Recalibrating the Right Wing Narrative | Abhinav Prakash Singh |

[@nitovatorsnitj]

Whenever I am confused, I always watch your video sir, and with this I am able to realize what is wrong with today's Left and Right

[@punyashloka4946]

Yes both left and right is pathetic in India.

[@TamilArjun4090]

Good talk on right wing. By calling ourselves right wing We are giving equal position to foreign ideologies in our traditional land.

[@sonalidave8067]

Why are we borrowing western terms like right wing and conservatism. It doesn’t apply to us. First he needs to research these terms origins

[@sonalidave8067]

What nonsense, India was always a nation, that is why Adi Shankaracharji went from north to south and east to west to establish his muths

[@poonamabbi7448]

Just an observation: WE are not calling ourselves "right" or "left"wing... it is those who are trying to DENY OUR EXISTENCE & IDENTITY & are upset about us TRYING TO DEFEND OURSELVES who are calling US the right wing & themselves the LEFT wing. These morons don't even know the ORIGIN OF & the meaning of the terms

[@pilotcyborg.gaming]

We are correct wing 🙏 not left or the other one

[@sonalidave8067]

autonomous psyche , gravity is a law of Nature. You can’t compare that with western social science/ political terms like right wing left wing. You need to expand your knowledge to concepts not born of western scholars. Also even in western political spectrum opposite of liberal is conservative not authoritarian. LOL. There is also communism and anarchy.

[@vik8860]

Mr.Abhinav Prakash Singh should have some role in the administration , preferably as a interface to the political or cultural intelligentsia abroad. He should be giving talks in international seminars and conferences etc. This level of potential should not be wasted.

[@siddharthsiddharth7106]

souvick choudhury Well said , he should be involved in party politics and discussions . Country needs talented future leaders . Why has this not been done yet ?

[@siddharthsiddharth7106]

There should also be another discussion regarding how India should deal with Islam

[@anandrmnn]

It's not done yet because a section of the upper castes in India still want to maintain the status quo - for them their superior social status is far more important than the future of the unity or even the existence of the country.

[@omvadlapatla7174]

andrmn this anti caste rhetoric has to stop. Caste is a cross-pollination from Europe. Varna ashram is not understood by thus Macaulay putra. The Verna prevents unnecessary competition and a race to the bottom. The Verna grants a locus standi to an individual to begin his journey to realize his human potential. There is social capital, generational capital and invaluable in building a rastra and it's global presence. Savarkar did not study the veda and it's universal values on dharma. Nither Savarkar, nor any modern so-called intellectual is not fit to coment nor make any policy decisions with out embodying the discipline required for practicing the living a vedic life. Bharatha desha is a veda bhoomi before it is a nation. We have imposed artificial unsustainable values embodied in the western thought such as nationalism, capitalism, market economic development, democratic institution all of which have failed globally to help a human achieve self actualization with out causing harm. He is not qualified to understanding such concepts and can only benefit pseudo intellectual crowds. The people who are qualified are the one who have both traditional vedic education and modern social understanding. With out both a person is not qualified for this position of commenting on narratives.

[@anandrmnn]

Om Vadlapatla : You are the text book example of what I said in my previous comment. Thanks for the self initiated demo.

[@nitinbhasin8898]

Great presentation... But I disagree that past philosophies are unimportant. The left has blindly inherited political theories coming from the west and we all know how badly the left wing adaption has worked. The right wing can't and shouldn't do the same because the Hindu philosophy is fundamentally different from Judio-Christian approach on which the theories of Western right are founded. Lot of work needs to be done to understand the past and use it to develop new theories.

[@liliesandtulips2000]

Exactly. Indian thought and culture is PRECIOUS! Westerners today are learning sanskrit and here we are destroying ourselves!!!

[@Masterofmultiverse]

Saying 'right wing' or 'left wing' itself is a legacy copied from the west! So .... And the word 'hindu' is originally a Mughal given gaali! Arya samaj founder pandit dayanand saraswati also admits this in his book 'satyarth prakash' What theory will you develop over that?

[@VineetMenon1]

We are rooted in dharmic wing, not right or wrong or left.

[@adityanjsg99]

Vineet Menon Yes but rooted doesn't help if it doesn't grow high enough.

[@NG-hy9ke]

Aditya can u make difference between a vary old banyan tree and a vary tall coconut tree

[@satyachandrakandula4881]

@autonomous psyche Right wing is still evloving as an environment which takes time. However no point in supporting in left as they have moved far from the actual ideology of left. Now that we are having a state with several problems, its better to have good and bad in Right rather than all in left.

[@satyachandrakandula4881]

@autonomous psyche Exactly, its still in evolving phase. YoU have people and thinkers so they will get their goals set . With the tough competition posed by Left it is not that easy though.

[@satyachandrakandula4881]

@autonomous psyche not of much knowledge, would be happy to know from you. If you are aware of?

[@bisk6634]

He is very much influenced by Savarkar and Ambedkar. When ever I encounter a right winger he always tries to shy away from 'cast problem '( that feeling was uneasiness) . But he did not,that without doubt made a spark(also recommended reading opponent's views, books). I really enjoyed it.I without doubt want him as my teacher. He really is, can be called public intellectual for modern conservative cause.I really like to have him 4-5 minutes commentry like Dhruv rathi and also want him to provide intellectual and theories regarding Conservative sources. Sir, It was really fresh and green to me.Thank you🙏

[@legionSpat]

I would disagree with the speaker on some points. 1. A random remark by the speaker was ": today people earn B-Tech , work in MNC, and then at 40 decide to contribute to social science. One should be involved since the beginning". I would point out that studying engineering / mathematics will only add to a person's ability to study social science in a more scientific, data driven way, rather than trusting one's emotions and intuitions. Moreover, the western countries, primarily USA, are encouraging inter-disciplinary work by bringing in "outsiders" with fresh perspectives, to prevent an area of study from becoming stagnant. 2. There was a very casual comment by the speaker "Why are we fixated on old theories, instead of focusing on modern ones." As a scientist, my own experience says that one should not throw away an old idea/theory just on account of being quaint. Chanakya's "arthshastra" principles were a masterpiece, and only recently has got the attention of the researchers. When library of Alexandria was burned by CHristians, much valuable knowledge was lost, such as planets revolving in elliptic orbits around the sun. And it took 1400 more years to re-discover this phenomenon. Aristotle in 3rd century BC associated the high/low tides in oceans to the moon, Galileo in 16th century said Aristotle was a fool in saying that. Galileo concluded high tides are caused due to motion of earth. So everything "ancient" cannot be thrown aside just on account of being old. Most Bowel Diseases cannot be treated with "modern" medicines, but with simple food rules in Ayurveda and yoga exercises. 3. Reading many textbooks is not going to get you anywhere. To be cutting edge in a field what you need to read peer -reviewed journal articles, and personally get involved in data extraction, analysis etc. Getting actively involved is important instead of passively reading someone else's book. 4. Don't be too harsh on Rajiv Malhotra Ji. It seems the speaker has read only one of his books "Breaking India". The speaker should comment on what material presented in Breaking India are futile extrapolations or hyperboles. He should also be aware of Rajiv Ji's other books.

[@prasadpopuri9019]

You are correct. Nationalist can choose any area to contribute to the country. Engineering is fine. Everybody need not go for social studies. Social sciences are not sciences. Mostly opinions. History written by our left and British is a matter of opinion. One should pursue sciences.

[@Masterofmultiverse]

chanakya is just an imaginary character from the play Mudrarakshasa written by Bana Bhatta! That is all there is to him! He has zero historical basis. arthashastra advocates organising society along caste lines, much like every other brahmin(hindu) text!

[@pallavirawat2756]

Most of our rural people are not even aware of the state, the nation and don't even know what India is. It's a sad reality. He is right.

[@imranatheist4280]

I was earlier an anti Brahmin guy. But now I realise I must speak against medieval caste system and not Brahmins alone. In fact the major works against casteism were done by Brahmins themselves

[@sandeep34mishra]

I am a Brahmin by birth...but against caste system

[@nilkanthmahadev2935]

@@sandeep34mishra Don't confuse with the Mughal & British made caste system with the VARNA system of Hinduism... It's is very hard to change the narrative or agenda set by the ABRAHAMIC groups (such as Christianity & Islam )....

[@kamathvishal5]

@@sandeep34mishra Our culture upto my knowledge had Varna ,false society and invasions from Mongols (muguls ) and British screwed up the Varna system

[@jbiswas5762]

The oblique references to Rajiv Malhotra are unfortunate. He works and writes from the citadel of anti-India thought - USA, and he has succeeded in countering the entire clique of Christian Marxist nexus painting India as a collection of wrongs. This kind of low level rivalry is what the right wing really needs to recalibrate.

[@BhavasagarDommaraju]

@Vedprakash Meena Don't confuse caste with Varna. Also before British the Islam invasion also contributed to social divisions.

[@TheShree909]

@Vedprakash Meena Rajiv never denied caste system before British. Rajiv never told caste system was firm d by British.

[@TheShree909]

The speaker did not talk about Rajiv Malhotra at all. He just said that reading just right wing book is not enough.

[@daliyaghosh6235]

The speech was an eye opener for Indian right wingers.

[@purnimasathoo4294]

Excellent Talk ...Abhinav Prakash is very articulate

[@designyourlifenow]

We need a complete recalibration of political dialog. And while we are looking at redefining the western narrative of the Indian past, we should also look at what worked, well for India in the past. And one thing, according to me, that worked really well in the past was the system of constructive debate. Nobody was a fundamentalist. If a philosophical teacher found the arguments of a competing school correct, they would whole-heartedly move to the other side. We need to redefine the political dialog and set the world an example by doing the same today in India. Right, Left, Libertinism are western concepts that we are trying to retrofit into India. Why should we? Nobody has a monopoly on the truth and there are equally correct arguments on all sides. If we just prioritise the pursuit of truth as our object, everything else will fall into place. My 2 paise...

[@bistrajendra1]

Well articulated thought --

[@checkfacts9701]

Untrue. Confused speaker. Left bred ✅ winger..

[@crsuthar]

@@checkfacts9701 I dont think so

[@punyashloka4946]

@@checkfacts9701 so he is a left winger now what a joke?

[@0di8ayh57]

Bharath first that's only right.

[@ConnectwithBarkhasharma]

You are awesome sir finally right wing have the right person who knows how to express Hindu Right wing thoughts to modern world.

[@utkarshpandey6879]

I see a lot of people disagreeing to Abhinav Prakash but you cannot deny the fact that this person has left us with a lot of points to ponder upon.

[@janardansingh5926]

A very factual & pragmatic presentation, such narrative should be for information of the masses 👌💐💐💐

[@ivarhakuse8572]

Need to be on a think tank, have a discourse with Rajiv Malhotra too.

[@avinashmishra7735]

Yes we are concerned about Caste System which was never meant to be by birth according to our scriptures and we are working hard to uproot this curse by introducing Vedic education in our vidyamandirs (although it's not on that scale which is needed) and now in IITs too after the recent announcement made by Prakash Javedkar (HRD minister) but why do you self claimed liberals feel chilly in your ass when you see Hindu Unity. huh? By the way, I never saw you commenting on Caste System that is prevalent in Christianity and Islam, why? Don't you know there are exclusively mentioned Ajlaf Arzal & Arzal concept in Islam although they pretend to be united in the name of ummah? Don't you know after the death of Muhammad, the racial discrimination started among Muslims in the name of Quresh (the owner) and Ansars (the servants). Don't you know there are separate churches in America for blacks and now in states like Kerala and Tamil Nadu too for Dalits? You must be a hypocrite to say that you don't know there're full time Christian lobbies in India who are working for Christians of 'lower strata' to get Reservation as Dalits which clearly means that even converting into Christianity don't help them getting out of this social divide. By the way, you Marxists and Muslims who talk so much about Caste System never want to talk about Ashraf ( Arabic word that means 'noble' which includes all undoubted descendants of foreigners and convert from high caste Hindus )and Ajlaf ( contemptuous Arabic term that means 'wreteches' or 'mean people' which include all other Mahomedans comprising the occupational groups and converts of lower ranks; they are also called Kamina or Itar, 'base' or Rasil, a corruption of Rizal, 'wothless'). In some places a third class , called Arzal or 'lowest of all', is added. With them no other Mahomedan would associate, and they are forbidden to enter the mosque, to use the public burial ground. Have anyone ever heard you self claimed secular and liberal intelletuals complain against discrimination against lower strata Muslims? Even if somebody would dare to speak against this, you leftists (whom I call professional mouners or 'Rudali' in desi bhasa) jump in to defend by saying it is their personal law safeguarded by the Constitution itself. I would say that unfortunately even our Constitution Makers didn't address all this discrimination in other communities while making the Constitution and therefore it has always a chance of ammendment. Look this is an ideological revolution against Marxist interpretation of India's History and creating a counter grand narrative of sampurna Bharta based on logic and scientific evidences. We need to challenge their deliberate misinterpretation of History which says Maharana Pratap was a fanatic patriot ; Chhatrapati Shivaji looted Surat ; Sri Aurobindo Ghosh, Lokmanya Bal Gangadhar Tilak and Lala Lajpat Rai were extremist ; Chandrashekhar Aazad, Bhagat Singh, Suryasen, Bhagajatin, etc were all terrorists in a sense ; Guru Tej Bahadur Singh was creating dunes and dunes of weath ; Raja Surajamal Jatt was cerating law and order problem that the roads of Agra and Delhi became unsafe for business and trade ; 1857 was a sepoy mutiny, the whole Indian philosophical system is superstitious, oppressive and discriminatory to not only women and dalits but also against Nature, there was nothing like Saraswati river, Aryans who came with all the Knowledge system from Europe and Middle East drove the native Indians (Dravidians) towards South ; and many more. I mean how disgusting that we never challenge them to verify all these non-sense. The word Arya is related to Quality of life & not related to race. Woman in India call her husband as aryaputra. Arya is an adjective. Calling somone Aryaputra is praising the parents who have given great 'samskaras' to the child. And coming to proofs, Aryan Dravidian Theory has been demolished by the Science of Gentics journals and the world has also started to recognize the same. Don't worry. Well somebody may be proud Tamilian but I'am proud Indian who respects everything part of Indian tradition. But do you self-claimed Dravidian people have any idea that almost 40% of Tamil words are from Sanskrit..for eg, both the words "Karuna" and "Nidhi" in the name Karuna Nidhi, the former CM of Tamil Nadu are from Sanskrit. Well, Tamil may be one of the oldest language in India but it simultaneously went on taking many words from Sanskrit too during the course of finding new words against newer experiences of that time.Even the concept of "SiddhaMedicine" had come from Aayurveda after it was extensively verified(even "Sidhha" is a Sanskrit word which means that which is proved). So Siddha Medicine has also been a part of our culture as a whole and not of exclusively yours. The Ramayna is one of many proofs of the historical fact that we are all one. Look bro, the word "Dravid" (phoneticaly Travid in it's originality) was coined by Adi Shankara (Keralite) first to introduce himself as the son of 3 waterbodies (Bay of Bengal, Indian Ocean and Sindhu Sagar which is now known as Arabian Sea); but by travelling the length and breadth of Bharat( even the word "Bharat" was not new to him) and debating with all major traditional scholars of that time and establishing 4 "Mathas" in all the 4 corners of India, he showed his vision of sampurna Bharat as one cultural and spiritual integrity. And Finally don't you try to build an impression that Buddhism is not originated from Dharmic Vedic philosophy and not a part of Sanatan Tradition. Nirvana, Vipasana, Rebirth, Karma, Sankya, Mimasa, etc are part and parcel of Hindus and Buddhists as well. But let me nail you once and for all on your cunning statement that Buddhism didn't flourish in India due to Hinduism which is not a true statement. Buddhism flourished in India for a thousand of years after Buddha until the arrival of Islam. In the 7th 8th and 9th century there were world renowned universities like Nalanada and Takshila having lot of Buddhism related literary work going on syncretically with Sanatan Tradition. The places like Nepal and Mayanmar which never got conquered, we see a lot of syncretic unified Hindu Buddhist thing that flourishes even today. There is a lot written about Hinduism-Buddhism syncretism and synthesis that flourishes for a long long period of time and we can go into why the arrival of Islam harmed Buddhists more than it harmed Hindus because Buddhism has to do being monastic and living in centralized places thus became easy targets, whereas Hindus were the householders. So the effect on the two was not the same. So you can't wish away the fact that until 7th 8th 9th century, Buddhism was fine in India and it's important to notice for a thousand of years.

[@subhra777]

That is a knowledgeable and apt reply to all forms of rhetoric....

[@mayank9638]

Abhinav Prakash is the one public speaker I'd pay to listen to. What a gem of an intellectual. He'll wipe the floor with literally anyone the leftists throw up.

[@anilrana7293]

hats off for giving such a thoughtful , actually realistic and practicable right wing approach .

[@sreerag3354]

Brilliant. This guy is a gem

[@naveenn7591]

Brilliant points. See reality as it is ....... Very intelligent discussion...

[@VenkateshwaranG]

Well articulated Abhinav

[@deepanshurajput1895]

Abolish reservation from this country.make every one equal

[@M3b3Ark]

Deepanshu Rajput Reservation must have economic clause, so even a poor UC person must get it.

[@jaiminvaidya8536]

That's what he is saying. Urbanization will lead to a condition where caste identity becomes redundant. And ask any person who has lived whole life in cities, he will say that he doesn't care whether his colleagues or neighbours are from which caste and some of them might not know the castes of their colleagues and neighbors.

[@asmitalandge3967]

Deepanshu Rajput why you are not raising question for abolishing the cast system of our country ? Reservation Policy is based on the cast system of our country. You don't know that reservation policy is only for Hindu Religionists including OBCs, SC , ST, VJNT, Maratha & 10%upper cast Hindu people. Are you against the prosperity of these people who are still Hindu Religion ?

[@satyachandrakandula4881]

@@asmitalandge3967 Its been 50 years and you still think it is used for upliftment? A state which accepts that a person should have a caste is making the discrimination constitutional. Some people speak reservation as their fundamental right. When are we going to get the upliftment? The only upliment proof is that all the upper castes who are struggling already should be poorer?

[@AshvinPatelUSA]

I probably agree with some of the points and may not with others. Homogeneity, progress and peace can be also achieved by embracing Dharmic philosophy which is rooted in our culture since ancient time. Yes, we have to remove the exploitation of caste system, but that does not mean we have to give up our identity. Real challenge is to develop and live in a harmony without losing our identity. We do not want to go in the path of South Korea and China. Yes, South Korea is a prosperous country now but it happened at the cost of their identity. China is cracking down on Buddhism and Tibetan culture in order to develop. Yes, we need to integrate and become mobile which will make us more homogenous, but we also know how to preserve our culture and identity. We can integrate but we do not assimilate and that is just fine with me. Speaker here is too rooted with western mindset. He need to explore more good in our culture not just bad and come up with original ideas of preserving our culture, identity while progressing, not just adopting western ideas in order to progress. Remember we were dominant culture, technologically superior, and economical power house with the same culture and ideology. Also we were and are one of the most peaceful culture in the world with stable society while preserving our diversity. I don't think we have that bad of a problem as liberals tend to portray and exploit. I believe we just really need to reawaken our social consciousness that we had before invasions. Gujarat overcomes problems because we have the underlying culture that has built in resistance which we can fall back to. And that is the reason we also provide distinct leaders in challenging times. When everyone gives up we rise to the challenge and fix the problem. One Gujarati gave us free Bharat, second gave us united Bharat, and third will give us Modern Bharat while preserving our culture. I am optimistic about the future of India.

[@anandshankar8466]

Ashvinkumar Patel what is our culture? Right now what we have is a distorted and polluted form. If we have to trace back, how far back do we go? Not realistic. The only way is evolving, deleting what's bad, including what's good and staying relevant.

[@AshvinPatelUSA]

That is a strange question? We have the most time tested reliable culture in the world. It is very easy to dismiss it by looking at it superficially. Yes, it has gone through many minor adjustments though out the history; which it supposed to do in order to advance and prosper. Our culture is our base which provides us solid footing. Lately it has become fashion to look at west and accept whatever they throw at us for their own benefits. They systematically taught us to look down at our own culture in order to accomplish their own agenda of looting and imposing their values on us. We were the most prosperous culture and vibrant economy for many millennia. So what if they invaded and looted for few hundreds of years. We still can bounce back and prosper while maintaining our culture and values (Here I am not talking about blindly following orthodox rituals). We better do it for the shake of humanity, otherwise we are headed for an extinction. If our conscious does not develop in parallel with the technological advancement, there is a high probability that we may wipe ourselves out at the cost of many more species on the planet earth. Only our deeply rooted culture has that ability and we need to lead the whole world in that regard for the benefit of all the species and our planet. I do not disagree with you, but what you are suggesting is an easy way out and I am not sure about it's long term viability. Tell you the truth, at first thought, I would probably think the same, but I hope you will dig deeper in our literatures. They are revealing! My favorite are Upanishads.

[@AadityaUpadhyaya]

Abhinav sir aache teacher hai , right wing ke narrative ko sahi dhar de rahe hain.

[@sandeep34mishra]

Caste system has to be destroyed at any cost...otherwise hinduism would collapse

[@surindermarkanda2924]

it is better to talk dharma/ adharma instead riight or left right/left imposed on us to abandon our culture

[@Masterofmultiverse]

The word 'dharma' itself is a cheap mimicry of the original Pali word "Dhamma" Same with the word 'sanatan' It was The Buddha who said "eso dhamm sanantano" to describe the religion based on the eternal law of cause and effect! culture?? really?? A Christian Lord William Bentinck put an end to your 'culture' of widow burning 'sati' in 1829 itself!

[@DipayanPyne94]

Panthera, the Pali word Dhamma is NOT Original. The Original word is Dharma. Don't you know that Pali is a Dialect of Sanskrit ? And yeah, if you are gonna characterise Indian culture with Sati, then you must understand that the same can be done with any culture. Take witch burning in Europe. Even Untouchability existed in Europe. Take the Cagots. Furthermore, the British Imperialists were themselves so uncultured that they engaged in all kinds of evils. Racism, Thievery, Divide and Rule, Famines, Oppression, Removal of Native Cultures etc etc. So, you have gotta stop bowing down in front of them like slaves bow down in front of their masters ...

[@omvadlapatla7174]

This anti caste rhetoric has to stop. Caste is a cross-pollination from Europe. Varna ashram is not understood by this so called modern right winger. The Varna prevents unnecessary competition and a race to the bottom. The Varna grants a locus standi to an individual to begin his journey to realize his human potential. There is social capital, generational capital and invaluable in building a rastra and it's global presence. All these are guaranteed with out competition in a varna ashram based society. Savarkar did not study the veda and it's universal values on dharma. Nither Savarkar, nor any modern so-called intellectual is not fit to coment nor make any policy decisions with out embodying the discipline required for practicing the living a vedic life. Bharatha desha is a veda bhoomi before it is a nation. We have imposed artificial unsustainable values embodied in the western thought such as nationalism, capitalism, market economic development, democratic institution all of which have failed globally to help a human achieve self actualization with out causing harm. He is not qualified to understanding such concepts and can only benefit pseudo intellectual crowds. The people who are qualified are the one who have both traditional vedic education and modern social understanding. With out both a person is not qualified for this position of commenting on narratives.

[@thehindumuse]

Our jatis were trade guilds and have served their purpose. Varna was a simple division of labour. The old jatis have crystallised and are holding the country back. Savarkar saw that, I hope you will too.

[@omvadlapatla7174]

Our Jatis have some association with our varna. Varna is determined by vritti, guna, and jati. We cannot eliminate jati from our social capital. What we need to eliminate is open competition between Jatis. By creating this pseudo competition we are loosing traditional and generatinal skills to modern rat race. The country in not being held back by its traditions, nor Jatis, nor Varna's. It is being help back by pseudo intellectuals designing policy and imposing western egalitarianism.

[@neel1761]

om vadlapatta ....ur comment looks like an advice to shift to vedic costumes and practices. Dont u think eating beef and drinking Soma has already created enough ruckus, starting these practices again will be very confusing for OBC's like me. We are already tuned for ridiculing beef eaters to stop that and start imitating them will be difficult for us.

[@omvadlapatla7174]

Sarcastic saint Your self identification as OBC belongs to 1901 census conducted by Herbert Hope Risley during the Raj. Would you lose all prior intellectual capital, social capital, and lineage for the administrative title you are carrying introduced for the purposes of British administration during a colonial rule? Or would you rather dig deep anthropologicaly to learn what your forefathers brought to this world. If you would like to know what your forefathers brought to this world adopt your Jati, adopt your varna, adopt your asthana vritti. Or your choice is to fade into some administrative policy manual created by some foreign force only to exploit our cultural, social, economic and spiritual cohesiveness. By losing your Jati you are not doing any favors for nation building nor to your successive generations. The Veda is not a relic from the past. It is very much applicable for the present and for the future. Veda is universal and not frozen in time. The issue we have now is not having qualified interpreters of the veda and dharma shastras. We have half backed knowledge which is more dangerous that pain ignorance. We have always been held together by dharma, not by some policy design which fails every time since the vedic times. The Vedas clearly say the social underpinnings are in its varna ashram sampradaya. First learn what the veda and the successive texts teach, they are not that different than what people already practice. The conflict actually is because of imposition of foreign value systems that were ill conceived for their own nation states. Look at Europe and the united states with the social issues it all is attributable to egalitarianism. So our true sampradaya is our dharma to protect today. "Dharmo rakshati rakshate" meaning protect dharma and it will protect you. You mess with dharma it messes with you simple equation. This is being experienced in USA and Europe where I have lived for many years as well as in in India.

[@neel1761]

Following !5th BC text in 21st century and convincing people to do so sounds like a good after retirement plan. What people need is a proper functioning and implementation of the current established democratic, republic and secular order. Here the problems is not of Vedas or Hadis or Bibilical teachings and philosophy.The problem is with people. You create the best administrative system and handed it over to fools to run it and it will definitely be an disaster. Look at the Scandinavian countries. They achieved Political, Social, Economical and moral heights using the same western ideologies which ur criticizing. After all it all boils down to what the great spirit Gandhi said Live and let Live.

[@PLIP5c]

This Speaker is very knowledgable, more people need to hear what he’s saying. His explanation of what a nation is makes so much sense and in India’s current situation there’s a need for intellectual people like this.

[@abhirajput7199]

a real gem of rightwing...

[@luckyjaipal]

Very well articulated

[@GeeksMonk]

You have excellent point.

[@OnkarShrma]

Wonderful lecture sir 👍👏 And I really agree with you on right should start reading their opponent work.

[@vc2616]

This talk is a contradiction, he says he is on the right yet seems to veer to the left. Also he says that the Vedic system was to simple and we should not dwell on it! I do NT agree!!!

[@Masterofmultiverse]

vedic system was/is bulsh- In mandal 10, it talks about different kinds(varnas) of men born from different parts of his body! First of all, this is sowing the seeds of discrimination in this country! And secondly, who impregnated brahma in such a way, is also a mystery

[@DipayanPyne94]

@@finickygods3896 Rest of the world could not write ? Tf are you talking about ? Writing itself began very late in India. In Greece, writing had already been in existence for much longer. Chinese had writing even before that. You seem to have very little idea about world history. In fact, writing was so unpopular in India that we Indians are still struggling today to date our Ancient texts properly because the Vedic people didn't write anything down. They just passed it down orally ...

[@rajeshkandukuri1042]

@@DipayanPyne94 Watch Raj Vedam sir's lecture on Indian civilization:untold story in this very same channel,then u will get a clear picture..

[@laatu100]

It is very educative

[@Phd101]

It is very insightful. The argument is well placed, and facts are rock solid.

[@singhskeptic5742]

How come I missed this great video..

[@shamakuma1967]

Bal Gangadhar Tilak also said it. Didn't he?

[@sj9403]

This is refreshing.

[@vivektiwari1353]

Wow ....I m very happy after listening you

[@siddharthsiddharth7106]

It's great to hear Abhinav sir . Really good points on present situation .

[@sainigagan5]

A very good and balanced talk

[@PS-eu6qk]

good intelligent lecture.

[@andal143]

only Hindu can think and talk like this.

[@suryakantnikam3364]

Very realistic practical thaughts

[@akashdwivedi2218]

You should be the home minister of india . I will support you to be the home minister of india . 😊

[@hawkeyes5703]

We are not 'right wing', just read what actual rw means, you'll understand... We are just against Indian left... Indic or dharmic wing would be better

[@a.srivastava944]

Chankya, vedic suggestions are versatile We should need to know that Many points of Your talk are very good but somewhere devoid of भारत की आत्मा Nice to tell about reading Thanks

[@tushartarat5983]

Bhai Aatma Ko Zinda rakhne ke liye vartamaan mein Vijay hona pardhta hai.

[@Anish61097]

Great thinker

[@TheAnkanBiswas]

Read - one piece of golden advise 👏

[@grkmurthy1157]

I dissent with the speaker on many points in this speech. Its half baked information.

[@priyabratadash4542]

Loved it

[@raghusharma798]

In my view the fundamental values of conservatism are: (1) small government; (2) low taxation; (3) strong military; (4) private sector priority for economic activity; (5) traditional family the key element of society; (6) essential belief in the existence of an enduring moral order (dharma, and Sanatana Dharma includes respect for other philosophical/religious beliefs including atheists, Islam and Christianity); (7) adherence to customs, convention (tradition) and continuity (including the firm conviction that our civilization is the vedic civilization that has been here from antiquity); (8) value for life (from the unborn to the old age/destitute); (9) dignity of labour; (10) charity as a way to share with the have not.

[@shantherimallaya3973]

Well put!

[@TheGuruNetOn]

Being Dharmic not equal to Right/left wing binary. It's about time we used our own terminology rather than copying blindly from others. We have our own concepts. Use them.

[@ron_ron9024]

I couldn't agree more. This is exactly the right outlook. I love that this channel looks at India and right wing from political, legal and realistic lens. It is important to be vocal based on facts and figures. Caste system has always kept us divided whether through oppression or now the increasing lobby for unfair reservations. Currently dalit groups feel more comfortable aligning themselves with Islamic groups or leftists, giving them a higher moral ground.

[@saijunk8697]

A very eye opening talk sir . I hope many among our right wingers and also the people on the other side listen to this and introspect so that India can have a better future . All those Hindus who don’t believe in caste discrimination should unite . The Original Varna system was different as it was a classification of human beings based on their individual inner qualities and their congenital affinity either towards knowledge ,power , love or perfection in works . It was not to create a hierarchy of superior and inferior human beings . It is possible that the members of the same family with similar biological traits and appearances can have different inner qualities and affinities and hence different varnas . We should remember that in the pre-constitutional, British era when there wasn’t any caste based reservation , there were some individuals from the backward castes and Dalits who attained higher education on their own merits and became doctors (allopathic medical practitioners)and professors in the universities . Unfortunately many fools in our society equate caste with Varna and support caste discrimination against Dalits and also try to justify the fascist fixing of profession based on the individual’s birth . We should isolate such venomous people. For such people who still believe in caste discrimination and who want to oppress others based on caste, I suggest that they should not call themselves Hindus but should rather identify themselves with their respective castes and should not support a party which believes in Hindu unity , they should rather go and support any pseudo secular casteist party which believes in divisive caste politics and in dynasty rule .

[@jasha9sandhu]

" without order there is no stability "

[@47atim]

WHEN EVER ANY HUMAN BEING ASKS FOR HIS OR HER RIGHTS AND LIBERTY , THEY SHOULD FIRST AND FOREMOST BE ASKED WHAT AND WHAT ARE YOUR RESPONSIBILITIES. TO YOUR MOTHER , RELATION , NEAR AND DEAR ONES ,YOUR SOCIETY,M YOUR TEACHERS AND THIS BREATH WE ARE GETTING FREE.

[@sangeetamandrai4889]

I saw that jail in kala pani on island; it's very depressing 😞. India should understand (right or left ) first comes India. Our ancestors lost life, they suffered lots of oppression for their future generations and it's a shame what future generations is doing; questioning their sacrifices and labelling them cowards. If they were cowards then you must not be remained hindu in present world.

[@shivaggopal8032]

Abhinav has some good observations- but his analysis is based on modern Western ideas and their path of evolution into nation-states. The late Pandit Deendayalji has thoroughly analysed all these and clearly stated the cause of Dharma based thoughts and ideas, distinctly Hindu, and now slowly moving in that direction under Modi. Opposition to urbanisation may be a Gandhian only. Western societies where economic prosperity has been achieved, you also see just small homogeneous groups of people - And the larger the population you find significant economic disparities and heirarchies India is an ocean of 30 languages, regions and cultural diversity of 1250 million. Please see/listen to lectures of Mr. Gurumurthy. Modernisation has to be based on Indian thought and genius to succeed and flourish in India. Also for thought there are only 4 varnas stated in Bhagavad Gita - how did it get distorted into nearly 3000?

[@vilasosc]

I agree about most of the talk in this speech but do not really convinced the part of speech which downgraded importance of villages and agriculture. And also about swadeshi and vedic period. It would have been good if you put light on how swadeshi and vedic culture, philosophy is not relevant today rather than suggesting to throw in dustbin

[@noonefornow1514]

He didn't threw it in dustbin, he just said that's what should be the only focus.

[@vilasosc]

@@noonefornow1514 yes throw in without thinking even it is good and relevent why bcoz its indian and old. evolution doesnt happened like that and left is trying to do that and you can see the result in west

[@Vikas-rx3gv]

must compile your thoughts in a book....

[@jasha9sandhu]

" a right is a right when enforced by a state"

[@shiva_kondapalli]

Interesting talk, but I must say, the man sounds radical in many ways, not at all conservative, and that's a good thing, I guess. Conservatism is a loser ideology anyways. And his argument seems to be on the lines of "economic change" such as urbanization, development of cities and modern industry will induce free movement of labor and lead to "social change" such as the melting away of caste differences, will create a similar shared experience amongst people that can lead to inter-marriage, less gender segregation and so on feels very Marxist actually, it can be summed up in one sentence: "the base informs the superstructure". Anyways nice talk, modern India, caste-free India, strong India, that's what I want.

[@yetneshdubey860]

Freedom of expression should be absolute. No one should be persecuted on the basis of their though & views. This is not true right wing politics. In America the freedom of speech is absolute, you can criticise everything & everyone & still remain protected by the law. The only function of the state should be to make sure that those rights remain protected from everyone.

[@TheGuruNetOn]

Don't agree with many interpretations and do agree with other interpretations. Either way certainly a very thought provoking talk.

[@jupiterkumar1]

The speaker is making some valid points. However, I disagree that sociological studies today have to be based on modern theories as prescribed by the speaker when we already know the implications of it on academia, Media and the bureaucracy. Most of the cognitive sciences and social sciences have its roots in Dharmic/Vedic traditions but have been repackaged and sold back to India to shape the mindset of the masses without any sacredness attached to the land and its history. Ours is a unique land that has sacred, living consecrated spaces that are live nests and living fractals of the working structure of the cosmos. So in that light Bharat is very different from all other nation states. We have a primal responsibility to align to those geometries. Speaker contradicts himself by initially saying we did not question the British characterization that we were backward, but later saying we have to turn our back to Vedic know how. If Vedic knowledge has lived on because of its own efficacy and primarily also because of the consolidation of the shastras as an open architecture and evolutionary living body of work, it is a very unique factor of civilizational continuity of a variety of sciences (including political science), technology and arts as a unified body of existential cosmology. Therefore it’s very much possible that with the coming of technological disruption and human displacements and mass confusion globally, the real answers to human evolution lies in this overarching and profound body of work. India has a massive strategic advantage to organize around its immense economic and sociological benefits for the general population to tune into. Otherwise it is akin to saying - remove the sacredness from yoga and practice it like an exercise imported back from abroad. We have way too much content to decode, register, practice, test and recreate to lay out the foundations of tomorrow’s challenged.

[@abhijitchaudhari9838]

Good

[@ved746]

As we want to see India as it is we should also talk about the digital and data revolution that is going on in the world and by correlation in the country. We must talk about how the country is going to evolve during this time and how we can preserve our identity in this time of rapid change. India must not be characterized only by its urban and industrial participation but also by its digital presence which has an opportunity to bring the rural folk also in the fold of the narrative.

[@siddharthsiddharth7106]

One thing I feel is that now time has come to discuss caste system of Islam and Christianity that is present in our country . If we have to deal with present situation this is important , media should pick these stories . It will help break the caste system present there .

[@PS-eu6qk]

Very good lecture.

[@n.s.karanth1381]

I really appreciate your call, we need not ,or should not glorify our past mistakes in order to oppose the present system ,we must admit our past mistakes and try how best we can overcome them urgently to revive our positive narratives The biggest foolishness of our right wingers is they still justify our old mistakes and oppose the leftists ,surely that is not the good way

[@bharathshaveri8325]

Always india first.jai Hind

[@avinashmishra7735]

Yes the real problem is in Caste System and that includes not only so called Brahmanism but also Dalit politics. Why were these self claimed liberal parties not able to address this issue in all these years? Probably those political vultures never had that kind of will and intention. This parliamentary democracy has allowed people to collect one group or the other in the name of oppressed over some other groups and cashed into these fault lines, but never really tried to lessen these social gaps. Why do you people who talk so much about Caste discrimination, feel frustrated to see Hindus getting united? By popularizing Vedic education and making it available to everyone across the spectrum, that time is not far when Hindus will uproot this menace of Caste System and will get united as Hindu first and Hindu last. However, I must say that Brahmin sages introduced the Varnashrama system to Hindus. They wanted to formally divide labor. The caste system was made rigid, NOT BECAUSE ALL BRAHMINS WERE CORRUPT. The caste system was made rigid because it was believed that when a certain family has the son learning from his father, that would not only cut back societal expenses on education but also introduce expertise in the society. However, as with any event in history, This had negative consequences too. My ancestors did not mean harm. But, I believe that expertise is not produced by son learning from father but by facing difficulties in life..nepotism sucks. Castes were never allotted by birth in the past.. It was decided by karma but later those in power at their own convenience deliberately misinterpreted the whole Vedas to serve their purpose... The present caste system is fucked up and we are responsible for it...It's already commanded in our scriptures to update our smritis( Manusmriti to Yagnivalkya to now Mitakshara and Dayabaga) like Puranas, Shastras and kavyas from time time with evolution in Human material and spiritual expereince. That's why we have so many interpretations of Ramayana and Sitayana, and that's why we are not hesitant to accept the Indian Constitution as one of our latest shastras and part of our religion. No Hindu can deny this. But can we expect the same from self claimed all time perfect Abrahamic religions too?

[@avinashmishra7735]

TO BE CONTINUED.....Religion was not responsible for this menace of Caste System , rather manipulations and deliberate misinterpretations of Varna and Jati vyavastha in Social Structure were. We self claimed Brahmans who don't want others to read Vedas and expose our greed, whose ancestors had cunningly manipulated our Shrutis(Vedas and Upnishads which are Universally Eternal and Fundamental that can't be changed) and didn't update Smritis (Shastras, Puranas and Kavyas) in greed so that the power, wealth, land and knowledge can be centralized (based on birth) and not decentralized in different sections of society based on individual skills or abilities, should come in front and lead the revolution of uprooting this Caste System from our society and accept ourselves as Hindu first and Hindu last. Regarding Smritis which are commanded to be updated in the sciptires itself, I would like to add that although Manusmriti was updated to Yagvalkya and then to Meetakshara and Daybaga School of Thoughts, but from then on we have been stagnant for last 1000-1500 years and never really cared to update and contexualized them in a more logical, spiritual and scientfic way. Similalrly, Puranas and Shastras too were not updated along with Human evolution and time. However, kavyas like Ramayna and Mahabharat, being 2 mahakavyas were interpreated many times in various ages according to one's own way of looking at things. Although the Jati vyvastha was based on state level to ensure that Children who inherit traditional skills from their parents can produce more in quality and quantity, but according to Varna vyvastha in puroshoktm (which came after Manusmriti and which was deliberately not made popular or accessed to every section of society), a child from any family holds all the right to be Brahman if he owes intellectual skills, or to be Kshtriya if he owes fighting skills even if his father has some skills other than that of Kshtriya. And that's why the weaver jati, steel making jati, goldsmiths, porters etc were not poor in dated History until 17th century. But since this Varna vyavastha and jati vyavastha which were very much logical and practical have been intoxicated to such a large extent now that we should not be thinking of reverse engineering these systems. Rather we should consider ourselves as Hindu first and Hindu last. We should continuously evolve our smritis(scriptures) with time on the basis of science and spiritual experience as it is already said in the scriptures, instead of being frozen and still like Abrahamic religions. You can also verify that- Purusha sukta from Rig veda says -" As mentioned in Rigveda 9.112.3, ' Karu-raham-tato-bhisag upal-pakshini-nanah, Nana-dhiyo vasu-yavo-anu-gaayiv tashthi-mindrayandu-parishravaha' which means ki Varna ka shabdik meaning hai rung (color) aur shastro me trigun(3 personality virtues). Yani satva, rajo aur tamo naam ki mano-sthiti ya mano-dasha(psyche) ko varna yani rungo k madhyam se v darshaya jata hai. Isliye satva ko safed (white), rajas ko laal (red) aur tamash ko krishna yani kaale (black) rung se abhivyakt kiya jata hai. Jab manushya apne astitva (existence) k liye kabhi jungli pashuo se aur kabhi dusre samooho (groups) k aakraman (attack) se fight kar raha tha, aisi vyavastha me jo satva guun pradhan(dominant) the jinhone society k samajik (social) or aadhyatmik (spiritual) marg-darshan ka jimma (responsibility) uthaya, they were called Brahman. Jo rajo guun dominant the, yoddha (warrior) the, veer the, yuddh me kushal aur nirbhik (fearless) the, jinhone apne samaj apne samudaay (community) ki raksha (defense) ki jimmedari uthayi, they were called Kshatriya. Jo rajo aur tamo guun pradhan the, jinhone samaj k paalan-poshan, bhojan aur rojmarra (daily needs) ki zarurato ki jimmedari li, they were called vaisya (business class). aur jo tamo guun pradhan the, inhone apne samaj apne samudaay ki sewa (service) ki jimmedari uthayi, they were called as shudra. " What did rishi Yagyavalkya say to king Janak of Mithila province in Brihadaranyako Upanishad in reply to the question( What does a man become like and how does he behave after knowing the eternal truth brahma?) of Acharya Gohan- "Jo brahm ko jaan chuka hai, wohi brahman ban jata hai fir chahe woh is dhara (earth) par kahi bhi kisi k v ghar me paida hua ho, baki koi brahman nahi hai, wo sab mrityu (death) aur shok (sorrow) k grasit hain. Brahm ko jaan lene k baad jo bhukh(hunger)-pyas(thirst), janm(birth)-mrityu(death) aur shok(mourn)-moh(worldly desires and attachments) ki kaamna se mukt(free) hokar bhiksha( begging) par nirvah karta hai, wahi brahman hai. )", which means Varna k is vyavastha ka apne pracheen (ancient) ruup (form) me janm se koi sambandh nahi tha. Aur agar Varna vyavastha Janm pe aadharit nahi hai, toh fir Janm se koi mahan aur koi heen kaisa?Mai uus vyavastha k khilaf hu jo pratyek manushya ko samajik aur adhyatmik uutkarsha ka awsar(equal opportunity) na de. All of us are born shudras, with knowledge we have to become brahman and then end up as one with the eternal. Every person should have an equal right to choose his/her profession kyoki wahi purusharth(only a metaphor here) hai aur shram(profession) ka vibhajan(distribution) kisi ek varna k adikar me nahi add ho sakta.Har vyakti me aseem sambhavnae hain aur unhi sambhavnao ka dwar kholna hi varna vyavastha hai. This was the reason why Bhargavram (popularly known as Parshuram) despite of being born in a brahman family, could hold farsa(sword) in his hand as Kshtriyas. This was the reason why Valmiki despite of being born in a Kshatriya family could become Brahman and got the upadhi of Maharishi for his intellectual and spiritual knowledge. This was the same reason why Karna despite of being nourished by a fisherwoman was allowed to learn shastrakala(Fighting skills) as warriors. This was the same reason why Valmiki despite of being a son of fisherwoman and himself being a lootera(robber) could get the seat of vyas and become famous as vedavyasa after getting transformed and knowing brahma (the eternal truth). This was the same reason why Kalidas despite of coming from lakarhara (woodcutter) family got the upadhi of Mahakavi(The great Poet) after getting transformed from a foolish man to Kalibhakta. And this was again the same reason why Ravana despite of being born in a North Indian Brahman family, got the adjective of Rakshasa and later on got punished by Rama who was a Kshatriya, and no brahman had any problem against this." The same has been told by bhagvan Mahavir (in Uttaradhyana Satra) too- "Kammuna brahamano hoi, Kammuna hoi Khatriyo, Vaisyo kammuna hoi, Suddo havai kammuna" which means it is the good and bad actions of a person and not his birth that determines his Varna. Similarly, bhagwan Buddha ne v Sutta nipata 9.57,58 me isi ko support kiya hai- " na Jachcha brahmano hoti, na jachcha hoti abrahmano(unbrhamnic); kammuna hoti brahmano, te piko hoti kammuna" and in Sutta nipta 7.21,22- " na jachcha vasli hoti, na jachcha hoti brahamno; kammuna vaslo hoti, kammuna hoti brahmano" which again mean ki Varna vyavastha me koi mahaan aur koi heen nahi. Jaise mastak(head), bhujao(arms), jangho(thighs) aur pairo(legs) ka ek vyakti k kalyan k liye ek sath kaam karna aawasyak hai, usi prakar samaj k kalyan k liye ek sath kaam karna aawsyak hai, usi prakar samaj k kalyan k liye sabhi varno ki samanya ruup se aawsyakta hai. For eg, Milk, Ghee, 'Chhanchh', Curd, etc all belong to the same family, but their values are different.

[@avinashmishra7735]

Since Communists never consider culture and civilization in their economic Marxist philosophy, therefore they would go to any extend to oppose Nationalism because for them every nation is nothing but just a piece of land where people should only care for their economic prosperity and financial equality, and not this culture or that culture. These sectarian movements like Dravidian movement and various Dalit Movements in order to create more rifts between different Caste fault lines or movements on regional language which were made to flourish all these years without much substance are actually driven by a typical Communist mindset (that since there's nothing in actual to bind so many cultures except those all-time favorite theoretical answers answers like "Universal Tolerance" and "Unity in Diversity" which are noting special as a glue to bind and can be irresponsibly applicable to people from any part of the world to demean their right to freedom, therefore India is not one nation) and thus playing into the global hands. But as soon as you would go deep into the gravity of the matter, you would find "Diversity in Unity" more appropriate than this fake popular "Unity in Diversity" concept in defining India's pluralism and multi-culture. But before advocating this point, let me tell you that instead of fake one way Tolerance and absolute non-violence, our Civilization stands on practical ground of Mutual-Respect and "Minimization of Harm"; and this evaluation of Harm is being done in terms of both nature and humanity as follows: 1- Dharma - Law of nature 2- Karma - Law of action 3- Rebirth (Multiple lives) 4- Temporary Heaven and Hell 5- Permanent way back to the source(Moksha).Transmigration and transcendence are one of the core concepts in all Dharmic religions. (Soul keeps on incarnating until : a) obtains Moksha (Hinduism). b) merges with the Creator (Sikhism). c) attains Nirvana (Buddhism). 6- Considering there are multiple ways to attain moksha, that paves way to peace within Dharmic religions. Meditation (the process and aim although ,may vary in each faith. Like Sikhism mostly concentrates on Naam Simran for Divine- Merger, Buddhism has other meditation techniques like Vipasna etc, and Hinduism too has kriyas, yogic meditations and so on). 7- Respects the freewill of the humans, allows to contemplate and argue the philosophies and beliefs. Seeking is given more importance than believing or disbelieving. Hence, all Indic Religions which originate out of free thinking environment, have a Dharmic Vedic core in them be it Sikhism or Jainism or Buddhism or Hindusim (Sanatana Dharma) or even athesim, and therefore have same "samskaras" and Mutual-Respect for each other and not bloody fake Tolerance (as propagated in the West) which itself sounds intrinsically very insulting. Therefore, no indic religion felt any 'theoretical' insecurity at least, unlike to the Abrahamic Religions which can't be more exclusive than saying "it's either my way or the highway (satanic)".Hindus believe in mutual respect, which is hard for abrahamic religions to accept who are expansionist. There lies the problem. Now before someone would jump on to my caste alleging me of supporting Brahmanism, I must say that I consider myself as Hindu first and Hindu last. I too want this fake birth based Caste System to immediately go away since it was never mentioned in our scriptures and there're so many ways for uprooting this menace of Caste System out of which Vedic education is the best possible way as per me which these political vultures will never agree upon in the name of secularism. Hindu as a community is in short of fund to open such schools because almost all our offering in Hindu temples get collected by the Govt and thus that money become 'secular'. There lies the another problem.

[@siddharthsiddharth7106]

A very good discourse , opinion is different on one or two points though very critical and thorough analysis of present day situations that conservative should look into . Can we get a better term than this term conservative , regarding India it does not fit fully . Something that is more at home . There have been many movements throughout history need some more today .

[@josephdevasia3921]

This guy talks sense.

[@siddharthsiddharth7106]

Joseph Devasia I like all talks of Abhinav sir

[@rohitlandge7033]

This is what i called intellectual approach

[@manassurya2019]

These caste defenders will be the death of us Hindus. We have suffered long enough due to these people's attitude. Enough of caste identity. Hindus need to urbanize, and equalize.

[@imranatheist4280]

Earliest idea of a national identity based on culture came from Shivaji Maharaj. Please understand this, the reason you are emphasising modernisation and industrialisation as means of achieving homogeneity, and therefore people rising above caste to a national awakening is because we lost the idea of protecting dharma. But such an Idea existed. Eg- Naga order of Sanyasis.

[@indiaemerging7584]

Wonderful talk by abhinav bhaiya, thankyou for putting the things in perspective.

[@jasha9sandhu]

For Indian nationalism to triumph, caste divide needs to go away. For that to happen inter caste marriage is only vehicle.

[@महात्माआंधी]

Why not ending reservation?? I didnt know about my caste untill i applied for iit exams

[@sutapabarman7871]

The most important things Thank u.

[@siddharthsiddharth7106]

Whatever debate ppl have about past till conditions on ground do not change today, situation will not improve ,this means right wing leaders must discuss these issues mentioned by Abhinav sir on ground , this is a very important point that they should pick up . Right wing should be controlling this discourse .

[@Vikas-rx3gv]

beautiful thoughts.....

[@lakhiramlekhwar3002]

Very brilliant talk sir, what you are articulating are facts and we are to be blamed for not letting India to become A Nation, all these cast systems still are hounding india in Villages, however our forefathers tried to transform by prevalazing against

[@lakhiramlekhwar3002]

But then it was again destroyed by some liberals and left wings and it’s unfortunate

[@prodoshranjanghosh2104]

You are really impressive, should the bharat think right way

[@poonamabbi7448]

Are you trying to tell us that we should read only what is approved by you, what pleases you, & what leaves you comfortable? You seem to be "one of those" you are so passionately accusing, & are actially in DENIAL of the breaking India forces. May be you are supported by them, or are "rewarded" by them... you know best... but you seem to be very uncomfortabe with discussng it...SO UNCOMFRTABLE that you are actually calling it a spent force...

[@kreativepulp8760]

I think you should listen to this talk again.

[@apurvgore6770]

I found Abinav Prakash Singh is confusing indian by talking on right and left wing and inducing the thought to follow maxist and left history instead of talking against it, it is important to bring confidence in people to develope people life which leads to the rise of country , according to you agriculture sector is useless to build nation , just look at the no. Of family who life r depend on it , you can't just make every village a industrial hub, and nor you can bring every villager in city and create national unity, and avoiding our ancient culture how will you connect people of India I don't understand, and freedom of speech is always missuse by others ,and according to you only Hindus should respect freedom of speech and not any other communities, you talked about Savarkar idea but the left have already declared him as deshdrohi what you will say about him, today most of the Indians in village are backward because the first 12 to 18 years they waste their time in learning languages, you give us example of Europe China USA then you should consider this point too , Please don't confuse indian after so many centuries now Indians are on right track , and you r trying to derail them Your speech shows that how you are portraying Hindus as hyper nationalist , and portraying -knowning vedic culture knowledge and discussing them- as backward ideology

[@apurvgore6770]

@Vaibhav that is what u believe . I am happy if vedic thought of life once again come in pictures . Because communism socialism has already failed. And capitalism had not done any good

[@stalinsampras]

@@apurvgore6770 but you believe ancient indian system was good?? Lol how moronic should you be, Ignorance is sure a bliss man

[@apurvgore6770]

@@stalinsampras it is better to be moron by believing in ancient india system rather to believe in blood drench socialism and communism and aimless atheism and become a pawn of some Russian and Arabs.

[@shankarkurtakoti9025]

brilliant analysis

[@kumarbrowns]

We do not want a modern industrial state devoid of its past glory. I agree we do have to acknowledge the caste fault lines and address them. But we have to stand on the Vedas. We want a dharmic India. Not a Soviet Union like behemoth that has forgotten its old glories.

[@rameshmuttur1236]

In the magnanimity of accepting the reality, the speaker does not give any solutions to the caste problems. It is very easy to define the problems with nice words, but, what are the solutions? Caste problems created by the political parties needs to be countered by people. So, young friend, what are the arguments, what are solutions?

[@Prashant08]

Give subsidy in everything but not reservation

[@samanbazhagan1949]

What a sad statement to make! At the end of this session or in the Q&A session: " ..must throw money to people!" To attract capable people into the team. Such an engaging speech ends with such an ordinary solution! Sri. C.Rajagopachari, long ago has written about money in demoracy. Wish the speaker and listeners of his speech go through it. I am saddened at the expert opinion being of such a low order!

[@indrason6974]

All social contracts are economic contracts in the end you can't do anything without money

[@atmakurmuraliKrishna]

Nothing wrong stated. UPA Government constituted NATIONAL ADVISORY COUNCIL to bulldoze liberal ideas. They were paid. Many liberal websites, portals and magazines are paid by liberal supporters across world. Nothing wrong in paying to right wing ideas

[@satsudha53]

There is difference, in miss spelling, in these translation on foot prints,which leads to opposite meaning.

[@porchelviramr4404]

Your talk comes from your colonized mind Sir! So sad! Why are we getting curses in the form of these kind of talks! About the thought of Vedic period, so sad!

[@bluelotus3090]

Nice 👍

[@anonymouslyopinionated656]

glorifying the village is a classic left wing thing. keep people poor and divided.

[@vijayprathap]

I disagree with him glorifying all urban lifestyle. The real culture of any country is preserved in its villages. If you urbanize the entire country, where will you get your food from? The references to koenrad elst and Rajiv malhotra is very distasteful. It is true that caste discrimination is a curse, but at the same time they preserve our cultures and values. It is one of the reasons why both Christianity and Islam failed to subjugate India completely.

[@YashKansalx]

no culture is made in India urban india