If Arthur constantly kills NPCs, then this will happen

[@fandyus4125]

Giving a weeping widow 2 dollars for the death of her husband might just be the most evil thing you can do in this game.

[@Kacpa2]

Well it worth much more than current day 2 dollars but still is hardly anything as a gesture. Modern day 75-ish dollars wont get her husband back, but would help for a while. Given than you could buy some life stock for 5$ for your farm in late 19th century. Living cost was closer to mkdern 3rd world countries, so it could last her for several months. Ideally ofc he should give more if he has more.

[@Whocares158]

Free money.

[@JackBrilla]

$2 dollars back in the day must of been a lot!

[@Kacpa2]

@@JackBrilla Its worth around 65-70-ish current day dollars.

[@fandyus4125]

@@JackBrilla it wasn't.

[@kaosone3631]

"Sorry miss I dragged him for miles with my horse so I could earn an achievement"

[@opossumshulgin8248]

Lmao

[@Lastwalker01]

It's there one where u have yo do that?!?

[@coreyboggs2011]

A true fan 😂😂😂

[@kaosone3631]

@@Lastwalker01 you've gotta lasso and drag an enemy or random to earn an achievement in the game.

[@geffphishnutz7140]

literally

[@ZephyrAlphaOne]

Giving $2 should've lowered Arthur's honor. That's just pure evil.

[@alexman378]

Especially considering he probably has the GDP of a small country in that satchel.

[@hayleyurie3997]

@muhelectionwasstolen7253 no dafq not? what's 80 dollars gonna do lol

[@basketballadigonzalez5561]

@@hayleyurie3997yes it was you bigot

[@imperiumoccidentis7351]

@@hayleyurie3997 I'd rather have 80 dollars that some family members.

[@hayleyurie3997]

@@imperiumoccidentis7351 oh no lol I'm sorry

[@pizza70123]

Giving her $2 should have counted as antagonizing lmao

[@caralho5237]

2 dollars at that time was a bunch of money, also the fact that she isn't 100% sure it was arthur who killed him

[@thewhitewolf58]

Well taking money would make made her a whore.

[@Gentleman...Driver]

$2 in 1899 is equivalent in purchasing power to about $73.10 today, an increase of $71.10 over 124 years. The dollar had an average inflation rate of 2.94% per year between 1899 and today, producing a cumulative price increase of 3,554.98%.

[@Rusty_Shackleford420]

That $2 will get her 2 cans of beans max in the general store.

[@gaydolfbitler]

​@@Rusty_Shackleford420ah, funeral food.

[@Sercil00]

"Here. Go buy yourself something nice." "It's... only 2 dollars..." "I said something NICE! Not something expensive!"

[@xo2317]

@@roasted.cheese it was a gta v reference 💀

[@roasted.cheese]

@@xo2317 oops sorry didn't get it

[@rwandanman1218]

2 dollars is like 60 dollars in 1898, she could buy groceries or something

[@JackyBoneskull]

@@rwandanman1218 you can buy 3-4 cans of beans with that

[@rwandanman1218]

@@JackyBoneskull what typa beans you be buying nigga

[@Currie2042]

“You evil bastard!” “Evil?! Ma’am, have you seen how high my honour rating is?”

[@Yeyeyayayoyo]

This comment is giving adolf hitler vibes

[@ninjireal]

@@YeyeyayayoyoDoes he speak to you, too?

[@wildward93]

Howdy mister!

[@JoyBoyvoid]

accept Jesus Christ he loves u died n rose again for ur forgiveness 🙏🏽❤️

[@nosacastell3253]

🤣🤣🤣

[@joaovictor4578]

"You killed my husband!" Arthur: Okay I'll catch you later then

[@thewhitewolf58]

Just gives me another person to shoot lol

[@kitch311]

Well a best be getting on!

[@SirPano85]

That's a positive thinking! 👍

[@squadscout808]

Okaay talk later then

[@pedrobarbosa6659]

lmao

[@jordanbooth4470]

I like the idea that this all happened in the same day, Arthur just goes from town to town like “oh not another widow yelling at me”

[@MarvinT0606]

plot-twist: it's the same woman following Arthur around to scam him

[@OvSpP]

@@MarvinT0606the same woman wearing blackface twice? Or whiteface once? She’s really dedicated to this scam.

[@MathsOP]

@@OvSpPyeah and the second widow didnt even accept the money.

[@Mrnoob-pv7ku]

@@MathsOP nor the third

[@MathsOP]

@@Mrnoob-pv7ku i only watched half the vid lol

[@cackslopper5321]

"Now i got 3 babies to raise alone" "I can sort this problem maam, where are they" *unholsters revolver

[@ToughLuckStudio]

The fact that this game came out 5 years ago and I played it for over 200 hours and I’m STILL seeing new things I’ve never seen is insane

[@juniorjulien2669]

Right. I’ve never seen these interactions and I’ve beat the game 4x 🤯

[@ProjectPhoenix21]

600 hours myself and yeah, the level of depth is still unmatched. Well, about 200 of those hours are online but the 2 playthroughs I've done were some of the best gaming I've ever done.

[@daiich1603]

Well RS knew they had to put alot into the game because their next game wasn’t coming out till 2030

[@JBrotsis1]

I too have beaten the game 3x and never seen this but let’s be honest, how many of us are murdering lunatics the whole campaign?

[@Sigman987]

​@@JBrotsis1I have completed 5× I have killed 10 thousand people at least

[@DeathUsagi]

Widow: "You took everything from me" Arthur: "I don't even know who you are"

[@GEREX94]

Widow: -You will...

[@Raarelyx]

@@GEREX94 Use bullet, problem solved.

[@big-kinoko]

Wait ... why I can hear this lines

[@CAdeNA_25]

@@big-kinoko THANOS

[@totallynotcass7732]

NUH UH

[@NebulaTheOfficial]

1:32 lmao that honor ping made that sound bad ass

[@TheQueen-vz7dq]

Lmfao 😂

[@lucasborges653]

Hahaha

[@annimemeiro]

+Disrespect

[@astralmiind]

It was like he spit in a bucket before he finished that line lmao

[@randomname46]

rdr2 vine boom

[@AhmedHasan-tg5uo]

Its amazing how good the voice acting these random npcs. Better than some AAA main characters in other games. RDR2 is a true masterpiece.

[@teacherfromthejungles6671]

that's why it takes Rockstar 10 years and two console generations to make a new game now

[@lordhanson476]

Rockstar's secret is that they killed real people's family members and then recorded their reactions.

[@FirEBeast]

@@lordhanson476ts had me cracking up 😂

[@xxmadmax999xx]

​@teacherfromthejungles6671 And robbing their fan base every year since GTA5 released. The new rdr1 port for example. $50 whole dollars for something 13yo with zero improvements. Just before that we get the buggy mess that is the GTA trilogy. All of this while neglecting RDO and making GTAO a worse hell hole every update. Classic Rockstar Antics.

[@rambo70141]

Like starfail?

[@mikdan8813]

"I'll never forgive you!" (Pockets two bucks at warp speed)

[@Gustav_Kuriga]

Refusing the money's not going to bring him back so...

[@Tinkletwisterthe3rd]

@@superiorduck3736💀

[@mythic6999]

Nah he wasted NO time taking that shi back

[@mrmb752]

Game is game is game is game

[@buckplug2423]

When you're a single mother with children in freaking 1899 you don't really have much of a choice

[@terrapinflyer273]

Man. The voice acting is just phenomenal in this game. Not to mention even the character model animations are pretty convincing at the same time.

[@BlackSmith6969]

@@beezyj3227 Bro just wait 1 more year and GTA VI will be released, Rockstar will use 70% assets from RDR2 and just imagine, that game will be the most detailed game in the history

[@galx9655]

Not really. Most of them are wearing hats and I can't even see their faces

[@johnsmith-i5j7i]

My face is tired.

[@jonbragg5175]

considering half the NPCs will pull a gun on you for simply walking by them, I think it's safe to assume that all 3 of the men probably had it coming.

[@rubentelur]

actually broooo they be so sensitive

[@JITCompilation]

I hopped on the side of a wagon just looking for a lift and the driver started shooting at me

[@Kamaulh]

This comment is just as evil lol

[@AlisonMendez-bx8tp]

@@JITCompilationI mean imagine if a stranger just hopped in your car ??? In America, that can def get you shot lol Not that weird

[@Betsy8592]

You need to request to ride first then if they say yes, they'll let you ​@@JITCompilation

[@stc3145]

Woman: «You killed my husband» Arthur: «Which one?»

[@nadeemkevka275]

😂😂😂😂soldier arthur

[@krishnarjunar2724]

​@@nadeemkevka275 MM: ✊😡✊

[@spiddlymcdiddly4201]

Broo I just binged that whole show last weekend. Soldier Boy was fucking awesome

[@dome4205]

damn that would be so savage if he said that

[@muthafukajones8114]

​@@krishnarjunar2724 Sean: Oi... not him, Micah is up there

[@txmclips7289]

Amazing how single one of these random encounters are voice acted brilliantly

[@Amadeus8484]

They did a good job.

[@Twistingmp4]

You say that like widows scream at you often

[@txmclips7289]

@@Twistingmp4 maybe not widows, but I have been screamed at by bitter and angry women

[@the1waffle4all72]

*Gives $2.00 for her husband's life despite having $5,000+ in his satchel.*

[@trevorwalsh9443]

That was a lot of money back then that’s like 60 dollars today.

[@commanderboom2626]

@@trevorwalsh9443 phew just enough to buy a copy of rdr2

[@xXSilentAgent47Xx]

They took 20K from Valentine bank among other parts that they robbed before chapter 6 and Bronte bank, yet it wasn't enough for Dutch. I wonder where they waste all that money? They cannot buy lands and only can get clothes & camp upgrades. Even if they got 5K from horses they stole in Chapter 3, it still wouldn't be enough.

[@rydersherm2490]

should have shot her also so she can join her husband in the game's memory dump (heaven)

[@PlushHIT]

​@@Michael.96 Well, seems like he was right about US in a way, but mistaken people for government

Dont you just love how he gets shit from every widow and even cracks a few jokes, but still has high honor LOL

[@fads90]

Yeah well he says ‘Hello’ to people all the time cheerfully so it balances his Karma out.

[@MarvinT0606]

@@fads90 plus dumping money and jewels in the contribution box

[@jeffwilliams3924]

After a long day of murderin', Arthur likes to kick back and go fishin'. He throws 'em all back, of course. He just does it it for the re-lax-ation (and honor bump).

[@BananaGusFringFan]

​@@MarvinT0606money and jewels of killed husbands

[@mangosaurusrex3416]

He rides around spamming “hey mister” after shooting up 87% of the town.

[@Robsonski96]

0:18 - Well, she's not wrong... 😅

[@gooddioOH6614]

I mean yea… just know someone probably shot the woman just for shits and giggles

[@nathanlarson7408]

For you, the day Arthur Morgan graced your town was the most important day of your life. For me, it was Tuesday.

[@Dolinnxn]

@SangiNET It's from the Street Fighter movie from 1994

[@tamelo]

I was going to post this...

[@jayess8714]

Dude, now THAT is a deep cut reference that I'm stoked I actually understood😂

[@ArgentumFox]

"It was a Wednesday!"

[@snoopywriter3643]

“I understood that the reference”

[@bloodyfitnerd1947]

"what's your problem?" I was just riding my horse, but now you're my problem, time to make someone a widow again.

[@jamesfandango9466]

Hahahahha yes

[@DoubleDee382]

Pretty sure that’s how this whole thing started.

[@collinmclaren6608]

Arthur: "Hey, mister!" :D NPC: "...Sonova ugly heifer!" Arthur: *equips explosive ammo*

[@Cody-ps3wy]

1:09 for anyone who’s lost here’s the moment here

[@dunzweiler]

*orphan

[@gutzbin]

2 dollars in 1899 is about 60-80 dollars in today’s money. Imagine the man who killed your husband and left you alone with 3 children gives you enough money to buy groceries for the week. Brutal.

[@RoyalestForte1000]

my mom had to spend 400 bucks this week on groceries alone, she didnt even get much, inflations a bitch

[@potencjalnypracownik2966]

@@RoyalestForte1000 buy cheaper you rich entitled pos

[@nickboi7270]

Interesting that the Annesburg widow takes it but the others don’t. Possibly life was rough In a coal mining town

[@PhantomEagle..]

Definitely, back then coal mining was atrocious

[@theotherohlourdespadua1131]

Before the Battle for Blair Mountain in 1924, coal mining in the US is rough to put lightly. Get injured while at work and it's basically enough reason to get fired or be forced to retire with pittance for a pension. Oh, and since coal mining towns were as temporary housing, anyone whose family member is not an employee of the mining company that owns the housing will be evicted... Oftentimes immediately...

[@Cartman4wesome]

@@PhantomEagle..probably did the Husband a favor by ending his life

[@paulrippcord506]

@@theotherohlourdespadua1131 16 Tons, what do you get? Another day older and deeper in debt.

[@GTAVictor9128]

In fact, Annesburg was a company town - a town built by the mining corporation where everything was owned by the corporations, including accomodation and the food at the stores.

[@Deyone_Jackson]

When the last one got scared and ran away saying "No, my baby needs me!", it really hit me in the heart for a second there🤧

[@pierrecurie]

Maybe she should have ran earlier, instead of shitting on the mass murdering monster.

[@B3rz_]

One time this lady was like "please I have a family" and I was like "not anymore you don't" as I dumped her hogtied ass over the bridge into the water to drown. It was *really* funny

[@Kokopilau77]

I was thinking my actions would’ve killed her for lulz and left her kids with nothing.

[@Enigma37_520]

😂😂😂😂

[@conraydo]

I was thinking the same. I also think I couldn't have fired that last shot after that.

[@ultimasterreviews3693]

" Womp Womp " - Arthur Morgan, 1899

[@Gogetavegito715]

Lol💀

[@FlaremoonDarkhooves]

"Skill issue" *gives 2$, then immediately proceeds to kill her*

[@Im2lazy4thisCrit]

“You killed my husband!” “Ok I’ll catch you later then”

[@mal_thespygirl]

Honestly, seeing how the women in the video delivered the lines of saddness, heartbreak, anger, and loneliness makes me feel their same pain. Great acting. It shows that your actions have consequences, that the characters around you matter, and how much the game is detailed.

[@NecromanticThrone]

Women 🙄

[@pylotlight]

​@@NecromanticThrone☕

[@realcritical-kr2dd]

Typical ☕️

[@AstraVoid]

Well there is nothing 2$ can not fix they will be fine

[@bujetpa5147]

@@NecromanticThroneImagine crying because you husband was killed and you need to raise three babies alone 😒🙄 everyone could do that Women☕️

[@d3viltube6]

That ending had me in tears. Wasn't expecting Arthur coming back looking to finish the job

[@cornpopwasabaddude4188]

Gotta see things through

[@JNGLST281]

That’s the kinda half assed attitude that’s wrong with the world today

[@shrimppimp4509]

​The hell are you talking about​@@JNGLST281

[@allamaadi]

@@JNGLST281😂

[@DedicationDeservesRespect]

That was an imposter, Arthur would never miss that badly

[@CrimsonSurvival]

I get rid of their Widows, too. I know, I’m mean. But if you won’t take the silver, better take the lead.😎

[@starstencahl8985]

I mean if there’s no one mourning left, it’s not even sad anymore technically 💀

[@sebastianacero933]

That makes us two

[@nevenneven8159]

I wonder what happens if you antagonize her then start shooting other married couples next to her..

[@LOLquendoTV]

Plata o plomo

[@ultimatecontagion]

Mean? My guy, you did these widows a favor. You deserve the key to the city for that alone.

[@jeezusjuice344]

The first lady came at me in Rhodes while working for the sheriff. I really didn’t appreciate the tone she came at me with, but I couldn’t shoot her for it, so I had to listen. And I came to realize how wrong it was for me to kill so many people. I felt so bad, all I wanted to do was reunite her with her husband, make it all right again. I apologized, and as I rode away, it came to me. I could reunite her and her husband. I turned the horse around and ran him as fast as I could back to the lady. That horse ran so fast, he smacked her right down to hell. And that’s how the horse Caligula began the reign of terror that would make him the third most prolific mass murdered in US history.

[@lukewarmmilk6499]

best comment on this video lmao, could totally see myself doing this if I got this encounter

[@Juancr2006]

Damn, that delivery was perfect

[@agingerbeard]

That escalated quickly 😅

[@crunkdaconqueror778]

Better death than getting hogtied and dumped in a river I suppose

[@thewanderingcreative7173]

Bronze medal’s not bad. At least you aren’t the gold medal, Lumbago

[@gabrieldossantoscosta4946]

Sometimes we forget, specially during the most emotional scenes of the game where Arthur helps who need the most, that he is the motherfucking grim reaper when it's conveniant

[@Nvrmnd8765]

100000%

[@caralho5237]

one of the reasons i dont feel sorry for him when he dies

[@mattt115]

Yea but like to think they were kinda like Robin hood . And mostly killed when needed or something . And he only bad if u make him too 😂😂😂

[@qwertyki9367]

@@caralho5237 well thats something new

[@jcoolguy1548]

​@@caralho5237 hey, at least he's better than Micah

[@MrCholoPants3415]

It's crazy how good the voice acting is in this game considering the sheer scope of the game. 500,000+ lines of dialogue... A truly one of a kind game.

[@dominickastelanac03]

Widow: "You killed my husband!" Arthur: *becomes MrBeast*

[@elirchi9214]

"This woman's husband is dead, so I surprised her with a new one." *does the freaking meme*

[@paulofelipebbraga9634]

At least Arthur doesn't try to sound like a good guy nor he make to stupid facial expressions Mr Beast does.

[@jraksysmagnanimous8622]

Well he wasn't that charitable here so I'd say MrCritter

[@ninjawizard7021]

Mr beast ? The dude that is friend with pedophiles ?

[@jcoolguy1548]

​@@paulofelipebbraga9634 but he is a good guy though. He's helping people

[@billbou2117]

Damn....I did some bad things in this game( as we all have) but i never encountered this. I had no idea Arthur could be this cold.

[@Я_Яша]

I mean it's y'all fan of him that keep bs about how kind he was, truth is its up to the player to decide if he will change or keep being a true outlaw, like c'mon he only realised he did wrong in is life once he was going to die, and before rdr2 events took place he must've killed countless of men and robbed many more, so...

[@vidhroh1538]

​@@Я_Яша But Arthur Saved Saddie Adler in the beginning of the game... he took her to his camp and allowed her to reside there even when his own camp mates were in desperate need to supplies

[@Meme-pv7tn]

@@vidhroh1538 umm.. Dutch did save her if Dutch wouldn’t approve arthur will let her die

[@KDizzy6]

“I’m not judging you, I haven’t only done good in my life either.” -Geralt of Rivia

[@jpiny4854]

@@vidhroh1538 It was more of dutchs decision and in another mission with charles arthur is quite cold with the family that had the father kidnaped so canon pre tb arthur is not that much of a saint helper.

[@divagaciones1628]

It's incredible how in this game, even the most random NPC has something interesting to say and delivers their lines with oscar-winning performance.

[@karstenvoigt7280]

"Oh, so there are some kids, who one day, when I've grown old and slow, might seek revenge? Can't let that happen. Show me those kids. Now!".

[@CrimsonSurvival]

😆😆🤣 I love it.

[@AdhvaithSane]

😂💀

[@sushanthadusumilli1067]

The plot of Last of Us 2 😂😂

[@arnvonsalzburg5033]

And the kid that seeks revenge just finds Arthurs grave. Deep story ;)

[@ultimatecontagion]

On God. We're not having another Abby in our hands.

[@pinkguycomments69]

"You're a good man Arthur Morgan, a good man"

[@XtraOrdinar-y]

Tbf this is only if you kill a lot of npcs in free roam so not really canon

[@SrChr778]

This is where Rockstar Studios is pretty much trying to tell you, "Do you even know what you're doing anymore? Look at how far you've strayed." In-game or not, all actions have consequences. Yup, even trying to sandbox a game isn't a consequence-free zone.

[@jediahramos2968]

Spec ops the line is a another example even if it wasn’t by rockstar

[@mellochello921]

Gta 6 will probably expand upon this both single player and online. Now your actions truly matter, and NPC'S will react to your rampage/ nonsensical killings. Rdr 2 online already has it with a bounty meter raising the more you kill innocents and other players killing you for money/ honor/ revenge for killing innocents.

[@makavili4429]

@@mellochello921 Idk I feel like GTA World and RDR World are two very different places. RDR feels more based in reality and morality, where the game forces you to self reflect on your actions and karma actually exists; whereas GTA seems to be more a satirical take on the modern world. GTA allows you to be cartoonishly evil without much consequence, conceding to the idea that it is a fictional world where you can do whatever you want for entertainment and comedic purposes, whereas RDR makes you bear the weight of true evil and consequence. GTA is satirical comedy like South Park, and RDR takes itself more seriously like a well written western action drama story.

[@waifung3367]

To her, it was the saddest day in her life. To Arthur, it was just another Tuesday.

[@atigamerofficial]

i killed rhodes one lol

[@unknownbannana8241]

Rejoin her with her husband

[@splashnskillz37]

A miserable tuesday at that

[@renzocontreras3844]

M. Bison quote 😂

[@Eantrin]

*Pulls over for the stranger encounter* *Doesn't listen* *Hands over medicine hoping for a free purchase at the gun store*

[@TheMessiahOfThe99Percent]

Noobs: give health potion Gentlemen: *Suck out venom*

[@mfelix3511]

@@TheMessiahOfThe99Percent S L U R P

[@jollycooperation7446]

*Buys most expensive item putting the stranger in debt they can't pay off*

[@dannymiller3315]

​@@jollycooperation7446 lol

[@MarvinT0606]

that fella saved me over $100 when I got the Springfield for free 🤣

[@WhiteHawk77]

“You killed my husband you bastard” “LEEENNNYY, You seen my friend Lenny?”

[@darthgamer9468]

1:10 The NPC getting agitated, because you rode "too close" to him, is hilarious.

[@mythic6999]

Bro I hate those guys

[@littlefairygirl161]

😂

[@aminetanouyat9643]

you pass like 500 meters away from them and they will get offended and annoyed lmaaao but maybe its the speed, they are like slow down, you are in a town with people walking through idk

[@Broodjemetbeleg]

​@@mythic6999I've wasted countless hours killing those guys lol.

[@m.a.a.d9275]

​@@aminetanouyat9643yeah its 100% the speed. It would be like driving 90 in a neighborhood

[@U-A710]

“You’ll get yours, I swear it.” Poetic justice my friends. Arthur gets his indeed.

[@ConfusedRevolutionary]

Some get theirs sooner than others. Like the widows..

[@Senior215]

Imagine the dialogue: “ooh I’m scared! What are you gonna do, give me an incurable disease that will force me to spend hours upon hours doing side missions in feeble attempts to prolong my life?”

[@Grunpex]

​​@@Senior215💀

[@CoolSaver]

"I guess you can't live a bad life and expect something good happen to you"

[@reidparker1848]

All of those innocent lawmen and soldiers, murdered by the self-pitying "hero" the game community fawns over. Himself blasted by Micah on a ridge somewhere in the not-Ozarks. He at least helped John try to leave.

[@DarthWall275]

"For you, the day Morgan killed your husband was the most important day of your life. For me, it was Tuesday"

[@sanlorenzo7896]

Rhodes Widow: “No, my baby needs me!” Arthur: “You should’ve thought of that earlier…” 🔫😏

[@NoName-hg6cc]

Arthur: "I'm gonna put some led in your eye"

[@Nyxtroos]

Revolver time

[@alexman378]

You want forgiveness? Get religion.

[@AFeralTrout420]

That does sound like something low honor Arthur would say 😂

[@Niuskayz]

"You killed my husband!" "Ok, here you go. 2 dollars." That's evil as hell Edit: grammar

[@kidtechnician9691]

Chad moment

[@BarrackObama348]

You do know ah stands for as hell, you said as hell hell, if you're gonna blacccent at least blacccent right

[@bkr1895]

“I believe thats the going rate”

[@e_sidera]

Ok but that a lot of money back then right?

[@Niuskayz]

@@e_sidera I believe you could say that (or not I dunno), 2$ in 1899(the time when the game took place) is about 73.52$ as of 2023. Either way I don't think 73.52$ would be worth the death of significant other but that's just my toughts

[@Lackhatred]

1:59 even the npc’s deserve an award damn

[@louthegiantcookie]

"I'll never forgive you!" Okay, then give back the money?

[@rickstick8421]

"Nah, it's mine now sonny"

[@air4045]

Yeah because any amount of money makes amends for killing someones loved one and she didn't take it because she's desperate

[@Hornywizard]

@@air4045 it’s a video game, I don’t think she really needs it😭

[@maksymalnybul6145]

@@rickstick8421 No Sonny. I don't have the money...

[@rickstick8421]

@@maksymalnybul6145 that was my money Tommy my money!"

[@amarantine1323]

This game is so insanely intricate. It's been years and I still find new videos showing new scenarios that I never even knew existed with dialogue and interactions that I've never heard.

[@theharshtruthoutthere]

lets analyse the lies which are world wide believed: lie: schools are of use (fact. schools keep slavery alive and stands for dumbing down the population of mankind) lie: moon and mars landings, (fact: even masons know they cannot leave - earth is closed system, unless you want to drown, there is no other place created for us to live in.) lie: news channels share truth (fact: these are for politic propaganda) lie: voting matters (fact: politic propaganda) lie: money has a value of its own (fact: it is just a tool of this world, which value has been agreed upon world wide) lie: NASA lies (globe and all....) (fact: NASA stands for TO DECEIVE) - you havn´t searched - have you? lie: the lgbtq++++ propaganda (fact: it is a part of masonry depopulation agenda, 500 000 000 souls, thats their goal.) lie: Evolution and the dinosaurs. (fact: mankind is not hybrid kind) to keep stating that there was an evolution, then we ain´t humans, we aint then mankind, we are then hybrids. Are you a hybrid? Lie: holidays (xmas, Halloween, new year eve and so on) (fact: PAGAN HOLIDAYS, to praise BAAL, the god of this world) lie: U.F.Os (fact: they are demons/evil spirits in high places, against whom we fight daily = spiritual warfare) lie: rules and laws rule the world (fact: signs and symbols of masonry do) lie: believe in being educated (fact: found daily living with the lack of knowledge) lie: religions are ways to heaven (fact: JESUS CHRIST is only way to heaven. Religions, no matter its name = masonic garbage) lie: our dead loved ones stay around to “ghost” (fact: hunting and ghosting is job of demons, not of humans. We, humans, come from GOD and return back to HIM and all the stories of having been seen a ghost - terrifying, scary, dark, cold - again no job of analysing been done here by you- right?) Lie: Humans have no immune system and we need vaccines as these save lives (fact: humans HAVE IMMUNE SYSTEM and vaccines are created for one or two purpose: to kill or to cripple) lie: there is no GOD (fact: There is GOD, who redeems sinners and created us directly from the dust of the earth: Psalms 139:14 I will praise thee; for I am fearfully and wonderfully made: marvellous are thy works; and that my soul knoweth right well.) to keep claiming that there is no GOD and we aint created directly from the dust of the earth, we soon run out logic, regardless to we place “evolution” in our claims or not.) lie: 911 was terror attack (fact: 911 was an inside job, meaning the work of your loved government) lie: Tv watching is of use (fact: television (TV) = tell a lie vision, a weapon for our minds, keeping it under MK ULTRA) 18 lies, should i go on? This world ain´t deceived, out there to deceive?

[@SunBunz]

Damn, the actors gave it their all, and most people never even seen this! I can’t believe how I keep discovering new things in this game no matter how many years pass!

[@MrTheoriginalderek]

"You probably don't remember doing it!" Arthur, "Honestly I can't remember which save that was."

[@ThepursuitofHappiness-fb8iy]

"It was the first save you ba@#$&"

[@silenraven1017]

The fact the Rhodes widow says her husband names gives her much more depth in the game than the other two

[@nutcrackerreal100]

theres a black robed kkk leader with the last name wesley

[@Anomalous_Bill]

2:35 when the lady stands next to that light pole there is a face on it. I have been collecting images throughout the whole game and they are hidden everywhere in the game. If you use photomode on that lightpole where she stands and mess with the filters and the brightness etc it will make that image come out more clearly. I been thinking of making a video at some point of all that i have found because i haven't seen anyone else mention it. The paintings in this game are cool to look at also with above method also.

[@muerte9O9]

Make a video

[@JizzyF83]

Widow: “You killed my husband!” Arthur: “Would you like to join him?”

[@nobody-yk2hu]

I go for high honour but next time I start a new playthrough I'll go for low honour

[@bulkvanderhuge9006]

I've been trying to be good in the game, but I swear the game doesn't want you to be good. I was at a crossroads, where some "White Dot encounter" wanted to take my horse and started shooting me, so I killed him. So while I was trying to hide the body, a stagecoach went by, so I had to shoot everybody in it and hide the bodies to avoid a bounty, but people kept coming through the crossroads while I was trying to hide the bodies. Eventually I had bodies laying around all over the area, and just rode my horse far into the woods, and snuck into Strawberry to pay my bounty.

[@igiari_objection]

Lets just place you under chaotic good 😂

[@zekeiwa5837]

i mean you could have easily escaped and pay the bounty after the first time you got spotted but you chose to murder several people over 5 bucks so you're not THAT good

[@cptaustro3157]

Pretty sure you can just leave if it's an encounter where they try to steal. Long as you don't lose honor, I don't think the game will count it as murder and more self defense... at least that's what I've seen in my game so far.

[@yoavbenclaudia3073]

So long as you’re quick enough, you don’t have to hide the body. It’s not modern day. They would have no way of tracing any of that back to you, even if it were in real life. In game, it’s even easier than that. As far as constant movement on the road, yes, I agree that the spawn rate makes the roads seem a bit busy, and I’m sure crossroads have a higher spawn rate (understandably). Just learn the spawn rate based on location and time of day, if you ever want to mug someone. Playing an honorable playthrough, usually you aren’t burdened for self defense, and even when you are, you don’t have to kill the witness. The game teaches you that mechanic early on, that you can threaten or even sweet talk (and I think bribe?) witnesses to calm them down. If you’re worried about the hassle, then just bolt it as soon as you’ve killed an attacker. Standing around dead bodies is was makes you suspicious in the game.

[@dft3091]

Nicky Santoro : [voice-over] A lot of holes in the desert, and a lot of problems are buried in those holes. But you gotta do it right. I mean, you gotta have the hole already dug before you show up with a package in the trunk. Otherwise, you're talking about a half-hour to forty-five minutes worth of digging. And who knows who's gonna come along in that time? Pretty soon, you gotta dig a few more holes. You could be there all fuckin' night.

[@RafaielGames]

You’re a good man Arthur Morgan a good man

[@luvmibratt]

The fact Arthur tells the women they are so worked up like they just crying over spilled milk was hilarious then dumped on em with 2 dollars 💀

[@posadist681]

Then I make my Arthur spill his milk inside them 😈

[@silvergift]

The amount of wedding rings I've collected from bandit camps will never cease to surprise me. I'm sorry but if you settle for a low ranking O'Driscoll with $0.50 to his name I think your life was ruined way before some dude named Arthur used your husband for target practice.

[@dustinchamberlain9626]

I always just figured it was from people they had killed and looted themselves.

[@holdenlol1196]

Bro this comment is so funny

[@elijahanderson6478]

I collect em like there trophys 😂 30 wedding rings means 30 husbands killed lol

[@Psilo-gn1sx]

"Wow these bandits sure have a lot of wives!" 🙄😂

[@Gentleman...Driver]

@@elijahanderson6478 lmao 😅

[@sbfhawk4343]

Its wild how the world around you in NPCs will act towards you when your vile and evil in character but when you are right and upright you are left alone to be in Peace and always admired

[@longtranthanh8544]

1:46 “Sure I’ll pay. With 2 dollars.”

[@Lupo32]

You like jelly beans ? I got some jelly beans - roger clark

[@anguslazy]

i cant believe arthur travelled 100 years into the future to eat jelly beans

[@Lupo32]

@@anguslazy It has been claimed that jelly beans were first mentioned during 1861, when Boston confectioner William Schrafft urged people to send his jelly beans to soldiers during the American Civil War. In United States slang during the 1910s and early 1920s, a "jellybean" or "jelly-bean" was a young man who dressed stylishly but had little else to recommend him. - taken from wikipedia

[@anguslazy]

@@Lupo32 i cant believe arthur travelled 40 years into the past to eat jelly beans

[@LordNifty]

Widow: "You killed my husband!" Arthur: "Do you have the slightest idea how little that narrows it down?"

[@regularguy12379]

"YOU KILLED MY HUSBAND" "i missed the part that's my problem"

[@joshklaver47]

"Nice outfit. Did your husband get it for you?"

[@B1argB1arg]

“Pizza time!” - Arthur Morgan, 1899

[@markgolden4807]

Dutch: we need money💰 Arthur: YOU WILL GET YOUR MONEY WHEN YOU FIX THIS DAMN DOOR!!!🚪🎭

[@kaybevang536]

Bully Maguire Dance By Arthur

[@AlExAnDeR30285]

"Gonna cry?"

[@Reggin2]

2:55 she hurt Arthur’s feelings

[@mikk.t.7824]

I agree arthur cried

[@adamrobinette6832]

You take things for granted when you play games like this. Seriously, hundreds of hours of little things to find, and the thought was put into it, to have these widows. And not only give thing spoke dialog, and interactions, but like with the last one, dialog and specific reactions to you pulling a gun on them. Anyone that doesn't think that video games can be pure art, have never taken the time to play a game like this one and really appreciate the incredible details, and how long it took to think up, and implement them all to where it would feel like a living breathing world.

[@constableconstable2563]

This has only happened to me once: I killed a guy in Valentine in a duel then his widow said he was a good man, even though he killed a man in a duel before me. This game does it's best to make you feel like an absolute evil bastard.

[@m.hisyam982]

You have to shoot at his gun or hands to gain honor

[@weswolverine]

I lost honor for defending myself against an NPC by a campfire who just started shooting at me. Like bro, you got it coming

[@merlinho0t]

This game is nothing short of a masterpiece. Years later and I’m still just learning of new interactions.

[@striker8961]

If they are so worried about providing for their children they should probably not start screaming at the man they believed killed their husbands in cold blood in the middle of the street.

[@RobotDanceBunny]

I usually just kill the widows if I'm already on that evil of a playthrough.

[@skeletonjanitor]

I let them live to feel the pain for the rest of their life

[@jaymac7203]

​@@skeletonjanitor Jesus christ. This game must be an essential outlet for you! 😂

[@Airhotpilot]

​@@skeletonjanitor Jesus my guy 😂

[@PhantomEagle..]

​@@skeletonjanitor I did that with the slave owner

[@tomc6217]

​@@PhantomEagle.. I used him to complete that horseman challenge where you have to drag a guy half way across the county. It was made even better by my accidentally dragging him through a campfire...

[@Onii-chan_choso]

Widow: You killed my husband and probably dont even remember. Arthur slowly loading revolver: Neither will you

[@brianT8721]

I did this one time with a lematt revolver, it was one of the npcs that robs your horse. I had it on express ammo and slowly loaded it too regular ammo, let him get on the horse, switched it to shotgun and fired.

[@Bomboclat-521]

"YOU KILLED MY HUSBAND" "Here have 2 dollars"

[@philly_sports1558]

This is honestly a better way of making you feel bad for your negative actions in a game than all of Last of Us 2. In RDR2, you can choose to be as cold-hearted and evil as you want, so when you see the consequences, it hits different. Last of Us 2 forces you to do violent and evil things over and over again with contrived writing, and then expects you to feel guilty when it’s all over.

[@albertwesker404]

That wretched game......

[@John-996]

For real RDR2 does such a great job of that. Manhunt is another game that lets you brutally kill people but its up to you as the player to decide how brutally you kill enemies. Kingdom come is anothet game that felt so immersive it felt like I had actually killed someone. Last of us 2 tries to make you question violence but I feel like RDR2 and Manhunt did a much better job at making me actually think about my actions. I feel like this much more in the strength of a video game then being forced to kill NPCs in last of us 2.

[@lisagonzalez1371]

Technically, you could stealth your way through most of the game, but I don't think it changes anything

[@philly_sports1558]

@@lisagonzalez1371 It still forces you to torture and kill certain people or animals. Except for the one person you were trying to kill the whole time lol

[@eminayeart]

​@@philly_sports1558 FACTS!!!

[@matias_8823]

For you, the day Arthur Morgan graced your village was the most important day of your life. But for me, it was a Tuesday.

[@Nozoki]

Came here for this.

[@captaintorchman1046]

0:35 dayum Arthur, this one is cold

[@Jumpyman_thegamerYT]

"You left me a widow" "Would you like to join your husband?"

[@albertwesker404]

What me, you, and every bloodthirsty player is thinking.

[@kevinthomas2906]

I would have ended all 3 of them

[@silvirhunter3607]

They do make express rounds for that reason, I'd wager.

[@tonychopper9142]

Arthur: "well, you should get with the other widows I've made and we can start a brothel, make me rich"

[@ottovonbismarck8460]

@@kevinthomas2906I did

[@schoolruler2]

The last one was more realistic of a heartless killer

[@benjaminwilson1804]

This is one of the thing that differentiate rdr2 with other games. U can feel some of your action has consequences. Absolute masterpiece 😊

[@eddiesmith5617]

All it needed was a widow or even a boy, or girl to try to take you out because you killed their husband/father. That would have been epic.

[@mad_nax9678]

If you like that sort of game, try true RPGs like Baldur's Gate, Witcher 3 or Cyberpunk. To name a few.

[@kingsgaming2265]

​@@mad_nax9678 played witcher 3 it's a good game but not comparable to rdr2 Cyberpunk 😂😂😂 Don't know about baldur gate

[@kingsgaming2265]

​@@mad_nax9678and why u mentioning other games in rdr2 video Rdr2 has a cult fanbase and no matter what u do people will still love rdr2 because it's the best game ever made.

[@Akuankka000]

@@kingsgaming2265chill out, he was recommending similar games. He didn’t mean anything bad by it, why are you getting so worked up?

[@SorryBadName]

“Sorry ma’am. I didn’t really want forgivness. I just gave you the 2 dollars so i had an excuse to rob you”

[@lisvender]

I never encountered this while playing, but I do remember looting a lot of wedding rings….

[@warrr_machine]

00:23 sorry ma’am. I have a train to rob and passengers to rob then kill for more money.

[@seppegielen2946]

love how the valentine woman won't take the money, but in annesburg she'll probably starve if she doesn't take it

[@OfficialPrinceKane]

"Wesley huh? I'm sorry.. he must have been a good man" LMFAOOOO

[@goatlps]

3:08 Those men must've been slow, this guy can't shoot for shit.

[@BruhDidYouKnowThat]

I don't know who to insult better here

[@krayzieridah]

Red Dead Redemption 2 is the most realistic game ever made. The attention to detail is out of this world. Even to this day's standard.

[@1012Games]

Sometimes I forget just how much of a menace you can be on this game

[@vicslick3]

“he probably had it coming” did it for me 😂

[@Joeljaboy]

Dude that last voice actor’s delivery was fantastic, really chilling

[@nathanchristman6660]

0:42 at least he was honest

[@Buschyo]

Damn that line delivery of he probably had it coming for the valentine widow sounded so different than the Arthur we know

[@24nickrodriguez]

That line was real cold.

[@shagrat6686]

Huh , sounds like nothing to me ,i have some plans for these encounters tho :>

[@leocookies1844]

​@@shagrat6686 Damn, you must've never played Undertale, bet if you did, you would've LOVED the Genocide route~ (Lol even i do slaughter NPCs but when i have cheats activated cuz idk, its kinda fun having unlimited ammo)

[@brendanbarham6062]

You must know a different Arthur 😂

[@antwandadon2341]

Ngl that line was ice 🥶

[@lordtachanka903]

Her: “you probably don’t even remember which one he was” Arthur: “I don’t remember which one he was” Her: “you monster”

[@tdegrddeehjgd]

True low honour players would have reunited those people with their loved ones.

[@Timewalker13]

🤝

[@ultimatecontagion]

🫱🏿‍🫲🏼

[@papajohn365]

Stranger: "You killed my husband!" Arthur: "Okay, catch ya later!"

[@intelligentspeculator7327]

Damn it's so realistic and so well acted. Jokes aside, I still remember the old GTA games from the early 00's, when killing NPC's had absolutely no emotional impact. This here genuinely feels like I'm a really shitty person and almost makes me sad.

[@Oll1000]

almost

[@Manlikegibbon]

@@Oll1000 Damnit I was gonna say it.

[@aneshkumar4513]

​@@Manlikegibbonif this game makes it almost then GTA VI sure makes you

[@Manlikegibbon]

@@aneshkumar4513 I'm finna be wanted for 365 murders within one day.

[@aneshkumar4513]

@@Manlikegibbon A year murder in just one day nice

[@arcadeofgames]

the game trying to make you feel bad for your actions makes it so much better.

[@MaxMustermann-go8xf]

The random interactions in RDR2 have better voice acting than the vast majority of games provide for main characters.

[@FrOhhhhZeN]

I can’t ever play a bad character it’s makes me feel awful

[@igiari_objection]

Same I try to play it that way at the beginning but then I subconsciously start making decisions that are positive and from there I completely flip back to being a good karma boy 😂😅

[@toaster4869]

It's so much fun though 😭

[@22QXX112]

​@@toaster4869 you evil bastard hahaha lol

[@gaunterodim8131]

I like to antagonize all these "tough men" in valentine but in chapter 6 I go to Saint Denis and spam greet button

[@andrewlowden322]

@@gaunterodim8131 *"HEY THERE, MISTER!!!" "HEY THERE, MISTER!!"* (repeat 4351243761257 times)

[@returnto_monke]

Mr Beast: " First widow to lose husband wins 2$"

[@gaminghellfire]

"You monster, you killed my husband" Me: How bout i renunite you with him 😂

[@ConfusedRevolutionary]

What a missed opportunity for such cold dialogue.

[@PotatoMan420]

Rockstar put so much detail into every single aspect of this game, if GTA 6 is half as detailed as this, it'll be a masterpiece.

[@SergeantExtreme]

Don't hold your breath.

[@mr_niceman]

first there needs to be a GTA6 ;-;

[@brendanbarham6062]

It will be a masterpiece. Or a shit show. No in between.. this game has suffered every single delay known to man. A literal generation has passed and two new systems created since gta 5 came out. And now with Rockstar once again delaying the release until 2024 or 2025. Theres no telling what will transpire between now and then to prevent the game from coming out as scheduled. Its sad. At some point you just gotta go with what ya got and build on future games from there. Revision of this gta 6 has gone on far too long.

[@border_collie7991]

The main guys who made rockstar great left or got pushed out by Sam Houser. I wouldn’t be surprised if GTA6 isn’t as good as previous titles considering the current state of gaming

[@AymanTravelTransport]

@@brendanbarham6062 crazy how by the time GTA VI comes out (assuming it is 2025), GTA V will be as old as GTA III was when V came out!