Quentyn is Alive Q&A

Preston answers questions about the Quentyn's Alive video.
Also, check out Preston in Esquire Magazine: www.esquire.com...
Q&A guide:
1. House Drinkwater's name
2. Hero's Journey and a boy goes to war
3. The Tattered Prince
4. Quentyn's future
5. Dany and Quentyn
6. Quentyn's genes
7. The Winds of Winter
8. Quentyn's whereabouts
9. Quaithe's prophecy
10. The oil's lethality
11. Quentyn's dragon bond
12. Martells and telepathy
13. House Martell and House Yronwood
14. House Martell and Valyrians
15. Quentyn and story's end
16. Quentyn's smile
17. The genetics of house Martell
18. Drink's sword
19. Quentyn's health
20. Secrecy
21. Illyrio, Blackfyres and House Yronwood
22. Doran's plan

[@transformersrevenge9]

preston is probably crying somewhere in the corner, after seeing how well D&D handled the dornish master plan in the new episode.

[@spetsnazbeaver]

We need a review of Season 6 Episode 1: The Bad Poosy Squad, ASAP

[@Mattocon757]

Drinkwater is a real name - one of them won a Premier League winners medal last year for Leicester.

[@chingizzhylkybayev8575]

Under the sun of Dorne, wealth is measured in water as much as in gold. So I always thought Drinkwater makes perfect sense as a Dornish surname. It would be stupid af in the Riverlands, that's for sure.

[@chingizzhylkybayev8575]

...and so Doran Martell is welcomed to the Westeros Club of Terrible Fathers.

[@naimaahmed9730]

Chingiz Zhylkybayev he takes his place with the likes of Tywin Lannister and Randyll Tarley

[@arcanefire7511]

@@naimaahmed9730 That's a great exaggeration lol

[@psammiad]

Tsk - Drinkwater is an Old English surname of ancient origin, attested as an ironic nickname for noted alcoholics or innkeepers!

[@rockchalk1257]

Thoroughly enjoy all your videos, particularly how you piece together the seemingly disparate supporting evidence throughout the source material. But if I had to push back on one conclusion you've made it is that GRRM is essentially a hippie at heart and that the "point" of the whole series is that War is futile and itself is the great evil. I’ve seen interviews where GRRM discusses his conscientious objector status in Vietnam, and he mentions, that if he had been drafted during WWII he would have fought, because that was a war worth fighting. If there exists a Hippie Scale with a 10 being your quintessential tie-dyed flower child, and a 1 being Curtis LeMay, I’d say GRRM is about a 6 (maybe 6.5). He certainly leans towards the Love&Peace side, but when I read GRRM there is nothing written in black and white. He loves the gray areas where opposing views on any subject can make very valid points; and this never leads to a clean, concise conclusion to be made. This is the #1 reason I love his stories, it is a much more compelling reflection of the real world. Without a doubt a major theme in his works is the human cost that comes from war. But if GRRM believes that WWII was a war worth fighting, is there any corollary in the World of Ice and Fire? If Dragons represent nuclear weapons, is there any reason that justifies using Nuclear weapons? Let’s say there exists a worldwide slave trade… would it be worth using nuclear weapons to end a worldwide slave trade? Maybe so. This seems to be much more in line with the moral dilemmas the show up throughout his stories.

[@lastEvergreen]

15:02 "Was taking a dragon Doran's plan all along?" "Of Course!" "Well congratulations you got yourself a dragon, what's the next step of your master plan?" "Crashing this Throne. With no survivors!"

[@sflr38]

Good video and article. I know eventually everyone will realize how just how much insight you have into asoiaf, Preston. You are head and shoulders above any other theorist out there and I've checked. I'm just happy I've been able to take this ride with you on your channel, others will be watching these videos years from now and finally realizing how right you were long before they wanted to believe it. Thanks again for sharing all your hard work and ideas with us!

[@omg_look_behind_you]

Probably only half of it, though. His theory crafting is still on par and often better than the material he is dissecting. Wish he would write.

[@AIfeim]

PRESTON ON SUICIDE WATCH AFTER NEW EPISODE TAKE HIS SHOELACES

[@ThereIsNoLord]

You thought S6 was bad. It had so much worse to get.

[@sedaniels8701]

I never get tired of "hooray, poo joke." The flat sarcasm of your voice is so cutting it's instant death. Beautiful.

[@NUFCMVFC]

Lol, can't wait for S6 E1 "What you are missing"....

[@akburst510]

+NUFCMVFC 7 hour video

[@rayraygunner]

+NUFCMVFC actually made me lol

[@rob27pal]

you are a legend for the entry of your video. thank you for doing what you do

[@TheIronUnderneathLL]

congratulations on the Esquire article. It's wonderful to see you as a part of the ASOIAF Game of Thrones community, being written about in Esquire. The mainstream media is taking more of an interest in GRRM's ASOIAF, which is wonderful. Only good can come from that!. This period of time we are so lucky to have; to be able to listen to George speak, be interviewed and him giving so much information,such is a gift and has never really happened before with great literature. We've never had the means of knowing a great author while enjoying his books, especially when they aren't even finished yet. It's an important story, and I'm so glad you're getting recognized for your videos. i know how much hard work goes into making a video, so thanks for all your work and being recognized for it. Be careful about the media. I have great respect for real journalism, but there are so many out there who don't follow that hard line to do the research, get the facts straight and only report those! But, all of that aside, great job. Your view on ASOIAF it's really interesting and does make sense if you've read all of GRRM's writing. It's pretty obvious that it's about trauma from war, ptsd, senseless death and what the planet does with that, because the planet feels it too.

[@rosecityandbeyond]

9:30 Objection! ADWD Chapter 14, Tyrion: "Tyrion had glimpsed a dozen different sorts: large turtles and small ones, flatbacks and red-ears, softshells and bonesnappers, brown turtles, green turtles, black turtles, clawed turtles and horned turtles, turtles whose ridged and patterned shells were covered with whorls of gold and jade and cream. Some were so large they could have borne a man upon their backs. *Yandry swore the Rhoynar princes* *used to ride them across the river.* He and his wife were Greenblood born, a pair of Dornish orphans come home to Mother Rhoyne."

[@PrestonJacobstheSweetrobin]

+Dessa Christmas Fair enough, I stand corrected. :)

[@rosecityandbeyond]

Preston Jacobs Woo! I love your videos, glad I could contribute just a little bit ^.^

[@ktoth29]

+Dessa Christmas That old man of the river/giant turtle passage is one of the weirdest in Dance. I'd like to see Preston delve into GRRMS turtle fetish.

[@billsoulta1050]

+Preston Jacobs I have read ADWD two times but i'm still confused... Could you make a video about the situation in Mereen when ADWD ends including the whereabouts of the characters involved ? ( for example where is Daario, the mercenary groups, the other minor characters ? )

[@billsoulta1050]

Cool because i aint reading it again

[@Sharks]

Preston answering my question has to be one of the greatest moments of my young life.

[@ashleydebartolo1219]

Congrats on the Esquire article Preston!

[@minch333]

+Ashley DeBartolo You think that's impressive? I was just featured in a Preston Jacobs video!

[@igorandrade9508]

6 years later I finally found this! Thank you so much!

[@ironmaiden5901]

Preston is going to have a heart attack when he watches the new episode

[@arturkushukov1815]

+Johnny Bills I'd love to see his reaction.

[@charlesgoodson1001]

I think Davos will use Melissandras ruby necklace to posse as John to lead the wildlings.

[@joeb3008]

Peston, I been a huge proponent of yours since your first video, your pink letter video about 2 years ago. I'm so glad I stumbled upon your video by chance all those years ago and had the opportunity to forward your new videos to my friends to enjoy.I like when you baffle me with out of this world tin foil and feel even better when I see eye to eye with you, posting comments, etc. I love your takes, your wit and am grateful for all your wonderful videos. you are most def a great and integral part of this community. I think you are highly intelligent and articulate And I couldn't be more stoked or happy for your success I can only hope that you are actually making some good bank from all your hard work. With that being said; ARE YOU OUT OF YOUR DAMN MIND? As Butch from PULP FICTION would put it-QUENTYNS DEAD BABY, QUENTYNS DEAD. His arch is pure perfection, brilliant and wrapped tight with a nice little bow on it. Its an anti-Kerouac story a deconstructed take on the adventure trope. It shows Doran is a stupid ass who loves kids but then sends his only son on a fools errand. Even his close friend Drink drops his swag demeanor and calls him out before the dragon foley because its such a fools errand. Its about how hard it is for a son to live up to his fathers standards, about a boy willing to do anything to have his father respect him and pat him on the back. Its what every man has to deal with, stepping out of his father's shadow. And Doran cast a huge shadow being the leader and prince of his country. The reason I love these books is because at its heart ASOIAF is a bunch of short stories with a bigger universe at its core, its an anthology series really. Im sure you like me are a fan of TALES FROM THE CRYPT, TWILIGHT ZONE, TALES FROM THE DARK SIDE, etc These books contain short stories blended into a bigger universe with its own stories to be told. Similar to the DARK TOWER series (King combined all his previous works into one bigger whole)or DC/MARVELL comics universes, the 90s OUTTER LIMITS did this as well or AMERICAN HORROR STORY to a lesser degree. GRRM has always been an anthology writer inspired by these short stories that share a collective universe. Think about it, in 1 chapter ARYA does her thing while in the next DAVOS does his thing and , JON SNOW plot deals with the grand universe.they have a story One chapter is horror like the red wedding in STORM while then theres a funny one like the Squishers tale from FEAST . What I can't get my head around is how someone so smart and well read could be so short sided, off base and just plain out wrong about something so obvious. I mean you can obviously write and I assume you studied creative writing. Cant you see this? I can tell you as a want-to-be writer, its really, really hard. Heck, even writing the worst professional script in the history of tv , film is hard, let alone a sweeping fantasy epic. GRRM is just one person, no one is smart enough or has a memory good enough to be able to twist and stretch all these event, places, characters around. I know the devil is in the details, but the poor guy is just one man. Its just impossible for one person to be that detailed and precise let alone a hippie writer. If you break down every minute sentence and word you can twist anything the man writes into whatever you want it to be to prove a point. If QM is indeed alive, and he most def isn't I would say GRRM has jumped the shark even. Okay my friend, sorry for the really long post. Thanks for getting me and keeping me passionate and excited about ASOIAF. I haven't read them since last spring and although I decided I'm not watching this season, and even though I'm convinced GRRM will not be finishing this series theres a tiny part of me that holds out hope that theres a chance because of people like you and RADIO WESTEROS, UNSPOILED, BFISH ETC. Thanks for the fun!

[@Fnidner]

damn

[@maggazilla]

Danny Drinkwater has been a revalation in the Leicester midfield. What a season!

[@da_ghoul9432]

Wait! YOu work for the State Department? No wonder you understand the game of thrones.

[@robertcorsini2641]

so much for the "Dornish Master Plan"

[@deathtokc4]

I really need Preston's reaction to the season 6 premiere right now!

[@magicalsimmy]

Sooooo....has anyone else been constantly refreshing their KZbin feed in the hopes Preston uploads a video on S6E1 tonight? Lol! No pressure, Preston. I just really want to hear you say (SPOILER), "Annnd finally, it is revealed that Melisandre does indeed ovulate sand." :D

[@arturkushukov1815]

+Skeptical Simmy Yep. I mean, for every good scene it had two awful ones. I want to see Preston rage about it.

[@NUFCMVFC]

+Skeptical Simmy Yeah this episode review will be just as entertaining as the episode itself, Ozzyman take should be interesting as well

[@HelyneMay]

I respectfully disagree. Quentyn's story, IMO, is a fable (in part) about being a good person without the moral fortitude to challenge atrocities. Quentyn was a nice kid who fails immediately in the hero's quest by refusing to resist or question his father. He is a good soldier who does as he was told. Making his journey into a chivalrous quest was Quentyn talking himself into war and atrocities as glory, as people will do about war. His father knew he would do anything to please him, and also to not be humiliated, and set him up to either steal a dragon, or fail with Arianne as the beneficiary of the failure (part of the greater Dornish Master Plan). Doran is "the princely sort", willing play high born children like chess pieces, and Arianne is his chosen queen...or "king", but under Dornish law. I'm probably wrong about at least half of this. ;) But I believe that Doran is going to back f'Aegon, not Daenerys. I agree that Quentyn was a distraction from the *real* Dornish Master Plan, and I am interested in what you have to say about Doran not wanting to steal a dragon. I've kind of theorized that Doran set Quentyn up to fail, but being able to steal a dragon would be a "value added", if unexpected, benefit to sending him to Meereen. Do you believe that Marwyn is related by marriage to Doran, and that they would have some [long forgotten by most] knowledge about your theory about dragon riding and hatching genetics? Will have to check out the Esquire piece. Congratulations!

[@thehobowizard]

I'm kinda worried about Preston, last nights episode may have been the final nail in the coffin for his sanity.

[@EdAnsbro]

Congrats on the Esquire article, Preston. I've been following your theories enthusiastically since I first spotted your Tower of Joy video. The Minds of Wolves and Robins theory really blew me away, and now the Esquire article has allowed me to share it, and thereby shock, my not QUITE as nerdy GoT friends. Keep'em coming!

[@ToneRetroGaming]

Congrats on the Esquire shout out

[@TheChiefpokishi]

Gratz on the Esquire article Preston. I hope it brings much more awareness, and followers, to your channel. Keep up the good work man.

[@BreakingBad1009]

Please do a video on how Trystane Martell can teleport.

[@jaygotgame1]

I think you got something special here on this channel bro you take George past books to make your theories pretty spot on when comes to game of thrones

[@crg750]

Congrats on the Esquire article Preston! I am an Esquire print subscriber and I was pumped to see they picked you out from all the ASOIAF critique(ers) on the KZbin. I have been following your channel for a few years now and it is always interesting and provides well researched, concise theses that offer practical insights into a world we all really enjoy. Thanks!

[@Starcom23]

After every each video from Preston I need a break - simply one man can't take this much information!

[@osirisgem]

Grinder it.... I knew I knew you from some where.

[@PrestonJacobstheSweetrobin]

+Vincent Amour Oh, Vincent! I didn't recognize you from the front. :P

[@osirisgem]

Haha that genuinely made me laugh out loud.

[@bobbybee2975]

Congratulations on the Esquire plug. Watch out for them though, looks like they dug into your personal life a little… Great point on Drinkwater taking the Tattered princes place, hadn’t thought of it before but it sounds completely possible.

[@Salamon2]

Preston, I know it's been YEARS since any action was on this video, but I recently discovered a bit of Stuart history which Quentyn's story seems (at least to me) to be directly pulled from. It's from English history, yes, specifically under the Stuart dynasty (I seem to recall GRRM saying in an interview he was inspired partly by the Stuart dynasty for the Targaryens in exile, but that's my memory at work, so take that for what it's worth). In any case, the history: Charles I, was not supposed to be his father's heir, his older brother Henry was, but Henry died of typhoid fever, leaving Charles his father's heir. Charles was not known for being that handsome (his older brother once teased him for having "rickety legs", nor was he see as a golden boy like his older brother Henry had been. However he was his father's heir and so a great match had to be made for him. An idea was proposed for Charles to be betrothed to a Princess of Spain, Charles and his buddies got the notion into their head that they'd travel to Spain themselves for Charles to ask the Infanta himself, and that he and his companions would do so in disguise passing as a common merchant for most of the trip. It was an idea out of a chivalric romance and Charles was a keen reader of those so he liked the notion. Heck, just to give you an idea of the kind of people on the party with him: the Duke of Buckingham, Charles' best friend, was more charming and handsome than Charles was (remind you of someone?). The trip was plagued with hazards and not all of Charles' buddies made it, but eventually Charles did get to Spain, and he did ask the Infanta to marry him, and she was at first shocked who she thought was a common merchant was in fact the Prince of Wales her parents had been negotiating to betrothe her to, and then seeing he was likely to pull many other crazy stunts like this, ultimately refused his offer. Charles slunk home in humiliation from the entire affair. Found that out from a documentary about the Stuart dynasty that you can find here on KZbin (specifically one which is about a minor lordly Welsh family which rose in power thanks to the Stuart dynasty, and stopped existing along the same time as the Stuarts--one of the sons of that family traveling and dying on the way to Spain). ETA: Found the title if you want to check it out yourself: The Stuarts A Bloody Reign. So, given that it's plainly clear GRRM isn't "subverting the Hero's Journey" but instead is repackaging history here, I think you have another tool in your arsenal when someone brings up the "subverting the Hero's Journey" argument when arguing about whether Quentyn is alive or not. It's not so much subversion, as it is history repackaged.

[@Jasonblade9012]

Preston, congrats for the article. Well deserved. I have one request. Could you make a series of videos about John like you did with Danny? I would like to know what's the deal with Alys Karstark, and in general another view with what happen to him in the books.

[@os44881616]

i actually thought that Quentyn was a bit of a Hobbit parody...

[@mortimersnead5821]

I just noticed that the video for "What You Are Missing 3.7" is tagged with a picture of Jaime who is noticeably missing a hand. To see if this was a running gag, I looked at the playlist. The only comparables were 2.10 that shows Arya missing most of her hair, and 3.1 where Davos is conspicuously missing his fingerbones. But that's just 3 out of 26, so it's probably not a real thing. But it should be. There are so many characters with missing bits.

[@jordanbean5507]

Great vid. Thank you for addressing my question and that makes a lot of sense. I have been reading more of GRRMs other work because of your channel and I am really enjoying it.

[@zachphillips9401]

4/20 Heres to you making this holiday that much better

[@nickkoch3467]

Congrats on the Esquire article, you deserve some attention for your theories. I know you say you're wrong for about half of it, but I'd say you're making better guesses than most of these theorists out there with all your background checks and extra research.

[@kettlemagic]

Congrats on the article! As always looking forward to more of your content!

[@PrestonJacobstheSweetrobin]

+kettlemagic Thank you!

[@ToneRetroGaming]

Grinder it damn lool

[@kandiemakeup]

Yess Preston! congratulations on 100,000 subscribers! you deserve it!!

[@Jaqen-HGhar]

Wow man making it in Esquire? That's awesome, you have come soooo far since your first videos. I'm gonna share that article all over the damn place. Feel like there might be some slight hope for the show to show at least SOME good stuff this season. I don't think it can recover from some of the "butterfly wings" they stepped on and it's still being run by B&W but who knows. This happens every year I convince myself they actually care about the world and then by the end of the year I feel like you did with the recap you did for episode S5Ep10 lol.

[@farabisalauddin6049]

Congrats dear Preston. I love the way imagined the ending. Thank you for all the great videos.

[@easports8009]

Congrats on the article! Love the channel!

[@BIZARBIES]

Congrats on the shout out in the article Preston! Your channel is one of my faves and it's cool to see you get some props for your research on GoT. I look forward to another season of GoT and your videos!

[@koolhitman1]

Wow Esquire Magazine wrote a piece about you. That is pretty cool.

[@TheAwesomeLamp]

Drinkwater is a real name. There's a footballer named that playing for Leicester City

[@ThereIsNoLord]

You think Sopranos came up with a name like Matthew Bevilaqua without doing any research? And yes, I do like responding to five year old comments.

[@Sora744]

8:53 House Martell is actually, Rhoynish and Andal, not first men.

[@deathmachine808]

You gonna change the channel name, buddy? 'Esquire Magazine Presents: Preston Jacobs'? This is honestly one of your best videos yet.

[@justniquol8972]

OMG thank you so much for answering my question.

[@randinho8872]

So much for the Dornish masterplan.....

[@lite4998]

+Sam Randles I think the last episode is a literal metaphor for how the showrunners butchered the Dornish storyline :P

[@lite4998]

Sam Randles But that brings up a whole new question of when Trystane learned to teleport, you know since he was supposed to be on the ship to KL.

[@MisterFourby]

+Denis Safiev From what I understood, he was on the ship. Just watch the scene before we see him in the boat; he's actually in King's Landing. I'm not saying it makes any sense: just that the Sand Snakes stole the Baelish/Melisandre fast travel. Also it means that Trystane stayed in the boat... No room given or whatever.

[@danielf4529]

YOU WERE THE CHOSEN ONE, PRESTON. I loved you...

[@WBG123098]

Props on the Esquire article

[@reddirt780]

RIP D.M.P

[@Sarsol1989]

Nice. Looking forward to other Q&A episodes. Do you have any plans to make this a more/less regular series, like answering questions after finishing each series?

[@classycrow1677]

I think a more correct interpretation is Quentyn is dead, and given that he was the only point of view character in the room, he had to observe what was happening for the sake of the narrative. Had he died instantly, it would have read "Quentyn turned and threw his left arm across his face to shield his eyes from the furnace wind... END CHAPTER (Because he died suddenly, and dead people can't narrate)

[@ledhole6778]

The very best analysis, as usual Mr. Jacobs. You and AltshiftX are a huge cut above the rest!

[@JasonWilliams89]

*refreshes sub box again*

[@woihjsd]

congratulations on the exposure! you've come a long way and your videos are so in-depth. keep em coming :)

[@KingoftheValar]

RIP house Martell, RIP Areo Hotah. Preston what did we do to deserve this?

[@Christopherjazzcat]

Quentyn ending up burned/disfigured and reassembling a frog would certainly be a sick joke I could see GRRM making.

[@samueljones8100]

Your videos always leave me with so many more questions :(

[@warrenray9760]

Grats on esquire, I hope it skyrockets your subs

[@TheDeetster]

and coming soon, Quentyn is Alive Q&A Q&A

[@Mankorra_Gomorrah]

Q&A Q&Q Part 1.1

[@senorallen9938]

Esquire! Next stop: guest star on Game of Thrones as a maester

[@oultimonome]

Sir, congrats on the interview! And, once more, for your insights. I think maybe even GRRM himself never re-read his own work with such detail as you did! Keep on the good work, see you in season 6!

[@ferraghamo]

I just love how 'Drinkwater' sounds.

[@leefroy5152]

It's nice to see you slowly closing in on 100k subs you definitely deserve it, always look forward to when i see an upload by you

[@PrestonJacobstheSweetrobin]

+WilkoGaming Thank you! I think youtube allows me to buy an award at 100,000. :)

[@loganmcstien90]

always respect your videos as youve read all or almost all GRRMs work. Authors tend to have reoccurring themes and motives and you sniff them out well. thank you.

[@protato911]

wow almost 100th subs, always love your channel, can't wait to see you get that sliver play button.

[@PewPewPlasmagun]

I'm rooting for (F)Aegon because Varys is Tuf lololol but still, a good cause. Better than other.

[@tynoguchi7450]

Thanks for answering for my question

[@Kapulaites]

As I started watching your channel after Season 5, I cannot tell you how exited I am to listen to your recaps! Thank you so much. What you are missing 3.8? Question: Is there any channel on KZbin that you go to for GOT info? You are the best by far. Just wondering if there is another channel you can recommend. I respect your opinion. Thanks

[@NxMaGiiCz]

You should do more Q&A's as it keeps the discussion going on your videos and allows deeper exploration!

[@atomicsunrise85]

good to see you getting noticed!! Glad I found your channel, I needed to hear what other book readers thought, I've read ice & fire 3 times, and my friends haven't got past book 1 yet.

[@wiser82]

Read the article. It's cool to understand everything the article is already saying already. Sounds like you have an interesting full time job. How awesome would a university class be with you as the prof. Well I guess that's what's already kinda happening here. Keep up the good work and the high video count!

[@wariyaintreyonk5350]

Thank you +Preston Looking forward to get the answer from your next Deeper Dorne video.

[@jirkakalecky2782]

Wasn't Nettles a seed? Making it possible for her to have dragon X gene?

[@PrestonJacobstheSweetrobin]

+Jirka “3ged” Kálecký Her lineage is really ambiguous. She might be a seed, but it didn't appear she had the gene or else she wouldn't have had to use the sheep.

[@andreasjmartins]

Nettles was a dragonseed, aye. Dragonseeds are the populace of Dragonstone, not necessarily direct sons and daughters of Targaryens. Dragonseeds are also mostly descended from male Targs pre-Conquest or until Good Queen Alysanne, who practiced the first night rite. Nettles most likely does not have the dragon x gene.

[@sophiawilson8696]

I don't think she a bastard of Targaryen she got to dragon because she feeding it sheep.

[@t.k.1319]

pretty sure TWOIAF specifically mentions that she was neither a Targaryen nor a seed. That's why it goes into so much detail about her method of feeding it sheep to get comfortable and form a bond. Other seeds tried to mount Sheep-Stealer and got hurt/burned.

[@williamjameshoffer4405]

TWOIAF confirms that Nettles was dragonseed. PJ is wrong on this one, but he's only human.

[@ToastedToast21]

This is a kickass vid. Thanks Preston!

[@ThatLadyBird]

Congrats, preston 💃

[@jeffralston1]

Nice article in Esquire. Congratulations.

[@vitormattos5368]

preston, are you going to talk of the princess of Dorne - doran, elia and oberyn mother - in the Deep Dorne series? She is the reason of Doran and Oberyn are so pro-Rhoynar, she also sent Oberyn to Oldtown when he was very young, he must have had older companions, loyal to the Princess - maybe even Marwyn was her agent in Oldtown. I would also like to know what you think of each of the Sand Snakes missions? And where is Septa Eglantine and the rest of the Lannister guards? If they all escaped with Myrcella, Doran knows about the swap than why is "desert girl" going to KL, and putting Tristane life at risk.

[@eetretsim]

Nice article! Also, Martin confirmed the Dorne storyline in "The Red Woman" is canon!

[@CreepyHollow]

Lmao, Preston is going to have a stroke, when he sees the Dornish plot in the first episode tonight!!

[@sermycahwhent4165]

Congratulations man on the article!

[@masonduke5647]

so many tantalizing hints. I can't wait for the next deeper Dorne.

[@manband20]

Well I guess I better brace myself for this season since it's coming back in 3 days. Can't wait for you ripping the show apart! And are you actually an auditor for the State Department? If so, my condolences. :P

[@skizzik121]

dear Preston, please make 15 videos per day. seriously though History of Westeros is the best pure information channel. but your channel is hands down the best one for theories and stipulation and easily one of my top 5 favorite youtube channels in general. i do wish you and HoW could produce videos faster buy i get they take time and i assume you have a day job or some other time commitment. keep up the amazing work

[@AlexD19931]

uhh, there's totally going to be a winner and it's Stannis the Mannis, this cannot be denied.

[@samanthavankirk8483]

You say we have no reason to believe the dornish can have telepathic abilities, but we actually kind of do. Arianne obsesses over her failed conspiracy to crown Myrcella, and wonders who could have possibly betrayed her plans to her father. Doran might be a southern analogue to Bran or Bloodraven, with his immobility and ability to influence people and know things he shouldn't. It's a longshot, but it seems possible to me.

[@filbertrocko]

The Tattered Prince asked for Pentos even though he won Pentos then left for a saleswords company ??? But he did say "for 2 dragons,,,,I want Pentos" Tatters was not down near the dragons....remember Quentyn specifically asked where he was and Meris said out side that this trick would not work"

[@Rashonda82]

Yeah, Preston! Get those press articles.

[@lite4998]

Trystane Martell can teleport!!! Trystane Martell = Obito Uchiha confirmed!!! Preston you need to make a video on this pronto!!!

[@angeliquethayer6750]

+Preston Jacobs congrats on the article!

[@NowShowingTTV]

Love the video and theory as always. I'm a big Quentyn fan. But you mention at 9:13 that Rhoynish water magic was once used to flood a rival city. If it's the story I think you're talking about, I'm pretty sure the guy who used the water magic to flood the city and curse the ruins was using it on his own city while it was under siege. He didn't agree with Nymeria's plan of running away, and when he was captured his enemies put him in a cage over his city to watch them sack it while he could do nothing. He prayed that the city would flood and be cursed as his way of getting rid of his enemies as they took over his land and hurt his people.

[@lincolnnoronha4128]

Nettles could have the dragon gene, since she most likely was a Targaryen bastard. Quentin did not rode the dragon. We would have seen him on the released WofW chapters.