corpus before. Here Adnan Rashid tells us how Bukhari himself did not take hadees from this man who was deceiving his Donkey. Mashallah, this is the pinnacle of the Scientific method! Shame on Islamophobes!

[@nazuddin6346]

Masha Allah Jazzak Allah khair For clarifying brother May Allah bless you Ameen

[@ibrahim.ky_2]

thanks for the video My brother😊 this is something the enemies of islam use all the time... it makes me sad 😔

[@TarbiyaatNUF]

May Allah swt reward you for this one. Ameen

[@hibatuadam2777]

Very educating.

[@maalikserebryakov]

Now that you are educated answer for me : Is it Halal for a Man to Marry a prepubescent girl?

[@ABDULRHEEM-kr1kr]

Convey message of Islam to all people of the world and to everyone who will come also convey message of Islam to all world leaders

[@peacenow6618]

Jazakallahu Khayran Ahsanul Jaza

[@Muslim-og3vc]

good video, no watering down of the deen

[@Just_A_Stranger]

Lady Margaret Beaufort (Countess of Richmond and Derby), mother of Henry VII of England, married as a seven-year-old girl Queen Isabella of Valois, daughter of Charles VI of France, married Richard II of England as a second wife when she was six years old girl

[@crossectionable]

The problem with Muhammed is that he is a pattern of conduct for muslims.The people in the examples you mention were not and have never been patterns of conduct for anyone. You have to give some examples of people that is a pattern of conduct (like Jesus for example) , not just say "some random people in other cultures did it" so therefore it's ok that Muhammed did it too.

[@ambrosiamlinga8402]

@@crossectionable you said it better

[@DDDSSDDDSSDDDSS]

@@crossectionable xtians say that God overshadowed and impregnated Mary at 12 years old... Talk about role model.

[@TakeQQQ]

@@crossectionable Did Jesus peace be upon him marry then, that your trying to compare him with Muhammed peace be upon him?

[@dr.monoarhossain6586]

@@crossectionable what a crook you are!

[@freeman7983]

Masha ALLAH good work

[@tiloshah4778]

Brother Adnaan , please make more videos like this discussing other topics with the lenses of truth

[@dr.monoarhossain6586]

Thanks, vai. Allah bless you.

[@TetrahedronIX]

Wow, Jesus or Muhammad. Reflect on your life at this point. Islam is a religion that centers around a man. You are watching a youtube video by a Islamic scholar who is having to explain your Prophet did marry a 6yr and consummated the marriage at 9yr according to the most authentic and trusted hadith. The quran is a compilation of jewish midrish, Nontrinitarian Christian Syric text from the 6th and 7th century. This is why the Quran is largely incomprehensible. Some of the same stories found in the Quran can be found in Syriac lectionaries used in Christian churches of Syria of that time and fully explained in larger detail. Other verses of the Quran are sermons from various Jewish and Christian sects of the time whom held different beliefs. This explains why the Quran is so contradictory, vague and out of context. Ironically the word Quran means "recitation" and contains various "recitations" from Jewish and Christian lectionaries written in Aramaic-Arabic hybrid language by nontrinitarian Arabic Christians who spoke Arabic but could write in Aramaic. Futhermore the Quran is about Jesus not Prophet Mohammad as "Mohammad" was a title for Jesus used by Arabic Christians at the time meaning "the praised one". There are 34 mentions of Jesus in the Qur'an and the name "Muhammad" is mentioned four times in the Quran. Think about it a lectionary (collection of recitations) by Arabic Christians would have included verses like John 14:16 "and I will pray to God that he will send another comforter whose title will be ((Praised One)) or Comforter or Counselor" (( Praised one)) in Arabic would be Ahmad or Muhammad), but these are not names they are titles describing Jesus. Islam is truly the Sunna of some guy named Muhammad which was written 200 years after the Quran, but the Quran is about Jesus he is truly the most praised and worthy of praise. He truly is the best example for all mankind, for he did no sin. He didn't have 9 wives, he was not a war monger and did not die of poison or sickness but gave his life as sacrifice for all mankind. Jesus is Mohammad(most worthy to be praised) and Jesus is Immanuel( God with us). Look at Matthew 1:23 ("they shall call his name Emmanuel") provides the name 'Emmanuel' (meaning God is with us). The verse says "They called his name" this doesn't mean another Prophet is coming named "Emmanuel" this means they called Jesus a title "Emmanuel" meaning (God is with us). They also called him "Ahmed" or Muhammad" for He is worthy to be praised. Jesus is waiting for you.

[@Kimeikus]

When you explain it to them, they usually respond in these two ways: *”Why does it matter if it was normal back then?”* Because the critics want to portray the Prophet (ﷺ) as a sexually deviant person. But if the Prophet (ﷺ) was just doing what everyone else did, he is not a sexually deviant person. By asking this question, they have effectively shifted the goalpost because they first try to argue that the Prophet (ﷺ) is deviant, and then they switch up their argument once you show them that it was normal back then. *”Why couldn’t Allah just inform the Prophet that it was harmful?“* Because the practice was not harmful given the circumstances they lived in. There’s a hidden premise that previous societies were just dumb (morally) and that we became smarter. There’s another hidden premise that 21st century Liberal norms are the pinnacle of human society. Not true. Go take an anthropology class. People adapted to their situation and they knew what was best for them. If you really believe that hundreds of thousands of “little girls” were left traumatized by millions of “perverted men”, then your understanding of history is quite flawed.

[@petternordberg2883]

Have not heard anyone say that we have reached the pinnacle of human society. Again, just because something was the norm, doesnt make it ethical, people went along with the norms considered right by the majority. I promise you that when little girls were married away in the past, they cried. When grown men went to bed with them, they cried. If a young child cries as you attempt to 'lay' with her, you are a unethical perverse piece of garbage

[@alearner2748]

@@petternordberg2883 buy what if the child when become an adult states that the one who she was married to was the best of mans and there was no other one better than him?

[@petternordberg2883]

@@alearner2748 How would she know that there was no one else better? (That goes for all people in long term relationships ofcourse)

[@davidalbert5425]

@@alearner2748 she was already an adult when the marriage was consummated, just like Adnan quoted from the early critics of Islam from their own Anti-Islamic books that she was physically and psychologically mature because of fast biological development at that time in hot 7th-century desert. Also the prophet (s.a.w) said "there should be no harm".

[@alearner2748]

@@davidalbert5425 yeah if she was oppressed then she wouldn't became a scholar and couldn't led an army you understand what will be a mindset of an person if towards someone who oppressed them these people are clowns

[@daroulsalamsikasso3477]

Thanks ustaze Adnan,I watched many dawa related on this topic,never satisfied until now.your explaination convinced me.i knew the hadith which Aïcha said she was 9 was truth because its is in Bukhari but how to understand it and explain it to christians when debating with them.i really understand now .may Allah rewards you. I'll also appreciate you to put often the links in the description of books you quoted ,it allows us to get the books.thanks

[@hamidtahri1765]

Absolutely shocking informations .thanks brother adnan

[@MohamedShou]

May Allah rewards Adnan Rashid immensely for his hard work and research on this topic and making us benefit from it

[@haikalrees9975]

There has certainly been for you in the Messenger of Allah an excellent pattern for anyone whose hope is in Allah and the Last Day and [who] remembers Allah often. Quran , chapter 33 , verse 21

[@maalikserebryakov]

Doesnt this verse mean its halal to marry a child for us because the Prophet did it

[@haikalrees9975]

There has certainly come to you a Messenger from among yourselves. Grievous to him is what you suffer; [he is] concerned over you and to the believers is kind and merciful. Quran , chapter 9 , verse 128

[@haikalrees9975]

@@maalikserebryakov what do you understand by reading this verse ? go and kill everyone ? why dont, you post the verse before this verse and the verse after this verse ? and see if it is what it is 🙂

[@denzo_dridz8923]

Salam wa Alaikom Adnan. Why was there a Israeli advert before the video started?

[@bintehaider5288]

Jazakallah o khairen kaseera

[@JamesCameron881]

At That Time No One Objected To The Marriage Of Prophet Mohammad [Saw] Ordinary Every Era Is Not The Same Every Era Has Some Changes

[@philipcoriolis6614]

But it was done by a man who is allegedly a role model for all times.

[@rafayshakeel4812]

@@philipcoriolis6614 People use to wipe their butts with stones in the 7th century. Would you also like us to do that, mate? Did the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) command us to marry 9-year-olds? I'm an Orthodox Muslim, I don't sugar coat my religion. In Islam, the age of marriage is not fixed. However, in the West, we've a number [18], which apparently turns people into mature adults. We don't have an issue with this number or any other law of the land, as long as it doesn't go against the teachings of Islam. In my humble opinion, the number 18 is an arbitrary number for classifying people as mature adults. Next time, don't speak without knowledge.

[@philipcoriolis6614]

@@rafayshakeel4812 Come on. We know that some scholars have allowed this kind of marriage based on the model's behavior in this century.

[@rafayshakeel4812]

@@philipcoriolis6614 I'm not aware of those 'scholars.' You need to understand a basic principle, mate! Aisha (RA) was not a kid. She went to war, she became one of the biggest scholars of Islam, etc... Even at the time of marriage, she was not a kid. An adult by definition is someone who has been through puberty and is physically and mentally mature. This is standard.

[@nurizzatul2154]

@@philipcoriolis6614 kzbin.info/www/bejne/nWqoh5WeaL59mq8 😊

[@khudabuxtalpur9103]

MASHA ALLAH

[@norzin99]

Appreciate it

[@sm743]

Salam ustadh I have a question in the sahih bukhari hadith what does 'betrothed' at 6 mean? is that nikkah or is that a cultural form on engagement of the community? does this have any implications for the possible ways to conduct muslim marriages within the shariah? jzk khair

[@AE86FTS]

I am no expert so take what I say with a grain of salt. From my understanding, 6 was when the marriage was initially proposed.

[@erikahammerramalho1025]

I definitely respect Adnan Rashid , I think his view on this and the evidence makes a lot of sense but I do think that it is worth questioning a few aspects that don't make sense ,one of these is that there is a hadith that from my limited knowledge and memory about this,by calculating the age and time would mean that Aisha was explaining speaking at the age of 3 years old in detail about complex concepts and events having deep understanding and awareness about the events surrounding her that are impossible for a 3 year old to even grasp and have even an understanding of let alone being able to explain it. This makes ni living sense and it's important to know that un the time of the Prophet Muhammad people in that society and mist parts of the world did not celebrate birthdays and follow and count their age closely at all many people had no idea of what their real age was and many who had some vague idea but it would be an a vague guess and it would be very inaccurate,even today I you go to third world countries you will still see that many people don't know their real age accurately,they don't follow their age accurately or celebrate birthdays every year to mark it an follow ,they don't know the exact year they were born and this is still going on today ,what do you then think about 1400 years ago at the time 9f the Prophet in the middle of a desert were the majority of people were illiterate? This is just a fact and It makes it very likely that Aisha and those around her were only guessing yheri age , or could be many years off from her real age and coupled with the hadith that from memory I think is weak hadiths had may Allah forgive me if I'm wrong about this ,but hadith that are weaker and when calculating would have Aisha explained complex events around her at the age of years old, this with the hadirhs being weaker and coupled with logic and what we know about the ability of a 3 years old doesn't make sense ,I don't have the hadirh number to reference unfortunately qt this moment but I will come back once I have found it.

[@ZakariahSH]

Two Islamic scholars are my favorite in the modern world. Dr. Ali Ataie and Ustad Adnan Rashid.

[@peacenow6618]

May Allah Accept your works, and make it a means of acceptance and Guidance for the Ummah!

[@abidaobali9075]

Jazak allaho gairen brother

[@hibatuadam2777]

Brilliantly done

[@takiyaazrin7562]

CNN witnesses Afghan marriage with 9-year-old kzbin.info/www/bejne/m2SmaZqoerNlfM0

[@Just_A_Stranger]

jazakumullah khairan

[@alberxenos]

السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته’ As-Salāmu `Alaykum wa Raħmatullāhi wa Barakātuhu

[@hadiyahabib7990]

jazakAllah. words can not describe how thoroughly you explained it all. it cleared up a lot things and makes us able to refute the claims of anti Islam people. may Allah bless you abundantly in this world and the hereafter .

[@nurizzatul2154]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/aZy0lWeOj5h4jM0 this also ❤️✨ Its basically the history people of the past . globally . 🥰

[@africanprophet4039]

How come he didn't mention Surah65:4 which instructs Muslims to divorce prepubescent children whom would not have menstruated yet and that Aisha was still playing with dolls which is haram but she was allowed because she had not reached the age of puberty. Come on man, you are smarter than this.

[@nurizzatul2154]

@@africanprophet4039 If you want to use that argument According to your imagination , The question is What Aisha says About prophet Muhammad ? 😅 Even When prophet Muhammad remembering Khadeejah and treating Khadijah’s family very well , Aisha was jealous . 😅 Aisha is one of the scholars in Islam and Our mothers of believers . 😅 How prophet treat all his wifes And Aisha and all are really kind and love with respect . Aisha told us a lot about prophet muhammad , how he treat woman and the community , how he walk , how the community re-acted with him , how he being fair to all his wifes , In those age , before Islam came , even the baby girl are burried without no reasons . At those time , People were embarassed If they got baby girl . Woman treated as a slaves , no rights , nothing . After Islam came , Islam bring all those rights including Mahr , inheritance , property and all , which those things does not parallel in the 7 century . 😅 Marriage is a blessing at those time . Woman right are highly important and woman are protected . Dr Garry Wills . kzbin.info/www/bejne/jZmse4tvZ7SppJI Imagine you are talking about Aisha , while Aisha are teaching us about how prophet’s Muhammad sunnah in daily life , how he help his wifes , sewing his Clothes , helping the community . He treat his daughter like a princess , He teach people how to treat woman with respect . He is knows as “the trustworthy ones” since he was young , His own enemy , abu jahal and all those people at that time call him that too . At those ages too , to see a man with that trust , good character is hard . Khadeejah , our mother , are the ones who propose to the prophet Muhammad when he was young because of his character and kindness to all people including the orphan and all people . We know his history through lectures , we dont assume or use imagination or assumption , but learn the whole things . 🥺❤️ their love story and struggle during the persecution of Muslim and those time in our remembrance . We always said to the non Muslim , If you want to read the Quran , read all , dont pick one verses , but read side by side with history . This is the most verses that Islamaphobes loves to use , while Prof Juan Cole explain the verses side by side with history in universities . kzbin.info/www/bejne/ppDOpp6of5yapac In the ages of no one care about woman , he teach ““The best among the believers is he whose character is the best. And the best among you is the one who is best to his wife” Aisha had an important role in early Islamic history, both during prophet Muhammad's life and after his death. In Sunni tradition, Aisha is portrayed as scholarly and inquisitive. She contributed to the spread of Muhammad's message and served the Muslim community for 44 years after his death.She is also known for narrating 2,210 hadiths,not just on matters related to Muhammad's private life, but also on topics such as inheritance, pilgrimage, and eschatology.Her intellect and knowledge in various subjects, including poetry and medicine, were highly praised by early luminaries such as al-Zuhri and her student Urwa ibn al-Zubayr. (Research about this) While non Muslim are critics the prophet without knowledge , Aisha are scholars in Islam , the ones who teling us how prophets Muhammad activities , how he put his eyes down and how he treat woman , Aisha is the one who companion refer too to ask a question , respected , and teach us about prophet Muhammad daily life . She was inteligent and wise . Her memory are Strong which makes she as a great scholars in Islam . Her attributionns in islamic history are important . Including lead the army during the conflict of Ali . She was brave . I mean what those century looks like . People globally . Thats why you need to learn those century . kzbin.info/www/bejne/aZy0lWeOj5h4jM0 . This is west in 19 century ages of puberty and those who lived at those time , biblical times , and so many more . This is custom in 7 century looks like kzbin.info/www/bejne/nWqoh5WeaL59mq8 from yaqeen institution . You can see in your religion yourself , at what ages Virgin mary married joseph or Rebecca and isac . Or people at those biblical times . Or you can learn the custom or situation at those time . But not using imagination , but education . You are christian , search in the Google about the “the covenant prophet Muhammad to christian” and his last speech . There is lots christian who has travel to the middle ease to see the reality rather than media . Their hospitality was amazing . The people there was amazing . Eventhough Im asian , i said that all the bloggers who travel there really open my eyes and mind . See all people as a human . Hear their stories , dont generalize all people as the same . Thank you .

[@africanprophet4039]

@@nurizzatul2154 So you did not respond to what I said. Aisha said she not seen any woman suffer as much as the believing women. Muhammad threatened to divorce his wives in the Quran, he also forbade anyone to marry them after him, they surely obey due to fear but the haddiths of Aisha expose Muhammad and Islam. She told us how a goat ate the Quran now there are some missing verses.

[@nurizzatul2154]

@@africanprophet4039 I agree with you that believing woman suffer so much at those time of persecution . Sumaiyyah and his family , wife of pharoah , Fatimah his daughter who see his father being persecuted by the maccan pagan at those timekzbin.info/www/bejne/pYnMYaunm851nM0 , Younger sister of Umar being slaped when Umar knows he received Islam *before Umar accept Islam . Bilal bin rabah , the most tortured persecution happened to him. whats more ? Bring the Hadith here about that Aisha said about that believing woman . And lets read the context . Whats more ? Do you want me to share “what Aisha means of believing woman struggle at those time “? How much peace treaty being Broken by the maccan pagans ? Those video i have you give you is about the verses by verses side by side with history by prof Juan Cole . Hear first , learm first , not assuming . If you want to learn about him , go to “yaqeen institute ” . There is Thousand of Hadith there explained everything . His daughter, all his family , all story . Go there learn and then speak . You love to attack Hadith , why dont learn all the Hadith and the history of people at the past ? Imagination ? Learn all situation . Not see one , and then dont have any idea and judge prophet. History first , then you can understand what Our mothers says . This is the most basic things . kzbin.info/www/bejne/ppDOpp6of5yapac If you ask again without seeing this video first , then go to “yaqeen institute” learn all the stories about the believing woman and prophets family , all of them and their story . Not imagination . You forget Quran being memorized by thousands of prophet Muhammad companion at that time . Throughout history until now , millions remember word by word . Someone write then eaten by goat , while through those time , there is lots people who have already memorized and hearing and memorize Al Quran With Prophet Muhammad in live . Whoever write It at those time , its up to them . But companion and all the memorizer has already memorize It . Whats the problem ? This is the problem when you know nothing about those time , and interpret Hadith using your own mind . If you want to learn , learn all his Hadith , all his life , how he treat all . Learn not imagine . Dont forget the work of Khaliph Uthman and companions and all the memorizers and the people at that time who manage It with a strict prosedure just to make sure the autenticity . Since those day , all people use one book /compilation in Quran as reference and It ease everyone until now . Thank you so much for Khaliph Uthman and other companions for the great job.

[@abdallaMoa]

Ustaad Adnan, Allaha ku barakeeyo.

[@SaqiUddin]

The Hadees are 100% authentic and the scientific method applied to ensure they are authentic is EXCEPTIONAL, and has never eve been done to a corpus before. Here Adnan Rashid tells us how Bukhari himself did not take hadees from this man who was deceiving his Donkey. Mashallah, this is the pinnacle of the Scientific method! Shame on Islamophobes!

[@mdsaief7880]

A good presentations altogether

[@ohana_is_family]

The only good is the confirmation of 6 at marriage 9at consummation. The rest is just misrepresentation and lies. No "Historical Analysis" of 19th c English Marriage Ages can overlook The European Marriage Pattern, great historians (Hajnla, Laslett) and the published marriage statistics by the government. The reason Adnan uses Jeremy Rifkin and "discover the truth" is because he is misrepresenting history. All historians contradict his nonsense.

[@mdsaief7880]

Don’t need to be so desperate, I know embracing the truth is not easy.

[@ohana_is_family]

@@mdsaief7880 I embraced the truth that Allah could not have wanted child-marriage and the Quran is not frm Allah. You're welcome to join, but believe what you want.

[@mdsaief7880]

Thousand year ago it was norm you can not apply 21st centuries law and about the Quran, Quran is sufficient for, It's self

[@ohana_is_family]

@@mdsaief7880 250 years before Muhammed the Romans set a marriage age at 12 after doctor Soranus wrote that early marriage was unhealthy. The Persian Empire prohibited consummation under the age of 12 and the Byzantine Empire had a marriage age of 13 and would prosecute Statutory Rape. Since Option of Puberty implies awareness of the morally probelmeatic nature of absence of consent, the question arises: why did Muhammed risk the life of e 9 year old girl after doctors had wanred against it and the neighbours had legislated against it? And why should we accept him as a "perfect example to follow"? The anachronism using antiquity standards was Muhammed.

[@yinkasly7376]

@adnan rashid. Please brother Adnan. It will be great to write this as an article. It will really help Muslims and non muslims on this topic write it in article and share the link brother.

[@user-ln1it2yj2z]

Masha Allah

[@Tazkia-Tasawwuf]

May thousands of your like be brought forth in the ummah.

[@joyphillips1821]

Isaiah 5: 20 Woe unto them that call evil good, and good evil; that put darkness for light, and light for darkness; that put bitter for sweet, and sweet for bitter!

[@deechonada]

mary was 12

[@komujimaru]

allah is the best of the deceivers Sura 3: 54 And he permits Muslims to do taqiyya sura 16: 106 open your minds people

[@ZiIIous]

@@komujimaru It doesn't say best of deceivers, it is best of planners. The word مكر in the Quran is consistently used that way. Literally not a single Quran translation wrote "deceiver". Taqiyya is a Shia concept.

[@anonymousperson331]

IT IS FRIDAY PLEASE RECITE SURAH KAHF.

[@HQ93]

May Allah swt bless you

[@user-yk5by3uc2b]

Mashallah brother Adnan driving away the flies

[@commandar88]

@@AS-ti6qf do you know how sunnah works or you have a simple minded understanding of it?

[@commandar88]

@@AS-ti6qf even today in a secular liberal society like USA, a child can get married. You being against it doesnt automatically make it right or wrong. It's just your opinion

[@commandar88]

@@AS-ti6qf sunnah is based on principles, not simply actions. For example, he married a widow, doesn't means everyone has to marry a widow. Do you know what fard is? Now, what you seem to have a problem exists today in liberal secular societies so you not like it is a blip to Islam. Lastly, you giving your subjective opinion isn't anything of value. Opinion is like farts, everyone has them and let's one rip

[@commandar88]

@@AS-ti6qf you applying your own sense of what sunnah is what's problematic. That's just you making a fool of yourself. You applying your subjective morality assuming others agree with you in Islam is also delusional. What you should do is focus on yourself and question why morals should have any intrinsic value to begin with

[@commandar88]

@@AS-ti6qf again, you are assuming your opinion to be valid when it's based on a false premise and no grounding. It's okay for you to voice your opinion but every opinion should be critiqued or else it won't hold for too long

[@izhaansyed8037]

1:26:20 Can someone get me this hadith brother Adnan is talking about?

[@izhaansyed8037]

@@wandering8003 Jazakhallah Khair!

[@komujimaru]

allah is the best of the deceivers Sura 3: 54 And he permits Muslims to do taqiyya sura 16: 106 open your minds people

[@SteveSmith-wh6wu]

About @1:16:00 Asks about a book, here is some Shakespeare where Juliet's father says she is too young to get married he knows marriage and pregnancy would be harmful for a child physically and mentally. "CAPULET But saying o'er what I have said before. My child is yet a stranger in the world. She hath not seen the change of fourteen years. Let two more summers wither in their pride Ere we may think her ripe to be a bride." This is not about laws and public opinion. This is about the unconscionable physical and psychological harm done to a child by child marriage and the fact that a child's brain is not developed enough to be able to understand such things and consent to them. In the same way we now know slavery was and is always wrong regardless of the laws, the public opinion and the time in history. We now know child marriage was and is always wrong regardless of the laws, the public opinion and the time in history. Aisha never had a child and some physical harm caused by 'consummating' a marriage with a little girl of only 9 years old and all the wrongs against Aisha that followed this are a likely explanation for her lack of children. If you want a person to be revered as a prophet, the perfect man and an example for all people from that point on. This 'prophet' must be judged by the highest moral standards available not the flawed standards of the time they lived in.

[@scaryjoker]

Pure conjecture. Opinion invalidated.

[@amandadarkwood535]

Thank you!!!!

[@NAZAR786100]

Please show the audience/listeners/spectators then and there.. !

[@razor-xn2ve]

Few more additions from my side in indian context: 1. Rabindranath Tagore the Nobel prize winner for india married a nine year old girl 2. India's celebrated mathematician , ramunujan was married to 11 year old while being 22 3. Amitov Ghosh another spritual figure in india married 13. Just Google these , you will get them from Wikipedia and other resources. More can be said ..., May Allah open the hearts of those who seek truth.

[@mohamedamineboudheb4390]

As always when I lesten to Adnan Rachid, afterwards I sleep less stupid

[@aamanaf2203]

Mashallah..brother adnan da'wah to provide understanding to most ignorant muslim and non believer. May Allah bless Brother Adnan with good health and continue to give da'wah.

[@jimblack8104]

Gay marriage is legal in America. Is this acceptable for you? Or is this wrong? Just because marrying a child in America is legal is doesn’t make it correct

[@commandar88]

@@jimblack8104 who decides whats correct and whats not? Your God?

[@jimblack8104]

@@commandar88 would you bed a 9 year old? Yes or no

[@p4kd012]

@@jimblack8104 Yes, I'm not ashamed of it. You have problem with it. .

[@aamanaf2203]

@@jimblack8104 If a person has reached puberty according to holy scripture is permissible hence a 9 year old as adolescent (reach puberty) and consent from parents/ guardian and the person with proper legal marriage. I don't think is wrong..compare to nowadays young boys and girls having sex freely and irresponsible of their action ... lead to abortion etc... Gay action is not permissable according to holy scripture and uphold the law hence i will not support it, however people who has inclination toward same sex is not a sin as long as it is not act upon it.

[@WasifHasassin47Khan]

I would definitely like to have a discussion/debate with this person. I think that his perspective is glued to the max that the hadiths are infallible and can prove that nothing is greater than the book of Allah or equivalent to it. Let me know when we can have a talk.

[@watch13famouspeoplewhoacce45]

Adnan Rashid 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

[@yusufk5298]

Very enlightening and thought provoking at a time when its fashionable for muslims to try and show that Hazrat Ayshas age at marriage was much greater than 9.

[@maalikserebryakov]

It was at 6 or seven, not 9.

[@yusufk5298]

@Artizz the term was invented in modern times. It didnt exist in Europe until the age of consent was raised in europe and america to 16, 18 etc being half that for centuries. This means europe and america were all paedophiles

[@sydhassan5245]

"we have become the most bookless persons" honestly Is true even i want to read books but i have no idea what to read (islamic), any suggestions?

[@ohana_is_family]

Read C Baugh "Minor Marriage in Early Islamic Law" Read Thanvi's Jewels in Paradise aka Heavenly Ornaments

[@bobnordstrom5944]

Read all of Robert Spencer 's books

[@ohana_is_family]

@@bobnordstrom5944 :-) Promoting critical thinking. ....

[@bobnordstrom5944]

Read all the books by EX Muslims Ayaan Hersi Ali Read the Bible and find the truth .

[@AM-iz2dg]

Humiliating refutation of the critics of Islam. Jazak'Allah khairan Ustad.

[@FT-827-]

Adnan brother i heard that the arabs at the time of our Prophet saw. Count the age of the Girls when they had their First Periode.. like for example when a girl got her Periode with 8 years old she would be 10 years old when she is 18. Is that right? Sorry for my english im from germany

[@DisturbedWraith]

She was 17 or 19. And Allah knows Best

[@alsolmo8993]

Where can I find that? Hadiths tells us that she was 6 years old when he married her. 9 when he consummated the marriage, and remained with him for nine years. You said 19? Then Muhammad had been dead for two years already. Should we not go by Sahih hadiths?

[@maalikserebryakov]

Ibn Kathir said: His statement: ‘He married with Aisha when she was six, thereafter consummating the marriage with her when she was nine’ *is not disputed by anyone* and is well established in the Sahih and elsewhere *[ Sirah Nubula 2/146 ]*

[@DisturbedWraith]

@@maalikserebryakov kzbin.info/www/bejne/ZmTFamp9isaWpq8

[@belkairsaiefeddine4944]

Can you do translation to Arabic

[@fatmaaldegham861]

ممكن ترجمة

[@nsayyed5469]

i saw 12 or 11 year old bride ,in my school i was in 6th grade and she was our classmate she was hindu her parents decided and i saw she was very happy too and my teacher was ok with it just because of they are discussing it in class room we know about it.

[@EliasRykart]

Was her husband also 40 years older than her?🤢

[@mansurhallaj8568]

Don't compare an act of a common man and a prophet of God.

[@takiyaazrin7562]

@@mansurhallaj8568 CNN witnesses Afghan marriage with 9-year-old kzbin.info/www/bejne/m2SmaZqoerNlfM0

[@naqib_313]

Rabindranath Tagore married 9 years old girl.

[@worshipperofallah1]

islamophobes will never Attack Rabindranath Tagore because they don't hate Rabindranath Tagore islamophobes only hate Muhammad (SAW) so they will only Attack our prophet(pbuh).

[@sach11234]

Yes, prophet Tagore was far better than mhd and its a fact....by the way mhd married aisha when she was 6. That was said by ur own mother of believers, Aisha.....😊

[@naqib_313]

@@sach11234Marrying & cohabiting are not similar dude.

[@worshipperofallah1]

There are So many famous people in human history who Married 8 or 9 or 10 or 12 or 13 years old girls, why don't islam haters Attack them. These people are Biased, partial, inconsistent and Hypocrites.

[@sach11234]

@@naqib_313 I know dude there is no marriage in islam but only contracts. But just for your info from ur own hadith...... Sahih Muslim 1422b Allah's Apostle (ﷺ) married me when I was six years old, and I was admitted to his house when I was nine years old. Who is speaking?

[@doc.2011]

To believe and follow the hadith is part of religion and without that a Muslim cannot be a Muslim. This is clear and straightforward

[@hatemelrai4931]

ترجم للعربيه رجاء .. و جزاك الله خيرا ..

[@NeoLegendX]

People jump the gun on this like crazy. It's all about time periods. Norms, convenience

[@philipcoriolis6614]

But it was done by a man who is allegedly a role model for all times.

[@NeoLegendX]

@@philipcoriolis6614 so? its not like this has disappeared because of some new woke care or all reasonable argument.

[@nurizzatul2154]

@@philipcoriolis6614 kzbin.info/www/bejne/aZy0lWeOj5h4jM0 This is from history of the 7 century , west in 19 century , and a lot . It’s basically “history people of the past” . From historian studies in university and many Quotes of judges in west and both side also . We Muslim understand the people at those biblical times too . So for what others attacking prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) ? Isaac and rebecca marriage at what ages ? What about Virgin Mary and Joseph according to their religion ? What about the people in the biblical times ? Some custom has the reason According the situation at those time . * about 7 century custom , here are the situation Yaqeen institute : kzbin.info/www/bejne/nWqoh5WeaL59mq8

[@commandar88]

@@philipcoriolis6614 im glad you accept prophet Muhammad ❤

[@philipcoriolis6614]

@@commandar88 Why would you be glad I were to accept prophet Muhammad ? Why would you care ?

[@justinshadrach829]

The legal age during the 18th century was 12 for Girls and 14 for boys. Juliet was 13 yeah and Romeo is thought to be a teenager also! Not 50+ In over a decade of tracing ancestry back to the 16th century in UK. 99% of the marriage records I've looked at are of late teens plus. The argument that is was normal is dumb for one the money people would marry off into wealthy families for elitist reasons. Hence your qoute about Heiresses being married as young as 6. Alot of the writers you referred to probably moved in those elitist circles too and so thought it was normal. But in the working class families a 9yr old married to a 50+ was not normal. The average age of marriage in the 18th century was mid twenties. You have academics reporting on

[@arifmunshi6833]

He's not saying that young brides were the norm he saying that the legal age was low and there was nothing wrong with it at the time. Not many people may have taken advantage of it but it wasn't frowned upon like it is today.

[@justinshadrach829]

@@arifmunshi6833 And even more so to prove he's trying to present it as something of the past. Well why has Saudi only just banned child marriages and raised the age to 18 in 2019?

[@arifmunshi6833]

@@justinshadrach829 that's because Saudi is not a country following the Sharia. It's Muslim majority country but it's Western aspirations have made it a lot more liberal.

[@justinshadrach829]

@@arifmunshi6833 Exactly your prooving my point. Whilst Adnan is saying it was normal in Mohammeds time...me and you know that as the best example among men, Mohammeds example dictates aspects of sharia for all time. So whereas the west has grown to defend the right of the young and ensure children are not taken advantage off, are you saying its wrong because it goes against mohammed?. True Liberals in the west have been behind sexual freedom, LGBT, dropping the age of consent, dismissing the importance of marriage etc. Raising the age is not a consequence of Liberalism in the west. In early Christianity, the Romans practiced exposure (leaving unwanted babies out in nature to die) The Christians didn't comply they rescued the babies. Just because something is culturally accepted doesn't mean its OK. Allah said Mohammed could basically have any women he wanted.

[@arifmunshi6833]

@@justinshadrach829 they are not right because of the fact that Muhammed did not say you must get married when you are 9 to the contrary he married his first wife who was almost double his age. The fact remains there may come a time where the life expectancy is low (war, disease or famine) and we need the population to grow. The question would then be what's the earliest possible time girls can get married the answer is puberty. Also the fact that you say the West has protected women's rights is totally false. There are young people who would like to get married early and by raising the age the West is suppressing their right. What ends up happening is what we see in British schools today where young boys and young girls want to 'try' things out and are at it like they're on the discovery channel.

[@tefaalmsry3171]

hello my brother in Islam, I know that you are a very good historian, and there is a thought that comes into my mind, it's not very important but I can't get rid of it, it's about a historical work about fashion in the Islamic civilization and its effect and connection on the Western Civilization, it is a small thing but I hope there is such a work, so everyone knows how much the Islamic civilization affected the world even in that level, to teach the people how to dress.

[@ohana_is_family]

Muslim Apologist Jonathan Brown: wrote in "Misquoting Muhammed" "Britain and, to a lesser extent, most of northwest Europe differed from the pre-modern pattern of early marriage. Marriage age tended to be later, in the mid-twenties. In England, available data suggest that this was the case as far back as the fourteenth century." and `"Law was an imperial export. The mission to rescue ‘native’ women from their backward cultures was a prominent theme in British portrayals of the empire’s colonial activities. In the late 1800s and early 1900s Britain moved to bring marriage customs in India into line with her imperial values, and a series of laws introduced age restrictions for Hindu and Muslim girls marrying." The above used fragements are quoted on the wiki of the islam subreddit about child-marriage/consent. Jonathan Brown confirms the European Marriage Pattern as marrying in the mid twentise since the 1400s and is completely contardicted by Adnan who claims: 31:56 !people before 1900 for them a 10 years old bride was normal a seven years old bride was normal" 39:02 "it was normal for them they could imagine a 10 years old bride they could imagine a nine and eight years old bride they could you cannot if you went to a wedding today as you've all testified right if you ready if you went to a wedding today but if you are alive in the nineteenth century no problem" Adnan is blatantly misrepresenting history.

[@tefaalmsry3171]

@@ohana_is_family I don't know what are you responding to, but this video kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z5y0lnpshNSFl9k has a lot of academic references I recommend watching

[@ohana_is_family]

@@tefaalmsry3171 I was responding to your claim that he discusses history as a historian. He does not If he was a historian he would discuss the mean age of first marriage and he would discuss major historians about the USA and UK and Europe's demographics (John Hajnal, Peter Laslett). He would also show Marriage Age statistics which were collected and published by teh brits since 1836. All show the European Marriage pattern with a mean age of first marriage in the mid twenties. All show that therre was a major gap between puberty and mean age of marriage because puberty was not relevant for the decision to marry. I watched your video. Paul recently had Jonathan Brown on his channel and Jonathan Brown's 'MisQuoting Muhammed" is mentioned in the wiki on child-marriage of the islam subreddit. "Britain and, to a lesser extent, most of northwest Europe differed from the pre-modern pattern of early marriage. Marriage age tended to be later, in the mid-twenties. In England, available data suggest that this was the case as far back as the fourteenth century." and `"Law was an imperial export. The mission to rescue ‘native’ women from their backward cultures was a prominent theme in British portrayals of the empire’s colonial activities. In the late 1800s and early 1900s Britain moved to bring marriage customs in India into line with her imperial values, and a series of laws introduced age restrictions for Hindu and Muslim girls marrying." The above used fragements are quoted on the wiki of the islam subreddit about child-marriage/consent. Jonathan Brown confirms the European Marriage Pattern as marrying in the mid twentise since the 1400s and is completely contardicted by Adnan who claims: 31:56 !people before 1900 for them a 10 years old bride was normal a seven years old bride was normal" 39:02 "it was normal for them they could imagine a 10 years old bride they could imagine a nine and eight years old bride they could you cannot if you went to a wedding today as you've all testified right if you ready if you went to a wedding today but if you are alive in the nineteenth century no problem" Adnan is blatantly misrepresenting history. And so is Paul. In the video you linked of Paul claims that during the colonial period supposedly pgirls of 7 knew about sex and marriage based on some law. But this contradicts what Jonathan brown wrote. ""n the late 1800s and early 1900s Britain moved to bring marriage customs in India into line with her imperial values, and a series of laws introduced age restrictions for Hindu and Muslim girls marrying." Paulk isa lying.

[@tefaalmsry3171]

@@ohana_is_family I am a beginner at learning English, and this is hard for me to just read, not to mention the knowledge that I must have to validate the information here, but I only know that I live in Egypt and I lived my half-life in a small village, my grandmother from My Father's Side married my grandfather when she was 11 years old, she had seven children, my grandmother from my mother's side she married my grandfather when she was 14 years old, had 5 children, my uncle from my mother's side his mother-in-law married when she was 10, had 6 children, now who are you to come and tell me that those men are pedophiles, this is disgusting to accuse those people with that, I don't even care about what age the Europeans used to get married, I don't give a damn about that, I know my value my own culture and the logic behind them, but I just remembered something about Romeo and Juliet, that Joliet was 13 years old and her mother used to blame her for not getting married because the girls at her age used to have their children playing around them

[@ohana_is_family]

@@tefaalmsry3171 I did not call anyone a pedophile. I pointed at the fact that the risk of harm is real from intercourse and from very early pregnancy. Accroding to historian Peter Laslett who checked the birth and marriage registers of england and is a Royal Academy Member level historian there is no evidence in the records that marriage at 13 was common in the upper classes at Shakespeare's time. Laslett pointed to the fact that the original story the play was based on had Juliet 16 years old. He speculated that since all roles were played by boys the age was possibly lowered so the boys selected to play Juliet would be small enough not to have their voice break. So, no Juliet 's Age in the play was not representative of marriage ages at the time. I will quote from the European Marriage Pattern wikipedia page these sections are both based on Peter Laslett "The Wold We Have Lost" 1965 which is in the archive dot org site. And I have read it. I can confirm that the wikipedia sections are accurate representations. # " From 1619 to 1660 in the archdiocese of Canterbury, England, the median age of the brides was 22 years and nine months while the median age for the grooms was 25 years and six months, with average ages of 24 years for the brides and nearly 28 years for the grooms, with the most common ages at marriage being 22 years for women and 24 years for men; the Church dictated that the age when one could marry without the consent of one's parents was 21 years. A large majority of English brides in this time were at least 19 years of age when they married, and only one bride in a thousand was thirteen years of age or younger.[45] William Shakespeare's drama Romeo and Juliet puts Juliet's age at just short of fourteen years; the idea of a woman marrying in secret at a very early age would have scandalized Elizabethans. The common belief in Elizabethan England was that motherhood before 16 was dangerous; popular manuals of health, as well as observations of married life, led Elizabethans to believe that early marriage and its consummation permanently damaged a young woman's health, impaired a young man's physical and mental development, and produced sickly or stunted children. Therefore, 18 came to be considered the earliest reasonable age for motherhood and 20 and 30 the ideal ages for women and men, respectively, to marry." If Adnan Rashid had consulted the works of respected Historians he would not be babbling nonsense. All obstetricsw, child marriage etc. related research says that the young ther bride, the greater the risks. The UN therfore set teh minimum marriage age at 18. You are free to not care at which age girls are impregnated, but I would challenge you to let them read the medical research and offer them the choice, and they'll not want to get impregnated at very young ages. . Are you brave enough to tell the truth to young brides and offer them the option of meaningful consent? 1.Science says 25-30 is the age of least risk to mother and child for a first pregnancy. https[]://[]www[].pnas[].org/content/113/19/5227 "With the onset of puberty, the female developmental trajectory diverges substantially from the childhood trajectory, whereas the male trajectory essentially continues its earlier course (Table S2). As a result, the female pelvis attains its obstetrically most favorable morphology around the age of 25-30 y, i.e., at the age of highest fertility" This has been known by obstetricians and midwives for a long time. https[]://[]archive[].org/details/familyphysiciang00hamm/page/592/mode/2up The family physician and guide to health ... Including a treatise on midwifery and the diseases peculiar to women by Hammack, Elijah B Publication date 1869 Topics Medicine, Popular Publisher St. Louis, Southwestern book and publishing co. "It is worthy of remark that marriage at too early an age is not conducive to health or longevity, but, on the contrary, the mortality among young married persons, I mean of married persons under the age of twenty, particularly women, is very great. I do not think that women ought to marry under twenty-two" The Greek/Roman Doctor Soranus lived 1st/2nd century AD He was born in Ephesus but practiced in Alexandria and subsequently in Rome wrote: https[]://[]archive.org/details/in.ernet.dli.2015.547535/page/n233/mode/2up In his book about gynecology in the section about problematic deliveries: "For it obtains whenever women married before maturity conceive and give birth while the uterus has not yet fully grown nor the fundus of (the) uterus expanded." So they knew the pelvic floor and birth canal were not mature enough. Then https[]://[]archive[].org/details/in.ernet.dli.2015.547535/page/n227/mode/2up "..difficult labor occur in those who give birth in a way which is contrary to nature? Diocles the Caerystan in the second book on gynecology says that primiparae and young women have difficult labor" and https[]://[]archive[].org/details/in.ernet.dli.2015.547535/page/n83/mode/2up "One must judge the majority from the ages of 15 to 40 to be fit for conception to..." 2.. The younger the mother, the greater the risk. Childbearing in adolescents aged 12-15 years in low resource countries: a neglected issue. New estimates from demographic and household surveys in 42 countries https[]://[]obgyn[].onlinelibrary[].wiley[].com[]/doi/full/10.1111/j.1600-0412.2012.01467.x " "It is frequently cited that girls who give birth aged 15-19 are more than twice as likely to die as those in their 20s (1, 2). However, this fails to capture the fact that risk increases with decreasing age. ......girls aged 15 or under had an odds ratio for maternal death four times higher than women aged 20-24. " 3\. It is not just mortality, it's fistulas. Science says it is a problem. https[]://[]www[].ncbi[].nlm[].nih[].gov/pmc/articles/PMC3877393/ "In sub-Saharan Africa and South Asia, obstetric fistula is very common, as access to and use of emergency obstetric care is limited ...... Several factors have been linked to the high occurrence of obstetric fistula in sub-Saharan Africa, including the preponderance of early marriage and teenage pregnancy, which in turn mean that the girls do not have pelvises which have sufficiently developed to allow reproduction \[10\]. This is further compounded by the poor nutritional status of most of the girls who live in these highly deprived settings \[11,12\]." Aid-workers confirm death and fistulas are the problem: https[]://[]www[].livescience[].com[]/19584-10-year-birth.html "The greatest danger, however, is to the pelvic floor. Girls may start ovulating and menstruating as early as age 9, though the average is around 12 to 13. ........ Just because a girl can get pregnant, though, doesn't mean she can safely deliver a baby. The pelvis does not fully widen until the late teens, meaning that young girls may not be able to push the baby through the birth canal. The results are horrific, said Wall and Thomas, who have both worked in Africa treating women in the aftermath of such labors. Girls may labor for days; many die. Their babies often don't survive labor either. The women and girls who do survive often develop fistulas, which are holes between the vaginal wall and the rectum or bladder. When the baby's head pushes down and gets stuck, it can cut portions of the mother's soft tissue between its skull and her pelvic bones. As a result, the tissue dies, and a hole forms. Feces and urine then leak through the hole and out of the vagina. Women with fistulas are often divorced and shunned. And young girls are at higher risk."

[@nancyhajj-ali9122]

joseph got married to mary when she was 12 and he was 90

[@blackmancool9983]

Where? Which book?

[@ramraghuwanshi2562]

Great, he too was pedophile.. By the way r u going to marry ur daughter at 6?

[@ohana_is_family]

In Islam and Christianity Mary was not impregnated by Joseph. So how can you use her as an example? Nobody wants to follow her example.

[@nancyhajj-ali9122]

@@blackmancool9983 catholic encyclopedia

[@user-fn5en9ez6k]

You missed the point that he had a sexual relationship with a nine year old please... how can you even defend something like that! That is totally unacceptable.

[@TetrahedronIX]

He didn't miss it. He even says it in the intro. Prophert Mohammad was the best example for all mankind. lol

[@ohana_is_family]

@@awalon2572 In fact by misrepresenting history Adnan tries to make it seem as if The West married early until recently. Complete poppycock. The reason Adnan resorts to non-standard , exotic sources like Jeremy Rifkin is because all historians contradict his nonsense.

[@ohana_is_family]

@@awalon2572 You are not talking about a different way of thinking. The Atecs cuting a man's heart out is not a different way of thinking, neither is exposing a 9 year old girl to Traumatic Fistula or death. Intercourse with a 9 year old puts her at serious risk of harm. Islam is not from Allah.

[@ohana_is_family]

@@awalon2572 1. In Muhammed's time they knew the risks of ifda (traumatic Fistula). This is because Aisha was fattened (ibn majah 3324) and ifda subsequently became part fo fiqh. Reliance of the traveller: Al-Misri (1302-1367) https[]://[]archive[].org/details/RelianceOfThetraveller/page/592/mode/2up?q=injury O4:13 “ A full indemnity is also paid for injuries which paralyze these members, or for injuring the partitional wall between vagina and rectum so they become one aperture.” Hidaya: al-Marghinani's Al-Hidaya (1197) https[]://[]archive[].org/details/the-mukhtasar-al-quduri/Al-Hidayah%20%28The%20Guidance%29%20-%20Vol%201/page/18/mode/2up?q=ifda Note “62 Ifda, in one of its uses, means the removal of the barrier between the two passages making them one. Usually happens when a very young girl is subjected to sexual inter¬ course.” 2. In Muhammed's time it had ben 500 years since Soranus had described the dangers of pregnancies under 15. The Roman Empire and later the Byzantian empire had adopted marriage age laws (Rome 12, Byzantine Empire 13) and the perisans prohibited consummation under the age of 12 So In Muhammed's time it was considered dangerous to girls and immoral.

[@nessimbencheik8308]

For 1400 years he was never accused of pedophilia at the time by his detractaires (Jews and Christians or idolaters) Why?? History explains it by itself, as in the 11th century, the queen of Leon and Casille Urracque1 was married at the age of 8, Philippe Auguste II in the 12th century married Isabelle at the age of 10. Juana, Queen of Sicily, married William II at the age of eleven, the Princess of Navarre in the 13th century married the King of France Philip IV the Beautiful at 11 years old. In the 14th century Princess Isabelle de Valois married Calais Richard II was married at the age of 8, St Augustine married a girl aged 10. And the list is long. All received the blessing from the pope Moreover, why criticizes the prophet Muhammad PBUH when we know that the Virgin Mary was 12 yo married with Joseph the carpenter, 90 yo and Isaac 40 yo with rebecca between 3 and 10 yo according your biblical exegesis if you go to France now, there is no more age of consent since 2016. It is the judge who will decide the act of consent if there is an issue. This is why the french tried to legiferate for an of 13 yo. Why 13 yo? on what basis?

[@rizgarrania7844]

Just because something was a norm in the Past doesn’t mean it was moral; in the past it was a norm to sacrifice humans for god or gods, but now when we think of it, it is disgusting. And I think that was a disgusting act and crime committed in the past.

[@instagramaccount96]

Logical fallacy called presentism. Renders your way of thinking and argument invalid.

[@alearner2748]

that's why if people from the past come and see you watching porn every day for them it's so immoral but for you it's not (not talking about you) but what would you say to them it doesn't matter what is immoral to you it's 21 century and it's normal now it doesn't matter if it was not normal back then, but that doesn't mean it should be still not normal today, the life changed. same argument and I am against porn

[@dr.monoarhossain6586]

Then the whole of your ancestors werer immoral. Go, and take some grass.

[@discoveringtruth594]

@@alearner2748 How inhu [*Cough* abortion (sacrificing babies in various ways in the wombs for "liberties")] ane! No, the perception of modern man in their surrounding norms is the benchmark because they're "modern", you see? The psychology, maturity and physical development of those in the luxurious, industrial world, especially from europe, must be the same as those adapted to the harsh realities of the desert and their living, and so the latter should get married at an age equivalent to theirs in their norms (after finishing university and then well into a career at age maybe 29, 30 finally after having a multiplicity of relationships), don't you see? But we must all unequivocally agree since we truly have the morals and care that this matter is not merely a suitability for environmental factors and individual maturity, no. It is also about morals. Promsicuity and a lack of boundaries in a liberal world (as can be seen in all areas of their living) would be chaotic for this specific matter to take place.

[@alearner2748]

@@discoveringtruth594 imagine if those who used to marry young girls heard about abortion, what would've they said that's so immoral how can you do that there are many things which now are normal but for those people these would be immoral like marrying young girl is immoral according to this generation

[@Harris.S]

اللهم صل علی محمد و علی ال محمد و اصحابه و اجمعین ❤❤❤❤❤

[@mrredd8439]

Muslims do not pray or deify the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH). Islam is monotheistic, and we as Muslims understand there is but one God, and that's Allah. Christians repeatedly attempt to discredit the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), because somehow this will discredit Islam. It won't! We love the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), but we do not worship him. Christians, because of their need to worship the Prophet Jesus (PBUH), think they can compare their idolatry of the Prophet Jesus (PBUH) to our love for the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH). In Islam, we love all of the prophets sent by Allah.

[@junaidsediqi9417]

MashaAllah

[@joyphillips1821]

Even the Jews wouldn't declare Aisha a woman till she was 12 when she had her batmitzvah... and Rebecca was not 3... if you look at Genesis 24: 11 it says the women were allowed to fetch from the well. And as for a 9 year old bride, among the Roman Empire ( secularists) a bride of 7 was considered NORMAL ( there are records of this- usually for wealthy families to join together) ... so they wouldn't question Aisha's age.....but they also wouldn't question homosexuality, persecution of Christians etc... so much for your medieval critics. A little history lesson and Adnan would know this.

[@roxastidus4109]

Baraka Allahu Fik. Just one thing about Khadija Radiya Allahu Anha, she was already married to the prophet when he received the revelation.

[@mfvohra101]

I mean at the end we are moving on because of social, liberal, atheist and secular value.

[@baiishelleykaliman743]

Masha Allah..

[@NATURLIST]

Checkout Robert Peterson from Australia: he done a case study of Of: Age of consent law, sir Mathew Hale, the head of the Hale commission, this man were studying to be a puritan Christian priest, then he change direction and study law instead, stand up in court as a jurist and defend husband against the charge of rape, and sir Mathew Hale said: 10 and 11 year old is the general legal age of consent in Britain (so this mean stagnant overall blanket age of consent law), and this was only just 2 and a half century ago,

[@ohana_is_family]

Historians do not look at exception and outliers to describe how a population behaves. They look at Mean Age of First Marriage which has been in the mid 20s since the 1400s in Europe and in the low twenties in the USA since the earliest data-collection (1730). Consent laws are mainly used in rape cases and can vary widely. They are not a good instrument to measure by..

[@coastline1975]

Camera works need to be improved.

[@fastng]

everyone asks how old Aisha RA was, but no one asks who Aisha RA was.

[@chadafiy]

Waiting eagerly for the Tipu Sultan video

[@poordadrichson6115]

Is this recent?

[@ohana_is_family]

A re-upload of a video that was uploaded in 2019 . the apologetcis presentation was in may 2019 kzbin.info/www/bejne/moKoZGiBibRoZ5o

[@sadeqmamnoon9088]

سورة النساء أية ٦ : وابتلوا اليتمى حتى إذا "بلغو النكاح " فان أنستم منهم "رشدا" فادفعو أموالهم ولا تاءكلو ها اسرافا" وبدارا. Keep an eye on orphans until they reach adulthood ! for marriage, only then return their wealth.......and their belongings...... So, age is not in question , maturity is the condition. !!!!

[@maalikserebryakov]

this condition is only for the orphans, and maturity is not a condition for the none orphan.

[@andrewfaniku]

“I’m a good Muslim. If anything good is said about our beloved Prophet in our holy books then I’ll say it’s true. At the same time if anything bad is said about our Holy Prophet then I’d say those are unreliable, misinterpreted and untrue.” Unfortunately, most sincere and truth-seeking Muslims are committed to reciting their Al-Fatiha, 5 times every day. Our words are potent. What you say repeatedly to yourself is more compelling than what someone else tells you. This is why it’s almost impossible, to convince a devout praying Muslim, that Mohammed has flaws or that God’s nature isn’t necessarily constrained into a singular entity, or that Christians are not deceived, or that Jews are not cursed. What we repeatedly say to ourselves, regardless of its validity, becomes our truth and belief. Be careful what you recite. 🙏🏾

[@amandadarkwood535]

Well you're clearly lying because many devout Muslims, including myself, have found flaws in Mohammad and left Islam.

[@Ahmed21778]

@@amandadarkwood535 "devout", yeah buddy surely you were "devout"

[@amandadarkwood535]

@@Ahmed21778 you aren’t Muslim

[@Ahmed21778]

@@amandadarkwood535 how did you know ? is it too obvious ?

[@amandadarkwood535]

@@Ahmed21778 same goes to you