Rangemaster (The Urban Gentry x Long Island Watch): Unbox, Review, Rant

[@theurbangentry]

Hello! Wow, thank you so much for such an honest and detailed review. Really outstanding. I would love to play a short clip of this in a video in a future episode, would that be ok with you? Naturally I will give full accreditation and a link in the description to your channel. Please keep up the great work and enjoy your RM! Onwards and upwards. Best regards, TGV

[@whichwatch4031]

Thank you for your compliment, TGV. Coming from you, it's very encouraging! I'd be happy for you to use a clip - no problem. I'll have a full review of the RM coming out soon-ish (next week or two), so there may be some good things to grab there too. I don't have fancy equipment, but there will surely some new shots and thoughts. I appreciate the creative effort you put into this watch...In fact, you inspired me to start creating my own face design - something I've been intending to do for some time.

[@bobby8737]

It’s a piece of crap

[@RoyalFizzbin]

@@bobby8737 I think it’s cool. Not. Must-have, but cool.

[@islandwatch]

Hi. Thank you. Pleasure to meet you!

[@whichwatch4031]

Pleasure!

[@thnd-uo4vp]

I am a fan of the two guys but unfortunately I am not a fan of this watch. I do not like Mark’s logo, the hands and font. When you compare the Seiko’s and Smiths to the Ranger it really makes it look sub par. Again, I like the guys and their channels, but I have to give honest feedback.

[@whichwatch4031]

All's fair in love and watches. I assume you like understated design?

[@cagataycakmak2280]

I think the logo placement and execution kills this watch. Islander logo is awkward and looks incomplete. The tgv logo also looks weird on the dial, In my opinion tgv logo should have been on the caseback only and the Islander logo needs to be redesigned.

[@johnholkham2420]

How come San Martin produce a similar watch and get stick for making homages yet Island watches seem to follow a similar path

[@JVan-ic6ic]

The islander logo just sucks

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Congratulations my friend.

[@whichwatch4031]

Thanks, brother! Love your videos btw. I'm a fellow Seiko/Casio addict.

[@TheChadWork2001]

What movement is this watch? a true no-date Miyota 9039 movement

[@kywatchguy7154]

Really nice review! Stumbled across your channel because of the watch (I have one on the way) and stayed because of your presentation. Informative and down to earth. Kind of like "regular guy buys watch and chats about it" including likes and dislikes. Well done. You also helped me get over the case of buyer's remorse I was starting to come down with. 👍 Looking forward to future videos.

[@whichwatch4031]

Thank you, my friend! I'm still trying to figure out my tone...weird to be in front of a camera. Hey - if you end up with buyers remorse, check the listings on eBay...they'll turn your frown upside down!

[@FFFFelix]

I echo everything @KYwatchguy said above 👌🏽

[@baconandbezels6992]

Great review. Loving my Rangemaster. I haven’t taken it off since I got it. Love your GS.

[@whichwatch4031]

Thank you! I'm seeing that you also posted a video of your watch - great stuff! Looking at your videos, I can tell you have good taste. Subscribed.

[@baconandbezels6992]

@@whichwatch4031 thanks!

[@rodg2335]

Good review. I don't care for this sarb033, Ranger mash up. Tired of homages

[@paulsteele6120]

Why are you living in your garage??

[@miguelmaldonado6049]

I missed it:( ….but I like it….including the Island Watch Logo.

[@reecegordon7073]

Enjoyed the review, your ad-lib ranting was pretty funny to be honest 😆 - and it makes such a difference seeing the watch on wrist

[@whichwatch4031]

Thank you!

[@phillyeli215]

I have #210 of the 500 made. I wear it everyday its comfortable and the legibility is awesome. The bezel is brushed which is a big plus. Wish it had a better bracelet and lume and the noisy Miyota movement is kinda irritating 🤷🏾‍♂️

[@Taylod1]

1St off I was happy to hear that this review was is not from the inner circle, so thank you. my comments are before I receive my watch, I have one on order as I've been looking for explorer style watch that is affordable. I agree Mark's logo is kind of cartoonish (sorry Mark) I would have preferred a display back and that fold over clasp is not for me but I'm willing to give it a chance. I would be willing to spend more for better movement, a better clasp and display back. Your review has lots of detail, I also like to know how much it weights and a lume shoot would be complete the review. Thank you for doing this review and can't wait to get my watch!

[@whichwatch4031]

Not sure on the weight...but plan on weighing all my watches soon. I usually prefer a display back, but in this case ---- the thinness of the watch is one of it's main selling points. Cheers!

[@gbh_events]

They've obviously gone for an explorer vibe here. It feels like they started off with an explorer design and just made a bunch of weird design decisions to make it look different to the explorer. The arabic numerals look weird with the angular cuts, the indices look weird (just compare to the explorer) and the bezel is comically large here. Yeah the watch-on-watch logo is dumb - the lion logo looks a lot better and the font they use for "lslander" is nice - they shoudl have used that up top. This handset reminds me of the Tudor Ranger - probably because it is exactly the same as the Tudor Ranger. It's an homage watch, homaging the tudor ranger and the rolex explorer.

[@dparis2172]

I think asking the question - Will this have an identity crisis? - re: the stepped dual finish lugs suggests there there is indeed something of an identity crisis at play. It’s probably my only knock on the watch, as an observer. My wish for v2 would be for a case closer to the Tudor Ranger. Like a brushed version of the case Islander uses on their “Manhasset” line, with subtle polishing included.

[@johnrb9397]

Need a review on the GS.

[@whichwatch4031]

Coming soon! Insane watch.

[@gerechoppers]

I’ve had mine for a week now. The dial is outstanding…very visible and the sharp point on the minute hand is my favorite part. I can only hear the Miyota rotor when my ear is really close to the watch. The winding feels a little grainy, but this is my first Miyota, so maybe that’s normal for these. My only real disappointment is that the bracelet isn’t a true 3 piece link, even though they appear to be. Overall I love this watch and love the way it wears. Definitely a keeper for me. I’m looking forward to years of enjoying it.

[@whichwatch4031]

Congrats! The winding on my RM is on par with the rest of my Miyota movement. No - it's not as smooth as my Swiss/French movements...but I'm not too picky on the winding, as I almost never wind my watches. Agreed on the 3-piece thing....I assume it's a cost-tradeoff consideration, as all of my 3-piece bracelets are on watches that cost more than this. Cheers!

[@eigrp]

That Islander logo. I'd have two or three of Marc's watches if it weren't for that. It's frustrating he's so stubborn about it. Oh, well. For that reason alone I'd wear the Smiths 100% of the time over the Rangemaster.

[@pmac206]

I bought a islander, I didn’t like it was a complete waste of money. It felt like a cheap Ali Express watch . I couldn’t even put that watch in my box it doesn’t deserve a place . There’s too many good wife brands out there to waste money on crap

[@FlipFlopsQ]

Agreed, the TGV logo should be on the top. I would argue they could have left off the Islander logo completely. The log is already on the crown and to be honest, not that attractive.

[@FlipFlopsQ]

I've actually reversed my opinion on this. As it is a collaboration, I think it's fitting that the Islander logo be above the TGV logo. I do wish Marc would change his logo though...

[@jjjfffppp]

solid suggestions about the dial. the lion with the islander text at 12 would have been very nice

[@SpartacusDog]

A great watch and a great review. I just love the whole 38mm package: the thinness, the SS finish, the hands, the markers, the spaced minute track, the lume, the 24hr chapter ring, the bezel, the crown, the bracelet & clasp; I mean, what more can be said! Has anyone mentioned a likely rerelease, or if it having drilled lugs might also be possible?

[@JS-ev4xc]

I still feel that Urban Gentry should not do a homage that the original is available, a vintage homage may be. But may be it does not matter over time when all will become unavailable brand new.

[@edk2221]

12:40 I find it hard to believe that they didn’t know of the Tudor Ranger design because the hands are nearly identical. Plus, the 3, 6, 9 dial.

[@Taylorripsharleys]

They were aware of the original Tudor ranger, Tudor rereleased the ranger just before this watch dropped. It draws inspiration from a few watches and brands.

[@henryperez606]

You’re very sharp

[@waffle911]

I've been wearing an ISL-82 Mitchell for a while before getting the ISL-153, so the circuit logo doesn't phase me quite as much. Have this Rangemaster on a Wrist Candy Watch Club "Valor" NATO strap also designed by TGV. The black, gray, and touch of red are reflected between the strap, dial, and rehaut, and the steel blue brings a bit more subtle color.

[@_KxK]

This "knob logo" will keep me away from buying any Islander. I really like both guys and this collab would have been enough of a reason to buy one, but damn ... won't happen.

[@Roberto68n]

Check out the no logo models: ISL-102 thru ISL-113.

[@martinwroe5555]

Awful, homage.

[@jimg518]

Maybe if the logo was a different color like the blue on the box…..

[@shanel4496]

I missed out but congratulations and great review. (Something tells me they might bring a version of this back due to the unexpected and unanimous popularity.)

[@kerrybayton2954]

Its a sarb033 with a faux explorer dial, nothing new here!

[@thegorn]

Is this COSC certified? Regardless I could never get it with that weird eyeball logo

[@amysances8548]

The circle logo kills this watch, which is a shame because everything else is pretty nice. Standard bracelet Mark puts on his watches, not great but better than Seiko’s. This watch could have been great, but Mark is not willing to budge on his silly logo.

[@whichwatch4031]

I predict he changes it in less than a year from now. Take that to the bank!

[@AmritKumar-hp1rv]

It’s terrible indeed.

[@droptuned83]

I like the logo.

[@watchdogpodcast239]

He won't change it. He loves it. People have been complaining about it for 3 years now and he still sells tons of watches.

[@islandwatch]

@@watchdogpodcast239 yes, precisely. ;) Hate is always louder than praise.

[@Reclaimtherainbow_Gen9]

Great vid! I have the same Everest and it’s probably the only reason I didn’t buy this watch for my collection.

[@whichwatch4031]

Thank you! Everest's an amazing watch - and yes, there is overlap there.

[@tubntxhwyaaj8264]

Printed or applied markers, and or indices?

[@williammedaris2005]

Bought this watch to wear as my daily driver. Once I got the bracelet sized correctly, I almost couldn’t tell I was even wearing it. Nice review, I just happened upon it and figured I’d take a look.

[@whichwatch4031]

Wears very comfortably!

[@mjf2377]

I like Marks watches, but I hate the logo 😞

[@johnrb9397]

Congratulations. I hope you have better luck than me on impulse watch purchases. The only watches I’ve ever sold were impulsive purchases.

[@whichwatch4031]

Yeah - comes with the territory I guess. There have also been watches I've lusted after for years, only to find that I wasn't crazy about them.

[@marvean2519]

Your GS is gorgeous. As for the Islander logo, it would like nicer if they wrote Islander on the dial and keep the logo on the crown imo.

[@whichwatch4031]

Thank you, brother! Yeah - most watch brands seem to simply use their name up top (no logo).

[@mmd4315]

I watch marks vids and Im sure I will buy one of his watches one day. But i much prefer a logo that is a small long island like the shark on the heimdallr or LIW.

[@whichwatch4031]

Yeah - I was considering the same thing --- though the shape of Long Island isn't immediately recognizable to most people. I'm going to mockup up a few logo ideas and maybe issue a design challenge on this channel. Stay tuned!

[@wendyandgeoffpattison2610]

I like that they have included the "double lug" design of the sarb033. Well done Tris & Marc. Date at 6 and titanium next time?

[@dparis2172]

So numerals at 3 and 9 only?

[@robvale7692]

In my opinion the dial is a hot mess, but some how i like it.. I just wish the TGV logo was on top and just a larger Islander text on the bottom with 200m and self winding.. may a 12 instead of that large trophism.. to much islander logos.

[@meltdowngrfx969]

Love my Tudor Ranger 👍

[@triniboy05]

Did you find any cons about the watch? 🙃

[@canonmanmart]

If there is anything I hate, its a review of a watch that's not available at the time the review was made. This watch sold out in less than a day! I've expressed my displeasure to Marc and TGV about limited edition watches in general. To me, watching a review of a watch that is sold out is a waste of my time. Nice watch, wish I could have gotten one!

[@LaurentiusTriarius]

I love pretty much everything about it but I'd see the islander and TGV family crest inverted as you suggested.

[@kobusvanrensburg4092]

Too much logo-ing(?) going on IMHO, but as a first model, it looks really good.I like it.

[@jimv.6631]

I’m a little bummed there were only 500 of these. And what good is a review for a watch you can’t get?

[@rickewilde]

If the self-winding was under Marks island logo i think the balance would be better. The dial feels bottom heavy giving an impression that watch is upside down. Strange. Good looking piece otherwise

[@yogiyoda]

Interesting review but why didn't you show and review the lume?

[@whichwatch4031]

To be honest, I've never really cared about lume (some of my favorite watches don't have it at all). For visibility in the dark, I prefer tritium or Indiglo or digital w/ backlight. I like going through tunnels with lume though! I should probably consider including in future videos though - other folks seem to care.

[@yogiyoda]

@@whichwatch4031 - Good lume is awesome. I love being to read the watch in poor lighting conditions. ...especially on a tool watch like this one. On a dress watch, it doesn't matter much

[@MegaNaydan]

Great review!

[@whichwatch4031]

Thank you!

[@johnsinclair2672]

Smiths and Seiko are dress watches, the watch reviewed I’d a tool watch.

[@alastairheptonstall7982]

I'm really glad you were able to show it directly with the Smiths Everest, that was great. It's the other watch with a 3,6,9 dial in this price range that I've considered buying (though it's not been in stock). Great video, thanks!

[@Richard-hn2mb]

Totally agree lion needs to be on top 🙄😁🤗 Next time maybe

[@lonewolf30531]

Thanks for content . The logo in center is horrible .

[@waynejrice]

First. I bought this for my son. I'm pretty sure it's going to be awesome.

[@tomlittle380]

It is I got mine, fantastic. God bless

[@whichwatch4031]

Give it to him yet? How does he like it?

[@waynejrice]

Not yet. His birthday is in January.

[@waynejrice]

@@whichwatch4031 He loves it.

[@w5glsgary919]

Congratulations . I would love to see a side by side detailed review of your Rangemaster vs the Smiths Everest following a few months of ownership.

[@whichwatch4031]

Thanks! Will likely be comparing them in the full review. They're the only 3,6,9 watches in my collection, so pretty similar to me.

[@batmansk6]

All around uggo of a watch

[@onraj9mm]

Looks like every $70 Seiko.

[@xgford94]

How quick did they sell out, totally missed the opportunity

[@whichwatch4031]

Same day as the Urban Gentry put out his video....Maybe 4-6 hours later or something of the sort. Wasn't immediate.

[@dabec7463]

I’ll buy it if you wanna sell it

[@alanwilkinson4080]

Hats off to the enterprising nature of the watch's release - but isn't it something of a true Frankenstein as it appears to be so clearly the parts of other watches we all know put together?

[@whichwatch4031]

Yeah - there's truth in that...though most watches fall into this category. And then some veer too far away from the accepted mold and end up being too "out there." Uniqueness/originality is definitely more important for some and less for others.

[@alanwilkinson4080]

@@whichwatch4031 if it makes a buyer happy, we should all be happy! I suspect you are correct as most watches are just… watches. I am frequently wrong, but liked your video, and don’t regard myself as a watch expert, but this watch just felt so borrowed from other watches that are so, so familiar to me as a marginal watch person. Best wishes and keep up the excellent work.

[@FFFFelix]

Great review! Thanks. Mine should arrive here in France any day 😁

[@whichwatch4031]

Thank you!

[@jimwatchyyc]

Bezel looks way too wide on video too.

[@whichwatch4031]

After wearing for a while.....all-in-all, I think it's indeed a bit too wide. However, it's what differentiates it within my collection. For one-watch perfection, I'd pick something different.

[@richardNbacchus]

great review man! whats the other watch at 2:29?

[@whichwatch4031]

Thank you! It's a Smiths Everest Silver Jubilee. I reviewed the watch for my first video on this channel. It has a slick aventurine dial.

[@goodlifebdg]

How much is it ?

[@whichwatch4031]

It was $369 (get the joke?)...but not available any more. Sold out in a few hours. Now selling for double that or more second hand :/.

[@SoCalWatchReviews]

Great video and congrats on picking one up 👍🏼

[@whichwatch4031]

Thank you! I'm enjoying your channel, SoCal - good stuff.

[@SoCalWatchReviews]

@@whichwatch4031 thank you 🙏

[@canadianwatchmonkey3992]

Exactly that islander logo looks like a painted on sub dial

[@panorama4526]

Even the San Martin looks better, this watch is a joke.

[@matthewhowell1455]

Great review of a great watch! I bought a Rangemaster as soon as they released and have been wearing it constantly since I got it. New subscriber here and I will be looking for your videos in the future. @DigitalDivider on Watch Crunch

[@whichwatch4031]

Thank you! Glad you're enjoying it.

[@matthewhowell1455]

@@whichwatch4031 There are two Rangemasters listed for auction on ebay and the bidding is at $600 for one and $610 for the other! The lowest buy it now price for a Rangemaster is $875! Glad I ordered mine early!