RDR2 Destroys STARFIELD - Comparison of Details! Which Is Best?

[@shumailazeeshan123]

Starfeild can't even be compared to gta4 . Starfeild being compared to rdr2 is a dream come true for tod Howard

[@WolfOfRagnar]

facts two different games and studios its like comparing apples to oranges

[@shumailazeeshan123]

​@@WolfOfRagnaropen world games one made by rockstar and other made by mighty Bethesda Starfeild was planned for 25 years it is still a good game according to 1998 standards 😂

[@WolfOfRagnar]

yes I love starfield its a great game but comparing these games is like apples to oranges @@shumailazeeshan123

[@shumailazeeshan123]

​@WolfOfRagnar you have your own likes and dislikes so i will not judge

[@WolfOfRagnar]

@@shumailazeeshan123 true but I like both games 😂 I own 2 copies of red dead one on PC one on xbox

[@joelstockwell4183]

RD2 is still the best game made, nothing close to comparing so far.. will be a legacy of its own❤

[@hossein.z8414]

❤️

[@humesspoon3176]

Yeah, that's definitely an exaggeration. No game with such a neglected online should be called the best game ever made.

[@joelstockwell4183]

@@humesspoon3176 I disagree. Online focused games are worse. Everyone loves this for the story and immersion. That’s what a good game is

[@humesspoon3176]

@@joelstockwell4183 Just because a game can blind people with other shiny bells, doesn’t mean that the features it does possess are easily ignored or ought to be. The online as advertised was utterly grandiose. Additionally, even if you’re a single-player fan, it’s ignorant to only base a game off of what you like. The strength of a game is to deliver to two audiences you target.

[@zixiongwang9659]

@@humesspoon3176 the hell does story mode have to do with online..? they even made the online mode a standalone game

[@eloisaguercoll1875]

Some people might say details like those don't matter when playing, and only matter when you purposefully pay attention to them, to them I say: When you are playing, without paying attention to details, the game immerses you in a world, this immersion needs great care, and those details are crucial to the immersion of a game. When a game lacks such details it creates a bland world that you only see as robots. Rdr2 managed to create what is probably the most immersive world in videogame history, precisely thanks to those details

[@eloisaguercoll1875]

@@sjustino completely absurd argument, Bethesda didn't create a 1000 planets, they are all procedural, amd when you get in one a map is created so it's not even a full planet like in no man's sky. Stop defending a company for doing a bad job

[@meryuchu533]

@@sjustino Bro RDR2 was also released in 2018 and was even playable on xbox one and PS4, the fact Starfield is released in 2023 and is a literal next gen game doesn't make sense for that quality, No Man's Sky has billions of planets with seamless transition all explorable by foot if you want and it's from 2016, also Starfield has like the same POIs, like if you explore a cryolab it's always gonna be the same enemies in the same layout, come on there's no excuse for that type of shit in 2023 with a brand new engine on top of that lmao

[@Любомир-ъ3ы]

@@sjustinothat’s a crap of a game

[@eloisaguercoll1875]

@@sjustino Saying they traded details and graphics for content is so incredibly stupid. Rdr2 has an insane amount of content, and so does No man's sky and many other triple A games, you're just searching for excuses, and there are zero excuses for making a gane that's simply poor on details. You're just simply a Bethesda fan boy. Mods are there to improve a game , not to complete the incomplete game you put out

[@Riley_MDS]

I honestly find it pathetic for the game dev to rely on mod creators to improve their shit game, but i applaud Todd Howard the liar in this one, he knows the Skyrim community, he'll make this game in bare minimum and let the mod creator improve it themselves. Less work for them, more work for mod creator.

[@ito2789]

Comparing Starfield to RDR2 is like comparing a PS2 game to a modern day PC game.

[@Juancho-05]

*PS3

[@Pigeonbutt]

@@Juancho-05I think he meant ps2 guy lol

[@lunchwrap7667]

Got me scared for es6

[@Domepeezy]

@@Juancho-05*ps2

[@G.A.C_Preserve]

PSP game*

[@evangelicae_rationis]

Even Far Cry 3, released in 2012, has way better interactions with fauna than Starfield. And i’ve seen people claiming it should be GOTY…

[@theo4781]

Starfield looks like an ambitious indie game compared to RDR2

[@khalilrikhtehgaran3688]

If Starfield was a indie game I could see people being more chill with it But Bethesda spent over 5 years on this game Rockstar may take a decade to release a game But they put time to make the game feel real Edit: ok maybe I got a bit mad there its just these recent years companies have done very bad jobs to listen to their fans and maybe starfield will hopefully improve the game overtime

[@thelonesomedrifter5884]

​@@khalilrikhtehgaran3688Microsoft needs things for gamepass.

[@dangelini1137]

Outdated at launch

[@kenz2756]

Starfield doesn't suck because of its lack of details. You'd be lying to say anyone cares about this sort of stuff in a Bethesda game for crying out loud. It was never their forte. It sucks because what Bethesda did good they did badly in starfield. In other Bethesda games the freedom, exploration, and the world lore was interesting and engaging. Starfield barely has any of this.

[@bengonto1250]

That statement is insulting to ambitious little indie games.

[@krajicsek13]

1:36 Love the little detail when the food falls off the fork and the guy notice it

[@biglion4631]

Goddamn! Never noticed that

[@deswithahoodiegaming]

To this Day Red dead 2 is still the best game i ever played.

[@TurnerTurnip]

I guess gameplay is not important for you. And if you think the gameplay in RDR2 is good, then clearly you haven't play many games.

[@dkm4567]

@@TurnerTurnip You just have a brain dead outlook on gaming. You can’t appreciate all the small details that make RDR2 such a cut above the rest. You probably have no patience whatsoever in games and always have to constantly be shooting, rushing, fighting, etc. This game is a mature gamers dream come true, something you’ll never understand in your sad life

[@salviahard9391]

Le gameplay et parfait faut savoir jouer. On incarne un cowboy. C'est très réaliste... juste s'adapter. C'est toi qui a pas jouer à beaucoup de jeu

[@indrashahdanaryaputrawijay8027]

@@TurnerTurnip yea prob bcs he has life and stepped outside rather than trying ''many games'' just to prove one man online

[@fernweh5945]

@@TurnerTurnip ding dong your opinion is wrong xD

[@miguiREC]

Even the space exploration is better in RDR2 💀

[@ravebourg]

Where the rocket in RDR2? Seen only a UFO but it's just an empty model without story.

[@Kenzo27272]

​@@ravebourgdid you take his comment seriously? Jesus Christ

[@christbenitez8797]

​@@ravebourgseriously dude?

[@mindspace3863]

Daft comments like this just eliminate any genuine criticism and instead reverse it making the supposed critics no more than mockers.

[@Levi4084]

@@ravebourgah fuck no

[@Wereismymilk]

I feel like modern games need to recognize the importance that RDR2 had on the open world community, and it should be the model for upcoming open world games, much like how cod was for Fps

[@QuizInMyEye]

Exactly, which is why im happy CD Projekt Red have done a lot of work overhauling Cyberpunk. Its very good now and sets a better standard than a lot of other devs

[@murkus3301]

Both big companies Starfield was in development over 7 years... RDR2 was in development for 8 years... One plays like an indie One plays like a triple A game

[@majesticscope6782]

Nah bro its actually 8 years. Bethesda started it on 2015

[@Mag1ckan]

I don't even know what refers to what.. *ahem* baldur's *cough* gate...

[@Ahlem_DMC]

Subnautia: what the fuck...😒

[@What-kc4ki]

Game developer of starfield literally said he wanted to make this game for 25 years but they didn't have technology and they started 15 year ago and this garbage came out so what the hell are you talking about?

[@lucasludwig2347]

Rdr2 started full production in 2013, so its development time is closer to 5 years. Between 2010 and 2013 the game was likely in conceptual phase.

[@SameBasicRiff]

holy fuck I knew about the food and NPC's in rdr2 but I still never saw that "food fall from the fork, then NPC picks it *back* up" animation. Game is literally WILD. GTA 6 NAO PLZZ!!!!

[@SignalFlowers]

I saw that and was completely blown away. How's such detail even possible ?

[@Pigeonbutt]

@@SignalFlowersthere’s something supernatural about rdr2. It’s almost like sentient AI level. Games spooky.

[@SignalFlowers]

@@Pigeonbutt and the fact that Rockstar has literally patented a new AI tech for NPCs in GTA 6 sounds even more "Scary" when we look at the normal NPCs in RDR2.

[@alexanderandersson8538]

Well after 10 years of mods being made it might go from a 2010 game to a 2015 game. 😂

[@zaaxi7424]

This makes me sad, but also happy as I might start playing RDR2 instead of Starfield

[@syazwan1765]

Both are different genre games tho.. but I definitely prefer story based game like rdr. It's definitely worth it.

[@Hhhh22222-w]

​@@syazwan1765its not about the genre but about the polish of the game

[@TurnerTurnip]

If gameplay is important to you, don't waste your time with RD2.

[@dkm4567]

@@TurnerTurnip lol you’ll have to elaborate on that cause right now that comment just sounds hilarious

[@TurnerTurnip]

@@dkm4567 Not much to elaborate. The gameplay was extremely boring. The only thing good about the game was the graphics and the voice acting. Both were top notch.

[@dishonorableknight9340]

Starfield is a good game but it doesn't feel like a generational leap like RDR2 was. It's just the same kind of game Bethesda always makes.

[@DungeonCrawlingMaster69]

riiiiiiiiiiiiight

[@Hhhh22222-w]

If anyone else released starfield other than bethesda, the gaming community would he shitting on it so hard lol... fallout 76 was worse than cyberpunk even skyrim when it first released was more buggy than cyberpunk

[@SonGoku-ep4wj]

Its not a good game u normies

[@s-nova9254]

​@@SonGoku-ep4wjthey so dumb bro

[@ZMondoHype]

And with the exact same AI as skyrim 😂 like they couldn’t even be bothered to tweak it. Such a letdown

[@TeaGamingPanda]

RDR2 has really set the bar for me. Everytime I wanna compare something it’s always RDR2 or TLOU2 to something. Though I am enjoying Starfield. RDR2 and TLOU2 really changed up the game, have yet to see another graphically like it or as immersive game. StarField immerses me, but in a role playing sense instead of a storytelling sense like RDR and TLOU, of course.

[@John-996]

Check out Kingdom come

[@anastaciasheep]

RDR2 is the best game of all times....nothing can compare with that.

[@Ivan_KV]

So, game are consuming more VRAM, meaning you have to buy more expensive GPUs, but at the same time getting worse in quality. That's great! Cheers to capitalism!

[@thejonkler69]

True

[@asscheeks3212]

TLOU2 isnt even open world, thats what makes RDR2 more impressive.

[@ZirhliArmadillo]

This shows us how well Rockstar Games optimize their games.

[@Axemcaxington]

What did you expect from Bethesda?

[@fransiskusrobisanjaya]

Fallout New Vegas and Skyrim

[@Axemcaxington]

@@fransiskusrobisanjaya new Vegas ain’t that good

[@hauntdcyan]

nuh uh clearly probably only played fallout 4 and 76 goober @@Axemcaxington

[@Axemcaxington]

@@hauntdcyan I’ve played new Vegas, 3, 4 and 76

[@hauntdcyan]

which one is the best huh?@@Axemcaxington

[@willythegman5509]

8:02 some are which is just another amazing detail the city folks like in Saint Denis and blackwater for the most part will try and flee because they are upper class and don’t know how to fight but in the country like Rhodes and Valentine it’s towns of farmhands and hard workers so of course they would

[@Literallyryangosling777]

Strongest city man vs weakest country boy

[@skylerjones3302]

Star field looks like a game that is about 40% finished

[@BlackFang7]

agreed

[@vio3667]

Even they added NPC drops food from fork gushh.

[@bluekassara]

i mean come on it’s not fair you are comparing a game to a real life

[@Forest762]

rdr2 is far from real life. Maybe rdr3 will come close to real life.

[@Роберт628]

2:27 прям жалко стало этого персонажа. Я видел на его лице и в его действиях страх за жизнь. У меня прям к ниму появилась эмпатия. Вот, что значит правдоподобный мир и персонажы.

[@glowinggames1561]

It's funny how even Skyrim had blood show up on enemies and swords yet starfield, a 2023 game with a larger budget I believe doesn't.

[@20VGT]

Starfield vs Cyberpunk might be worthy competition... because anything Rockstar have release going back 15 years or more it isn't comparable.

[@binumahanta9983]

cyberpunk takes the crown then

[@giannid.7794]

Really Cyberpunk since this is patch and update, they very very much more beautiful than Starfield.

[@Pigeonbutt]

Cyberpunk after 2.0 is downright amazing. The changes to NPC life and the ray tracing 4k. Very good game now. Definitely worth a replay.

[@derederekat9051]

Bruh, rn Cyberpunk 77 is vibrant and brilliant, starefield is desolated and bland, simple as that.

[@Gamer4lyfe00]

This is crazy but I'm playing rdr2 again right now after deleting stalefield 😅 and of course rdr2 is wayyyy superior 👌🏽

[@jacobcornwell4981]

I did the same thing 😂

[@Evobed562]

I thought I was the only one 😅 I was let down by starfield really overhyped

[@paburopasillas7783]

I'm still asking why people are saying that Starfield is the best game ever created 💀💀💀

[@euricoaw1535]

Simple, they have no taste in gaming

[@axstro5142]

Game's Fun,not like all that that Bethesda said it was,but a decent game,but yeah,red dead (even rdr1) is galaxies better in most aspects

[@Hhhh22222-w]

Who said that?

[@Eliassthepro]

As an Xbox fanboy no one said that. We’re just happy that we finally got an 8/10 game bruh 😭

[@derederekat9051]

Bethesda Cultist worshiping the crap that come out of Tod Arse.

[@lucasbrandt5501]

Rdr2 is the most well made game of all time

[@reven40]

starfield, a game so famous that i have never heard of it after the announcment

[@Guts364]

Starfield looks like gta sa with mods lmfao

[@mikeyswift2010]

The blood and gore in Starfield is literally the most disappointing thing in the entire game for me, no exageration. I don't even feel like i'm actually killing someone its like im shooting them with a bb gun

[@jamesnewham7125]

It's very unfair to compare any game to Rockstars titles, in terms of attention to detail rockstar are light-years ahead of any other developer.

[@pooya4434]

RDR2 looks way better but somehow Starfield requires more powerful pc. How's that possible? I don't know.

[@G.A.C_Preserve]

Exactly

[@mrcat4508]

Comparing star field to red dead redemption 2 isn't fair no matter how good star field is it wasn’t competing in the details department

[@ILoveLSD]

it’s crazy how they made oblivion better than starfield

[@DG-001-q4p]

Starfield 2077 😂

[@giannid.7794]

Really Cyberpunk since this is patch and update, they very very much more beautiful than Starfield.

[@changsiah2]

Hater

[@Pigeonbutt]

@@giannid.7794yeah cyberpunk is actually dope now. One of the best games made

[@Forest762]

@@giannid.7794 Yeah, after years of patching.

[@alan-oq4vk]

The water in rdr is insane

[@Ramiobomb]

RDR2 actually makes you regret your crimes.

[@AntonioVillaran-b3f]

Starfiled reminds me alot of cyber punk when it came out

[@kawaiiqueee]

Cyberpunk2077 had gorgeous art direction even when the game suffered from too many bugs and felt 20% finished- Starfield doesn't look pretty imo but the detailed fruit looks yummy

[@derederekat9051]

Cyberpunk was a total mess in release day but the story was still pretty good and hooking, starefield on the other side... 😅

[@markizfun]

so stupid how starfield forgot how bullets shoot through glass and npcs dont react to getting attacked

[@monkemonkerson5620]

When a game needs tons of mods and patches in order to be "better" than the base version (Cyber$hit, Stalefield, etc.) then you've failed as a developer. Bethesda truley is the most overhyped studio in gaming and Todd "it just works" Howard isn't the genius people make him out to be.

[@x6King6x]

Imagine rockstar made starfield.

[@Paintkillerify]

Starfield is literally Skyrim with mods, but in space. Heck, even modded skyrim is better lol

[@m41a1z]

even the graphics RDR2 better than this game..

[@MoodyMarkV]

Rockstar Games is Beast when it comes to the physics aspects so take note developers

[@Rextryker]

RDR2 se ha vuelto un standard para comparar las entregas de juegos de mundo abierto. Me encanta!

[@talarnelbenito3547]

Bro they got that same yee-yee ass fallout 4 character death animation

[@J14Irish]

RDR2 is the benchmark!

[@gigategu9776]

RDR2 makes Starfield look like a mobile game.

[@RockyyeXe]

Red dead 2 is just on another levl man

[@emmanuelifeagwa6312]

Imagine what GTA 6 would be like given that rdr2 came out back in 2018

[@OSITO-xm7gl]

Obviously wins red dead redemption 2, a game of old generation very advanced in its whole world

[@ExpertExterminators]

Although I will say that in the grenades exploding in water comparison. That the RDR2 dynamite shouldn't explode in water since water would extinguish the flame. But it is silly that Starfield's grenades don't cause a ripple effect considering ITS NOT A LIT FUSE. Another game with a western setting is Hunt:Showdown which has lit fuse dynamite variations that don't explode in water completely. (Unless it's a waxed dynamite.) I would also like to add that it's insane how starfield doesn't have glass breaking on bullet impact. As I've recently played Splinter Cell (2002) and Splinter Cell Pandora Tomorrow (2004). Those games are atleast two decades old and those games have glass which breaks on bullet impact. Not even on the first bullet either. The first bullet gives it a shatter texture. Depending on the size of the glass it can take more than two bullets too!

[@HonkHonkler]

Rockstar games are like half RPGs I’ve come to realize.

[@heroiam1812]

??

[@Two_T]

Watching this video I wonder, is Starfild really a 2023 game?

[@tungnguyendinh1960]

I think you should compare this game with cyberbug 2020 not ver 2023, it seems more balanced

[@STARLIXOfracassou]

Não! Teve desenvolvedor de Starfield comparando esse lixo com RDR 2.

[@tausifalfaruk2120]

Wow Cyberpunk 2077 in update version

[@МухаммедАли-б7д]

RDR2>>>>>>>>>Shitfield

[@Itz_evan1822]

Imagine if Rockstar made a space game with current technology

[@LeonardoCarlosLizarazoDuarte]

I don't know if they could make a game like that....but hey! They published ONI for PS2 and PC, god i wish to play that game in this consoles

[@abdullahazadhimel-3768]

cyberpunk 2077: finally a worthy opponent

[@isaacA38]

Corpses also decay in red dead 2 with multiple steps of decay from slightly rotten, to extremly rotten to blank bones

[@calvinyip364]

What'sup with the graphic on star field.

[@luckyizzac]

4:47 the train bell and the music syncing up xD

[@Саныч-с5ы]

Единственная игра которая может превзойти РДР2 это ГТА6 и та ещё не вышла, но самое пугающее что эта игра от той же студии, так что РДР2 ещё года 3 не догонят

[@Ashtasticle94]

Starfields snow looks like sand textures with a whiteish colour put over it

[@derederekat9051]

Probably it's.

[@AWARHERO]

0:30 in case of the fire damage, was your character in Starfield wearing a space suit? (you can hide the spacesuit while in a settlement). Doesn't change the fact how dumb it looked anyway.

[@outlawsforlife999]

Trust me nothing can compare to rdr 2

[@iamkelz6047]

Rdr 2 is untouchable

[@csjackass867]

Unfair comparison

[@derederekat9051]

Yeah, a game released years ago should not be compared with a more recent game, it's not fair, better BG3 vs Starefield... but... starefield still bites the dust...

[@Theyluvmoney223]

Never compare a rockstar masterpiece to a Bethesda game

[@Bigchubby_97]

Starfield is just cyberpunk all over again

[@Pigeonbutt]

Cyberpunk came back after the 2.0 patch. At least for series x it’s low key amazing now. Definitely worth a second play through

[@derederekat9051]

Starefield doesn't even have a solid frame to relay on, they will need to remade the whole game from scratch to modify history, game balance, character progression, universe background, character background, history progression, events, cities, fast travel, simply everything!

[@ryanz486]

Even though I don't like RDR2, don't even mention Starfield with it. That Gollum game is more on par with starfield.

[@The.king95]

I hope the next new GTA game will be very realistic like Red Dead 2

[@16menoftain]

Even though ive actually enjoyed my time in starfield it is nothing compared to the absolute masterpiece that is rdr2!!!

[@Bluesluvr1]

When it got to the 'sandwich' part I cracked up.

[@a.guy9900sp]

fartfield vs rdr2 yea great Comparison😂

[@sabihasultana3570]

If rockstar made starfield it would be a better game

[@Pigeonbutt]

It would be insane.

[@woweric]

never seen star-field game play or even played it, but damn that engine looks ancient. my hopes for es6 are honestly vague at this point.

[@martiniavarone5128]

Red dead it's the best game there is, and it didn't even win the goty 😢

[@essenciadedeus3352]

Muito melhor fazer um mundo pequeno mais cheio de impressões e muito bem acabado, doque um universo vazio com mecânicas infantis e ultrapassadas.😢 Viva ao red dead pra sempre!

[@caiquehenrique4367]

Vc tá com cara de só ter jogado starfield pelo KZbin amigo kkkkkk

[@essenciadedeus3352]

@@caiquehenrique4367 não amigo, é fato a olho nu!

[@caiquehenrique4367]

@@essenciadedeus3352 vc conhece as mecânicas a olho nu ? Como disse , opinião de quem não jogou nem deve ser levada a sério , vc pode gostar ou não gostar do jogo , dês de que vc tenha pelo menos jogado . Vc me parece que não tem opinião própria , me parece não vc não tem . Porque vc não poder ter uma opinião de algo que vc não conhece .

[@STARLIXOfracassou]

​@@caiquehenrique4367EU JOGUEI E POSSO PROVAR! Starfield é um lixo! Fiz 20 horas desse jogo e a única conclusão que eu tiro é que Starfield é um jogo ultrapassado. Enredo, gameplay, exploração, interação, animação, gráfico, ambientação... tudo nesse jogo é antiquado, ultrapassado. Mas o que esperar de um jogo que está, praticamente, de graça? OBS: Joguei no PC, porque os jogos dos estúdios Xbox saem Day One no PC KKKK. Posso provar que joguei. Se quiser que eu prove, manda o zap que eu te passo a GT, foto, vídeo, mando a p0rr4 toda.

[@generaltenzenyamauchi5291]

​@@caiquehenrique4367 Mano... não precisa nem gastar dinheiro e nem perder tempo jogando o jogo pra perceber não meu kkkkk tu não viu o vídeo? os npc correndo pra trás igual o Michel Jackson... água sem efeito, falta de detalhes básicos que até GTA San Andreas que LANÇOU 19 ANOS ATRÁS têm véi kkkkk se tu quiser continuar babando ovo de Starfield pode ir... quem vai tar perdendo dinheiro é tu.

[@LetoChrist]

Star Field is basically fallout in the future lol

[@patrickjmoynihan]

I’m enjoying Starfield. But details and immersion = not near same level as rdr2.

[@berrymansir]

It now occurs to me that starfield is a piece of shit.

[@0b100]

I was sad I wasn't going to be able to play Starfield because I had a PS5. After seeing the game post launch all I can is I'm ready for Spiderman on Friday.

[@jina682]

Normal guy: ooooh nice observation Innocent guy: WhY Do U KilL inNocEnt pEoPle ?

[@deaeth1411]

Also known as: 2018 game obliterates 2023 game. It makes me worry to think how next TES will be... I don't expect anything more than this.

[@joaofcbh]

Who said starfield its better than spider man 2?💀💀💀

[@bdleo300]

Let's see Atomic Heart vs Starfield

[@sloppyjoe5263]

Are you playing on xbox series s?

[@elimanetourederuoth8418]

it"s not a comparaison but a humiliation

[@avstudiosgroupent18]

6:59 Sounds like Batman Arkham City sound effect punch

[@rilmi7746]

Rdr2 crazy game😭

[@Im_Foxyz]

fair comparision, a rpg game vs a action-adventure game

[@derederekat9051]

Where are the role playing aspects on starefield? Pretty linear game with little to no impact with your actions.

[@hexagonshorts2186]

RDR2 is the ONLY game that I still did not go for a second playthrough because the game is soooooo freaking good. I am a remorseless guy who slaughters NPC for fun but there was this one random event in RDR2 where a robber killed the husband and left the wife in the road. Her crying broke me so bad that I stopped my mission, restarted a checkpoint but the event did not repeat.

[@Wendigo922]

Serious talent gap between studios

[@josuecalix9057]

Starfield is Cyberpunk 2.0 basically

[@derederekat9051]

Let's be just, I think a fair comparison it should be done between games of the same caliber, it will be a better figth if the versus it's: Saint Row 5 vs Starefield 😅😅😅

[@stonertrone7392]

It's no games really that can be compared to rdr2 when it comes to being realistic

[@MixenAran]

It's not fair to compare RDR2 to any game. Come on, if you compare the amount of sick details that RDR2 has, you could make a video that lasts for hours. RDR2 is a spectacular game and we all agree, even I who am playing and enjoying Starfield (because I love Bethesda games) would not compare them because it is unfair... Unless you are part of the team of ignorant people who preferred give the GOTY of the year 2018 award to a linear game, with silly characters and a story that practically takes you by the hand instead of an open world game, full of amazing details and full of charismatic characters (I call it "the theft of the century")

[@John-996]

Could not Agree more for Me RDR2 was hands down GOTY really pushed the bar for both open Worlds and story games. I would Give Kingdom come second place also an amazing game.

[@TheManWho_BOUGHT_TheWorld96]

Some people wake up and choose to compare a masterpiece to a cheap garbage and its funny both games have same size of 120gb and one of them can completely run smooth on a hdd and give 10 times better performance than the other and also have 100 times better graphics and details