This Is The Worst Makeup Ever | Pro MUA reacts to Judy D Worst Reviewed Makeup Artist!

[@RobertWelsh]

Hey everyone! You can follow my new reaction channel here! - youtube.com/@Robert_Reacts?si=_3OQzH-wmLhC_Jrp

[@Angel4Sale]

The makeup look wasn’t worth $50 but the amount of makeup on her face is probably worth $50 LOOOL

[@11_elleven]

$50 is blush and brows alone 😅🤣😵‍💫

[@ninaasf-ck]

This "artist" is owning "more is more"

[@Rue994]

Highly doubt that. I’ve seen maybe two of these places use products you can even get at a Boots, Sephora or Ulta. Most are surely loaded down with lead and other banned toxins and chemicals.

[@AKbaby89]

Ive never felt so confident that id do better than the professional makeup artist until this video.

[@HelenAvery]

Right!? My own makeup skills are low but I ain't charging anyone for it, that's for sure!

[@AngelaSmith_1970]

Ikr 😳 if I was a professional makeup artist I’d be embarrassed of that makeup job 😢

[@tash4122]

😂🤪🤣

[@tamikopoole]

This

[@sundaymusingswithsarah]

I was just about to type the same. How can anyone with any conscience charge for this?!

[@chelseab1438]

Petition for Robert to do Judy’s makeup so she can finally have a professional 😅

[@kelseydaniellex]

Yes I was just about to comment this 😭👌🏽 I’d love to see this ❤

[@VivaVendetta]

I think Judy more than deserves Robert's expertise now, after putting herself through so much for our entertainment!

[@Temptthedevil]

@@VivaVendetta Bring in James to do her nails and give her a facial lol

[@erenapearsall6596]

Yes, let’s do it!

[@therealJamieJoy]

YES, PLEASE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! If you start an actual petition I would sign it and get random family members to also sigh just to get this going! LOL

[@stephaniejohnson6420]

My 6 year old niece recently created this exact same look on herself with her child makeup kit and thought that she looked so glam. We told her she slayed it of course and she was absolutely proud of herself. Dinner time made her super mad though because her mom made her remove her eyeliner to go out to the restaurant. My sister secretly told us there was no way she’d let her out the house looking like a clown. My niece non-the-wiser told her in response and I quote “you’re just jealous because my makeup looks better than yours.” 😂😂😂😂

[@taranullius9221]

Haha I also thought instantly of my niece when she got into my palettes and some other makeup when she was 8. Hers was actually better. The eyes were terrible but she showed more restraint with the blush and lips. She did a number on my KVD holographic palette though XD

[@standdownrobots_ihaveoldglory]

A six year old knows how to remove liner? Im impressed!

[@HaintblueRee]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣screaming

[@allthatsheiz]

Ooooooo 😂 she is fresh

[@madokami03]

​@@taranullius9221NOOOO that pallette is so beautiful too, rip to it 😭

[@ShreeNation]

The artist made her look 20 years older. That has got to be some type of achievement

[@jesclifford88]

Also like a man in drag 😫🤭

[@tammiemartinez6485]

She also managed to make her look like someone punched both sides of her face. While Judy thinks she was the victorious one I'd beg to differ 😂

[@belindamilne4922]

Definitely some 80s society matron vibes going on there. Either that, or she thinks Judy works at Cirque de Soleil (as a clown)

[@Jigglypowerpuffgirl]

It makes me so sad when I think of all the free makeup applications I did while working at Macys, when judging by Judy’s videos I could have been changing $100 plus for my skills

[@victoriamuschka4207]

This woman needs a gold medal for sitting through this makeup application. How this person applied makeup like this with a straight face over, over over over, over and over again especially on the cheeks Is absolutely amazing to me.

[@firebug1364]

It's sad when a little hygiene and professionalism in Judy's videos are like seeing unicorns or mermaids 😂😂😂😂

[@denaemichele]

OMG. I don't think I've ever seen that much bronzer and blush piled onto one spot on someone's face.

[@jesclifford88]

I may or may not have ended up with a face like that after doing my makeup while drunk once 😂 I didn’t go out though so it was fine haha 😅

[@chelseab1438]

The difference between her neck and face color had me 💀

[@abookishmess]

😭😭 she aged Judy by decades and the bronzer is so wild it's like a bruise on her. The eyebrows look like bricks. Judy is so pretty and i can't get over how these artists dont even have to do much AND STILL FUMBLE.

[@artboxfashion4042]

This reminds me of old school Stage Makeup! Everybody used exaggerated makeup in ballet. It looks like shite up close but from faraway it looks fine.

[@SheilaMarguerite]

You're such a kind person. I love that no matter how terrible the results are in these, you always find something positive to point out 😊

[@therealJamieJoy]

I also appreciate Robert's constructive criticism. It's helpful advice, as well. :)

[@lynettefinnigan9540]

😂😂😂😂 I said the same thing, he's so kind, he can always find at least something nice to say....I'm sorry, I wouldn't be able to, I would be busy running home to scrub my face off!!!!😂

[@codirennke1109]

I'm shit at makeup so I learn the most from these videos of yours Robert. The tips you say to correct what these awful makeup artists do... I'm like "oh yeah of course you wouldn't want to do that" 😬 I've been doing exactly that for years lol. Thank you so much for explaining things the way you do... it actually helps me understand how to translate a technique to my own face instead of just trying to imitate what I see online. 💜

[@jackiejeffords2932]

I’ve learned so many tips too I love how he gives constructive criticism but positive comments too it’s a good balance 😊

[@cheyannewooten95]

concealer as eyeshadow primer works FOR ME because i have INCREDIBLY dry skin. but i would never do it on someone else assuming it will work

[@britty...........8137]

Would love to see Robert reacting to James doing Judy’s makeup 🤣

[@TheFranklinFarmhouse]

i hope they do on the shared channel!

[@FatBabyToodles]

😂❤🎉 that would be awesome 😂

[@skairdykat]

I think even James could do better than these MUAs 😂

[@monicapatton1405]

Yesss

[@Rue994]

That would be amazing 😂

[@Zelda_Kitty]

I love that you're helping Judy reach 1 million subscribers. She's great!

[@nany____]

I'm fully convinced that those MUAs already know who Judy is and they do it on purpose, THERE'S NO WAY they actually charge people for this 😭

[@irradiated_woman8016]

Never underestimate the audacity of people who don't know that they don't know what they're doing.

[@20twelvevolution]

I agree. I really do think a lot of these are set up for youtube.

[@sluttymctits4496]

There have been a few of Judy's videos in the past where the employees in the salon call her out and know exactly who she is. "That's the girl from KZbin." She's been doing this for years and is known in her city. No doubt some, if not most by this point, of her videos are purposely bad.

[@shannonw6583]

I actually thought the same thing while watching...

[@nitsirkroy]

Especially bc arent they always in ecuador? If the same city, even a large one, i feel she’s big enough now they must know her …

[@jaimemicelotti8539]

I remember having a “makeup artist” at the mall convince me to hop in his chair for a free makeover. I was hesitant. My daughters and their friend said I should try it. He wiped off my current makeup. He did something called reverse contour. He went with the darkest shade he had. Put it all over my face and then added the lightest shade. He then went over my cupids bow. Gave me round lips etc. I have naturally full lips. (Italian genetics) I felt caked on; with hugely weird shaped lips. When we got outside of the mall… I saw myself in my car visor mirror. I was an Oompa Loompa. I’m glad that I keep extra napkins in my car. I wanted that stuff off me ASAP. I tried to wipe off what I could. As soon as I got home I scrubbed my face.

[@taranullius9221]

Oof you gave me flashbacks. I've only ever done one at Elizabeth Arden when I was 17 and never again. This was in the late 90s so, if you can imagine the colour I was as someone

[@jaimemicelotti8539]

@@taranullius9221 , my experience was at a Nordstrom or Macys in 2017. I’m assuming you and I are of a similar age. I was teenager in the 90’s. I’m 46. I didn’t wear makeup much in the 90’s. Occasionally i’d wear some lipstick. I was more into the grunge look.

[@pnutty5139]

This happened to me at Stila when a new Nordstroms opened. My friends and i made makeover appointments. I had mild acne at the time and I guess none of their regular foundation would cover it because she coated my entire face in thick concealer. I have hooded eyes and she used pastel shimmery lilac up to my brows, no brow colour so just undefined concealer caked brows and thick black eyeliner top and bottom. I looked like a puffy eyed wax figure when she was done lol. My friends all got cute looks and I was so embarrassed to have to walk around the mall looking a mess for the rest of our visit 😢

[@AntonioOliveira-ed5yt]

It's always good to remember that $50 might not be a lot of money in America or Europe, but it is A LOT here in Latin America, in Brazil 50 dollars is 20% of our monthly minimum wage

[@CrystalFier]

Anyone else say "Creativity and individuality have no rules, but makeup most DEFINITELY has a theory," with him? 😅😅😅

[@abookishmess]

Every time 😂

[@aleigha9141]

Yep 🙋‍♀️

[@hannahlanai]

And it couldn’t apply more in this video lol

[@jenniebeann]

I would love to see Robert do Judy's make up x

[@hairydino4568]

We should have him in disguise first, doing a terrible make up look, then he does a good one after 👌😆

[@yvettebasson1243]

My skin is already cringing. These videos are like watching a train wreck.

[@heathervannatter364]

Yep 😊

[@emptydempty6319]

Judy's smile and the way her eyes crinkle really looks like her brother's and that's so adorable! Love em both!

[@jannamagpie8324]

They made her cheeks look so sunken in. I’m not a makeup artist but I am a visual artist and I feel like it’s common knowledge that you highlight what you want to bring forward and contour where you want shadows. This MUA put shadows directly on top of her cheekbones!

[@ayajade6683]

Not in countries like Ecuador as they're not licensed and usually mimicking what they see across multiple videos that rarely are in Spanish so they often don't understand the theory

[@bethanychatman9531]

​@@ayajade6683 come on, they have to know that this doesn't match what they see on the Internet, tho.

[@lesley4085]

Poor Judy, I think the make up artist was trying out her pantomime dame look for the upcoming season! My neck was sore just watching this, love watching your facial expressions Robert 😁

[@EGGrun]

Robert! I would love a series where you "fix" these horrible make-up looks. Like to try replicate it on one side as it is and doing it right on the other side.

[@AJ_AJ.]

Okay but like, our standards are so slow that this makeup artist did an amazing job compared to the usual horrors we see from her videos 😂

[@angelicarose493]

Robert I so need you and Judy to do a collab where you do her makeup show us how her makeup should ACTUALLY be done. I would love that. ❤

[@sea_g0at]

the concealer line on the nose had me asking, “trixie? is that you?”

[@jackiejeffords2932]

Yesss

[@ellyung333]

I’m always in awe of how beautiful her skin is! The way the artists always torture her skin and thinking how gross some of those products/tools could be.. 😮

[@adafihj6439]

The best way to end my work day seeing Robert have an breakdown over a Judy D video 😂😂😂😂

[@Petronella1]

I’ve would pay 50$ to not get that makeup 😂

[@gigiapollo]

Robert please do Judy’s makeup 😭 she deserves it and her skin needs it 🤣

[@maryeckel9682]

And James to give her a lukkkzuuury skin prep!

[@smb611]

Judy is so brave! She does this so we don't have to! Thanks for reacting to her videos!

[@imposiblenata]

How does she encounter this many *extremely* bad makeup artists? Not to mention ones that allow her to film

[@markusfeindt]

It’s obviously staged and the people know her from KZbin and she knows that’s why I’m not interested in watching her she keeps on doing this even tho she knows that the people that are doing her makeup know her so it’s all fake

[@BreakofDawn]

She purposely looks for them, from the worst reviews

[@sophiestbh]

@@markusfeindtshe literally lives in ecuador.. those makeup artists don't all know her from youtube. it's a developing country, there aren't as close to as many regulations to beauty practices as there are in the US or Europe. I live in Germany and I could easily find just as many horrible makeup artists just by looking at their google review pics.

[@ayajade6683]

Because she's in a very poor country where people don't have licensing for this and it's normal to film it in Ecuador as this price range is like going to a high end spa in the USA

[@shi.survives]

​@@markusfeindtit's very obvious when you watch a couple of her videos that they're not staged😮‍💨 I'm not even a subscriber of hers and you can tell. That's just how it is in countries like ours at most places. Unless you go to a high-end salon, this stuff is all you get

[@TreeCurtis84]

I would love to see Robert do Judy's makeup! That'd be such a fun crossover video!

[@Sleipnirseight]

18:12 someone would have to pay ME to subject me to this. Consider it payment for emotional damages

[@felinemoonchild]

I would LOVE to see your reaction to a recent Worst Makeup video she did where she had an allergic reaction. No spoilers, but the way the MUA reacted when Judy mentioned it was burning... 😱

[@Rue994]

Love these breakdowns and you are getting more blunt while still being respectful and professional…when most people watch these and their skin crawls and respect and politeness go right out the window😂 I am always utterly shocked that these so called makeup artists feel proud of their “work” and have the audacity to charge for what they do and how disgusting their tools and products always are. They should be paying people to come in frankly and let them practice on their beautiful faces.

[@11_elleven]

Robert darling I just can’t understand how these “aRtIsTs” keep doing so awful. She has such a nicely structured face for makeup application, does she not?! The bone structure, her lid space, etc!?.. I would definitely apply blusher in a more “doll-like” method on her to bring the illusion of fuller/more youthful cheeks. How they’ve applied it just accentuates flat cheeks ☹️ Anyway, love you & your videos as alwaysss! 🖤🖤

[@nitzeart]

THE BLUSH ON THE FOREHEAD!! Well, thay one is new. Never been seen before 😂😂

[@jaqsre]

i wouldn’t pay. this is a look a child would do for free 😭

[@paulahobbs4411]

Oh my God! It's 2:30 a.m. and I had to throw the brakes on and rewind to hear "red and green should never be seen except for Christmas and Halloween!" 5 times😂 that's fucking brilliant!

[@palladium607]

You hit a million!!!! Well deserved! I knew since i found you early on youd be huge in no time! Your content is top notch, and i love your new vids covering different brands and such. Also, love Judy D too. Shes hilarious! ❤

[@dyskelia]

How this man found the patience to compliment parts of this, I will never know 😔😔

[@rosech0senOne]

Honestly, these are some of my fave videos lol. Your reactions are hilarious 😂

[@spudboyfan1286]

I almost got an eye infection watching that! 😮😮😮 this is just awful

[@stephaniegrehan9084]

I like how you can explain what mistakes are happening and what you should do instead and the outcome. Woof that's a bad makeup

[@horrorveronica724]

Love these reaction videos! Judy is a champ for going through this for us.

[@Camii_0613]

Judy is one of our strongest soldiers, appreciate her more with each video Can't imagine what her skin has gone through 😭😭

[@munguiamoon]

I love a creator like you with your platform helping another one like Judy who’s almost at 1 mil! You both make videos that are high quality and been following both you guys for 4-5+ years. Ty for your effort, and continued series of videos..fr

[@DMoz13]

I'm no make up artist but seeing that train wreck has given me new confidence.

[@jesclifford88]

Ooh beautiful eye look today Robert 😍 I’ve got so many screenshots of paused videos for your eyeshadow 😅 I love when you cover these videos! I feel so bad for Judy’s face though 😣 she’s an absolute warrior!

[@SlothDaan]

I think the artist would have to pay ME $50 if I had to leave the shop like that. Can you imagine being seen in public with make-up like that?! Also, the contouring/bronzer, blush and highlight were all in the exact same place..

[@jenniferwbc]

Love ❤️ JudyD ❤ and love it when you do a reaction video! That poor girl works hard for content- always chaos!

[@omgcarsonnn]

Hi Robert, could you please do a tutorial on the eyeshadow look you’re wearing here? It’s so beautiful and I wanna learn to do something like this 💕

[@Beckanai]

I love watching Judy's videos! She's trying to hit 1m before the new year, she's definitely with it, I hope she does it! ❤

[@bethanyrose9026]

Lol I am a complete amateur but I love makeup and do it for fun. I did my friends makeup for her wedding and it looked 1000x better than this

[@sacgeekgirl]

Ya know, I would also LOVE to see some examples of really Good Makeovers and explaining why they steps they take are good and what they did in detail. Esp if the makeup Style is very different ...like bridal vs music fest makeup 🩷🩷🩷

[@LovelySunshine17]

OMG, lol! I would not pay for this 😂😂😂 I would have told the MUA to re-do my face. Absolutely horrendous!

[@babeofmoss]

I really enjoy you reacting to Judy's videos. Happy to see you bring this back again 💚

[@tatjanaarandelovic9555]

That was not worth $50. The lips in Judy were the only acceptable part of the whole makeup. When she started putting the contour/bronzer? on Judy- I wanted to scream 😮. As you said, Robert- the pachyness, the grey colour of the makeup, the blush pit onto the contour/ bronzer? Horrible 😮😢. Thank you for another brilliant reaction video, Robert xxx ❤

[@roastymarsh6284]

Yes it was. The technique is not worth 50 but the amount of products on her skin was 50. It was too much product.

[@tixipixi1043]

And also, I, personally didn't even like the lips. They were done too much.. Judy deserves better. I saw her videos makeup done by actual pros, and then you can see how lips can look great, without exaggeration ☺️

[@marry6merra90]

Omg, the purple eyeshadow looks neon, so gorgeous and saturated love the look ❤❤

[@angiebarth1292]

I love her and her videos make me laugh but I’m also scared for her skin.

[@janna8147]

Yay! 100% improvement in my Monday, just by one video showing up 💜💜

[@asterholland9081]

Anyone else not getting audio at 5:15?

[@twukibxnny]

Was looking for the, thought my headphones broke lol

[@Takapon218]

I love your reaction at 6:31 it's so genuinely surprised. I love it 💀

[@vikicarts1772]

Oh Robert! I can tell watching this caused you as much pain as Judys neck is in 😂😂😂

[@killerfreckles1162]

Wow, just wow. I don’t understand why on earth this lady thought bronzer and blush are optimal in the same place like some sort of brosh. Brosh is not a thing!

[@Crow_Smith]

"How much would you pay for this?" I'd have them PAY ME so I could afford a different artist after this one was done practicing. Because I have to say this is practice to not feel mad about it. I haven't done/touched my makeup in like 3 years and I feel like I could potentially go to the store, grab a random palette for eyes, cheeks, and some lippie and stuff and still not look so muddy. I probably can't do my brows and wouldn't be close to "professionally done" by a good pro MUA, but it would look better than this I'm sure.

[@batmanrobin2011]

I have no idea why none of these “MUAs” know how to shape or line her lips especially her bottom lip. Most of them just line and shape half of her bottom lip and call it a day. Most don’t even clean up around her lip line. It pisses me off

[@palicar]

Al got rhythm.

[@laurahollohan1388]

Your eye makeup is STUNNING Robert!!! I hope you do/did a tutorial on that!!

[@dawnrenee7280]

I couldn’t switch fast enough! Love these reaction videos, Judy D takes the abuse so we don’t have to! 🖤💜🖤💜 P.s. Algorithm!🤣

[@nope66755]

yaaaay I love your Judy D vids, she has the patience (and skin) of a saint

[@hirohiwo]

videos like this make me enter the delulu land and think I am a better makeup user and enjoyer than these people charging Judy D for HORRIBLE makeup LMAO

[@tjingtjongbil7694]

Same 😂

[@samanthab9297]

Love your honesty Robert, makes my day ♥️

[@Lady.alchemy29]

I feel way more confident now about how good I am at doing my makeup 😂

[@gingerd2563]

You have such a nice voice and even your critique sounds quite calming! Your videos are amazing and perfect for relaxing and laughing after hard day at work

[@AlanaByTheShore]

She looks punched in the face with bronzer on her face like that, similar to Mikayla Noguera. 😳 😐 😂 🤣 😕 After skimming her videos, I am under the impression this is all planned out. Everyone makes her look bad on purpose and she knows it already in advance. I can't trust a KZbinr like this.

[@VeronicaSpark]

Your eyeshadow look is particularly GORGEOUS in this video!! 😍 Such velvety, seamless blend... I'm inspired to try to duplicate it; love those shades!

[@MeganSpruce90]

You and James' have been out of my algorithm until recently when you guys were on Beautiful & Bothered! Since then, I've been binging all I've missed!

[@aleigha9141]

Robert always takes up for Judy and calls the MUAs out for what they’re doing wrong and I am HERE for it! These are some of my favorite videos. I learn so much! If you’re not already subscribed to Judy’s channel, you really should go give it a watch and subscribe. She is awesome! Thank you Robert for your honest reaction 😊 Love you and love your content! Also loving the make up look and hair today too! Sending much love hugs and positive vibes your way 🖤

[@kattieSkyNinja13]

I always move around my clients! I ask them to look down when im doing their eyes etc but i would never keep asking them to look up n have my hand on their head!!!!

[@jacindajones6390]

I love so much when you react to Judy d videos!!! Love you and James both soooo much!!! ❤

[@noodlesdoodly]

Well this certainly boosted my confidence in my shoddy makeup skills! also, LOVE your vids - I watch them all the time and my husband came up behind me and the first words out of his mouth were "wow he is gorgeous" - SLAY!!!

[@mimiswishes]

i just noticed now but happy 1M !! i love watching you so much you definitely deserve them all and more

[@megwhaley4887]

This was a year ago. I’m binge watching you watching Judy. When are you gonna do Judy’s make up? We all are waiting for it. She’s so beautiful and you will do her right

[@donnamiddleton3964]

Love these videos ❤

[@Sonia87V]

Robert, your eye makeup is stunning! Briliantly done! Those colors look wonderful on you

[@dawnfrazier6146]

I would not pay for that look. How dare that person call themselves a makeup artist. The shame and chargeing $50 to beat that's bad! Luv you Robert you are really good at this.😊

[@filledepieuvre]

Love Judy’s channel, been subscribed to it since seeing all of your react videos. Isn’t it crazy seeing a make up artist age her or turn her skin grey like this when Judy has a wonderful face and skin ! It was sooo satisfying seeing one of hers such as the two at the Gucci store in Dubai w the Manta(Mantha?) who turned her make up look into a masterpiece !!!! Recommend everyone watching those for a 180 where Judy gets justice 💕🩷💜👏👏👏

[@SavannahRoseYo]

that eye look ur wearing is so pretty!!!!!! the lavender / periwinkle looks so good 😭😭

[@FatBabyToodles]

😂😂😂 "the thingy bone" hahah made me instantly sing in my head "the thingy bone connected to... My face bone!"😂 Obv thats not how the kids song goes but it was funny to me 😂😂❤

[@Maggie21180]

Oh your eyeshadow primer rant is my favorite 😂 I ordered the sigma one during black friday but your shade ignite was out of stock so I got the pinkier one. I better love it Robert 🤭

[@stephanieobrien7504]

Love the purpely silver eyeshadow look today!!

[@terrijackson1210]

Hi Robert, new to your channel and I love it. Poor Judy, what a trooper! That MUA, I'm sure means well, but she needs more training!

[@Classichoney04]

Robert we need a tutorial for this stunning look you are wearing 👀❤ love this 😍