Red Eyed Mimics, Reservation Witches, and Window Watchers | 6.9 | Strange Listener Stories 27

[@BeliefHolePodcast]

🔥 Become an Expansion member for 2X the Episodes! 🔗expansion.beliefhole.com/ ⏰ TIMESTAMPS: 00:00 | Episode Trailer 04:34 | Coming Up in the Episode: Shotgun Show Down with Red Eyed Mimics, disembodied Desert Voices, Floating Faces, and Afterlife House Parties 05:54 | Shotgun Vs Red-Eyed Mimic | Schosha, NY | Leigh Buettler 14:15 | When You Were Little You Could See the River | Poland | Martyna 18:22 | The After (Life) Party | Sierra 29:30 | Singing in the Rain and the Antlered Watcher | Scotland | Becky 37:45 | Episode Sponsored by Aura Security | 2 Week Free Trial 40:35 | A Tilly the Nightmare | Ireland | Abbey Mc Laughlin 46:03 | Expansion Preview 50:43 | Crime Weekly Podcast | In Depth True Crime 54:21 | Graveyard Shift on the Reservation | Puppet Master | Texas | Holli 1:02:29 | Dirty Face at the Window | Anonymous | 2003 1:09:53 | Fun in Fields with Fairies | Ingrid 1:24:28 | Skywhale Rider Shoutouts! 1:26:12 | Thank Yous

[@kathymcguire8287]

❤😮😮😮❤

[@jaspersilence9328]

"Magic just drifts on the wind out there...like dust" That was poetry brother!

[@BeliefHolePodcast]

Lol aww cheers Jasper 🍻 I think it was just my mouth trying to make sense of my brain thoughts in the moment 😂

[@sarahrandall-laurentsch2347]

​@@BeliefHolePodcast just trying to say words with your mouth? Hehe🤭 luv ya Jer❤

[@AudaciousAmber]

I always love your animated pictures. They're so creative

[@synesthesia.aesthetic]

I love the Surveillance Outpost! I always enjoy your visuals a lot

[@weebbasi]

Thank you for sharing my story! And thank you for compliment about my accent - that's a first for me lol , always thought it is a weird mix of everything 😆I have to admit that it does feels odd to hear myself in your podcast haha You nailed the name pronunciation, good job! I really appreciate what you've said about all of family members knowing each other before we came to this world - a beautiful thought I will keep in my mind from now. I really wish I could remember something from this story, if grandpa told me about the river - think how many cool secrets he could have said too? What if there's some treasure under the house? I guess we'll never know. Keep it up guys, love your podcast and again, thank you for putting my story out there! Sending love from Poland ❤

[@raeray8245]

I hear that! I wish I could ask my grandparents so many things. edit: YEs, your accent is beautiful! and what a moving story. :)

[@megsgonnamake]

I think this is my 3rd year listening outside on my "up North" trip I take every year....always fun and super creepy! It's hot as balls but I'm excited to listen by the camp fire at the lake! I'm just starting because I was waiting for the dark! Im so freaked out!! Yesss! Love you guys so much!! Let's gooo!!!😅😮❤😂

[@UAPReportingCenter]

That sounds amazing honestly. I could imagine just sitting on the porch of a cabin at night listening to this. Would be beautiful.

[@leahsclassical]

Are you up north in Michigan??

[@BeliefHolePodcast]

Sounds like an awesome place to be listening! Wish we could join 🔥

[@megsgonnamake]

@@BeliefHolePodcast ME TOO!!

[@megsgonnamake]

@@leahsclassical yes!!

[@Callmeclouddd]

Woooooot! Happy to be here in the middle of the Hole.🥰 I'm a Beliefer!

[@gypsyfox3285]

P.S. That blood moon forest story reminds me of folklore about a portal that opens up every so many years to another world. They gather and play ‘olde’ music in forests. Like from the middle ages melodies. If you want to leave with them, they will take you to their world . But you don’t, you can still join in and listen for a while and even dance. But have to go before the beautiful music stops or they will take you anyway.

[@cleanserene6330]

I was thinking of A Midsummer Nights Dream, but its been 30 years since I've read it...I guess I better read it again to see if it was Puck... fairies dancing at midnight... or what the deal was 🧚🏼‍♀️🧚🦹

[@GingeRenee]

I really appreciate you guys giving trigger warnings beforehand giving us listeners a heads up on heavier topics we may not be mentally able to listen to. I certainly appreciate it a lot. I’m a mother and anything that has to do with children being hurt really breaks my heart so i truly appreciate knowing when i should skip ahead a bit to avoid hearing stuff i do not want to hear.

[@BeliefHolePodcast]

Good to know and glad you appreciate it!!

[@dear.ambelina]

Here's to hoping all make insane amounts of money. This podcast has saved my sanity since October or November. Working nights as a CNA is rough and creepy stuff keeps your heart rate up.

[@BeliefHolePodcast]

Cheers for the kind words, ambelina :) be sure to let us know if you have any strange experiences working as a CNA 🙌 we’re always looking for stories

[@KristenKras]

Great to hear your voices again, doing what you do well. That guy who took his own life, that was a really creepy story (the paramedic story). Lots of other great stuff though in the tales.

[@NotJessH]

I’m so excited to finally get to listen to this!!! My husband is outta town for work, my kids are in bed. I took a bubble bath and drank a glass of wine (or two) and now I’m cozy in my bed with my belief hole friends!

[@Strange_Castle]

Driving into work this morning during the witching hour, enjoying the episode scanning the backroads for Not Deer when I hear, Scrooge McDucks skirt... I love this show so much! Makes me feel like I'm hanging out with good friends. Keep up the awesome work guys! Soon I'll drop some of my strange stories

[@synastrytarot]

i’m on a road trip across canada right now and this podcast IS THE BEST COMPANION

[@BeliefHolePodcast]

Heck yeah 🙌

[@eligefashion]

My man and I are camping up in northern Ontario and this is perfect for our spoopy adventures 🎉

[@lluviathewolfgirl]

WHOA! One of my favorite podcasts recommended one of my other favorite podcasts! Love both you guys and Crime Weekly!

[@The_ZeroLine]

_The veil is thin._ That one whisper turned the story from good-to-great. I’m always up to at least 5 AM. So that time never feels strange to me, unless I’m outside.

[@BATM_Media]

I wake up for work when the veil is thin. I probably don't see or hear anything because I'm tired and busy.

[@aimeewank7859]

lol same. Been up all night, love having the B-Hole for company. 🦉✨✌🏽

[@a.walters123]

Late night insomniac here too, usually falling asleep around 4-5AM also. There’s an energy during these hours in the very early morning or “late night”.

[@jennyserenityforestelgin]

I definitely laughed way too hard at the Bob lizarrrrd comment. My ADHD is fun, quick brain connections that typically no one else gets. I get it!

[@BeliefHolePodcast]

😂 🙌

[@leahreynolds852]

I’ve been feeling burnt out and exhausted lately. Im at work today and wondering how I was gonna get through the day… then I tuned in to you guys and now I have a pep in my step, I don’t know where I would be without yall 😭😭😭 thank youuu to my belief boys! 🙏💕

[@BeliefHolePodcast]

That really means a lot, Leah 🙌

[@leahreynolds852]

@@BeliefHolePodcast 🥹💕💕

[@raeray8245]

The after-show calls on the Art Bell show were my fav paranormal stories. This is great. Sounds like a place of witchcraft in the woods with the first story.

[@BeliefHolePodcast]

Man Art Bell. What a host. Love covering his stories. We need to do an episode on him and play some of his greatest calls sometime.

[@CraigStephens777]

I agree 100%. Wa, State aka Sasquatch Country 😊

[@Sujichan]

OMG, in summer of 2011 in this rural town I live in, I was house/pet sitting for my bestie. She lived one street behind me, so we'd cut through the parking area of this natural gas business to visit each other. I was living with my daughter and her newborn, helping her out. My bestie had gone on a trip, so I was there for a week. We were in a heatwave and the power went out. I texted my daughter to ask if they wanted to come over for the night so I could help her out. She said no, she'd be fine. Evening, I'm sitting there on the couch, reading by lantern light when I hear a baby crying outside. I need to mention, where my bestie lived, right beside the house was a cemetery, and across the street from the graveyard was a gothic looking Anglican church. (Yes, the house was creepy. I didn't like it.) I hear the baby crying, and think my daughter changed her mind. I go to the door, and open the inside one, leaving the screen door open, waiting. Nothing. I look around. No one is outside, the sun is almost fully lowered, and I'm still hearing a baby crying like it's getting closer, but there is no one out there. I can see a fair distance down both sides of the street. No one. The hair on the back of my neck starts to rise. My heart is pounding. I feel so much dread. I shut the door, went to the couch and texted my daughter. No, she's at home, baby asleep. Can she hear a baby crying outside? No. I was so afraid, I slept on the couch with the lantern nearby, and had nightmares all night about things prowling outside the house, looking inside the windows and waiting.

[@BeliefHolePodcast]

😬 Creepy invisible babies floating down the road during a blackout? No freaking thank you. Ghost? Trickster? Either way it’s not good. Definitely send in your story. beliefhole.com/share-your-paranormal-story/ 🙌

[@Sleepparalysisdemon2]

* The veil is thin story* just gave me the * good* chills. Loved it.

[@theflail]

I love that you guys are working with Steph and Derrick. Any chance of you guys working with them for an episode? I know Stephanie at least loves covering scary, mysterious stories on her personal channel.

[@BeliefHolePodcast]

Nothing scheduled, but sounds like would be a lot of fun 🙌

[@toddembleton1476]

My cats jumped when you played the animal scream 😆 🤣 😂

[@Maelstrom001]

As an Austinite we welcome you to our great city john!!

[@ultragroove1]

“Shhh….The veil is thin.” Oooh!! This legit got me. Wowza that was super creepy. I’ve experienced the distant inaudible background conversation strangeness at night during bouts of insomnia. But if I ever heard the above I would have run out the house ala Amityville Horror. Good show Belief Hole & thanks contributors.

[@deborahdanhauer8525]

Oh don’t do that, it’s always worse outside❤️🐝🤗

[@tammyj2873]

Love Crime Weekly! Been a fan since the start ❤ Stephanie truly goes into great detail and Derrick is awesome coming in from his professional perspective & I promise I’m not a paid sponsor 😂 Love Belief Hole and definitely try to share videos with friends and my husband. ❤ my fellow Ohioans 🎉

So cool to see Tilley's story told! Thanks guys!!

[@deniseconnolly4385]

Can we send prayers to that beautiful paramedic in the reservation 💜 tough job to take on hes obviously got a solid backbone 🙏

[@theburntcookieshub5803]

Thank y'all very much, but I have a wonderful girl who gets me through it all; moreso God blessin' to all you

[@lisadwhitworth]

Welcome back to Texas!

[@ricywright8296]

This was one of your best episodes in a while boys, you always do good work but this one stands out.keep up the great work!

[@BeliefHolePodcast]

Cheers 🙌

[@billygames1018]

I feel like my “in the hole” jokes are getting stale. Never the less, I’m ready to be deep in the hole tonight. I love you guys.

[@mistrjt9213]

I’ll be right behind you, dinkleberry.

[@doublestarships646]

Needs more hole.

[@Psychedelicbodega]

Just go away. It’s called a schtick. I bet you think comedy is bad and offensive too

[@doublestarships646]

@@Psychedelicbodega lol he wasn't being mean.

[@treytraylor7078]

@@doublestarships646 Guess what! I've got a fever, and the only prescription is more hole!

[@Critastic]

I just discovered your guys show, I’ve been binging all the previous episodes! You guys are entertaining and the content is awesome! It gets me through work. If you guys need a story about my ghost encounter at the Bird cage theatre in Arizona I can send it to you guys, it was an incredible and later terrifying experience. Keep it up guys!

[@BeliefHolePodcast]

Send it in beliefhole.com/share-your-paranormal-story/ 🙌

[@Scrappydoodah]

Yes! Made it on time to the live!

[@HighPingDrifter1]

Fun fact - Michael Fish failed to predict that storm because it was actually conjured by a black magician, at least according to the book The Black Alchemist by Andrew Collins. It's a supposedly true story of psychic questing, occult artifacts and psychic battles that took place in the UK in the 80's.

[@Mardi-Shorts-DevonGirlUK]

That's sounds interesting. I shall look that up. I grew up in the South East of England. I remember that storm being aged 10. Didn't 7 Oaks become 5 Oaks from that particular storm? 80s was a fun time to experience childhood 😎

[@HighPingDrifter1]

@@Mardi-Shorts-DevonGirlUK When we had to get our spooky true stories from books rather than podcasts :)

[@BeliefHolePodcast]

That sounds like it would be a killer episode!

[@BeliefHolePodcast]

80s childhood for the win🥋🦕🔥

[@BeliefHolePodcast]

We still have all those books! And now we use to inform our podcasts 😂 🙌

[@carmeltabby]

Excited for the episode and hoping everyone is healthy and going to bed when they should......looking at you Chris!!!! 🧐

[@BeliefHolePodcast]

😂 🙌

[@robohg9917]

That first listener story was a good listen! That uncle and girlfriend part 😂, I like how she read That

[@ingridherrington5015]

I love Ingrid’s story but maybe I’m bias 😂 she sounds like my doppelgänger 🙈

[@ingridkuehl3540]

Maybe we are both each doppelgängers? 😂

[@recycledteenager176]

Another tasty episode from my favorite podcast masters 🙌 Thanks guys 🥰

[@BeliefHolePodcast]

Thanks for listening 🙌

[@northgambit]

Shame its always so late for me [3am]. Have fun everybody, much love!

[@BeliefHolePodcast]

Sorry my friend! Wish KZbin would create a feature to allow multiple premiere times!

[@The_ZeroLine]

Infanticide is the “more clinical way” to say “infant homicide.” That awful suicide story + grinning demon reminded me of that terrible listener story you told from the woman pregnant w/triplets whose husband totally changed and crazy things started happening in the house.

[@theburntcookieshub5803]

Correct. Thankfully the infant survived, though was very critical upon reception at the ED.

[@TiffanyFusini]

I am relistening to this episode because I think I fell asleep during the first listen. I also, like Jon, wake up between 2-4am every single night. Or nearly every night. Sometimes I don't end up going back to sleep, because the energy is so intense.

[@StarWarsJay]

The lady at the end might have had a bottle or two 😂

[@ingridkuehl3540]

I only had 3!!

[@Sofia-ge6wm]

This episode was amazing guys!! I'd love if you guys do an episode on hallways in my old apartment I remember I hated my hallway and would always go full sprinting down it I don't know why but I always felt something dark in that hallway whenever I'd run down it I'd feel something behind me like I was getting chased Edits: Just fixing some typos!

[@BeliefHolePodcast]

hallways are naturally creepy. Interesting suggestion!

[@supersnail4293]

New to the hole but you three are the best really enjoy thank you dudes

[@lauren7dryad]

About the veil being thin, I wonder if the other dimensions, cryptids etc get freaked out by each other - for instance does a dogman have a scary or fun encounter with a shadow person or a hag get chased by a ghost child - do they interact with each other and not just us.

[@BeliefHolePodcast]

Well now that is an interesting thought 🧐

[@roberthutch7984]

The moment she said the vale is this in the after (life) party the light over me flickered. I work nights and it was pretty unsettling

[@cleanserene6330]

Veil

[@a.walters123]

That warning at the beginning regarding the rez stories was definitely warranted. The death video seriously shook me in my inner spirit.

[@BeliefHolePodcast]

Agreed. One of the darkest stories we've come across.

[@anastasiab6134]

love this channel so much so many great spooky shows & you guys make it so fun ,ya make me laugh while giving me the creeps .Your the best!

[@BeliefHolePodcast]

aww cheers to that. thanks for the kid words ❤

[@Exlynn.]

I'd love see u guys doing the intro in the future live streams.

[@BeliefHolePodcast]

That’s a great idea 😆

[@jash6244]

I believe you could never sell your soul because it's not yours to give in the first place .

[@BeliefHolePodcast]

True that

[@The_ZeroLine]

False dat.

[@emmaroni4619]

You guys should do an episode on Indigenous legends. A collab with Shanclan shadow production would be great

[@BeliefHolePodcast]

We've covered them in various episodes, but will definitely do so again!

[@brjefrco]

The singing in the rain , a green man and a fayle , i need to know was the water clean and clear nearby ?

[@Sleepparalysisdemon2]

So excited for this episode!

[@littlezork]

Good show as always, guys!!

[@gypsyfox3285]

I love these are true tales. I am not a big fan of creepypasta. It’s great if it’s your thing. But like those of us here, the notion that what we are listening to just might be real. It is very interesting to ponder. I give every story the benefit of the doubt for sure. I do not understand why doubters lurk about on occasion just to troll. That just baffles me. I listen to what I love and intrigues me. And I love this show. Thank you guys, and the listeners that share the experiences they have had. Perhaps one day I will too. I am just not sure which one to pick from first. ❤

[@BeliefHolePodcast]

Cheers Gypsy. You're speaking to the heart of the show, and we're glad to have you here 👊

[@JeebusFeetus]

Let's go!!!!!!!!! Been waiting for some hole !

[@Cathida]

Always A Tremendous Pleasure and Satisfaction Seeing and Hearing Your Show Bro's Thanks Cris, Jon & Jeremy...Much Obliged! Your Hole Is Like A Trunk Full of Goodies! The Loot of Grandiose Pirates Booty! Well, I ain't lyin!!😂😊 Goodnight Fellas!!

[@susanbutler2542]

Thank you very much for the great videos❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@CraigStephens777]

Amazing Stories. Thank You!😊

[@SimulacraViro]

Glad I found you guys,kickass

[@saunyawilliams403]

I Love You Guys and I Love the podcast. ❤😂. Heard your moving John. Best wishes but please don't let the show. Biggest Hugs to my guys John, Chris and Jeremy. Y'all make my day. ❤❤❤

[@BeliefHolePodcast]

Thanks for the kind message Saun 👊 We appreciate it. Sincerely

[@gayemorgan4575]

❤❤❤ I love the listener stories. Sending love from Australia 🇦🇺

[@n.m.3981]

God bless sweet brave Tilley

[@stephaniemcnickle7705]

Hi guys. I've been listening to crime weekly for a lil while now. She's great!!!! I'm recommending another which is Emma Kenney true crime. She works with the psychology behind the perpetrators and with those whom survive. She REALLY does a thorough, in depth job of breaking down each case, the how's and why's behind the thot process of those who commit the crime as well as legitimately working in the field of recovery for those who have been affected by the crime. Check her out too!!!!! 😄. I was so excited to see that there was a new episode last night. Keep em comin boys!!😅😊.

[@megzdubv2950]

So glad ya boys are back

[@CorkySchillinger]

Loved it!

[@Eyeamsayter]

These background animations are looking good boys.

[@BeliefHolePodcast]

👊

[@valerielargin3848]

The little girl singing in the thunderstorm and the shirtless man with green pants and antlers... that is 100% the Fae Folk. Also known as faeries (fairies) or the Sith in Gaelic (pronounced "shee" as in banshee). They are the "Good Folk" as long as you don't piss them off... an angry faery can go toe to toe with any demon, in fact, many people believe they are some of the fallen angels; otherworldly beauty with a propensity for mischief if not straight out cruelty.

[@TiffanyFusini]

Hey brothers, I just wanted to let you know that I was informing my Internet service provider about your podcast, and he was super interested and had me repeat it so he could write it down. Also, he lives in Ohio! ❤ You guys!

[@mistrjt9213]

The veil is thin lady has a great narrating voice! 👍

[@ericruiz658]

Sometimes John sounds like he just got woken up and is surprised... He's 😁 fun

[@rinfowler7544]

Philippines mentioned‼️‼️ 🇵🇭🇵🇭🔥🔥🔥

[@ValleyMermaid]

Awesome episode!!!

[@drewroosevelt6506]

I lived in a place I couldn’t leave and had a crazy few experiences at 3:14am with knocking and nightmares of a child. Another guy heard a child crying sometimes. I might email the full story or something. I begged to leave that place harder than I’ve begged for anything and I was allowed to. I couldn’t have handled another night. Two nightmares with a child in one and both happened exactly at 3:14am two nights in a row. So bizarre. I knew something was screwing with me

[@garymadskullmcgill]

i was only just thinking the other day that theres a big hole in my life, that was until i found you guys and this podcast, and now im a Believer...

[@megzdubv2950]

Our Loki Bird does same chirpy bark every time our son has a seizure, it’s unreal & it’s shepherd like

[@megzdubv2950]

It sucks having to appreciate these small things

[@jaynerobinson7008]

'Sparked out ' fast asleep.

[@369thegoosedrankwine1]

❤ Looking forward to it!

[@lara4life656]

Ok. The last story. I try patience. I do. But my gosh. Spit. It. Out .

[@tiffanyattenborough8784]

I thought I was the only one

[@lara4life656]

@@tiffanyattenborough8784 thank god. I felt bad saying it. Glad I wasn't the only one. 🤭

[@kj5250]

Great ep❤

[@Peasant_in_a_tree]

Scotia, NY is a historic ifo/high strangeness hotspot. Akin to point pleasant, wv. In the 1960s there was a flap where mibs, ufos, humanoids etc. were showing up everywhere in area. It culminated in a teenage kid dying on the ice, from freight/heart condition. It is well worth looking into. Extremely fascinating stuff. Also, john keel was even involved. "Beyond creepy" the KZbin channel, also has a great video on the topic

[@dfektdysfunkshun6215]

This is awesome 👍 I live and work in the area of the first story. And I've seen some crazy stuff myself.

[@JamesKonzek-xr5zy]

I'm getting me some Hole time! 🕳️

[@kkech1]

There's a distinct heaviness around the 3AM atmosphere. I've taken late night walks ever since I was a kid, and I don't even have to check the clock to know when it is around that time. Not only is it dead silent, but the air feels heavy to breathe. I wonder if it has something to do with radiation, being turned away from the sun and all. Also, waking up for no reason around that time.. I wonder if it's just primal instinct kicking in because it gets so quiet.

[@lara4life656]

Algorithm booster for my boys in the hole. Scoot your booty, I'm jumpimg into to join the gang!

[@jeremywalker666]

I've been listening to this podcast for awhile now without ever knowing what the bros look like. Chris and Jeremy look close to what one would expect but i always figured John was a dark, long-haired, stoner. Never would've expected a nerdy ginger lol. Love the stories guys.

[@BeliefHolePodcast]

Lol nerdy ginger. Never have been called that before.

[@jeremywalker666]

Wow that came off way more dickish than I intended. I mean you look more intelligent than one would expect lol

[@Epyon2007]

love your show

[@BeliefHolePodcast]

Cheers, my friend! Glad to have you in the Hole 🙌

[@endor8witch]

i've had a few experiences EXACTLY like in the after life party story by sierra.

[@FloatingThroughTheRealm]

Yayyyy 🎉 can’t wait!!!

[@nebulaeclipses]

Woooooo I love the listener stories!

[@megzdubv2950]

My Shep’s not professionally trained yet he senses every seizure my epileptic son has?!?! Loki’s amazing!!!

[@hindleygj]

Is the Puppet master Texan on the expansion ? Can we please hear more from him ? Eh ?

[@theburntcookieshub5803]

Apologies mate, I don't have much more to say paranormal wise. Just a few incidents really they just go in the back in my mind compared to the other corporeal memories. - Holli

[@tiffanystout.]

Sean Connery was definitely Scottish. Born in Edinburgh.

[@j4nk3n]

Speaking of "knowing" its 3am, i always seem to get that with a full moon, ill feel weird and check outside and bam, full moon, very strange

[@synesthesia.aesthetic]

Look into the story of Patricia and Melinda and their New England farmhouse. It's detailed in "The Demonologist: The Extraordinary Career of Ed and Lorraine Warren" by Gerlad Brittle. It's in "Chapter 8: Oppression : The Strategy Revealed". Fascinating case that I never see discussed.

[@jonigeszvain3084]

Sierra, I for sure believe you. I bet it was ancestors and friends of your grandfather waiting for him to cross over. Thought's?

[@Dddd.6754]

My favourite channel ❤️...

[@TaigaSibirskaya]

I went looking for Bigfoot in my local area in Britain but discovered something else. I was once walking on an old railway track, now a paved trail, and an invisible creature made a grunting noise behind me. I turned around and there was nothing there. But the entity seemed like it was happy that I turned around. like it said "ehhhh" True or False ?

[@Unknown-UpTown-Resident]

"I didn't wake up, I was woken up. I was dragged, purposely from my slumber." - Only a writer would describe being woken up in this way 🤣