Red Dead Redemption 2024 REVIEW! Why RDR1 Is BETTER Than RDR2!

[@Saviour30]

Happy New Year Keep the channel alive! - www.paypal.com/paypalme/Saviour30 -Stay great and humble! Consider subscribe! Or JOIN as A MEMBER - You will get complete access to full playlist of extra content at level 1! My MUSIC HERE - open.spotify.com/artist/7wwpZRq8gAUFRw103smfPi

[@brandonferguson7361]

Rdr1s map also feels like it could fit in with the real US border, aside from the river flowing the wrong way. Rdr2s map feels like they condensed everything way too much. The south is only a few miles away from the desert, it makes no sense.

[@VinylcoteYT]

What area are you talking about? Lemoyne and the desert part of New Austin are decently far apart man

[@fightingtothepoint4u732]

Rdr2 backgrounds also look claustrophobic and weird. In rdr1 the backgrounds look so massive and realistic just look at new austin or west elizabeth. You really FEEL like youre there. Rdr2 just looks like a condensed rpg assassins creed world simulation. I also think rdr1 is much more immersive.

[@Particle_Ghost]

Couldn't stand the 2nd game, but I replay the first one about every other year. I also do the same with GTA 4 and Max Pyne 3.

[@coleguitar2233]

Samn

[@stevekaufmann8109]

rdr1 has mexico and zombies like why is this a conversation?

[@glitchy6449]

W video, this honestly needed to be made! I just wanted to add my personal most hated aspect of Rdr 2 which is the wanted system, it's so damn annoying I honestly can't belive they pourposely made it this way!

[@imbuevirtue]

I feel the same way, it’s like the 5 star wanted level from GTA in rdr2 and it takes away from the cowboy feeling rdr 1 has with being an outlaw

[@VinylcoteYT]

Tbh the wanted system can suck, but I think a lot of that comes from a fundamental lack of understanding on the players part and a lack of explaining on Rockstars

[@RebirthRavenIX]

7 Reasons I Like RDR1 Over RDR2: 1. Better Deadeye: John's deadeye is the best deadeye in the series, not only is he FASTER & More ACCURATE than Arthur Morgan, but John Marston in deadeye mode takes 0 Damage from Gunshots, essentially becoming a juggernaut 2. Better Duels: The Duels in RDR1 are significantly better than RDR2 Duels, there were much more duels in RDR1 as well, depending on which difficulty you play at in rdr1, enemies can draw just fast as you and even faster. 3. Better Guns: Obviously the guns in rdr1 are better and one factor is because of the era it takes place, RDR2's time is set in 1899, while RDR1's time is in 1911 and 1914, meaning RDR1 has higher technology & better guns, The guns in rdr1 are also much more consistent in damage and speed, meanwhile the guns in RDR2 will drop damage, accuracy, and speed overtime. 4. Infinite Stamina: In RDR1 John Marston never runs out of stamina and can run forever, RDR2, John and Arthur run out of stamina. 5. Faster Horses: The Horses in RDR1 outrun the horses in RDR2. 6. There is More Action: In rdr1 we simply see more gunfights and battles than RDR2. 7. RDR1 Is A More Realistic (Wild West) Game: While both games are inaccurate in terms of historical wild west events, RDR1 is more realistic in this genre, and looks even more realistic like you're actually closely in the Wild West. RDR2 Should be more realistic due to the fact that the Wild West in History was bigger in 1899 than 1911, The American Frontier Ended in 1912 and RDR1 was still more accurate of a wild western game, though its really still a spaghetti western game.

[@elguitarTom]

The only thing I wished the RDR games had was: - Bullet ballistics (so enemies can' snipe you a mile away) - Proper smoke emitting from the guns and staying longer before they disappear (Warband mods does this well) - More replay value = make a "live in the west mode" where you have to eat, drink and stay warm for surival (could be unlocked afte finishing the game).

[@kaiserwave5977]

Rdr2 boring asf the missions drag out in comparison to the first game

[@Saviour30]

amen

[@sniperwolf111111]

I think one of the biggest problem with rdr2 imo is that everything (as far as missions are concerned, both story and secondary) is hyper scripted. Even the bounty hunting missions are all scripted. “Go here, watch a cutscene, capture the bad guy in a very specific on rails way” rather than giving the player the capacity and free reign to approach the bounty how they would like, e.g sniper the target from long distance, stalk and take them out stealthy etc. free roaming however, hunting, free roam gunfights, are where the game truly shines. Bounty hunters chasing you through the bush as you desperately try to escape. Unfortunately the open world is too bare in my view to keep one entertained for a long time. The missions really needed to be up to the same kind of level and give the player much more agency. Even the gunfights in missions feel completely stale. The ai seems to be wooden and again, on rails, spawning from the same location, taking cover in the same location, standing there shooting like idiots, as opposed to the ai in free roam which is much better during gunfights. Extremely disappointing missed opportunity rdr2 is. Don’t get me wrong, I still enjoyed it first playthrough, cause it was fresh, however the story has zero replayability and even on the first playthrough much of it I found tedious. May as well watch a movie, constantly holds your hand and it’s not even a challenge. Could have at least added a hardcore difficulty mode like the first game did.

[@sniperwolf111111]

Not to mention, the gunplay and physics feels worse than in rdr1. Much worse. Rdr1 nailed it. Like how did they go backwards there… It’s a shooting game set in the Wild West, which at its core revolves around… shorting. They put time and effort into making horse testicles shrink in cold weather (like seriously who gives a shit, stupid gimmick) but the guns and shooting feels like trash 🤨 The one thing they really should’ve nailed… Rockstar really need to fire whoever is responsible for developing the guns/gun sounds. GTA V was laughably bad. Rdr2 isn’t much better, as far as the sounds are concerned at least. Like a multi billion dollar company, how hard is it to take a day trip to a gun range? And hire a small team to give rdr2 a next gen update while you’re at it. No faith in rockstar anymore.

[@sniperwolf111111]

Even cod developers have managed to get guns sounding pretty good now days

[@sniperwolf111111]

The Schofield revolver in rdr2 is laughable

[@sniperwolf111111]

Literally sounds like a Walmart brand Star Trek phaser

[@elguitarTom]

For some weird reason I felt the map in RDR2 was smaller. Perhaps due to wasted space like the snowy hills that you rarely visit again, the huge swamps thare are just boring. They should have had a big desert area instead, and mexico and more variation in the nature. Also that huge like at the end of the map is a waste of space. And yes the RDR1 had better euphoria physics and was just overall fun to play.

[@Loriddian]

I haven't beaten rdr2s campaign and I bought it on release day. I beat rdr 1 in a couple of weeks.

[@Saviour30]

Amen I did finish it but felt like a slog

[@joemamma9998]

The hunting in rdr 2 feels like a game of its own

[@stevekaufmann8109]

and the fishing, i just wish it had more bounty hunts, night watch, cheating in poker and a dlc similar to undead nightmare

[@pegasus4200]

this game is still the goat of rockstar games..

[@ObviouslyKieran]

Funny way of spelling GTA San Andreas...

[@ConmanPlayz]

@@ObviouslyKieranSan Andreas and Rdr1 are the best. Love both

[@MinecraftvsBurnout]

​@Indie_Better_than_AAA At least, Gta San Andreas is better and more realistic than Gta 3 and Gta Vice City. Especially better and realistic than Gta 3. Gta Vice City is still good, though.

[@Yamemame]

rdr2 has a bunch of pointless mechanics that definitely doesnt need, yet the shooting, which is arguably the most important part of the gameplay, it's so half assed, like why???

[@Saviour30]

I agree the hun play feels realistic yet at the same time not, teleportation etc and it doesn’t feel that fun to use

[@Saviour30]

Hope you subscribe and become a wise one ☝️

[@qresind]

100% agree. RDR2 is a chore simulator and it's slow, boring and doesn't work well. I bought the undead nightmare dlc for the first time because a friend recommended me. So I went in without expectations, maybe even negative expactations, becayse it never thought a cowboy/zombie game could be good. But it was absolutely amazing. I understand everyone has their own opinion. But I just can't get over how 99.99 of people go absolutely ape shit about RDR2 even though is sooooooo bad.

[@Saviour30]

100% I’m glad you see it also! And the story is so much more tight in 1! Hope you subscribe brother

[@kevinderuyter749]

I absolutely agree. From the moment the story unfolds, RDR outshines the sequel in so many ways. I believe the sequel is a fantastic game, but it is riddled with countless tedious simulations. I wanted to love RDR2, but I stopped playing it because it is, beyond question, nerve wracking.

[@theoneeyedghoulofdreams1557]

Rdr2 is like watching paint dry! I love it but ye Rdr 1 is still amazing

[@Ravvox]

Watching paint dry sure is boring but the final painting is a masterpiece

[@dapper120]

you just have a low attention span

[@shamar5673]

@@dapper120 nah the game is boring

[@coleguitar2233]

@@dapper120riding on a horse for 3 hours then it randomly dies and you’re stuck ?

[@dapper120]

@@coleguitar2233 get better at the game? 😀

[@DeadnotAlive]

I get so much crap for saying RDR1 is better and that I like John more than Arthur like bro half the ppl giving me hate weren’t even a concept in their daddy’s ballsack when I first played Red Dead I actually bought the game on PC and I gotta say 9/10 port there are minor bugs that are barely noticeable but they don’t ruin the gameplay and that’s what matters I think the thing I missed the most was the dialogue like bro imagine your being a badass and John just yells out (you couldn’t shoot a fart out of your own a**) Arthur is just like eh ooo ahh aka (NOTHING) oh and the ambiance is insane I’m a music nerd don’t even like country and I think it’s the greatest soundtrack next to cyberpunk 2077 and Halo

[@chaos4reason97]

my fav part about rdr1, is when you get into a fgiht, either with the cops, or with a gang. and you hear the signature american venom theme play, it genuinely made me feel like a badass cowboy

[@Darkmiss7078]

The very reason that the immersion in RDR2 is so good is because almost every single action that the characters can do is fully animated to look real, the world is full of life, from people to the smallest bugs, all of them have something to do and somewhere to go, and (in my opinion) RDR2 has THE most immersive and realistic world ever created, and on top of that fantastic script writing, voice acting and story. RDR was a great game too and still one of my favorit games. But RDR2 took it to another level, that so far (for me ) no other game has been able to match.

[@Saviour30]

Ye the world is amazing but that doesn’t make it a good game

[@Raresttooth]

@@Saviour30 Bro what, the game world is a huge factor on determining how good a game is. I still have not seen any game match it. The game world in rdr2 solos almost all games from 2018 to 2023

[@k.t.1641]

Funny, the reasons that made you love it made me annoyed. Rdr2 is a good SIM, but not a good "game". Rdr 1 had just the right about of both. I dont hate rdr2 at all, I just dont think of it as a ""game"".

[@bellaollie2037]

@@Raresttooth play the 1st game & prepare to have a much better time

[@stevekaufmann8109]

yea rdr2 is a damn near perfect game but rdr1 is so much funner because it has mexico and undead nightmare. It's a damn shame that rockstar forgot about rdr2.

[@markpoland5748]

Man your the type a guy I'd share a bottle with, this game is alot better I get the whole cinematic stuff because that's when a game is not a game, because it's borderline real and games aren't ment too be real, hence the word Game. Your on the money on this one I hate the let's make a game with real actors let's make the game a film but you can interact with it. Love everything you said made alot of sense and it's a pity younger gamers are getting sucked into the all frills games, as I said loved you're take on the game would like to hear more, stay safe and well pal...

[@Saviour30]

Hey man thanks so much for the kind comment, means more than you know. Dealing with some bad anxiety right now and pushing myself to make more videos so I appreciate you enjoyed it. Hope you join the community and watch more of my stuff ^^ and yes I’m glad you share my pov also, haha games are getting more and more popular and focused on trying to replicate other traditional media… very sad. But still we have double A games! And if you want to support me as I’ve recently decided to try go full time and quit my job, feel free to sling me a virtual beer as a thanks 🙏 but no pressure your support is already appreciated

[@SnakePlissy]

Threw a subscribe cuz you’re preaching to my soul with this point at 5:15 . I found RD2 far too painful which is a crying shame considering how beautiful it is & the potential. I’ve played RD1 literally over a dozen times lol one of my favs of all time but ya RD2 can’t get through a third still 😅

[@jazsebastian]

Hey brother you smashing it!! Sent ya a little howdy do on the FB, I know you busy AF, same here. It's literally the wild west. Chat soon. I hope. :p

[@JariCstr]

RDR1 Online is definitely better than RDR2 online, especially the ability to have private lobby and character/ mount unlockings. great vid btw cheers!

[@epicmusichub]

happy new year, can't wait for what you'll bring in 2024!

[@thebatmandc777]

Another thing I would say is that RDR1 has different gangs or factions which makes it feel like you’re not the only outlaw. Like RDR2 you have the o’driscolls but that’s it. Whereas in the first game you got Waltons gang, the miners, bollard twins, bandit os etc. plus they all randomly will ride in posses and shoot up the towns too lol

[@Saviour30]

glad you can see it! hope you sub my dude

[@mz3329]

I just replayed RDR1 in Switch and couldnt agree more. Ich liked RDR2 but Part 1 is way more fun.

[@Saviour30]

amen bro hope you sub

[@pablorodrigues1670]

Thanks! I couldn't agree more. I really like RDR2, Arthur is an amazing character, but RDR1 feel special. More fun, better soundtrack, the atmosphere...

[@eagleyezxgaming]

I think the ending of RDR1 is one of the best endings in all of gaming.

[@Saviour30]

Yes it made me cry haha can’t even say that I was shamed, hope your subscribed here bro

[@AngelMerus]

I agree with you rdr 1 is superior to rdr2 gameplay wise on online modes imo I've jad rdr 1 since I was 10 it is worthy of game of the year and undead nightmare was elite I would spend hrs playing it

[@saviour3.0Clips]

I should make it clear but I do say this in the video! Rdr2 is a good game and it’s amazing because of its world and technology but it’s not as good as a game

[@Cokeastur]

Clearly you haven't understood neither RDR1 nor RDR2 and that's why you won't understand RDR3. First of all RDR2 is what Take Two wanted to do with RDR1 but couldn't. That said, RDR2 is set in 1899, the end of the cowboy and outlaws era, and RDR1 is set in 1910, where cowboys didn't exist anymore, so keep that in mind because that alone just blows your argument. And it's ok, is just your opinion, I've enjoyed both games (I'm 11 years older than you) I guess I have a different understanding on what story video games are. Anyways, good to know your opinion, is just that. Give another try to RDR2 and try feel the different era

[@samarvir126]

Rdr1 is set in 1911 and rdr1 still felt more like a western. Rdr2 was full of filler

[@thebatman5852]

I respect your opinion but i highly prefer red dead redemption 2 im in my 6th playthrought and never get tired of it

[@frostwage6044]

so let me get this straight you played a realistic game and hated the fact that it's realistic? if you love arcade games so much then go play an arcade game. you kept saying it feels and it looks and it sounds better but you never actually gave any reasons. and more things to do really the game takes about double or tribble to finish. there is a reason that over 90% of the people that played both games say that rdr2 is way better and consider rdr2 to be the best game ever made.

[@KNAFHLCJPT7A8EU3]

I think both are masterpieces and there aint one better than the other

[@iustin-gabrielcostache]

Please answer me how did you drive a boat in rdr1, this was 13min and 7secs in the video?

[@Saviour30]

Hey sorry it’s mods :) hope you subscribe brother

[@iustin-gabrielcostache]

Oh thanks

[@bhuwanshah3215]

It’s fine you didn’t like rdr2. That’s your opinion but that doesn’t make rdr2 a bad game. The things you got annoyed with are the things that actually made rdr2 a great game and it is a great game. I just bought rdr1 and it is no way near rdr2. In fact Understandable since rdr1 is a 2010 game.

[@Joe_Kerr_9797]

I like RDR2 but I prefer RDR1 more, it's a lot more fun and replayble and has more of a western feel to it, most RDR2 fanboys seems like they can't handle someone having a different opinion and they get mad about it.

[@TomeOfKnowledge74]

I think you might be missing the point of the "slow" gameplay of RDR2. It gives the perception of the slower days of the "Wild West", by forcing you to slow down and just appreciate how things were done. Many younger players just want action all the time, and don't know how to just relax and enjoy.

[@Saviour30]

I’m 26 so not a TikTok bot… I just felt like it was wasting my time. But you enjoy what you love that’s the point of the video! :) just giving my human perspective on this

[@eddiebhoy6754]

Not played rdr and just finished rdr2 .after playing rdr2 is it worth playing rdr

[@Saviour30]

10000% yes sir and also hope you subscribe

[@eddiebhoy6754]

@Saviour30 download it just now then and give it a go

[@pegasus4200]

yep 100% real truth..

[@Copperbollex]

You’ve been blinded by nostalgia my friend

[@Dankehum]

Just how GTA 4 is years ahead of V

[@Saviour30]

Physics

[@Alduin3914]

I did love rdr 2 story but it makes me rage, I hate the contrls with a boling hate passion and the fream roam is boring and emty, Rdr 1 is 10000% better. But I rather play skyrim.

[@Ghostcoast1]

John's death at the end of rdr1 is badass and Arthur goes out like a wimpy little b****.

[@Saviour30]

Yes I agree the showdown at the end is tragic but awesome protecting his family! Hope you sub my bro

[@siwe_wiwegaming5540]

Arthur dies of fucking tuberculosis and in some cases getting shot in the head after helping john to safety, the events of rdr1 would not have even happened if not for Arthurs sacrifice

[@youngtrout4950]

Red Dead Redemption 2 looks nice and is very detailed but honestly it gets boring very quickly, especially in free roam. There's just not that much to do besides look at the world, and that gets old fast. It's not even a game that I want to replay. I can't give it more than a 7/10 even at its best moments. Red Dead Redemption 1 on the other hand is actually fun in free roam because it's more similar to GTA in gun-play and general mechanics. RDR2 is just too simulator-y for its own good in my honest opinion. Yeah it's a good game, but I honestly don't even know if I would recommend it. There are other games to play that are a lot more fun.

[@mattyboi070707]

Why can’t we have and appreciate “movie games” and think they are awsome and fun and impressive for what they are as well as appreciating everything else? I love getting lost in an RPG and building a character, but I also adore just swinging around as Spiderman too. I don’t think you have to put one thing down to lift another up.

[@bhuwanshah3215]

Exactly, I agree. This guy doesn’t understand what games can be I guess.

[@mattyboi070707]

I disagree about there being more varied random encounters. I played 1 recently and I had the same guy come and ask me to save his buddy who was about to be hanged about 20 times. Not a complaint, it is fun, but it’s definitely not more varied.

[@Darkmiss7078]

I don't agree at all, People that find RDR2 too slow are more of an instant gratification, want things to happen NOW! instantly and magickly. RDR2 is a masterpiece of realism, and made to reflect realism as close as possible for a game, go back to Call of duty or other instant gratification games and leave RDR2's mechanics and simulation alone.

[@Saviour30]

Completely disagree, as a stoic I don’t care about instant gratification and I don’t use platforms to give me that dopamine rush. I’m very mindful about what I take in. However when I’m playing a game I want to feel immersed and this “ realism “ you speak of pulls me out of the experience as it’s not consistent or fun in my view in the media format which is a video game 🎮

[@shawnbyers6947]

I actually think a lot of people play video games for instant gratification and escapism. They want to become powerhouse characters impossible in real life society and do things that would otherwise have varying real-life consequences. If you want realism and feeling true satisfaction, go outside. Stop playing video games and experience our beautiful planet Earth. Go contribute to society and do good deeds. There is a fine line between fun and realism in video games and imo, RDR2 borders on simulation when most casual players are coming from the zanny, arcade fun that is GTA V. We don't need chores and metres to manage in our Rockstar titles. We just want to blow sh*t up and have an epic narrative 😎 👏. Oh, and not to mention to escape our real life expectations and responsibilities for a period of time.

[@Darkmiss7078]

@@shawnbyers6947 This is very true, and I play some games like that myself, but not all games have to be that way, and shouldn't be criticised for being different.

[@WhiteBoyEvil]

RDR1 is western game. RDR2 is just more east. Both are masterpieces

[@partlycloudy9443]

I absolutely love RDR1 and RDR2, But the immersion in RDR2 is far better. I can spend hours just free roaming in RDR2, and I actually feel like im in the world. RDR1 feels like im playing a game, RDR2 feels like an experience. RDR1s world is just empty feeling by comparison. Although, I do like the ragdoll mechanics when killing npcs in RDR1 better.

[@stevekaufmann8109]

i feel the opposite rdr2 is just so big that it doesn't have enough encounters to keep me highly entertained. Riding your horse through the woods with little interaction gets so mundane. The unlimited bounties, mexico, undead nightmare etc... in rdr1 gave it so much replay ability.

[@bhuwanshah3215]

Ikr what is this guy talking about 😂 Rdr2 world immersion is unbelievable and unbeatable.

[@Aldourquizatirado]

Why is this guy so aggressive about it, I love both of the games and I understand what he is saying but he's so aggressive

[@Saviour30]

What? No I wasn’t love whatever you want I think you misunderstood passion for being aggressive

[@siwe_wiwegaming5540]

RDR2 is trying to tell a story and all components are attempting to achieve that goal if you cant see that im sorry for you

[@merkjalanan966]

if you ever played death stranding, you probably won't like it too.

[@bellaollie2037]

twas a good video - keep speaking the truth

[@funky0308]

But mate, in 18min video you are wasting 4min to subscribe and check my other things nonsense. Come on, let's go into this topic. BTW, I tried to watch video, comment and be part of this you should work on you amd your videos, sorry but to have so many adds in 18min video (that's something you are allowing in your video or not - for those who don't know that), and you really pump video with adds.. it's barley watchable. You are right about RDR2 but you should make videos without rambling for a 5min about nothing and without million adds in a few minutes video

[@Saviour30]

You are 100 right aout my intro being way too long I am working on that now moving foward! And sadly I need ads as I am trying to pay my bills with this and I get almsot zero fan funding so what else can I do

[@iitbftw]

It's definietly nostalgia. I am currently playing through RDR1 after beating RDR2 and it's a fucking chore. There is 0 incentive from the game to go explore, hunt and do bounties unlike RDR2. Being unable to swim and instantly dying when going in to waist high water is fucking insane (Yes, I know John can't swim in RDR2 as well). Got to finish the story before comparing that component but RDR1's gameplay is no better than RDR2 in anyway. In RDR2, it's paced slowly and gives you time to explore. RDR1 feels like a race to find Bill and kill him.

[@Saviour30]

That’s your opinion. I’m replying it now and it’s even better than I remembered! Also now 60fps and 4K so looks amazing. I love everything about it way more, especially the tone. But that was the point of the video, enjoy what you enjoy friend

[@Euruk1]

It's not nostalgia. Game has a special charm.

[@samarvir126]

Rdr2 is a chore not rdr1 lol. There is also no need to swim in rdr1. Not everyone likes slow ass games like rdr2 and people prefer games full of action like rdr1

[@stevekaufmann8109]

bro it's literally the opposite. like what?

[@sulista4855]

Try playing RDR2 without auto aim, you'll rather die.

[@Skylark241]

Bro i’ve played both 1 and 2 And I’m being honest, rdr 2 was way better than 1

[@bhuwanshah3215]

Because rdr2 is better

[@endercreeperdan]

Both games are great but the story of rdr1 is kinda boring at the beginning

[@samarvir126]

Same with rdr2 but they both get better the more u play through the story

[@kaiserwave5977]

You acting like the prologue in the second game doesn’t take 2 hours to get through

[@stevekaufmann8109]

@@kaiserwave5977it took me 3 hours

[@Yamemame]

Rdr2 is just boring in general

[@Darren-sn4ki]

No RDR2 is better then 1

[@RebirthRavenIX]

rdr1 better

[@CapinCrunch]

GTA IV > GTA V The Witcher 2 > The Witcher 3

[@thekshark3987]

Yeah but the Witcher 3 is WAYYY better than 2

[@iustin-gabrielcostache]

Please answer my question

[@29mbj62]

Keep dreaming

[@Saviour30]

well I think so that's the point

[@pegasus4200]

haha remember this is the internet @@Saviour30

[@theoneeyedghoulofdreams1557]

Rdr 2 is good but like watching paint dry

[@ProdigalSui]

L take. Gameplay alone makes rdr2 leagues better than 1 lol

[@KingGamer-oj7hn]

No RDR2 Is BETTER Than RDR1

[@longerkonger1757]

No there both equal and masterpieces

[@theharwoodbutcher70]

RDR1 was way more fun

[@AndrusKungla]

​@@theharwoodbutcher70exactly!

[@ConmanPlayz]

Rdr1 is way better and fun. Rdr2 is just boring

[@ConmanPlayz]

Don’t tell me I don’t know rdr lore. Played it ever since 2013

[@funky0308]

Playing RDR1 right now and for now only I can say - it's old game, nothing special, Rockstar copied many things from RDR to RDR2,, especially from the beginning of the story and put that to RDR2. There are so many similar things and stories in both games. I'm PC gamer so I never had a chance to olay RDR1, I'll play it and we'll see which one is better but yeah, RDR2 is overrated, that's for sure, we'll see how will RDR be. For now, first few hrs - nothing special. it's raw amd odd but OK, it's 14 year old game. We'll see

[@syntax276]

RDR 1 is ass

[@samarvir126]

L statement lol

[@MinecraftvsBurnout]

Wrong, my friend.

[@crazycowpoke]

I love both. But RDR1 is more fun and action packed.