Red Wing vs Irish Setter Boots: 6 Reasons to Pick One (In 6 Minutes)

[@erskerbobbles]

My Family is originally from Red Wing, MN. My Grandparents were the first residents to live year round on the rugged majestic bluffs overlooking the mighty Mississippi in Wacouta (between R.W. & Frontinac). For years they were locally known for their matched pairs of beautiful Irish Setters. They always named them Mike & Collean. In 1952 "The Shoe" (as the locals called it) needed an artist's model for their new hunting boot line. Mike (#3) was ideal. The rest is history.... Red Wings forever!!!

[@Speweythealien]

I"m an electrician and the wingshooters are my favorite work boot - they last, they're tanks, they're comfortable, and they're not so expensive I feel like I need to be careful with them. Plus they look cooler the more you wear them.

[@edbigtruck]

I’ve been wearing the Irish Setter wing shooters for work and bird hunting for years. When the soles wore out I had the RedWing Store replace the soles with Vibram Star and bar soles made a good boot a great boot.

[@Bearded360]

Great idea i may just do the same with mine.

[@danielhanks6508]

I have worn the Irish Setter Ashbys for years. The wear much better than the wing shooter which I have had several pairs. I’m on my feet in concrete and asphalt for 9-11 hours per day and the ashbys are more comfortable than my sneakers.

[@aa-.-477]

Looks like great boots and comfortable. For the price 1 flaw not waterproof.

[@JWitt30]

I'm really eyeing these up.. do you have the soft or hard toe.. I've heard the soft toe our a bit more comfortable, but I also work with concrete/asphalt so it's mandatory at my company..

[@ry69scott]

@@JWitt30I know this is super late but I transitioned from some 6-7 year old Ariat’s to Ashby’s and man… World of difference. Standing on my feet 11-12 hours a day is no joke and I got them at a local western store for $120 (they were discounted). Combine them with insoles and it’s life changing. I’ve been working in various warehouse/plants from 18-24 and I felt like I was aging more rapidly with uncomfortable footwear.

[@gfabie4901]

The most solid and balanced comparison thus far. Thanks!

[@Stridewise]

Hell of a first comment, thank you Fabie!!!

[@averageguy7641]

I'm a cement contractor I work in the Irish setters and do my estimates in the Red wings Both badass boots but yeah the Irish setters are more comfortable

[@jamesdean4972]

Yeah red wings for around town Irish setter or danner for work because then I don’t feel like I have to be careful with them

[@gorilwolf]

I love my Irish setters I’ve have 2 pairs one for work and the other for going out. The pair I use for going out I’ve also doubled as a hiking boot and they are the best. Once the soles wear out I’m planning on putting a vibram lug sole to make them extra grippy

[@TheIronSnail]

Nick i can’t wait to take over your channel for a video and do your accent the entire time

[@TheIronSnail]

Nick it’s Michael btw this is my KZbin account

[@anibalbabilonia1867]

I have my Irish settlers now for around 14 years! And they are the most comfortable boots I’ve ever worn! And they still look great today! And they didn’t take long to break them in! Love them.👌😎👍♥️

[@mackwalls866]

That's awesome, I've had my red Wing mocs 29 yrs and Same. Keep it up bro

[@griffinmurr1477]

I like them and they hold up alright but 9 months and they’re shot for me

[@blake_229]

Irish setters have never disappointed me.

[@TheTruthseeker707]

Great video. These where not on my radar until I was almost about to leave the store and found out that this moc boot is actually made by redwing. I don’t know if it’s just me but I did not feel good buying a copy of the moc boot made by another company that was not redwing. It felt like they were stealing a design not theirs. But today I wore them and so far so good. Glad I bought them and probably one day still buy the redwing’s. God bless to all.

[@fredsvlogandreviews5867]

my red wing boots are Irish setter but I still just call them red wing boots as it says red wing on it. Any way, when I bought them in 2019 I had never heard of the brand at all and people were saying they were great and made in the USA so I bought the cheapest boots I could find directly from red wing and it turned out to be the Irish setter. But I like them. I like how they are water proof, I like how they are holding up even after this long and a con and a pro is they are very warm so I typically just wear them in the winter or on cold days.

[@volkoff6357]

Today, I bought the Irish Setters and the custom insole that the sales associate suggested. They scanned my foot for shape and had me walk on a pressure pad so they could tell what size was the perfect fit. I only tried on one other pair of their work shoes and ended up with a 10.5 wide, and the fit is great. I'm breaking them in now and hope they will serve me well at my new job. Great comparison.

[@JimfromBuffalo]

The real comparison should have been 10875 VS the Wingshooter ST. Great vid Nick!

[@StolenAlias]

Its the same as the 875. Literally.

[@angryagain68]

It's worth mentioning that the none moctoe version of the Wingshooter has completely different leather. Feels more like a heavy chrome tan leather. I do wish they would use that leather on the moctoe version as well.

[@keenobservations3050]

The liner on my Irish setters fell apart within 6 months and before I even knew it my socks were getting shredded by the liner. Then my heals began to get punished. I wish red wing still made heritage style steel toe boots. I am wearing a pair of red wing moc toe steel toe boots I bought back in 1994. Been resoled 3 times but I maybe out of luck for a 4th time. Sad

[@Wilson_Kelly]

Stridewise #1 youtuber once again

[@yepanon4670]

Irish Setter wingshooters i bought literally 5 years ago and put through hell and back are still waterproof and unbroken. The souls are worn down. but all the stiching and leather is as it was when bought. The most comfortable boot ive ever been stepped in, like putting your foot into a hug from a matress. I cant throw them away from sentimental reasons, theyve been through so many highs and lows and at certain times the only thing I had left.

[@Mark.G475]

In six minutes!! I like it! Great idea. Cheers from Milwaukee Wisconsin 🇺🇲🧀🍻

[@Stridewise]

It was total coincidence the video was 6 minutes hahah

[@WRA_Moon]

For work I’ve always gotten Irish Setter ST but casual wear I have soft toe RedWing 405 Traction Tread I do steel stud framing and drywall for a living(I’d definitely recommend getting tough toe epoxy put over the toe on the Irish setters)

[@Bearded360]

This could be the best comparison vid on youtube.

[@Stridewise]

Oh snap thanks for the accolades Eric!

[@UnknownUser-rb9pd]

Another negative of the Irish Setter (and all membrane boots) is that the membrane can get punctured by bits of grit. And if water gets inside, via a puncture or because water splashed over the top of the boot, your feet sit in a puddle as the only way the water gets out is by a very slow evaporation process that is made much worse if the outer leather is wet. I have had several membrane boots that got soaked inside take weeks to dry out even while unworn, and develop some pretty terrible odours in the lining that were very difficult to get rid off.

[@minnesota-hk1vp]

Nice comparison!

[@VTI2CLN]

Why are my Irish setter bottoms like plastic not rubber super slippery?

[@thatguy_jose]

Redwing and Irish setter does come with soft toe or steel toe, i was there at their store a day ago Lol

[@Billrovid]

Finally thank you for making this video. Ive been looking for this info.

[@angelafox4380]

Enjoyed your video. Thank you for sharing this 💗

[@jacobsidorin2055]

I have owed 3 pairs of Irish red and one pair of the red wings. I am a trade guy and favor red wings over the Irish red. The both have pro and cons. Irish red have a better sole. The big issue with them is the stitch by the safety toe always comes apart and cus they are water proof they are super hot in the summer. Red wings are more comfortable especially in the heal area do to the extra leather at the heal. I live in Colorado and the boots not being water proof does not matter to me. Thick leather is good enough.

[@darrenhall7454]

As an amateur boot enthusiast, I’m ashamed to say that this is all news to me. I never questioned it. So thanks, Nick. 👍

[@StolenAlias]

Shame on you

[@darrenhall7454]

@@StolenAlias 😂 Exactly! I’ll just sit in the corner for a while with my head in my hands.

[@henrystickman1651]

The Irish setter are asphault boots, best I've seen lol. Most boots are terrible for paving but these seem like nice ones

[@ericochoa4271]

I wish I could find more videos on red wings supersole 2.0. I beat the absolute hell out of those boots and they still hold up.

[@Stridewise]

wanna write a review of them for my site?

[@ericochoa4271]

@Stridewise Yeah I would.

[@Stridewise]

@@ericochoa4271 email me! nick at stridewise.com

[@ThiCityProductions]

Bought these Irish Setters. I also picked up those superfeet GREEN insoles. I wear the 11 1/2. Superfeet insoles 11.5 match exactly the pre existing insoles the Irish Setters are sold with. No need to modify the insoles. Look for the letter F if you wear 11.5. I have a somewhat thin foot. I inserted the green insoles and put the stock insoles on top. Shoe fits me perfect now. Just make sure you get the right color of insole for your specific arch type. UPDATE!! Ok so I purchased a pair of Irish Setters steel toe for $225. I deliver and install appliances. We have 15 to 20 stops a day. 30 appliances give or take. FELL APART JUST OVER 6 MONTHS! :( Any recommendations for a comfortable, durable steel toe for heavy delivery and install?

[@SupraFreshZ]

Did Redwing cancel the Oxblood Heritage Moc?

[@StolenAlias]

Yeah. Red Wing is honestly an L right now.

[@Zednix]

I had a pair of Irish Setter Crosby's and unfortunately had to get rid of them because they are dangerous to wear in the snow. The soles seem to have zero grip in the snow, especially once it is below -10c here. I picked up some Keens, which are meh so far, and am struggling to find comfortable insoles for those boots. I have a V shaped foot and a tall ridge so it can be hard to find something that fits well. Bit of a struggle still.

[@averageguy7641]

You might want to get that v-shaped foot looked at fella js

[@Zednix]

@@averageguy7641 I can start an only fans account for my grippers if you want to check them out

[@ghostoflazlo]

This comment is gold. I was looking at the setters for winter wear. How would you say they stand for warmth? Was thinking of adding a wool sole since they don't really come across as a "winter boot" per say

[@Zednix]

@@ghostoflazlo Don't buy the Crosby's if you plan on walking on snow because it will be dangerous.

[@benjaminallen2370]

Irish Setter Trailblazers for snow… have had them several years and do alot of snow hiking in them

[@MrBill-ee4mr]

Why do your irish setters boots have differnet soles than what is shown on the website

[@thomashardy1851]

If you want a Moc Toe for work, Thorogood is a better option than Irish settler, looks good like redwings has water proof and safety toe and it is made in America.

[@jmarth523]

I am an electrician and I use the standard Wingshooter. Ive worn them for 2 years, really fn hard. 0 issues and still have many years left on them at this rate. Also the sole hasn't worn through the thin synthetic tread laminate so nowhere close to a resole! Got mine for $165 2 years ago

[@Emezepe3]

Are the irish setters actually waterproof

[@Allguitarinfo]

Looking to choose soon be😂tween redwings and irish setters

[@antmontey2169]

Does the Irish setter ashbys have a leather heel counter?

[@samsonmogire4959]

I made an order using red wing website they received my order then later they refunded i don't get it maybe you can explain to me

[@TylerSnyder305]

Nobody around me wears Irish setter. They wear American made Thorogood and Carolina moc toes if they're not wearing cowboy boots. They are overpriced for an imported boot when you can get a Carolina fir around the same price or thorogood for a little more with much better leather.

[@sharkskin3448]

Imho, if you use them for work, you're going to wear through the toe. Save $100 with the wingshooters or get the Thorogoods.

[@deaddada]

As a structural Ironworker in Manhattan, the made-in-usa 8" Moc Toe was the gold standard in safety, durability and protection. Number one, you DON'T want a steel/composite toe if ypu're working with steel, because if a beam falls on your foot, the steel or composite toe is going to cut your toes clean off. You're much better off having them smashed- smashed toes can heal, severed toes, not so much. Number 2, those bullshit Irish Setter boots won't last one job. Why pay $200 for garbage trash when you can get the real thing for slightly more, which, because of the Goodyear welt, you can get resoled over and over again?!? As an actual construction person, who is skilled and paid a 6 figure plus wage because of that skill, we don't play that Irish Setter crap. It's unsafe, unreliable, and basically a poor tool. So, this video ignores the workers for whom these boots, with these soles, were originally made.

[@jamesdean4972]

I am in trade school for welding. From what I’ve heard the soles of the 10875’s declined in durability drastically in mid 2000’s. I own both 875 and 10875 as well as 866 (pretty much their classic models for iron/roughnecking/ag) and I love all three. I also own danner 8 inch moc steel toe which are made in USA not as comfortable but the sole lasts longer

[@Dan-lq6dg]

Great video!

[@RogerLoera]

So what's going on with the Redwing website? They've been out of stock of ALL their shoes for some time now. I read something about having back order issues whatever that means. Hopefully some redwing employee can elaborate. Thanks.

[@loganmiller4045]

There is a shortage rn it’s hard to get certain boots but call your local redwing store and they can try to order a boot your looking for

[@floydholland8337]

Does Red Wing even make or sell boots anymore? I dont think you can find any to try or buy hardly anywhere.....

[@Stridewise]

boot companies are having lots of trouble maintaining production post pandemic

[@floydholland8337]

That would be an interesting video.

[@Ggllg2323]

Irish setter wingshooter st Red wings traction tred vs traction tred lite

[@kevinleyva3003]

I have both for different uses. 10875 for out and about, with the 8 inch wing shooters w/ 400g insulation for wet winters. Tho I have retired the wing shooters for a pair of Chippewa Kush ‘N’ Kollar boots.

[@Beariam24]

I wish I wish I wish I could get hold of the Irish setters in the UK. I’m an electrician and with wide feet. It’s almost impossible to get boots that look like these. Purchasing on eBay and Amazon is so hit and miss for something like this. Maybe Next time your in the uk drop me off some in uk 9.5 ee 😝😝

[@jamesdean4972]

Look at danner

[@centenoj85]

Calidad y humildad

[@395glen]

I disagree to an extent while yes Irish setter does have composite toe and waterproof they aren’t really designed for longevity of hard labor. The leather is a cheaper material and the outsole is made of mostly foam with a little rubber sole that wears out quickly. For me they are mainly a hunting boot with extras to appeal to blue collar workers. If I want those extra features I would just choose some thorogoods but I still prefer original heritage red wings versus overseas hunting boots

[@mattlopez5418]

Ur comparing mock toe, red wing and iriah setter makes many other boots. Redwing warranty is 6 months longer than irish setter, that should tell u which is a much better boot for work. In my experience irish setters are lighter and kore comfortable but do not last as long as the Redwing

[@alexgrover1456]

My work requires a composite safety tow. Redwing Heritage does not make any boots with that specification. So no, Redwing is not the best work boot.

[@shy5840]

I’ve bought thorogoods every year for the past 5 years. They are the best boot I’ve had but I just wish they would last longer. It’s always the soles/insoles wearing down

[@McflyJr_]

Not fair comparison. Compare a red wing 2415 to the wingshooter. The boots you’re comparing couldn’t be more different

[@Bryen12]

Love 875

[@fredseekingbibleturth]

My personal research into the difference is that red wing are made in the USA and Irish setter are made in Vietnam.

[@matttherrien9608]

Genius.

[@fredseekingbibleturth]

@@matttherrien9608 Although I have learned that that is not the case with all red wings. Some red wings are even made in China. but didn't find that out until later I think it si more a case of red wing being higher quality and irish setter being lower quality.

[@wanderingdaze7018]

Irish setter for work red wing mocs to go out

[@jonlouis2582]

Thanks for the refresher. I was considering the Irish Setter boots, but they wouldn’t work for me in my job. My feet would be a sweaty mess by the end of the day!

[@TylerSnyder305]

Get a pair of Carolina or Thorogood moc toes, much better leather and Made here in the USA. thorogood prices have gone up some lately but the Carolinas should still be about the same price as the Irish setters. Both of these superior options use the same leather and overall similar construction, but cove does run stitching all the way through the outsole at the toe on the Carolina boots to prevent the outsole from separating there.

[@Stridewise]

Ashbies aren't waterproof so probably more breathable

[@jonlouis2582]

@@Stridewise Thanks.

[@simonmandrakejones]

I come from Ireland...we just call them Setters.

[@Stridewise]

nice

[@simonmandrakejones]

@@Stridewise Sorry. I couldn't help myself 😃

[@hughitt6107]

Get both lol

[@christopherdavisson617]

Look, safety wise the Wing Shooter St is a more suitable work boot. That being said? Well the 875 is a lot more durable and long lasting in every day construction applications. To boot the 875 is much better looking. (My God that Wing Shooter is hideous haha)

[@egorboroda1099]

А зачем? Есть прекрасный аналог от Whites Perry !!!

[@jasev587]

At 2023, the Irish Setter is far better than any Red Wing, for me.

[@addisonesslinger3653]

The sole should be black.

[@samwroblewski748]

You say “Irish” like the Irish.

[@Stridewise]

ok

[@joewatts2940]

Irish setters look better

[@someaussiebloke4487]

I'm Aussie but your bastardised accent and turbo speed needs subtitles my dude

[@MordecaiAliVanAllenOShea]

Weird, I’m American and can understand him perfectly. Maybe you need to clean the dust bunnies out of your ears, mate.

[@someaussiebloke4487]

@@MordecaiAliVanAllenOShea no mate. No I don't.

[@franky3fingers337]

Lol, he’s perfectly understandable. Just talks a little weird but that’s ok.

[@thatfitfriend]

Mate, you have dust bunnies in ya ears!

[@StolenAlias]

Clean the shite outta ya ears mate.

[@CarlWinslow545]

The Irish Setters are terrible. The toe wore out and the stitches busted within a month. Go with Rocky Boots