Ranking Every Lawman in Red Dead Redemption II

[@ausernameicanuse8127]

Sheriff Freeman executing a Del Lobo was the coolest introduction to a town in the whole game

[@Cheez_Doodlezz]

He should had been a story line character and be voiced by Samuel L. Jackson

[@oc11studiosOFFICIAL]

@@Cheez_Doodlezzfax

[@studiosraufncingr6965]

@@Cheez_Doodlezz Sheriff Freeman: I've had it with these motherfuckings Del Lobo's in this motherfucking town!

[@sherm2572]

@@Cheez_Doodlezzhe probably would’ve if the new austin section of the story wasn’t cut out

[@Cosmiciconic]

Bro i stopped him from killing the del lobo idk y 😂

[@blaster23456]

For me, when I realized how nice Lambert was, I immediately thought "That is a man who got this position because he doesn't understand how bad things really are"

[@Gingersnap_Adventures]

He does have a nice mustache tho, you gotta give him that.

[@pedrotbird5426]

Sheriff Freeman gives major main character energy, the man can one shot you with that shotgun meaning he doesn't take any shit even from the main character

[@Jajusz]

Cuz hes na idiot without an Proper aim

[@Gingersnap_Adventures]

The fact he doesn’t take crap from the player themselves probably says something like you should be a partner or bounty hunter with him and not some enemy cuz that shotguns probably killed many people and blasted many heads off.

[@zTomasTurbando]

Malloy actually goes beyond cheating his wife. In a certain moment while passing behind his office, you can hear discussion coming from the upper floor. If you stay and hear you quickly realize it's Sheriff Malloy and his lover, Moira Calthorpe. If you stay to hear she says she wants to breakup with him, then you hear someone being strangled and Moira never appears again. So yeah, Malloy literally killed his fucking lover. And if you kill and loot Malloy, you will get a letter of Moira saying she wanted to breakup because she was afraid their affair would become public. He's also corrupt and accepts bribes from a guy who steals livestock.

[@garrettneukam2588]

What fr?? When can you encounter this

[@Gingersnap_Adventures]

Dudes at least a funny guy, he also seems like a guy who’d hold your drink for you.

[@MrfrogAXN]

Sheriff Freeman is awesome. He would’ve been even more cool if he was in the first game.

[@ckopen7192]

well tbf the firrst game also flips which one was populated and which one isnt.

[@nickv1212]

And I'm pretty sure he's based off of real life badass, ex-slave turned US Marshall Bass Reeves.

[@Gingersnap_Adventures]

If RDR1 ever gets a remaster I’d like if he’d at least be like the sheriff/secondary sheriff did those ever exist?) along side the Marshall since state Marshall and Sheriff are two different titles.

[@norhanl]

Even though he had a brief appearance, I really liked Marshal Slim Grant

[@LevisH21]

I wish the devs would have allowed the players to save his unique looking white hat. many lawmen have white hats but sadly you can't save them in your inventory.

[@guffingtonreal]

For some reason, Sheriff Freeman to me it feels like they wanted to get Keith David to voice him. Anyway, I love every single interaction we get with him in the story and the additional parts he gets in Online. He's so cool.

[@filmsbyhen]

YESSS everyone talks about sam Jackson but he gives me way more Keith David vibes

[@sheriff_of_tumbleweed]

"Challenge me and you will discover a new definition of justice. My definition." Very nice ranking.

[@oc11studiosOFFICIAL]

Ofc Freeman is best he’s like a certified badass and he just looks cool! Who don’t love Freeman

[@Joe_blow121]

People who have been one shot by him

[@oc11studiosOFFICIAL]

@@Joe_blow121 haha 😂

[@Jajusz]

I dont know, he abuses power and he is just a wannabe tough guy who can barely shoot (reason why he haves a shotgun) Malloy is best,a lot of missions and dead eye kind of thing

[@kingman-fm4dq]

​@@Jajusz he can one shot you though

[@AlikStansberry]

My favorite Chiefs/Sheriffs are; Malloy, Freeman, Dunbar and Lambert. Lambert absolutely rocks that handlebar mustache and accent, he’s pretty nice and respectful when you interact with him. Dunbar has always come off to me as this very friendly old man with plenty of experience, he’s the only lawman character I really feel bad for killing whenever I start a shootout in Blackwater. Freeman is incredibly badass and intimidating. The way he preaches about “the law is king, the law is emperor” and constantly lecturing you and the settlers to follow the law is really something. I’ve seen people can him the government version of Dutch sometimes lol. But yeah, Freeman is pretty much the goat. Malloy is a really close favorite for me, being the sheriff of my favorite town in the game and how bad and forth he and Arthur come off is nothing short of fantastic. I love his grizzled look in the epilogue and just looking at him I can tell he’s been through and seen a lot.(not to mention his badass facial scars)

[@JohnJackson-04]

Also he drops the hardest quote ever. "You don't hire a saint to catch a sinner."

[@groove7522]

"He's got no sauce no style. He's boring, I don't fuck with him, I don't fuck with his fit." you sir have my attention and my subscription.

[@naif4129]

Leigh Johnson was the best lawman ever Only 2011 kids know him

[@dennis_duran]

in 2011 I was 7, but I 100% agree. Leigh Johnson is one of the very best acted mocap roles I’ve ever seen.

[@fingerlessnoob8710]

yes i was born in 2010 but my dad has a copy of rdr 1 that i used to play with and i can 100% agree best lawman fr

[@Thedudewhoasked987]

Agreed

[@TaskForce_Raccoon]

Ya, always got vibes from him like he could take on anybody, as long as they were in his jurisdiction. He commands John Marston's respect which is not easy, especially since this is during John's assassin/gunslinger masquerading as a bounty hunter phase.

[@badtoxxin7909]

Marshall Tom Davies from online also deserves praise. Although not overly present in the missions he is very memorable to me

[@smuller1090]

How can you not like Dunbar, he is always friendly and does a decent job

[@JXßT3R]

His kinda sucks tbh

[@TaskForce_Raccoon]

The marshal of Armadillo in the first RDR was so badass, to this day I'll still replay the missions with him. He was one of the few people that wasn't intimidated by Marston and didn't try to manipulate him. He just said things how they were, and told John he could either ride with him or stay out of his way. I always got the feeling that He could've soloed the whole Vand Der Linde gang, just like Landon Ricketts probably could've gunned down everyone except prime John (after taking lessons from Landon).

[@gpturtle11]

I like how sheriff freeman in the games cannon was a famous gunslinger that couldn’t go straight so he became a sheriff

[@spyguy888]

Do you know where that info is from? Like is that found somewhere in game or something?

[@keecko8169]

one thing i dislike abt gray is we never see him outside of story missions. And IK its so we dont do some bullshit method to kill him before the final missions in chapter 3, but you cant even use GUNS in Rhodes during chapter 3 anyways so why not just see him around with archibald trying his hardest to upkeep the law?

[@krognarTV]

Henry your line was "yeah Palmer is kind of lame"

[@mojotex357]

Could you imagine a whole dlc about Freeman

[@benshapirosgreatuncle4060]

I think a “ranking every state” video would be awesome to see

[@keecko8169]

Its kinda easy to tell tho. LIke obviously Ambarino would be last since you're never really going to the grizzlies just out of curiosity. The only redeeming quality ABOUT the grizzlies is just that the white arabian spawns there and it's where American Venom mainly takes place. Then obv Lemoyne and New Hanover are gonna be fighting for 2nd and 1st. Then you can infer west elizabeth would be pretty low since blackwater is the only town keeping it alive because strawberry is lowkey kinda booty cheeks. Then you'd just have new austin chilling in the middle

[@kingman-fm4dq]

​@@keecko8169my ranking for example 5) Ambarino 4) Strawberry 3) new austin 2) new hanover 1) lemoyne

[@pygmyrhino8049]

I’m edging to this video

[@Literallyryangosling777]

Im mewing right now

[@terminallumbago6465]

My ranking from worst to best: 10. Sheriff Jones, Annesburg. I forgot Annesburg had a sheriff because a) he’s so basic, and b) I don’t go there unless I have to. To me he’s no different from any other random NPC. 9. Sheriff Palmer, Armadillo. We only see him for about 30 seconds before he talks about catching a train or a stagecoach (can’t remember which) then running off in the opposite direction. He’s a coward who apparently has no sense of direction. 8. Sheriff Hanley, Strawberry original. We only see him for 30 seconds before the prison break. He’s plain and boring but at least he’s not a deserter. He also gets a couple bonus points for calling Micah an idiot. 7. Sheriff Farley, Strawberry replacement. I was today years old when I realized he exists. He’s no different from any other NPC. 6. Chief Lambert, Saint Denis. He seems nice enough but I’ve had very little interactions with him. 5. Sheriff Gray, Rhodes original. He’s a drunken, incompetent oaf who clearly only got his position because of nepotism. But he’s important to the story so that’s why he’s not lower. Plus the scene where he dies is pretty cool. 4. Sheriff Thomas, Rhodes replacement. He’s definitely effective at his job and someone who’s not to be messed with. Plus he gives you extra money during the one bounty hunting mission. 3. Chief Dunbar, Blackwater. He’s a no-nonsense lawman who’s very effective at his job. I also love his comments about the bounties during the bounty hunting missions. He seems like a badass grandpa with a lot of stories to tell. 2. Sheriff Malloy, Valentine. I love his banter with Arthur and his snarky comments to and about the bounties. I also think the story of his not-so-hidden affair is interesting. 1. Sheriff Freeman, Tumbleweed. He is an absolute badass who upholds the law with an iron fist. He’s easily the most no-bullshit lawman in the game, and the random speeches he gives at all hours (regardless of if anyone is listening) are wild.

[@Paleolithic_footage]

Been waiting for this video for a long time, did not disappoint

[@noah_body_cares]

I genuinely really like Sheriff Malloy. I feel like he's the most honorable and reasonable out of any of the sheriffs (ignoring his affair lol)

[@haanis5458]

Bro literally killed a woman

[@gladeateor1950]

@@haanis5458makes him more a savage

[@koolaid33]

Sheriff Freeman is the highlight of Tumbleweed for me.

[@josh6795]

Literally the best editing and production ive seen on youtube no glaze, the intro was cool asf

[@Isaac_646]

0:06 Its kinda funny, but in Stillwater Oklahoma. At OSU university when there is a football game happening, the stadium screens play this before the players come out for the intro. Its engraved into my brain at this point because I've seen it for 15 years.

[@DrilleDeLesee]

Fun fact: Freeman kills the PC with one bullet. One of 4(?) characters that can do that.

[@ckopen7192]

hes just got better deadeye

[@StRANGEMANRDR]

hermit,night folk,freeman,vampire

[@g_grass874]

​@@StRANGEMANRDRi think you get oneshotted with the encounter in bayou where a guy asks you to save his wife

[@vennomation]

I hope you do more intros like this it’s really good

[@semerkin777]

0:38 you can meet him once more in Tumbleweed. He leaves Armadillo, and after that he works as a deputy in Tumbleweed. He brings the Del Lobo bandit to Sheriff Freeman. His model is unique, you can also see him in RDO.

[@Animalcell775]

If you got your plate empty please do a ranking video about all of the guns based off of aesthetic, performance or how fun they are. Your the goat🙏

[@vikramgeet]

After the first sheriff dies the second sheriff in strawberry v Farley I think that’s how to spell it never sits on the sheriffs chair where the old sheriff was sitting he sits like where he used to sit every time the one next to the door I think he is paying respect to the old sheriff

[@melodysketchdraws]

"I don't fuck with him, I don't fuck with his fit" man murdered the sheriff in his own damn office

[@MrKrabs69]

Arg arg arg I love you Henry films

[@aywhole]

money

[@RiverLiddell-v9g]

Sheriff Freeman is just the goat. Brutal, cold, and insane, he's the exact thing you'd think of when hearing "1800s wild west sheriff."

[@Tired_cowboy1899]

Sherrif jones reminds me of the bartender from rdr1 in armadillo

[@Gingersnap_Adventures]

Malloy’s my fave sheriff as he sounds and looks like a sheriff who you can trust and be your friend/partner with.

[@Bushmasterghillie]

I like how your outro song for this video is keep me hanging on by vanilla fudge it compliments the ending of the video with sheriff freeman.

[@farmtown4089]

lmao the beginning of the vid is so epic

[@enzoofelba]

Sheriff Jones doesn’t have a whole lot of character but he definitely nails this one line when turning in dead bounties: “Boy howdy, that one’s dead as a wagon wheel!”

[@Bravery206]

Sherrif Malloy is an absolute tank. You can shoot him like 5 times or more in the damn chest and he would still be alive.

[@zoroarkplayzz5360]

It’s crazy that after you kill the del lobo gang Sheriff Palmer goes to tumbleweed after he leaves Armadillo

[@derdork3233]

When i stumbled into tumbleweed and met sherriff freeman i was impressed. He was really intimidating. And executing the del lobo was the cherry on top. I never caused any trouble while in his town. When he asked me if i will uphold the law in tumbleweed i didn't even think about diaagreeing with him. Also because john is 'supposed' to keep his name clean and be a good citizen. After all, he left the gang life behind.

[@ZetsuboNoShima]

I’d love to see you do a video ranking your favorite bounties from story mode, as well as the infamous and legendary bounties from RDO :)

[@totalcreativegaming6681]

Gotta agree, Sheriff Freeman is a bonafide badass. He’s even pretty cool in Online.

[@thenorseguy2495]

Awesome video. I knew you would rank sheriff Freeman as nr. 1 and Malloy as nr. 2. Maybe you could rank the 10 best horses in story mode in one of your next videos🤠

[@DinoTruman]

love your vids man

[@5nafFNAFSquirrelsquirrel]

Bro there is no way that after I see tombstone and then I click and see that intro

[@gamingmoth4542]

Sheriff's Jones is kinda a "Mid" Sheriff. Nothing good, but nothing bad.

[@danim8414]

Here are some video ideas: Ranking secrets in rdr2 Ranking stolen/found/bought/crafted hats in rdr2 Ranking legendary animals in rdr2

[@the1truejoe178]

Not to mention sheriff Freeman one shots you if you are wanted. My head cannon is that sheriff Freeman is such a bad ass that he has deadeye.

[@ItsL402]

You completely humiliated sherif Palmer I’m glad Marshal Leigh Johnson is taking care of the area now Leigh Jo

[@cristinaelizabethkraat1569]

You should rank every region in the game, so like the bayou and Scarlett meadows in Lemoyne, The Heartlands and Roanoke for New Hanover, The West and east Grizzlies for Ambarino, Big Valley, Great Plains, and Tall Trees, or maybe make Great Plains and Tall Trees as one for West Elizabeth, and Finally The grazing countries and desert for New Austin. Just a thought.

[@AlastorTheNPDemon]

Freeman... reminds me of the archangel Azrael. He is similarly ruthless and lawful.

[@TexasBlueYT]

Sherif Palmer actually goes to tumbleweed and he’s the guy talking to freeman (who’s exciting the del lobo) when you enter the town

[@mtr1258]

I don’t F with him…I don’t F with his fit absolutely sent me💀

[@chrishelbling3879]

69-year old gamer here. Love your analyses of this glorious game.

[@NashTheInsomniac]

awesome stuff yo! I would love to see a hotel review video next! Valentine for me would be last jus cause it doesn’t have a deck right in the room, and that goddamn man screaming constantly next to you.

[@loaafe]

a lot of these sheriffs get more characterization in online

[@Rcpdcopsrcpdfr]

Freeman and the og sheriff gray from the story

[@Deebstertron]

Sam Freeman arrested me for arresting a Del Lobo unprompted. Apparently, I was "disturbing the peace".

[@Paleolithic_footage]

That's one thing I hate about this game. You can't bring criminals to the sheriffs around the world. Especially Freeman, he would be grateful for us to do so.

[@CountHasting]

Honestly number 9 I feel like he's the only reason. Strawberry is actually a peaceful town like he seems like a good sheriff. He's just really dry.

[@pvhep4036]

And his name is when Samuel L Jackson and Morgan Freeman had a little baby sheriff

[@Animalcell775]

Sheriff Farley 🔛🔝

[@UrlocalYamahaRider]

My boy really put woody in there 💀

[@joeyrodriguez4922]

My top 3 1 sheriff Malloy 2 sheriff freeman 3 police chef Lambert

[@The_Rejects_]

you can rarely find sheriff palmer in tumbleweed as a normal lawman but its not often

[@g1ad1y69]

I wish Freeman was involved in the story in some way. Too badass to not show him blowing heads off.

[@andrewgarcia5546]

Chief Dunbar. *gasp* 😲😲 could it be possible that he served in the civil war and had a trusty steed named Cisco?😉😉Wink wink, if y’all get my reference.

[@filmsbyhen]

And a wolf buddy named Two Socks!

[@andrewgarcia5546]

@@filmsbyhen thanks for the reminder lol can’t forget his trusty companion Two Socks

[@ravirr8407]

In online the blackwater police chief shaves his mustache off every time you turn in a dead bounty but it this clip he doesn't have it i guess he had the mustache in online only

[@kingman-fm4dq]

Cuz that's 1898, we can meet him (without him automatically shooting us) in 1907, nearly 10 years have, it's obvious he's older

[@johnmarstonwastaken831]

"Honey wake up henry films made his yearly upload"

[@thebigg774]

My favorite lawman is probably Fenton

[@ArthurVanDerTacitus]

Thanks for the intro! Tombstone is good as it gets!

[@MikeOhearn4Real]

The video we all waited for!

[@ncopictures7182]

Some of these guys are great, but none will beat the OG Leigh Johnson!

[@skinskinner]

gordon freeman: epic sheriff freeman epic

[@Hambot360]

Fun Fact: The Armadillo Sheriff can be seen in Tumbleweed, if i can remember correctly :)

[@cvcorvus]

lambert deserves to be top 3 for that mustache alone

[@notjimpickens7928]

ngl i killed sherrif malloy alot after i found out hes just a lesser version of bluebeard the bride-killers folk tale. bro killed the woman he was cheating on his wife with, and acts like normal afterwards 😬

[@ConnerNystuen]

Dunbar getting below Jones is criminal. That's my boy!

[@filmsbyhen]

He isn’t though? lol

[@ConnerNystuen]

@@filmsbyhen My bad, I meant to say Farley, don't know where I got Jones from lol.

[@filmsbyhen]

@@ConnerNystuen haha

[@Newlsop]

Something that makes me like Dunbar a little more is how he acts in the red dead online mission ‘if the hat fits 😂 he roasts his deputy for letting a conman out of his cell and they gave him a sick moustache and cooler hat (link to the video to save you time: kzbin.info/www/bejne/eqjIaKRsorqYjNksi=whpdho3BCWKXrRbe)

[@ofFISHal_FISH_FISH]

Palmer is the one to bring the del lobo to sheriff freeman when you first visit Tumbleweed i think it's just an reused character model cause his voice is diffrent

[@LOLIOI00]

Now don’t like Malloy neither hate him because he’s a great sheriff but he strangled his wife in his building. (To find out you go at night and go to the second floor of his office/building and get near the door and you should hear him arguing at his wife and then eventually strangle her).

[@NailLoneSoldier]

Oh and by the way since i got your attention, whats your opinion on Marshall Tom Davies

[@seancolorado]

it's a shame Freeman is sheriff of an epilogue town. He brings so much life to an otherwise empty area of the map

[@PureMotivationPower]

You forgot one thing. As far as I know Sheriff Freeman can one shot you with the shotgun. One of the only NPC that can one shot you no matter your health.

[@k1ng6879]

Sheriff Freeman is the only sheriff that one shots Arthur or John

[@gubson-xy2ow]

jones has got to be the worst one for me because since he holds his position in a mining town he is practically just a strike breaker

[@filmsbyhen]

Based on

[@gubson-xy2ow]

@@filmsbyhen in red dead online there is a legendary bounty where you get sent by him to capture or kill a union leader

[@tacticalbananas8885]

Van Horn’s law is the best without a doubt

[@meepliss7560]

great video I really enjoyed it

[@kavryck]

i love you henry films

[@Journey_to_who_knows]

I don’t understood why it’s Armadillo with the plague instead of Tumbleweed, the abandonment makes no sense with their roles swapped so much.

[@Cj01981]

If you haven’t you should rank every rdr1 gang hideout/sherrif

[@VyndettaahMedia]

Police chief Dunbar is super W

[@OndrejBartos-qf8jq]

Have you ranked every camp of the gang yet? Would love to see it

[@joeyrodriguez4922]

I honestly think sheriff gray should be 9 because I think he hired a sniper that killed Sean outta nowhere

[@Mruntouchable424]

Sheriff freeman has the same justice as akainu

[@americanboot7818]

You forgot to mention that sheriff freeman can one shot the player with any of his weapons

[@ohio4290]

2:51 I forgot annesberg even existed

[@NailLoneSoldier]

Sheriff freeman is even better in the online story