THE WORST MAKEUP OF 2024 ... so far | Bad makeup releases

[@RobertWelsh]

Hey everyone!!! HOPEFULLY this video is much better quality visually than my previous uploads!! I think I fixed it!!??

[@oliviaoxley]

Hi Robert! Thank you for all your hard work ❤🖤

[@dinasilva9263]

Yes looks great now.✨

[@thermalshockx]

@@RobertWelsh looks great on my end! High quality and looove the makeup today!

[@TheSqueet]

It looks great! Thank you so much for all of your work on these videos! I am such a super fan! ❤

[@FoxxyFire-HellFrost]

Please do a Best of 2024 So Far as well. 😊

[@ernturnstheburn]

THIS SHADE OF PURPLE IS MAKING YOUR EYES LOOK SO GORGE AND CHOCOLATEY

[@lauriemoser9070]

Yes what pallette is that gorgeous purple from??

[@sanjapetrevska4994]

Yes! I’m so inspired. Totally want that chocolatey eye.

[@PiXie232]

Right? He looks so good!!

[@thisismyaltaccount85]

Purple and brown are likely opposite on the color wheel, hence why they compliment each other so well

[@Frick27]

It’s true - we really do need to move past our obsession with celebrities. I'm already noticing a shift in how people view them, and I'm glad to see it happening.

[@RockNess15]

Next step.. influencers!

[@LilyRose-e3n]

We see the same people saying that lick Selena’s and Rihanna’s ass. Just saying

[@EmmaRosesConcertClips]

@@RockNess15you comment, on an influencer’s video.

[@clarabear501]

I think the change is with the tail end of Gen Z. They grew up with celebrities being shoved down their throats. There is no appeal to follow these shiny, impersonal characters. Why idolize a Kardashian when books and video games offer exciting and relatable characters for teens. You know a celeb is boring when they’re more 2D than a fictional character lol

[@EpicKandy]

one of my favorite things about Robert is that when something doesn't work for him the first time, he tries again a different way and sometimes he keeps trying until he exhausts every method he knows. I know we've all seen make up people who use something once, hate it, and throw it out. not Robert. love that he wants things to work and puts in the work himself. another reason to trust him, really

[@HeatherAustinmakeup]

Ooooo people were so mad when said I hated the L’Oréal spray 😅 I love hearing your thoughts!

[@RobertWelsh]

It was so bad Heather!!! 😂😂😂 im glad im not the only one!

[@lenahenderson3622]

I love seeing Heather comment on Robert's video! This is the best!

[@andrea_mahia]

Loreal is generally a good brand. But just because something doesn't work for you. Doesn't mean you have to like it. So nevermind the nye sayers.

[@user-uz5pk4wd4t]

which setting sprays do you recommend? is urban decay any good?

[@francinejones2524]

I never use Lorel anymore! I used it early 2000’s.

[@KateTheGreatOf1988]

Love that you named a few products that you did like for every one you didn’t. :) Also, your eye makeup is *chefs kiss*!! 😘

[@RobertWelsh]

Thank you! 🖤

[@juliaa717]

The chorus of “boos” at each product took me out 😂😂 thank you for providing educational and entertaining content Robert 💜

[@horrorveronica724]

It took me a while to hear that it was boo-ing. I thought it was that strange kind of ”Hawaiian music” and couldn’t understand why🤣🤣 but my earphones are crap so… love the purples btw!

[@RobertWelsh]

😂😂😂😂

[@angellombness4371]

The purple 💜 yeeeeeeees

[@maryeckel9682]

😂😂

[@jenhatton984]

I was saying boo-urns

[@francinejones2524]

😂😂😂

[@nicola_pink]

Don't usually make soppy comments, but I have recently moved and have been struggling, yours and James' content has been very comforting for me ❤❤

[@KateTheGreatOf1988]

@@nicola_pink 🫂 ❤️ ❤️ If you ever need a good laugh, try watching their “try not to laugh” videos that are on their joint channel…ALWAYS does the trick for me. :) Hang in there! 🥰

[@reinventingmeesh]

@@nicola_pink i lost my father 2 weeks ago, and i agree...his and James content IS soothing. And if you ever want a hit of joy, watch one of @heatherautin going over her latest haul🙂 i wish you lots and lots more peace.

[@kategoldsworthy737]

Good for you for saying it. I'm sure a lot of us have felt the same; during difficult times Robert and James are wonderful to watch, and do the heart good. Better times are ahead for you, I am sure. Lucky us to know about the Welsh Twins 😀

[@carriefish]

@nicola_pink I'm right there with you. Some awful struggles after recently moving. Their content is helping immensely to distract me, make me laugh, and keep me going. 🫶🏻

[@dianamerchant1026]

They are very soothing. The twin channel is adorable❤

[@mystic_mimi21]

5:48 ‘Hair spray in a can!’ As opposed to the usual hair spray in tube? 😂 love you Robert. These videos are great as it is near impossible to get a trust worthy review

[@thegoosegirl42]

Personally I buy my hair spray in a jar. Like mayo

[@EmmieHunny]

I mean they do make aerosol-free hairsprays in squirt bottles

[@Manders13]

If you owned a brand (makeup, brushes, candles, whatevs), I would purchase in an instant, because I trust you and your opinion over many, many others. You deserve to be a household name!

[@lw6431]

Agreed! His brand would be amazing

[@beccaa6187]

OOOO CANDLES!!!

[@purrgundy]

​@@lw6431 Skin Up really is amazing! Obsessed with their lipstick

[@DayaLucky-bg8lq]

I enjoy his videos and know he has a lot of knowledge in terms of makeup. However the success brand takes WAY more than just knowledge of the product.

[@stillnotstill]

​@@DayaLucky-bg8lq that's a good point! Do you think he'd be good at choosing good experts to work with? I think probably so!

[@szarkarachel]

The only thing I've heard about Kim's makeup brand was "why's it so overpriced?" And I get it. It's browns. It's nudes. Nothing special about it...

[@lydiaj7492]

Yeah, it's so strange!

[@alyson_l27]

Well, it's on brand with her. Bland, you know. I can not imagine her selling rainbow makeup and fun stuff lol

[@HundraNyanserAvTurkos]

Very strange! Get the BeautyBay nude or neutral instead!

[@Genevieve1023]

​@@alyson_l27 That's true. But, look at her brand then, look at Patrick Ta and Charlotte Tilbury. A brand can specialize in wearable makeup without being boring.

[@Mothpunk]

Given her house looks like the world's most expensive sensory deprivation tank, the sad beige overpriced makeup does not shock me at this point

[@a.r.mproductions5616]

That’s so funny Flower Knows sent you a pallet that doesn’t exist. Congrats you have your own unique pallet. 😂

[@countcain]

Like, how does that even happen? 😂

[@dibidibiday6]

@@countcainit’s not that it doesn’t exist at all he just got sent the chinese exclusive version of the palette instead of the international one. They have slightly different releases between the two recently. International got highlighters and slightly more colourful blushes and the chinese market got more pale blushes and concealers/colourcorrectors. I know this cuz I follow quite a few cbeauty lovers and was really wanting the chinese version of the palette TT

[@aiat414]

the funny thing is it does exist it's just China exclusive hahaha he got lucky if you ask me

[@UrbanAmazon83]

Anyone else think Robert's look in this video is on point? Always dresses well but, that shirt is fantastic

[@lila5120]

Such a fine line between innovative and gimmicky. I don't understand how people are waiting for their peel off lip stain to develop lol

[@maryeckel9682]

That commercial stalks me all over the internet and it won't stop!

[@HotFlushSummer]

Please give us a demo video on that eye makeup look - that’s one of the best eye looks I’ve ever seen you do Robert!! Great video, we love hearing you go off about makeup you don’t like, I click instantly! 😂😂😂💕

[@vickihammons1443]

1000 % agree

[@bheatz22]

💯💯

[@DiMagnolia]

That glossier brush reminds me of those weird roll of gum dispensers, I can’t remember what they were called

[@leev263]

Bubble tape! I knew the shape reminded me of something!

[@lilissupafly]

It really does 😂

[@DiMagnolia]

@@leev263 thank you!!

[@melissaselenebeauty]

Looooove that purple eye look!! 🖤🖤

[@RobertWelsh]

Thank you! 🖤🖤

[@faithziqubu1331]

Wheather professional or not. Robert is by far the best make-up content created. He is so informative. You really help me make an informed decision when I do my make-up purchases. ❤

[@lacienewcombe5121]

“It’s giving ✨CREMATION ✨” 😂😂😂 you never fail to make me laugh! Love your videos

[@TheSqueet]

I love the booing in the background 😂. Not only are you and James the only KZbinrs I trust to not push product and to always be honest, but I am lucky enough to have the same skin issues you do so your advice is always spot on for me. You’re right, that BB cream from Kosas was terrible and it made me so sad! Thank you for your thoughtful and honest videos, and for always making me laugh! Much love to you and the pups!

[@Charlies-angel2018]

I adore Robert. Even when he's telling us what he doesn't like, imo he's still professional about it (yes, his comments make me chuckle but they're not personal attacks on any brand). And that is why I trust him with all his recommendations.

[@ohyah8916]

can’t focus on the video, i’m just starring and analysing the eye makeup andddd the lip gloss !!! the shine !!! the colour !!! where is it from ? 😂

[@ItsJustAndi]

yess this lip color

[@tylerreanne01]

Ooft Robert!! This makeup look is giving Disney Villain in the best way 😍🖤💜

[@lolaheart5887]

I must be following all the right people because I haven't heard anyone say anything about Kim' Kardashian's makeup brand other than it was a pass for them.

[@JenAyuni]

Please please put out a tutorial on how you did your purple look! That is the most gorgeous purple shadow look I've ever seen 😍

[@slay_mantha]

i was so disappointed w/ the twilight palette for so many reasons, but one of the biggest irks i had was that there was SO much potential for a twilight collection. there are so many cool concepts you could do (character features, vampire vs werewolf palettes, color changing things based on the vampire eyes to name a few) and they chose the most boring route possible. it felt like something made by people who didn't actually watch the movies or have any kind of nostalgic investment in the series.

[@jaqsre]

i sometimes use my mother hairspray and it’s VERY hairspray scented. that’s how i imagine that l’oréal setting spray so i’ll pass 😭

[@RobertWelsh]

It’s exactly that smell!

[@laurievt]

The Twilight palette review made me giggle. At the same time those colors are true to Western Washington in the winter time. 😂 But I get it. At the same time most of us in Seattle have 50 shades of black in our wardrobe.

[@SheilaMarguerite]

I will confess that I'm one of those ppl who used to use hairspray as a setting spray back in the day!! That's one I won't be getting, I'm partial to the NYX matte setting spray anyway 😊

[@what.the.whatever]

I use the NYX matte setting spray, can't go wrong with NYX

[@DaddyMoogie]

"50 shades of gray" Nooooooo don't give them ideas

[@purrgundy]

I'm surprised they didn't do it already, given the trend of cool-toned/grey eyeshadows

[@leev263]

50 shades was originally twilight fanfic, it would be a natural progression 🫢

[@kt2906]

This purple look is EVERYTHING. You look stunning!!! 💜

[@user-rq6tw4zp4w]

Oh my, I bought the L'Oréal setting spray a day before your video came out claiming it was crap, and I agree 100%. It was such a bad setting spray, felt horrible, and smelled awful, I felt like I needed a gas mask while using it... and in a pinch I went back to using my extra strong hold hairspray over my makeup....😬 The setting spray was so expensive, too😭 13 euros!

[@aliciaf1055]

Phenomenal makeup! The lip is just perfect with the purple eye.

[@Kimtasker]

Robert when ARE you doing your own brand? It would be UNREAL

[@originofsky]

I WAS SOOOOO UPSET WITH THE TWILIGHT PALETTE 😭😭😭😭 It doesn't tell a story even SLIGHTLY with those colors! I saw it and said, "what's the point of all those grays, when they blend together for another shade of gray???" it feels useless!! they should have had greens, blues for the ocean and Bella's blue item at the wedding, OBV blood red, more orange-y red for Bella's truck, white, black, brown (dirt/earth), light blue (ocean spray/original movie color scheme with bluish white lights), amber for the vampire eyes, etc. They could have done SO much better. I reread the series like 5 times when I was a young teenager. I think I could have planned the colorways much better than the pros picked for this palette. They could have even brought on fans that are artists, and had them help. Ugh it's just totally a lazy cash grab with 0 effort put in.

[@Ajae78]

Thank you for talking about that awful Glossier foundation brush! No one talks about it for some reason and it’s so bad! The few times I used it, I kept accidentally grazing my face with the metal portion. I finally cast that clunky mess into my makeup graveyard drawer. Didn’t much care for the foundation either.

[@angelahampson391]

Don’t get me started on the Glossier perfume can’t smell anything and please don’t tell me it’s how it reacts with my skin it’s a con imo ❤

[@lilissupafly]

I was watching the last episode of Glow Up last week and thought 'why have they never had Robert on?' and then you and James pop up in the masterclass audience! I was excited 😂

[@GrungeGalactica]

I love this vampy look Robert and that lip colour works so well!

[@ginadiodati1965]

"It looks like people were cremated and put into the palette." 😂 I spit my coffee out... You're so courteous and kind even when describing things you dislike. However, this time, you just went all out on Colourpop.

[@mekellemon3668]

The “boo” sounds are sending me😂😂

[@michelle7455]

Robert’s makeup always looks amazing but something about the purple eye today is choking me owwwwt!🤩

[@bisexualantigone]

Robert, I adore that shirt, it's gorgeous! Love the spiky big collar so much

[@talknerdytome5713]

Robert you are literally the only male makeup artist/professional that doesn’t get on my nerves ❤

[@AKbaby89]

Im on disability and live in an expensive state and have a very strict, expensive diet, so im SUPER picky about what i buy (i dont return things, and i pan my products. So if i dont like something, ill pay to ship it to one of my friends just so it gets used😂) but i saw a product at Sephora that really intrigued me, and i thought for sure id love it. The product im talking about is from a brand called Good Light, and its called Taste of space lip milk. Its a VERY matte product, it doesnt give any moisture or hydration, it actually dries out my lips, you have to put on a tiny bit and its white out shade of white, and you have to blend it in and it goes transparent. Its the thinnest product ive ever felt, you cannot layer it or put anything over it, unless of course you enjoy sandy lips, because that is what anything turns into if you try to put anything at all over the thinnest layer of product in the universe. Thinner than air. So anyways, it is a very confusing product to me, ive tried to figure out if theres a different way to use it or if its meant to be worn over something else that isnt mentioned anywhere from what ive seen😂 i just cannot think of a positive about the product, i guess other than the scent. It has a nice raspberry scent. 🤷‍♀️🤣

[@dinahmclean8036]

Robert, have you tried anything from Vampyre Cosmetics? I've pre-ordered their complete Buffy the Vampire Collection because I'm a die-hard fan, but I haven't seen hardly any reviews and I trust your take!

[@leighh1981]

That LIP!!!!!!?? PLEASE, what is that stunning lip?!?! I'm always looking for shades exactly like that❤❤

[@aimeevandijk1482]

This is my dream eye look, and I will hopelessly keep trying to recreate it forever

[@Kiteattackkilo]

Its pretty easy you should try it

[@reinventingmeesh]

If you haven't already please please please please please please do a tutorial on how you did your eyes today there are amazing and I have to say you look extra handsome with your hair that way 😅❤

[@carolschapter]

some releases this year are very good - tho im tired of seeing 100 blushes and lip liner releases (although i love lip liners and blushes) but last year, i think, the releases - SPECIALLY THOSE PH THINGIES THAT WERE SO *BORING* - were very but very boring and this yr there's new things or more variety

[@RobertWelsh]

This has been the year of blush!! 😂😂

[@VickyRyan2018]

I really want Robert to make more tutorials videos 😢😢 this eye look is gorgeous

[@zoomzoom103]

Okay I know this probably means next to nothing coming from someone who has never actually done make up before and only watches videos on youtube. but can I just say I really LOVE your eye make up in all your videos. like whenever I click on a video I always say "oh those are such pretty eyes today!"

[@recommendationsfromrach]

Here to ask what the lip gloss you have on is. Gorge! ❤

[@H.A.-zr2wc]

Love the eyes!!!🖤 Colourpop in the thumbnail...Dont roast one of your sponsors 😭

[@RobertWelsh]

😂😂😂 I love them! They aren’t my sponsors though I just have an affiliate link with them. Have to keep it honest!

[@victoriacbee]

The Twilight and Robert Pattinson shade 😂 I love it!

[@Woots_1]

Most of my collection comes from your advice. I only started using make up in my early 50's so I was a novice. You've always sent me in the right direction. Thank you Robert. 🙏

[@SheilaMarguerite]

I have nothing against them, but I am so uninterested in anything the Kardashians do, either as a group or individually 😅

[@DiMagnolia]

Robert, this lip is STUNNING on you

[@alisonsmith5339]

I’m getting ming vibes from Flash Gordon with this make up love it ❤

[@natashacutmore7005]

The Flower Knows products are packaged so beautifully- I ended up buying some as a gift for a friend after watching your previous video (avoided the highlighter though!).

[@scarlettroger1508]

The eye makeup is everything and a bit more.

[@barbarapauley3053]

So glad to hear your thoughts on the Kosas BB Burst. I got a sample at Sephora this weekend and opened it this morning to try- it looked curdled. Not putting that on my face. Love your eye look! ❤

[@wenchielauren]

GOODNESS. Like everyone else I am literally spellbound by that gorgeous purple eyeshadow!!! This is what my eyeshadow yearns to be when it grows up LOL 💜 Noticed your beautiful hands too, your look is overall just so polished. The attention to detail is always impressive.

[@IndigooceanOrg]

I love Flower Knows packaging, but never use it because the makeup itself never compares to other products I have.

[@jlkitz1775]

Perfect timing. I needed something, and someone funny to watch 😘👍🏾

[@RobertWelsh]

🖤🖤🖤

[@shakodeycarson9253]

Omg those eyes! PURPLE is my favorite color and I’m feeling inspired 💕💕

[@judymcdougall]

Robert your opinion is spot on. I love your new black shirt and your eye makeup. Fabulous as always ♥️☮️🖤

[@voicesa4921]

I absolutely love watching you! One of the very few influencers who is honest and actually knows what hes talking about. Thank you. I nearly fell for that L'Oréal bloody spray. The packaging screams of hair spray. 😂😂😂 leave the room after you’ve used it 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 Brilliant.

[@CausticCandy]

Great video! (The booing sounds SENT me! 😂) Love the shadow too, looks like you’re wearing tapes!

[@ValeriaKoleva]

Absolutely love these kinds of reviews, hearing your thoughts and the way you word everything! However, I would really appreciate visuals of the moments you described that disappointed you in the products. For example, I would’ve really loved seeing your attempts to apply the Kosas foundation, the highlighter from the other brand, etc. Much love!

[@ReptilianTeaDrinker]

The purple on your eyes is GORGEOUS! :O As a lover of purple, this makes me so bloody happy! You have so many iconic eye makeup looks! Also, hard agree on all of these! WE WANT MAKEUP THAT EXCITES US! I'm like a kid at the sweet shop when it comes to makeup, I want makeup that makes me happy and excited. But some releases have been pretty disappointing. For Glossier, for example, I've only ever liked their stretch concealer, cloud paint blush and their mascara. I've tried their eyeshadows and lip products and I HATED them. They felt horrible on the skin and were so DRY feeling and looked really bad too. Now I'm seeing these new releases and I can't fathom what they were thinking. :(

[@JS-jd3to]

You are so beautiful Robert! Stunning man ❤

[@nikolasincorporated]

Worst of 2024 for me easily was the supergoop skin tint 😅 patchy, dry, strange color range, and idk why but every influencer loved it! It went right back to sephora after a week of trying and failing to make it work

[@charismw2319]

We need him to collab with something. I want a perfume or candle from him. In masc, neutral, or feminine scents. Same with candles. He just seems like he smells good. I trust Robert with all my beauty needs.

[@Hannah-zw9ow]

I would totally buy a Robert welsh candle!!!!

[@sleepygoblin87]

I really want to learn how to do eye makeup like that! You're killing it with the makeup today! I need to practice more.

[@lyndsayellese]

loving the eyes 😍 wish i could do that on myself.. your amazing as always love your videos and your twin channel 😁💖 x

[@RobertWelsh]

Thank you so much! 🖤

[@jenniebeann]

Oh wow another AMAZING eye look from you Robert, there's no better colour than purple.

[@cheribosworth8023]

Chef’s Kiss on the purple eyeshadow. Looks fabulous on you! What palette is it?

[@lyndatewell4604]

Robert, I LOVE your eyeshadow look!! Gorgeous colors and application!!!

[@Mothpunk]

So glad I'm not the only one who wasn't feeling the twilight collection! I love a grungy color palette but i feel like it just was not right for a twilight release. I'm also not particularly nostalgic for twilight (at first i hated it because it was popular but as i got older i had genuine problems with the story) so I was already wasn't exactly excited, maybe I'm biased lol

[@katfanker]

This was brilliant, Robert! You are so kind, funny, and genuine. That shirt is beautiful, and oh my goodness, those purple eyes are perfection. Bravo

[@laurenmarieny]

You look fantastic in this video. Your face looks so sculpted and your skin and makeup looks great!

[@staciemelissa1122]

Thank you so much for helping me to learn so much more about makeup and at the same time have a laugh as you are hysterically funny😂

[@DiMagnolia]

I agree about twilight, the plot line just pissed me off 😂

[@jojomarch]

I swear I didn't see one good review on that Kosas bb cream (and I watched a lot!) - I don't know what they did!

[@katiekilgore6319]

I'm OBSESSED with the Kosas one, sometimes I fall asleep with it on and my skin genuinely feels amazing after finally removing it 😂 it stays on my skin all day long with literally zero issues.

[@sophie-2805]

Its giving og robert, that kind of shirt, dark eyes, and the purpleeeeee

[@AnnaNguyen-g8w]

I don't even know what you talked about in this video because your purple eye make up is stunning!!!! In love.

[@biggerbeautyupnorth]

This is absolutely my favourite eyeshadow look on your eyes ever. Stunning 😍

[@NeoStar]

The worst product I’ve used this year is definitely the Revlon Suede Ink Lip. Talk about running dry clay across your mouth. It dried out my lips and felt absolutely awful on application.

[@katiem4517]

My biggest makeup disappointment this year was one of the Huda Beauty Creamy Eyeshadow palettes. One of her nine pan palettes. The formula just kept getting muddy on the lids when you tried adding more than one shade and creased on me so badly. I loved her grunge palette so much though so my expectations were high.

[@PaulaMorrison-me4ee]

Your eyes look absolutely stunning! Beautiful! ❤ I agree with you about the L'oreal setting spray - bloody awful! In fact I'd rather use hair spray - I was a teenager in the 80s, it was so much of a thing. Much love 😘

[@morgsfif01]

robert the tan is a slay you are glowing!

[@marycampbell9734]

I love listening to you explaining these products! But I’m needing to know what that lippie is your using because it’s right up my alley!

[@adrianabriones7578]

“That might be the next collection, but you don’t want 50 Shades of Green Grey” 😅

[@loveit7484]

Your eye make up is ALWAYS amazing. Always. The look in this video is just WOW! Looks fabulous.

[@victoriaa9933]

The new Supergoop skin tint. It looks nice and dewey when applied but then either melts off if it's too hot and humid, or get dry throughout the day. It somehow disappears as the day goes by as well. It ends up sitting in pores. It's not terrible, but for the price point, it's not worth it. The wear is like the Maybelline BB Fresh Cream but less hydrating.

[@aubreygriffin9378]

You’re my favorite comfort channel ❤❤ I miss the grwm style spooky stories!

[@kerlitasso515]

OBSESSED with this eyeshadow 😍

[@StephanieBrianaClark]

THAT PURPLE EYE LOOK IS PURE 🔥🔥🔥 Slay it, Robert! ♡

[@StephanieBrianaClark]

What pallet or shadows did you use, if I may ask? Will you have a tutorial coming out for it? 😊