As a Japanese person who has known her since her first album, I can't even imagine someone comparing her to Ado. She is the mother of recent Japanese pop music, and Ado is one of her progeny. I remember being shocked when her first album came out, as a Japanese female musician of the same age, 25 years ago. It was fascinating to see your reaction from a new perspective. Thanks.
@crominokgr11 ай бұрын
Shiina Ringo has continued to be Japan's queen of music since the late '90s. If you were to survey Japanese singers and musicians, it's likely that everyone has, at least once, expressed admiration for her or her band, Tokyo Incidents.
@irodama11 ай бұрын
you should not judge her singing just by watching only one live video. ringo tends to change the music arrangements and the way she sings on each show ... also her face changes. many people are still confused which is her real face.
What's amazing about her is her ability to self-produce, not only creating the sounds and lyrics of the songs, but also the composition of the band members and the stage direction, all based on her own ideas. For this reason, she is respected not only by the general public but also by people in the entertainment and music worlds. Her unique worldview, reflected in her singing voice, lyrics, and appearance, still fascinates many Japanese people. I feel that if she had been willing to expand overseas, she would have become a little more well-known overseas.
@chicken-samurai878711 ай бұрын
I think she is difficult to hear because she is sick She can't ride on air plane
@しこきよ11 ай бұрын
Thank you for listening to and comparing "Crime and Punishment", "Ado" and "Ringo Shiina". Apparently, he found out that the "Ado version" was not the original, and that's how he learned of the existence of "Ringo Shiina", but he is very happy that he found "Ringo Shiina". Both "Ringo Shiina" and "Ado" are the best artists, but I worship them as "Ringo Shiina = Queen" and "Ado = Princess." Thank you for your reaction.
@nelzyr6 ай бұрын
Thats actually nice lol, Sheena Ringo as the Queen and Ado as the princess
@guitarandy240610 ай бұрын
Whilst this is one of the definitive filmed versions of this song, it's also a song that's rarely performed by Shiina exactly the same way twice. This performance is from 15yrs after she first recorded it for her 2nd album and is a noticeably jazzier arrangement than the original studio version, which also had an slightly more aggressive & desperate sounding vocal take. In the first portion of her solo career there was a wild almost dangerous energy to both her gigs and her image. As you kinda noticed, often Shiina likes to inhabit roles/characters when singing and includes that as part of her portraying the lyrics of songs, the majority of her actions on stage are very deliberate and often self-choreographed. Crime & Punishment whilst great barely scratches the surface of her overall musical range TBH, she's a musical chameleon in the best sense of the word, also a competent multi-instrumentalist and since 2003 has been the frontwoman of a killer art-rock band full of S-Tier musicians called Tokyo Jihen/Tokyo Incidents. This show happened in the 2nd phase of her solo career and was in the middle of Tokyo Jihen going on a literal eight year gigging hiatus (Feb 29th 2012-Feb 29th 2020).
Thank you SO MUCH for reacting to Shiina Ringo. I've been in love with her music since I was in college 20 years ago (that hurts to say how long it's been hahaha oh well). But all that time, even though I have friends who like Japanese music, they tend to just focus on anime and video game music, and Shiina Ringo has famously never done music for anime (until ONLY RECENTLY, with Hell's Paradise; my jaw dropped when I found out!), so I've been a very lonely Shiina Ringo fan for a long, long time. I'm so glad Ado covered her song Crime and Punishment, because I know that means more people around the world will find Shiina Ringo!! 🍎🎸
@Roninmann7 ай бұрын
I’m definitely overdue to check out more of her songs. I remember getting a little lost looking into her catalogue. Any suggestions?
@minako1347 ай бұрын
@@Roninmann Her two breakout hit albums from the late 90s/early 00s were Muzai Moratorium and Shousai Strip, nearly every track is a classic that most music nerds in Japan can sing from memory. She also made a band called Tokyo Incidents, I loved their first album Kyoiku ("Education"). Even as a fan of over 20 years I too get overwhelmed by how much music she's made that I'm STILL getting caught up on....
@suguruji999411 ай бұрын
オリジナルのMVも観てほしいな
@hedobannord118410 ай бұрын
Sheena Ringo is an amazing artist, and extremly versatile in her styles. It's sad she isn't known more in the west. And yes, I also think Sheena Ringo sounds more natural here than Ado (but her version is cool too).
@fusaes472211 ай бұрын
やったー!椎名林檎のリアクションありがとうございます✨丁寧な解説がまた嬉しかったです😆
@Roninmann11 ай бұрын
Thank you!
@kei0721011 ай бұрын
Ado has boldly taken up the challenge and opened up another new world. Sheena Ringo has great depth to complete the world of this song, and this is how I feel about it.I give the biggest applause to these two talented singers 👏👏 I highly recommend "W●RK" by Millennium Parade & Sheena Ringo. And please get to another rock band "King Gnu" led by Millennium Parade's leader, Daiki Tsuneda, as soon as possible 🎵🎵
@myos180610 ай бұрын
椎名林檎の 長く短い祭りライブバージョン最高ですよ!
@maomao_meow11 ай бұрын
Thanks for the great reaction. I love RIngo's version since years ago. This live performance has been already a legendary when Ado covered it. I didn't expect anyone can exceed Ringo's performance but Ado blew me. It's really difficult to choose one song to a deserted island...today, my feeling is Ringo, but tomorrow I might choose Ado.
@kault018 ай бұрын
Ado has an amazing and unique voice and has a great future ahead of her. Shiina Ringo's song catalogue is something else entirely. Like, I adore Sir Ian McKellen, but this is Miss Shakespeare you're talking about. The fact that on top of writing and arranging and producing tons of quality music like the best in the world (male or female, Japanese or foreign), she can also perform at this level, to me is kind of a miracle
Wow! Ringo-san definitely sounds like a well versed and experienced musician. Ado did a great job taking on a huge task.
@AyueKodamaes10 ай бұрын
Sheena's vocals are better. I don't like how Ado kinda screams the notes.
@松井秀喜-h6j11 ай бұрын
Sheena Ringo is the singer that ADO most respects. Hatsune Miku is a god to ADO.
@mevius1096911 ай бұрын
Your opinion is great♪ However, for ADO to cover such a difficult song, she has to overcome the high hurdles of making technical efforts and finishing it in her own way while paying respect to the original! The fact that ADO was allowed to cover this song is amazing in itself ❤️😊
@Roninmann11 ай бұрын
Ado is a very bold artist and I think she did an amazing job. I agree with everything you said.
@mmaru-sssad1stic7 ай бұрын
i love the guttural expression in ado's verison, but truly nothing will really top sheena ringo cuz GODDAMN THAT WOMAN IS AMAZING
@キタ-y3r11 ай бұрын
コンサート用にアレンジされています。オリジナルはもっとロックです。
@nogarddragonkin11 ай бұрын
both versions are great.. sheenas version especially this particular live performance to me hold so much more emotion is why i prefer it.. but ados version is still spectacular and who knows maybe in another 10-15 years Ado will be mature enough to add that emotion as well as her talent into a song like this just as much
@frankmustermann727211 ай бұрын
Through ado I became aware of Shiina Ringo. I think Shiina Ringo is more of a diva, in the best sense.
@maidthehormone11 ай бұрын
Sheena worked on ADO's Crime & Punishment cover and was very happy about it. Sheena has so many many good songs since the 90s and is a musical role model for many Japanese women, like Miku Kobato from Band Maid. I love both versions.
@realdocloco11 ай бұрын
She wrote a lot for other singers too - including Ado btw.
@maidthehormone11 ай бұрын
@@realdocloco yep, i know😁
@PaulEngineer11 ай бұрын
Love both performers. Ado can make you burn with this... Sheena will make you melt first. Sheena (or Shiina) Ringo celebrated her 25th Anniversary Tour this year.
@fukushimaben.sansantakasan2 ай бұрын
改札の安蛍光灯って歌詞がとても好きだ。一気に景色が目に浮かんでくる。
@vmguilleng9 ай бұрын
Sí, para quienes seguimos hace años la carrera de Shiina Ringo obviamente preferiremos la versión original y lo más interesante es cómo ella ha logrado apropiarse de la canción de maneras diferentes en los años que la ha cantado. La versión de ADO es chévere y muy interesante, no es en mi opinión una mala versión pero tomando en cuenta que esta canción salió en el 2000 cuando todavía había mucha experimentación en el Jpop y en un contexto de explosión de la cultura japonesa hacia occidente, tiene mucho más peso la versión original con esa Shiina Ringo rompiendo esquemas y siendo admirada hasta por artistas internacionales que la estiman como una influencia. ADO ha revivido esa admiración por Shiina Ringo y con algo más de atrevimiento podría darle al Jpop un renacimiento que en su momento dió Shiina en una época donde el Kpop y las fórmulas de industria dominan sin proponer algo nuevo. De pronto desde las mismas Atarashii Gakko y ADO estemos viendo eso.
@BlackListEDz11 ай бұрын
Really happy to see you reacting to Sheena's version as well! Maybe if you have the time you can check out her other songs such as 熱愛発覚中 from the same Live! Its a complete different style and her other performances are great as well!
Easily the best DIVA from Japan, breath taking live performance and songs that are soul capturing ❤
@壬申10 ай бұрын
Shiina Ringo I listened to this Japanese singer ten years ago, but at that time I didn’t really like listening to music, and I didn’t have the convenient channels that I have now.
@user-fc3zb1xz1e11 ай бұрын
椎名林檎はAdoに全部自分の曲を歌わせたいって言ってたからね
@kamikome149411 ай бұрын
椎名林檎をリアクションしてくれてありがとう😊彼女が居なかったら、adoも生まれてません👍
@こたま-e1h9 ай бұрын
椎名林檎懐かしい・・・ここで見ると思わなかった I really love 椎名林檎's stage presence, and I see a lot of influence on Ado. When I listened to Ado for the first time, I thought she was just one of the followers of 椎名林檎 but I think Ado has pursued her originality since her debut and kept improving her styles. I still like the original version better when it comes to 罪と罰, I might be biased here because 椎名林檎 was a godess to me but yeah Ado can do pretty much anything, and I found her so fascinating so I like both singers equally. Ado is still young but she is already a promising singer and has a lot of fans overseas, and I believe she will continue to grow, I can't wait to see where goes.
@elenaekanathapetrova228211 ай бұрын
I personally prefer Ado's version) I mean both are really cool but I kind of more empathize to Ado. anyway Ado really admire her so for me it's just a bigger picture of her background.
@Roninmann11 ай бұрын
She did an amazing job with the song! There's no wrong answer if you prefer one over the other.
@minako1347 ай бұрын
Oh, one more thing - please react to MORE Shiina Ringo, at least one of her studio-recorded songs, so you can get up close and personal with her vocals, her vocals are EVERYTHING!! Sadly a lot of her music videos get copyright striked, so there's only 1 you can watch on KZbin, the rest are album art for the visual only: Honnou ("Instinct") - MV kzbin.info/www/bejne/e3Tbc3uegshqpas Gips - english & spanish subtitles kzbin.info/www/bejne/gJing6hpg8djr9E
@keisukeh106610 ай бұрын
ADOよりRINGOの方が100倍良い。
@KM-vv5pg11 ай бұрын
highly recommend Ringo’s ‘NIPPON’ MV 😊
@ぽこたん-x9t5 ай бұрын
ADO has stated that the musician she admires is Ringo Shiina. In other side, Shiina has stated that if there had been ADO at the time, she would have offered the songs she wrote to ADO instead of singing them herself.
@J.Inkwell_art11 ай бұрын
There is so much energy, like full blast! It is great, but for sure I need to take a second listen to fully take in this performance. I like the jazzy tone ~ (•́ ω •̀๑)
@icollect1003Ай бұрын
Adoが惚れ込むのも納得する圧倒的なカリスマ性
@FauxieDaoJia11 ай бұрын
You have to go outside of charting music (someone like Emily Bear, perhaps) to find a more versatile female composer than Shiina Ringo. I think the best rendition of Tsumi to Batsu is probably the one from 'Electric Mole (though 'Gekokujyo Xstasy' has it with organ rather than piano, which I prefer). I recommend listening to literally anything she's penned for herself or other artists this last 25 years. The following is a pretty good example of her composition chops: kzbin.info/www/bejne/oXvGnJJvpdqqqbM
@ねるさん-c1k11 ай бұрын
There is also a version sung by AiNA THE END. If I post the link, it will be blocked, so search for "AiNA THE END 罪と罰" and you will find the video from 3 years ago. I also recommend "red birthmark", the 2nd season ending theme of Gundam Witches from Mercury, which she sings.
@realdocloco11 ай бұрын
Aina is another singer strongly influenced by Sheena Ringo.
@Cristian-hn2ey7 ай бұрын
No conozco a ado, lo poco que escuché suena como dijiste, muy insegura y forzada, shiina es simplemente genial Hay un disco que hicieron tributo a ella donde rescato kiss me por kaela kimura, lejos de imitar a shiina lo adaptó a su estilo consiguiendo una versión increíble, creo que a ado le faltó eso, identidad
@myos180610 ай бұрын
椎名林檎の 長く短い祭りライブバージョン最高ですよ!
@naejinАй бұрын
Original feels more traditional Jpop mixed with a bit of Jazz feel? Ano's version maybe a younger generations interpretation? Although I have to admit Shiina Ringo looks rather young here too (I think she may have been 38 at the time), but she is 45 today.
@kaitotatsuya5 ай бұрын
No offence but Ado is still a princess. Sheena is the Queen of jazz for 20+ years.
Ado herself is a singer who was greatly influenced by Ringo Shiina.
@user-yz6xv7tv2i5 ай бұрын
曲を発表した当時と最近とではそれぞれの良さがあるなと感じる
@psychedelicyeti60534 ай бұрын
It's so funny to come to Shiina's videos and everyone talking about someone named Ado. And I'm like, "who's Ado?!" 😂 I've been a fan of her's (and Tokyo Jihen) since the 2000's when i confused her with Anna Tsuchiya 😂😂 (because i think Shiina was the musical director for Sakuran and I thought the singer in the soundtrack was Anna). It's always the first version of a song people tend to like more. It took a while for me to like Metric's "black sheep" after originally hearing Brie Larson sing it in Scott Pilgrim, but I now prefer the original vs the soundtrack while i know people who still prefer Brie's version over the original. Same with people who argue if Dolly Parton's original "I will always love you" is better or lesser than Whitney's cover of it. Imo, both are great 💕
@Olkam-w5u4 ай бұрын
Actually, Ado did this cover as an homage because she adores Shiina Ringo. They know each other, Shiina Ringo wrote the song "Missing" for a horror film, which Ado sang. In general, you can hear a lot of Shiina Ringo's influence in Ado.
@1tolightradius8 ай бұрын
to even compare these two is fucking wild. Ado doesn't have a single album that come close to Sheena's THIRD best album (muzai moratorium), let alone her 2nd and 3rd which are actual classics of the genre. I don't care about a strong booming voice if you're just doing eye-catching American Idol covers of songs that other people wrote and outdid you on. This song isn't meant to be yelled from the mountaintops it's supposed to be mumbled from a train station to your shitty tokyo apartment, but these youtube cover artists all just extract the power from the songs and remove any subtlety to them for those clippable moments of them using their vocal talent to impress.
@FauxieDaoJia4 ай бұрын
Saying 'youtube cover artists' about an artist with over 3 billion total views is kinda wild, even if for the most part I kinda agree with your overall sentiment (nobody is Ringo tbf).
You took the version of the already mature Shiina’s performance, but here is her video, where she performs for the first time, at 21 years old. It's different here. kzbin.info/www/bejne/moS7p4mjrK-rnpYsi=3g0duJ7svuJSsr3t
@bedatse191511 ай бұрын
The top comment from ADO video speak it all. Queen Ringo version is throwing you perfume bottle, still very much a lady. Princess Ado version is chasing you with cleavers, in both hands.
@Roninmann11 ай бұрын
That's a scary mental image of Ado haha
@うどん大好き-o6j4 ай бұрын
queen
@elevown11 ай бұрын
I profer Ado's - but its just that- a personal preference- rather than saying its 'better'. You also have to give Ringo a lot of props for writing it in the first place!
@wakajenni24 күн бұрын
Ringo! Defennely!
@アザミ-t4q9 ай бұрын
Games of the XXXI Olympiad Flag Handover Ceremony of music produce by Ringo Shina
@ukowo11 ай бұрын
you should listen to Shiina Ringo - A double Suicide, i found out she didn't made the song, she covered it.
@christianmunar809211 ай бұрын
Sheena is the original songwriter of a double suicide, so it's basically her song. She has made several songs for other artists, in fact, she has a complete album where she sings some of them, it is called Reimport Vol 2, A Double Suicide belongs to that album
@Wizhito9 ай бұрын
Entiendo porque Ado la admira tanto, veo mucha inspiración tomada de Shina Ringo, y yo prefiero la versión de Ado, no solamente porque la escuché primero sino porque el sentimiento que le impregna a cada palabra hace resonar la letra de una manera mas emocional, mas profunda
@chiruya_go-go11 ай бұрын
ライブじゃなくて音源聴いて欲しいなー😅
@spikebrillianttrackiloveth91435 ай бұрын
The name is Ado not Aydo. just saying
@Roninmann5 ай бұрын
Don’t think I’ve ever pronounced it Aydo, but thanks.
The approach in this video is so disappointing. The era in which the song is being sung is different, and I find your intentions even unpleasant. It is really a pity.
@Roninmann11 ай бұрын
I respectfully gave my opinion between 2 talented artists. Not sure what you find unpleasant or what you think my intention is.
@flitzerps952211 ай бұрын
Ados version is by FAR superior
@1tolightradius8 ай бұрын
nah it's dogshit
@NB_MOCHI_JPN11 ай бұрын
浪人マン(・∀・)イイネ!! Thank you for Watching "Sheena Ringo" also "Nippon" MV is SO COOL! U LIKE IT INDEED! kzbin.info/www/bejne/pl61fXZvj8ydnrs