The "Indian Problem" in Malaysia | Newsflash

The Indian B40 community suffers from high school dropout rates, higher crime rates, and low employment rates - but instead of calling it an "Indian Problem", maybe it's time to look at how we could address these issues as a country.
Watch more episodes of Newsflash every week by SUBSCRIBING to our channel: / rageonlinetv

[@karunanithin.ramachandran6482]

The main fault lies with our Indian politicians. They are not interested in developing the Indian community but filling their own pockets and that of their relatives and cronies. The NGOs' entrusted to develop the Indian community should have no political connections at all. And the NGOs must be audited by a neutral entity to ensure there is no corruption. Why is there never an audit on temple committees, after they do receive large sums of donations. Where does all this money go to. ?

[@londondigitalecommerce]

That Indian minister have no more interests to shout onbehalf of Indian community since appointed by Mahathir as Mrnteri Pepaduan .. suddenly he became abruptly silent as Mahathir may do his ticks to silence him 😁❗ Sounds like Bribe 😁❗

[@sarojakrieg4780]

karunanithi n.ramachandran yes you are correct They are scared of Malay and Chinese This politicians are coward even they don't do well

[@com.s4210]

This is true. Goverment give money but all vanish.

[@yusoffmdsalleh]

True.....just like inTamil movies.....corruption ,greedy......

[@kimjuonn8473]

Vanikam brother, same goes to Dayak Sarawak (in addition other bumis of Sabah & Sarawak), while the political personel didn't stand for their own people. They only bring candy during election. For what the research says, the community have badly effected by economic restructuring by Malaysian Govt. These is exactly happen to Bumis Sabah & Sarawak and even worse, while their homeland dig up(oil&gas,timber etc.) just to fulling corrupted political pockets, and the people pay for the consequences. The hopes towards any Govt becoming faded especially towards Malaya Political Party and we as Bornean will have to say goodbye to this Corrupted Federation.

[@chateytung]

The fact is Professional Indians most of them have migrate to Canada , US , UK and Australia, The remain Professional India in Malaysia most are Lawyer and Doctor

[@user-gy2bk4kj8j]

Because india had good relationship with the 5 eye country and why did not the indians in Malaysia went back to their own land India to work? cause India itself have low cost jobs too... same to Chinese in malaysia went to Singapore, Taiwan or China to work cause in Malaysia races are not treated equally

[@jeyarajshankar]

not entirely true.

[@sarojinichelliah5500]

Be informed that the 17% of the Indians in Malaysia contribute to more than 20% of the economy as they are hardworking. The Malays and Chinese look down on us because for one our colour and their ignorance about us the Tamils who are the earliest civilised people in the world . Facts in old writings proven to be true with evidence showing the world that our ideas found in those books were stolen and adapted by others. The wheel was not a Sumerian tech but ours.

[@jazzyjazz9872]

@@sarojinichelliah5500 I admire you people, like everything else sad but true

[@shahrisemanbg3364]

@@user-gy2bk4kj8j Blaming others is not a solution bro. Malays in Singapore also claims inequality.

[@rambutans5857]

During my high school time, I was puzzled when one of my female Indian classmate chosen to discontinue her school as she her family needs to work to fund her sister's wedding.

[@hindutva_raj]

The highest income group in America are Indians....not Chinese, Whites or others....so what happened in Malaysia ??? Racism plain and simple...

[@hindutva_raj]

@Afapora Aodkak In India...they have got your complaining attitude...outside India...they work hard and complain less...making a baseless statement and lol about it shows a mind devoid of logic...

[@Alexandria-c2x]

That’s true

[@KK-ro7gx]

You think Indian excellent everywhere they go? Bullshit. Similar to Nationalist mentality.

[@hindutva_raj]

@@KK-ro7gx Bullshit is what is coming out of your mouth.....argue with facts not with crap coming out of your mouth......loser

[@KK-ro7gx]

@@hindutva_raj So what do you know how Indian performed in Malaysia. You also spreading bullshit lol. All you think it other is the problem, while Indian innocent.

[@thebontuka.]

Now...this is a video worth watching on Deepavali!

[@joshpcc]

I'm an Indian, i know how much it took me to come up in life. Its not easy as compared to my fellow schoolmates, college mates, colleagues of other majority races. Thank you NewsFlash, appreciate it! Let's work together in near future!

[@johndicejohndice5620]

Ha ha ha bullshit. We built up Malaysia...we was not slave...for example K.Malaiperumal Pillay.. Raja raja Chola ...help us la ...but don't brand us slave...you ahsooo

[@natep6729]

@@johndicejohndice5620 yes you're right. We are not slaves. But our ancestors were. The British brought our great-great grandparents to British Malaya as forced labour, which is slightly better than africans in the West, but still slave like nonetheless. There's nothing to be ashamed of that. That's our history. Self denial will never bring you anywhere.

[@firedup692]

There we go again with the stereotyping based on race. If you were really mired in poverty in the past, you will realise that poverty transcends all boundaries.

[@com.s4210]

All excuses to be higlighted for not blaming yourself. It is not reality. Everybody know that including yourself.

[@annajacinta1200]

Do you know who is the Main head for the gang???? Go and get your facts well before you say anything much....Indians are intelligent people unfortunately Indoan leaders were not looking into this matter seriously....parents who were working as odd job or labourers couldnt do much.

[@chiaolim7773]

The Indians in Singapore are doing far better so it cant be genetics but systematic discrimination. The Malays has help from government, the Chinese are taking care of themselves since they are most economically powerful which leaves the Indians disadvantaged. Assistance should be given to those whom needs it, regardless of race. Why is everything in Malaysia based on race?

[@huanduan5818]

slighty better because the help of chinese in singapore

[@Taliban.The.Hyperpower]

Ask the Uighur and Kashmiris in China and India dear Lim.. 🖕

[@venoth1980]

@@huanduan5818 what help the Chinese helped the Indians ...dont take credits for someone else's effort

[@Taliban.The.Hyperpower]

@Jack Jacky Don't lie to yourself.. Chinese people wherever they're are democratic by display but communistic by operating system.. Exception is with Taiwan and HK..

[@Taliban.The.Hyperpower]

@Jack Jacky Cheap expensive flat is on leasehold? To keep singaporean enslaved to the islander gov from generation to generation? lol.. Freedom of market is taboo in a 'democratic' country huh? Demographic divide and conquer is another thing, kiasu will be kiasu..

[@aaron007freeze]

I'm a Malaysian Indian and trust me it's not the countries fault that my fellow Indians do not pass their exams , it's their own fault as they choose not to excel or change the fate of their lives , I've also seen amazing indian doctors and pilots who came from a poor background or an uneducated family. So it's all up to the individual if they want to succeed. Sadly my machans think that being all rowdy will get them through life.

[@thesageofktn3296]

And also, Indians fight among themselves. The Malaysian Indian community is always jealous of one another. It's always a race to see who has a better education, career and salary. I'm proud of being a Malaysian Indian but seeing my community rival each other makes it hard for me to hope for things to change for Indians in Malaysia.

[@Abitsarcastic]

Yes similarly the core of the problem is also due to themselves not motivated enough to do more in life.. some of us started from dirt poor families and still managed to presevere through life to be successfull... the problem is the environment whereby the families and relatives not prioritising education.. no amount of help or money can be given to solve problem related to the attitude of the community.. somehow the successfull indians needs to give back to their communities to change their mindset and perspective in life to put education first.. same goes to all communities

[@biplav32]

Its weird. Indian-Americans are highest paid of all ethic groups.

[@guardian7keys]

can i ask you, how have you recently helped another fellow indian in need?

[@CometFire2010]

@@biplav32 only the best ones get opportunity to work in America. They know the system and their families know the pattern/mantra to good life, education and business.

[@debl5848]

Gangterism is indeed a symptom of society's problems. My sister used to have an Indian helper-cleaner but later I got know that she was sick, then husband died and now the sickly lady left with two young kids. So so sad. I dread to think of her children's prospects. It may become a vicious cycle.

[@yeapsoon3115]

So please send a copy of this video to Maszlee, Waytha, Azmin and Zuraida.

[@popthatbeep]

One more thing I would add is the social harmonic gap within the indian community itself. Example, if there are two families of indian live in a non indian majority area, instead of supporting each other, both families would prefer to establish a bitter relationship between themselves. Feels like the caste system still have impact on malaysia indian society. True story. Can ask malay or chinese how many times they had to calm down these kind of disputes among indians. Despite all circumstances, I believe they could be better collectively, but it have to be done within their community itself first.

[@HKspurs10]

Singaporean indians on the other hand do well in school and many are rich businessmen and professionals. Many of our top lawyers and doctors are indian singaporeans.

[@robinhood1939]

bullcrap.. they are just the same like in malaysia🤣😂

[@dherandeva301]

@@robinhood1939 hey chee bye u got any proof that they are the same as malaysian,who is the law minister ot singapore,who is the chief justice in singapore,who is the dean of mt elizabeth hospital.Name me a malay dpm or famous lawyer in singapore,after chinese are indians deem successful

[@dherandeva301]

Agree ,most sporeans indians are top doctors and lawyers,look at most singapore ministers like law and dpm are indians

[@bangtongkat6821]

yea we needa improve our education system asap... no more indian school, chinese school or malay school. just one school where english is mandatory and maybe mother cans pick over malay, indian or chinese to learn.. maybe 2 out of 3 so for example chinese and indian + english... yall agree??

[@Hana_Nabila]

Yaaa... I'm quite agree about that. Bahasa Malaysia & English as a primary and mandatory language for all races.Also can choose one of the other languages as a secondary language Chinese(Mandarin/Cantonese) or Tamil.

[@DeclanzWorld]

British English 🇬🇧 vs 🇲🇾 Bahasa Malaysia kzbin.info/www/bejne/aGTdiol3iL-BbpI

[@harrywoodroof9575]

Add Thai language for the Malays as most Of Northern Malays and East Coast Malays are Thai Muslims and native to the Peninsula. Only Southern Malays are mostly Javanese and Sundanese from Indonesia.

[@ColonelFluffles]

What???? In Europe Indians are either night shop owners or doctors. Or they do something with chemistry or something. In Malaysia it's the opposite. So weird to me wtf 😂

[@panda-dn2cc]

i blame british and all west country because this problems lmao

[@panda-dn2cc]

pls read british and malay history lmao

[@KK-ro7gx]

Indian in India live in slum They are only be successful by using opportunities that exist in country that is not their own.

[@rajasingammuthusamy959]

What to do as vacancies are based upon racial, religion and language backgrounds. Education is a secondary matter or not important at all as forgery certificates are acceptable in the country.

[@rajasingammuthusamy959]

the RM15000 - RM18,000 payment by the prospective employee or employment migrant is very tempting to resist for processing the travel journey. Nothing comes free in this world.

[@pahatpahat9566]

In the community that I stay, most Indian parents just want their children to be doctors, lawyers, engineers. I know of a friend who "forced " his son to sit for the Higher School certificate three times just to get a qualifying entry to a Russian/Ukraine medical school!

[@singaporenoodles7189]

I really did enjoy watching this video because I would like learn about Malaysian politics and topics surrounding Malaysia , I'm from Trinidad and we have an Indian community that makes up half of our country population

[@pilihanku9261]

Learn aboutTamil in Sri Langka terrorism

[@gobi6773]

@@pilihanku9261 ooi..ape maksud u ngan tamil terrorism in Sri lanka..?that was a civil war damn it..same as Palestinian hamas doing with Yahudi Israeli..faham geopolitik pastu ckp..x tahu ape² bende pun.. inilah akibat selalu tengok berita TV3 tu..buka mata sikit tu brother.. tingkatan ilmu tentang dunia tu..jgn asyik terperap jer dalam bulatan agama dan menilai semula bende..okay..!!

[@harrywoodroof9575]

@@gobi6773 As a Malaysian Malay, Tamil is foreign people in Southeast Asia. They are not ASEAN natives like the Malays/Filipino/Thai/Khmer/Indo. Even in Tamil native island of Sri Lanka they get heavily massacred by their own Buddhist indian sub-ethnic of Sinhalese, not to mention in Malaysia🇲🇾 where our sole official language is Malay, our sole official religion is Islam. Chola Empire is petty and weak, they ended can't even established their own Tamil Independent country n has to incorporated into Indo-Aryan-dominated United States of Bharat(India). Tamil people has lived and contributed to Myanmar 🇲🇲 (an ASEAN country of British ex-colony too like Malaysia) a lot during British imperialism era and they once outnumbered the Bamar-Buddhists dominant natives in the cities, unfortunately they ended get mass expelled after WW2 out from Burma and the rest treated as "resident aliens" despite being bordered with India and nearest non-indian state with the Chola Empire. Why suddenly wanna claim Malaysia? Even in Kadaram ,the Tamil can't no longer have Thaipusam as their holiday and we the Malays Bumiputra aka ASEAN native will do like how Sinhalese did to Tamilar Hindus if they cross their limits here in this Malay land+ex-Brunei sultanate (Sarawak)+ex-Sulu Sultanate (Sabah). Even in East Malaysia and East Coast states, their population can be counted by fingers. About Malay Arabized and Islamised language,🇲🇾💞 It's just like how the Filipinos's official language, Tagalog a spaniardized and Christianized Malay (despite has Spanish, Tamil and Chinese loan words), the Filipinos are proud with their identity and no non-natives ever question the sovereignty of their national language of the Philippines 🇵🇭! Chola fleets used to reach till there but none of that r remembered nowadays. Malaysia only has this pottek sentiments bcuz the Malays accept and treat these immigrants humanely despite being Southeast Asian native unlike their own indian sub-ethnic of Sinhala. Such a muttal race with nonsense, pretentious pride and biggest irony.

[@rajkiran1982]

@@pilihanku9261 Asshole, first learn about Tamil Genocide in Lanka. You ban a language that people speak and discriminate on basis of it and what do you expect to get out of it.

[@PikaPluff]

@@harrywoodroof9575 hate-boner

[@Tunpredictable]

Super informative piece! Definitely helped my empathy. Would be better if there are a few key calls to action at the end and links in the description for people to get involved to better the situation. :)

[@josepjosep1827]

Not too late to go back India with PIO and OCI is another real option.. Dont create trouble in the Malay States

[@guruarunasalam9599]

Thank you for the well researched work and it was well presented. I agree a lot needs to be done and I hope to see a way through all the obstacles. May there be more awareness amongst Malaysians and may the NGOs device ways of implementing changes and making it work for the benefit of those who need help.

[@malmalhi007]

We have a similar problem with Pakistanis in Uk .. 1.5% of the population accounts for 14% of national prison population mainly for drug dealing and child grooming (91% ). They also make 14% of the mentally handicapped population because of cousin marriages. Edication is free and compulsory for all but it has made little difference to them. They are burden to society because disproportionately more has to be spent on them than they contribute. I would rather have the Indian society rather than exchange them for Pakistanis. Sometimes one gets the impression they are on a Jihad to rob western communities for their warped ideologies.

[@MrRowley5]

Islam is the problem

[@NittenRajput]

11% Chinese members in gang? Are you kidding me

[@bowlampar]

If a certain ethnic group has unusual high drop out rate in Malaysian public school, it is not an 'Indian problem', but a Malaysia issue that need to address properly and look into seriously by government in order to find a solution. Miss Lady Genius!

[@Taliban.The.Hyperpower]

Not 100% correct.. Because Indian youth think that being rowdy will get them somewhere through life.. You don't see this kind of attitude in Malay or Chinese youth.. It has something to do with culture or indiam movies that promotes violence and fight on daily basis

[@kaviarasanganesan36]

@@Taliban.The.Hyperpower talk with fact yo.

[@matthewmann8969]

South Asians be it Indians, Pakistanis, Bengals, Sri Lankans, Maldivians, Bhutanese, Nepalese, Adamese, Or Nicobaries often get lots of nasty comments aimed at them

[@bengguansim5154]

The​ problem​ is​ not​ with​ the​ fornulation of​ laws, projects​ or​ blueprints.​ Malaysians​ are​ fantastic​ on​ paper, but​ implementation and​ then​ monitoring? Hope​less.

[@mspremalatha5721]

Quote 3.57 - Not as SLAVE!! Brght in as Indians are skill workers and hardworking. Indians made roads, railway track, coloniol bldgs and missionary schools and not forgetting Kellies Castle situated at Bt Gajah, Perak. Indians from India and Sri Lanka from professional group i.e. Doctors, Teachers,Lawyers, Engineers, Estates/Plantation Managers and staff. INDIANS ARE NOT SLAVE!!! Treated like slave!! We Indians struggle and come up our own. Our own sweat matters!! We less complain. We are grateful. Indians are experts and intelligent. Just google Sundar Puchai and Satya Nadella. USA today ruling govt Under Your Honourble Sir Joe Biden majority are INDIANS✌Vravo!! I am a proud INDIAN!!🌹🌹🌹

[@RajKumarRaj-jw9fg]

Thank you very much. We are proud to say Indian. 💓

[@stedjkgfddugbofc5450]

dude ofcourse indians are not. slavery is illegal in malaysia duh.. infact almost the whole world

[@harrywoodroof9575]

False Tamil pride.....U can't be proud as "Indians" as U and Indo-Aryans are nemesis. Look at the close Sinhalese.. sad

[@arulraj3076]

Well done on your research, every Indian parents must take the responsibility n the leàd role for the successes to come in the future !

[@Kathiarwari]

Tamil and other South Indians are doing very well in America and other foreign countries - head of Google, Top Professors & Scientists, even the US Vice President Kamala Harris is half Tamil. The reason? Education is highly prized by them. Unless Tamils in Malaysia receive proper education their problems will remain

[@stedjkgfddugbofc5450]

lol. so with any other race. any race has their own ceo and rich peoole. just look at india itself. the first thing people think of india is poverty, poop on streets, bus r4pe, and scam calls

[@kalvin7269]

@@stedjkgfddugbofc5450 no offence but I've never seen any malay or indonesian becoming ceo of any top companies. And no one from southeast Asia has ever won nobel prize for science. Do you know the very first Asian to win nobel prize in physics is a Tamil? And do you know Ramanujan, one of the best mathematician of all time is also a Tamil. So, obviously tamils are better than you guys. Don't be so stupid.

[@kalvin7269]

@Influens agama akan hilang jika tiada mahukannya. Southeast Asia is doing better because of the Chinese population over here. Singapore, the only developed country in southeast Asia is a Chinese majority country. Without them, Southeast Asia would be even poorer than now.

[@babitonggek148]

@@kalvin7269 who cares with all those things...at least we stay and develop in our own countries in our own region...Chinese and Indian why always like to migrate to other countries in order to have better life?..why cant u just stay at ur mainland and develop ur country...especially Indian..only know to migrate..develop ur own mainland first..dont run..funny

[@carolmalini2733]

@@babitonggek148 because Indians like to mix with whites

[@umahpapachan3182]

Malaysian exams are the worst and the Education department favours Malays by giving them a higher pass rates.

[@gajaenthiranganisan858]

Great argument here... Another topic for discussion could be the doctor situation in Malaysia. Housemen who have completed their housemanship are not getting the same pay/on the same pay grade as their MO colleagues for doing the same job. The contract system is a huge challenge to even do masters and progress. So what's next? Stay on as doctors where there is no promise of progress or a career switch.

[@josepjosep1827]

Not too late to go back India with PIO and OCI is another real option.. Dont create trouble in the Malay States

[@neerajsingh408]

Interesting to note that while Indian expats are mostly successful in English countries (better than their English counterparts), they struggle in countries like Malaysia, Arab countries. Seems like an issue with both social structure in Malaysia and the kind of Indians who moved to Malaysia. Statistical examination can reveal insights that enable us to counter the slums.

[@sergelondon916]

Because in those non western countries they are clear second class citizens.

[@shubhankmanhas5255]

Normally working class people gp to these countries

[@pregnantenglish6019]

@@sergelondon916 Fully agree. In Malaysia especially, non-Malay/Muslims r clearly 2nd class citizens. Their Constitution clearly favours their own MAJORITY race (ie the so-called "Bumiputras"). Just compare the Malaysian Indians wif their counterparts fortunate enough to be born in Singapore (which treats ALL races equally). The outcomes (in Singapore) are dramatically different.

[@sofiaglove]

Please disect Taib Mahmud in Sarawak or Sarawak & Sabah underdevelopment issues. Thanks!

[@rukhsah]

Everything is peninsular peninsular

[@sofiaglove]

@MajuAkses huh?

[@arys83]

this is an objective piece of information, it can only be appreciated by those with maturity and critical thinking. kudos to R.AGE for handling this sensitive issue with tact. hope more youtube channels can do the same..

[@FA9082]

No it's not objective, statistics are ALWAYS massaged to lead people to a predetermined conclusion This is just another propaganda piece like any other

[@muhammadnurhazim6428]

Kena ada persatuan yg bantu indian community dari aspek education dan skills development. Hope oneday, they will get an equility as others. Cheers

[@samteh3033]

Are the figures reliable?

[@londondigitalecommerce]

@Tay Hock Leng I am afraid those who governs the Justice System imported from Third World like the "fools " Latheefa koya and Thomy Thomas and those governs the economy like Mr Eng as recently as just last few weeks ago , Malaysia aviation system have been banned from entering United States as the US government have down graded Malaysia aviation status to a second class Third World Status the same ranking group with Bangladesh . Institutional Global finance spooked by the emergence of immigrants government led by DAP have left Malaysia as Malaysia economy going spiraling south as the IMF have no confidence the way the Immigrants government DAP do things ❗I reckon Thomy and koya to give a hand and look after the human right of their own society as there are 450 millions of Indian citizens being denied their human rights for a toilets as defecating on the open public space are so rampant in India and China...I wonder what the heck these DAP minister from third word country messing about with decent and civilised country like Malaysia once a dramatic highly successful and highly organised country but going down to the abyss since DAP taking over ....The fools like Thomy , Latheefa koya and Mr Eng should do good and helping the Human Right to those innocent and neglected population of their own society in need such as in India and China ,not only defecation is a big issue but over 90% of their population work for a slave wages and even so there are another section of their society over 100 millions of india citizens being denied their human right for a decent living as they are living in a slum not meant for a human, I am concern for their human right and their need for help ❓❗Do these " Three Stooges " ( *You know who & what I mean* ⁉️ ) have enough IQ to govern a society let alone civilised and highly organised nation like Malaysia ❓as this three low third world IQ and the rest in DAP imported from a third world are turning Malaysia into a status of a Third World Nation....❗I reckon to immigrants from India,China, Bangladesh ,Pakistani and Nepalese in DAP ,do the job you are very good at and capable of doing the most as a hard working productive labour serving the Malay and English society ❗ By merit ,DAP are not meant to govern a society let alone to govern a highly civilised and highly organised country like Malaysia❗and all the news of Indian terrorist and Chinese Communist harbouring inside DAP and dodgy dealing and cover ups messing the justice system by the imported low IQ third world koya and Thomy have just prove that is the case ❗

[@pilihanku9261]

@@londondigitalecommerce Very good.I agree.Should be read by johan jaafar and liberal thieves like rafidah.

[@tariqhaikalbinmohdhaizam5960]

I think maybe the gov should invest more on vocational training school since not everyone are good at math,science etc.

[@premchangoberdhan9509]

Wow, Indians are the Africans of Malaysia.

[@koalamud5087]

This was such an eye-opener, thank you so much

[@TharsyanJaderuby]

This is the reason why our parents and grand folks always advice on one thing to have a better life, no matter what you do and what you'd wish for - Education.

[@ualuuanie]

1:50 Please explain how can a Malaysian regardless of race have no education when what I learn from my Malaysian friends that primary schooling is free?

[@JosephEYSam]

Typical things and though in rural area made this. Although it's free, it's not 'productive' for poor families where they need man power to work. Children are involved in workplace/ignorance the importance education made the situation.

[@ualuuanie]

@@JosephEYSam Ah I see the 3rd world mentality. Thanks for explaining

[@leem.5917]

Airbus A380 too bad for Perkara 153

[@guardian7keys]

primary school is not free. u need to pay school fees, PIBG fees, then additional fees the school may ask. on top of that school uniforms have to be purchased. heck some school charge for school badge and even PE clothing. additional books besides the school textbooks also have to be purchased. if u are behind in class, and can't afford to attend private tuition it makes the situation worse. in some places, schools especially tamil schools are dilapidated and a student has to walk so far to attend school as they can't afford school bus fees etc.

[@bowlampar]

Your Malaysian friend is telling lies to you , especially to foreigner who is clueless about Malaysia.

[@mavidurka6704]

Hi. R. age .please do a episode on domestic violence and another episode on suicide among youngsters

[@gunalannalliah7302]

Give indians good education

[@luvenpranicfrequency8043]

Lets talk about the truth, necessity and effectivity of the concept of Malays being the bumiputra of this land. The history of this land is common knowledge. Yet, it is categorically surpressed by the goverment and made into a highly sensitive topic about which none should even question. Physical evidence is destroyed and the people are fear mongered into submitting to the status quo. Its amazing how even the Malay language being mostly made up of Tamil, Hindi and Sanskrit words does not open people's eyes. This is the power of categorical indoctrination or brainwashing. The divide comes due to religion. The act of not accepting the Indians and Chinese as equal citizens at the time of independance is one born out of fear, is archaic and Malaysia must leave it behind in order to progress as one united Nation. Otherwise, racism will always remain and marginalisation will always remain. We the so called non-bumis are not seeking to be above anyone, but only as equals. I was born on this land, i am a putra of this bumi.

[@maninaction21]

I think you are not seeing the reason why this is a sensitive issue. This was our home since parameswara discover melaka. It always has been. The reason why we malays cant accept equal view is because of that issue. We fought for our freedom but fail miserably. We loose a lot through out history. Then the brits take in the indians and chinese into our home. which really pisses us even more. To achieve independance we have to put aside everything just to take back our long lost land. That is why malays like me are very very very sensitive talking about bumiputera issue. Its hard to take it in but facts taken from history must be accepted with open hearts. We can tolerate other races coming in to achieve independance. Why cant you guys tolerate on the bumiputera issue. Just a thought for the mind. I'm just explaining why bumiputera is very sensitive for us, so that people would know.

[@maninaction21]

What if i stay in other people's house for a long time n considered as housemates already but i want what the owner owns because i am his housemate...do i consider the owner racist towards him? Its called own's rights and we can't just give away our rights, u just have to kept in mind that from the start our history lives here, lives within the malays. That my friend is not racism. That is being human

[@lsmrkqj]

@@maninaction21 You are spitting words based on emotion not logic and practicality. How do you expect this country to move forword when you keep mongering over the past. You only heard one side of the story but when will you be able to open your heart and accept that we all bleed the same?

[@lsmrkqj]

It is sad. The only possible way it seems to get pass this whole mess is to leave this country when a large whole portion of the population is still singing the same song and dont want to accept change.

[@sathiahalya3003]

This is the Malay Archipelago. Singapore is 70% Chinese.

[@carolmalini7333]

They're brought as indenture labours by British not as slaves.

[@harrywoodroof9575]

They r slaves with low caste dravidians until today's's digital equal era

[@malasyu]

Could you discuss the Rape of Sarawak where billions were laundered out of Sarawak following the logging operations its leaders, which has been highlighted over the years by Clare Rowcastle Brown.

[@leongchunwah5131]

Regardless of Malaysian Indian, Malay or Chinese communities, we have to learn self-reliance. Nobody can help unless we help ourselves. Government shall adopt an open approach to facilitate those work hard to change their living standard like giving license to operate, leasing lands for those who want to be a farmer, ensuring basic living needs such as electricity & clean water supply, proper roads and affordable housing. Again, regardless of races, any Malaysian win, it is the success of Malaysia. Malaysian Chinese companies successfully help the country earn billions dollars of foreign exchange in 2020 from the rubber glove business, especially important when the covid-19 strikes and very low oil price.

[@kalvin7269]

First ask ur Chinese not to too much involved in nepotism

[@JacksonHustler]

oh man, thats really bad when they say we have to die glamolously

[@doctor4ghugus]

What are the names of the NGOs working with Indians in Malayasia?

[@lionelproctor82]

One of the reasons for high dropout rates among Indian students could be that those who attend Tamil medium primary schools may have trouble adjusting to Malay medium secondary schools. Chinese students who attend government Mandarin medium schools still have the option of attending private Mandarin medium (Independent) secondary schools.

[@shding2971]

Enjoyed the presentation - the reporting, the facts and the analysis. Thank you R.age. Please continue such quality reporting in issues which will hopefully galvanise into action and make Malaysia a more progressive nation. Much of our news nowadays are dominated by biased political and financial reports, and too little deal with day-to-day issues which affect ordinary people. Please keep up the good work and quality reporting. Thank you.

[@josepjosep1827]

Not too late to go back India with PIO and OCI is another real option.. Dont create trouble in the Malay States

[@tintunbirha]

Very good indeed. Very well analysed and presented.

[@anantpatel3608]

This may be due to rigorous extremism Islam

[@Taliban.The.Hyperpower]

Go migrate then..

[@Taliban.The.Hyperpower]

@NM Sure.. Just like ISIS, ltte and commxnism.. All are extremist..

[@Taliban.The.Hyperpower]

@ꤾꤳꤰꤻꥃꥅꤹꥆꤶꥄꥂ Do you agree, ISIS, commxnist, and ltte is extremist? Don't keep quiet now.. speak 😅

[@Taliban.The.Hyperpower]

@ꤾꤳꤰꤻꥃꥅꤹꥆꤶꥄꥂ koyak 😂

[@howelau1123]

WHERE IS THE MIC AND WHAT HAVE THEY DONE TO THE INDIAN?

[@zuccmarkerbergzuccurmama]

*Topic suggestion* Non bumiputra Malaysians have been accusing the government for racial preferences when hiring civil servants, but I have actually seen statistics and numbers that explained otherwise, do you guys think it is a relevant topic to discuss about on this channel?

[@da62585]

Numbers can be altered, my friend.

[@faziatulamira2765]

Hi there, mind sharing the links for the documents? Just for personal reading

[@KertBart]

Me too. Can i get those statistics please

[@subramaniammunusamy9357]

If our civil service is dominated 95% by one race,what numbers are you talking about?

[@mapledoodle5516]

Malay Indians seem very similar to American Blacks. Issues are practically identical.

[@xoweerty7490]

Mandarin Speaking on job vacancy

[@xoweerty7490]

2:40

[@markbr9429]

Jayakailash Menon I agree all Malaysians should learn Mandarin if they could because what do you have to lose? Only benefit right? Sadly, many private sector employers use “mandarin speaking” not because they’re dealing with China companies, but because they favour their own race and are unable to communicate effectively in Malay or English. This is Malaysia, not China. If Malaysians cannot speak and write in Malay then it is a huge problem, both politically and socially. For the most part “Mandarin Speaking” in job adverts is simply a form of racism. Why? Because those companies do not wish to accept and comply to Malaysian culture, language and way of life. Secondly, Chinese and Tamil schools need to be replaced with sekolah Kebangsaan. Look at Indonesia and Thailand, the Chinese there speak the national language even at home. Heck, they even have Indonesian and Thai names. In Malaysia we are lucky.

[@markbr9429]

@Airbus A380 chinese colony? Lol china can't even handle tiny hong kong

[@markbr9429]

@Airbus A380 lol u stupid little ant 😂

[@pooja350]

@@markbr9429 little did you know...

[@sesaz3]

Awesome point of view that so called Indian leaders don't have. Raspac'

[@tanchye1720]

The ‘research’ must separate Indian, Malay and Chinese instead of Indian & Malaysian to get a better picture.

[@kageromtp3043]

Do for malay too..how em hard to get a job and get lower payment

[@adlansalleh412]

Thanks for info

[@orionNsirius]

Train 100k Malaysia indians to be expert in IT and cyber security.

[@anniezz._.8745]

But not all of the 100k will be interested in it cuz people has different interest

[@kumanet99]

if there is no discrimination in Malaysia in the name of religion, racial, business opportunities, education, govt. and public sector employments, including the word Tamil schools which signifies a community, MIC being communal, only for the Tamils etc. Indians in this country will be much better. indians are doing very well in other countries world wide, especially in the middle east and Europe and USA, where there are less discriminations. Malaysia does not provide any equal playing field for minority indians. They are been discriminated.

[@lewdongan2698]

Next topic: Chinese problem

[@rayymondthomas]

You forgot " " 😂. very important

[@BadassBikerOwns]

There is a Chinese problem, and it is that poor Chinese try so hard to hide their poverty instead of asking for help, as they genuinely deserve. And the rich Chinese look at them with the ultimate expression of loathe and disdain. Sorry to say but like many East Asian societies, I think the Chinese society is greatly lacking in compassion. And because of our Bumiputra history, the govt too sidelines them.

[@jihooacap]

"only chinese speaker" have u realize that ?

[@faizyusuf2470]

@rinrin is this your typical Malay? Why are you guys have to bring Indon? He's not even Indon and you're already bring the race card -_-

[@lsmrkqj]

@@jihooacap "only chinese speaker" not "chinese only". Do you see the difference? Alot of non-chinese dont see the segregation in the chinese community themselves.

[@kriskhoo]

Blame the governing system..

[@DGoldy303]

Yes its the system!

[@sonoar0ckmans939]

Finally, at least there are bipartisanship view on news..like your video

[@zainuddinbrahim4625]

Love e content..keep it up...at least there is some issue being made to be acknowledged.

[@testprofile1840]

3:56 maybe you should recheck your facts they were not brought by british they were alaways there even all of malaysia similar to indonesia was all hindu or buddhist and you can see that from the ancient temples in india but sadly they were converted by force to muslims and by time it seems the populus has forgot their real roots and culture

[@KK-ro7gx]

Temple back then are build by Malay ethnic group who later convert to islam. Not Indian origin. Indian in Malaysia today was either Tamil or Sikh people. Who build the ancient temple in Malaysia? Hindu-Buddhist ✅ Indian ❌

[@KK-ro7gx]

There was never force convert in Malaysia. Also Islam was brought to Malaysia by Indian trader 😜 your own people.

[@OnlyXmoney]

At this time, in 2021 if malasiyan ask India to take all indians out in india, then with all people, then only few people in India can buy whole malasiya and gift them to indians which were thier treated badly!!!

[@OnlyXmoney]

@@yamcha8309 I am saying what media shows..no personel hate towards malasiya!!

[@raajsupaya6182]

MIC?

[@trishmodhgil3179]

The main issue tht brings indians down is their false pride. I'm not racist, i'm just an indian tht observes..

[@Robertsmith001]

You are wrong bro..

[@trishmodhgil3179]

@@Robertsmith001 I would like to know more :)

[@sashilemla6229]

When visiting Malaysia once, heard that Indians were leading in educated n doing good...now this news is new to me n I feel Indians should try to live up to its version of being forward in education

[@stardust2045]

It's partially true. In Malaysia,the Sikhs, Muslim and Christian seem to do very well because many came in as merchants. Even the Sri Lankan and North Indian Hindus do well. But Tamil Hindus were not fortunate. Tamil Hindus were brought in as indentured labourers to work on the estate farm and many still unable to escape the poverty trap in the country. What's worst is that Sikhs and Muslim don't want to identify themselves as Indians in Malaysia.

[@goyam2981]

Dark-skinned Indians in Thailand would probably be thought of as vendors selling peas and nuts or roti. Sikh people are usually owners of fabric shops. There may be some teasing but I don't think it's as bad as in Malaysia in terms of discrimination.

[@andyc9902]

Indian community in Usa is the highest paid

[@qwertydadabla6204]

but all indian community in india dont even have money to build toilets

[@josepjosep1827]

Not too late to go back India with PIO and OCI . Dont create trouble in the Malay States

[@govindm9221]

Its all failure of government of the day which ignored the Indian community economic contributions in nation building past century. There was not even single solid affirmative action when estates fragmentaion happened due to rapit development in last 50 over years. NEP supposely serve all races but failed with overzealous policy makers high handed and discriminative practices.

[@harrywoodroof9575]

Indian also made economic contributions in Myanmar🇲🇲 during British Burma, they ended up get expelled out of Burma once Bamar-Buddhists majority gained Independence from the British, not to mention Sri Lanka🇱🇰...

[@mrchow7517]

By design and ruthless strategy the BRITISH government have caused a lot of recurring hardships to many people all GOVERNMENTS (govern the mind) are illegal God bless our Indian, Malay, Indonesia, Thai and Chinese brothers you're in my thoughts and prayers

[@premchangoberdhan9509]

Indians, you need to work hard and smart. Please don't depend on anyone for your development. It is you responsibility.

[@Robertsmith001]

What race are you? Are you Indian? In almost every other country, Indian diaspora earn above national average, the exception is Malaysia. Clearly, some thing is wrong with Malaysia

[@premchangoberdhan9509]

@@Robertsmith001 Take a look at the Indian subcontinent and the people that inhabit it. You will find that there are many races that are indigenous. Indian is not a race strictly speaking.

[@premchangoberdhan9509]

@@Robertsmith001 Take a look at the Indian subcontinent and the people that inhabit it. You will find that there are many races that are indigenous to India. Strictly speaking Indian is not an a race. All political correctness aside there are some people or races that do better in life. In India it is no different. Generally the people with the darker skin tend to be at the lower rungs of society. Why that is?, well that is a whole long contentious discussion.

[@frankunderwood6810]

@@premchangoberdhan9509 i like this kinda belief work hard and smart. Plus, be independent, no excuses. Do not make excuses and blaming others, whether the system favors us or not. Excuses are like tumors,it will grow bigger, silently the excuses will kill us. This is how the successful indians in europe and america set their mind to prosper, be independent and have no excuses. Simple.

[@kalvin7269]

Malaysian indians are not asking for any assistance. We are just asking for equal opportunities. In every sector in Malaysia, Indians will be ignored/discriminated. Even if you are well educated, you have to struggle to get a good job. There are companies that will straight away reject them once they see an Indian name on cv. You could see discrimination happening in Malaysia in every layer but people tend to ignore them and blame the Indians for that.

[@AdrianChiang-kx3cw]

Always act big and gengster on the street, road and everywhere!

[@kalvin7269]

Indians in South Africa, Mauritius, Fiji and Singapore had the same history as Indians in Malaysia. Indians in those countries are very successful and better off than the native people, then how is it in Malaysia Indians are not doing well? Is it really the Indians' fault or the country's fault?

[@subak8343]

The goverment fault

[@nikhil5680]

@Nik 20 absolutely successful

[@doublecheeseburger22]

@Jalak yep they are successful

[@harrywoodroof9575]

It's false Tamil pride's fault

[@aaryaputra108]

It's been 5 years since this video was made, it would be good to get an update on how this 10 year government plan is progressing and positively affecting Indian people or whether corruption by government officials or NGOs are swallowing up the money.

[@truth-ip1qj]

Who gose to Malaysia, Mostly muslims.This is what you teach them.Now you have imported Jakir nayak,Good luck.

[@varunkumark3878]

Education, strong family units needed

[@mohaanrao9860]

Well said girl....appreciate it and thank you to highlight and bring awareness to those Malaysians

[@andyc9902]

Come to usa lah

[@saraswathyselvakumar628]

Lets put the employment issue on a side...What about the Indian students IPTA offer? Gvrnmnt set up its own 'kuoto' for them...but do they really got the offer to study in IPTA..?..i wonder...do they really care about the Indians education?...Do we deserve this? 10A's indian student had to wait after she did her 'rayuan' for matrics...Rich students go for private institute..but what about the poor one..they have to take a huge loan and then study...if you see this issue as a 'racism topic', please wake up...try understand the situation of the indian students...

[@RajKumarRaj-jw9fg]

Yeah! That's itz.

[@gitadas9983]

It has been a long hard struggle for the working-class Indians. We have to accept the fact that we have to help ourselves. We have contributed to the development of this country without any returns. Do not expect anything from the other races.

[@harrywoodroof9575]

Nah Ur not

[@sundarmann6167]

The only cure is, if the stupid govt. start exercising policies based on merit instead of race. Then, we'll have social issues solved by itself. You don't need to be a rocket to know that.😂😂

[@68521000]

Very true based on data and socioeconomic impact.

[@NittenRajput]

Lack of eduction doesn't equals to Crime/ being a criminal. There are many highly qualified people who became terrorists. Education is not a sole reason. Crime/ being a criminal have many factors in play.

[@nicholasmahendra3229]

Hello newsflash : dont divert the real fact. Dont you see in any goverment centres how many indians are employed. In private sectors how much does a indian get paid. Madam go down to the ground level and make a sirvey..

[@animetoon187]

Country which makes law on ethnicity talks about ethnic underdevelopment .

[@saravanatharumasegaram7200]

as an Indian... stop blaming governments n other races .let's ask our fellow Indians what have they contributed to their Indian brothers / sisters/ children. first we need to ask all the major temple management who has so much of money . they don't pay tax neither do they their acc audited. they have big cash god knows used for what . I think we Indians should start questioning the major temples in malaysia

[@londondigitalecommerce]

Yes. ❗the imported Sami from India without control and immigration regulations ❗May be people from Indian using this route to sneak in to Malaysia ❗The government are not aware as respecting the right for a religion practice in Malaysia blinded the immigrantion authority from doing the jobs ❗I can see why Indian the poorest in Malaysia are coming from❗

[@harrywoodroof9575]

True

[@derrickrimson9655]

i can agree on the unemployment 9 stuff (Quota system still exist) but when it comes to education you have to blame indian culture nowdays with media and movies where teenagers think its cool to flunk their exams and also i have seen alot of parents who rather see their child work rather than studeis

[@dilyaTebya]

So you are telling that ALL malay kids thinks school is cool?? In every race they will be school dropouts. But how about the afterward that counts. malays still have upper hand because of goverment help.

[@Robertsmith001]

You are very ignorant man

[@kalvin7269]

I'm an Indian too, studied in a tamil school. Never seen students thinking it's cool to ponteng class. Maybe there are some, but majority of us would not do that. Don't be so ignorant.

[@sarojinichelliah5500]

We the Indians don’t nt need any research done by others on us and can solve the problems we have whether solvable or not and rage is not equipped to do it . Just make sure you keep to issues that are common to all like for instance weight issue seen clearly in presenters. Talk about colour discrimination, race discrimination and don’t make a fool of yourselves on a world stage. We don’t need you to change us.We are doing well if you just look at the demographics.

[@RajKumarRaj-jw9fg]

Yeah ! That's true.

[@paikiah77]

News seem to suggest more foreign companies leaving Malaysia than arriving. The same with expat numbers, which is a surprise as KL was previously a haven for expats. Something's wrong and is the new govt acting on it?

[@binal-flecki2387]

new government haha, you elected mahathir for fuck sake, the person who started all this shit fucking delusional man

[@shilaasamysamy9393]

Fucking BN and UMNO Cronies did all this mess..

[@shoutout3651]

Haha Indian excel in every country they go .Malaysia must be holding them back .surprise surprise

[@stedjkgfddugbofc5450]

excel? lol look at india itself. the first thing people think of india is poverty, poop on streets, bus r4pe, and scam calls

[@kalvin7269]

@@stedjkgfddugbofc5450 have you been to Singapore? Local Singaporean indians there are doing far better than malaysian Indians.

[@Nik_hilll]

I dont think Malaysia have good education system.

[@leelaleela2541]

100 precent true

[@anjalireddy2711]

Effort appreciated.

[@sahraniakamparam3530]

How much u know about Indian? Only the untrue n negatives. Do u know about our Tamil language n the history of Tamil people. Pls study our history first. How much our history teach this world. We still depend our own not others.

[@stedjkgfddugbofc5450]

why would anyone study a poor culture? if you want someone to learn about you first increase your own value. not the other way around. respect is given not demanded

[@sahraniakamparam3530]

We not poor culture. We can prove we not poor culture. We not say others culture. We not said others culture badly. So, Better don't talk about negatives n better talk good thinks about other race. We respect others also, so u better respect others. If u keep quite n no disturb others n I also respect u

[@harrywoodroof9575]

false Tamil pride sad.....

[@LiveLive-ix5jz]

Sambanthan and mic the cause of Tamil suffering????? Caste bramin racist law??? Om peace

[@leem.5917]

Live016 Live016 since when the shit did sambanthan cause the downfall of indians ?

[@rajamanikaliyappan3631]

It's not Brahmin IDIOT. Money matters

[@CometFire2010]

Another Brahmin hater vomits here unnecessarily. Lolz. Keep your petty politics in India

[@Robertsmith001]

@@CometFire2010 No one cares

[@kimmulakshmi]

As a Malaysian, it's the Indians own fault for failing in school. Focusing too much on Tamil Movies (which often portrays Gangsterism, etc). The only people to blame for failure are the people themselves. Nothing else. I come from a family of doctors & engineers. No one else is to blame but themselves. The mindset must also change too.

[@CometFire2010]

Someone in the family needs to break the cycle/circle and create a new pattern to success for generations to come.

[@terastarship2]

2062 India Indians conquers South East Asia countries, every countries listed in SEA.

[@chiaolim7773]

Yes! If cow dung is your weapon

[@BenjaminMilekowsky]

Third world country dream...☻

[@macdmacd7896]

all local indians in the USA, CANADA, UK, AUSTRALIA shall come home for love.

[@waleedelephantboy1796]

I feel the same too, plus my Paternal Grandma is Indian and I worried her Indian community as well

[@nationalmixvideos3698]

For a moment I thought she was Shiori tsukada legend she is