Punisher vs Punisher! WHO WOULD WIN IN A FIGHT?

Who would win in a fight between the Punisher from the early 2000's and the hipster reboot Punisher from the Marvel Cinematic Universe? FIND OUT NOW!
I know that there have been four different versions of the Punisher in the live-action world, but I only pitted the two of the most grounded characters in reality.
But if the four were to ever to get into a battle royale, here is a link to a video that shows who the winner is and why they would win: goo.gl/fCWvF8
As stated in the video, this video is made to determine who would win in a fictional fight, not to argue who is the better incarnation or actor.
Clip At 5:20 - By Tpindell
/ tpindell3
If you liked this video, then stick around!
Follow Me on Social Media!
Facebook: profile.php?...
Instagram: / _gubz_
Personal Instagram: / ohmygubby
Twitter: / _gubz
Sources of info:
Head Injuries - goo.gl/i8V2tP
Velocity On That One Punisher Scene - goo.gl/4iGqsn
Products used to create my videos:
Mic: goo.gl/p8LPjV
Pop Filter: goo.gl/kUacpj
[DISCLAIMER] The affiliate links provided above help support my KZbin channel. You don't have to use them, but to those of you who do-thank you so much!
Outro:
Whithe - Garcion
• Whithe - Garcion
/ whithe-sam
track from Vidadu Music

[@yolanda8563]

5:52 Speedom 👌

[@Uglyboy616]

Thanks man I was wondering what track it was

[@fiend9677]

iBourne xx 1994 u

[@Marvelfanatic3658]

J Garrett ???????????????

[@uncannypigeon8754]

Can we get a 1 hour version? Lol

[@Mvxzzz]

iBourne xx 1994 yeah eminems verse awesome song love how fast Eminem can rap

[@josephkush1032]

Jon berthnal was born to play the punisher, plain and simple

[@jerieljohnson8748]

Joseph kush Jon berthnal was born for punisher, Ryan Reynolds was born for Deadpool, and Hugh Jackman for Wolverine

[@Gugnar678]

His actual voice is different though. He is a really good actor. He can also smile

[@daylonsmith6603]

Jeriel Johnson perfect

[@angelzgalaxy4975]

Jeriel Johnson Robert Downey jr is iron man

[@markymark5198]

Idk i feel Netflix made him more of a brute savage then a ex marine.

[@mattolson7146]

If you compare battlecries, Bernthal wins hands down lol.

[@litboi4312]

Matt Olson damn right

[@septimber]

@@litboi4312 you're goddamn right he does

[@kash_1085]

Jon Bernthal’s Punisher: Raghhhhhhh

[@Xenovaz9]

RUU-SOO

[@perlarodriguez9191]

I truly agreed with you! He is the best punisher so far!

[@calebducommun7589]

Don’t forget Berthnals fight with the Russian body builders. That’s way harder that older punishers waldo fight

[@unofficial_slash4541]

More badass too. The way he used that weight on the dudes face. XD

[@jaredmccarty1606]

That was season 2 though, they only wanted to go off season 1 of Punisher. Which is fair because season 2 Punisher made him even stronger and overall more badass.

[@Jackn17_]

Jared McCarty Didnt he say “season 1 and season 2 punisher”

[@foxuuu]

@@Jackn17_ he said season 1 punisher series and the punisher from daredevil season 2 i guess

[@johng3858]

Foxu this came out prior to season 2 of the punisher, so it wasn’t even considered.

[@DevonPatrick16]

Bernthal was born for this role. He is the perfect Punisher and revived lots of people’s interest in one of the coolest Marvel characters of all time

[@the2tonegemini]

Agreed

[@orangemaniabrother2232]

It's a good show but it doesn't feel like Punisher to me, it's not like any comics I've read

[@DevonPatrick16]

Orange Mania, Brother! It had a very Garth Ennis feel to me though. It wasn’t a specific issue or run, but it mixes Ennis’s Punisher with David Mazzucchelli’s Daredevil Universe

[@orangemaniabrother2232]

@@DevonPatrick16 Ennis Punisher I'm very familiar with, the Tom Jane movie had many elements of that and others, just didn't like the look of Jane. Bernthal kinda looks the part, about 85% there but he's too friendly, too normal and seems too easy to move on from what I've gathered. The stories have been top notch though, I have no complaints as a show in itself, the violence and action is superb. Just doesn't feel like Frank to me but then I doubt you could make a series about him without fleshing his personality up a bit lol

[@isayweirdshityk]

I thought he was born to play Shane jk

[@privatesector0422]

The Punisher IS Jon Bernthal... He doesn't play The Punisher... " he just is"

[@Carlos-vd4uf]

Yep!

[@Berlin19691]

PRIVATE SECTOR 042 Fuckin oath

[@Deivid-bn6yw]

PRIVATE SECTOR 042 it’s like John wick is Keanu Reeves I can’t see anyone else playing John wick

[@frankcastle4547]

Better say goodbye to Netflix

[@spider-man5262]

Tom Jane is the best punisher berthnal is second

[@jonathanrayne]

Jon Bernthal went toe to toe with Daredevil and beat him. Nuff said.

[@josephhensley2601]

He didn't beat him

[@sushii00]

@@josephhensley2601 pretty sure he shot him in the head and tied him to a chimney

[@vig0_868]

@@josephhensley2601 he won, and daredevil has his suit. Without he would definitely be beaten to dead by frank

[@r3gvaaz221]

@@vig0_868 and the best thing about frank is he never wears a mask

[@nicklaushamm1178]

@@josephhensley2601 yes he did

[@abhimanyuverma1274]

"I'm not the one who dies kid. I'm the one who does the killing."

[@rickey1503]

Bruh do u think this guys channel died

[@xqyzmmm]

Supa_Bad Jam it didn’t die he doesn’t do yt anymore

[@LaloSalamancaGaming69]

Im not in danger skyler i am the danger

[@King-O-Hell]

@@LaloSalamancaGaming69 Lol, great line.

[@LUCIFER-M0RN1NGSTAR]

bernthals punisher is basically the marvel version of john wick lol

[@jacobparish6904]

Forgot to mention Thomas Jane’s entire boardwalk scene. Got shot in both legs, shot in bicep, kicked through railing falling 10ft shot in chest nearly getting blown up. And still swam to the beach . Talk about endurance.

[@checampbell9247]

This. This is exactly what I thought of when he went to endurance. Not just going through two walls.

[@tracemullen1812]

Jon bernthal is still better

[@dyrohe7026]

@@tracemullen1812 well there were only one or two episodes where Jon Bernthals Punisher wasn't full of blood, bruises and broken bones

[@p_4225]

Also mental endurance, that dude saw his whole family murdered

[@matthewkevinobispo6582]

His mom got shot in front of him :(

[@imjennylyn1252]

Berthnal brings a level of believable brutality to the character.

[@antionettekidd9749]

You are right I love berthnal's portrayal, the pain and yes the anger are believable.

[@wassel327]

God damn right

[@mrdiabeto]

Watch the walking dead

[@stanknight9159]

@@mrdiabeto I'm thinking of it. Does he play a good guy? Punisher-like?

[@mrdiabeto]

Stan Knight he plays Shane who isn’t really a good guy nor a bad guy.. you’d have to watch the show to get it. It’s on Netflix

[@ghunt09]

Bernthal should be the only person to play Punisher moving forward.

[@kylo4ever693]

exactly!

[@primary2630]

Disney... lol yeah right

[@humanbeing5330]

facts

[@LeoVault]

I agree. Kinda like Cavill with superman. I know the movies suck but Henry was born for that role.

[@mfandrew3261]

yup

[@Kyle-hm7ee]

Season 2 punisher when he quick draws his weapon and merks 5 dudes who already had their weapons out before they could even react

[@MhtsopoylosChemical]

They were 6 dudes not 5😂

[@shadowstalker527]

@@MhtsopoylosChemical it's just 1 more dude but that's impressive

[@JDJoshofficial]

I think Thomas Jane did a good job as the punisher, I wish his movie had gotten a sequel, he even resembles The Punisher from the comics a little more than Bernthal

[@danskyl7279]

Gotta pick Thomas Jane, love Jon's potrayal of a different Punisher but Jane is just more line in with the comic books.

[@TheKnightPatriot]

Lots of Bernthal love down here. I love his portrayal, but I don’t think Jane’s performances as the Punisher should be forgotten or discounted. He deserves love too.

[@VincentBrando]

Thomas Jane did a great Punisher in the Xbox Video game which came out in 2005! He has a great deep voice and the game was violent and true to The Punisher, But Jon Bernthal has taken the Punisher to another level.

[@punkem733]

He does deserve love, but this is who would win in a fight, not give love to both. Netflix pun would wreck jane's.

[@MrRobschnieder]

I felt like it was two different styles of the punisher. Both were ruthless but Jon's portrayal showed the berserk and fury the punisher is capable of. Thomas' version was the methodical and revenge focused. He out started his enemy and instead of beating him to death he wanted to punish him mentally. Take away everything from him and making him kill his own friend and wife. I love both and can watch both repeadily.

[@Vindominus]

Funny, most of the comments I see are Jane love lol I got you tho, I prefer Bernthal but Jane was the first and only movie Punisher that I really liked.

[@joesee505]

The Knight Patriot Jane for Mia is hands down the best punisher. He just fits the character so well in that movie.

[@m.draven477]

1 batch 2 batch Penny and dime. Come on bros. Simple

[@private679r.i.c.o4]

👌

[@lukestevenson8306]

Flustercuck

[@evans8882]

@@lukestevenson8306 **flustercluck**

[@dr.josemanalo2141]

*tiktak*

[@darkseid477]

9:01 it’s a ballistic knife and an actual weapon that even Russian special forces use as a last resort

[@KoldenKoose]

_Death: So uh... Wanna call it quits?_ *Jon's Punisher: Nah Fam* That got me laughing🤣

[@BenPT15]

Personally I think Frank Castle is the best Punisher. :3

[@kp-chris]

it's not like frank castle is the punisher or anything

[@BenPT15]

xd Absolutely, that title belongs to Frank Castle.

[@redyeah8761]

@@BenPT15 Exactly. 9 + 10 = 21 right? And what about that cow that gave birth yesterday morning? We still have to buy him some food, right?

[@JackSpear1000]

That's like saying 'Peter Parker is the Best Spider-Man'.

[@maxdeckard628]

@@redyeah8761 LMAO that was too much 😂😂😂😂

[@lulurobot2065]

Jon berthnal hands down! No one will ever beat his performance as the punisher!

[@SawYouDie]

Lulu Adness i feel like he should be in movie

[@tristiansharpe5152]

Hugh jackman

[@sirsucksalot3510]

its about them murdering each other not performance

[@sonofflexx5994]

Do u realize it’s not about who’s a better actor ?

[@mariedapitan3369]

jon berthnal the best punisher ever

[@gavinbeazley3365]

Thomas Jane is like master chief from halo but Jon Bernthal is like doom guy from Doom.

[@Rico_71]

Ok that's it. This comment wins. 10/10

[@gamerstheater1187]

Thomas is the old doom guy while Bernthal is Doom Slayer

[@Ho_Lii_Fuk]

9:24 Pistols actually penetrate through objects much better than shotguns no matter what shells you're using. Pellets don't penetrate through armor that well. But you're right that the vest TV-series version was wearing wasn't bulletproof at all because it couldn't stop even 9mm.

[@zancudoc2628]

Yeah if he got shot once with that shotgun he would have had a level 3a military vest but the thing is he got shot twice in the same spot so he would have gotten shot because the pellets would have penetrated

[@rodericklep2858]

his vest stopped every bullet that hit him tho

[@h.plovecat4307]

When you beat people to death with a sledge hammer to the tune of "Hell Broke Luce", you automatically win.

[@kyereturn9665]

Agree!!!

[@anthonysm6001]

Did you not watch the beginning? Jane's character has his entire family brutally killed, hes shot point blank in the chest, blown up and you say he doesnt have endurance

[@ACG7001]

Brain Stem Soup *loose

[@doomguy7707]

Agree

[@ItzWoodz3392]

Yeeeeeeeessssssssss agree ur right this man won the argument

[@brittgroenewegen654]

I think the Punisher would win

[@dexterflash7275]

Britt Groenewegen 😂😂😂

[@d3f3nd47]

I was gonna comment that and then i noticed it was already commented :(

[@imnotreal0763]

Liar, The punisher would destroy The punisher!

[@BlackoutSkeleton]

Britt Groenewegen Agreed but I think Punisher would be a pretty good match for Punisher.

[@jst3358]

Nah you’re dreaming Punisher would win

[@rosemoreno5110]

You forgot to mention how Jon Bernthal's punisher allowed that boss guy to take his gun and point it at him to get the information he needed because he knew torture wouldn't work, and emptied the gun beforehand. To me, Jon Bernthal won intellect.

[@isaiahramirez4521]

Lmao nahh

[@LethalByChoice]

Thomas Jane Punisher: Who are you? Jon Bernthal Punisher: I'm you but stronger

[@ashtonerby8890]

The og punisher and the mcmap punisher

[@CaptainAmercia]

Definitely need to play the Punisher Video Game it’s just perfect

[@hardcordiv4190]

Tom Jane : and I have the better story

[@_frxst_5]

@@hardcordiv4190 not really tbh

[@LUCIFER-M0RN1NGSTAR]

facts

[@danielrocha-garcia8609]

John Bernthal is the best punisher period.

[@MovieGuy666]

yep

[@Gman_2002]

Agreed

[@rahulnath4441]

Yessir

[@whatevs4455]

uuuuhm....Ray Stevenson?

[@aarondarby1597]

SharX Ray Stevenson was pretty boring as The Punisher. Bernthal was way more convincing as Castle. Stevenson was an invincible, overpowered killing machine with no depth or character. Bernthal was a cold blooded killer, but he has his human, down to earth moments. Also, Bernthal did his research and read a lot of the comics, and he understands the character. Thomas Jane was good, but the other actors were bland, pale interpretations of The Punisher.

[@OneEightSeven187]

Season 2 punisher would destroy season 1and movie punisher

[@jaimemartinezjr.3204]

@Craven Payne I know he’s so badass

[@wicked_death2859]

Yeah, Jons Punisher now is better at everything that Thomas Jane Punisher can do

[@SawYouDie]

Crazy how these igga be getting hurt and still be going and John pilgrim go hard 💪🏿

[@sembatimothynkalamo8986]

@@SawYouDie John Pilgrim surprisingly does kick ass. Frank still tore him a new one in the end but it was pretty unexpected how he went through his old supremisist buddies like butter

[@SawYouDie]

Semba Timothy Nkalamo yes brother that was crazy wen he grabbed his head and punched his jaw idk why but i laughed at thats scene that stuff had to hurt

[@MrHellsing76]

I know it's probably been said,and Jon's Punisher already won but giving Thomas Jane the win for his 'vest' was so uneducated, it showed how the Thomas Jane Punisher writers have no idea what impact is or how getting shot works on a human body, as a shotgun at that range, would put him on the ground, While Jon's shows realistic impact from getting hit by a 45. to the chest at close range. Coupled with the fact that all his injuries in season Daredevil season 2, and Season 1-2 of his own show happen in the span of weeks, he literally stitches himself together and just powers on through with barely any need to rest and recover. MCU punisher is honestly the closest there has been to the Comic vers in terms of sheer threat level. unlike almost anyone else, the more you injure him, the more dangerous he gets.

[@davions]

Thomas Jane's Punisher was able to recover from being flung around and stabbed by a giant, within a few hours. Bernthal's Punisher had to be hospitalized. So I think Jane should have won that round.

[@gabrielheffner4499]

I think that was because bernthal went up against 6 Russian's in a gym and Thomas Jane only went up against 1

[@vincegredo]

Thomas Jane's punisher seems more squared away, his tactics are precise and everything he does is practical and effective. Jon's punisher seems more erratic and unpredictable.

[@abdulbah2176]

Put all those together and u have the ultimate killing machine

[@thewolverine7619]

You can plan for all sorts of enemies but the unpredictable ones are impossible to predict that's why they are so dangerous

[@caffeinedelusions]

Which is why the kind of folks who deal with psyops and antiterrorism operations don't plan for what an enemy WILL do, they plan for what an enemy CAN do, and develop multiple responses to fit available scenarios. Unpredictable chaos factors aren't an overpowering advantage, they're an issue, yes... but they're an issue that Tom Jane's Punisher and the people with his background have to account for and adapt to every day.

[@brandoandthenewromantics5842]

Yes I agree

[@FalseF4CZ]

the wolverine 7619 They’re extremely predictable. They resort to their pure wild instincts. Predict that they’ll act like an animal. It’s what jigsaw did in season 2 and made frank think he killed a bunch of innocent people shooting blindly. Jigsaw taunted frank on purpose so he would lose control and think he murdered those people.

[@CAMOHEADSHOT]

While I agree with the outcome, Tom Jane's punisher was shot in the chest multiple times on the dock before he washed up on shore and survived a grenade explosion in a bathtub, as well as a pretty steep tumble down a flight of stairs with the Russian (who snapped his neck on the stairs). Also John Bernthal was brutalized when agent orange tortured him and he survived. Just surprised that these points weren't mentioned in the endurance section.

[@RaulTorres-vr6tm]

Man this is tough. I loved Thomas Jane Punisher. He had an honest love for The Punisher. Jon Bernthal is fantastic as The Punisher. I think honestly the difference is writing and length of ability to dive into the character.

[@squidtron-ck9rq]

Uhh, armor plates are actually ridiculously effective against shotguns. Both pellets and slugs are unable to penetrate most standard body armor plating and normally you need a rifle-caliber round to do anything more than slight dents and scratches.

[@daanvanrijn4117]

THANK YOU! I had to scroll soooo far down for this. People need to check their facts.

[@squidtron-ck9rq]

@@daanvanrijn4117 its not as if there's a guy with a 5 million sub channel dedicated specifically for stuff just like that (cough*DemolitionRanch*cough)

[@sierra1513]

Although getting shot with a shotgun slug would not be fun, body armor or not

[@Blind_Smithy]

​@@sierra1513 the slug would likely cause internal bleeding and break several ribs. a .45 ACP round will wind you and bruise your ribs. possibly causing hairline fractures. A slug carries at least 4 times that energy.

[@sierra1513]

@@Blind_Smithy yeah, that's what I was implying.

[@alexdumitrescu3025]

Let's be honest here, who doesn't like jon bernthal punisher?

[@Gugnar678]

Some guy two comments above this. He thinks jons character is too emotional

[@luisrobles422]

I don't

[@pervysage3425]

I don't

[@aaronh678]

@@alexdumitrescu3025 Well I dislike him as the punisher. So, pleased to meet you?

[@spider-man5262]

His good but I have to say I prefer Tom Jane .

[@evans8882]

Jon Bernthal wins everytime hands down

[@logroller3946]

Still think both are badass in their own way

[@evans8882]

@@logroller3946 jon is a bamboo chute and the other guy is a spaghetti

[@abney_66]

Not everytime but most of the time

[@rcavicchijr]

Toughness is just one part of endurance. There should have been a durability aspect too. Bernthal might have taken more damage and kept going, but he constantly looked like shredded meat. Seriously, Bernthal was running on sheer will by the end of most of his encounters. Jane definitely looked like he physically held up better to damage. Jane might get a few cuts and bruises, but Bernthal literally looked like a zombie that had decayed for two years in water before walking through a saw mill.

[@4sphaltskept163]

Bernthal got hit a lot more tho? If Jane got hit just as much he'd prolly also look like a rotten tomato

[@alexpennymeme1905]

​@@4sphaltskept163Jane was shot through both arms, busted through wood, shot in the heart, hit point blank with a gas explosion into water, and yet still had the strength left to swim to safety. He could simply take more and keep going when compared to Bernthal

[@JaxBlade]

YES!! BEEN WAITING FOR THIS!!

[@isaacquinones6738]

JaxBlade LOVE YOUR VIDEOS MAN!!!

[@justinmalik3158]

jaxblade

[@sebasfl.22]

JaxBlade hey i see u everywhere

[@_General_Grievous__]

Same

[@redcarpetworthy100]

JaxBlade “those people I killed I want you to know that I’d do it all over again if given the chance”

[@PwnzerProductions]

ballistic knives are a real thing

[@blitzninja4396]

Buy me one.

[@napalmitofficial7471]

Blitz Ninja you can't, it's highly illegal everywhere in the US. You can make your own out of house appliances.

[@blitzninja4396]

I was kidding but thanx good to know.

[@OGGHOST364]

For me honestly Thomas Jane will always be the true punisher for me. I love John bernthal as the punisher too but Thomas Jane gives that classic anti hero tone to it. Hard to explain

[@dariuswrongside5811]

I get where you're coming from because he was the guy that they turned the punisher from the original comics to look like when that movie came out because they turned what the punisher look like from the movie with Thomas Jane into what the punisher would look like until they decided to change up the punisher much more. John Is a good punisher but I feel that he's pulling off the maximum punisher idea to it and not the original antihero.

[@CaptainAmercia]

@@dariuswrongside5811 he also voiced the Punisher in the game which hands down is one of my favourite performances

[@anthonyjohnson9106]

Facts

[@kriptgaming4161]

“So you wanna call it quits huh” “Na fam” casually closes door

[@jotun.616]

Dude. Janes tricked his villain into killing his wife and right hand man. He wins intellect by a long shot.

[@-slice-6103]

I wouldn’t say by a long shot, but yes. But Punisher Season 2 adds to Berthals feats, so... :/

[@alexandriaocasio-whoretez5122]

Jon Bernthal is the best punisher EVER! It's not even close.

[@idontgetreplynotifications9667]

Dustin Noobs agreed

[@_DanielFernandez_]

Nope, Ray stevensen was better.

[@thewateversho223gaming]

@@_DanielFernandez_ Who?

[@FinalFlameProductions]

Jane is better.

[@theonetruemexicantm2572]

YES

[@briancrowley7686]

Love both these actors as the punisher, hands down. I thought this was an extremely fair analysis, except one part. As far as endurance, don't forget Thomas Jane's punisher took a bullet in the chest, was left on a dock that blew up, and was thrown into the sea before being found. That was probably worse than that Russian fight.

[@checampbell9247]

To be fair, it's a difficult thing to judge since one version had a full series of screen time to depict these skills and abilities whereas the other had 2 hours and twenty minutes. That's the equivalent of maybe 3 episodes...of a show with 13 per season.

[@Bilal-lp1zb]

Let's do TV show flash Vs DCEU flash

[@stiw91]

Best idea ever

[@YC_001]

If he does that gubz should put the new power that barry got he was going so fast that everyone was still u can say that ezra already did that but he didn’t everyone was still moving the sword and ww was still falling they weren’t still

[@alexau5351]

Bilal Yes

[@jacobholt2086]

I like this but we probably would have to wait a little

[@peewa_2339]

L.R. Yeah I have to agree. We’ll see more of his capabilities with a solo movie.

[@alstone4253]

That's why Jane's punisher needed the dirty laundry film, to give him some good hand-to-hand feats

[@royothegr8216]

Jon bernthal playing the punisher is equivalent to RDJ playing Ironman

[@plasticweapon]

there's no definitive punisher.

[@IceeUltra]

i’d say that taking a point blank 12 guage shot to the chest, regardless of armor, without being winded in the slightest is more of a testament to Old Punisher’s endurance, whereas Bernthals’ shot to the head was more luck than anything. still love them both

[@Ken_.Backwood]

The punisher would win duh come on Gubz

[@Dan81825]

what? nah man its obvious Frank Castle would win, i mean... cmon man

[@HybridFlaav]

Dan81369 thats if ur referring to the 2004 punisher

[@hundjager023]

YNGDMNDX Topic what u on about

[@whataloserd4951]

no I think The punisher would win

[@numberoneintrovert]

I'm gonna go with the guy with the guns.

[@MohammedAlomrani]

11:10 I feel like u could’ve chosen the scene where goes after that one in the gym full of body builders and he just kills all of them

[@edwardheppenstall8690]

Or the Afghanistan flashback where he goes full 1 man army

[@parker7411]

Punisher: *gets shot in Head Also punisher: *endurance 100*

[@redd6653]

Jon Bernthal was born for that role lmao

[@JacobEttinger]

Netflix Punisher needs to be brought into the Movies on the bigscreen in Phase 4.

[@daniellesieur738]

id love to see him be a good or a bad guy, the punisher vs captain america would be great

[@negx3933]

That’s a massive clash of tones. Probably not happening

[@C4pt4inEyebrows]

I dont. The pg13 universe would water him down. Id rather keep him in the show as an unadulterated badass

[@jamretro1336]

Lawrence Stevens Eh, Caps not bulletproof, all he has to do is snipe him.

[@totalmetaljacket789]

Lawrence Stevens Cap is an expert fighter but he isn't impervious to bullets.

[@bwilliam6287]

Do Wolver-- oh wait a minute.....

[@darthheisenburg3807]

b william Hugh Jackman vs 90s Wolverine?

[@ripperdoesntstream347]

Ha. Nobody will ever play wolverine as best as Hugh Jackman

[@goinbonkerz3852]

Don’t forget Jon bernthal was tortured for hours and then proceeded to kill everyone in the lair lol

[@stanknight9159]

"The Punisher is the most dangerous man I know" - Superman. True quote.

[@m3rc120]

You're forgetting John Wick...

[@princesuraj4840]

@@m3rc120 John Wick is nothing in front of Comic Punisher

[@darkriff777]

I love both. Jane's version had a baddie believing he was being cooked by a blowtorch, meanwhile Jane was cooking a piece of meat and jabbing the poor guy with an iceream lolly.

[@totalmetaljacket789]

DPM Actual Frank will gladly just torture you. No pretending needed.

[@91stix39]

see that's the difference. Jon bernthals portrayal of the punisher would've been just burning him with a blow torch

[@miserabletlc2055]

Johnny Pringle the thing is punisher 2004 didnt want to torture that guy because he felt like he wouldve easily talked regardless

[@Hellraiser988]

The Commonly Informed exactly plus he use phycological torture on an idiot

[@miserabletlc2055]

Hellraiser988 Yup. Also its much smarter to turn people against your enemies than just kill them all directly. TJ Punisher was al9t more Manipulative while all the same Punishing. To your enemies pawns into your informants.

[@jacobangeles5539]

Ben Barnes Billy Russo > Dominic West Billy Russo.

[@erikgonzalez928]

Jacob Angeles one is an ex marine in the same death squad as jons punisher and the other was just a mafia thug

[@rafaelkoch7526]

Ben Barneswould kill him easily, a military trained black opps operative vs some mafia thug.

[@blue1133]

I love both versions of the punisher. But gotta go with Jon Bernthal here, i think the problem with the punisher 2004 is that the director and producers had the chance to explore the ultra-gore violence aspect of the character due to the R rating, but they barely touched it ( the closest and only scene that best represents the brutality of the punisher is when he breaks a guy's arms and then proceeds to pierce a knife through his mouth), plus they could've also demonstrated the punisher fighting skills a bit more, specially seeing how Thomas Jane physically prepared for the role, guy looks like a beast but has difficulties with most of the hand to hand encounters in the movie. If they could've fixed those 2 issues i think it would be almost unpredictable to decide which one of the 2 would win.

[@caffeinedelusions]

I've got to give it to Tom Jane. Yeah, Berthnal's Punisher is more physically imposing... but Jane's Punisher is just fundamentally more clever and inventive. Jane's Punisher is trained to get in your head and manipulate not just what the fight is, but how you're going to fight it, until in the end the truth is that he's made you defeat yourself. Berthnal's Punisher would be WAY too easy for Jane's Punisher to psyops against.

[@caffeinedelusions]

Also, Dirty Laundry is nice and all, and I still consider it as good as a canon continuation... but its content doesn't really have an impact on or reveal any new capabilities of the Tom Jane Punisher.

[@bigpapan.g3245]

1987 robocop vs 2014 robocop

[@styl0zgames741]

1987 because it has more movies meaning more features.

[@JackRipper-kz7yz]

BigPapa N.G 2014 would destroy 1987 Robocop

[@transformerdude4251]

I actually love the 2014 Robocop

[@AshReed42]

1987!! The originals are always better 😊

[@ApriliaRSV4F]

1987 would win for sure. But I did like the 2014 movie.

[@smithwesson1896]

Whenever I read a Punisher comic, I hear his quotes in Thomas Jane's voice

[@douglasmonroe7417]

Good video comparison. But you left one thing off about Thomas Jane's Punisher in the endurance category. After punisher got shot, they poured fuel every where and ignited it. Punisher survived an explosion. Not saying that gives him a tremendous advantage. But it is neck and neck when you think about it. Also you mentioned that he had body armor that deflected shotgun shells. So that should've gave him an advantage. Just wanted to point that out.

[@joshm.1398]

He also forgot the fact that Jane's Punisher was shot a couple times and was caught in an explosion and still survived in the beginning

[@mrmarkstv6585]

Ok Flash vs Flash or....I don't know

[@SaucyCheeseburgerwithRanch]

Mr Marks TV which flash?

[@deathmafuba9282]

Skytrainer_ Trent flash

[@l0kumidit641]

yes movie vs tv flash, though I don't think it'll be fair cuz tv flash has more to run with

[@alexisc800]

Robbie Reyes Ghost Rider vs Johnny Blaze Ghost Rider

[@peewa_2339]

I think Johnny blaze. He got shot with an rpg and survived

[@samuelsurfboard9887]

Robbie Reyes got stabbed with pure carbon and survived.

[@graytex8665]

Mashup C3ntr4l so did Robbie

[@AmatoGore]

Magma 308 Johnny can kill many powered humans while Robbie had a hard time taking Quake who is a girl out in their first encounter

[@graytex8665]

Sexy Savage true but that was his first time with someone powered, plus he’s still new to the Rider thing

[@DeathTheKid10]

"Kunai blade shooter" Also known to everybody else as a ballistic knife.

[@ptcool12]

8:44 I love that you put in david so In a just kidding news part 😂 caught me by surprise

[@OscarNovember1776]

Jon Berthnal is the true punisher

[@opedits-ar8920]

That is so true

[@longshotk1340]

Good video. I'm a fan. But you should've mentioned the fact that Thomas Jane survived a face to face explosion, also fell into the sea while being shot

[@TheQuatum]

longshot K1 yea I like Gubz but this one wasn't so good

[@AmatoGore]

longshot K1 survive is different from endurance. Bernthal get shot, stabbed, and etc but still managed to got up and continue to fight like nothing happens. I didn’t watched the Jane movie yet but from another comment someone said “in the beginning, jane survive explosion” so i assume he pass out so still Bernthal>Jane. If i wrong then oh well

[@RottenTomatoRejects]

That’s not about endurance. It’s about how long you can keep going. Bernthal has taken much worse beatings and kept going. The explosion was something that would either instantly kill him or he’d survive. He survived. But you didn’t see him get back up. In fact it took awhile for him to get better. Bernthal took a headshot which is way more likely to kill you, he’s been stabbed multiple times, shot multiple times, beaten, etc, and still kept going, and even had enough to make him rage while he should’ve been dead 3 days before that when he got shot a bunch of times.

[@thefanwithoutaface8105]

He did not keep going, by the end of the Interrogation scene with the Irish guys, he maybe managed to take out a hand ful of other dudes and had to be hospitalized just to avoid dying. Jane's Punisher got beaten to death by the Russian and just kept on going.

[@167thSpartan]

He did about as much as Bernthal's character after the interrogation scene. In the Movie, he was beaten to near death, then splashed water in the dudes face and tackled him down a flight of stairs before passing out. Now if you want to talk about recovery, Jane was back in action the next day.

[@unfazedreview3000]

Thomas Jane totally. The vibe, the voice (especially in The classic PS2 game). Dirty Laundry rocked too.

[@Frezznine]

I think the coolest thing about the punisher is it’s implied that he gets used to getting shot. So he himself can deal the pain of being shot repeatedly with or without the armor. It’s a known fact that someone can actually get used to being shot to which is crazy

[@iceandsnow5183]

"Bernthal is gouging out eyeballs whenever he can." 🤣🤣🤣 Love this video, great job! Jon is the one and only true Punisher.

[@ijathill]

Jons punisher is way more realistic if we’re being honest, that’s why I like his more.

[@e115x525]

Im sorry what? Realistic? Do you know what it takes for the body to recover from gunshot wounds? Thats weeks out of action at a minimum. Tom Janes is about 35x more realistic.

[@ASRMN27]

Yeah no, jons is beyond fantasy.

[@darthdorito-spicyflav.5460]

We're really going to use the word realistic with comics?

[@HELLFIRE-yw4ko]

Ya

[@thedarkknight646]

No bernthal’s portrayal is anything but realistic. Thomas jane’s portrayal is tactical and calculated. bernthal’s punisher is a run and gunner rambo type

[@cassiusfelix2805]

This is going be fun to rewatch

[@AssassinEmbers]

While I grew up loving Thomas jane's punisher and he introduced to me to the character I've come to love Jon Bernthal's version way better and I've come to a realization that he truly brought justice to the character jon Bernthal's punisher truly is the best punisher ever and I really hope to see jon take up role of the punisher again in a movie someday

[@CaptainAmercia]

I personally prefer him in the Video game along with his amazing dialogue and quotes as the punisher along with the amazing music it all just same together as the ultimate Punisher experience

[@uncannypigeon8754]

Flash (Erza Miller) vs Flash (Grant Gustin) Riddler (Jim Carrey) vs Riddler (Gotham) Thor (MCU) vs Thor (1988) Cat Woman (2004) vs Cat Woman (2012) Venom (Spiderman 3) vs Venom (2018) Wonder Woman (2016) vs Wonder Woman (1975) Captain America (MCU) vs Captain America (1979) Bane (1997) vs Bane (Dark Knight) Howard The Duck (MCU) vs Howard The Duck (1986) Nick Fury (David Hasselhoff) vs Nick Fury (Sam Jackson) Deadpool (Origins) vs Deadpool (2016) Dr. Strange (1978) vs Dr. Strange (MCU) King Pin (2003) vs King Pin (2015) TMNT (2014) vs TMNT (1990) Shredder (2014) vs Shredder (1990) Dr. Doom (2004) vs Dr. Doom (Fant4stic) Elektra (2003) vs Elektra (2015) Joker (Dark Knight) vs Joker (Suicide Squad) Green Arrow (CW) vs Green Arrow (Smallville) Lex Luthor (1978) vs Lex Luthor (2016) Zod (2013) vs Zod (1980) Mr. Freeze (1997) vs Mr. Freeze (Gotham) Robin (1966) vs Robin (1997) Spiderman (2016) vs Spiderman (2002) Batman (1966) vs Batman (1989)

[@brickheadstudios8372]

Good list but it's Bane.

[@uncannypigeon8754]

Brickhead Studios oh thanks lol

[@SvpremeJay]

Uncanny Pigeon can y’all like this so gubz can like this

[@zainsheikh8894]

Uncanny Pigeon after seeing infinity war mcu thor stomps

[@The_Buff_Guy]

I agree with the result but you forgot to mention that Jane was ALSO brought back from the dead after he got shot in the chest real close to the heart. The bullet was about as close to his heart and Bernthal's was to his brain... so yeah, both their endurance levels are quite outstanding.

[@billylee4460]

I dont know man, Thomas survive an explosive point blank though....But since the movie only have so much screen time... of course the TV one gonna win.

[@jerven325]

Billy Lee so did jon

[@billylee4460]

Trevora Big Pussi But he didn't survive one at point blank. To survive what Thomas did your limps and internal organs would of been blasted off. But than again it's a movie.

[@jerven325]

Billy Lee true

[@stayfrosty5070]

Don't forget the near drowning, where oxygen could have been cut to his brain putting his endurance on par or higher than bernthal's

[@zaodedong9935]

The comic book Punisher would destroy both of them. 🤣

[@georgewillis7348]

Bernthal hands down. 2004 film was good but as soon as I seen the Netflix series, I was amazed by his amazing portrayal of the punisher character. Also, had 10x more brutal fight scenes and he's down right savage. Hope the season 3 speculation is not just a pipe dream.

[@tcdoescomicslive9369]

Always a dope watch. You the man Gubz

[@rafaykhokhar2670]

TC Does Comics wait a minute, I know u, I follow u on the Instagram

[@tcdoescomicslive9369]

das me!!

[@lw9207]

Been waiting for this for so long THANK YOU GUBZ

[@Basedroider]

First of all, Thomas Jane IS the best punisher. Period. Secondly, you clearly out looked the fact that Frank Castle was shot in the head and bullets riddled his body in the beginning of the second punisher, with Thomas Jane in it.

[@MrShiftey13]

I swear, Berthnal's Punisher had to have a mutant healing factor. It's too ridiculous watching him heal and get back up an episode later or even in the same episode. Physical Therapy not needed, haha!

[@matthewvandeberg7642]

Plz do the jack nicleson joker vs suicide squad joker

[@TheRobbyVerse]

AdventureJedi24 he choose Jared cause he's a modern version of jack joker

[@cloroxbleach7781]

Jared Leto is not the joker he is simply just a pimped out clown

[@williamlampkin3933]

Ill save you the trouble.... nicholson wins

[@markhellings4203]

R.i.p stan lee❤

[@rumbazumba3189]

Coming back to gubz's videos everytime I rewatch a movie

[@unofficial_slash4541]

Don't forget the scene where Jon's Punisher kept taking metal gloves to the faces for a straight 6 hours or more at the end of season one. He's also scarier imo.

[@creativeworkshopguy523]

Make cw flash vs Justice leauge flash. Or cw superman vs Henry Cavil superman.

[@happywheeler6389]

CreativeWork shopGuy not really fair TV show flash is broken

[@creativeworkshopguy523]

Happy Wheeler How do you mean "broken"? Love your user name by the way.

[@happywheeler6389]

CreativeWork shopGuy at times he can Mach 4 while other times he can't outrun a motorcycle nearly impossible to measure his speed

[@creativeworkshopguy523]

Danny SJ Maybe but cw's superman has the fortress of solitude so he has the ancient kryptonian knowledge. And he didn't got ass kicked against metallo completely.

[@creativeworkshopguy523]

Majin 21 Which flash? Cw right? Whatever, the DCEU flash can run just as fast as the cw's flash.

[@reecewainman7850]

Do grant gustin flash vs Ezra Miller flash

[@imnotreal0763]

Grant's flash is faster. But Ezra still has a chance.

[@skyrimplayer2547]

That should wait until the Flash solo film comes out, you know to make it fair

[@TheFabioOrchedella]

Asd_Maker not true ezras faster by a long shot

[@imnotreal0763]

Gubz calculated that Ezra's speed is mach 27, But he also calculated Grant's flash's speed, Which was faster than savitar's speed (Which was over mach 40)

[@TheFabioOrchedella]

Asd_Maker sorry, my mistake

[@backlash7232]

I loved the way Jon Bernthal’s Punisher utilized Military hand to hand combat in the fight scenes!

[@Alphamask978]

I think both Bernthal’s & Jane’s version of the punishers were both skilled in different ways and provided different threats to their enemies but I think Bernthal would probably win though I feel if it was a show down.

[@Slaterbrah]

It’s a ballistic knife and the Punisher LOVES the ballistic knife in the comics

[@jwaximus1113]

that moment I realize my dad Is super human bc he got shot in the head in the Marine Core

[@cr8zysn1per10]

@@bruhmoment042 Corps

[@jaydenmitchem8282]

Watching the Netflix punisher and makes me forget about him in The Walking Dead when I watch the Netflix one he seems like a totally different person

[@retrodoodmanx7161]

Bernthal hands down. Perfect for the role. Like RDJ as Iron Man, Samuel Jackson as Nick Fury, Hugh Jackman as Wolverine, Chris Evans as Cap Murica, Tom Hiddleston and Chris Hemsworth as Loki and Thor.

[@pascho1057]

Nick fury is the only one that off in your list

[@retrodoodmanx7161]

@@pascho1057 Care to tell why? I'm curious as to who is your pick for Fury.

[@whitewolf6113]

Gubz I can’t stress this enough... Your videos are like Mount Everest quality if every other video on youtube is that 10 feet hill across my street. For real I love your content so much, I don’t even mind that your videos are far a part cuz I can tell while watching that you put a ton of effort into them. Besides I know you have a lot to do in school and such which I respect that you prioritise. Keep up the great work Gubz, your videos are always the ones I look forward to the most

[@jeezul]

Jon is a bad ass Punisher, but I had more of an emotional connection with Thomas' Punisher. He felt more of a family man to me.

[@l0kumidit641]

jack frost yeah jons punisher was a family man but he u know...

[@johndobson2674]

jack frost See I relate better to Bernthal's Frank Castle. For one, as a Marine, I'm a little biased towards Jon's Punisher. Secondly, I served with 1st Force Reconnaissance Battalion in '02, Detatchment One from '03 to '06, and 1st Marine Raider Battalion from '06 to '11. This Frank Castle being a Recon Marine and my having been a Recon Marine just generally make it easier for me to relate to him. While Micro, and Madani, and Karen are all wondering why he is the way he is, I'm sitting back and wanting to buy the man a beer and offer him a place to stay. I've been there, I understand what they portray this Castle as having gone through in terms of combat. While I didn't have me wife and kid killed in front of me, I was sitting in Kandahar and when mail call came, I got a single envelope with a Dear John letter, and divorce papers. Really because of my own experiences, Jon Bernthal's Frank Castle is much easier for me to relate to.

[@l0kumidit641]

John Dobson Thanks for your service mate!

[@noahyoung2910]

Both Punishers were Marines, it's just not shown in the 2004 movie but it is mentioned

[@GriffinKneesock]

Its strange looking back on it. Excluding the original 80's movie, each popular Punisher iteration for me had a key thing right, I wish I could just combine them all. Jane has the perfect Punisher voice, The actor (name is failing me right now) from Warzone nailed the "attitude" akin to Garth's Punisher. And then you have Berthnal, who I think nails the look.

[@faheemwyne5098]

Fair analysis. BTW these 2 are my favourite versions of The Punisher

[@maximuskoltun3283]

Don't forget how he took a beating from Wilson fisk