Replica By The Fireplace by Maison Margiela Fragrance Review! | CHESTNUT & VANILLA Goodness!

[@12345678927164]

Loved this when I tried it today. Picked up a bottle. Reminds me of good memories. No false advertising here, so is safe for a blind buy, which is rare these days.

[@laurasutcliffe723]

I sprayed By the Fireplace on my wrist in Sephora and I initially did not like the scent it gave off. But the dry down had me smelling like a toasted marshmallow, mixed with slight bonfire smoke smell for the rest of the day and night. I couldn’t stop smelling wrists and my friends were following me around all night telling me how good I smelled. I really love this perfume, and I’m bummed that I’ll have to put it away soon for the Spring/Summer season. But come next September and it’ll be heavy in my rotation. 😌🤍🧡🤎

[@marilyn96]

By the fireplace it’s my favorite from MM. it’s does reminds me moments from when I was younger I cried the first time I tried in a MM store i wasn’t expecting to be this real. I don’t own springtime in a park but it’s on my wishlist to me it’s very lovely.

[@giannilollo769]

by the fireplace is for me the best scent from the replica line

[@kanamichelle7404]

I grew up in the mountains and ski areas and lived in cabins with fireplaces. This brings all of that to mind. It smells like when you have spent a fall evening in front of a bonfire or campfire, after a day on the slopes, talking with ski bum friends, roasting marshmallows. When you go inside you smell like burnt wood and smoke, and something sweet. I actually would have named it Campfire or Bonfire, as I think it smells more like an outdoor fire experience, with smoke permeating your clothing. For me it is full bottle worthy!

[@calebnei8276]

I love it! Toasted marshmallow!

[@adambogdaowicz2266]

I wore this at work and one of the construction workers that comes through told me I smell like Thanksgiving.

[@Redolessence]

Oh wow! Haha. I'll take it as a compliment

[@adambogdaowicz2266]

Will you review mac's my heroine? And point the people into something in that direction because it's discontinued and that kills me.

[@rholandtubban3413]

Haha

[@ditomasso6089]

One of my topnotch fragrances. I always get compliments whenever I'd wear By The Fireplace, really love the Vanilla scent it projects. Solid 10/10 winter fragrance!

[@migwigpee0796]

For real. I mic it with a citrusy fragrance during summer and it creates the perfect mix too. It’s super good layered

[@Emerold7777]

MY top 4 are: Coffee Break, Whispers in the Library, Jazz Club, and By The fireplace.. I also enjoy Autumn Vibes, Sailing day, and Macha Meditation

[@beatrizsandoval4395]

I just received it today in the mail. I had never smelled it before but I instantly fell in love with it. Sad here in California our cold weather is not long so I won’t be able to wear it much.

[@yungmimi5325]

wear it anyway, as long as you’re in a place with ac, and even without ac. think about middle eastern fragrances and how dense and sweet they get, yet middle easterns wear them despite them being near the literal desert lol 😂

[@PsalmsGirl]

I love By The Fireplace. It took several wears before I was hooked and it became one of my winter favorites. I also like Under the Lemon Tree and On A Date as summer fragrances.

[@TheKonnoisseur11]

REVIEW: This is a unisex masculine-leaning scent of burning fireplace wood that has been smoothed out and slightly sweetened by vanilla and orange blossom so it does not get too perfumey or feminine. Smelling like a fireplace is definitely unique (especially with the Peru balsam and clove) but simultaneously familiar. This is for those looking for a versatile soft woodsy and comforting!

[@warner04]

I've tried the Replica discovery set. Great value to try many of their popular frags. With that said, for me, I think "By the Fireplace" smells too smoky. My favorites are "Sailing Day" and "Jazz Club".

[@paulwillson3081]

That’s strange because I prefer by the fireplace as I feel jazz club is too Smokey

[@BA-cz4is]

@@paulwillson3081jazz club is the winner I like both but jazz club is more appealing

[@jojose417]

Just blind bought By the Fireplace looking forward to getting it!! Warm spicy woody vanilla are all right up my alley

[@DiegoDeschain]

I absolutely love this line's presentation.

[@kaidenkaufman7192]

Got a little sampler from goldengate mall in san fransico when i lived there. Loved it. Kept it for awhile after i used it all. Gonna get a bigger bottle of it now

[@TheExtremetraveler]

This is an outstanding scent - but wow, I found hypnotizing fire by Harmonist - and I think it just encompasses the smoky, warm, seductive aura just thaaaat much better. I say that if money was no object. Since I am on a fragrance budget however... this one hits it out of the park when it comes to value.

[@Angeloojohnson]

Hypnotizing fire is my hands down favorite fragrance I get compliment every and I mean every time I wear it

[@tlpcmour]

Definitely one of my go to’s for fall and winter fragrances!

[@blackcat6508]

My favotites are Soul Of the Forest, Across Sands, By The Fireplace and Jazz Club. Sadly the whole perfume line (black bottles) got discontinued a couple of years ago.

[@rare3014]

Not sure why but women LOVE this fragrance. First time i wore it 3 coworkers commented how good i smelled.

[@beardwiley]

Just ordered Jazz Club, which will be my first Replica fragrance. By the Fireplace was the other one I was looking at.

[@sodriscoll77]

Hey, this is my favourite from the brand, the candle of this perfume is on my list. Next I love Whispers in the Library, Jazz Club and Coffee Break.

[@jts4248]

I got it I love the smell but I can't see myself wearing this. I'm going to try it on a real cold day again

[@lookhowshegobbledthat]

Top tier fall/winter scent. Will always have a bottle. Lasts firever on clothes and prefer that over spraying on skin. Very smoky burning woods and cloves in the opening with a very sweet marshmellows and smores drydown.

[@ZokiUtoka110]

Can it be worn in spring?

[@lookhowshegobbledthat]

​@@ZokiUtoka110 No. Winter, maybe a very cold fall day. Not versatile, I prefer to wear it on outside clothes, like a winter coat or scarf. Will linger for days.

[@latonyagipson-bowman9186]

I have a few travel sprays from the house and this is one of them and I really like it in the warmer months

[@Redolessence]

Nice!!

[@liamsi75]

Searched for Beach walk review, surprised you didn't do one.

[@Redolessence]

I know! Haha. I really need to review that one! Thank you for watching.

[@londontomas7612]

I love by the fireplace and jazz club mixed together and on their own! I also love bubble bath❤️

[@sondesix_]

Oh wow, I thought you have reviewed this one before. It really is very good. I fell in love the first time I smelled it, and if it becomes way too sweet or cloying, I just layer it with something fresh. 😅 A great review!

[@Redolessence]

So glad you love this one!!

[@thuggathuggababy]

whispers in the library is prob my favorite. Also liked under the lemontree, by the fireplace, and jazz club

[@jrashada]

I love By the fireplace but could you recommend something similar but more unique and a little longer lasting if possible. Thank you and great content

[@enzay6740]

This is way better than Jazz Club IMO. When I smelled Jazz Club in the store I instantly thought of a smoker in their late 60s

[@GetaRidebyRyan]

Really like this fragrance. When I got this one, I also got a decant of Scents of Wood Praline in Maple at the same time, and man they are so similar on a test strip.

[@mheberling5939]

I do not own any, but I have been impressed with some that I have sampled.

[@christinayoussef7482]

This is one of my few favorite unique scents I have ever tried, I tried on 2018 love itttt so much but I was so disappointed with the longevity and progection 😭😭 even with over spray it doesn’t last on my skin or my clothes for more than an hour 🤦🏻‍♀️

[@jov6826]

Yeah, that's what I find as well. It doesn't last long at all. 1 hour top.

[@g0dspeeed546]

nose blind

[@jov6826]

​@g0dspeeed546 true... cos 2 weeks ago i went to see my parents and they could all smell it.... i was like "how can this be!?" Lol But yeah noseblindness.

[@98vboon]

In general, hows the longevity in the Replica perfumes? Seeing it as EDT, and also, the pricetag.😂 All info is welcomed, thanks in advanced!

[@nxd010]

Nice scent, which I have and I love it! But it last not very long unfortunately. Penhaligon's Babylon is a great alternative in my humble opinion and it lasts longer! Have a nice day

[@MiamiSammy]

In the dead of winter I spray this fragrance basically every single day. I rarely wear it out of the house but I always have it on my sweatshirt at home or blanket. I also have “marshmallow fireside candles” so my whole house just smells like this cozy masterpiece.

[@latonyagipson-bowman9186]

Hey Steven, let's hear your thoughts on this one

[@traffictraffic]

I dunno man, my nose sucks. With this one I only get ash and burnt wood, nothing else. I do however really like Jazz Club. With what I smell I can easily, easily close my eyes and see myself in a jazz club, sitting down in a leather couch just chilling and listening to some jazz.

[@JT-rx1eo]

I have many frags from the Replica line. Maybe my favorite is Soul of the Forest. I like By the Fireplace, but Jazz Club a bit better. I like Under the Lemon Tree. Its underrated, as is Autumn Vibes.

[@mikejesus1882]

Just the best fragrance reviewer!!! Thanks Steven. Nice review.

[@dansaklofskerealestate]

I'm surprised by how many positive things people had to say about this. I love Jazz Club, but when my wife and her friends got a smell of By the Fireplace, they all thought I smelled like I've been sitting out around a fire.. And that's not a compliment. The smoked/burnt smell makes it just a little too unusual, and is just a little too much for my taste.

[@besti2715]

I just got mine and it’s super…. I would say late night old smell? With cigarettes / vanilla?????

[@Mr37kirk]

Bubble bath is good too a clean smell

[@makobay]

My favorite from the house is "Across Sands."

[@JT-rx1eo]

I've got a decant of Across Sands. I like that scent profile, but I think Serge Lutens Arabie does it better.

[@Computerlegacy]

Ok im not goina lie i thought the name Replica meant it was a replica of another brand lol not and actual brand line made by Maison Margiela

[@darkstar_destroyer377]

I enjoyed "Music Festival" but, by and large, I find MMM parfums a bit lackluster. In a large market, they just don't stand out.

[@Redolessence]

Thank you so much for sharing!

[@iykischiang2036]

啊 我终于知道这个牌子怎么读了 我一直读成mayson margila

[@ANSWERTHECALLOFJESUSCHRIST]

I LOVE By The Fireplace. I find it unique and beautiful, but what I like about is is precisely what makes some people totally hate it. 😅

[@elijahumogilevsky7004]

Thanks a lot for the great review! Made me subscribe to your channel immediately. Do you think that By the fireplace would be a nice present for someone liking the leathery Bottega Veneta perfume?

[@labandademozcas2127]

How does this compare to Forest Blends from Scentologia

[@Redolessence]

I haven't tried that one. Sorry.

[@Mr37kirk]

Thank you for doing this Channel you are good. Could you do a review of fragrances that stay on your clothes? I love when I pick up a sweater or a jacket that smells like a fragrance I have. Sometimes fragrances smell better on clothes

[@GabeGarrett-t7s]

Great video Steven!

[@MoahGentle]

Jazz Club doesn’t last on me nor is it unique enough for me to warrant a fb purchase. Not bad though but to me BtF is one of a kind. Perfect for colder weather, nights or even a date night. Sweet, cozy, nutty, gorgeous parfum.

[@lookhowshegobbledthat]

I agree. I like Jazz Club, but not enough to get another bottle/refiller. Very sweet vanilla rum and pepper that makes it almost coconutty with faint tobacco in the background. I'll probably will always keep a bottle of BTF.

[@guyson99]

I wish I liked this more (it's always smelled like 99% smoke to me), but I'm looking forward to their new release "Under the Stars"

[@latonyagipson-bowman9186]

Thank you for sharing this review

[@Redolessence]

Thank you!

[@Tobertus]

Hi! Love your content, keep it up :) I was searching for a top 10 Montale fragrances from you but it appears you did not make that one (yet). Do you anticipate making one because I would love to see a top Montale list. If you have the collection of course.

[@Redolessence]

Thank you so much for all the kind words! I would love to make that video in the future! Thank you!

[@Tobertus]

@@Redolessence that's awesome, take care!

[@TheFragranceDecantBoutique]

Can’t wait to try this one ❤

[@cote96able]

Jazz Club is a wonderful warm spicy sent for the wintertime. I don't care for By The Fireplace.

[@MrDefjam100]

jazz club is way better imo

[@goldstarchoice]

For me personally, the women go CRAZY for this. My wife doesn't want me wearing it without her around.😂

[@Bruce661]

I have By The Fireplace and Jazz Club. They are both solid in their own ways and I've received an equal amount of compliments with each. Unfortunately on hold for the next few months here in North America...

[@labandademozcas2127]

They had them at my local kohl’s today

[@persianprince91]

Skip the name brand and go with Woody Chestnut by Dossier (inspired by this fragrance).

[@adjeibarnes3716]

Jazz Club is solid

[@oforistanley]

Does it last long?

[@christinayoussef7482]

Absolutely NOT 😢

[@heem2941]

@@christinayoussef7482dam

[@infinityseren1]

Jazz club and By the fireplace are my two favorites from the line so far. I do love Autumn/winter scents the best.

[@BTCentral]

Review sailing day

[@Redolessence]

Thank you for recommending it

[@oberzocker3D]

Thank you, fragrance Jake gyllenhaal

[@Bammyy]

lmao

[@donnahibler8374]

All her stuff smells better after it’s been used and left in the bottle for a bit.

[@polarbear8188]

i really smell something burnt at the end ofmiddle notes. i even can imagine stone house or stone fireplace. its a painting in fragrance.

[@mind-of-neo]

Ngl i don't like by the fireplace or jazz club very much 😂

[@meralddrayton2106]

Yes It doesn't last long st all.

[@mtoconnor9898]

At the barber

[@Redolessence]

Thank you for sharing

[@gamalielcenteno4801]

👍👍👍👍

[@mancuniamancunia9212]

Looks like & smells like vape liquid in a bottle 🤮

[@2WheelsForever]

Jazz Club made me gag. Ot was too mediciney with the opening. Sent back for a refund