William Lane Craig vs Alex Rosenberg | "Is Faith In God Reasonable?" | Purdue University

[@kq6up]

Is it just me, or is Dr. Rosenberg trying to plug his book in the second rejoinder, and really what he said in that section made no sense to me.

[@phile.1381]

I'm not a physicist and even I can answer Dr. Rosenberg's problem of the difference of two U-238 atoms, with one emitting an alpha particle and the other not doing the same at the same time. Why this perplexes him I don't know, but the following questions answer the supposed dilemma. Do these two atoms occupy the exact same space at the exact same time? Are the forces acting on them both doing so at the exact same angle or energy for both at the same time? And is Dr. Rosenberg certain that these two atoms are exactly the same down to their most minute sub-atomic particles? I hope this basic misunderstanding of physics does not keep Dr. Rosenberg from the experience of eternal life in Christ. He would have an eternity in hell instead to regret letting this mistake doom him.

[@terrycolins6694]

Rosenberg has no clue if he does shame of him…and may he enjoy his glorious end

[@ethanrichard4950]

Glorious end?

[@phile.1381]

Dr. Rosenberg highlights his arrogant ignorance by stating that God has broken His own moral laws. An atheist once challenged me on this as well. He quoted, "Thou shalt not kill", and then thought he had successfully tried God and found Him guilty. I pointed out that the better translation is, "Thou shalt not murder", and the answer is that God has never murdered anyone, for when He kills, it is always done in justice or mercy, since the Giver of Life is able to resurrect, and to Him, people do not cease to exist when they die, but change location (heaven or hell). Such infantile arguments that atheists flee to shows the emptiness of their argument, as well as their desperation for God to not exist. Otherwise, they'd be held accountable for their own sins, which they are loath to have happen.