Response to 23 Questions - Part 58 - Singing and Music ( Ghina aur Moseeqi ) - Javed Ahmed Ghamidi

[@Adept.maneuver]

I got goosebumps 😳. How can one be so knowledgeable and intelligent at the same time. Allah Pak ki hi tareef hai jo Us ne Ghamidi sahab jese log paida kie is dunya mei. JazakAllah!

[@khawarnadeem1807]

ان صورتوں کوترسےگی چشمِ جہاں کہ آج کمیاب ہیں تو کل ہمیں نایاب دیکھنا

[@fjs921]

@@khawarnadeem1807 اُف...

[@farzanayasmin912]

JazakiAllah khair

[@MohammadUrfan]

@@khawarnadeem1807 بلاشبہ۔۔۔!!!!

[@tahmidrahman8527]

Allah ka panah aise sakshiyaat se

[@adilmapnoo837]

The only scholar who changed my complete perspective on islam. Alhmadulillah i am now a better muslin, a logical muslim. Can never thank this great man for the impact he has on me.

[@drtariqhabib]

Totally agree.

[@mujtabas]

Yes so many has the same opinion what you said.

[@MohammadUrfan]

Me too...!!!

[@MBilalShaikh]

I agree with you, it has happened to many of us

[@noorazeemkhan5206]

Seriously my brother... 100% agreed

[@thewanderingdervish]

Wah. This is the difference between a Moulvi and a Scholar. Beautifully explained. Ghamidi sahib just nailed it 💝

[@NaushadShafkat]

Allah-o-Akbar! What a great intellectual! Unbelievable mastery on his subject. Ghamidi Sb's scholarship is amazing. Allah bless him with health happiness and a long life.

[@IshratJahan-gg5cy]

Mene Aaj Tak itni gehrai se kisi ko bolte hue ni suna. He is like knowledge from depth to surface of ocean.... Allah aapke knowledge ko Puri duniya mei shaya kre aameen

[@zmisolutionz9393]

Most awaited series... اللّٰہ استاد محترم کو صحت مند زندگی دے اور ان کی عمر دراز فرمائے آمین

[@dawoodkhaninfosolution6462]

Ameen

[@tabindanaveed8261]

آمین

[@fazalhakeem1910]

Be ikhteyar AP k ly Yahi Dua dil sa nikalti ha.. k Allah Aap ko hifzzzzz o aman ma rakkkkkkey...

[@AMMADUDDINQURESHI]

May be 10 years from now most of the people will start to understand him. A true gem , A master .... Love ❤️

[@khurammushtaqch]

Masha Allah zabardast kia khoobsoorat andaz say baat samja di .... Ap jaisay logoon nay firqa wariat ki jarain hila di hain ... Allah ap ko istiqaamat aur zindgi day aur hum logoon ko deen ki samj ameen

[@maanmustafa8153]

ماشاءاللہ۔ شاعر والی آیات کی مثال دے کر آپ نے مدعا ہی سمیٹ دیا ، بہت عمدہ دلیل سلامت رہیں ❤️

[@zorozoro4806]

Allhamdu lilah ghamdi sahab ko dekh ker or sun ker dill ko sukoon aya ..... ghamdi sahab ko dubara achi sehet de ker allah ne sari ommat per ahsan kia he ....

[@muhammadaslamjavaidmalik3708]

Alhamdolillah! Series ka dobara aghaz hua! Maza aa gya! Skoon aa gya! Allah Ustaad e Mohtaram ko hamesha sehat SE rakhy lambi Umar k sath. Ghamdi sb ko sunny k lye highly qualified zaroori ha! Allah Ghamdi sb ka saya hum pr tadair salamat rakhy. Ameeeen!

[@rashidkhan-jw3ob]

serior ki agle epsiode kb aya ge

[@Jamal-gd4xk]

We should share this knowledge to world so people at least will start thinking especially Muslims. Allah apko sehatmand rakhe ustad Ghamidi sahab

[@Umair0047]

Alhamdulillah. Allah SWT aap ko sehat dandrusti wali lambi umar atta karein Mohtaram Ghamidi Sahib.

[@imtiazmemon1764]

Shukir Alhamdolillah , Ustad mohtram back again in this series.

[@aliraa3196]

At last........Was waiting anxiously......Ghamidi sahab ....is an ocean of Knowledge, Chosen by Allah, The man of Islamic Manners.....

[@sm-hh5005]

Great Tohfa for us

[@hunainshoukatsoomro2057]

I think, this series is outstanding bundle and explosion of knowledge

[@ni2980]

Thank you so much for resuming this series. Allah ghamidi sahab ko hamesha salamat rakhay.

[@muhammadrayyan6681]

Ghamid sb wins the argument on poetry, splendid

[@TheO_siddiqui]

Kya Andaz he, kya guftugo he Masha'Allah❤Allah sehat aafiat Kay Sath Zindagi de. Aameen

[@husnainarif6309]

Allah o Akbar Ghamidi sahib ma sha Allah Kya ilm hai aur smjane ka tariqa hai Allah khush rkhe apko

[@itsmylife318]

Gamidi sahib you are a remarkable man and intelligent scholar .

[@djkirmani7984]

What an excellent discussion from Ghamdi Sahab ! An eye opener for those who argue on Music and singing haram in Islam . There is a fine line to enjoy these funoon or art ! May Allah bless Ghamdi Sahab with long life and unlimited Ilm o bayan Ameen 🤲

[@ThinkDeep_Official]

Very logical , unbiased and research based true analysis. The crux of music like other thing How you use . ( it's far from present day so called Ulema)

[@Malik-eo3qe]

Guys please pray for our Ustaad Emam JAVED AHMED GHAMIDI sahab❤

[@uroojkhalid7430]

اللہ ہدایت دے بیچارے کو۔

[@ashkehlan4743]

About Professor Javed Ahmed Ghamidi, I not only believe that there is no scholar of his stature profundity of religious thought and precision of its understanding and lucidity of his articulation in the Muslim word, but I also believe that I have yet to see anybody more profound just and humane than Professor Javed Ahmed Ghamidi sahib, when it comes to commentary on social issues including human rights. May Allah bless his countless blessings upon Ghamdi sb! Ameeeeeen. ( USTAAD MOHTARAM MAY YOUR SEED PROSPER GOD WILLING)

[@javediqbalamc]

i wish for my nation to wait for this series instead of any other every week.. and watch this with all members of family sitting together both youngsters and elders alike learning from the greatest scholar of our time .. may ALLAH bless you with a long healthy life Ustaz e muhtram

[@muhsinkamal9988]

Amazing. Ghamdi sahab jab koi baat baayan krta hay to aisa lagta hy jaisy poory kaa pora deen usky saamny bilkul wazih parha hy aur un may say ghamdi sahab baat samjha raha hy... Kamaal k aadmi hy.. Allah lambi zindagi ataa farmayein

[@zmisolutionz9393]

اللّٰہ کا ہزار ہا شکر کے اتنے تنگ نظری کے ماحول میں جہاں دین محمد کے ماننے والوں نے دین کو ایک ناقابلِ قبول نظام کے طور سے پیش کرنے میں کوئی کسر نہیں چھوڑی ہے وہاں اللّٰہ ربّ العزت نے مجھ جیسے گناہ گار کو ھدایت دیں کے لیے استاد محترم کی فکر و استدلال کی جانب راغب کیا، شاید کبھی صراط مستقیم کی دعا دل سے مانگ لی ہوگی۔ اللّٰہ استاد محترم کو صحت دے وہ میرے لیے روحانی باپ کا درجہ رکھتے ہیں اللہ تعالیٰ ان کا سایہ مجھ پر رکھے۔ آمین اور مجھے بلکہ ہم سب کو سیکھنے اور اس عمل پیہم والی زندگی اور آخرت میں بارگاہ رب العزت میں شرمندگی سے بچنے کا موقع فراہم کرے۔ اللھم آمین

[@asifahmadbhat9693]

Ghamdi sahibs interpretation can satisfy anyone.

[@robbykiller2323]

No he can't satisfy the stupid.

[@ArifKhan-ds1od]

@@robbykiller2323 😄😄 true that

[@centric145]

What did he sa8d?can u summarize?

[@farrukhyousaf4799]

Read sahih bukhari 5590 hadees

[@lifebysanasaqib]

omg, i was sooooo happy when I saw this on my feed!! So good to see you guys return to these series. May God bless you and the entire team! Ameen

[@oye214]

I love Ghamdi Sahab’s Khusay. Suits him well.

[@sairaqureshi8470]

Wow..... so true and logical. Why any scholar could not think like this before

[@centric145]

Please can u summarize what he is saying?

[@qaiseransari8867]

@@centric145 Ya, music is not prohibited by it self but how we uses it, if it is vulgar then that is prohibited .

[@centric145]

@@qaiseransari8867 thank u

[@bilalsaeed220]

Incredible, accurate, and applicable explanation

[@muhammadahmed719]

Thought translation of the word اثم is not accurate

[@fazalahmadkhan2412]

Jazakallah sir, great scholarly analysis.May you have a long life

[@awaissahib6394]

MashaAllah Allah hidayat or ilam my mazeed barkten ata farmaen or tmaam muamlat ko ehsan samajh kr umaat ki rehnumai ki tofeeq ata kren.. Bohot acha laga apki guftagu sun kr... Meny shaid 29 saal my pehli bar itna bara byan suna ho ga kisi mozuu par

[@owaissadiq9050]

Sir I think no one in this world right now can explain this topic in such a discipline way of speaking that you have done. Your are unique person in this world right now. I pray and hope Allah Pak give you long healthy life with peace and happiness. Ameen

[@haroon420]

I love his logical and academic view at looking at religion and how precise his language is! ❤

[@the.learning.muslimah]

Dont go for intellectual answers. Go for how our Salafus saliheen understood Islam

[@JavedAkhtar-vs5wz]

Alhamdulillah Very Very clear Jazak ALLAH khairan

[@sattarbhatti2222]

بھت خوب۔جزاکم اللہ خیرا۔

[@muhammadazfarjaweed8424]

Zabardast Ghamidi Sb. Allah àap ke Saath hai. Jealousy ulma se ghabrana nahi. Allah àap ko apni hifazat main rakhay.

[@zarinaahmed5255]

He is a great scholar have a great patience and manners

[@haroon420]

Alhumdulliah a man of stature such as Dr Ghamidi being around in the time and age of social media!! We’ve got so much material available from him!! ❤❤❤

[@zameersarwar7219]

May Allah Pak bless both of you

[@aqibbashir1986]

Wow !!! Waiting for Hadith vs Sunnat series!!

[@rashidkhan-jw3ob]

7new serior kb tk aya ge

[@aroosausmani100]

Mashaallah kamal ki zahanat or philosophical mind dia ha. Ghamdi sb ko...Allah pak mujy apni life ma in say bil mushafa mulaqat ka sharf aata kary...he is such and inspirational personality for me...Allah blees him with good health n long life...aamen

[@muhammadadeemakram6717]

Ghamdi sahib you are 100 percent correct in interpreting religion through logic. If we try to understand Islam with logic and knowledge then we arrive at correct understanding of what Allah expects from us. Our heart beat is a perfect form music Bestowed by Allah.We hear Music in wilderness , in mountains and plains, Allah provided this environment to his Man.

[@mdaslam7148]

Allah Ghamdi sb ko sehat aur lambi umar de ameen

[@ynsltd]

A long wait but much pleased to see Ghamdi Sb healthy. A very informative episode.

[@umairalikhan47]

Was anxiously waiting for this series continuation.. Much love

[@MoliChachaykiBeti]

شاید غامدی صاحب اس صدی کے مجدد ہیں۔۔۔۔اور ہم نے خوش قسمتی سے ان کے دور کو پا لیا

[@leomalcolm6786]

Bhai ho skta ap theek ho but sab kay apny apny mujadid ha 😅

[@farrukhyousaf4799]

Shahih bukhari hadees 5590 prhein or dekhein apky mujadid shb kitny sahi hain

[@SaqibMehmood]

@@farrukhyousaf4799 o mere bhai ghamidi sahab ne Quran e paak se sabit kia h kisi baat ka asool, agar koi hadeeth Quran e pak ki ayat ke khilaf ho to iska matlab wo hadeeth ko sahi mano ge tum???

[@ksu222100]

واہ جناب کب سے غامدی صاحب مجدد ہو گیے؟!!!

[@zarakkhan4259]

Yaqeenan

[@duadua8900]

Jazak Allah

[@Umair_Linguistics]

Masha Allah sir. May Allah give barakah in your knowledge.

[@pashteen8348]

*Achaaaa *... I like the way hassan ilyas says it

[@ambreenrafiq9719]

😀😀😀😀

[@ambreenrafiq9719]

Same here

[@ibnerohani5656]

jazakALLAH true scholar may ALLAH give to sir Ghamdi sahab long life that we can learn more.ameen

[@rihanhashmi5538]

Aahaha jawab nhi zabardast lecture

[@MalikOsama-dt3cc]

Mohtram Ustaz Imam! may Allah give you long and healthy life so that we may keep learning from you.

[@taplrahimyarkhan6012]

Amazing perspective to understand Islam.... Ustad Mohtram Zinda Abab. Allah Apka Saya hamesha Slamat rakhy. Ameen

[@zafarsaeed4488]

What a logical n appropriate way of making people understand about issues vis a vis Islam

[@farooqmuhammad6939]

Now i am wondering for those 38 who have disliked this intellectual discussion of premium quality . Agreeing or disagreeing is different but presenting a rational and logically bringing to a conclusion is done here remarkably by ustad. javed ahmed ghamdi sahib. May allah subhan watallah be happy with him.

[@kjkalam]

Sir I m very very thankful from the bottom of my heart ♥. U have not only reconstruct the religious thoughts but also RE LIVE the original اسلام. Thanx sir once again. ALLAH APKO BEHTAREEN JAZA SE NAWAZE. Aur apne hifz o amaan mai rakhe. AAMEEN

[@fawadsumar4178]

He is the genuine reaserch scholar with proclaimed 1400 years islam which is a true islam concieved and preserved by peace be upon him and followed by thier companions. Hands off to you sir with lots of love and respect.

[@hafishah5086]

Wah bohat umda ghamidi sahib salamat rahein

[@muhammadsafdardurrani]

Bohat khoobsoorat tateekey se aur tafseel se bayan kiya ghamdi sab ne...masha Allah

[@yousafkhalid4870]

Very good knowledge thanks Love for Ghamidi sahib.......

[@Adnchz-jh4ct]

JazakAllah❤ Complete knowledge of islam, Ghamdi sb Excellent ❤

[@centric145]

Please team Ghamidi saab ,we need more "advertising"on Ghamidi saab in the English speaking world.The west is plagued by salafi wahabi islam .JGsaab can cure us but please we need more translations and a way to make him known to this part of the world.

[@fjs921]

If ten people who liked the point share with ten people each, it is good enough. Do your part, they are doing theirs with limited resources. Thanks

[@jabeenmughal6847]

What a great asset for the generation I love his lectures and addicted to his knowledge I can't sleep without listing to him May ALLAH give him the healthiest and longest full of knowledge life Aameen

[@amjadshekh4731]

ZazakALLAH

[@nursinglecturer]

JazakAllah ❤❤ Excellent!!!

[@drjollygood]

Stunning Brilliance!!! O people !!! Try to understand Ghamidi sahib, He is a living legend: imam of the present time. He is no ordinary Islamic scholar. A razor sharp intellect cutting through multiple and dense layers of fable to uncover the source of legend. Civilisations are ascendant when this level of scholarship and depth of research becomes their habit. They decline when a culture of mythology, cult or blind following decimates the search of truth. Wa maa alena illal blagh.

[@kamranhashmi009]

Amazing! Amazing! Amazing! Amazing! Former guitar player turned molvi! I agree totally!

[@amirnazirviewers2112]

What a man yaar... I had to miss many classes because I couldn't pause your lecture. Love you ghamdi sir 💕

[@pakiahsen]

Mashallah. Ghamidi sb is explaining the religion of Allah as Jesus Christ pbuh explain in front of Jews. As Jews rejected Hazrat Essa pbuh similarly muslims are doing same. May Allah give hidayat to muslims

[@shabeerm.8854]

MashaAllah, samajh agai baat, Allah Aapki umar aur sehat salamat rakhe

[@bilalsaeed220]

Bht hi alwww sir.. Best Islamic Scholar 👍👍👍

[@tabassumhussain3703]

عرصے سے انتظار اللہ صحت عطا فرماۓ آمین

[@muhammadamjad327]

سبحان اللہ ۔۔شاعر والی مثال دے کر سمندر کو کوزے میں بند کر دیا۔۔غامدی صاحب علم کا سمندر ھیں ۔۔بیان کی روانی بہت متاثر کن ھے۔۔ربط اور دلیل۔ماشاءاللہ

[@syedhassan233]

اللہ تعالی محترم غامدی صاحب کو صحت و سلامتی دے 💐

[@majidaziz6178]

Masha Allah mind blowing

[@muhammadArshad-tt5tu]

Very thoughtful sitting.

[@sci-today]

much awaited! 😍

[@MuhammadImran-ne9cd]

Long awaited. Thanks for continuing the series. The topic of music must be very interesting. JazakAllah

[@saimali239]

Zindabad ghamdi sahb buht achi misale dete hen

[@abdulnasir2699]

Barak Allah.

[@abz0909]

Jazkallah for uploading, excellent points raised

[@Itsasim72]

JazakAllah❤️

[@zuhakhalid3139]

Excellent discussion 🥺👍 He's the moral creator of the era, born after centuries.

[@shaziasaher3557]

MashaAllah JazakaAllah May Allah G bless you both in ur both lives Ameen

[@211skt]

Worth listening...

[@shanawarPTI]

I have never seen anyone talking with such clarity. Every word that comes out of his mouth has a whole philosophy behind it. True researcher of our beloved deen. Afsos iss baat pe hota hai k gher zaruri naam nihaad islami ulema ne islam ki aisi shakal pesh ki hai humesha se k log seham k islam follow karain na k feham se. Ghamdi sahb Allah aap ko apnay hifz o amaan mai rakhay aur humain apnay ilm k zakheeray se roshan rakhtay rahain

[@gulnawaz7789]

ماشاءاللّٰه ۔۔۔۔سبحان اللّه

[@thesapiens5479]

Please, for this important knowledgeable series.., create an English subtitle.

[@kabir9222]

Ghamidi sb is a gem 💎 for Islam

[@IrshadUllahOfficial9]

Ma Sha ALLAH

[@umarsiddique1207]

Allah bless him❤️❤️

[@dskhann]

40:48 behtreen! MashaAllah

[@anasss1180]

The more i hear u the more i got connected with islam The more my love with god increases

[@ibn2257]

پروردگارِ عالم میری دعا ہے کہ آپ اپنی اِس آیت کی عمر دراز فرمائیں۔ آمین

[@AbduulBasit]

Ameen

[@mha8252]

آمین۔

[@buttaurangzeb5412]

Javed ghamadi is just love it allah aap ko sehat aur tandrusti day all time great for me I don't think any other better prayer than this prayer allah qabool farmaey aameen aurangzeb butt from Switzerland daska sialkot siranwali ❤ ♥