Reviewing Every RWBY Episode Volumes 1-3 Compilation

My Patreon: / judgmental_critter
My Merch: teespring.com/...
My Twitter: / judgmentalthe
My Comic: www.tumblr.com...
For October of 2023 I decided to challenge myself and release a review every day for the whole month! This is for all those people who don't like flooding their watch history with a bunch of extra vids!

[@jesterfairy3845]

"I'm tired of being the lovable idiot" Jaune, don't say that about yourself... "Lovable" is way too generous

[@yersonpanqueba9263]

The Pokémon battle has begun! -Citter used video's recap; video recap was negated... -RT used copyright strike; it's super effective! -Citter used Zelda's red heart background; it's super effective; it's a critical hit! -RT has failed, Citter has won the battle! Citter got the medal "RWBY's Video Recap N°1".

[@SaraBanartist]

Going over these episodes reminds me of how much more impact these fights felt like they had early on. And I mean literal IMPACT. Yang whaling on that Ursa and Ren soloing a huge snake felt heavy, like there was weight to the blows. It also reminds me of how, later on, I'd start to get real confused why one threat is worse than what we've seen these characters handle previously. Like, Ren totaled that snake...so why was the Grim that wrecked his village such a problem? Were its stats higher?

[@calebkelly8221]

Yeah, it's still a puzzle to me how the heck Ren bodies the snek so early on... Made me think at the time, "Wow, this grimm is one of the really big but weak ones, or Ren has too much skill for animé warriors academy."

[@monokuma2104]

This whole video is just a reminder for me on how torchwick was a good villain.....sassy and funny

[@CodeTetsu]

Something about the edited footage makes me feel like I'm watching Rwby on a Nintendo 3DS

[@johnynoway9127]

the racist protag could have worked if it wasnt just...there for 1 episode. like yang's arm

[@momonomo2008]

Weiss being racist could’ve been done well if it was actually treated as the issue it was and not just some random character flaw. If they had dedicated time to show her work over her prejudices and learn why she was wrong it would have worked- but they just didnt

[@johnynoway9127]

@@momonomo2008 like...most things in rwby..

[@uhagi6720]

Looking back on it, Weiss ending her trauma enforced racism in the span of a day, over a girl she barely knew anything about, should have been a CLEAR sign that RT would completely butcher their racism plotline.

[@VenathTehN3RD]

@@momonomo2008 And I feel like the way they portray her later in the series, particularly early V7, only kind of exacerbates the issue. Specifically the encounter with the drunk man in Mantle where he calls Blake a "stupid faunus" and Weiss responds by yeeting him into a dumpster...when Blake, the person who is part of the group that (at least by RWBY's terrible standards given how rarely they actually demonstrate it instead of just saying it happens) experiences oppression, was attempting to peacefully deescalate the situation. So they essentially went full White Savior Trope in order to show that she's totally not racist ("See guys? She used to hate the faunus and now she assaulted a civilian for saying a mean thing to a faunus! Look at how much she's grown!"), and did so at the cost of completely disregarding the agency of the actual member of the minority in question. Because actually spending time on developing and addressing that character arc is hard, but solving it by just making Blake regress into a meek and passive damsel so that Weiss and/or Yang can save from the big bad bigots - thus showing off how not bigoted they totally are in the process - is easy. Not like Blake's entire character arc for the first half of the show was about her learning to take back her autonomy and finding the best way to stand up against those who hurt her, her family, and her race or anything like that -___-

[@madelinehattertea]

Scatman world

[@sawesomeness]

Scatman Crothers

[@madelinehattertea]

@@sawesomeness what’s a crothers

[@sawesomeness]

@@madelinehattertea A great man. RIP

[@ElyssaCaouettedavies]

And also, they have proven many times. maiden eye flames match the eye colour of the Wieler, not the aura color. If Nora became a maiden her eye flames would not be pink they’d be blue like her eyes, winters maiden eyes are same as her eyes, Penny is a perfect example. Her flames are green like her eyes and ravens is red like her eyes. I don’t understand people keep thinking that the maiden eyes match the aura when they are supposed to match the eyes

[@randomguy7946]

Will you be doing one for 4-6 and 7-9?

[@thejudgmentalcritter6584]

Yeah! :D

[@bluefacestan1826]

Would have been cool if ren had the summing semblance

[@naturescorruptedinfactorie8062]

It would’ve made sense considering his backstory relates to the Grimm

[@Nightflowerr14]

Literally the best part about this video is the voice overs at the end of each review. Makes me laugh every time

[@bigpapastalin601]

Idk why but I've been simping over your voice and laugh. Karl would approve of this

[@Ribena-s9x]

Do 4-6

[@derrickdaniels3955]

That'll be fun

[@supersparrowJ]

4 and 6 should be fun to revisit. Can’t say the same for 5.

[@BrisketBlues]

are you gonna review the other volumes?

[@thejudgmentalcritter6584]

I'm planning on it!

[@calebkelly8221]

​@@thejudgmentalcritter6584YAAAY! THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU

[@JadeMoore-w9w]

Also having the racist character wear white is a bit iffy

[@theironarmada1308]

Hey, it happened! Thanks for taking my advice!

[@kaitofuang1180]

Yes the day has come for second best judge to come back with a new video of RWBY medicine to keep me in check of future project of story pacing and building😁😆👍...and despite it's the beacon arc, which is the greatest, I can't deny the do's and don't you point out that I'm taking note of. 👍 I love always your analysis and comments videos you post, so I can't wait for Haven Arc, cause I can't wait to hear your loving comments on them, especially for Volume 5 😂since I can never forget your group review you post on Volume 8😁👍 always gets me laughing.😂 Thank you for always being one of my few dose reality check of how to do a proper story, let alone a story with actual characters development and getting me away from the RWBY craziness compare to others that are blinded by the fandom crazy ideals of shows.🙏😊 Thank you for the reminder that I'm myself and have my opinion with agreement or not, with my right to express as well. 😊👍🙏 I can't wait to see more videos on your review on all the others shows than RWBY as well. Keep up the amazing work and Happy New Year for the future luck you shall receive.😁👍🎂🎉 P.S- if your wondering why I have you as second best judge, I'm sorry to say there's no beating Judge Judy when she judge the many I've watched now that I'm older to understand what the heck my grandparents were watching when I was baby-sat. And seeing they are surprising yet also brutal almost similar to how you are with each of your review videos of the show.😆👍🙏❤️

[@Kawaiikitten39]

Please please do more compilations

[@ElyssaCaouettedavies]

I have to say that ports conversation with weiss and Weiss wanting to be leader I think was very good, the way u described It is nothing like the actual scene.

[@aisushitai2680]

Already watched each video when originally uploaded in the RWBY-thon but I'm so glad to have the entire series in one big super-comp. I have absolutely no problem rewatching this series.

[@nadlanod5897]

Now this was peak RWBY.

[@terrantitanium6441]

becasue

[@natenate3353]

I didn’t notice that for like 10 minutes 😭

[@thefoxmaster753]

You could explain blake not being with everyone by saying she was with another group launching in from somewhere else wich would explain how alot of the other becon teams formed.

[@dariusbrawl3759]

16:30 If i'm not mistaken, it's kinda implied he lied about who his grandfather was?

[@MultiBoxingKid]

Really?

[@skyslasher2297]

14:22 I feel like I’m one of only three people to like this arc. Like team JNPR and their stories blow team RWBYs out of the ocean and into the trash bin and Jaunes story here is the start of that.

[@terrantitanium6441]

censorship :(

[@astereotypicalgamer1708]

The nostalgia...

[@codman4372wx]

Well i have 90 minutes of work left. Now i know what to watch

[@tigerchild3676]

I remember watching RWBY freshman year of highschool when it was only two volumes out. Now I’m in my last semester and senior year of college and rewatching the whole thing with my brother. I feel nostalgic, and while I still have my criticisms with the show, plus shaking my fist in the air at RT for being a shit company, I have to owe it to RWBY for putting me on this path in the first place. I like storytelling, I like art, I want to write and it’s all thanks to this show I found thanks to a Come With Me Now AMV of this show when I was just starting out with anime. Quite the full circle.

[@tmate88-j8y]

Volume 3 is probably still my favorite volume and Volume 1 Chapter 8 my favorite episode.

[@calebkelly8221]

Hot take: There are signs of Bees as soon as the forever fall forest episode. Watch Blake closely and you can see her looking at Yangs butt.

[@healingbunnyboi2742]

Penny has always been the softest part of the show to me. I love the song Friend so much and it genuinely makes me cry sometimes listening to the lyrics

[@timothyacowin9761]

3-12 is the best episode in rwby. 6-6 is great but 3-12 is responsible for the plot

[@pipisochkaaaa]

I only in this video realized that the setting is called "the world of remnant" and all i can think about now is remnant from fnaf

[@tuliobednarczukpecinemisko5606]

Nice recap!

[@timothyacowin9761]

Season 3 ep 3 is so ruby at her funniest. When she meets winter and she reunites with grow. Pure gold.

[@timothyacowin9761]

Yang vs neo is still the best fight in the show. It's perfect

[@voxthetvdemon1030]

Anyone wanna do a story together involving rwby?

[@voxthetvdemon1030]

Anyone interested?

[@calebkelly8221]

​@@voxthetvdemon1030what kind?

[@voxthetvdemon1030]

@@calebkelly8221 like a fun crossover roleplay kinda deal in the comments like we are now

[@calebkelly8221]

@@voxthetvdemon1030 I'm good

[@voxthetvdemon1030]

@@calebkelly8221 oh well it was gonna really fun and full of action and to be honest I was really hoping someone would agree

[@soulsearcher117]

Sorry for the long reply about the Spotify thing. I just woke up, but how much revenue do they make? Also, how many subscribers does the voice actress for Ruby Rose's character and Vtuber known as Lindsay Stone have on the Twitch website? Cause I've read that once a month, for every subscriber she has, she gets either $5 or $25 from all of them.

[@thejudgmentalcritter6584]

I have no way of knowing any of this information.