Reviewing ONE OF SCOTLAND'S MOST EXPENSIVE RESTAURANTS - THE WITCHERY!

[@GaryEats]

Hi all. A real tough one to film and edit this one today. Fine dining videos aren't always the easiest to video but I hope you enjoy it. Thanks everyone! Of course, I also meant stomach... not bladder. Maybe needed a trip to the bathroom!

[@patrickwong4824]

Just a suggestion but I like James Andrews's style of fine dining video. He does it with the voice-over and don’t think he has a cameraman.

[@WendyS-3]

Looking forward to this Gary ❤

[@puredeadmagicman9652]

Did enjoy it, thanks, it was like being there! 👌🏻

[@accountnamewithheld]

Maybe message the restaurant in advance for their least busy booking next time? And explain what you are doing. Though I'm sure you're famous enough by now...

[@kathyhayden2499]

I like Gary's style of presenting,I guess each to their own❤

[@stuartcarter7053]

I love how Gary reviews a posh place like this and then the pub that gives three courses for £4. And always honest. Brilliant review as always.

[@Suzyfromtheblock]

Agreed ❤

[@GaryEats]

Thank you Stuart, I love mixing it up even though I prefer the pub ones lol

[@George-nb5oj]

A 3 course meal for 4 pound home cooked that's is unbelievable in this day and age amazing

[@aberdeendeltaforce]

I was thinking that, I subbed instantly when he reviewed the starbar in Glasgow, he has a nice vibe about his videos and it’s the perfect escape from the madness of the world right now.

[@AbrasiveScotsman]

I'd feel a million times more comfortable in the Glasgow pub than that place. £110 for one person? Flipping heck.

[@teresaharris-travelbybooks5564]

We stayed at the Witchery in 2019. We didn't have an evening dining experience, but we did have a complimentary breakfast every morning. Breakfast is served in a cozy, downstairs room that has red brocade walls, candlelight, and linen tableware. And we could order whatever we wanted. Staying there is like living in a castle. Yes, a once in a lifetime experience, but it was fabulous.

[@GaryEats]

That is absolutely wonderful to hear. I’m pleased you had a great visit.

[@ZG0002]

It really is, the rooms are something else and service is just as good.

[@wildrover65]

This highlights the fact that Gary is the people's reviewer,he goes from a place that serves £4 dinner's to a restaurant that does lemon sole at £50 ending with a bill of £110 total. Same enthusiasm,same honesty,same sense of humour..I just woke up,eyes stuck together,can't focus but as soon as I saw the new review I started my day off with a smile,thankyou Gary

[@GaryEats]

Thank you very much my friend, means a lot

[@Lulubelle.III.]

I can see why GaryEats is number one across the globe (and yes, he truly is). A kind and humorous Brit who eats with a fork, knife and spoon. Gary respects every restaurant, its' patrons, the food, and his fans with honest reviews and honest critiques. He uses adjectives other than "tasty" and "delicious." Gary continues to captivate an ever-growing audience with his authenticity and charm. Thank you, Mr Gary for providing a little bit of laughter and a lot of love in every video you release. Cheers, from across the pond. 🍻

[@GaryEats]

Thank you so much for your wonderful comment again you don’t know how much that means to me so thank you very much once again and please have a wonderful weekend

[@paulrobson7887]

I went to Edinburgh Uni and when I graduated my Mum & Dad took me there for a special celebratory treat. That was 30 years ago but I still remember it being one of the best meals I’ve ever had.

[@GaryEats]

Fantastic!! Glad you enjoyed it Paul

[@katieblair1000]

Gary's such a gent. I love how considerate he is of the other diners when he's filming. Top bloke. 👍

[@GaryEats]

That’s very kind to say Katie thank you

[@WorksopWhiskey]

And that Gary is why you’re definitely one of THE best food tubers on this platform. So so respectful not just for the establishment’s but the other paying customers around you. Basically the majority of the rest don’t give a monkeys about anyone else wherever they are. Note to all the others….be like Gary!!

[@GaryEats]

I really appreciate that, thank you

[@friendlyhorseuk7220]

I wouldn't say one of the best food tubers, I would say THE best.

[@wellypreston]

As soon as I saw he had posted this I made a brew and a smoke and thoroughly enjoyed the 18 minutes .

[@JimR-km1yf]

Be like Gary.. there's a good thought for the day 😊

[@jeremymoore6106]

My wife and I were in Edinburgh back in 2000. We were lucky enough to enjoy a meal at this incredible restaurant. Thank you for bringing back cherished memories. It was, as Gary said a once in a lifetime experience. We did and do not eat out at restaurants, expensive or otherwise very much. This was a real treat. Worth it.

[@stephenleonard6336]

Well done, Gary. A great advert for Edinburgh! Well done for being so respectful about your filming! Class!

[@GaryEats]

Thank you very much, Stephen

[@Mickmickster]

Recent subscriber, great channel. No fluff, no silliness, just straightforward reviews. Very refreshing.

[@GaryEats]

That’s very kind to say Mick thank you

[@annieterminetschuppon7232]

I don't get having to pay additional side dishes for a main having nothing sided! It's never ever happening in any restaurant in France. A main always comes with its adequate side dish not like an additional hotelier profit . At the dish price, they can afford to give free boiled potatoes😮

[@ridstock9663]

Unfortunately because its on the Royal Mile in a very touristy area they can get away with it but i agree £7 for some blanched spinach is absolutely shocking behaviour, especially when the main costs £50 already. Profiteering at its worst.

[@simoncleveland8993]

They charge for vegetables and then have the cheek to charge you 10% service charge on top

[@patrikpass2962]

Am I missing something but isn't there restaurants charging 10 grand out there?

[@RiverDanube]

Absolutely agree. Also, if they are a fine dining restaurant then the chef would know what sides are going to be best as a combination. Once upon a time, fresh bread was also served and a good restaurant would offer a sorbet or other mouth cleanser between courses. Now restaurants want an added service charge. What will they think of next?

[@JohnSmith-il3kv]

@@RiverDanube What will they think of next?.... Maybe VAT on the service charge!

[@mikebriggs9243]

What I love about your food reviews is you go for a cheap 3 course meal to a high end restaurant and you give a fair review every time. Cheers Gary.

[@GaryEats]

I really appreciate that, thanks Mike. It has to be fair, a lot of people like the fine dining videos which is why I do them. I do prefer the home comfort though. Take care and have a lovely week

[@hazzaknox1069]

I used to live in Edinburgh and still study there. So glad that as a journalism student, you are giving the place some love, especially the restaurants and bars that make the city thrive! Awesome work as per usual

[@GaryEats]

I love Edinburgh 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

[@debrafrost5264]

Another great review Gary and I love how considerate you are towards others. The food looked amazing and the restaurant was gorgeous, thank you Gary and cameraman for the top notch video.

[@geishasha]

The quality of the Haggis shows it was free-range and not factory farmed, as so many Haggis are nowadays.

[@GaryEats]

This was top quality

[@bhodge9380]

LMAO at free range haggis. Not sure many haggis get to see a sheep bladder nowadays. I would've gone to The Kitchin in Leith for a fantastic lunch.

[@simplesimonhadapie]

​@@bhodge9380I suggested this or the scran or scallie in Stockbridge. Leith has loads of brilliant places to eat

[@Kim-Jong-Un-4]

free range Haggis lol 😂

[@knighttemplar99]

Haggis should be raised to run free in the fields as nature intended 😂😂😂

[@mpbrooks]

As a Glaswegian now living in Sydney this channel is almost becoming a comfort blanket. The Starbar for the honest and authentic piece of Glasgow and now, a culturally just as important seminal Edinburgh restaurant. One of the pubs I most miss from Glasgow is the Smiddy Bar on Dunbarton Road as it, like this channel, hosted every walk of life and everyone left their pretenses at the door and got along.

[@JB-ts1es]

Good Celtic pub

[@GaryEats]

I’m really pleased you are enjoying the videos from Scotland, I have to say I had a fantastic time and I will be back next year, the good news is I have more to come

[@Lizzie-h3j]

I LOVE the Smiddy Bar. I'm just outside Glasgow nxt time I'm in town I'll have a drink there for you.

[@kingbeastie]

I live on Dumbarton Rd, I go to the Deoch an Dorus mostly and The Thornwood too, both great bars. Never been in The Smiddy, will pop in sometime.

[@josephodonnell8649]

Our Gary describing his delicious food review in hushed tones like Sir David Attenborough sitting next to the gorillas .Such respect for his fellow diners. Im so happy you and the cameraman have had a brilliant visit to bonnie Scotland.🍺🍺

[@GaryEats]

Thanks Joseph, it's been a wonderful experience so far

[@noooname2568]

15:12 so decent and honest of you Gary. Some people wouldn’t care about others why they try to enjoy their meal (especially at those prices!) You’re a top man!

[@GaryEats]

Really appreciate that, thank you... I don't think it's right to disturb others whilst dining

[@jimbean2274]

@@GaryEats That is the way of a true gentleman, I think he has earned the title. A real oldschool English hero :)= . Love from germany, you safe honor of your country :D

[@BigRocheyD]

I came here to say something similar. Respect to you reviewing the dessert outside 👍

[@HKB-1]

Some very, very few people are born naturals to be presenters, and Gary is one of them.

[@sebekkha]

Agreed. Love your content Gary. Keep it up.

[@matthewbowen209]

A real Gentleman as always Gary not wanting to disturb others, you and the cameraman deserve a treat every now and then,excellent honest review again enjoy your trip in Scotland

[@GaryEats]

Thank you very much Matthew

[@Quaker521]

Sometimes the food and the experience are worth paying that bit extra and that looked to me like it was worth it. Great starter, fabulous main and chocolate to finish - heaven! Thanks for a super video guys. Cheers.

[@GaryEats]

Well said. I really appreciate that, thanks

[@Flange-lw9sp]

The Secret Garden at the Witchery is one of my favourite restaurants in the World. It’s best to visit in winter and at night, as it’s just candlelight and very atmospheric.

[@GaryEats]

That’s so great to hear 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

[@vixenplays6296]

We used to steal their massive candles they had years ago and they were huge 😂😂😂

[@boomerhgt]

Classy

[@mattysowls]

This is why your amazing Gary, you do cheap places and expensive places and your honesty is always 100% top top bloke

[@GaryEats]

I do try mix it up on the channel, Matty thank you for recognising that

[@cathiemac-tp3ff]

I'm so glad you found some really fantastic restaurants to dine in and, I truly believe that Scottish produce is some of the finest in the world

[@GaryEats]

I totally agree!

[@lyndseybeaumont7301]

You are such a considerate person Gary. I love that about you xx

[@GaryEats]

Thank you very much Lyndsey xx

[@user-oi9yy4zz3k]

Gary, so pleased you enjoyed your visit to Scotland, loved and commented on your wonderful heart felt visit to the Star Bar in Glasgow and the other videos,We tend to be tarnished on having an awful diet here but it’s great to see you promote our food industry which is quite wonderful. Really enjoy your content, keep up the good work sir.

[@anneb.8633]

Gary, your elegant manners are a model for us all. Love you to bits ❤

[@GaryEats]

Thank you very much Anne

[@Amanda-m-50]

Love The Witchery, so pleased you enjoyed it. As you said, it’s an experience venue and worth going, even if only once. You are so considerate of those around you when filming. A true gent! 😊x

[@GaryEats]

Really appreciate that, thank you Amanda. It's very tough to film in these types of restaurants at times x

[@carattentat4944]

Gary,another hit on quality and honesty,combined with authentic luxury,perfect !!

[@GaryEats]

Thank you so very much

[@G78.]

Gary You deserved a expensive treat after producing videos that brighten people’s lives Up Thanks from Ireland my friend

[@GaryEats]

Thank you so much G, you're ever so kind

[@G78.]

@@GaryEats 👍🍀

[@azharkelly3497]

You tube at it's best! Thanks for helping me wind down after work. Cheers Fella.

[@GaryEats]

Thank you very much

[@lesleymcglinchey3337]

The head chef has been there for 30÷ years,totally unassuming guy ,not many people know him,but we love him!! Go DR!!

[@GaryEats]

Fantastic stuff Lesley!

[@johnplynch4866]

Thanks as always, Gary, for your enthusiastic and honest review. I would never have gone there previously to watching your video. I would now. It's always nice when you give the staff a shout out.

[@GaryEats]

The service was excellent so only right to recognise John

[@maltehestbech3192]

Thanks as always, Gary!

[@GaryEats]

My pleasure!

[@t.a.7970]

5am and I can't sleep. Always grateful for a Gary vid.

[@GaryEats]

Sorry to hear that, maybe I can bore you to sleep lol

[@t.a.7970]

@@GaryEats Not a chance mate. Never bored watching your reviews.

[@TP-om8of]

Sleep? At 5 am you should be getting up!

[@t.a.7970]

@@TP-om8of Nah..Too hot to be awake all day here. I go to bed at about 8am before the heat sets in and get up after the daily thunderstorm has cooled things off a bit. The Australian summer is a giant pain in the arse.

[@lisad8052]

I'd love to visit Scotland, it's such a beautiful old country. Thanks Gary for taking us along with you, what a wonderful video. 💚✌️ Did the wee cameraman get to eat?

[@GaryEats]

You are very welcome Lisa, I love Scotland!

[@BritishGu10]

Here since the beginning it’s a delight seeing your channel grow!

[@GaryEats]

Thank you for still supporting the channel for such a long time it’s really appreciated

[@evernautical]

Great review, always a pleasure to watch. But those prices are insane!

[@GaryEats]

Yes they are! I really appreciate that, thanks

[@rhonda6791]

Oh my from beginning to end the food looked lovingly prepared and delicious. The restaurant beautiful. Loved the pumpkins. What a perfect experience.

[@GaryEats]

Brilliant!!

[@robertseaton8720]

Another great video Gary, food looked fantastic & you're very respectful. Looks like you're really enjoying your little tour of Scotland 😁

[@GaryEats]

Thank you and definitely a great trio Robert….but ….

[@steveb1390]

I love the variety of cuisines you cover Gary. Certainly not a place that you’re gonna be dining in every night of the week, but nice to experience something like that on occasion. It’s great to see what else is out there and good to see you’re having some good meals in Scotland 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

[@GaryEats]

I really appreciate that, thank you Steve. I really do my best along with the cameraman to mix up the content

[@johnblossom8447]

Beautiful area and beautiful meal. Thank you for sharing. I always look forward to your videos.

[@GaryEats]

So nice of you John

[@LorraineJones-yp2dt]

Fantastic place Gary. You are so honest and professional caring for the other diners. Nice for a special occasion

[@GaryEats]

That’s very kind to say Lorraine 🌹🌹

[@RosieHarp]

I love Edinburgh so much. History, architecture, atmosphere, underground city, spooky vibes, it's all there. Looking forward to this ❤

[@Obullshtter]

So many drugs

[@MargaretWood-z6l]

​@@ObullshtterNo worse than anywhere else. Trainspotting was years and years ago!!!!

[@NorthSon]

@@ObullshtterAs opposed to every other UK city…

[@RosieHarp]

They're available in every city if that what you're into

[@MargaretWood-z6l]

@RosieHarp Exactly

[@caesarsco]

Hi Gary, my girlfriend and I absolutely love you and your videos. Whenever a new video of yours drops we can't wait to watch it while eating or getting ready to leave the house, only to end up running late because we stick on another! We're both Scottish and would LOVE to recommend a couple of our absolute favourite restaurants here for the next time you're out and about in bonnie Scotland! Chaophraya - an elegant Thai restaurant with a stunning glass balcony that overlooks Edinburgh with fantastic views of the Edinburgh Castles - spent a couple birthdays here and the service and food were both top quality - would recommend the mixed sharing platter and the stir fried chicken in black bean sauce (also 1 Chaophraya in Glasgow and 1 in Aberdeen) The Cotton House - a classy, excellent service and high quality Chinese-Oriental restaurant, can't recommend highly enough, definitely the nicest Chinese restaurant we've been to - located in Denny, just outside of Stirling & Glasgow - would recommend the salt and chilli chicken and satay chicken. Great video as always Gary. We are both 24 and watch every video the day it drops because your channel gives such an escape from the chaotic normality we're all used to, and allows us to just sit back, chill out and watch a lovely man talk about (usually) lovely food. Cheers!

[@GaryEats]

Wow thank you so much. I'm really glad you enjoy the videos - when I come back to Scotland, I will definitely visit one of your recommendations!

[@caesarsco]

@@GaryEats Pleasure! We shall welcome you back with open arms, cheers!

[@Born2winalways]

I might be in Edinburgh after Christmas day, never been there so fingers cross I get a chance to be bewitched and checkout Cotton house. Thank you Gary guys..

[@kingbeastie]

I am in Glasgow and have never heard of Chaophraya, will definitely check it out. Thank you.

[@chronomatt6990]

Gary not wanting to disturb other diners’ experiences despite there being loud guest chatting in the background shows what a top man he is. Is there any other more considerate and well-mannered KZbinr?

[@GaryEats]

It’s only right to consider other diners when they are spending so much money in my opinion and thank you

[@fabianmckenna8197]

​@@GaryEats Absolutely spot on Gary...... My wife and I were most impressed when having lunch at the Witchery a couple of years ago. Food was fantastic as was the service and that restaurant just has the loveliest ambiance. Perfect......

[@ShirleyKahn]

Gary, that is why you are so special because of your consideration of other diners. This is another great review. Thank you.

[@GaryEats]

Thank you very much Shirley

[@lauraweiss7875]

Here’s hoping I get a chance to visit Edinburgh one more time before I kick the bucket. It’s such a charming city. Thanks for your equally charming review video!

[@GaryEats]

Laura it's a wonderful city, I highly recommend

[@douglasgrahamdronefilmingp2068]

Another great video Gary and Cameraman looked really good and hats off to you as usual respecting everyone in the restaurant.

[@GaryEats]

Thank you kindly Douglas, Scotland just continues to amaze me in every way. I wonder how much it costs to buy a house here lol

[@douglasgrahamdronefilmingp2068]

@@GaryEats Glad your enjoying Scotland as they say the best small country in the world. It would surprise you the price of houses. If you sell in the south of England you will get a decent house in Scotland with some cash to spend at The Witchery.

[@richardmurray2068]

Gary and his respect for fellow diners shows what a class act he is!

[@GaryEats]

Thank you!

[@marthaallan-hand1714]

FYI, Gary, the haggis is from Findlays butchers in Porty, and Haggis is stuffed in the sheep's stomach not the Bladder..

[@GaryEats]

I meant to say liver not bladder, sorry!

[@shadowside8433]

Where does Findley's catch it about, tho?

[@dannibal]

@@GaryEats 😅

[@mightay6672]

​@@GaryEatsThe stomach it's encased in.sheeps😊

[@nickhickson8738]

Sounds revolting either way tbh.

[@dariogemelli]

Awesome review Gary. Great respect shown as always. Thanks for coming up to Scotland and promoting the great places we have up here!

[@GaryEats]

Really appreciate that, thank you... you're in such a wonderful country

[@AlienMidget123]

Gary, you are such an absolute and considerate gentleman. Aware that guests around you are paying a lot of money and not wanting to continue so as not to spoil their experience in any way. I think this is a factor in why this community is so special and why we all adore you and Mr Camerman. Big love! ❤ x

[@GaryEats]

Thank you very much!!

[@donladmulligan4676]

It’s nice to see your conscientious of your environment.

[@GaryEats]

Thank you and of course

[@JohnLejman]

Had lunch there last Monday and it is all that Gary says it is but is it worth the price? ... YES IT IS. Will I go back? ... absolutely.

[@juliesheehanmorgan]

This brought back so many memories for me! Stayed here about 20 years ago during a very happy period in my life. We ate here but can’t remember really but I know for sure the prices wouldn’t have been anything like this lol. The room was stunning, very opulent and dramatic. Happy days, thanks for the memories Gary! x

[@GaryEats]

That’s absolutely wonderful to hear Julie xx🌹❤️🌹

[@HavingTheCrack]

That walkway with all the pumpkins 🎃 love it, what a cool restaurant, love the theme coupled with fine dining

[@GaryEats]

Lol fantastic and the theme was excellent

[@theshowmanuk]

Great review, and your excellence at conveying the meal. Super.

[@GaryEats]

Thank you very much

[@Erin-Christine]

Hi Gary! What a beautiful restaurant to review, right in the heart of Edinburgh. The entry & interior are stunning. My ex-partner & I must have walked past The Witchery several times on our last trip to Edinburgh, but if we had looked at the menu & converted it to AUD, it may well have ended in bankruptcy if we had chosen to dine there! 😅 Your starter, main & desert all looked delicious. You always give excellent descriptions of the food in all of your reviews & on this occasion you went above & beyond. Given how expensive it is, your comments throughout provided alot of worthy details, especially for anyone thinking of visiting this restaurant & being wary of potentially very costly tourist traps. Well done on the filming. A fine dining restaurant, which is busy must be very challenging. As always, you managed to do both a quality review, while being discreet & considerate to the surroundings. The shots of Edinburgh Castle made me very holiday nostalgic towards the end. 🩷 Your reviews in Scotland have been wonderful & I've so enjoyed every minute of them! See you on the next one Gary. 💙🌷🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

[@GaryEats]

I have to say, I had a wonderful visit to Scotland, Erin, I was really pleasantly surprised at how good the food was and how wonderful the people were, I can’t wait to go back next year, this one was expensive, but the food was quality. I want to thank you so much for all the support you give me on the channel. It is really, really appreciated. Please take care and have a great week. Xx❤️❤️🌹🌹❤️❤️

[@Erin-Christine]

@GaryEats Thanks so much Gary. The interior of the restaurant alone must have made for a delightful experience. I'm always happy to support the channel. You have one of the best on KZbin & a really lovely & growing community along with it. One of the gems of social media. 🌷💙

[@Paul_Allaker8450]

You can really see the quality of the ingredients shining through. You can tell the owners/chefs really have a passion for their restaurant, and as a treat, this easily justifies the prices. Top review, Gary. 👌🏻

[@GaryEats]

Wow, thank you!

[@andreashaynes3346]

Fine dining and a beautiful setting. You were very respectful Gary and amazing quality of food. A special occasion and one to savour. Bless you and thank you for sharing with us Gary, much appreciated. Soon be reaching 200K subscribers and we all enjoy the journey with you 🫶🫶🫶

[@GaryEats]

Thanks so much Andreas, please take care of yourself. How are you doing?

[@andreashaynes3346]

​@GaryEats Definitely in the best place right now. Got IV treatment for the MS on 20th December. Xmas will be a time of recovery for me. It's always a pleasure and comfort, watching your posts. Many thanks again Gary 🫶🫶🫶

[@binopereira8531]

Another great review. Congratulations on reaching 185k subscribers,well deserved. Hope everyone is having a great day.

[@GaryEats]

Thank you so very much as always

[@koosk41]

So happy to see you are having such a wonderful time in Scotland, and based on everything you bring us, thoroughly deserving of three successive great experiences and so contrasting with it👏🏻

[@GaryEats]

Thank you very much

[@jerryweston4097]

This looked amazing great stuff Gary

[@GaryEats]

Many thanks Jerry

[@carolbarrett5132]

Ooh Gary you have gone very posh with this one! I think one liked this experience! The food looked amazing and the service and setting was great too. One has gone up in the world. I hope the cameraman indulged too!! Well done boys, you are having a great Scottish 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 tour!! 😘

[@GaryEats]

One did enjoy 😂 and definitely a great rip Carol ❤️❤️

[@andreanagy4801]

Lovely city. It was nice to visit it with you once again! All the best dear Gary!❤

[@GaryEats]

Thank you very much Andrea

[@venlo842]

Gaz always puts a smile on my face

[@GaryEats]

Really appreciate that, thank you

[@SusanStevenson-p1d]

Another great review. Thank you Gary. You are a real gentleman thinking of the other customers and stopping the filming so they were not disturbed. Very expensive but the food looked really good and a friendly service.

[@GaryEats]

It was very expensive, but it was excellent quality quality Susan and it wasn’t right for me to carry on filming

[@neilmorrison7356]

Glad you are having a good time in Scotland Gary 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🦄🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🦄

[@GaryEats]

Really appreciate that, thank you Neil. Truly loved it here!

[@neilmorrison7356]

We went to Rules and Lumo while in London we also went to Roka on Charlotte Streer

[@shutup2751]

portions looked very decent sizes which is always a good sign, lot of top restaurants you'd still be hungry after all 3 courses

[@GaryEats]

When you put it like that shutup, you make a very good point

[@Tiffany-en7ks]

I don't think I could ever get tired of your food reviews Gary. You make me feel like I'm eating right there with you!

[@GaryEats]

Thank you very much Tiffany, I'm glad you love them!

[@nickfilleul3463]

MAN ALIVE Gary, so glad you reviewed this one. It’s so great to see a top money restaurant deliver when as we know sometimes a hard won reputation can be allowed to slide. The fact that the chef offered to serve both the fish and the haggis deboned is such a nice touch. Wild Haggis on the menu is so rare these days and such a treat as they are a real bugger to catch on the hoof. An even rarer delicacy are haggis legs, not much meat but oh so delicious when cooked in cream and garlic. Never seen them in Edinburgh but they are much more widely served as a starter or side dish around the forests and lochs much further north. Keep up the good work. ❤

[@GaryEats]

Thank you so very much Nick and a great comment

[@apollomemories7399]

And I bet that you can't even pronounce 'lochs'. Get some new jokes ffs.

[@raven3212]

@@apollomemories7399 You must be a hoot at parties...🤣

[@apollomemories7399]

@@raven3212 But really? What age are you?

[@raven3212]

@@apollomemories7399 old enough to have a sense of humour. Have a lovely day.

[@JulieLane-wj8me]

Hi Gary that restaurant looked beautiful.the fish looked really delicious and the dessert tasty another fantastic video as always.

[@GaryEats]

Thank you very much Julie ❤️

[@sandradolls5682]

You are so considerate and always delighted with your reviews Gary . Enjoyed the history and special occasion treat for a bucket list gold stars always for you and camera man . Edinburgh and restaurant look magic and majestic 🎉

[@GaryEats]

There is a lovely comment, thank you very much, Sandra 🌹

[@dazzathomas2817]

My dinner can wait.. in the middle of peeling spuds and the notification came through. Greeno and Gary videos on the same day are an absolute luxury.

[@GaryEats]

You're very kind Dazza, hope you are doing well

[@patrickwong4824]

Start watching Greeno and his £20 three-course meal when Gary's video appears. Sorry Greeno, Gary gets first dibs, even though I love them both.

[@worldofwarcraftnoob254]

The venue looked gorgeously rustic. I could live there! I agree that would be a once in a lifetime treat.

[@GaryEats]

It’s definitely a beautiful venue and at once in a lifetime treat

[@MrGearoid65]

Great video as always Gary. Thank you for putting such care and attention into making your reviews and in your consideration of the other diners. Top class guy in a top class venue. I've never been to Edinburgh but it's now on my list!!! From Dublin Ireland 🇮🇪. 😊

[@GaryEats]

That is truly a wonderful comment thank you so very much and if you do visit, you won’t be disappointed 🇮🇪🇮🇪🇮🇪

[@maryconlan1384]

Gary,on track for that 200,000 subscribers VERY SOON Your reviews are always a pleasure to watch

[@GaryEats]

I really appreciate that, thanks Mary

[@EMEL-hr4ut]

Joe Rogan...you got competition ! 😅

[@tinalouise5880]

I thought this was beautifully filmed and edited. As always such a gentleman Gary thinking of the others around u 😊

[@GaryEats]

That’s so kind Tina thank you ❤️

[@philgrossman660]

Wonderful review as always. Spectacular fine dining, did not disappoint. As someone else mentioned, that was a free range haggis, you gotta be quick to catch them. Brilliant!

[@GaryEats]

That really made me laugh thank you, Phil

[@gavrfc09]

Glad i subscribed. Your reviews are excellent!

[@GaryEats]

Welcome aboard!

[@alex-E7WHU]

Edinburgh is a fabulous city. ♥️⚒️

[@GaryEats]

Wonderful beautiful city

[@liamchally8621]

It’s nice to see more fine dining videos and definitely worth it for a special day on honestly really nice how respectful you feel for all the others and the staff great work Gary 😊

[@GaryEats]

I do try to mix it up Liam and thank you

[@bpure2560]

A GaryEats video is just what we need to cheer us all up on this miserable Monday. Hope there's haggis tonight. I need to get out more. 😂 Yaaay there's haggis!!!! Ooooh did we hear cameramans voice? He's building up his part. This time next year you'll be the cameraman and he'll be presenting. 😂 15k more subscribers needed to get to the magic 200k. Will we get there by Christmas? It will be the best Christmas pressie ever. 🤞You're spending a lot of money so don't worry so much about taking up the table space to talk about the food you are eating. £110? Wowsers. Take all the time you need after paying that much. 😱

[@GaryEats]

It has really been a miserable monday! No not him

[@ginagraham1902]

Hi Gary! Love your videos,always make me hungry!

[@GaryEats]

Thank you Gina 🌹

[@cdb7698]

Yet another great review Gary. As a Scot living in Spain who enjoys fish; I appreciate your honesty regarding the difference of truly fresh fish to what has to be the acceptance that we mostly buy from supermarkets and fish mongers. Also to your wisdom that ‘fine dining’ is an experience to cherish ( like any other ‘treat’ ; a concert ticket, a theatre show etc etc) …..keep giving it a go!

[@GaryEats]

That’s very kind to say and thank you for watching from Spain

[@Fpsnige]

2 hours after pisting this video 23k people have already seen this and thus a huge advertisement for the Witchery that will only grow. And Gary is such a nice fella hes concerned about the experience of everyone else there! Youre a true gent, Gary.

[@GaryEats]

That’s so very kind as always thank you

[@brodiep4360]

Sadly I must disagree with the general tone of the comments. Location is fabulous. Service exemplary. Food at least that of the fixed price lunch we enjoyed a couple of months ago was however of poor quality and value for money. No vegetarian options minuscule portions and watery fish pie. You can eat much better in Edinburgh for less money.

[@robinmunro47]

I ate there years ago, as it was the venue chosen for a wedding reception. The service was snailpaced, and the lamb was poorly cooked and flavourless. I hope it's improved in recent years, as I was bitterly disappointed. 😢

[@daverobson2204]

Good to see how the other half live and I'm not really missing out

[@GaryEats]

It's all personal preference as you've said Dave, I do prefer my home comfort food more but this was a nice treat!

[@EMEL-hr4ut]

😂 ...if you cannot drive a car through it ....then it is too posh and ££££..😂 kidding. I would rather eat once a week and be able to appreciate good food..

[@daverobson2204]

good luck with that

[@lyndaruff-vg1hw]

Thank you for another great video. Love the respect you show to others, and one to go to on a special visit! The food looked superb, thank you Gary and the cameraman!❤

[@GaryEats]

That’s very kind ❤️❤️

[@costasworldofmusicmemories5792]

You are right Gary. This restaurant is for that very special occaison. A restaurant that great memories are made of. As always " Let's give it go" Great video ! 👍👍👍👍👍 Jim and Harriet

[@GaryEats]

Sometimes you have to pay that bit extra to have a wonderful meal and some wonderful memories, Jim and Harriet

[@Paratus7]

Number One at the Balmoral, The Kitchin and The Table can be more expensive,… Great review. Thank you

[@GaryEats]

I will have to check those out!

[@johnrobertgriffiths8435]

Never fails to make my day Garry. Absolutely brilliant review. Now that would have to be a very special celebration, but it was worth the wait. Thank you, Garry and cameraman.

[@GaryEats]

Thank you so very much John

[@80sKIDSTV]

Love the videos Gary

[@GaryEats]

Really appreciate that, thank you

[@worldofwarcraftnoob254]

Gary really deserves his own show on mainstream telly, I'm telling ya!

[@Ben74_50]

So does Greeno and Deano :)

[@paulapplewhite6135]

Is that a blessing? Mainstream telly is dying a death. KZbin is no longer the poor relation.

[@GaryEats]

I am really happy just working with my son

[@european-one]

​@@GaryEatsdoes your son ever try the food? He had to have been curious on this one

[@1mlister]

Very glad to have been one of the people to recommend the place and to see you enjoyed it.

[@GaryEats]

Thank you very much

[@gregpies1649]

Charging extra for the side dishes 😮 £50 for the fish 🐠 £110 all up is about $220 Australian 😮 I can get a supermarket trolley full of food for that. Definitely out of my price bracket. The fish did look nice and the desert looked yummy 😊

[@GaryEats]

Yes it’s a bit cheeky but it’s absolutely superb

[@robsmith6281]

Easy to spend a lot of money there Gary food looked A1+. Great review as always mate 👍🏻😁

[@GaryEats]

Thanks Rob, you're not wrong👍

[@goldenserenity2385]

Subscribed. Like the variety of the channel

[@GaryEats]

Awesome, thank you!

[@THEDONKDEVIL]

Stop what you're doing, Gary has uploaded 😎😎

[@GaryEats]

Really appreciate that, thank you lol!!

[@gdfggggg]

I did

[@GreenoEats]

Looked great that pal - the colour on that fish was perfect!

[@GaryEats]

Thank you Greeno speak soon

[@JimR-km1yf]

Another top review Gary and C.M. , it is mighty expensive for most people myself included, nice to treat yourself to the best if you have the means to do it or if you can commit to a savings plan. Always considerate Gary, like someone said previously your manners and care for others is top notch.

[@GaryEats]

This was incredibly expensive gym but definitely one for that special occasion and if people are spending their harder money, it’s not right that I’m talking into a camera

[@simongilbert2704]

never thought i would end up watching a food channel ;;; but here i am with my last weeks bag of opened pork scratchings , tesco cheese and onion crisps , cheese and onion pringles , last weeks ham on reduced tesco hard rolls --- livin the dream ;;; glad you enjoyed that marvelous place ,, but a lot above my peasant taste ;;;

[@GaryEats]

I understand your point, Simon, as it is very expensive