Robert Spencer: My New Book Proves That Muhammad Probably Never Existed!

[@sheikhboyardee556]

I love Dr. Spencer's book. I'm half way through and it is excellent. Easy to read & explains Muhammad in detail.

[@GySGTGerman]

The truth makes the true NON-BELIEVERS mad as hell!!!

[@mikeyyy10000]

🙌 We love you Robert, we do, we love you Robert we do, we love you Robert we do, oooooh Robert we love you 🙌

[@godisgreat982]

🤣🤣

[@rudrarishi2523]

There are people who claim that they are descendants of The Prophet. But if he is an imagination then everything else also is. Wonder someone who lives 1800 km to 4800 km writes about another place and person after 200 years. Amazing

[@othmanahmad7331]

If prophet muhammad s.a.w never exist why haters worrying about him so much.?. Lets peoples decide. Read Al Quran very good for you.

[@cameronpickard7456]

robert demonstrates the truth good on him

[@mariamajallow9879]

Muhammad existed

[@solvingpolitics3172]

Why not also prove that there were no Devine revelations to Mohamed. Everything he said an illiterate Bedouin could have dreamed up. Nothing to show Devine wisdom from him! Also: Mohamed: “The Koran is the word of Allah👉 The Koran: “Mohamed is my final messenger👈 Mohamed: I am the greatest of deceivers🏆

[@GySGTGerman]

Outstanding 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

[@Curiouzzz750]

And no witnesses either

[@2Hesiod]

Muhammad certainly was not a historical person. Spencer's new edition is much improved and excellent.

[@ryu.2382]

😂😂😂 are you serious

[@2Hesiod]

@@ryu.2382 The idea that Muhammad was a historical person is not serious. It is ridiculous. It is ignorant.

[@ryu.2382]

@@2Hesiod I bet your a Christian, cos only Christian’s can come up with some stupid claims. And you are telling me there no records on prophet Muhammad from external sources

[@dr.bashar3878]

N next show be like" Robert Spencer probably never exisyed,"🤣

[@doyoureallycare5740]

I love baby aisha & sexy zainab

[@b4fun82]

4:05 collecting in arabic came with many meanings In this time It mean memorized I finished memo the QORAN In ramadan that s what he try to say

[@callumclarke1733]

God bless Robert Spencer ✝️

[@leedza]

never read the book, however, just based on the accounts of Muhammad there is consistency in terms of personality traits that humanise him. I would like believe Muhammad was real person all be it has a bit of a sociopath. You could definitely do a psycho analysis of Muhammad and come up with a real person.

[@gk-qf9hv]

Dan Gibson is NOT a scholar, he is a writer. Same applies to you Robert. Neither of you is an othority on the subject. All you say are things that can be found on internet.

[@cameronpickard7456]

robert knows way more than most muslims

[@wisdomofislamm]

@@cameronpickard7456 next joke

[@taab84]

@@cameronpickard7456 another video kzbin.info/www/bejne/lZ69mIZ_ob1lZrc

[@maxb9315]

That's an argument from authority and a logical fallacy.

[@2Hesiod]

They made him up to unite a diverse empire.

[@ARCDBEACH]

Yup, just like Constantine and 325 council of nicea

[@gk-qf9hv]

Well well. There is a contemporary witness writing that Mohammed entered Jerusalem in 634 (yes 34). Robert obviously knows nothing more than what he watches on KZbin.

[@karenthompson1337]

Yes. However this ‘Mohammad’ (likely just the title the praised one and not a name) said that he came to announce the coming of the Messiah - so as Islam claims it’s prophet is the last of the prophets, Islam wouldn’t have him announcing another prophet to come. You need to read and quote that entire reference to a 634 Mohammad, nothing in the Standard Islamic Narrative ‘SIN’ says that Mohammad was alive in 634, in fact it says he died in 632 and it does not record him being in Jerusalem except for the Night Journey.

[@Curiouzzz750]

@@karenthompson1337 Even the night journey is very questionable, the temple where Mohammad allegedly prayed was actually knocked down by the Romans so Muslims seem to be lead down the garden path . It doesn't make sense

[@karenthompson1337]

@@Curiouzzz750 Yes. I agree. Nothing about the SIN is based on fact. I think the Night Journey was made up to create a link between Mo & Jerusalem.

[@Roseblindbags123]

@@karenthompson1337 the Messiah is not another Prophet hes a prophet that had already come before him and he doesn't have a message to bring to anyone

[@ARCDBEACH]

I couldn't get past the guy having sex with a 9yo whom he "married" at 6yo. Yall lost me right there, no chomo has any say after that horror. That makes me so fckin mad people ignore that detestable act.😡😡🤬

[@RayAdamsCanada]

Mohamed (peace be upon him) is the seal of prophets and Allah (swt) is the creator of everything we see and we don’t see.

[@Lawton-Talks]

So Mohamed is Jesus, and Allah is God. Except that Muslims don't comprehend that there's already been a book about that? It's like when the alphabet people think a man can become a woman. Unintelligent folk, rewriting what's already been said to suit them.

[@Karma-hy6ki]

@@Lawton-Talks oh you are so misinformed and ignorant that’s it’s sad. Your first sentence just proved you don’t even know what ur talking about and have some blind hatred towards Islam without getting ur facts right

[@RayAdamsCanada]

@@Lawton-Talks Greeting my non-Muslim friend; let me enlighten you, do you know windows 11 just came out. I have windows 10, but windows 11 is better version than 10, it has everything I need. It is suited for my needs better than windows 10. I will upgrade to 11. Don’t miss out. Peace!

[@maxb9315]

That's not an argument. It's merely an assertion.

[@franciscogris4116]

En español tambien

[@dr.bashar3878]

He constantly speaks Ill of prophet

[@emilioalvarez8010]

Oh no! Cry me a river

[@pratyush7711]

Then what,u gonna cry ? Go cry

[@dr.bashar3878]

@@Estxoxo do you exist ???

[@delazeez3667]

you can debunk every one of his claims by doing a google search for each point, so simple. yet, he is a revered man by many. world really is coming apart you guys. brace

[@اشوراشور-م8ث]

وانا مؤمن يقينا أن لا وجود لي رجل اسمه محمد

[@Ex_muzzie]

Me too

[@backgroundMASCAL]

so, you "experts" wanna talk about Muhamad but dont know that this guy with the turban is Imam Ali and not Muhamad ...?😂 😂 😂

[@maire0808]

U talk bull, read Mohammed's life story, I did in mosque, child rapist, slave girl rapist, 11wives, several concubines lusted after his own relatives children and wives... From satan, God does not send filthy gits, only Jesus the pure one sent from god

[@shaktichauhan7128]

Genius the great scholar Robert Spencer

[@WestSideBarson]

There's outside reports of Muhammad from his time he definitely existed lol.

[@karkkimarkkinat2109]

That makes zero sense...

[@WestSideBarson]

@@karkkimarkkinat2109 what makes zero sense? There's accounts of Muhammad outside of Muslim sources. If that simple statement doesn't make sense to you maybe it's your fault.

[@pratyush7711]

Why care for a simple cult leader. Who was get hallucinating his whole fking life after getting out from a cave ??

[@WestSideBarson]

@@pratyush7711 I almost entertained you...

[@DrBashirHakeem]

Ohh, really? Take a microphone in your hand , travel globally and aware people at their doorsteps.

[@zoeashes6347]

Enjoyed several good reads by Robert Spencer ... the latest of which is the Critical Qur'an. Of course, there is also the revised edition of "Did Muhammad Exist" and "The History of Jihad." You will know that the Standard Islamic Narrative ... is all pure propaganda ... unsupported by any historical facts. Do not be taken in any longer by the propaganda of the SIN which is all falsehoods and lies. Another good book which is a 100 year old title is "ISLAM - A Challenge to Faith" by Samuel M Zwemer. It is dated but it is still a good read. Samuel M Zwemer is called the Apostle to the Muslims in his day.

[@abubakaradan7583]

don't talk bad about my prophet he existed

[@mrmidman47]

please show us some of respect to our prophet, we don’t realize how our prophet looks like in photo or image we don’t draw him (pbuh) , please that’s wrong, there’s red lines in everything .

[@TheBighobby]

islam religion is true

[@hamitcheikhphotoeye6148]

After his death no one remember you Inshallah read Quran Words last 1500 year no change in one dot بِسْمِ اللّٰهِ الرَّحْمٰنِ الرَّحِيْمِ بَلْ هُوَ قُرْاٰنٌ مَّجِیْدٌۙ -----Transliteration----- Bal huwa quranun majeedun -----Syed Abul Ala Maududi----- Nay; but this is a glorious Qur'an, -----Safi-ur-Rehman Mubarakpuri----- Nay! This is a Glorious Qur'an, -----Muhammad Pickthall----- Nay, but it is a glorious Qur'an. -----Saheeh International----- But this is an honored Qur'an -----Muhammad Sarwar----- What is revealed to you is certainly a glorious Quran -----Muhammad Shakir----- Nay! it is a glorious Quran, -----Abdul Majid Daryabadi----- Aye! it is a Recitation glorious, -----Yusuf Ali----- Nay, this is a Glorious Qur'an, Al-Quran - Surah 85 - Al-Burooj - Ayah 21

[@giovannimannelli2158]

It's not his new book it's been works of Patricia Chrone that demonstrates that.

[@Akram_El-Masry]

Islam's obscure origins ? dude we don't just know about the prophet and his life and doings and actions we know the lives and actions and sayings of almost everyone who interreacted with the prophet from authentic repeated separate sources pathetic

[@doyoureallycare5740]

I love aisha & zainab

[@maxb9315]

@@doyoureallycare5740 Why?

[@maxb9315]

It's far from pathetic. It's a reasoned and cogent argument. Read the book.