Rating Custom Magic: The Gathering Cards

[@noname-eo1he]

8:50 "The Game" (Memetic Hazard Variant) is a nice reference. Speaking of which, I just lost the game.

[@Temperans]

I am surprised someone managed to make so many people lose "The Game" simultaneously, props to them.

[@jothki]

And Nikachu wasn't one of them, apparently. When did people who aren't me get so young?

[@MegaHuntress]

The man is a menace >:D

[@Gr3y1F0x]

I lost the game.

[@TallDarknGruesome]

Snow dragon seems like a perfectly fine card. That last breathability just needs a clause that I can only be used once per turn

[@helmholtzthemulewatson4763]

Or better yet. "the first time you use this ability each turn" That way you can still pump it like an actual shivan

[@mapeus]

4:00 Man, would it have to be changed in MTG like Necrovalley was (from yugioh)? It's rather unclear what would "affecting the graveyard" (I'm guessing it's "affect", not "effect") really mean.

[@BrolysShadow_]

Hope custom streams can stay on wednesdays. If not, it was a pleasure making cards for ya

[@amazincrackmonkey7176]

Bacon catbug's caricature cards are great. Really embodies the coffee crew.

[@Lyakusha1]

Damnit! I've lost the Game

[@dancing_odie]

Those spark spells require that spell to be the planes walker ability for the turn so the green one makes sense. It means you can't use that planeswalker's loyalty ability for the turn

[@MajraMangetsu]

Witch is really good.

[@Wauly]

35:00 I think it would be cool to have a spark spell that pluses a planeswalker or one that proliferates

[@mythtage]

i love using ichormoon gauntlet which is sorta close to that

[@Lyakusha1]

More than 3 hours! You guys really like your custom cards

[@NikachuMTGLive]

I know!

[@algotkristoffersson15]

34:53 it cost the ability to activate that planeswalkers loyalty abilities this turn.

[@TeaHauss]

23:00 honestly, a flusterstorm for abilities would be somewhat fair, it theoretically stops the super greedy with their crazy value. It would need a specific variation of storm like, "ability storm - copy this spell for each ability target player put on the stack this turn." Otherwise, the caster can build their own value train and make the copies themselves. Probably a green card since they've countered abilities in the past? Personally, I'd add colors to it to make it less ubiquitous, maybe {G}{W/U}

[@lainling]

Feels like a mechanic that would only be playable in digital. Way too many ways to miscount how many abilities went on the stack in the turn.

[@SuperfieldCrUn]

I believe the reason behind Spellflare's wording is that it allows you to choose whether a spell hits everyone or just all of your opponents. Target yourself, and it will copy onto all the opponents. Target an opponent, and it will copy onto the other opponents, but not you.

[@SuperfieldCrUn]

The Spark abilities don't just consume a planeswalker's loyalty counters, it also counts as them using a loyalty ability - and planeswalkers can only use a loyalty ability once per turn. So the 0 loyalty cost on World's Birth would require you to both have a planeswalker under your control and they wouldn't be able to use one of their own abilities that turn. You could conceivably have Spark cards that add loyalty counters and it would still be considered a cost as that planeswalker wouldn't be able to use a different, arguably better ability on that turn.

[@sureskonkmtg]

Arcanis Ultra's right, I wasn't around for my last card but Ragnarok's win condition is based off of Norse Mythology, where the world would rise again after the burning of the world with two human survivors, Líf and Lífþrasir. I tried to balance the card by making it Legendary (you need at least one legendary creature, maybe your Commander in edh formats), making it target a lot of things through damage (can be thwarted by indestructible, shroud, hexproof, etc) and being specific in exactly 2 humans. It's possible that you could try to combo with Ragnarok in some sort of lifegain burn deck, but it requires setup, which I feel every alternate win condition of this magnitude should have.

[@nycstreetpoet]

11:16 I want it to get printed. They stapled three Hedron Crabs together, and a group of crabs is, in fact, called a consortium. 15:20 All of the other morph/manifest cards can only be flipped if they are a creature. Pull from the Aether doesn’t care, which makes probably too strong.

[@Lasagnadestroyer]

3 hour stream!?!? Raking in that money 💰

[@Littledeadfly]

44:19 That's not a bad idea, oelboy. It helps with most of these cards from sounding so clunky. 48:28 OK, I also LOLed.

[@EmilyGamerGirl]

2:45:40 How often are you ***drawing your Commander***? It would need to be in your library?

[@NikachuMTGLive]

Brainstorm!

[@thiagosestini29]

28:20 Not Sengir Vampire, but Seraph (Ice Age) is pretty close.

[@fabienchamberland4791]

4:00 Necrovalley looking card

[@MajraMangetsu]

The idea behind Judy was more Gobelin Sharpshooter. But Massacre Girl is a valid comparision, lol.

[@araxansilverblood1549]

I will say about World's Birth, even at 0 Loyalty it still takes the ability use for the turn, if you don't have the select few cards that add more which is really rare outside Commander.

[@CanisMythson]

I have an interesting idea, but I wouldn't know how to implement it, let alone show it. I was thinking something like that Friend of Wolves guy, but... Trixillia, Guardian of Fate (3WB) Legendary Planeswalker - Sphinx Starts with 2 loyalty. When Trixillia, Guardian of Fate enters the battlefield, create a 0/3 white and blue legendary token named "Prophet's Words" with Vigilance, Defender and Indestructible. As long as you control Prophet's Words, Trixillia, Guardian of Fate has Hexproof. +1 - Prophet's Words loses Defender until end of turn, and gains +1/+0 for each loyalty counter on Trixillia until end of turn. -1 - Exile Trixillia, Guardian of Fate. At end of turn, return Trixillia to the battlefield under your control. -6 - Sacrifice Prophet's Words. Take an additional turn after this one.

[@heheheiamasuperstarwarrior9281]

Fun fact! You can trigger "The Game"'s ability by simply mentioning the existence of The Game! In fact, You just lost The Game :)

[@buttface1202]

FFFFFFFFFFFFFfffffffffffffUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuUuuuuuUuuuuUUUUUUUUUUUUU

[@2019inuyasha]

we are not the ones that mentioned the ability...thus You have lost the game...LOL

[@darthtorus9341]

10:28 That crab is BUSTED with Bruvac.. 18 milled cards for each land played???

[@esol927]

Re: Grievous Dealings/Spellflare, if it just said "each opponent" then it wouldn't target, which is relevant for a variety of things.

[@jamesmoniz5263]

It’ll never not be funny to me when people just port yugioh cards into magic. Terms like "negate”, cards that name other very specific cards and playing cards from your library~ it’s like… very clearly made by a yugioh play who enjoys vomiting they entire hand deck and graveyard all out at once

[@gabrote42]

6:48 Very intelligent, because if it trades, you don't get treasure. Cool 12:19 The opposite of Dovin's Veto. Balanced 33:11 Good with cheap Tibalt, Wrenn and Six, Jace Reborned and other cheap walkers 34:24 Chandra, Acolyte of Flame lore +20 Reminder that you can only use a Lyalty ability once per turn. You can't cast this if you used the walker, and vice versa 1:12:26 It's 2 affinity, but it doesn't make mana. Not bad 1:23:40 Effectively this reads "If an opponent would cast a creature spell from their hand, exile it instead with a tile counter on it. If it doesn't have suspend, it gains suspend." but disallows discounts to mana costs 1:41:49 Not quite, it makes you go -1. It's actually strictly better Ego whatever, that faerie discard card, because THAT card exiles your card and only discards one 1:51:20 Banger card. And it's a legend so it's not broken

[@araxansilverblood1549]

The amount of Blink, and Artifact Graveyard recursion absolutely busts Trash Heap.

[@2019inuyasha]

snowdragon only places stun counter doesnt tap the creatures down.

[@elisetehhooman4236]

The spark mechanic is more fair because it counts as a loyalty ability so that’s why world’s birth is fair

[@SushiElemental]

3:02:52 Well yeah I'm gonna watch the whole thing - playing MineCraft modpacks on the side. SkyFactory 4 right now - really good 🌳

[@SeraphRyan]

for Nemesis, I think it should be without vigilance and have first strike and deathtouch.

[@bencheevers6693]

Sep-tuple oct-tuple non-tuple dec-tuple undec-tuple dozen bakers dozen is the proper continuation of that sequence

[@koori049]

land walk is just a primitive degenerate form of horsemanship. fight me.

[@inquisitorhoennheim5389]

Honestly, I think Rias is a fair card. The most you will get out of it is a 3/4 demon and a card off the bat with the cost being 3 life. Heck, it dies to bolt, and any other card that deals 2 damage.

[@yugimumoto1]

Cemetery of final rest is just yugiohs necrovalley in mtg text lmao

[@crowcoregames1785]

2:08:24 broken i can cast one legand and then reorder my deck of 100 cards in any order lol 3:02:58 yeh fist of suns 5 mana win the game lol

[@RukiHyena]

scoff being run as a sideboard in non-blue decks. xd

[@algotkristoffersson15]

16:59 not if they someone has given themself hexproof.

[@2019inuyasha]

Turn land and Gaea's balance after crab that's 6 x 9 or 72 cards gone

[@Breviparopus]

Way to broken. In my Aesi commander deck I would win that turn

[@Breviparopus]

Veil from pull from the Aether let's you cast it if it's not a land Morph only let's you cast creatures

[@seanrasmussen2877]

Cemetery of the Final Rest is a Bloodborne card 🔥🔥

[@Gaming_Antics]

City of Ass is still the best custom card.

[@Nebukanezzer]

8 mana graveyard hate card... why..?

[@Delenter]

if it was Mill One Card, it would have been workable.

[@TetsuRiken]

I got an idea one generic "The reverse game" Instant Split Second If a player would play "The Game" counter that spell and then you win the game. I can't lose because I dont play yhe game

[@buttface1202]

Everyone plays the game

[@alwaysabiggafish3305]

funny seeing bacon catbug tell someone the rules are in the description and then he gets banned on reddit xD

[@Arikel1349]

Damage is Considered as "loss of life", but Loss of Life, is not considered as "Damage".

[@13Piou12]

After more than 15 years without thinking of it, i lost The game.

[@briansneary7535]

d4 red soldiers instead

[@mattmaccay2351]

High school DXD lol

[@magicsinglez]

You don’t pronounce these card names the way other players pronounce them. . .

[@ModernArtery]

Man, Yu-Gi-Oh players really love making absurd cards with 500 words and zero regard for Magic rules or card templating. At least they tip well

[@boochin]

damn, just lost the game.