As a french speaker I woukd like to point a pun : in french " trancher " means " decide " but also " cut " so here it means basically " enough talking time to cut your head " Thanks for the song
@nettaatzili19362 жыл бұрын
I have Disco Elysium to thank for this history lesson.
@terran53642 жыл бұрын
I will never not be awed by the ZA/UM devs' decision to all but hand-wave anarchism out of DE's contemporary and historical narrative ("They shot them well. So well one forgets they even existed.") but named the whole city after the _nom de guerre_ of a literal bomb-throwing anarchist.
@Todyo17982 жыл бұрын
@@terran5364 Considering this fact and that even DE's Marxism is a bit tongue-in-cheek I do wonder about the personal politics of some of the producers.
@vfanon Жыл бұрын
@@Todyo1798To me, honestly my interpretation of any “intent” was heavily colored by the kids on the ice, since they’re set up as literally *the positive force keeping the pale contained with their hardcore music*. I may be wrong but the original cultural collective seemed almost *punk*-aligned, and so I have always considered the idea they are more anarchist than marxist-leninist or what-have-you. It did always weird me out that most people seemed to miss what seemed like clear subtext to me to instead specify how “Ah, this is such a post-Soviet take on nostalgia for communism…” it is, sure, but to me it also seems like an anarchist and maybe verging on post-left critique of Scientific Communism in particular, too. Perhaps I’m entirely wrong to speculate on any of this, but it’s just the thoughts the game made me think and I’m curious to see if anyone else saw the same subtext scattered throughout the game. Maybe it’s all just the sines saying this to me, but the sines get shit right, man.
@terran5364 Жыл бұрын
@@vfanonSee, the wild thing to me is that communism in DE is almost layered. You can look at it on a superficial level as a normie and simply take it as a comical critique. Alternatively you could look deeper into it and realize that while bluntly criticizing our own history with socialism and Marxist theory, it might have some weight to it in Elysium. I don't know if you've read any of the translations of Sacred And Terrible Air, but it directly shows that, yes, faith in Communism not only can resist the pale-it can drive it back. The novel succeeds, I feel, in conveying this feeling on the nominally anarchic Kurvitz's part that belief in a socialist project is a belief in goodness without qualification. Justice, morals, and beauty have their utility, but you shouldn't forsake goodness just for them. The enthusiasm becomes something almost admirable in of itself. “Communism is mighty! Believe in communism, it’s a blast! I promise! It’s beautiful if you believe in men, but without it...!” “Without it, there is nothing.” “Nothing. There was a snowstorm, but it was white, it was morning. Communism is white, it’s glistening! Communism is the morning, it’s jubilation!”
@luk7269 Жыл бұрын
@@vfanon I wouldn't say the game is nostalgic, as much as it is hopeful, like just think about the title, "disco elysium", we know from the game that elysium is the world, and we also know that communism, just like disco, once were majour parts of DE's world but have since been almost forgotten, yet they still inspire people to try again, disco is dead, but it's what keeps your character going, and while communism might have seemed dead at the start of the game, there is clearly hope in the end that the better fututre the communards worked for in the first place will see the light of day, especially after a mercenary group hired by a monopoly tried to shoot down civilians. In the end the world is still inspired by disco.
@bobmorane2082 Жыл бұрын
In French it says “on va maintenant trancher” but it got a double meaning in English it should say “we will now cut our decisions” since he’s being guillotined
@rutufn0596 Жыл бұрын
"On va trancher" this is the words used by the so called "french" "justice state", as it is said in the song ( at least how i understand it as a FrAnch mysel And you art right, it mean
@MrSnowmanFR Жыл бұрын
@@rutufn0596 we all know the World Economic Forum is controlling us
@raven_the_crow Жыл бұрын
The singer is Renaud. He's known for being very critical of the french government. He is now 71 yo.
@jujucaesar7751 Жыл бұрын
he WAS known for that.
@raven_the_crow Жыл бұрын
@@jujucaesar7751 he's not dead
@MrSnowmanFR Жыл бұрын
one of my favourite singers, he was known to criticize a lot of political figures (Thatcher, the french government, the germans, etc) but no it's not Renaud, that's not his voice, good try though !
@Ihkirem7 ай бұрын
@@MrSnowmanFR Renaud never recorded this song but he did write it (during May 1968)
@Luckar73 ай бұрын
seeing how France turned i can understand that he became an alcoholic
@thornil2231 Жыл бұрын
Dansons la Ravacholle, vive le son, vive le son Dansons la Ravacholle, vive le son d'l'explosion
@schizeinbornheim773210 ай бұрын
Dans la grande ville de Paris Dans la grand ville de Paris !
@manoxxmax12878 ай бұрын
@@schizeinbornheim7732il y a des bourgeois bien nouris il ya des bourgeois bien nouris et
@Poukounet2 ай бұрын
Fait intéressant, Ravachol fut condamné à mort à Montbrison, mais les juges et la police estimant qu'il y aurait eu des risques de débordement lors de son exécution, la préfecture transforma l'entrée de l'école catholique se trouvant côté du tribunal comme place. Maintenant, cette école est devenu un lycée et en y entrant je pense tous les jours au camarade Ravachol mort à quelques mètres de moi.
@happymolecule88943 жыл бұрын
Based and frenchpilled
@haggard_hermit2 жыл бұрын
It’s only a matter of time ❤️
@ikarus68192 жыл бұрын
And a matter of effort!!!!!!!
@Spunktopolis2 жыл бұрын
To right my friend, we will rise again
@Paul-hs9un2 жыл бұрын
@@Spunktopolis issou
@Lidavaz_ Жыл бұрын
will never happen
@haggard_hermit Жыл бұрын
@@Lidavaz_ you’ll be forgotten.
@fauconnoir4475 Жыл бұрын
Je menfous des commentaires, souvent bien trop d'ailleurs, Pas besoin de mots seul notre drapeau noir 🏴
@the_chosen_one56423 жыл бұрын
based
@raymondefouanon99303 жыл бұрын
Merci 💟💟💟🇫🇷🇫🇷🇫🇷
@cxarhomell586710 ай бұрын
J'espère que vous réalisez que l'anarchisme ne fonctionne jamais. C'est irréaliste. Je vous exhorte à en apprendre davantage sur l’anarchisme et sur la manière dont il provoquera la chute d’un pays et de son peuple.
@ChalkyMuffin9693 жыл бұрын
Pretty epic
@jasonhughes-ii8oe3 ай бұрын
the student exchange formation for south america ireland uk. it came from within irish in colombia as a brand
@lucbourbon78822 жыл бұрын
Pauvre renaud sechan s'il se rendait compte de ce qu'il est devenu....
@kirkeaske2 жыл бұрын
Ce n'est pas Renaud...
@Neyliece Жыл бұрын
C'est pas Renaud qui chante mais c'est lui qui a écrit la chanson, il l'a jamais enregistré@@kirkeaske
@MrGwendall3 жыл бұрын
belle chanson de Renaud a l'époque où il se disait anarchiste. le texte est sympa et rend hommage a notre compagnon Ravachol. la vidéo est pas mal a un détail prés : le drapeau bleu ,blanc rouge au début de la vidéo. l'anarchisme n'a pas de patrie. seul le drapeau noir la représente, sait tu pourquoi compagnon? si tu ne le sait pas alors renseigne toi et tu verra et comprendra que l'anarchisme ne peut en aucun cas représenter une nation (extrait d'un chant anarchiste ,si tu cherche tu trouvera duquel je parle : " oui la patrie est une baliverne ,un sentiment doubler de lâcheté....") amitié fraternelle.
@smle2702 жыл бұрын
Ты ошибаешься, мой французский товарищ. Нацию анархизм представлять может, вспомни народно-освободительное движение в Корее. Но это всё не значит, что мы должны променять интернационализм на шовинизм, вовсе нет. Просто национальное самоопределение - личное дело каждого, как и право на свободу вероисповедания.
@MrGwendall2 жыл бұрын
@Angelo Ferreira je ne confond rien ,ou tu ,n'a pas lu mon com. ou tu ne l'a pas compris . je réitère mon affirmation , l'anarchisme n'a pas de patrie ,il n'a pas n ,on plus de religions ou croyance,. pourtant tu vois je suis français, juste parce que je suis né en France de parent français, si j'était né ailleurs dans le monde , n'en serais pas moins humain. je n'ai rien contre la France ,ou l'Angleterre ou je ne sais tout les pays qui peuple la terre . il sont pour moi une richesses qui pourrait renforcer l' humanité plutôt que la divisé dans des clivages patriotique ou religieux. v il n'y a Pas de honte a dire je suis français ,ou allemand ou iranien ou que sais -je . ni de dire je suis chrétiens ou juif ou musulman ou Payen ou athée. l'important est de savoir et de comprendre que le pays ou tu es née ,n'est qu'un endroit géographique posé sur une carte .et que la religion en laquelle tu peut croire n'affecte en rien ton choix ,ta liberté. tu es le seul maitre de ta vie et de tes choix. tu n'a ni dieu ( tu peut croire en un dieu ,si c'est ton choix mais la religions sert le pouvoir ni toi ,ni ta foi ) et jamais tu ne dois avoir de maitre. ne te soumet pas ni a une religions ,ni a un état . le drapeau français comme tant d'autre drapeau représente des choses qui sont en désaccord avec l'esprit libertaire des anarchistes. moi je te le dis compagnon tant qu'il y aura des patries ou des religions les hommes se feront la guerre . pourquoi? pour le pouvoir : tout pouvoir est maudit . maudit soit la guerre et tout ceux qui l'ordonne
@Raphael912502 жыл бұрын
C'est pas Renaud.
@PepitodelaVega2 жыл бұрын
@@MrGwendall l'anarchie c'est la liberté, de croire ou pas peu importe, d'être ce que tu veut ,les paroles et les actes parleront d'eux même ,la liberté prime avant tout! Sans conflit ,le savoir l'apprentissage est permanent ,mais seul la liberté d'être de l'humain compte
@kirkeaske2 жыл бұрын
"le texte est sympa et rend hommage a notre compagnon Ravachol"... Ben dis donc, la race humaine est tombée bien bas ! Se revendiquer le "compagnon" d'un terroriste, c'est quand même le comble de l'anti-humanisme ! Ca se revendique contre la peine de mort mais ça tue en masse en faisant exploser des bombes... Les consanguins dans toute leur splendeur !
@classicalsheetmusic19862 жыл бұрын
based.
@louisemichel99993 ай бұрын
Bonjour 🌷 👋 vivre l’Anarchisme. Toutes mes Amitiés Camarades 🇦🇱 🌷 🏴☠️
@jasonhughes-ii8oe3 ай бұрын
completely underestimating everyone knowing brendan forde being dead1 and 2 not hiring replacements with way more time on their hands and so on and so forth
@jasonhughes-ii8oe3 ай бұрын
i marked the berlin wall with a fairbairn sykes
@jasonhughes-ii8oe3 ай бұрын
howard and garrison are the two most consistent western formation for the wall absolutely missed
@jasonhughes-ii8oe3 ай бұрын
peter gilligan was gonna be in there already before i came so...
@jasonhughes-ii8oe4 ай бұрын
I BELIEVE EVERYONE COULD HAVE A BEATIUFUL APARTMENT AND IT COULD BE BUILT IN 3-9 YEARS IF EVERYONE STOPPED FOR AN HOUR
@jasonhughes-ii8oe4 ай бұрын
Ibrahim Ferrer - Perfume de Gardenias to the duchess
@jasonhughes-ii8oe4 ай бұрын
its the accountant receptionist
@jasonhughes-ii8oe4 ай бұрын
JAMES WHATS WRONG WITH TEH BETS AND THE PEOPLE THEY PICKED THEMSELVES FIRST
@jasonhughes-ii8oe3 ай бұрын
THATS THE OPTION THEY WANT ON MINES
@jasonhughes-ii8oe3 ай бұрын
and if you only wanted to draw bets and heat
@jasonhughes-ii8oe4 ай бұрын
THEY SOLD THE SAME PAPER I DID BEFORE 1997
@jasonhughes-ii8oe4 ай бұрын
BIKERS ALWAYS MATCH BOXERS THATS BASE CAPTAIN HITTER YEAH SO THE BIKERS YOU HAVE TO GIVE US THE BENEFIT OF THE DOUBT
@jasonhughes-ii8oe4 ай бұрын
SHE WASNT WITH OCUICR SAYING WE SHOULD PUT CHILDREN IN VANS AND GO TO DONEGAL SHE WANTED TO HELP LUCY STAND UP TO BULLIES IN THE PARTY
@ネロ帝-g3u2 жыл бұрын
Anarchism is best ❗️ i love this
@cxarhomell586710 ай бұрын
It will never work.
@supercool1312 Жыл бұрын
hes literally me
@Azafell4 ай бұрын
what have you done
@jasonhughes-ii8oe4 ай бұрын
JAMES GETS MORE BETS THAN THE DUCHESS NEITHER PAY
@renatorafael26912 жыл бұрын
Onde que eu vim parar??
@daniellocatelli_2 жыл бұрын
Viva a Anarquia!
@jean-pierrechoquet2909 Жыл бұрын
Hélas, rien n'a changé, 2.023, je suis vieux, mais toujours, "socialiste libertaire" ! Vive l'Anarchie !!!💥💥💥💣💣💣
@SyndicalDream10 күн бұрын
vive camarade! 🏴🚩🏴🚩🏴⛏️🔨
@jasonhughes-ii8oe3 ай бұрын
no we dont do 50/50 breakdancing wont get the account open
@jasonhughes-ii8oe3 ай бұрын
for 10 yeaars mary lou has senaid monaghan mind removals solid in this bet bare with the party think 2006 flyer team enthusiasm in town 8am-3am
@jasonhughes-ii8oe3 ай бұрын
we did the gerry keane islamic fake non removal embassy party and the muslim wedding at the dogs we done pokerstars through aidan can they get anyone before 20
@jasonhughes-ii8oe3 ай бұрын
we don james o callaghan haghey all the go arounds mtk boxing pitches ufc mcgregor they do not care about any of that stuff language chess and communist litrature puzzles however they enjoy
@jasonhughes-ii8oe3 ай бұрын
SO YEAH IN HAVANA THEY KNOW ABOUT THE REEL TO REEL THING CUBAN CIGAR SIGNATURE YOU CANT OFFER IT TO THE AMBASSADOR
@jasonhughes-ii8oe4 ай бұрын
EVERYONE CROSSBETS KIDS ANYWAY JAMES
@jasonhughes-ii8oe4 ай бұрын
BUT WHY DO THE PLACE KEEP CIRCLING HIM WHY DONT THEY ALL JUMP ON HIM OH THEY DIED LIKE THAT NOT COMMITING TO THE RUGBY TACKLE
@jasonhughes-ii8oe4 ай бұрын
WE LOST 5 HELICOPTERS YOU CAN SEE A MISSLE BOUNCE OFF HIS CHEST PAT IS VERY PROUD HIS SONE DOESNT GET HURT BY MISSLES IF YOU MAKE IT TO THE MISSLES YOUR A MAN IN THE IRISH PRSON SERVICE THEY LOST TANKS
@lucjean9705 Жыл бұрын
tranquillement !
@jasonhughes-ii8oe4 ай бұрын
NO THERE 6 YEARS OF DIALOGUE BETWEEN HOUSES THAT CAN SEND EACH OTHER MESSAGES AND BLUE TICKS OF ME AND PAT CRYING SAYING WE'LL INVADE RUSSIA TO GET BACK WITH PETER AND JAMES
@jasonhughes-ii8oe3 ай бұрын
im trying to do movie association about a movie siegal was in with a mohawk looking for a small head cliche pretty punk rugby school soldier a dan hardy meets jake gyllenhaal
@jasonhughes-ii8oe4 ай бұрын
YOU KNOW THIS SONG IS FROM THE POLICE ABROAD ITS ABOUT HAUGHEY BROKE HIS HAND IN THE FIGHT STRAIGHT AWAY AFTER GIVING A TEAM TALK AND IS CRYING FOR HOURS WHILE YOU SEE THE BLOOD ON HIS HAND LIKE RED RIGHT HAND AND FIANNA FAIL YOU DO NOT KNOW WHAT YOUR SAYING 99.99% OF MOUNTJOY HAD TO BEG JAMES TO WATCH IT WE COULDNT MAKE IT THROUGH WHICH BECAME A POINT OF FURTHER BULLYING MEAND OISIN ARENT ALLOWED TRY
@jasonhughes-ii8oe4 ай бұрын
RED RIGHT HAND
@chrislaparole43024 ай бұрын
👍💪🏴🏴☠️
@chekhososlanian19422 жыл бұрын
Can’t wait when there will be a song about JStark or Andrei Zeltser. RIP
@thornil2231 Жыл бұрын
What? those were right wing-terrorists. Sorry you are on the wrong page.
@chekhososlanian1942 Жыл бұрын
@@thornil2231 Do some research, Andrei Zeltser was a common Belorussian man and JStark openly rejected affiliation with any political movement or ideology, solely focusing on dissolution of gun control and the ability of people for self-empowerment. They also never committed any acts of terrorism, it’s just a blatant lie.
@pivomanslovensko Жыл бұрын
@@thornil2231How is JStark a right wing terorrist?
@thornil2231 Жыл бұрын
don't ask me, do like me, do some research... @@pivomanslovensko
@billy6044 Жыл бұрын
@@thornil2231 dude
@jasonhughes-ii8oe4 ай бұрын
JAMES COULD USE HIS POLITICAL INFLUENCE TO MAXAMISE PAT IN THE VATICAN THOUGH AND HE WONT I NEED SUPPORT FROM THE WORLD BANK
@jasonhughes-ii8oe4 ай бұрын
I HEARD DAITHI SAYING COMRADE BUT THIS IS TEAM USA IF YOU SEPERATE I BELIEVE DESSIE HERS SHOULD BE ON THE TABLE
@jasonhughes-ii8oe3 ай бұрын
im not crpossing the synia dessert into cliffs of snipers a sacrifice islam will never forgive
@jasonhughes-ii8oe3 ай бұрын
50 TO AOUT 3000
@jasonhughes-ii8oe4 ай бұрын
wagner over the rotschilds or any team in the west wagner let me go free transfer
@remka20002 жыл бұрын
🏴
@fredericopereirapereira817810 ай бұрын
@jasonhughes-ii8oe3 ай бұрын
its all the rioters anyone with cash as many teams as you want
@jasonhughes-ii8oe4 ай бұрын
I WANT A FEW STATUES I HAVE MOLLY MALONE JAMES JOYCE THE POT SWITCH Statue of Elisabeth, Empress of Austria and Queen of Hungary, in Downtown Budapest Statue of Elisabeth Empress of Austria and Queen of Hungary in downtown Budapest WWP 1
@Jay-to2cn4 ай бұрын
We got the black widow mossad trap but he got that on link from the paper I'll take the cross bets for dominos of every prisoner off the witch thanks 🇮🇪🇨🇺🇮🇱🇷🇺💯☎️🚨🇧🇦🇷🇸 too many meeting groups want the duchess pot switch in the schedule it's a champion I must insist
@jasonhughes-ii8oe3 ай бұрын
what about anywhere stocking cuban cigars cross bet in on 30 purchases your getting on need better floors of conversation moto gp season tickets british superbike season tickets and back to the golf coarse suits the age demographic for a solid team
@iillililillliliilliiililil5066 Жыл бұрын
Property is not theft, Proudhon and Bakunin were petit bourgeois utopians, read Marx.
@DerDrako Жыл бұрын
Marx, who profited from a bourgeois friend, called Friedrich Engels. If you make silly claims, stick to it.
@supercool1312 Жыл бұрын
fill your shelf
@drunkenslav233411 ай бұрын
inshallah brother meow
@eflower399 ай бұрын
Property is still theft even in Marxist theory. Even if we communists disagree with the methods of anarchist we should always remember we have the same goal.
@iillililillliliilliiililil50668 ай бұрын
@@supercool1312my shelf is already filled with the numerous works of Marx, Engels, and Lenin.