Rating AI Generated Magic: The Gathering Cards

[@TROLOLOLOLO007]

2:40 It just hit me. It says damage. Not combat damage. Thermo alchemist taps deals damage. Create a token with haste. Tap that one and boom infinite damage.

[@Clock83131]

Can confirm, any pinger is infinite with this one, including ETB triggers, and including damage to creatures.

[@yorickkuiper2999]

Fight or bite creatures work to. If you fight, you even get a copy of the opponent's creature that you fought

[@xryuran]

Was just coming down to say that

[@normanbromley-xd7ls]

Apex altisaur would cause crazy things to happen

[@grandbean9031]

Any creature attacking is actually infinite. A 1/1 attacks, it deals 1 damage. You copy a token with 1/1 and haste. It attacks for 1 damage, you copy a token with 1/1 and haste. It attacks for 1 damage. Rinse and repeat forever.

[@tmon3y777]

Narset goes infinite with literally any creature that has a ping ability because the token has haste. Fireslinger for one comes to mind, drop that on turn two then dark ritual into Narset on three and win without other cards needed. Broken as hell.

[@CS-wx3ob]

And he seemed to miss that only the person who controls Narset gets all the tokens.

[@BoxBoy_99]

Lmfao I only came into the comments to say this same thing. Looks like everyone noticed xD

[@HiddenOcelot]

​@CS-wx3ob the good past is it doesn't have to be your creatures that deal damage, if your opponent deals damage to literally anything you can make a copy of it.

[@MGSchmahl]

Even Icatian Javelineers is an infinite combo with this.

[@Muhahahahaz]

7:24 only Planeswalkers die from zero loyalty As an Artifact, this enters with zero loyalty by default. But because it has a +1 ability, it can gain loyalty counters. To activate a minus ability, you must have enough loyalty counters to pay for it, but the card doesn’t “die” at zero Edit: Found a ruling on it (I assume the same would apply for any non-Planeswalker permanent): “Loyalty abilities can be used by non-planeswalkers. A planeswalker which turns into a creature can still use its loyalty abilities, with the same timing restrictions and the same cost or addition of loyalty counters as usual. It will not go to the graveyard for having 0 loyalty until it becomes a planeswalker again.”

[@davidhower7095]

The superchat at 14:33 is wrong. Non-planeswalkers with loyalty abilities work perfectly fine. See Sarkhan the Masterless or Luxior, Giada’s Gift. The permanent not being a planeswalker means that it enters the battlefield with no loyalty counters, but because it’s not a planeswalker, it also doesn’t die from having zero loyalty. You still have to pay loyalty costs for those abilities.

[@rundalldj]

Also it's green counter doubling effects still happen on planswalker abilities.

[@defenastrator]

Yeah but unless it's been patched the restriction of one loyalty ability per turn is a property of the planeswalker type so...

[@64MilestotheGallon]

@@defenastrator that can't be right -- that would make luxior, giada's gift absolutely busted

[@Muhahahahaz]

14:31 in case anyone cares, Fireburn is wrong (Everything has zero “loyalty” counters by default. They’re just counters, they can have any name. The special number in the lower right just tells you how many counters to put on a Planeswalker as it enters the battlefield. Positive loyalty abilities literally add loyalty counters no matter what type the Permanent in question is)

[@samarius_art_and_games]

2:38 it doesn't say combat damage, it just says "deals damage", so a creature with a burn ability still gets copied if it uses that burn ability. And only the cards controller gets the tokens.

[@nailahprincessofhokuto2024]

Doesn't even say to a Player. So it would trigger from blocking

[@hurktang]

@@nailahprincessofhokuto2024 exactly, you block titan of industry with your 1/1. you get a 1/1 back and your own titan of industry.

[@grandbean9031]

If you have even a single creature with 1 attack then it's infinite.

[@gentleman_muk]

Would a creature with double strike trigger it twice?

[@samarius_art_and_games]

@@gentleman_muk yes. Meaning you, not the double strike's owner, get two tokens.

[@ExeEspe-by2ct]

Narset, the Freezed Cobra doesn’t say Combat Damage, so any damage caused by a creature is good, even just taping Goblin Firespitter would do it

[@reubenfromow4854]

Or summoning any 1 red cost creature that deals 1 damage upon entering

[@jeffreysugar5709]

Mogg fanatic. Just repeated sacrifice govlins

[@jedstanaland2897]

Non-planeswalkers can use loyalty abilities fairly easily without having a starting loyalty. Experiment kraj, and Shelob's food tokens are examples of how you can easily make a non-planeswalker have the ability to make use of loyalty abilities though they are still limited to once per turn unless you have other cards in place.

[@EcclesiastesLiker-py5ts]

Interesting design idea: What if Sew Assult means "You life total becomes x". That way, you can cast a timewalk for 3 mana BUT you go to 1 life, and if you want more you pay more, making the timewalk ability less broken. Pay enough, its lifegain.

[@justinfox2310]

Nanset and a infinitely-duplicating army of Prodigal Sorcerers

[@SomeGuy712x]

Second half of the video: (31:33) Those are nice Mountains. (31:36) Skate to-Gethbare: Word salad, shred. Man, it's once again a shame to have such neat art wasted on a ninged cards. Would've been really cool if this skateboarding Kor Elf Warrior did something sensical and awesome. (33:13) Magmaid Fragment: Super duper OP! Ship for Modern Horizons LXIV then ban! IT DANGER!!! Okay, so on turn 1, I'll play Mountain, Lotus Petal, and Magmaid Fragment. Next, I'll search my library for Atarka, World Render; Karlach, Fury of Avernus; Thrakkus the Butcher; and either Mass Hysteria or Concordant Crossroads, and put those onto the battlfield. Then finally, I'll attack with everyone twice for 118 total damage. GG. (35:08) Extraction: Fair, ship. Not sure what makes it a Class, but it's doable. However, if I wanted to turn land into life gain, I think I'd rather use Zuban Orb instead. At least the flavor is totally on point, and something that benefits from tokens such as Academy Manufactor would probably really like this. (36:20) Neat Swamps. (36:24) Thunder Show: Word salad, shred. Again with the amazing art, but on a card that just doesn't work. A sorcery cannot enter the battlefield, and even if it could, it would help not your life total. Also, the X in the mana cost isn't used for anything. (37:58) Lost Armist: Fair, ship. Totally doable! Nothing weird or dysfunctional about this ramp card at all! It Zibers! (39:53) Saprending Kigs: Word salad, shred. This Homorrib dies immediately upon being summoned. Must've been lemonfected with something nasty. :P (42:01) Whirlphode Trickster: Fair, ship. The static ability is strong, but it takes 8 mana to cast this guy, so it's totally fine, and the loyalty abilities are perfectly doable too. (43:41) Mirror Summoner: OP, ship then ban. Effectively a 5/5 flying dude for 4 mana, which is already a bit strong, and then it has a couple more upsides to it, especially its last ability. At least everything here is doable. It's just _really_ strong. (46:01) There's our Assamblack token. Neat. (46:10) Neat Islands. (46:13) Wingmaric Tender: Likely OP, ship then ban later if needed. Good for Vampire & Frie tribal, but seems quite pushed, being effectively either a 5/5 or a 4/4 with a +1/+1 counter on another creature with no downside right out the gate for just 3 mana. (47:29) Swallower Prowler: Fair, ship. The Fractals it creates will likely die instantly, but you will get card draws out of them. Maybe it's a tad OP, but what do I know? (50:27) Neat Plains. (50:30) Irenime from Offiros: Fair, ship. Banding is back, baby! It Zibers! (51:00) Spikd, Flame-Creater: Fair, ship. Interesting graveyard ability for sure. (52:48) Helm of the Invader: Fair, ship. Looks like the AI had to think "Twice" about this card's subtypes. Also, the bottom ability would be super niche, but otherwise, this is a pretty cool card. Maybe a bit OP, but we've seen far worse already. (54:55) Manacorn Knights: Likely OP, ship then ban later if needed. Interesting guy that really loves having counters put on him. Even -1/-1 counters would be welcomed. Oh, and you get lots of 1/1 Lifelink Insects from noncreature spells. That might be very OP. (56:27) Ju Tapes: Fair, ship. Don't confuse the creature token with Changelings. It's just a Changel creature. Anyway, it's effectively a 1/1 flier with Flash for 2 mana, which might have Artiface synergy. :P (57:25) Alkurin Recovery: Word salad, shred. Gotta investigate why the first player can't play lose lands. :P (57:43) Zurgo Zuo: Underpowered, ship. Might have synergy with Ninjutsu, but the mana cost of this artifact is just way too high. (58:39) Sun-Blade Sun: Fair, ship. The timing restriction is weird, but it's totally doable. Maybe work this into a deck with creatures that put -1/-1 counters on themselves, like Devoted Druid, the Hatchlings from Eventide, and creatures with Persist. (1:00:26) The Fist of the Surge: Fair, maybe underpowered, ship. Mana cost seems a tad high for what it does, but it is doable. (1:01:16) Tyrant's Tile Alla: Fair, word salad, ship. It has Partner, but isn't legendary, so that's kinda useless. And, there's no such thing as a "basic" creature... unless maybe you counted cards like Relentless Rats that allow you to have any number of them in your deck, but those don't actually have the "basic" supertype. (1:02:28) Oops, that's right! It's not even a creature! The power and toughness must be the true "Illusion Of The Fish". So... Word Salad, shred.

[@jasonking3182]

The Elder cat artwork is amazing

[@SomeGuy712x]

First half of this video: (0:00) Assa Lancellor: Fair, tiny bit of word salad, ship. Just remove the comma after "instant" and it would be just perfect. Maybe a tad OP, actually, but honestly, white could use the card draw. This totally Zibers. (1:06) Those are indeed a couple of nice Islands. (1:12) Narset, the Freezed Cobra: OP, ship then ban. Any pinging creature such as good ol' Prodigal Sorcerer will go infinite with this easily. Maybe if it got rid of the haste part, and/or restricted it to combat damage... it would still be broken if it let you copy your opponent's guys whenever they smack you, so limit it to just creatures you control too. (3:48) Purging the Sea: Word salad, shred. I give this card a 4 out of 10. :P (5:04) 4 means death for this card's eligibility. (Along with the superfluous lifelink and the undefined X.) (5:17) Arcane Broodmaster: Likely OP, word salad, shred. Define "it" before I can even consider this. (6:37) Arcriat's Attendant: Word salad, shred. A non-planeswalker artifact with loyalty abilities is technically doable. However, the -9 ability has another undefined X. D'oh. (8:59) Yeah, that is true, so maybe this is fair and can be shipped. Still, I'd reword it to: "Exile any number of cards from the top of your library. You may play them this turn." (9:17) That's a nice Plains. (9:19) Kaph Vastle: Word salad, shred. The reminder text for swampwalk is wrong, it's just a "Legendary - Construct" without being a creature or any other regular card type, and it has no power/toughness. (11:33) Nulls, the Darner: Word salad, shred. It was okay until partway through the block of text. So, this card's chances are now null. Darn. (12:15) That's a comma, not an apostrophe. (12:17) And now, Chaot ensues! :P (12:23) Chaot: Practically unplayable, shred. If those two sentences were swapped, then it would be doable, and in fact OP. But, as it is here, all it'll do is trigger the city's blessing if you have ten or more permanents, and then fail to return any creatures from the graveyard to the battlefield, because it just exiled them all! (14:37) Huh, so non-existent loyalty is not the same as having 0 loyalty counters and being able to activate a + loyalty ability? (14:52) Glossum Sew Assault: OP, word salad, shred. The X in the cost isn't used for anything, we don't need a white Time Walk taking over the meta, and this card's words lost total controlleds controls. (16:09) Riptic Turd: Fair, ship... Wait, it has no card type! It only has a hyphen and a subtyped! Aw, well that stinks for this turd. If it had the card type Creature, it would totally Ziber. (17:14) WAH! You usually restrain yourself from saying that kind of word. I'm surprised you didn't go with something like "bullcrap" instead... (18:19) Obstral Mark: Fair, ship. Finally, a 100% doable card! Great for decks that focus on -Treefolk- Tranfolk tribal too! It Zibers! (20:32) Those are some nice Wastes. (20:36) Jamer, the Silencer Trap: Fair, word salad, shred. I assume the activated ability is referring to each color in the spell you exiled. That ability is actually rather underwhelming, I think. Also, the last two sentences are wonky with when they occur. Remove those, and this would be doable. (22:43) Nimbus Iddid: Underpowered, shred. Well, it technically does something... that isn't really meaningful. So, this like the goggles that do nothing. (24:11) Deadly Titans: Word salad, shred. Man, such cool art wasted on this undefined X that we've seen all too often. Maybe if that X there was a finite reasonable number like 2 or 3, or if there was an X in the mana cost, then this would be doable. (25:52) Fire Strength: Fair, ship. It's doable, though the way its ability works, it would've made sense for it to have the Background subtype. (27:54) Basal Strike: OP, ban before even thinking of shipping it! If it had only the first sentence of text, it would just be a mediocre burn spell, but then that second sentence is where it gets completely bonkers! IT DANGER!!!

[@ShadowVR2]

Did anyone looking at Narset, the Freezed Cobra ever make the connection that Tyranid might be referring to the race from Warhammer 40k?

[@stevefurrier9932]

23:54 If you have cards in your graveyard,do you put the cards in the graveyard on top of each other?Cause if yes,it can be useful,to look,what kind of creature died before the last creature? Czuse then you can assume what deck is an opponent playing,and which creature your opponent plays next turn)?It can help in certain situarions

[@cad97]

There are pre-modern cards that care about graveyard order and if those are available players need to maintain graveyard order, but by current modern rules you're allowed to rearrange your graveyard arbitrarily at any time.

[@stevefurrier9932]

@@cad97 Thanks

[@sceadumor]

Tbh, at this point I'd view a solitary X in the casting cost as a feature to change the casting cost for cards that care about it.

[@stevefurrier9932]

36:06 What does food tokens do? And how many times you can sac a land? Until you have none?Cause on turn 7 that could be very strong

[@cad97]

{2}, {T}, Sacrifice this artifact: You gain 3 life.

[@divicarpe1844]

I saw the end in stream, now I can see the beginning.

[@stevefurrier9932]

1:01:40 I think basic creature means,that only effects non-legendsry creatures,and not effects legendary creatures,planeswalkers,or token crestires,or creature copies

[@davidhower7095]

Basic creatures don’t exist. But… Basic Lands do. If you turn a Basic Land into a creature, it will satisfy the card because your forest is now a Basic Land Creature.

[@cassandracastro2759]

It occurs to me that a way to make Chaot (14:00) playable would be: 4B, Sorcery - Ascend. Exile all graveyards. Then, if you have the City's Blessing, return all creature cards you own exiled by Chaot to the battlefield. I don't know how busted it would be, getting the city's blessing on a deck that tries to get creatures in the graveyard can be a little difficult.

[@rundalldj]

Under that text you could just bring back all creatures and it would still be fair

[@andreleleux3581]

On Narset the Freezed Cobra 2:45 think of the creatures that have "Tap: deal 1 damage to any target" and then give them a way to get a hasted copy on damage. It just allows for an infinite combo for any number of tap to deal damage pings

[@stevefurrier9932]

19:53 How many of this special land could you have in play pr in the deck? I never palyed magic,i am just here for the laughs.And another question,how many cards is in a deck? Or is it depending on format?

[@davidhower7095]

In most formats, you can play up to 4 copies of the card, and the deck size minimum is 60 cards total. In commander, you’re only allowed to play 1 copy of the card, out of 100 total cards.

[@stevefurrier9932]

@@davidhower7095 I thought to the legendaries you have another limit,and the 4 copy applies to only common cards,not legendaries. I think another youtube MTG creator said this once,or there is w new rule,what i don't know?

[@draconis17]

Manacorn Knights, finally a place to dump all the counters that don't do anything from the other cards

[@stevefurrier9932]

13:44 Do we have cards what is if exiled goes back to the graveyard,even if you exiled it from the graveyard?In this case coupd be useful

[@davidhower7095]

There are cards that do that, but the entire card has to finish resolving before anything else can happen. So there’s no way to sneak something back into the graveyard between effects.

[@lenardstarks5891]

I understood Jamer as exile cards from the top of an opponent’s library’s until they exile x lands where x is the number of colors of the spell you exiled then return the lands in a random order and leave the rest exiled

[@mr.selfdestruct7928]

chaot can be used with creatures with channel; cast chaot, exile graveyards, channel a creature into your graveyard and chaot puts it to the battlefield

[@nathanwilkins6107]

Things can’t happen in the middle of a spell resolving

[@a.giovanni.m6740]

54:50 Manacorn's first effect concerns me. Does the number of +2/+2 counter Manacorn Knights is equal to the number of counters on it? If that's the case, if it only has a single +2/+2 (nothing else) counter on it, nothing happens. The moment you adds another counter of a different type (example, one +1/+1 counter or a loyalty counter) on it though, the number of counters on it becomes 2, with 1 of them being that +2/+2. Manacorn then puts another +2/+2 counter on it, and there's three counters on it. I think you get the idea where this is going. I'm not an MTG player, so let me know if I've made a mistake somewhere.

[@lyndsaypeters5981]

56:18 I'm pretty sure there's a creature that has an ability where the cost is to put -1/-1 counters on creatures. With this card there's no downside so you can use it as many times as you want

[@clangauss4155]

Surely a non-creature artifact with no loyalty counters gains a loyalty counter if you somehow +1 it, right?

[@SephieRothe]

Fire Strength + Xantcha, sleeper agent. It says Commander creatures you own and Xantcha goes into an opponents control when she ETBs so you can get the advantage when attacking that opponent.

[@Zeekfox]

@18:19 I seem to recall Nikachu in past videos being okay with something like a 4 mana 5/5 with haste and trample or something like that, saying it wasn't overly pushed for Modern. Obstral Mark is essentially 4 mana (three plus tapping the land itself) and a sacrificed land drop for a 5/5. Granted it is colorless, immune to counterspells, and can be done at the end of the opponent's turn, but it does put you a mana behind if you turn it into a creature. But perhaps the option of just having the land that can convert to a creature is powerful enough? I don't really know.

[@ReyosBlackwood]

Narset the freezed cobra doesn't say they create a token copy, it says YOU create one, so if an opponent swings, you get a copy of all their creatures, it also doesn't say damage to what, so if someone blocks, you then get a token copy of all the blockers too. the card is insanely broken, like play this and win level

[@Chepakishui]

Thunder show: anything other than your life total becomes 20.

[@thepotatorepublic9481]

39:48 The other revealed cards go on the battlefield to

[@quincyking010]

Fire strength effects any creature that deals damage to you including your own. So it's a self harm effect that let's u draw 2 and if it's a sacrifice card that does it it shuffles from graveyard.

[@stevefurrier9932]

11:01 How does normal(not ai generated)constructs work? Can somebody explain to me?

[@jellywillreturn]

It’s just a creature type, it has no implicit properties.

[@stevefurrier9932]

@@jellywillreturn Thanks.

[@dr.tre90]

Obstral Mask reminded me of Ambush Viper. I always so wish that I could just flash it in to block immediately without my opponent getting priority again, but I can't 😔 Token would have the same problem but these effects are still cool.

[@lyndsaypeters5981]

59:50 they're a bunch of cards that give benefits at the cost of slowly getting weaker with -1/-1counters

[@stevefurrier9932]

48:37 I think if The card is 0/0 so or dies first,so it wouldn't have the time to activate the ability upon death,cause the card didn't got say you sqcrifice it

[@reddragonminecraftmodsandm4366]

Fire strength works if your own creature pings you to draw two cards

[@Muhahahahaz]

18:55 it’s essentially 4 mana though, because Obstral Mark cannot generate mana during that same turn (Also, you’re sacking a land and permanently losing 1 mana for all future turns)

[@ILIAL_General]

Ok I know I’m very late but wouldn’t jamer also allow you to look at said cards? And wouldn’t it happen multiple times for each colour on the card you exiled so you have multiple chances to know the card order? Let’s say I exile a card, red, blue, black, I exile the top three cards of my opponents library I see uh muldrifter emrakul and a plains (named three random cards) in that order, the 2nd timw I only see the muldrifter and plains in that order which means emrakul is the third top card and on the third time I see only a plains meaning the top card of their deck is plains the next is muldrifter snd the next is emrakul

[@silverifications]

That Narset just says damage, not combat damage and it doesn’t say to a player. That is hecka broken. If your creature gets blocked, you get two creature tokens. If your creature pings something, you get a token.

[@PlatonicLiquid]

With haste, so it can ping again, infinitely if it doesn't use resources

[@jaimerivera2382]

Any creature with an ETB trigger that targets a player is game over. Or even just a lowly pinger. Have a pinger in play, play Narset, tap your pinger to deal damage to face - you get a new pinger with haste that you tap to deal damage to face - you get a new pinger with haste that you tap to deal damage to face - ad infinitum.

[@3st3st77]

0:23 The comma is important here. The effect states that when you cast your first instant of the game, you must spell "each turn" like in the spelling bee contest. Afterwards, you may draw a card. I don't know what happens if you spell it incorrectly. You probably still draw a card.

[@blueredlover1060]

23:47 It is an artifact, so there might be value attached to the type. Mostly does nothing.

[@dancing_odie]

1:52 Narset, The Freezed Cobra would be op with Thermo- Alchemist. Tap Thermo, deal 1 damage, get another Thermo with haste. Tap the token, deal 1 damage, get another token...

[@stevefurrier9932]

52:15 It's a legendary so you could only have 2 copies of it,no? You need a card what puts things into graveyard,and a card,what brings back things from the graveyard,so every second turn,you can draw a lot of cards.Put it into the graveyard,cast abilities while it's in the graveyard,and what messes with the graveyard,than bring back the Spik,Flame-Creater,and do this on the next turn

[@davidhower7095]

Spikd doesn’t leave the graveyard when his ability triggers. It will trigger every turn until he’s removed from the graveyard by something else.

[@stevefurrier9932]

@@davidhower7095 I told it's in graveyard,do the things,then bring back,put it back to the graveyard,and you can do it again,the same

[@_Vengeance_]

I love the design of Basal Strike and Magmaid Fragment. They give red a clear new color identity, the higher-cost card is appropriately more powerful than the lower-cost card, and the AI even designed it so Basal Strike doesn't make Magmaid Fragment useless by letting you Cycle it (otherwise it'd be awful for card advantage if after Basal Strike you have 1 dead card in your hand).

[@stevefurrier9932]

32:15 I want that just for the art

[@nighthawk0317]

From how I'm reading Lost Armist, you don't just put the lands on the battlefield because because it say reveal until you 3 lands and put them on the battlefield. There's a dimir mill cards that does something similar when you cast certain spells is the reason why I believe it would work this way. However, i could be wrong.

[@gene8447]

OK but Jamer doesn't say that those exiled cards come back, just the lands. Play a wubrg spell and you can get through a good half of their deck in exile by midgame. And at that point... what, you gave them more lands? That they may not even need? Oh no... landfall isn't even in our current standard set, so all you're doing is potentially giving them dud draws while exiling their deck.

[@nathanwilkins6107]

I asked chatGPT to make flavor text for the broodmaster and this is what it gave: "Within the heart of the enchanted forest, where whispers become winds and shadows dance with moonlight, the Arcane Broodmaster emerges from the ancient thicket. As the eldest of feline mystics, it weaves spells into its every step, leaving trails of starlit dreams in its wake. Its mesmerizing eyes hold the secrets of ages, and its mighty paws command the very essence of magic. The forest bows to its presence, for it is not just a guardian, but the embodiment of the wild arcane itself."

[@FreedomTaleTrio]

1:02:03 I think basic creatures would be creatures without any abilities, aside from (maybe) flying and/or haste.

[@Elvalley]

"Extraction" is black because you're literally destroying the land to get food, instead of implementing a more sustainable method of generating food (like using any card that taps for food or generates food in any way that doesn't imply losing permanents)

[@SecularStrategy]

1:01:34 If someone casts Animate Land on a forest, then it dies, it will trigger this effect. Extremely narrow, but it can happen.

[@taemyr]

22:41 Furgus prothection will tend to bring one land closer to the top of opponents deck.

[@BoxBoy_99]

2:38 it says "damage" instead of "combat damage" meaning that any source of dmg, from an activated (and tappable, possibly) ability, or from a fight spell would trigger this. Not only does this go infinite on any creature that has a "tap: deal [damage]" ability, since it isn't limited to once per turn, this would be also pretty strong in a Gruul deck yeah? Think this card is broken... Needs a limit of once (twice?) per turn for balance reasons.

[@ShadowAgent94]

The manacorn turtle would also get boosts for other counters like flying counters or indestructible or a hexproof counter

[@Daniel-q9f8p]

In token decks you can play Fire Strength, give an opponent control of your commander, attack them and trade your tokens for a ton of cards.

[@ReyosBlackwood]

9:12 you wouldn't want to, notice it doesn't say "without paying their mana cost" so you have to pay for the cards you exiled, if you have a cheap enough combo you could try it, but it's really very glass cannon to try

[@richardfarrer5616]

Narset the Feezed Cobra + Basalt Ravager, say: Escalating chain of damage to any targets which kill all opponents.

[@Muhahahahaz]

57:07 that’s pretty funny, you came up with a Chadra/angel portmanteau 😂 Pretty sure the AI just took the “ing” off of Changeling though… (Which would have actually been useful)

[@EHShinobi]

53:59 Steal opponents creatures with hijack effects, attack with them and exile them at end of combat step, frog is actually a good way of perma removing potent creatures from the opponent's field. Do not underestimate that 3rd ability

[@burnsida]

For Jamer, if you play omnath, your opponent reveals cards from the top of their deck until they reveal a land card, they would do that a total of 4 times, and then put the 4 land cards on top of their library in a random order, and who knows what we do with the rest of the revealed cards

[@TheEpicSpire]

24:20 since you choose x.. then exile your whole deck.. play all the lands (since this card says that i can) and then cast my winning combo. could be a turn 1 win if i have a lotus petal, a swamp, and this card in my starting hand....

[@danhendricks5896]

Nikachu, "its not gonna enter the battlefield, its a sorcery." This sounds like a challenge.

[@thezerowulf2046]

Chaot is actually a really cool card. Because it is a 2 part effect, so you exile all graveyards yours included, then you have the opportunity to put creatures into your graveyard at instant speed before the 2nd trigger. Thats a really fun spell.

[@suprememasterleader3355]

you cannot activate instants in between differant phases of a cards effect resolving. once the effect goes on the stack you can respond, when it is resolving no one can do anything until it has finished resolving

[@jarkkos]

Would Arcriat's Attendant work as an Equipment for Plainswalker, giving it those additional abilities. Well, it doesn't say it is Equipment, but if it did :D

[@christopherpoet458]

3:11 - Not sure you are getting how busted this card is. The damage trigger says NOTHING about it being combat damage. So... cards that "tap: deal 1 damage to target opponent" get spammed. Each token gains haste and can tap to deal 1 damage. And the card says nothing about tokens not being affected. This is a Mono red commander for sure.

[@somecleverthing]

Move over Coalition Victory; forcing your opponent to eat 8 magic cards is the greatest alternative win condition of all time.

[@VodShod]

5:00 they may have a casting cost of 4?

[@Muhahahahaz]

4:32 wow… You’re right! I had assumed X would just default to zero (as it does in certain other situations involving X in the mana cost). But it turns out that Rule 107.3f allows us to choose any value for X, if it isn’t defined 😂 However… “double Lifelink” isn’t a thing. Multiple instances are redundant, so you would only heal once (which totally makes this card fair and balanced Kappa)

[@DesArthes]

2:40 is too broken: life gain in red, what they thinking??

[@lyndsaypeters5981]

6:00 actually generated a card that had the ability to activate when you eat it it had ingest but the reminder text said when this card enters your mouth

[@dancing_odie]

13:00 If it exiles all graveyards, how can it return creatures from the graveyard to the battlefield? It should say "Return all creatures from your graveyard to the battlefield under your control then exile all graveyards."

[@danhendricks5896]

Lost armist reminds me of the two land goblin charbelcher decks. If you don't have 3 lands in the deck, you will put your whole deck into play. The challenge then becomes casting it with so few lands.

[@clegge7]

36:24 You can use magmaid fragment from two AI cards before to get it onto the battlefield!

[@nathanwilkins6107]

Purging the sea loses to any -1/-1 effect so maybe it’s fine. (This is of course a joke) To fix Jamer it should exile until you reveal x lands and then you put the lands into play tapped under your control.

[@Tletna]

Nikachu wasn't understanding that new Narset card correct. That thing was way way OP. Also, Narset's controller makes a token any time any creature (opponents' also) does *any* damage.. I just don't think he realized how busted that was. Also, several potential infinite combos there. Also, maybe I'm out of the loop with rules, but isn't X unspecified just = to zero?

[@isthisone]

If X is unspecified, it may be chosen

[@Tletna]

@@isthisone During casting or activating an ability, that makes sense. Otherwise, that makes zero sense. Also, just saying it doesn't make it true/untrue. Where in the rules would I find that? In the old days, I'd just read the rules, but nowadays I feel like I need to hire a tax attorney to read through MtG rules.

[@oelboy]

2:20 Fanatical Firebrand, Cunning Sparkmage and Vulshok Sorcerer immediately break Narset. Firebrand + Narset is a 6 mana "I win the game" combo in mono red. That's really danger! Other than that, such a deck would probably consitently win as soon as Narset comes into play.

[@BoringAaron]

Swallower prowler making a 0/0 creature triggers all the "when a creature enters" and "when a creature dies" triggers you may have lying around

[@PhantomMarth]

Jamer, the Silencer Trap would be insane. For each color, that player has to exile until they find a land card. "Put those cards," referred to the lands. The remaining cards stay exiled. So, play spell they exile version of Mind Funeral however you have screwed their next draws to be only lands. That's how I understood the wording. But am probably wrong 😅

[@oelboy]

1:01:39 Dryad Arbor + Rootpath Purifier leaves you with a Basic Land Creature.

[@benjones1717]

Arcane Broodmaster; shove 8 cards in your opponents mouth and win the game

[@oz_jones]

Definitely from an un- set 😂

[@pyrotempestwing]

Thunder Show might work in Commander on turn 2, assuming we’re going with the “a player other than you” interpretation.

[@nlb137]

Narset would be a two-card combo with any pinger. Pinger pings, makes a copy with haste, the copy pings, makes a copy of the copy, etc. Totally busted.

[@doktahv8837]

Ok so I just wanna know PlatonicLiquid, who is that on your profile pic? It's really bugging me.

[@benjaminberkey2920]

That manacorn knight is so broken. It synergizes perfect with doubling season. Perfect in a gruul deck. Have season out, the knight, and a green spell that allows you to distribute more than one +1/+1 counters among creatures you control could make him huge and also create six 1/1 flyers with lifelink.

[@Kantilvih]

Narset manages to make a token of itself, which uses its haste to heal. Then next turn, each triggers twice, and you have scute swarm buildup

[@TheAceOfFire]

2:38, Not only do the tokens not go away after they are created, but anytime or creature attacks anything else including other creatures... Only you, the owner of narset gets the copies! In Commander that means that if any player fights anyone else, you just gained an army for no cost! This is beyond broken. 27:33, Fire Strength won't draw your opponents ANY cards, because it's only affecting Commander creatures that you personally own!

[@BoringAaron]

It's very impressive that a card with creature type "insect" actually looks like an insect

[@2019inuyasha]

A loyalty ability of a permanent can still be activated even if that permanent isn't a planeswalker. But even so, in general, only one loyalty ability of a permanent can be activated in a turn, and only once that turn (C.R. 606.3).606.3. A player may activate a loyalty ability of a permanent they control any time they have priority and the stack is empty during a main phase of their turn, but only if no player has previously activated a loyalty ability of that permanent that turn. The rule says "of a permanent," not "of a planeswalker." You can activate a loyalty ability, even if the permanent in question is not currently a planeswalker. So yes you can add a loyalty counter to any permanent but can only activate that permanent loyalty ability once per turn to either add or subtract loyalty counters from the permanent. only planeswalkers would die from no loyalty. to activate ability you must however remove appropriate amount of loyalty counters...

[@tylerhorn3712]

I like how you've learned the niche mtg terms.

[@maxwellmulford5898]

The Narset is STONE COLD BROKEN. It doesn’t say anything about hitting the opponent or anything like that, even if they’re blocked and deal damage to their blocker. Even if they die, they replace themselves. It’s not printable.

[@somecleverthing]

What if the frog helm swamp was like Spikd, where it drew a card and then exiled a card from your hand. That would actually be pretty balanced on a swamp that comes in tapped.

[@rundalldj]

38:44 Land fall would go nuts.

[@Kristjan0209]

What great start to the video. Suprised you haven't heard of tyranids since the warhammer decks were very popular. Also for reason you thought the creature had to hit face and finally you get the copies. So for example I attack with a 2/2 they block with a 2/2, they trade and you get 2 2/2 creatures.

[@Computer-STEM-NERD-903]

Better Version of Chaos( “Chaot”: 14:13 ): “Ascend(Reminder text here…) If you have the City’s Blessing, Exile all noncreature spells from all graveyards, then return all creatures from all graveyards under your control. Otherwise, exile all cards from all graveyards.”

[@Computer-STEM-NERD-903]

Tbf, strictly better/worse Rise of the Dark Realms

[@BoxBoy_99]

After watching this, i briefly hopped onto chat GPT (first time too, made an account) and provided it with a quick prompt. Heres what it came up with! Crescendo: Legendary Enchantment Mana Cost: 3W Flavor Text: "It only goes upwards from here." Abilities: At the beginning of your upkeep, you may tap any number of creatures you control. If you do, put a +1/+1 counter on each of those creatures. (Note: This is a custom card and not an official Magic: The Gathering card. It's created for fun and creative purposes.) What do y'all think?

[@BoxBoy_99]

Attempt two (this time LOTR set): Legolas, Friend of the Dwarves Legendary Creature - Elf Warrior Mana Cost: 2RG Abilities: When Legolas, Friend of the Dwarves dies, you may search your library for a Dwarf creature card and put it onto the battlefield tapped. If you do, shuffle your library. Power/Toughness: 3/3 (Note: This is a custom card and not an official Magic: The Gathering card. It's created for fun and creative purposes.)

[@NikachuMTGLive]

It’s neat!

[@jackattackhissnack]

Narset goes infinite with enchanter tim