ReCategorizer: Tutorial + Download | Minecraft 1.19+/1.20+

[@14llison]

I need someone to convert this to an instructional booklet like the ones that come with Lego kits

[@overtonesnteatime198]

a.I.

[@Dogbreath42]

look up the mod litematica you can turn any build/contraption into a lego instruction booklet

[@salg6782]

It pains me I finished building your previous version right before you dropped the videos for the new one, BUT it works amazingly. Truly enhances your game experience. You're AWESOME!

[@Lukysao]

Deza vi

[@Lokolow]

Just finished building the version from 10 months ago and got recommended this one. Can't complain, the older one still works perfectly for me :D

[@Lokolow]

MA NEM QUE O CARA É BRASILEIRO. EU ASSISTI O OUTRO VIDEO POR UMAS 8 HORAS PRA FAZER O NEGOCIO TODO E NAO DESCONFIEI EM NENHUM MOMENTO KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK

[@Nikolouska314]

Same here ahah but the other one is just as good as this one

[@eduardodanonao]

​@@Lokolowo cara fala bem dms, mas a propósito, qual o video que vc faz o separador?

[@MaizumaGames]

Check the video description for links, chapters & download! The video ended up a bit choppy unfortunately but I can't fix it for now so I apologize. Audio is fine though and everything was recorded with a lot of care to help you get this system up working, so enjoy it! Stay tuned for the follow up video with MORE additions to the storage system! kzbin.info/aero/PL3_Ixao62eq_4Sionl7RcrmkBFmIAsuxD

[@Mekhami]

this audio is so quiet...?

[@sammysammyson]

Question, what happens if the system happens to get overloaded? That is, your storage silo of an item completely fills. Does it just pause until there is space? Ty :D

[@savosavic1222]

​​​​​@MaizumaGamesa w one problem with your sistem that i have expirianced idk if u fexed it or not but it problem goes like this: 1st of all i build 31 categoris in one row and problem lies in that i can't stop minecart from collecting stuff from input when hopers aren't finished transporting the items to desired category and minecart skips same category in finding items wich means (I want to store 2 shoulkerboxes of gravel gravel goes in outpt minecart does it usual route and does everything normally and then 2nd time when he tries to find gravel in category it skips that category bc hopers aren't finished and comparator didn't lock hoppers in and then 3rd time it's same like a 1st and 4th is like 2nd and so on) now I'm trying to somehow make minecart wait on input rails until last item finishes hopering in chest ik u said to not buld too long but it was too late for me to reverse later in video edit: this apps only on last 9 categorys others work just fine

[@therealtimmyt5247]

I can definitely see the advantages of this new system over the old one. I know you mentioned there will likely be another video featuring a few add-ons. I would love to see how you integrate a shulker loader for the bulk storage! I think that would really make the system perfect.

[@RSTaku]

agreed

[@BartlebyNineteen]

Quick note on banner crafting: if you name the banner on the anvil first, then duplicate, the name gets applied to the duplicated banner as well and is guaranteed to stack (named map duplication works the same way). Otherwise, my 60 slice build (3x20) works: built on 1.20 fabric entirely from the instructions in this video. Thank you for putting this all together! Now I just need to figure out what I'm going to do with 25 shulker boxes of shears...

[@overtonesnteatime198]

But what about the anvil loader???? i need it lol

[@midpoint3871]

Building this from a world download right now. So hyped for this because I was worried about missing the details which i know is important. Timing of this is perfect thank you!

[@LavrentiEmirashvili]

Hey if it doesn't bother you could you tell me how you placed down comparator near input chest? Its supposed to be activated but its not active in my build even tho i tried everything

[@midpoint3871]

@@LavrentiEmirashvili there are a few that need the composter to have a power level of 1 I believe. Just a single flower does it, I'm not sure which comparator you mean though

[@coldhanded]

Thank you so much for the detailed breakdown and tutorial on the build. Having lots of fun with this.

[@vojtechstiborsky9522]

hey, made it through the first part, so far only in my creative world, I just wanna say thats some crazy redstone magic and Im glad big brains like you do this for the rest of minecraft community! I expected this to be so hard to build but your explanation is on point, slow, precise, just crazy good :D thank you so much

[@chubyduck]

Thank you for this tutorial. It took me a whole week to build and lots of troubleshooting but I finally finished building this in my mountain. I'm very happy and desperately needed to upgrade my previously small sorting system with all the new blocks in the game. I started playing in 1.13 and I can barley keep up with all the new features and blocks in Minecraft now. Still so much for me to explore that I am behind on.

[@cuencaguy9799]

I've been thinking for a long time about storage, both in my ender chest and a storage room, but I haven't been completely happy with what I've had. I've been using one wall of your old MIS, but it just didn't have enough space or do enough. I'm now combining two sets of Cybot's shulker sorter (sorting for up to 130 boxes where the items in the shulker box are the filters) with an expanded version of your compressed storage (26 slices of storage without a nonstackable filter) and finally this new, improved design of yours with two added slices just to make everything fit nicely. I'm currently testing the full system in a creative world, and it's about 8.4 MSPT in an empty superflat world. The full system is almost 50x60, so I'll need a few chunkloaders, but it should save me so much time. Thank you so much for your contributions to Minecraft storage systems :)

[@sammysammyson]

This is fantastic. Not only is it just a great system, but also very well-explained and easy to follow with all the nitty gritty details of how to make sure that you don't break such a touchy contraption. One minor thing though, is there any way you can increase the volume of your speech? Would make things a bit easier to follow :) Fantastic work on this, I started resource gathering for it yesterday and honestly...it's not very expensive for survival.

[@louiseandersen8534]

I have a problem where the minecart does not "fall down" through the chest like it should. I just goes on the powered rail and when it's supposed to "fall down" through the chest and load items from the input chest, it doesn't it just stays on like the edge of the rail/hopper. Anybody experienced that and know how to fix? I tried it in both multiplayer and singleplayer. Still doesn't work.

[@MaizumaGames]

Please try the solution presented at the chapter named "Alternative Unloader". The world download has been updated to with an even better solution.

[@MidnightDoom777]

Do the rails at 30:50 need to be curved? if so, why?

[@MaizumaGames]

Optional. They make the minecart move faster, so it sorts items faster.

[@extravagantbee6257]

It works - and I managed to debug an issue with my build because you explained it so well. Now I just have to program all the chests.... Thank you for your amazing creation and clear video.

[@BetheCog]

I dont use litematica, does anyone have the material list for the full room that they can share?

[@ShesCute.]

Could i make the same thing again but not using the input at the bottom and just connecting hoppers to the chest where the minecart takes them from

[@danielsiress1753]

No clue why but all of a sudden doesnt work... was working fine and just randomly stopped. For some reason the hopper will not empty, it will partially empty then refill itself somehow. then it will park itself stopping the farm. I have a litematica of it, nothing different, I have another functioning version of it in the same world, no difference. If anybody can knows why this is or how to fix it plz help!!!

[@franklyn9926]

I recently just built this sorting system and I am having a problem. The water bucket dispensers sometimes turn on and off, which then turns off the powered rails, I then press the button on the dispenser again, and it does the same thing. Did I do something wrong? BIT MORE EXPLANATION - The sorting system works beautifully except for the water bucket mechanism. When the minecart does it's circuit, it turns on some redstone, which then, makes the dispenser activate, which then, uses the water bucket and the water goes into the leaf. But sometimes the mechanism messes up and turns off the powered rails completely, which means I have to push the button to activate it again, AND THEN, the powered rails turn off AGAIN, which means, you guessed it, I gotta push the button. I am starting to get frustrated with it, I don't know what is happening, please help me. I have always used the basic, water pushing items system, but I don't want to build a system which has out of date sorting, with the filter system. Thanks for reading if you did, hope you can help. ALSO FORGOT TO MENTION this is the second time that I have built a sorting system from @Maizuma.

[@yardenendvelt7731]

Hii Im dealing with the same problem did you manage to fix it?

[@franklyn9926]

@@yardenendvelt7731 I have no idea how redstone works. So imma just wait a little bit. So no I didn't.

[@MaizumaGames]

Hi, have you checked your front line comparators ? The main cause for the ramp (where the rails switch on/off) to go out of sync with the system is when you have extra categories triggered that didn't get properly reset. Try to use the method I described in my 2 videos to reset *and check* that the categories have been reset. Another possible cause is when the sorter is built in between chunks so it gets partially unloaded! This means the synchronization signal is lost which breaks the circuit you described.

[@yardenendvelt7731]

@@MaizumaGames that is the problem sorry if I didnt explained my self good enough but every time I try to sort something one item {ender pearl in my case) keep going to the top dropper and nothing I tried seem to fix it other than manually reset

[@franklyn9926]

@@MaizumaGames Aight, ill check it out, and come back to you if it doesn't work. Thanks.

[@gabriellascott2057]

What may I have done wrong if when I go to test my hopper minecart (like at 22:15) it makes it to the tip but it does not drop down it gets stuck sitting on top of the input chest

[@dABiGfATLol]

i wish i could understand the shulker unloader with overflow protection part. ive downloaded the world and stared at it for an hour trying to follow whats happening rip

[@zetertheduck]

I have a question about the circuit built at 37:37. Sometimes the minecart doesn't get the signal, possibly because only a small number of items went through the system, giving out an even number of pulses and not giving the minecart enough time to continue moving. How could this be fixed?

[@JacobVega]

(Taking the tutorial step by step) For the dispensers at 4:30 , would water bottles work as a substitute for snowballs/shears? Also, around 6:00 , would bottles be able to substitute the shears as well?

[@LyricAndCompany]

Did you ever end up doing the part 2 to this explaining the add ons and everything? I'm not sure if it was done or if I'm just missing it somewhere obvious ^^"

[@dibsteronly3053]

Problem with mine. I did everything up to 25:34 but my items that I tested all went to the overflow chest. PLZ HELP Edit - nvm my problem, silly mistake by me

[@SerrOleg]

Hey I seem to be having the same issue others are experiencing: Multiple stacks past the 21st segment end up in the non-categorised slice after the 1st stack. I've noticed this issue only occurs when the sorter is oriented east to west. When oriented the other way west to east it works perfectly fine. I have applied your changes in v2.0.1 in planet minecraft however the issue still occurs. Any ideas?

[@SerrOleg]

It seems the slice hopper is locking after the minecart goes through once, instead of staying unlocked

[@MaizumaGames]

Yes, this bug has been confirmed, I thought you were referring to old bug I had already fixed. I still don't have a complete fix for this one but I'm working on it. I did publish version 2.0.2 today which addresses another issue related to direction East/West.

[@forsant229]

​@@SerrOlegany fixes?

[@SerrOleg]

No fixes unfortunately. I found that for me it works fine if I don't make slices larger than 23 so I just did that in my world@@forsant229

[@gg-bc6sw]

Can anyone help mine minecart is not picking up any item from the chest

[@judgejlo]

I've inspected every piece of this and it just isn't working for me. The banners/items get borked in the first section. Complete loss for what's going on

[@judgejlo]

Now it's only sort of broken. I'm testing with two items, one from the first and last slice of the first section. They're both getting put into the first slot, not their respective ones.

[@judgejlo]

Everything goes into the first slot... sheesh

[@judgejlo]

So seems the right slice gets activated but items still end up in the first slot... Anyone else have this?

[@judgejlo]

Don't build tired. Missing comparator and it works. I feel dumb.

[@MaizumaGames]

Don't be so hard on yourself over this. It's a complex build in general and I have updated it multiple times before I got it right. Even so, Minecraft is unfortunately known to change redstone behavior overnight.

[@christinlohner2305]

well... I've just tried to build this on my paper 1.21.1 and unfortunatly it doesn't work this way. The minecart is not going through the chest upwards to the other rails line. It gets stuck at the chest and then rolls back to the starting point....... :-(

[@ruffnerkid]

I built this in my creative world and it works like a charms! Now to start working on it in my survival! As of right now this is the best system I have seen! I saw Impulse build it in hermitcraft and I had to try it! Amazing stuff Maizuma! Keep it up! Highly recommend everyone watch all 3 videos pertaining to the ReCategorizer as Muzuma shows you debugging as well

[@MaizumaGames]

Thanks! I hope you fun with the build!

[@DylWEEB]

Im having a weird problem I am using the alternate method of putting the hopper minecart on the chest, but it doesnt move when the powered rail turns on, and the items dont go into the sorter they just go back into the bottom loading hopper

[@MaizumaGames]

You need to fix your banner setup. Quantities need to be exact. You also need to make sure your banner stack properly (it's a common problem).

[@darealmax337gaming]

I'm have troubles figureing out how the shulker box loader and storage works. The sign that says, "Input chest for shulker boxes to get filled" and "When lamp is off empty boxes go to straight to the box loader".

[@dapyr]

Do I need to contain it within 3x3 chunks? Or can I expand it to be bigger, like 5x5? I've also noticed a few changes in the latest design, like using a fern instead of a full dispenser with shears, as well as some other small changes. Could I just use that, or do I still need to use the shears?

[@RayTomlin]

I really love the build, but the presentation is difficult to follow.. Tried building in creative, had issues.. I'll try again later.

[@mootvey]

hey! i just built the anvil replacement system, and it replaces anvils even when they arent broken, just cracked , and as a result it drops anvils. is this an intended feature or an oversight?

[@MaizumaGames]

Oh no! This wasn't intended. I might have designed it based on old behavior. Well, back to the drawing board :-]

[@mootvey]

@@MaizumaGames ah i see! well keep me updated!

[@richardmeyer8433]

This needs way more views!

[@ajbiffl4695]

I was running into a problem with a 32-slice version. Even with the latest changes from the world download, the minecart got stuck at the far end when sorting stuff on that end. The signal extenders underneath the snowball droppers were double pulsing, which double pulsed the powdered snow and turned off the rails. My fix is ugly, just a new signal extender with a few repeaters that drops down below the system... seems to be working so far

[@Cb34Pe]

The junction you made at 36:22 (and the redstone line attached to target blocks) it's only purpose is to set one snow ball in that hopper, and nothing when sorter is running. Am i right? I am making 21 slices and i just put button as 7:14 but from both side. I was wondering if it will work or not.

[@miraclechild4124]

after very much trouble shooting I've got it up and running! awesome tutorial, great entry level storage tech! the powered rails that connect to the waterlogged leaves are being turned off sometimes and I have to manually reset it, how can I fix that?

[@MaizumaGames]

If that corner rail is turning off when it shouldn't it might be that your slices are not properly reset, there might be one or more open categories. You can fix by hitting the resetting button at the top and checking the locking comparators as shown in the video.

[@yardenendvelt7731]

@@MaizumaGames Hii Great tutorial But I ran into the same problem where one item get into the locked dropers and I have to manually reset it every time. got any tips?

[@dustinlkjh]

at 14:14 i cant figure out how to get the rail to not turn into the large one, it will not go the direction you have it at any ideas?

[@MaizumaGames]

The order in witch you place the rail matter, also make sure to be facing the same direction you want the rail to be aligned to.

[@bryanstauffer8773]

I am trying to build this on PS4. The whole thing appears to work except for the fact that minecarts don’t pass through chests and so I tried moving the input chests but the minecarts keeps dropping the orange flag off instead of the white flag and then the system breaks. Any help would be amazing

[@bryanstauffer8773]

I had to tear this farm down and build the bedrock version. It works great!!

[@populous10]

I'm following along with the tutorial, up to the first basic test, 22:30 in the video, cart leaves with 1 slot seal, 15 unloader banners and 3 shears, when the cart returns it has 16 of the unloader banners and the top hopper has 0. Any ideas where I'm going wrong or how to fix?

[@MaizumaGames]

Is your hopper at the top being locked somehow ? And are you building in vanilla/fabric or something else ?

[@SajjadAzami-zq3qr]

I have a problem with this I have build it from your world download and sometimes the Minecarts stop in the safety position and I have to push the button on the dispenser.😢

[@jakoj2098]

dam went through everything and the banners keep moving from minecart to top hopper that should only have 1x white banner? the item I want to sort sits in slot 2 of top hopper but banners keep adding from minecart, it was sorting a stak until it hit no.39 then minecart just stoped?

[@thiagoalmeida7356]

I'm having a problem, I built the first version but when I test it there's something wrong happening with the hopper minecart, it unloads the Seal and an Unloader but it get them back before it's able to get any item from the input chest, so the minecart keeps looping and nothing is sorted. Anyone has the same problem and is there a fix for this?

[@ZZzz_ProductionZ_zzZZ]

Yes, it is the issue that Cass tries to address @27:50. I tried many different configurations, but the minecart skips the unloading for me. It is only in the west/east direction. Playing on a fabric server.

[@TheAmazingLeo]

Oh man I'm so excited to give this a go!

[@maiconteixeira5332]

Cass, sorry I don't speak english Seu trabalho é incrível Acho que seria legal se vc fizesse um video mostrando a evolução do categorizer desde a versão inicial até agr. Valeu

[@MaizumaGames]

Boa idéia!

[@djrobotzz]

just built it and it is so cool! Its fast, reliable and easy to change filters! Only down side is of course the complexity of the build, but i paid attention so i got it to work perfectly!

[@chihaa-mt7bm]

4:11 does it have to be shears or can i use any non stackable item?

[@naj7969]

the hoppers fill with useful items. Not sure how to stall them or lock them once chest is full on bottom

[@TobiPower20]

Is there any chance that we can get another tutorial on how to build and integrate the shulkerbox loader and unloader?

[@jandon4639]

is it safe without the chunk loader or should you turn off the mashine / wait till sorting is finisched before leaving the area ?

[@MaizumaGames]

A chunk loader is recommended for this one. If you build the new version (I updated the world download) you might not need a chunk loader. The world download also includes an optional lever in case you decide to turn the sorter off while away.

[@chululu7657]

sir, you are doing gods work

[@ethanordorica2808]

Hello, what is the purpose of the iron trapdoor on your latest version? My machine works without it, with it the minecart gets stuck.

[@adamroberts7132]

I’ve built 2 sections, first at 15 chests long and second at 20 chest long. Not sure why, but in the first section 15 long, the sorter does not deposit items in tile 14 and 15 and sends them on to the 20 tile long section and the unsorted item chest T the end. Snowballs/shears everything has been triple check and I can’t find anything wrong.

[@mazza.tr1278]

i broke my and idk how or what i did my minecart keeps dropping off the banner in the hopper for the Categorizer cheats i need help or something

[@FadedDZ]

Built on a 1.20 paper server. Had a decent bit of trouble getting the minecart to stop exactly on the unloader hopper. Using the alternative unloader on my last two segments works perfectly! Thank you so much for the detailed tutorial!

[@stryderdominique4185]

Im on 1.20.1 Same! on one section I had to add an extra soul sand block and that fixed it. I also am having weird issues with the minecart getting stuck at the end of the track. Did you have that problem too?

[@FadedDZ]

As in, stuck on top of the unloader hopper? I had an issue with that, you need to make sure the hopper minecart loses all of the momentum and stops EXACTLY on the powered rail, otherwise the rail will not move the cart out of the unloading sequence. I believe it is explained in the video more thoroughly. @@stryderdominique4185

[@stryderdominique4185]

@@FadedDZ no Im not having an issue with the unloading, Im having an issue with the minecart getting stuck at the end of my chest system,

[@connorh.5601]

@@FadedDZ For anyone in the future having this problem: i was able to fix it by placing down a ton of soul sand around the track anywhere that wouldn't mess with the redstone. i had to play around with it a bit to get it in all the right places and none of the wrong ones

[@doopdoop7895]

are there any disadvantages of this compared to traditional MIS's?

[@asdfasdfasdf2053]

I can't get this to work reliably, and I'm not sure if it's something I did, or what. I didn't like the idea of a square, I wanted a long line (storage hall, not storage room), so I made one of these ~45 chests long. It will work for a little while, and then the hopper minecart will just stop at its stop point, prior to going up over the curved rails. I'll push the button to retract the powdered snow, and then it will go. Not sure if it's the same problem or a different one, but also items will wind up in random spots, sometimes a couple of them in the wrong spot, while some of them make it to the correct chest. Early on the in the videos, you say that you can extend things indefinitely, but then later you say that you shouldn't extend a single leg past a certain point, so I'm thinking that however the system works, the long rail lines might be breaking it. Either that, or the constant activation of the observer for the powdered snow is de-sync'ing the system somehow. I built the system by using a litematica schematic I took of the small system, then scaled out the rail lines to make the system longer, and then implemented the observers and alternating rails on the bottom of the system. I saw at least one difference between the proof of concept small system, and the larger system though, so maybe there is something else I need to add? This was my first use of litematica, and my first complex storage system, though I am no stranger to complexity (programming, robots, sysadmin, etc.). I had to use 2 chunk loaders to cover the entire system, it wound up being just over 3 chunks long, and hung over the borders on both sides of 3 contiguous chunks.

[@MaizumaGames]

I fixed some issues with the system over time. Overcoming chunk management limitations in Minecraft is quite challenging. The minecart stops at the opposite corner most probably because a pulse is lost so as you concluded it desyncs. I tried to address this issue in the latest version (currently 2.1.0s) so it might me worth checking it out. Be careful when copying & pasting the build using mods since redstone components sometimes get into an incoherent state if not updated manually.

[@pixondu6833]

With the new fast minecart system, will this separator stop working, improve or get worse?

[@aboveheaven08]

At about the 14:16 mark, I'm having trouble getting the 1 powered rail to stay pointed perpendicular to the unpowered rail. If i place the 2 rails there, it's pointed the right direction, but when i break the rail thats not needed, the remaining one auto-corrects its orientation to be in line with the unpowered rail. Any tips or tricks? Or maybe this is a BR vs Java thing?

[@aboveheaven08]

I figured out a way past it, if anyone else has this issue, I can describe how I got it to work

[@xombiemike]

Does the chunk loader only need to be used if the control circuit is in more than one chunk? Can that chunk loader be turned on and off by the MISS when needed?

[@BrankoVT]

Is there a maximum limit per section? I have a section with 26 categories (and the unsorted and unstackable items). Any category from column 21 onwards doesn't work. A second stack from the same category will not light up the lamp, and thus won't unlock the hopper meaning those items flow into the unsorted column. Is there an easy fix for this?

[@XhyRobtic]

Having the exact same issue, anything after the 21st chest is broken. Did you find a fix?

[@XhyRobtic]

Yeah so after further testing I keep getting the same issue. Rebuilt it block by block to be 30 chests wide and it still stops around the 23rd ish chest. I really don't get what the hell is wrong.

[@MaizumaGames]

It can be any size, I think there is an example with 26 or 27 categories with the world download.

[@rickyland9919]

On my build, the minecart does not fall through the input chest. I have the world download and it works, but not on my local game. Any suggestions?

[@MaizumaGames]

Yes, try the solution present at the chapter "Alternative Unloader" at around 27:50

[@dABiGfATLol]

why do you not recommend extending 36:35 more than once?

[@TheQueenLuffy]

ive made this! and it works great but i keep having an issue where the droppers in the center of the slices get shears in them which then breaks down the whole system! i don't know how to fix it!

[@tapsiespot832]

I'm having the same problem and have no idea what's causing it. A bunch of my items keep getting sorted into the wrong chests

[@MaizumaGames]

Hi! This project has been updated, please check out the new map (and new world download), a fix might be available. You can also join the discord server for help :-]

[@Dis3spectful]

​@@MaizumaGamesnew world download updated on this video?

[@Dis3spectful]

have you run into any problems with this that need fixing?

[@The.Sketty]

For me, the issue was the fact, that the sorter wasn't loaded. Try build chunk loader to fully load it

[@makaiwise4609]

I'm trying to build the rails like you showed on 1.20.1 but the rails always revert back to straight rails. Has this been patched?

[@DiddlyDarnDio]

Hey! I'm trying to build this in 1.20.1 (I have some performance enhancing mods on as well) but the minecart seems unable to pull things out of the input chest? It just gets immediately filled by the banners from the hopper. Is this a common problem for anyone else in 1.20.1?

[@jakoj2098]

has anyone had issuies with the banners from top hopper getting picked up by minecraft then they end up in lower hopper which should only have a white banner in it? also the snow balls somtimes end up in sort chest in first chest?

[@martimcunha3734]

Not sure if it's the same problem, but I'm having trouble with the banners as well

[@jakoj2098]

@@martimcunha3734 maybe new updates has killed the way it sorts, the banners just dont stay in the right hopper went over everything but cant see if its my end

[@martimcunha3734]

@@jakoj2098 I mean I'm building my recategorizer on a laggy aternos server so that may be the issue

[@Jakey_1]

I built your orignal categorizer design and have come up with an issue where the minecart sends its next item to sort before all 64 items move through the hoppers due to the design of my base. any suggestions on extending the delay of the send circuit?

[@MaizumaGames]

You could try a pre-sorter. I have a relatively recent video on that on my channel in case you're interested.

[@daviderisaliti3560]

Hey, really great tutorial. However I’m having an issue with the neinth category. I’m using the wall shaped one. The item disappear from the category chest but does not return into it and the item sort in the uncategorized chest. The neinth slot is also precisely the slot we’re I’ve placed the two repeaters for the activator rail line. I’ve rewatched your speech multiple times, what am I missing ?

[@lerog1393]

Why are target blocks used in the scheme?

[@geometrydash8834]

I only just started watching your other video on your multi item sorter, happy i waited to build it

[@conneroliver5731]

Im having a problem with snowballs going into the middle droppers that are never suppose to have them? as far as I can tell I have the redstone in the right spot. Anyone run into the same issue and have a solution? Thanks!

[@Lucian-yu1fi]

Why haven't you posted anything for a while? I would have loved to see a tutorial with the new version that contains the new updates,I hope you start posting again !!!😔

[@MaizumaGames]

Dealing with some stuff and solving problems recently. Thanks for the feedback though, I intend to post again soon if everything works out.

[@Lucian-yu1fi]

Thanks a lot for the reply😄!!Looking forward to the new updated tutorial!!Can't wait for you to post again!!

[@dumpling9160]

@@MaizumaGames thx for still working on it i really fell in love with that sorting system

[@koleherrick]

Thanks for the video! Just got done building this in my single player world and just did a big sort to give it an endurance test and I noticed a couple items I have filters set for still made it into the uncategorized chest. It did sort some of them, and only a few made it past the filter. I checked and they do stack together, just made it past the filter somehow. The valves and detection system are otherwise perfect, no idea if it was just a minecraft bug/tic problem or if there is something to tweak. Otherwise a fantastic sorting system!

[@MaizumaGames]

How long did you make the section where your items are supposed to go ? Are you running a Forge build or Vanilla/Fabric ? May be a problem with the sync line under the slices (35:55) kzbin.info/www/bejne/jmrHqGmMopl6rLc

[@london1944]

@@MaizumaGames I have the same issue (Vanilla, Minecraft Realm), 29 blocks long (9 chests, 3 empty, 7chests, 3 empty, 7 chests), sync line is 8 activator rails, 8 DR, 8 AR, 6 DR. The first two sections (9 chests, 3 empty, 7chests) work perfectly fine, but in the last section the problem occurs...

[@robbejaeken3147]

@@london1944 Did you find a solution?

[@ganooshgaming46]

Unless I missed it in the video, How does the reorganizer handle overflow? From my testing, it just breaks

[@SerrOleg]

I believe overflow ends up in the "uncategorised" storage slice at the end of the system along with any items that are not categorised in the filters

[@XhyRobtic]

Love the sorter! I build a big version of this for a friend but I'm running into an issue I have 3 walls, each 30 chests long, and I connected them all correctly, they rail line is extended with the observers and the target block has an extender too. However, the problem is that after it sorts the first stack with no issues, it gets to the 2nd stack of the same item but it doesn't actually unlock the slice the item is meant to go to. Just tested it now, and it's consistent. Every 2nd stack doesn't unlock the slice and it just ends up going into the next wall. I built it in the world download and the ones you made don't have this issue, so I'm confused why it does that. Why would it work the 1st stack but not the 2nd and then work again on the 3rd?

[@SerrOleg]

Out of curiosity, how are your walls aligned? I noticed that for me building it East to West (left to right) I encounter this issue, however the other way round (West to East) works fine

[@MaizumaGames]

If it's sorting correctly every other time it's a bug! The world download has a fix for it. Please check out the end of any section, you will find a pair of activator rails on top of the dispenser. That's the fix for the tutorial version :-]

[@SerrOleg]

@@MaizumaGames The issue occurs even with the rails placed unfortunately :(

[@XhyRobtic]

@@MaizumaGames I found that fix on the planet minecraft post. It fixes it for the last category yeah, but it won't for anything in-between. Seems to start doing that after the 21st slice too. So it's been breaking pretty regularly :/

[@FzsinClips]

The Minecart hopper isn’t taking the whole stack. It just leaves after getting like 5.

[@MaizumaGames]

It's a directional inconsistency with redstone. I managed to make a fix for it in the latest version of the world download.

[@tomkaczmarek596]

When I first test the minecart, the rail at the top gets powered and does not drop down. Any idea what mistake I would have made?

[@MaizumaGames]

Your minecart is too fast to stop normally at the unloader as addressed in the video. Are you using the soul sand blocks correctly ? Please make sure to check the chapter titled "Alternative Unloader"

[@Christian-Bachman]

Do I need to build the whole minecart unloading system every corner in the sorting system, or can I just connect the hopper line and rail from one line of chests to the next around a bend? I'm sure I am missing something important but it seems to me like there wouldn't be an issue?

[@tyiedd]

I have this weird issue with the junction that extends the repeater's signal at 36:23. For some reason I don't know the fifteenth redstone dust is always on and never lets the hopper minecart return the categorized item (as they are locked). Overall this leads to the 15th slice not working entirely and it deposits the items for that chest in the uncategorized chest. Do you have any tips or need more information from me? I am not much of a Redstone guy so I can't figure out why it is stuck on. Any tips, solutions or alternate signal extenders would be greatly appreciated. Thanks!

[@ajbiffl4695]

Are the hoppers in the fifteenth slice next to the filter chest in the correct state? Very top empty, one snowball right next to the chest, 2 snowballs and shears below the chest, and the dropper completely full of snowballs?

[@phil_not_funny]

Is there a downside to extending one side? As you said you highly dont recommend it, but what is the is the consequence?

[@aboveheaven08]

New issue, when i go to test the path of the minecart, it rollows the path correctly, but doesnt re-direct from the top powered rail, through the hopper to the rail below. It just pushes the minecart onto the double chest....

[@MaizumaGames]

Please try the solution presented on the "Alternative Minecart Unloader" chapter: kzbin.info/www/bejne/jmrHqGmMopl6rLc

[@aboveheaven08]

Thanks for the response, I tried the alternate unloader method as well, and whenever the cart lands on the powered rail on the hopper, as soon as it powers on, it slides the cart over onto the double chest instead of feeding it through the hopper. It could just be a bedrock issue. If you have any other suggestions I'm open to them.

[@MaizumaGames]

@@aboveheaven08 Apparently minecarts won't go through block in BE. Check the video description for a BE build by Redstone Wizard of Oz!

[@RedstoneWizard1983]

Love the build

[@latvian_fallen_angel]

Can rail just be straight above that hopper line?

[@simonvutov7575]

29:19 is this vanilla?

[@TheLegomann97]

I'm working on making a ReCategorizer for my world and have a question. Is this unload safe? If I were to log out while it's running, would it cause problems with the system? It's in spawn chunks so it's fine from a chunk loading perspective, but logging out and in is my main concern. Sorry if this was addressed in the video, I've been jumping around a lot in the video so I might have missed you mentioning it.

[@snipersimo-gaming34]

so does it keep working if you log out? or does it break?

[@zetertheduck]

About the curved rails - is 3 curved rails then a powered rail the best configuration for speed? I'm looking at the shots from 32:50. Anyway, I'm looking forward to part 2 for the shulker box sorters for this system.

[@MaizumaGames]

It's the best configuration I found in my tests. Also some configurations only make a difference on long distances.

[@jekyldnthide]

Having an issue where the minecart gets stuck on top of the chest and doesnt drop to the rail below. Anyone else having this issue or know how to fix it?

[@Bhalial]

Fix your minecart speed. Use the soulsand blocks he mentions in the video kzbin.info/www/bejne/jmrHqGmMopl6rLc

[@andrekeizers8911]

Thnxz man for the tutorial. I have your previous version in my base. Going for the tear down soon and build your new system. Luckily I have a shulkerfarm 😉

[@OfficialRune]

my minecart gets stuck exactly where you put the sign in your world download. it stops on the powered rail on the hopper and starts unloading the banners and shears. the "SlotSeal" lands in the hopper underneath with the 1 "unloader" and 3 "SlotFiller". the shears and the 15 "Unloader" land in the most right bottom chest of the storage system. I even compared it with litematica schematic but i couldnt find any differences. i really dont understand why this is happening. I even tried the alternative rail setup, but it made no difference. any ideas why this is happening?

[@dedtective]

Try using the alternative minecart loader at 27:50? I think I had the same issue as you, and that fixed it.

[@OfficialRune]

@@dedtective i have fixed it, thank you!

[@jamesdavis-mann706]

so got to testing the first two slices, and my snow bucket always drops out, and i can't fathom out why

[@MaizumaGames]

Some things to check: 1. Make sure you're using *powder snow*. 2. Make sure the bucket is placed inside a dispenser and not a dropper!

[@jamesdavis-mann706]

@@MaizumaGames Hi thanks - it's definetly a powder snow bucket, placed in the middle as shown in a dispenser - the minecart gets stuck on a depowered rail as it's going up towards the target block. When i put the powdered snow back in the dispenser it then powers the rail again, but the snow gets dispensed.

[@BeastlyHacker]

Has anyone attempted to mix this with Maizumas compressed storage? I would be very interested to see that

[@eshwar6969]

Yeah it’s pretty simple, just line it up with the hoppers, he designed it so it would be an add on

[@BeastlyHacker]

@eshwar6969 I mean fully integrate it with the system, not just use it as a module. After lining it up with the hoppers, I added a usability to the MIS so the Compressed Storage can request shulker boxes from the system, and there is only one input module for all of it. That part was a bit tricky, and I'd like to see if anyone else did it in a more elegant way

[@LavrentiEmirashvili]

Could you explain why it has to be built in the same chunk? I built it with litematica and didnt know chunk placement mattered

[@Just_Me_Being_Myself]

I don't know much about this sorter specifically, but usually it's because if you go too far away from a chunk it unloads, meaning that the redstone pieces stop working until you come back. If you have redstone elements that work together, but are not in the same chunk, a part of it unloads, while another part keeps working. And that often causes problems. With most contraptions you can stay in the chunk while it is working and you will be fine. I think it might be the same here, but I can't guarantee that.

[@BetheCog]

So keen to build this!

[@rokuta]

Do snowballs have to be in one of the first standard impulseSV slices before the items get to the minecarts?

[@MaizumaGames]

No, the only exception about snowballs is mention around 26:50

[@kalancosta7650]

Hahahahaha “If you want to sort snowballs and eggs in the chest….. first off you’re crazy…….” This had me laughing so hard

[@reyrey658]

when dose the mega sorter tutorial video come out?

[@MaizumaGames]

I'm working somethings out so it might take me a few extra weeks. If you need something for now you try to use the world download as a reference.

[@kellyallen927]

What is the final footprint (lxwxd)? I have a large open space I'd like to put it in but am not sure it would fit.

[@MaizumaGames]

The system can be of any size as I explained in the video. The world download is also available (link in video description) in case you wanted to build yours exactly as I built mine.

[@kellyallen927]

@@MaizumaGames I was talking mostly about height and depth, not width. I know you can adjust size, but was trying to see if it would fit where I wanted height and depth wise.