Root Beer Reviews: Save your money, don't buy these books! Part 1

[@SakuraDarling]

You give really great in-depth reviews of your books, Jess. Some people will talk about why they dislike or hate books and not give a proper reason as to why they dislike them. Glad you're uploading again!

[@OmnidogsVault]

Thank you so much!

[@MADDROBB]

Your review of Kevin Smith’s Batman has me laughing out loud. I’m so glad I never invested in them

[@OmnidogsVault]

hahahaha they're really awful

[@MADDROBB]

Omnidog's Vault I used to really like Kevin Smith but as I got older and watched his new Reboot Jay and Silent Bob, they’re really not that funny anymore

[@Hazukisam]

Finally a video where i dont end up buying stuff. Great video as always.😄

[@davidmolinaro4993]

I LOVE your videos. I recently stumbled across them and am enjoying the hell out of them. Then I saw this one and I can’t stop laughing. It’s hysterical. Now I have to search for other “bucket” books. Thank you so much!!!

[@OmnidogsVault]

lol, thank you so much!!

[@tediousmaximus1067]

You are so right about Batman: Odyssey. I love Neal Adams as an artist but his writing ... oh my god. He can't write to save himself. That book is a disaster!

[@vampazilla2622]

SO TRUE!!!!!

[@dadp12780]

Just subscribed. Man I’m glad I don’t own any of the books here. Thanks Jess!

[@zombiesrppl2589]

Hey... Just wanted to comment from the future in March 2020. You're really going to wish you kept those last books with all the T.P. shortage right now 😆. Great video I just found your channel and have been binging your videos.

[@KalEl016]

Outcast is really unfortunate. Elizabeth Breitweiser makes everything she touches look absolutely gorgeous (The Fade Out, Kill or Be Killed) and this book is no exception. But the pacing of the 1st volume was sooo slow and I couldn't care enough to pick up the next one.

[@OmnidogsVault]

the art is really nice

[@ShaneMatlock]

I expected to disagree with you on a few of these but most of the stuff you show is spot on. I liked Walking Dead well enough. It was entertaining, if overly dialogue heavy, but Kirkman is really overrated. I lost some respect for Gem Mint when he said Invincible was one of his favorite comic books he has ever read. I read the whole thing via my local library and it was fine, but definitely shouldn't be your favorite comic unless you're not reading enough of those thousands of omnibuses behind you. Neal Adams should not be writing anything, ever. My only real disagreement with you would be that I didn't hate Kevin Smith's Batman. It wasn't great by any means and his Green Arrow and Daredevil were both much better, but I got a few laughs out of his Batman. But I never really took it seriously either. It just seemed like Kevin Smith writing Batman, which means lots of juvenile humor. He is capable of better work and maybe it is unfinished because he knows it wasn't his best.

[@OmnidogsVault]

Smotlock I’m glad we agreed more than we disagreed! Thanks for watching!

[@1JeffBlack]

That cover of "Batman Odyssey" tells a lot about the quality of that book...Batman riding a dinosaur...ugh! Nice review! Just a old HQ fan here, but also one more sub :)

[@jeffreyroberts4156]

Glad to see you brought back the "bucket of shame" and poring the dreadful A&W on those bad boys (ok, I do drink regular A&W occasionally but that's only because it's all we ever get around here). I have Outcast 1 I picked up last year because I saw everyone on Omnibros pick it up but I still haven't read it yet. I was about to get vol 2 when it came out but glad I didn't. Nice shirt, by the way. I suppose you will be rooting for Rams this evening in the wild card game? Being from Fargo, I'm a north division guy so I will be rooting for Vikings next week (if Rams win looks like they will be playing MN).

[@OmnidogsVault]

glad you like the bucket of shame lol! I like regular A & W, just not diet...

[@lloydwong7852]

Hahaha! "Your time on this earth is short" What did you do to the Wolf-Man Omnibus after you gave it the rootbeer bath? It would have been funny to pull the original bathed copy and given it another bath! I feel bad saying I needed more Omnidog videos in your cat then seeing these posted!

[@OmnidogsVault]

LOL, it's okay, I'm glad you want more content!

[@spencerwelchii573]

I agree with all but the last 3 books, I liked them all a lot...particularly if you look at Kevin Smith's books as 'Elseworlds' books.

[@Nadeensbeat]

I was sooo close to purchasing Outcast!! The Black Monday Murders moves up on my to buy list!

[@Phil1_427]

root beer of the month club...what a great idea!! Rucka book on the list makes me sad. another one i was looking at recently was stump town...any thoughts on stump town?

[@OmnidogsVault]

I liked all of Stumptown!

[@sillyname3998]

Lol this was awesome can't wait for part 2 :)

[@earlgrey862]

as much as I have to agree on Odyssey: Outcast is not the re-invention of comics or sth, but it's definitely a well told horror story with good art.

[@richardNbacchus]

To this day im still upset that I spend $12 on Batman: Cacophony 😂

[@carla_the_strange7234]

Is "Outcast" that boring?! >.< BTW everytime you shower your books with root beer I am in shock!!!! But I trust your actions. My wallet thanks you! :P

[@kakupicollo]

No, it's brilliant.

[@studentministry3870]

Never read the Batman books by kevin smith. I saw the artwork online and was embarrassed for Walt Flanagan. So bad. But great warning video Jess!

[@rolan5948]

Lol I already bought all 4 kick ass hardcovers, I guess I’m forced to read all but from reading kick ass 1 and the hit girl prelude it was damn enjoyable and funny

[@jabezcreed]

Yeah, unfortunately Neal Addams has been allowed to write a few more times. Superman: Coming of the Supermen and now Deadman.

[@srijitbhattacharya887]

Omnidog! I wish you had given this review earlier! I already bought 2 volumes of Kirkman's Outcast....and I have to agree that it's not good. Volume 1 is lame and the story is cliched and the characters are forced. All in all, the story feels disjointed with events happening like out of the blue. There is no characterization or insight whatsoever.

[@OmnidogsVault]

sorry I didn't get it out sooner! Your review is spot on!

[@SuperSilver316]

I don't like those stories either, but I don't think books should be treated in this way. Then again, i've burned copies of the great expectations, so what do I know.

[@OmnidogsVault]

Understood. You are entitled to your opinion!

[@SuperSilver316]

thanks for the great content, I really enjoy this channel and all of the omnibus collectors channels, you guys do great work, and I love your general positive outlook on comics and collected editions. I understand why you did what you did, but I'm glad you you still listened to what I had to say.

[@OmnidogsVault]

@@SuperSilver316 absolutely! Thank you for your praise, I really appreciate it. The root beer dumping was a shtick that has been retired now. I think it was funny for a while but every book has alot of hard work put into it by creators and that needs to be respected.

[@SuperSilver316]

great to hear, keep up the great work!

[@blueg8731]

16:00 So those books are like Star Wars 8... I love that bucket of shame.

[@jakenap7184]

Going back and watching some of your old videos, this video is the most sassy you’ve ever been lol. You’re like a 17 year old valley girl haha You should do another couple of these videos (I know part 2 exists) these are so funny and entertaining

[@OmnidogsVault]

lol, sassy

[@felipesarmientodejor]

LOL!!!!! My friend you should have break them apart and recycle them! Now with the root beer I am not sure if they can be recycled 😔

[@OmnidogsVault]

I wanted to set them on fire!!!

[@felipesarmientodejor]

Omnidog's Vault lol!!!! Understandable!

[@mangageekdom]

I'm so sorry you had to buy/read all that.

[@OmnidogsVault]

LOL, all for the good of the channel!!

[@MrJohnffrey87]

I think Allstar Batman and Robin the Boy Wonder is much worse, though the art by Jim Lee is good, the writing by Frank Miller is horrible, it's like what the hell happened to Frank Miller? he used to be such a good comic artist and writer, but Batman in that book is a complete psycho and lunatic who abuses Dick Grayson and Alfred and kills cops and criminals.

[@ChesterLivingstonIII]

Did you like the Hit-Girl series?

[@bigboycheesepuffs9644]

Any good Ant man comics out there?

[@OmnidogsVault]

Antman: Scott Lang and Astonishing Ant Man by Nick Spencer are good!

[@bigboycheesepuffs9644]

Omnidog's Vault thx

[@Katsudon305]

I also recommend Astonishing Ant-Man from Nick Spencer. It's fun... and funny.

[@ryleynelson5335]

got through 17 issues of outcast then dropped the series because it just wasn't very interesting.

[@GameBookMovieGuy]

"Stinkarooni!"

[@michischwarz]

For me it's Rick Remenders take on Captain America in Dimension Z and the whole lot after it. What a piece of crap. Worst comic books in years for me. Lack of story is compensated with utter brutality. Don't buy these.

[@89ty3]

Yes! We need more angry Jess

[@ReaperXC]

Watched this the week after buying the Adams Batman omnibus. Colouring sucks.

[@mladenkulic446]

Greg rucka can't do no wrong, well i didn't like his Stumptown Vol 2 Case of the Baby in the Velvet Case.

[@Broncos4Ever303]

Batman Noel is fantastic.

[@jeremyg371]

Didn't know you had hate in you. Good to see your not a robot. lol, just kidding thx for the review & keep it up.

[@ThisGuysThoughts]

Nice review

[@tolga_berk]

Next time you might use the bathtub ;)

[@sugarray6250]

The two that I didn't really like was, Y the last man. I was begging it to end and Kill or be Killed. Way, way, way overated.

[@Spartan_83]

A lot of people like outcast.

[@OmnidogsVault]

I think that's great, I just happen to be one of the ones who don't. I think Invincible is the only thing I like from him though

[@Spartan_83]

@@OmnidogsVault I haven't read it, tried watching the show but thought it was slow and boring but maybe it got better?

[@godson305]

Once again the shame bucket

[@OmnidogsVault]

LOL

[@NFLDude56]

PLEASE cover Wolverine: The Best There Is, absolutely the worst marvel comic I've read. Complete unlikable garbage.