Red Dead Redemption game review

[@Pongus_420]

Here because we're coming up on 2 years and he hasn't reviewed the sequel

[@RatedRoeh]

its 2023 and im still waiting for his review :((

[@kalaichelvan]

why?@@RatedRoeh

[@ruan6244]

2024... Not happening

[@rbleaks818]

Red Dead Redemption 2 anyone?

[@poppysgtspanky]

richard chan yep

[@kaidraoe7044]

ye..

[@CB-qg3yh]

richard chan you mean red dead 3!!!

[@AlejandroGonzalez-gh1to]

richard Lai even though it's a prequel

[@SergioSanchez-ig4uj]

yessir

[@RedSoxFan701]

To this day, Red Dead Redemption is my favorite video game of all time. Anyone who is thinking about getting this game should buy it as soon as possible. You won't regret it.

[@mathewfox7292]

no buy game of the year edition even better

[@Darkpara1]

It's amazeballs. I kept my Xbox 360 just to play it now and then for nostalgia. I really hope they give us a new one sometime soon.

[@scottianson5133]

It's still great in 2022. I like it more than the sequel.

[@MarcSisco]

RDR will go down in history.

[@Spinosaurus1231]

Red Dead Redemption is my favorite game of all time.

[@maxammo357]

I can see why.

[@dayburks]

maxammo357 fr tho

[@lilkenprez205]

Just play the sequel bro

[@micahtandy4222]

Wait until the year 2018

[@CapableFlawless]

Spinosaurus1231 have you played red dead 2?

[@vincentnguyen1995]

My favorite open world game is still Red Dead Redemption and favorite western is The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly.

[@cardiacade]

Same as!

[@trigunnn2]

i cried a little after i read you comment because i completely agree =)

[@trigunnn2]

ehhh

[@jacobluden3903]

My favorite western game is always going to be Gun for the PS2

[@classicps2games984]

Jacob Luden That game was awful

[@ryancox9281]

Red Dead Redemption is probably my favorite video game.

[@jamesagradi6820]

I’d love to see an RDR2 review

[@ikeonabike1419]

I wonder why he hasn’t reviewed it yet.

[@joker18524]

@@ikeonabike1419 idk what video it was but he talked shit about it briefly saying it was too much work or something

[@spawncampe]

@@joker18524 any idea which video it was?

[@StraightEdgeKnight19]

@@spawncampe he didn’t talk shit about it but he briefly talked about it in his Resident Evil 2 Remake review

[@brobro9169]

@@joker18524he didn’t talk shit abt it, he just sed it was very time consuming and didn’t have time to finish it

[@michaelnally2841]

My favorite game of all time. Now I think the town Jeremy was talking about was thieves landing since he wasn't wanted. And yeah that's my favorite place in the game. My biggest gripe and this is being super nitpickey. I wish I could challenge people to showdowns. I wanna be like. "Hey you you piece of shit! I don't like the way you look at me so I'm gonna blow your face off!" Come on raise your hand if you'd wanna as well.

[@ConquerorofallZombie]

I found the farmer portion of the game worked really well for the story and Marston's character. One of the best parts of the game IMO.

[@davenic2471]

+ConquerorofallZombie I hated the intro farm part but the one at the end is great.

[@alexh.5462]

Was it just me or did John Marston meet Satan in that Stanger Mission titled "I Know You"? I swear that guy was the devil, just the way he talked and all of the innuendos and vagueness to his speech also the fact John shot him in the back and he didn't die. And don't tell me John missed. The only way he could miss anything was with either holy or unholy intervention.

[@horscraft4604]

Thank you for confirming I'm not the only one who thinks this! I was thinking he was some kind of phantom or some sort of demon.

[@kduffin33]

Scott Hawkins haha i felt the same ….was sketched out by him so i hog tied him and threw him off the cliff

[@alexh.5462]

I know he was freaking creepy in his snakes well worded phrases! ReWatch the missions on KZbin and put his comments in the prespective of him being the Devil! I looked it up and it seem everyone one has an opinion of who he is whether he is God, Death, Satan, a minor-demon, a relative or friend he has forgotten cause if you look around John's house you see pictures of him for some weird reason. Rockstar will not confirm nor deny who or what the Stranger is and I think that is on purpose, kinda fun to keep it a mystery too huh:)?!!!

[@kobebonhomme7037]

if i had not missed this quest, i probs would've done something similar to kduffin33 although to suit my style, put him on train tracks. i believe the guy to be death so putting him in a predicament that almost (but hardly ever) ends in death would be fitting for a wild west game.

[@tommycipriani2254]

I think the man in black was God, I doubt it was the devil.

[@markostamenkovic8350]

7th gen gave us the best pirate game and the best western game (and both some of the best games overall). Red Dead Redemption (GTA in wild west, but also a lot more than that) and Assasin's Creed IV: Black Flag (Sid Meier's Pirates! on steroids with parkour added in). Both of these are straight up amazing, and i don't understand why developers don't tackle these subjects more often, they are really rarely made.

[@josh.0220]

why does everyone just play black flag

[@farldiemanie8775]

+Joshua Hurd it's the best

[@josh.0220]

Farldie Manie so you haven't played Brotherhood?

[@farldiemanie8775]

Joshua Hurd I think 4 is better

[@josh.0220]

Farldie Manie you're allowed to but it's not

[@72Kraken]

am I the only one still waiting for the remastered version?

[@WallyHolland]

I heard that they're announcing it at E3, but I've also heard a lot of similar stories in the past

[@SonGoku-hr5kz]

I want a remaster,and a sequal. BUT I WANT IT ON PC!.

[@hhaidar121]

I'd be disappointed if they remastered it instead of releasing a sequel/prequel.

[@Dreadpirateflappy]

It is false, Rockstar have never been at E3 and were not due to be there this year.

[@culumminto1217]

They just made it backwards compatible on Xbox today lol

[@purgejmi]

Never saw a Jeremy Jahns RDR2 review pop up in my Notifications... Still playing? :D

[@fonziegoebel6114]

Rockstar should definitely make a medieval game!

[@samuraibarvidessays]

Review the second one, Jeremy. That would be awesome

[@seeonaga1524]

Still haven't reviewed red dead redemption 2.

[@DoverDaniel]

"HEY you left me for dead?!... Well, that's not nice, im gonna call 911"HAHAHAHAASUHUAUHSAHUASUHUSHASUHA

[@All4Randomness1]

what

[@ILoveAnime1121]

My favorite western is the True Grit reboot.

[@mid_life_crisis13]

Considering it took about three years for you to review RdR 1, do we have to wait 18 months for RDR2 review? I thought maybe you didn’t like it, and since it got incredible reviews elsewhere, you didn’t feel it necessary to do a review. But, after watching your rdr1 review, again all these years later, and hearing some of things you liked about it, I don’t imagine you disliked RDR2. I’m stumped. BTW, I think your rdr1 review was the first video from your channel I ever watched and I subbed immediately. So there’s that.

[@MeesTW]

My favorite westerns are The Outlaw Josey Wales, The Searchers, The Good, The Bad and The Ugly and Once Upon A Time In The West. My favorite open world games are Red Dead Redemption, The Witcher 3, GTAV and Elder Scrolls IV Oblivion.

[@modvind]

Remove GTA and replace Oblivion with Skyrim and that's me

[@EpicMrbilly]

Imposter

[@MeesTW]

Halowars10232 nothin personal kid

[@frostb1041]

What about Tombstone?

[@jakelonergan8313]

+Mees dawn rider, OUTLAW, purgatory, 3:10 to Yuma and true grit 2010

[@KennethEspericueta340]

2016 and still best game ever

[@kennethespericueta1366]

Yeah

[@youngknight5589]

I'd love if they make a medieval game

[@modvind]

I like The Witcher 3 more but RDR is definitly a close second

[@metalmat3651]

I'll give Vice City #1 but this get's #2

[@tuxic263]

eh,Id give it 8/10,Doesn't give you much for being an outlaw,too easy,Buggy as hell(like not being able to rob someone,people who you lasso freeze,getting on a moving train and getting transported to outer space),framerate was a bit choppy at times,and had like 1-2 times where it "froze", you can't rob shops for the money in the cash register,and stealth is probably the worst ive seen in any game.I literally got caught behind the wall of a town when the police was on the other part of the town.And if you're big on stealth like me,It's going to piss you off,and checkpoints when you die on the open world can be hella frustrating.But decent game,Still havent finished it though

[@anirudhmenon4234]

I discovered this gem only this year. What a beautiful game. Now, my list of favourite open world games are as follows: 1. Red Dead Redemption 2. GTA V (I don't care what anyone anyone says, but I didn't spend 100 hours on this game because it sucked, i spent it because I enjoyed every damn moment of it) 3. Assassin's Creed II 4. Spider-Man 2 5. Assassin's Creed IV : Black Flag

[@tyspyranger]

Damn good list sir.

[@theinsanitygamers007]

great list i didn't really like red dead redemption when i first played it i kinda stopped(because i was young and stupid) but im going to play it again i just know its going to be awesome now.

[@AaroNinjaJones195]

theinsanitygamers007 i had the same experience, i bought the game on release and just kinda lost interest. I then recently went back and finished and was like wtf was i thinking haha.

[@juanoro-barcenas79495]

My Top 5 1. Sleeping Dogs 2. Red Dead Redemption 3. Mad Max 4. Assassin's Creed IV Black Flag 5. Saints Row IV

[@NoWhereMan95]

Riding into Mexico for the first time with the song “Far away” playing in the background is one of the greatest moments in videogame history.

[@sdbo7102]

Red Dead Redemption, Halo CE, & Shenmue are my favorite games of all time.

[@Flipyap42]

Great list

[@EAchank]

Sheamue was fun for its time for sure I hope 3 comes out and 2 gets a re release with better controls

[@レッド-h1i]

We have the same taste.

[@ppjeje929]

Still haven’t done red dead 2. I would love that.

[@marstopia8992]

For me this game has one of the defining moments of video game history. When you finally get off that boat after you reached Mexico, get on your horse and then "Far Away" by Jose Gonzales suddenly starts playing. That's like the moment you get out of the vault for the first time in Fallout 3, the sun blends and you are seeing the wastelands for the first time. Such moments I will always remember.

[@solidsnake9898]

Definitely better than GTA V!

[@jpk9902]

+Solid Snake Such a Hayter

[@theawesomeguy5754]

Much David

[@mryolo1523]

I definitely agree. GTA is an overrated piece of crap

[@HassanMohamoud-lg2xw]

+Solid Snake story yes the rest NO

[@Noobelli]

+Mohamoud Hassan In the multiplayer it was way more fun before it got completely broken.

[@brianstatz7840]

Waiting for the RDR 2 review now! :)

[@TJ_ax]

5 years and Jeremy still hasn’t reviewed Red Dead 2. Smh

[@fwzm.158]

Jeremy how about Red dead redemption 2 review

[@SpiderandMosquito]

An old cowboy went ridin out one dark and windy day Upon a ridge he rested as he went along his way When all at once a mighty herd of red-eyed cows he saw Plowin through the ragid skies and up a cloudy draw Their brands were still on fire and their hooves were made of steel Their horns were black and shiny and their hot breath he could feel A bolt of fear went through him as they thundered through the sky For he saw the riders comin hard and he heard their mournful cries Yippie i ohhh ohh ohh Yippie i aye ye ye Ghost riders in the sky Their faces gaunt, their eyes were blurred Their shirts all soaked with sweat He's ridin hard to catch that herd But he aint caught em yet Cause they got to ride forever in that range up in the sky On horses snortin fire as they ride on hear their cries As the riders loped on by him he heard one call his name 'if you wanna save your soul from hell a-ridin on our range Then cowboy change your ways today or with us you will ride Tryin to catch the devil's herd across these endless skies Yippie i ohhh oh oh Yippie i aye ye ye Ghost riders in the sky Ghost riders in the sky Ghost riders in the sky

[@HarleyD1991]

+Christian Schmude Ghost Riders in the sky. amazing song. Love the Outlaws version best.

[@douglasmonroe7417]

Johnny cash was the one to make that song famous. No one could top his version of that song.

[@LucasFeniks]

Red Dead Redemption 2 was the only game that I ever broke my own policy against pre-ordering a game.

[@rybrentmannftw]

red dead redemption is definitely the best western game. As for western movies, The good the bad and the ugly and once upon a time in the west.

[@tonygmichael6434]

Dude....Jeremy,it's about that time,RD2 review if you have indeed played it. It's a monsterous hole in your gaming review section. But I guess...'That's the way it is" Just finished it myself for the first time..It was an experience to put it mildly..What a game~!!

[@chiyosake]

I'ts December 3, 2020! Where was the review for Red Dead Redemption 2?!

[@gleam6370]

He said he never finished it :/

[@AramisHall]

Wait a minute!! Great Johnny "Drama" reference! I applaud you sir. I kinda feel like I'm the only one who appreciates that.

[@MrLongduckdoong]

Aramis Hall Listen to TOM LEYKIS!!!

[@kingcharles69]

This game CRUSHS GTA.

[@Ghaffar_KH]

It rapes it.

[@kingcharles69]

Not funny...

[@davidvanau3182]

+King Charles Yeah, it is.

[@al112v4]

I am a huge GTA die hard fan and I agree. This game beats the shit out of GTA V. The old western time works even more perfect than modern time for Rockstar.

[@JonDials]

*crushes

[@michaelcoffey1991]

Red Dead Redemption man that ending :/........... just an amazing amount of content with damn near endless side quests and bounty's. True amazing game, high hopes for the next game in the series.

[@52icon]

Jeremy. How about a RDR2 review??

[@waubadoo]

I'm still wondering why he didn't review Red Dead Redemption 2

[@esco5593]

2:12 I had my computer volume at 80% (as always) and had the video volume all the way up with my high quality headphones, and at the first, "BAM" I paused the video instantly because I literally thought the background gun sound was somebody getting shot in the street right out of my window. Wow

[@whalewaffle2771]

An instant classic from this decade, yes sir...

[@midwaynights]

Where is your red dead 2 review dude??

[@monkeyboy9931]

Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion. Classic game and some of the best video game music ever. Now I just have a craving to go play that game :D

[@izetyusein3323]

Red Dead Redemption is one of my favorite PS3 games of all of time and The Last of Us

[@danielandres1579]

Same here! 😎🙏

[@kam2840]

I think they introduced the advanced guns mostly because Red Dead Redemption is all about the death of the wild west. That's why towards the end of the game we're introduced to automobiles and modern day guns. Plus at the end of the game, if you buy a newspaper, it says that War has concluded in Europe which means it's at 1918 and that time we pretty much had planes already.

[@bennolaaa]

Jason Connors the war broke out in 1914 but yeah, good point.

[@DiVi00027]

I hope to see you do rdr2 review one day. Greatest gaming experience of my life. And one of the best storylines I've ever seen in any media or books

[@adalbertosanchez14]

Rdr 2 review we need it

[@GoldenMrobbie]

Red Dead Redemption, Django Unchained, Good bad and the ugly, hatefull eight, is the shit

[@MolotovVids]

whens he gonna review rdr2

[@Jaydot34.]

I've had this in my games collection for years but started playing it again yesterday for like 8 hours 👍 this game is off the hook easily one of the greatest open world games👊💯 as soon as I get home I'm playing the shite out of it some more 👊💯👊💯

[@D3D3D]

I'm defenitely gonna buy this one!

[@farldiemanie8775]

You should've bought it back in 2010

[@karlmcdonald9720]

You can still buy it now though and still think it's great cause it's amazing

[@TheNatureboy64]

Speaking for myself (an admitted western fanatic), Red Dead Redemption is the Greatest Open World RPG ever made on every level. The dialogue is actually interesting (unlike so many RPGs) and well thought out. The gameplay includes every nuance of life in the Old West life and battles, including even hunting, (too many animals to name here),sharpshooting and so much more. Most hours of fun I've ever had playing any game hands down pardner! And you can play it in multiplayer which it is extremely suited too also! Not perfect but close as it gets.

[@E-Chap]

Agreed man, I want a ps4/xbox one sequel

[@LUNITICWILL]

Red Dead Redemption is a MASTERPIECE. it may have flaws but it did it's genre justice.

[@spycheck]

Where’s your red dead redemption 2 review?

[@Phoenix1121212]

Watching this while taking a break after playing RDR2 for the last 5 hours :)

[@pabloriveroshachette1693]

Too bad Arthur doesn't appear on red dead 1, kinda tells you what happens to him in rdr2

[@teagonbarry7838]

dude legend of the west outfit is the best just saying

[@sals6671]

Agreed

[@deadambitions5786]

Th duster and poncho are cool

[@michelle2754]

yeah took awhile to get it and is by 2nd favorite outfit..number 1 is deadly assassin

[@johndawson3494]

Without a doubt my favorite video game of all time. An instant classic, video games don't get much better than this.

[@mrsmile9221]

I'm going to buy this game, but should I buy the game of the year edition or not? It's like 5 bucks more (not that big of a difference, I know, but is it even different from the normal version?). Would be very thankful for an answer. :)

[@Tinog393]

Mr Smile get the Game of the Year Edition Edition it comes with adlc story and more content

[@brycecrane2569]

still pissed you never reviewed rdr2

[@mrmoviemanic1]

"Your hands upon a deadman's gun and you're looking down the sights, your heart is worn, and the seams are torn, and they've given you reason to fight"

[@VcLegacymy_own_url]

I luv this game so much. The ending broke my heart

[@Donnie1428]

Mine to :0, it kinda sucked though because i read about it in a KZbin Comment before actually finishing the Game myself -_-

[@delusionalcanucksfan6424]

I wish they released a 2nd one 😩

[@CastleBravo17]

the GOAT .......but they did

[@alexh.5462]

Btw Once Upon a Time in the West is one of the best Westerns out there. That ending is Badass!!!

[@xRsAtx]

Mafia 2

[@xXxXKusKusXxXx]

Open world game? I would say Dark Souls but since the world in Dark Souls is not exactly open it's more like areas and tunnels connected together (which is great and has a great design) then I will go with Skyrim.

[@Dunga2Dunga]

I don't count games like GTA RDR in same category as skyrim/darksouls yes there both open world but they are so vastly different skyrim is a more no limits literal do what ever you want in a fantasy setting as GTA/RDR is a more Realism cinematic open world. I know some people will be like well there both open world so there the same. To me at least there not. But ya for me best open world RPG: Skyrim, I love dark souls just like you pumped for DS2 but like u said skyrim is definitely more open world no limits then DS. Open World action game: Red Dead Redemption. I love GTA 5 and IMO overall best GTA to date but RDR was so amazing to me and my friends. The story was rockstars best story, best online (I know Gta online has more to do but, overall I got bored of GTA 5 online quicker then I did RDR and even GTA 4's. Even though GTA online has most content) I just loved the gambling in the game and online if Gta 5 adds that all be so happy. Of course this is all my opinion.

[@FiveFingerOutfit]

DungaDunga those are rpgs...gta rdr arent rpgs...that would be why they're not in the same category...

[@stormymonday9312]

4:17 I love you for that Firefly reference.

[@kane666]

was my no1 best game of last decade until the last of us

[@tanner6184]

I lose more respect for this channel every single day he fails to review Red Dead Redemption 2

[@KingSciarrillo]

I was hoping you reviewed this...awesome!

[@michaelnally2841]

Am I the only one who thinks this game could work as a great tv series?

[@luke.hillis7634]

Michael Nally west world

[@Whiskerscatrabit1996]

The poncho outfit is better.

[@mordirit8727]

Because nobody say shit to your mule when you wear that outfit. My mule is very sensitive.

[@AWoundedEagle]

Love your comment about only using revolvers. Totally relate to that.

[@thomasm3100]

I want Jeremy to review RDR2

[@Cyrusrm7]

Surely he would have done it by now, Maybe he had a very unpopular opinion and feared the Backlash😀

[@gleam6370]

@@Cyrusrm7 no. He said it was too long, And he never finished it

[@Cyrusrm7]

@@gleam6370 So he probably didn't like it that much if he felt bored in the middle of the story and didn't finish it.

[@gleam6370]

@@Cyrusrm7 yea, It’s disappointing. I absolutely loved the game. It’s a commendable tribute to the first rdr

[@Cyrusrm7]

@@gleam6370 So when and where he said that he didn't finish it?

[@AivarPC]

Oh my gentle Jesus, this is the best game ever!

[@thisjustincomics]

Ikr

[@TheRedman790]

Favorite open world game? ...Tie. Red Dead Redemption. Grand Theft Auto Vice City. Thank you Rockstar. Now ..RDR 2? Take my money. Take it all!

[@chrislappe7241]

Do red dead redemption 2!

[@ziggyzig64]

Red dead Redemption 2 review please.

[@purgejmi]

RDR2 was an amazing story, the best western story ever told imo, had some beautiful moments and left me horrified and shocked at the end of the main story before the epilogue. Maybe your ending was better, but my version of Arthur was an evil guy so I got the bad ending lol.

[@JokerWalkthroughs]

please review watch dogs

[@Icebergslim91]

This guy trying to be funny or something?

[@gunpoint1687]

Yes. He succeeded.

[@Icebergslim91]

Joshua Hoban I don't mean this as a insult but are you 12?

[@DanishKhanIITB]

don't know.... are you??

[@chriswestergaard4506]

Are you trying to sound tough, small fry?

[@gunpoint1687]

As a matter of fact yes, I am twelve. Now does that help your case? The fact that you got owned by a twelve year old? What were you trying to accomplish when you replied?

[@unguidedreaper7763]

They need to make a new series for next gen consoles. RDR is without a doubt Rockstar's best series to me.

[@imam3603]

I’ve found myself, on multiple occasions while driving through to Mexico, playing the same song that plays after John’s first time crossing over with Irish. and my favorite western game after red dead redemption is GUN.

[@ericwells7777]

I CAN NOT BELIEVE Jeremy didnt even touch on the part where you first enter Mexico in the game and the soundtrack.....WOW...That alone sold me on the game!!!!!

[@musicmitchy4296]

I am shocked you didn't say anything about the hunting..... By far the most amazing thing is that you can go far far out in the middle of no where and hunt, you the skin your kills and bring them back into town to sell you goods. You can make good money doing this. And depending on where you are you will be hunting different game.

[@William_Sk]

Thank you for getting that message up here!

[@Zeldafinalfantasyfan]

2:48 Still cooler looking than the Governor's eyepatch from The Walking Dead.

[@orange2591]

Why no video on Red Dead Redemption 2?

[@AnimuLLLL]

Truly one of the greatest games of all time.

[@maxxmackereth5627]

I just finished this game. I love everything about. I'm close to getting the Deadly Assassin and Hunter Outfits and I'm close to getting some achiviements. I even found the Jackelope. Great game and great story and ending.

[@ericksonc9468]

Hey, December 11th 2024 where is red dead redemption 2 review?

[@Zombitology]

This is the best game I have ever played. MGS4 came really close, but I got attached to John Marston.

[@angel07p]

I can positively say Red Dead Redemption is the best game I've ever played.

[@glyph2011]

One. How the years have flown by. Two. I’m one of the few gamers who played RDR2 first and am now playing this to see what happens to John. It’s amazing to see so many characters from RDR2 in this. Also, thieves landing really expanded in 10 years! Really enjoining the continuing story. Hope John gets his revenge on Dutch.

[@OnlyShallowReviews]

In terms of open world games, it'd have to be between TESV: Skyrim, Grand Theft Auto V, Assassin's Creed II and Red Dead Redemption. In terms of westerns, Django Unchained without a doubt.

[@arashjot2]

My game of this generation. My friends and I spent months playing the multiplayer and exploring every inch of the game. Rockstar is a phenomenal game development company.

[@Brennan163]

Fun Fact: In Franklin's second safehouse in GTA V, there's a book on one of the shelves titled 'Red Dead' by J Marston

[@xxcampheroxx]

Since you might be taking suggestions now, I think doing a review for the 2nd one would be dope! Just a recommendation