Pune International Centre: Lecture by Prof. Christine Fair

[@GovindSingh-oy5ex]

She knows more about Pakistan than Pakistanis themselves do. And she is ultimate when it comes to sarcastic humour based on facts. She can cause trouble in many languages for sure.

[@munibahuma5583]

Govind Singh She does'nt know any thing she took lots of money from pakistani institutions for her lectuers now ya Kanjri Kutyia ky thra bhonk rahy ha ...

[@Makrania]

Muniba Huma Foul language discredits the argument.

[@MohammedAMulla]

@@munibahuma5583 there is no doubt about as she is کنجرئ

[@stuarthastie6374]

Muniba Huma She took insightful observations institutions like ISI no doubt lavished hospitality initially. Pak Uni’s don’t pay so well. If you are Pak military you know how to slice off a profit.

[@hamzayousafzai9204]

@@stuarthastie6374 She has wasted her PHD, time proves rather than predictions. Facts r facts.

[@DrJG9]

48:12 - 52:00! "Why would they give up nukes and jihadists when that's how they get the world to pay their bills? So there is an understanding of this in governments across the world" - high time!

[@hinduindia7362]

2024 Cricket world cup final India vs. Baluchistan

[@MohammedAMulla]

2024 cricket world cup final India vs J.Kashmir. InshAllah

[@rahulchandak2988]

Pretty sure pakistan will lose to J.K and then blame india for it

[@burhaanbabar3086]

Pakistan vs Ladakh

[@peachtreedesigns8221]

We Pakistanis would like to play 2024 final with Khalistan.

[@SSR3010]

@@peachtreedesigns8221 haan zarur khelna with capital of Khalistan being Lahore.

[@manukantbhatnagar1239]

What worries me more is that most people attending this lectures ( i have seen many of them) are old people (by old i mean retired),we need young students and people in working age to attend this event and have a front row seats thats how our mind will expand and an active action plan will be developed

[@howtomanufacture]

Thanks for taking keen interest in CPEC project. This shows that CPEC is one of important project not only for Pakistan and china but also for rest of the world especially for America and India as witness from Christine presentation and other experts were gathered from all over the country and sit in front of her. Various issues were highlighted in this presentation and have expert opinion regarding geography, security, job employment, strategically analysis etc. Though this presentation was given in Pune India to Indian expert but we the Pakistani have certainly got a lot of benefit from her expertise and we will put her point of view in our cpec wing. I would like to give some comment on her presentation. You know that this project was started in 2013 just four year before having no detail engineering design having no previous working except few dialogue which have been taken by the previous governments but these were limited to paper work only. When project launched it has divided into 3 stages which are: a) Early Harvest Projects (2018) b) Short-Term Projects (2020) c) Mid-Term Projects (2025) d) Long-Term Projects (2030) You know very well then anybody else that if a project like cpec started without proper master planning will have a lot of issues but we are not losing our heart and we are trying to eliminate all of issues as proceeding in to the project including all those issues highlighted by Christine and we took her criticism in positive way Though we know better than anybody else the core issues of Pakistan encountered in this gigantic project. Various issues pertaining to this project are highlighted by Christine fair, I would like to respond to the following being a Pakistani to remove some misconception from the mind of the other people and for guidance: i) Christine told that Baluch people are opposes of cpec. This is not true for whole Baluch people. There are few groups which are opposing like BLA etc.. Who is funded by external forces and you know very well then anybody else. As you mentioned in the presentation about the route and I would like to update you that there are 3 routes eastern, center and western and you know the Baluch people are demanding that to pass the western route from Baluchistan which is the poorest area in all Pakistan so that they may benefit in true sense. This is misconception about the Baluch that they are opposite but they are demanding more in cpec. ii) Christine showed a picture of sliding area of Atta Abad and then show a bridge was constructed over there and told that this is bomb prone. In regard I would tell Christine that it is not so easy to attack on this bridge and even on any cpec bridge. Pak army have given the assurance of all sort of security. Moreover it is located in a region even it is nearly impossible to target from missile as of high location and peaks over there. Moreover I would like to inform you that there are other alternate routes in proposal which are all weathered routes and are in pipeline. There are other various issues about which the Christine have no idea but we have taken them and working on it. Moreover it is bring in your kind notice that all the provinces and federal government of Pakistan is on one page. Cpec divisions have been established both in federal level and on provincial levels. They are doing their work with full devotions and in collaboration with Chinese government. This is the project which is in progress and which comes in thousands years of any nations. See the pages of the history no project like cpec had over their. I would like to quote here that the hindi movie praise that “baray baray dasho may choti choti bathing hoti rehti hai” so similarly issues will be there in such a gigantic project.

[@satwikmohanty9390]

I love her, straight and direct. and BTW m the 1st one to comment

[@barkupatree6871]

i am watching dr. fair, about 4 years too late.. somewhat eerie. thank you for sharing this wealth of knowledge, dr. fair.

[@DrJG9]

"Depends on if you do it successfully" - 86:55 Prof Fair responding to a query about how US would react if India took action against pak for a terrorist attack.

[@DrJG9]

40:30 - 40:50 it is quite obvious that the purpose of this highway through length of pak is military usage, and moreover such usage for threat obviously to India, but on part of pak it amounts to cutting off pak's own nose to spite India - which again is as it has been through the whole seven decades of history of pak!

[@aashishpaggare5006]

wow prof. fair was in pune.....

[@truthseeker7383]

It's great to pay her to get to India and be critical about Pakistan, money well spent.

[@DrJG9]

Responding to a post:- Actually it was created elsewhere, finalised the day Berlin fell with USSR tanks rolling in and winning race amongst allies, so The Great Game was back on, and Western powers needed a convenient spot guaranteed for military base, with a port for troops and artillery transportation and an airbase for use against USSR. Nehru and generally congress refused such a guarantee, Jinnah said oh of course no problem - hence the military base camouflaged as a new country, suitable for intolerants and jihadists! Tarek Fateh telling the story of historical facts is worth hearing.

[@rehmankhan0398]

lol even Wikipedia is better source than that joker you are referring here

[@nikhilmali9256]

always pleasure to hear ms fair...

[@DrJG9]

"It surprises that India treats pak as an equal" 74:15 - that is simply the still un shrugged off inheritance from British régime, coupled with Gandhian heritage imbibed in congress and allies rule - the reason for what Prof Fair says she doesn't understand in India fearing pak nukes while pak having no such fear of Indian nukes, is in the Urdu phrase "God fears naked man", to wit, India has much to lose because India has looked to Life, Knowledge and generally positive values, while the islamists crazy simply seek annihilation of world in faith of reward promised supposedly in their book, and hence keep provoking. Also, pak generally has been fed a misconception that India is full of those who can only make money but not fight, while pak heritage is of invading marauding looters who will massacre in millions. '71 defeat surprised them, hence the relatively good behaviour for short term Prof Fair speaks of.

[@yogeshjog6072]

Good comment. But that's exactly what she says we shd call their bluff. Or clear their misunderstanding. I think we have started doing that with balakot or surgical strike 1. But this lady criticises it to be not capable .. (needs separate long discussion ) Here 2016 she says we don't do anything , modi only speaks big and has same policies since 2001 of bearing attacks and blames change is only in speaking big words. Now when we attack she says , we shd do it more covertly. Even 1st surgical attacks also shd have been secret not made into movie she speaks with burkha dutt. Then how will world n ppl of india pak see the change in india policy?? More than actual damage , this mssg was important. She is confused and inconsistent at times.

[@SivanandaSaiChilukuri]

They said it was off the record and put it online in its entirety anyway!

[@rodenderon]

How wise is this to put this on the put license domain? wasn't Prof. Fair during the talk that it was off the record?

[@danishnisar8709]

She explains the dirty ISI very well.

[@adamdavids1760]

Dirty??? Dont tall about dirty you river ganges rat, you people are the most cowardly people on the face of this earth

[@stuarthastie6374]

adam davids kicked your ass out of Bangladesh.

[@abhijitvmehta]

The audio is very poor. Hope you can clear it up and update this video.

[@malmalhi007]

better with headphones

[@jay36742]

Wow Carol - you are brilliant! I admire you and the immense knowledge you have. I visit the U.S often and would love to meet you someday. Hope you see my message : -)

[@DrJG9]

79:00 if this talk really did happen the day before surgical strikes by India, it is uncanny. Re aman ki asha people, again, Tarek Fateh would agree!

[@ParikshitBhujbal]

Please please, can u upload the link for the ppt, as this video was made very poorly and doesn't do any justice to the topic.

[@adisura9904]

also a real good insight into the CPEC and the Sino-Pak relationship.

[@DrJG9]

If there is lack of resentment in pak about China controlling pak 71:52, perhaps it is the Mongol invaders' heritage that daunts and awes pak!

[@indianskeptic3451]

At 53:22 the video is cut out.

[@TonyMetalhead]

Christine should hold seminars in cities throughout India and the U.S. to educate people on current affairs between, the US, India, China and Pakistan. The fact is that America has no other option but to help India to remain the super power! America cannot sail in two boats at the same time by funding terrorist State Pakistan and to create road block for China from becoming the next super power!

[@haroonhafeez2368]

Kid what's your army going to do in Afghanistan? Typical American thinking rule the world, only superpower why you blood thirsty power seeking hounds always want to rule world? What's wrong with your can't you stay at your on backyard? Why you people have the need to sell your ways to all world? Why?

[@meallmighty4ever]

i wish she can come down to dhanbad , iit - ism

[@will22joseph]

its more like entertainment than a discussion to me :D I enjoyed it

[@meerbaluch4795]

We will get freedom than I will call fair to research on Baloch and Balochistan.

[@taimurahmedkhan6448]

Pointing out any country with fake information is so easy like that I can blame America and India too but things like this won't work. I am feeling good that there is power in pakistan that enemies try there best to degrade Pakistan. Love for pakistan

[@DrJG9]

Responding to a post about China colonising and repenting too late finding terrorists from pak:- Oriental threshold of pain is another story, people who knew about both sides have said German and Russian pow were at receiving ends of torture a tad less extreme compared with those in custody of east Asian enemies. But real victims would be the hapless poor of land that was once part of India, because those that sell them to China have accounts and children settled abroad safely! People who could have benefited if the project were from west are instead going to be pushed off land that was theirs, whether Northern Kashmir regions of Gilgit Baltistan or southern ones Baluchistan and Sindh! When West Punjab wakes up, thieves will be in Canada, and their state won't be any better than Tibet! Remember, khans are of Mongolian origin, Chingis Khan and his clan colonised from China to eastern borders of Russia, Iran and more, before one daughter's son was kicked all the way south to India, and hated India where he refused to be buried - his remains were finally taken from Afghanistan to his home in Central Asia as per his wish, less than a couple of centuries ago.

[@nianetic5165]

Best comment by hillary on their faces:"u want to grow snakes that will only kiill your neighbours"

[@NikhileshSurve]

1:40:13 Dilip Padgaovkar just had to be that over smart person to bring Trump into this which led to her ranting her anti Trump nonsense with Russian hacking conspiracy theory & also feminist nonsense, talked about southern poverty law centre as something good who are now facing allegations of racial & gender discrimination themselves. She then brought David Duke into this who has also praised _Tulsi Gabbard_ the only elected Hindu parliamentarian. Christine Fair probably considers _Swastika_ as an evil symbol too coz that's also a western consensus to refer _Hakenkreuz_ as.

[@James5Sapphire]

I wish she would come to Kolkata

[@karanbhattt]

Abhik Biswas Mamta begum would not let her.

[@DrJG9]

107:01"there are many ambassadors, generals and airmarshals today in the audience" and so the questions that seemed pointed! Or were those merely from typical Pune guys? Could very well be latter!

[@SalmanKhan-si7ed]

IN SHORT A DREAMY AND FAIRY TALES KIND OF ANALYSIS MEANT ONLY FOR INDIA

[@najeeb3579]

buddy you're wrong here! The christine Fair not only India listen to her lecture. recently EU has been asked help by lecturing to EU MPs in Brussels to get broader picture on South Asia specially India and Pakistan. This is the problem by Pakistanis , if anyone talk some truth which is not suit you then they're GADDAR !!! you've to accept that there's something wrong happening in Pakistan too.see present day scenario your own neighbours Muslim countries such as Afghanistan and doesn't like you. so, your myopic view there's no takers! grow up

[@SalmanKhan-si7ed]

same Goes for u tHAT WHHHEN anyone expose indians u term tHem ISI AGENT SO PAKISTAN IS NOT TE ONLY SUFFERER OF THAT DISEASE INDIA TOO SUFFERINGG FROM THAT DISEASE

[@SalmanKhan-si7ed]

GENERAL MYCRESTAL COMMANDER ISAF FORCE IN AFANISTAN OPENLY SAID TAAT INDIA IS USING AFGGHAN TERRITORY AND PLAYING DIRTY PROXY WAR AGAINST PAKISTAN, DENY IT AND CALLH IM ISI AGGENT WHICHH U CAN DO VERY EASILY

[@najeeb3579]

Salman Khan whoelse!? It's an old FAIRYTALE, Come on tell me. UN General assembly how many countries supported you?! Give me a name. Same time India has tremendous support from different countries around the world. To declare pak as terror sponsoring country we have a hundreds of thousands signs already collected. It will goes through UN American congress and British parliament plus Brussels European union. You try against it... Will see how you gonna sustain with that!

[@SalmanKhan-si7ed]

ANY FAIRY TALE THAT EXPOSE INDIANS OR AFGHANEES R OILD FAIRY TALE BUT ANY FAIRY TALE LIKE CHRISTINE IS REAL FAIRY TALE. WE ALSO HAVE MANY CHRISTINE FEAR. IT,S EASY TO HIRE SERVICES OF CHRISTINE FAIR BY PAYING THEM DOLLARS TO LOBBY FOR U AND WE ALSO HAVE MANY CHRISTINE FAIR

[@ThePresidentGuard]

There is a guy talking about peranoia, I think whole world knows that Indian government always cry even the US special Secretary went back and report to start department that indian has nothing to talk except talking about India

[@DrJG9]

77:11 Tarek Fateh would agree and applaud!

[@sagarswargam5374]

She doesn't need introduction...

[@magarmachh]

What is the date when this lecture was delivered?

[@DrJG9]

It wasn't that "pak was well behaved until khalistan insurgency" 75:20, on the contrary pak engineered it, via whispering to pilgrims and supplying weapons, ammunition et al! So if any good behaviour in fact there was, it was superficial, while intrigues as to how to revenge against India for Bangladesh were being cooked up. What never occurred to pak is to look within for causes of East Bengal revolt - because pak assumed like all racists that superiority of those that could claim West and Central Asian DNA of invaders must be kowtowed to by all! This mindset still shows in yt comments from pak, claiming pak superiority due to "height and skin colour" over India which they assert is all "short, dark and ugly"! India lacks such absolute equations, and values education, achievements, knowledge and capabilities, so pak comments come across as ridiculous and immature.

[@goldilockszone4389]

People walking in during the session and out, bad audio, and no planning - This is India's planning a conference.

[@dhruvbedi4039]

no its not ,its a political science professors conference

[@goldilockszone4389]

besides the point - a country filled uncouth and rude rampant feudalists and ideas of chicanery, cavalier, and utter disparage for incipient youth and innovation

[@dhruvbedi4039]

no it is the point ,by trying to falsely malign India's Intellect and its policy efforts you show your hollowness ,btw your description is perfect for Pakistan

[@goldilockszone4389]

PAL is that even a name - look are you pic you look wanna be - jerk ass who must be earning $100 a year

[@prabinpal1226]

You are totally right on this one.. no arguments there

[@laelanso]

Cannot hear wear a mic

[@bnkakl]

why does she say the caesar tyhe dog whisperer is a fraud and shud not have a TV show! at 49:00

[@bnkakl]

i love and respect him a lot. so its all the more disturbing. i hv mostly used all this techniques to train my baby and its worked out fine.

[@DrJG9]

70:18 apart from risks of manipulation instead of direct straight talk, re Chabahar one thought India is very much doing it! How old is this talk?

[@sandeshkadam3040]

I am big fan of fair

[@dbn281]

did not know that fact about Hilary Clinton...

[@chakravarthy123]

She should have a mobile mike

[@Motorhed_Mandke]

When you talk to people about their technological advancements and the projector breaks down... 😁😁😅 Jokes apart a good perspective on cpec

[@uchaudh]

Did she just criticize Pakistani powerpoint skill at 10 minutes and 50 seconds or something? LOL, coming from someone, who took three minuets to make the ppt full screen and didn't realize she was not in a presentation mode :)

[@hiphop4life760]

you are on record

[@MrBalvinder2010]

RAW must recruit her.

[@silverhawck]

Whenever Christine talks against Pakistan, Indians audiences laugh loudly and when she talks anything positive about Pakistan there is pin drop silence. i am just amazed how innocent Indians are.

[@adisura9904]

is that a chicken?

[@ThePresidentGuard]

She has always talk about Pakistan she never give any other presentation I would prefer if she could enlighten the failure of US in Afghanistan and her role where she has failed to the job she was assigned for. Her talk is mainly sum up of what you learn on tabloid news paper

[@محمدآصف-ص7م]

keep on with your khyaali plao

[@kashifkalwar7970]

She is an indian agent, everyone knows

[@deepzoned5263]

Kashif Ali Feel sad cause you guys are brainwashed so badly by ur news media and millitary..

[@qasimraja5043]

Long live ISI and Pakistan army and Pakistan. CHINA friendship

[@sandeshkadam3040]

Fucking idiot

[@संजयगोस्वामी-ग6ह]

Poor audio🙄

[@tanny786]

god bless Pakistan keep burnol close indians chhoota

[@mahabharat7743]

Lets see if you can laugh off the tunnel diverting Brahmaputra to inner magnolia lets see if you can bomb that

[@roublemac3882]

she makes sense but there is a hidden agenda

[@Shahzada]

26.35 She SupportingTerrorism , i dont even know how you guys are allowing her to give a lecture.

[@prometheus9142]

Her bias is obvious.

[@MohammedAMulla]

Why she so much worry about Pakistan. Kiya kisi Pakistani ney ??????#???

[@atif0321]

what so ever EPEC gonna pain in ass for indian and US

[@SaneLiesbuster]

You didn't even get the name right !

[@atif0321]

doesn't make any difference

[@hamzayousaf5693]

Pakistan new neighbours in next few years are Khalistan, Manipur, Assam etc And addition of one more province in Pakistan will be Kashmir InShaAllah

[@bicentinialman]

Pakistan Banega Kashmir Ola Hu Ukber!

[@tseek001]

Balderdash .. 😆😆

[@Amjadalishah56]

The way you explained the road between mountains speaks high about your biasness towards Pakistan. Ma'am you lost all your credibility after expressing your desire to bomb that road. Please have some sense, start speaking truth.

[@Amjadalishah56]

you are full of hate towards Pakistan. "Army is colonizing Pakistan because they are recruiting Baluch". What kind of remarks are these, Ma'am every army in the world recruit their nationals including US, India, China, Japan, none of the army want to recruit outsiders or foreigners.

[@Amjadalishah56]

Bro John Doe, this lady hate Pakistan anyway.

[@yogeshjog6072]

@@Amjadalishah56 her basic contention is, she says pakistan establishment still works like how british left it. As my understanding goes.. she means as india developed it's democracy pakistan could not. So like Iran , Afghan it's much of elitist (army isi jamindars etc) who run the country. Compared to that Bangla desh i india are much more pro ppl , much more welfare states.

[@zeeshansiddiqi2576]

yeah they actually lose in 2019

[@chaudharyabdulrayan5890]

All she does is tell what is what. Doesn't provide or share a single shred of documented evidence.

[@chaudharyabdulrayan5890]

@Advait Kolhatkar ofcourse it is who told you its not?? Trucks go from Gwadar to china and Afghanistan. Soon many other countries will use it too. Just youtube it up.

[@chaudharyabdulrayan5890]

@Advait Kolhatkar our government denies that, they say with revenue from Gwadar and other economic zones we can repay the debt. But whatever be the case, whats that got to do with india or our border issues?

[@chaudharyabdulrayan5890]

@Advait Kolhatkar there's no war your medias a pthetic liar 🤦‍♂️

[@Akhilkumar0024]

​@@chaudharyabdulrayan5890 how is CPEC working these days 😂😂 are you generating enough money from gwadar to atleast save pak from imminent default

[@chaudharyabdulrayan5890]

@@Akhilkumar0024 beta ji thora media se bahir niklo and look at the world. every country in the world is in debt, inflation is everywhere. you really think world bank imf dont control countries? khalistan movement is rising again, i've seen all the videos and i dont think its a coincidence that it happened after india stood by russia in that conflict.

[@zeeshanasim6553]

Paid professor

[@sandeshkadam3040]

Fucking idiot

[@sandeshkadam3040]

Jai hind jai Maharashtra

[@winstonmaraj8029]

Truth is truth. Paid or not.

[@hashirmahad4452]

whay an american come to india abd comment on cpeck wich china and pakistan neighbouring countries. i think she is oaod by indians if cpeck success or failure it our buisness why you indians are weeping cpeck is strenthing pak and gawadat is become hub of hot water cinnectin CA countries and upt russia and Siberia and nortploecoil and gas soory...

[@markzwik]

Lady i have heard what you said. In my point of view you are partial, one-sided, parti pris, partisan, prejudiced etc. Your word should not be taken seriously.

[@muhammadimran846]

Completely one sided speech, so she don't deserve to talk about CPEC.

[@muhammadimran846]

CPEC is the part of OBOR which is going through a lot of other countries. One thing I m sure if CPEC is harmful for PAKISTAN. Ferry+Tariq Fatah+India will not oppose it 😜 as all of them are not the friends of Pakistan 🇵🇰

[@muhammadimran846]

India already lost opportunity to join CPEC. and has only option to keep doing proxies in Baulochistan and Larachi

[@muhammadimran846]

Let's the CPEC get fully operational then I m sure this project will bring more prosperity in whole PAKISTAN 🇵🇰 and eventually India will request Pakistan soon to join CPEC.

[@muhammadimran846]

Is Ferrie found any good thing in CPEC? May be she worked only on 🇮🇳 and 🇺🇸 agendas.

[@muhammadimran846]

Useless speech, just crying on CPEC.😂

[@SalmanKhan-si7ed]

I THINK CHRISTINE FAIR WILL DIE WITH THE DREAM TO FINISH PAKISTAN AND WILL REST IN PEACE

[@SaneLiesbuster]

Islam is very goonda friendly.

[@SaneLiesbuster]

@Salman Khan You need urgent help !

[@rockyybaba8769]

I'm pretty sure she never visited pakistan in her entire life.. Never meet the locals...and here she tends to be a master of knowing everything about a country.. By reading some bias books or articles on newspaper which are written by stereotypical entities doesn't make u have an extensive knowledge about that country..

[@haroonhafeez2368]

She did visit Pakistan and our fools treated her like lords.

[@stuarthastie6374]

haroon hafeez is that when they threatened to have a regiment rape her ?

[@vm0531]

Her behaviour looks as if she's just trying to please Indians by saying what Indians want to hear. I don't understand what she gains by doing so.

[@ThePresidentGuard]

If Pakistan strategy is wrong so why mighty America is on his knees after 13years of spending billions on Afghanistan, I think she should go and get better education to teach their state Department....LoL

[@jamalafridi513]

india wallo tum logo ka sahi fuddu bana rahi hai ...

[@bendsally7300]

india just get jealous

[@khalidaziz5921]

it's not true

[@khalidaziz5921]

yes its a propaganda war nothing else

[@threshhold5531]

poor audio

[@DrJG9]

"Depends on if you do it successfully" - 86:55 Prof Fair responding to a query about how US would react if India took action against pak for a terrorist attack.

[@yogeshjog6072]

She expected to call paki nuclear bluff.. I think we have started doing that with balakot or surgical strike 1. But this lady criticises it to be not capable .. (needs separate long discussion ) Here 2016 she says we don't do anything , modi only speaks big and has same policies since 2001 of bearing attacks and blames change is only in speaking big words. Now when we attack she says , we shd do it more covertly. Even 1st surgical attacks also shd have been secret not made into movie she speaks with burkha dutt. Then how will world n ppl of india pak see the change in india policy?? *More than actual damage , this mssg was important.* She is confused and inconsistent at times.