Rugby Referee Analysis: Andrew Brace - SA vs England

  Рет қаралды 40,941

TASanalytics

TASanalytics

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 169
@anwerwatt3218
@anwerwatt3218 3 күн бұрын
Bro, we’ve missed you😭🤚🏽, please let the videos come through. Excited to have you back🤝🏽
@JohnTerblanche-l1r
@JohnTerblanche-l1r 3 күн бұрын
I dont agree. This bro is disrespecting all the reffs. It's clear since 23' reffs are trying to give us a fast nice spectacle and they really try their best, thats their job. If you psycho analise like this guy you get this result. Reffs cant stop the game every 2m. Everyone complained about the 23' game being to slow and stop start, now people are gonna harass the reffs when they are only doing their what the fans wanted in the first place. The ref was actually really good in this game, we should stop looking for penalties everywhere and just enjoy the spectacle as it is now, fast and entertaining. If there really was an bad call WR has it's own channel with an former reff Nigel Owens who gives us some insight not some utuber who moans about every ruck, if reffs did what this channel is showing us rugby will be done as a spectacle...
@anwerwatt3218
@anwerwatt3218 3 күн бұрын
@@JohnTerblanche-l1rmaybe if the refs were more consistent, we wouldn’t have to watch these videos. How the hell do you miss a penalty or dangerous tackle in front of your eyes, plus they have TMO. Rugby is a contact sport, if refs ignore the rules, a lot of great players will have to retire early. Imagine not giving a penalty or red or yellow card because the game needs to flow, like what the hell. And btw, if you don’t like his videos, don’t watch them. Some of us enjoy it. Sharp
@boerbru9721
@boerbru9721 3 күн бұрын
@@JohnTerblanche-l1r i dont agree with you , theres channels that nitpick teams and players thats fine but when its refs people start getting precious about it. i like his insights and his analysis of refereeing hes not implying refs should stop the game every ruck either. but i do like when shows ref being inconsistent especially at scrum-times and shows there is a bigger problem which is that world rugby adds rules every year but hardly rescinds old rules.
@tommiejoubert4462
@tommiejoubert4462 3 күн бұрын
Glad your back! Can you please do a video on Ireland VS Argentina. I thought the way that Ireland defended the maul and disrupted the Argentinian rucks were a new level of working in the gray area of the law.
@rob.1
@rob.1 3 күн бұрын
As ever, you make some good points, but too often your commentary states something absolutely happens, when the visuals clearly dont show that. Show, dont tell.
@LTronZero
@LTronZero 3 күн бұрын
Probably the best officiating I’ve seen between Springboks and England as well 🙄
@tasanalytics
@tasanalytics 3 күн бұрын
Yip, that's the sad part.
@elliottsw
@elliottsw 3 күн бұрын
Great video! I have a few responses as someone who works in this area. 1) The ball went backwards. Not a knock on. 2) Good spot, however it could be that because of the short closing distance, the SA player didn't have time to get in to position before the England player was on him. Maybe. 3) His arms are clearly stretched out attempting to wrap the legs of the player. Just because he failed the tackle doesn't mean it was a no arms tackle. It should be a head injury assessment, not a yellow card. 4) Yep, definitely a neck roll. The second one I'm not so sure, he was binding and fell to the side when he was pushed, and let go. If he pulled the SA player with him then maybe, and maybe his intent was a neck roll - but it didn't happen. 5) Diving in to the ruck, yeah he does seem to be - but it could be a legal attempt to touch the ball down on the line, I'm not sure though I think you're right. 6) Definitely a penalty, nothing SA12 could do about that. This is similar to number 2 in your video. 7) The SA obstruction is more deliberate because as he is running back to get onside he slows down deliberately in front of the catching player to prevent anyone contesting the ball or tackling him when he lands - the England ones are worth looking at but I *think* they don't slow down and aren't directly in front of the receiver - the SA player gets to the ball in most of your clips, as the England player is out of the way. That's the difference, they're not obstructing the tackle once the carrier lands. 8) That's a great spot, both lineouts and scrums have become increasingly slack with people ignoring the laws and refs not enforcing them. Because there are so many set plays, players focus on doing their role instead of following the rules. 9) The England player is not offside because he was onside when he initially bound to the maul and did not release his bind. He has to be onside when he initially binds, he does not have to release if it turns. 10) England 6 did not try to collapse the maul, he was ripped out of it and thrown to the floor. The players who then tripped over him were not bound to the maul and therefore not part of it. The ball is further up the pitch, still in the maul. 11) England 8 did not go off his feet, he was on his feet (although very close to his knees) and his hands were on the tackled player. The SA player comes round the side (also arguably off his feet in a similar position) and picks up the ball. If the SA player stepped over instead of diving round this would have been okay. The reason SA get penalised for going off their feet is that the England counter ruckers actually form a ruck over the ball to contest it, unlike the previous example where SA just dived in round the side without forming a gate. 12) Back to the scrums it's the same thing, SA famously always pull their opponents down - so much so that refs don't even seem to notice it. How are props supposed to stay upright when their opponent is putting all their weight on their shirt, tugging them to the ground? It needs sorting out. 13) The advantage would go away after a certain number of phases, and usually goes as soon as you kick the ball. What makes you say it was a penalty advantage?
@menlolottering
@menlolottering 3 күн бұрын
Why comment and critisize someone else's work. That is the easiest thing in life! If you are in the industry - point us to your videos and comments!
@chadliampolley6991
@chadliampolley6991 3 күн бұрын
@@menlolottering Seriously, my dude? Perhaps you object, but this is a public video of CRITICISM of the refereeing. I don't see it as objectionable to add to that in a constructive way. Jesus.
@braindeadprawn
@braindeadprawn 3 күн бұрын
What's wrong with 12? I'm genuinely asking. Both sides are trying to get the other side to collapse? Are you saying you are not allowed to pull down on your bind?
@elliottsw
@elliottsw 3 күн бұрын
​@@braindeadprawn yes you're not allowed to pull down on their shirt - that's intentionally collapsing the scrum
@Hiltok
@Hiltok 3 күн бұрын
I'm just an interested rugby viewer (Aussie) and I think you are right on your assessments. Worth noting that on (1) whether the ball is knocked on or not is moot since Kolisis (the tackler) and also Libbock are both very offside having run forward immediately the ball is thrown by George - no waiting for it to clear the 15m line. De Allende and the outside backs held their position. The offside move happened behind the ref so needed the AR's to call it. AR's never call lineout throwers for having their feet on touch and in the field of play. The only excuse is that they have eyes up looking for more impactful stuff and they still miss this sort of thing. It is frustrating when obvious stuff gets missed.
@bengreen171
@bengreen171 3 күн бұрын
That first clip - was never a knock on. The ball went backwards.
@andrewhussey2002
@andrewhussey2002 3 күн бұрын
I think you should referee a live game and then Andrew Brace can spend a few hours with the video on slow motion and critique your job.
@HoBBLeCooKiE
@HoBBLeCooKiE 2 күн бұрын
The slomo was for everyone to see what he means and take it in. Some of these were ignorance or bias from the officials. I think you should stop being a poes.
@leplessis8179
@leplessis8179 18 сағат бұрын
Many of us - and I've refereed over 1000 games in three continents - completely agree with this analysis.
@hannovermeulen3126
@hannovermeulen3126 15 сағат бұрын
@@HoBBLeCooKiE couldnt say it better
@farquad3138
@farquad3138 19 сағат бұрын
Its not a knock on if it bounces backwards mate
@FearlessOnFourWheels
@FearlessOnFourWheels 3 күн бұрын
So 15 yellow cards in a game, that will be fun.
@Hard_Thinker
@Hard_Thinker 3 күн бұрын
So what are you saying, we shouldn’t have rule or we shouldn’t always apply the rule. In you esteemed opinion, when should we or shouldn’t we apply them o’mighty one? If there are 15 yellow cards in the game it shouldn’t be because of the officiating, but because of the decisions made by the players.
@FearlessOnFourWheels
@FearlessOnFourWheels 3 күн бұрын
@Hard_Thinker Common sense should be used. If it's not malicious the game must be allowed to flow. It is a contact sport. That is why we watch it and play it. If new rules are brought in the players must be given time to get used to the rules. It should not kill the game.
@HoBBLeCooKiE
@HoBBLeCooKiE 2 күн бұрын
No. If these calls were called correctly, the players would see they cannot get away with it. Stop being so ignorant.
@keanubahnsen1791
@keanubahnsen1791 2 күн бұрын
Glad you’re back 😍😍😍
@roleinc7204
@roleinc7204 3 күн бұрын
The obstruction rule at kicks is a mess. NZ has been absolutely hammered with penalties from this. Not seeing the consistency for other teams either. The foul play for head contact is also an utter mess of a rule. Dipping into the tackle (the fault of the attacking player) is responsible for 80% of these incidents. The strictness around these accidental incidents are sending players who are in correct tackling positions to the sin bin which is making the game generally worse, not better. There needs to be an adjustment to the rule whereby any dipping or ducking into a tackle that provokes head contact should be deemed accidental and thus exempt from any 'foul play' sanctions.
@dn822
@dn822 3 күн бұрын
Seems like even if you run a straight line back and someone runs into you it's a penalty. I mean the need to get back to be inplay
@ethant4531
@ethant4531 2 күн бұрын
@@dn822 and the thing is, what are they supposed to do? Stand still to prevent a penalty? Really stupid.
@jameswyatt4443
@jameswyatt4443 17 сағат бұрын
The lineout is not illegal, you, they’re still part of the lineout even if they step to the left.
@jacklav1
@jacklav1 3 күн бұрын
Great video, really informative. I think it would be even better if you read the observations as it’s hard to follow what’s happening if you have to jump between reading the text and following the action.
@iallso1
@iallso1 2 күн бұрын
1:06 in, there is no twist from the white 4 on green 16, green 16 goes to his right when cleared out by white 5. Whether that clean out is legal is another matter, but yet another mistake by the officials.
@waltbarratt200
@waltbarratt200 3 күн бұрын
Love you’re vids please keep them coming, it exposes how poor and inconsistent the referees are today, world rugby is ruining the game we all love, perhaps there is a job for you with them
@Michele-y9i
@Michele-y9i 3 күн бұрын
I agree on De Allende high tackle and english double banking and Dan Cole binding from the wrong side of the maul. The other are either down to referee feeling either just wrong. Ben Earls clearly knocks it backward, the high tackle on Itoje is not clear (there is no ricochet on the head, maybe it was just shoulder on shoulder) the scrums need to be seen from both sides and Kolisi double receiver is completely fine to me. Also if you compete at the breakdown and than you go off feat is fine, you must not go straight to ground before competing. Ben Earls no arms tackle is a 50-50 as he clearly tries to wrap but fails by a lot. I am neutral and I think the referee did a good job overall :)
@supersaien21
@supersaien21 23 сағат бұрын
Can you do thee fiji vs ireland game please. You will definitely find alot of bias there
@TheAseer2020
@TheAseer2020 Күн бұрын
Love your channel. I have always thought that one other onfield assistant reff needs to be added.
@nickmcewan5932
@nickmcewan5932 Күн бұрын
We keep seeing the same thing every week! Problem is no one is holding the officials to account🤷🏻‍♂️ I can appreciate how the on field referee might miss a few things or make a wrong call in the moment, I get that. What I can’t understand is the TMO interference and totally wrong calls when they have replay and time to review! There’s no excuse for that! Look at the All Blacks last couple of games, TMO calls a neck roll when it clearly wasn’t against France at a crucial time in the match, and this was Marius Jonker a seasoned referee! then fast forward a week and the TMO is begging the referee to give a yellow when the referee has made his decision! Good on him for sticking with his call! TMO needs massive restriction I feel?
@pauljamison3340
@pauljamison3340 3 күн бұрын
The standard of referring at the moment is terrible!!! TMO's are not much better, they only see what they want to see. The first clip was obvious during the game but no call from the TMO!!!
@MadMarchTaffy
@MadMarchTaffy 2 күн бұрын
when will you do one about the Boss being offside at every breakdown and never getting pinged for it?
@colinhoran9351
@colinhoran9351 3 күн бұрын
I think the kick chase obstructions are really tough to call. You could probably call a penalty every single time, it's more about penalizing the most egregious obstructions imo.
@KOTW.Adventures
@KOTW.Adventures Күн бұрын
As much as I enjoy watching these videos, if the ref blew everything that you mentioned, the game would take twice as long.
@TheCryptoSniper
@TheCryptoSniper 3 күн бұрын
Any take on the Fassi 'Forward pass'
@johnhanson5943
@johnhanson5943 2 күн бұрын
Still - I‘d enjoy being an international ref. Great job.
@Whoknows-zu2eb
@Whoknows-zu2eb 3 күн бұрын
I get why you do this in that channels are now monetised and negativity breeds popularity, but they're not helpful. You are criticising decisions which can easily be missed in the speed of the game. Wasn't it Wayne Barnes when he retired said that we either accept the game with referee errors or we meticulously review every decision with the TMO to ensure right decisions. I know which one I'd prefer. I think it would be better to include more positives about the ref, else it just feeds into the awful rhetoric that has crept into the game.
@bradrockl8330
@bradrockl8330 3 күн бұрын
How can it be missed when there is TMO!!!And yet the ref missed a lot of calls
@mhorlor
@mhorlor 3 күн бұрын
We need to hold a high standard but constant criticism doesn’t achieve that. Positive feedback has to come with the negative.
@ahighlander7278
@ahighlander7278 2 күн бұрын
Surely that\s the point, the whole inconsistency of the officiating. The TMOs think the game is all about them.
@sergiolopez-zu2cr
@sergiolopez-zu2cr 3 күн бұрын
SA missed Ben O´k
@Vidyanth
@Vidyanth 3 күн бұрын
Great anaylsis
@waynelion-cachet35
@waynelion-cachet35 3 күн бұрын
Its fair to say, the ref was not up to standard. World Rugby needs to raise the standard
@juanpbotha
@juanpbotha 3 күн бұрын
That last one had me super confused. Absolutely no advantage; absolutely no advantage over called: I couldn't believe my eyes.
@kylesmythe8126
@kylesmythe8126 3 күн бұрын
What's the hype about Ben Earls? I don't get it
@Macron87
@Macron87 3 күн бұрын
He’s had a few great games. A few shockers.
@kylesmythe8126
@kylesmythe8126 3 күн бұрын
@Macron87 ya I guess that is to be expected in a transitional England team, I feel like he's doing more wrong than right at the moment though
@janvorster4694
@janvorster4694 18 сағат бұрын
Refs must be hold accountable
@die_regte_vicks
@die_regte_vicks 2 күн бұрын
bro where do yoy get the full matches downloaded?
@PauCandi
@PauCandi 3 күн бұрын
@TASanalytics You have to do the analysis of the end of the match between Ireland and Argentina, it was a blatant theft!
@garethhazell3545
@garethhazell3545 11 сағат бұрын
What was your opinion on Holly Davidson refereeing of the Ireland vs Fiji match. I thought she seemed to be targeting Fiji and penalizing them unfairly?
@hehehe6810
@hehehe6810 3 күн бұрын
The game has become WWE. The team that is trailing will always get the benefit of the doubt or no one sees their trangressions, its like a participation medal. this is to ensure cliff-hanger games. Unfortunately its not right and should be investigated. I suspect the officials are under clear instructions, to me this is match fixing and over dramatization of games. We will never see big wins again.
@georgecouvaras9533
@georgecouvaras9533 3 күн бұрын
The question that I have, is how many incorrect decisions constitute a good game for the referee and his team. In my opinion none of them are worth feeding - oxygen thieves at the very best.
@henryburton6529
@henryburton6529 2 күн бұрын
First one obviously went backwards
@iceswallowgum8540
@iceswallowgum8540 2 күн бұрын
What is the other option for genge at those rucks?
@michaelkeegan9260
@michaelkeegan9260 19 сағат бұрын
Counter rucking legally... get low grab player, push. Not run and dive with a leading shoulder at their head.
@RATELdefcon1
@RATELdefcon1 3 күн бұрын
If ever there was match fixing or shall we rather say an attempt. It seems the TMO's is the most influenced party.
@mhorlor
@mhorlor 3 күн бұрын
De Allende is too upright. Can’t be much debate on that.
@igsaan8573
@igsaan8573 3 күн бұрын
Please analyze the Argentina vs Ireland. Especially the scrums 😮
@Ballas56
@Ballas56 2 күн бұрын
Everybody can make a mistake - the trick is too learn from it and improve. Is Andrew Brace getting better after all his mistakes? Probably not - do something World Rugby. Additional coaching may work.
@lieutenantdanielson
@lieutenantdanielson 3 күн бұрын
its 4 seconds in and you're wrong. A knock on is a loss of control of the ball resulting in the ball travelling forwards and touching another player or the ground. It clearly is a loss of possession backwards and touches the floor
@HoBBLeCooKiE
@HoBBLeCooKiE 2 күн бұрын
Tell me using physics how you go forward and lose the ball backwards. It hits the ground (not floor, we aren't dancing) and then only rolls backwards.
@fredrickjsimpson
@fredrickjsimpson 22 сағат бұрын
Do the Fiji vs Ireland game please.
@wayoflifefitness5622
@wayoflifefitness5622 3 күн бұрын
How is a ref or even a tmo supposed to pick all this up, you may as well just accept watching it with the current rules that a bunch of stuff will get missed every game
@alec1115
@alec1115 3 күн бұрын
One thing we are taught as referees is materiality. If there is a slight infringement that does not affect play, we issue a warning and do not assess a PK.
@elliottsw
@elliottsw 3 күн бұрын
The TMO has access to all the cameras and all the replays they need to make a decision but if they stopped to check every single play every single time, the match would take all day. As such there will always be things that are missed, especially knock ons where the ball goes backwards - they're hard to spot even in slow motion.
@stevebritton8741
@stevebritton8741 2 күн бұрын
clear knock on ??? the ball went backwards
@bkj3845
@bkj3845 2 күн бұрын
Funny how the losers of the match defend their teams foul play, TSA is doing a good job with these analyses, although it won't change the outcome, the SH will always chew the hind-tit when they play in the NH!
@johanheath9051
@johanheath9051 3 күн бұрын
Stop eating Sour grapes, a loss is a loss, get over it, Springboks are the best💪💪
@El_Wrath
@El_Wrath 3 күн бұрын
Genge needs to go
@fu8713
@fu8713 3 күн бұрын
All these pedantic rules are a FUKN MESS this modern day game is fkn ridiculous 👎🏻👎🏻🤌🤌😬🤛🤛
@andrewfarrer4568
@andrewfarrer4568 3 күн бұрын
Is brace just bad or is he biased? would love to see stats on ref's wrt 50/50 calls and incorrect calls in each game and see if it shows bias.
@JohanPlankies
@JohanPlankies 3 күн бұрын
When i look at previous boks and URC games where Brace has officiated SA teams, the calls are allways 50/50. He got reprimanded for the Stormers game, they lost because of scrum penalties they didnt receive. There was quite a few times during this game that Brace would lift his arm for a penalty, then lowered his arm again, not blowing his whistle, got me thinking he wasent sure about his calls on field and most of these calls were made against the boks.
@JohnTerblanche-l1r
@JohnTerblanche-l1r 3 күн бұрын
The 12 was trying to buy a yellow. SA 12 stopped dead in his tracks a meter before contact. The 12 then rams his head up into SA 12, he could have easily lowered his head to stomach level and did a drive with his feet to gain meters instead he reared his head up for nothing. He was having a shite game anyway, they had a overlap once in SA 22, just for him to kick the ball dead. SA12 is a world cup winner, best 12 SA has ever had arguably. just for some shite club lvl player who runs like a bull into his head, Damian has tackled many 12s in similar positions for years. I think the 12 wanted to be removed because he knew he was playing average, he got smashed by KLA, and when they had a chance in 2nd half, he popped the ball to the 13 who got smashed by Kriel, instead of the behind the back to Marcus who is their best player and had a possible overlap...
@pazstrength5322
@pazstrength5322 3 күн бұрын
First clip SA off side at the line out
@johnsmithwinkwink1704
@johnsmithwinkwink1704 3 күн бұрын
The Ref tried his hardest to let the Poms will and they still LOST.
@hugh8891
@hugh8891 3 күн бұрын
First tackle siya makes on earl, is it not knocked on by siya in the tackle so play on??
@groundhogguns5828
@groundhogguns5828 2 күн бұрын
People still get emotionally invested in sport. One big corrupt kabal run by bookies.
@gerryoconnor5846
@gerryoconnor5846 3 күн бұрын
the game would be terrible to watch if there were this many stops,
@axxey
@axxey 3 күн бұрын
With the amount Malcolm Marx is on the grass opponents side of the ruck constantly not supporting his body weight at all putting his head down there it's not surprising. He knows the rules are bullsheet and regularly puts himself in bad positions then appeals to the ref.
@MeiA-h9r
@MeiA-h9r Күн бұрын
5:42 since when can tacklers roll into the cleaners I thought you supposed to roll east or west and not north or south
@chrismia2402
@chrismia2402 3 күн бұрын
Brace is a known SA hater.
@themotobanditshow
@themotobanditshow 16 сағат бұрын
I watched this game. The ref was shite..
@cameronmurie
@cameronmurie 3 күн бұрын
ball went backwards off SA 6 tackle. I have seen refs call that knock on from the tackler. So There's that. ( and I dont like Brace much)
@beetle6323
@beetle6323 2 күн бұрын
Andy Grace is should not be allowed to ref international games, his clueless and blind.
@iallso1
@iallso1 2 күн бұрын
5:09 green 7 does not go straight for the ball, but instead rests his body weight on the ruck, then when the ball comes back, green 7 plays the ball in the ruck with his hands. Clearly foul play.
@MrDude-ht3rv
@MrDude-ht3rv 3 күн бұрын
Great video. Andrew brace has always been & will always be an atrociously bad official
@MeiA-h9r
@MeiA-h9r Күн бұрын
I appreciate it that you only post games that depict HORRENDOUS officiating This must have been the most frustrating game to watch in terms of officiating and World Rugby need me to invest more into training its refs better instead of pushing out more dumb rules
@Willhhoward
@Willhhoward 3 күн бұрын
This channel is riddled with inaccuracies 1. When SA6 hit ENG 8, the ball gos backwards 2. ENG 8 Dives at the knee. The Eng8 is statonay as the contact is made and is pushed down due to the force of the contact 3. The differences with clearing with the kicks is that the SA play slows infront of the catcher where as the eng players continue to run past the catcher 4. Dan Cole is not in a offside position, as at point of contact he is at the front of the maul 5. There is a difference between collapsing the maul and not collapsing the maul This channle name should be changed to "cry more because refs cant be perfect"
@kobuslouw9533
@kobuslouw9533 3 күн бұрын
Oh we're not crying, we won. Sounds like you are crying though.
@Pubwie
@Pubwie 3 күн бұрын
The only inaccuracy is England's ability to tackle with arms
@EliJon378
@EliJon378 3 күн бұрын
Your knowledge of rugby boggles the mind! The fact your comment starts with "This channel is riddled with inaccuracies" says mountains. Consider starting your own channel to argue your interpretations. All opinions matter, but to start the comment the way you did is unnecessary. I'll end my comment this way, 4 times World Champions, current Rugby Championship champions, number one in the world, most respected opposition of the All Blacks, their supporters can't be that inaccurate.
@elliottsw
@elliottsw 3 күн бұрын
​@@EliJon378this video criticises both sides, assuming anyone who disagrees with the criticism is an England fan is a bit odd. If this channel is a SA fan channel then it should say so but it seems to be balanced and fair to me (even if I disagree with some of the analysis).
@EliJon378
@EliJon378 3 күн бұрын
@@elliottsw I'm assuming it's a SA supporter because it only seems to show SA videos, and there's nothing in the rules that says it should say who they support. Yes you're right, it does show both sides, and it is fair and balanced.
@davidshekleton9908
@davidshekleton9908 6 сағат бұрын
Message to them person who made this post. I am assuming you are South African?. I am South African as well and if you are South African I'm a little bit embarrassed for you. I only watch 43 seconds into this and had to turn it off. That first knock on you point to the ball is clearly knocked back in the tackle.... You even have it in slow motion. How did you not pick that up?... The next two incidents you raised were just ridiculous so I switched this off
@mattjones3361
@mattjones3361 2 күн бұрын
Youve got a few a those wrong im afraid. Some well spotted, but some wrong. But we have to accept that not everything will be seen and hope that things will be evenly missed and evenly penalised, otherwise we will ruin the game nitpicking.
@goldie0919
@goldie0919 3 күн бұрын
Haven't seen such a biased view of the game by yourself, either your S.A or just hate England (most do).
@leplessis8179
@leplessis8179 18 сағат бұрын
Anyone watch Luke Pearce this weekend? Doh! - His Dad was a MUCH better referee!
@jameslast7555
@jameslast7555 2 күн бұрын
Dirty Cheslin Kolby off side at the kick, then goes on to take out the player in the air. Has a history of dirty play like that. Cant believe this was missed. The player fell very heavily due to this blatant foul play.
@tristiana5642
@tristiana5642 2 күн бұрын
When you're on the loosing side you gotta be defensive even when the officials did they're best to help you out, but now you're scrapping the bottom of the barrel 😂 offside, can see your point but dirty play? you're smoking cheap kak😂 it was a fair contest in the air, eng player cut him off as well as he had to go around the guy and then jump. Another example of the officials trying to not keep consistent where it benefits you 🤫🤏
@HoBBLeCooKiE
@HoBBLeCooKiE 2 күн бұрын
Another biased dimwit.
@samgreer8274
@samgreer8274 3 күн бұрын
Its all to even up the game. Unfair on the Boks but thats what I believe the refs are doing.
@brycefairbairn389
@brycefairbairn389 3 күн бұрын
You should do a video of a full game showing how many times SA players try to jackel the ball (successful or not) while not supporting body weight. I think you could do a highlights package on a certain number 16 alone and the number of times he doesn’t support his weight 😂
@Hiltok
@Hiltok 3 күн бұрын
Very first thing in your video, you have Kolisi tackling Earls and complain about Earl's knocking on. How about you check if Kolisi was onside? He should have been back 10m until the ball goes over the 15m line. Of course he ran forward as soon as George threw it, and Libbock was also very obviously offside. The AR's should have called it because that happens behind the back of the ref.
@hendrileroux751
@hendrileroux751 3 күн бұрын
Please stop using the subtitles. If you cant talk use a IA voice or something. Love the great analysis but you cant read and watch the play at the same time. Its hard to see what you trying to show. Just some positive suggestions....thanks
@saiyandemonisher
@saiyandemonisher 3 күн бұрын
Agree
@RatedR18-00
@RatedR18-00 2 күн бұрын
It really isn't that difficult as you make it sound buddy lol If it's that hard for you how about pausing the video to read it then continue to watch, you low IQ individual😂
@fu8713
@fu8713 3 күн бұрын
Why aren’t Springboks playing Ireland and or France????😳🤷🏼‍♂️😂 Someone is looking after them lol not only the referees the World Rugby guy must be South African lol
@Mysterx1440
@Mysterx1440 3 күн бұрын
English refs are a blight on the game
@Whoknows-zu2eb
@Whoknows-zu2eb 3 күн бұрын
He's Irish.
@deltazulu3650
@deltazulu3650 Күн бұрын
Every experienced rugby player can RE-referee a match with the aid of multiple angles, slow motion replays & all the rest & pin point numerous differences in the reading of decisions, fxxxxxg snore-bore! Such tedious antics are guaranteed to destroy our great game. On balance such drawn out small minded dragging over the coals of a match evidences roughly equal good fortune for both sides. Just play on gentlemen, this is rugby that we enjoy playing hard & fast without academic forensics of refereeing after the fact. Suggest people stop their bleating & whinging referee analytics.
@nicholasmlogan
@nicholasmlogan 3 күн бұрын
There WAS head contact but the SA player was such a sweetie and such a gorgeous gentleman he deserved a pat on the bum and some free movie tickets not a penalty.
@patrickthomas8101
@patrickthomas8101 3 күн бұрын
Why was this video made? most of the analytics are saying look at this correct call? First highlight was a knock backwards at no-point was knocked on forward. why that even shown? This is not even a bad game. this feels more like vid just to start drama. call yourselves journalists. Im South african too yet some your vids are just stupid and dont help the game anyway.
@tsaki_titan
@tsaki_titan 3 күн бұрын
Hes back!! Did "The black jersey" report you 200 times and you couldnt upload?😂😂🤦🏽‍♂️
@tasanalytics
@tasanalytics 3 күн бұрын
Well he probbably did do that😂, but no, just been very busy with work so it's hard to upload regularly. Trying to catch up on uploads now at the end of the year.
@tsaki_titan
@tsaki_titan 3 күн бұрын
@tasanalytics ohh I see I see, I swear everytime after each game that played since July, I kept saying, "TAS is going to have a field trip with this games analysis"😂😂😂 I'm starting to watch rugby games on a deeper level now
@stevedouglas3975
@stevedouglas3975 3 күн бұрын
That's it, look for every offence England did with a mircroscope. SA won so stop moaning. As for De Allende he should definitely go lower and that is yellow.
@millenniumgang7
@millenniumgang7 3 күн бұрын
Wow. He clearly looked at both.
@johanolwage213
@johanolwage213 3 күн бұрын
Kak ref.
@davidglew9979
@davidglew9979 3 күн бұрын
Hou are simply the most biased commentator. You whine about every call that goes against south africa, but believe they never commit a foul. Waste of time, please stop posting this one sided drivel
@Hard_Thinker
@Hard_Thinker 3 күн бұрын
No one makes you watch them!
@mikedellar5653
@mikedellar5653 3 күн бұрын
Well, Rassie. Maybe you should have take up refereeing, and left Jacques to do his thing?
@JohnErlebach
@JohnErlebach 3 күн бұрын
So after 27 penalties in the game, you want even more?
@Hard_Thinker
@Hard_Thinker 3 күн бұрын
You right, why have rules.
@bennash8887
@bennash8887 3 күн бұрын
Maybe we should just use robots to ref the game. Will you be the first one to put your hand up and do it?
@KiSsHaN100
@KiSsHaN100 3 күн бұрын
SA can do whatever they want for ages and now we complain about other doing it to them?
@Hard_Thinker
@Hard_Thinker 3 күн бұрын
Get help buddy, excessive animosity to Saffas. We’re just normal people at the end of the day 😂😂
@KiSsHaN100
@KiSsHaN100 2 күн бұрын
@@Hard_Thinker There is nothing more excessive than SA fans and everyone knows it, get out of Orania some time you might learn something from the world 😂
@ChazzyWS
@ChazzyWS 3 күн бұрын
You're worse than the TMO!
@chrisfield3161
@chrisfield3161 3 күн бұрын
Pretty low key stuff TBH. Nothing overally wrong or controversial. Personallly id love to see penalty advantage shortened. It's become ludicrous. A couple more rucks then blow if it hasn't gone forward. But playing on and on, and on, and on, and on......well....you get my drift.
@etiennegreyling6190
@etiennegreyling6190 3 күн бұрын
Dude I really think you should change the background music it sounds horrible. I really think it would help boost your channel
@petestewart9442
@petestewart9442 3 күн бұрын
I feel you are being way too overly critical with officiating. Why dont you be the official then if you are such a critic that grills the ref and TMO on every decision?
@eazyollie9370
@eazyollie9370 3 күн бұрын
You just cry about everything man
@jhb340
@jhb340 3 күн бұрын
Northern hemisphere teams have all the refs in their pocket and still can win shit😂
@PubgFadedYT
@PubgFadedYT 2 күн бұрын
Think you can do better get om the field and show us then 🥱🥱
Antoine Dupont’s 24 Hours In The NFL | LA Chargers
7:42
Los Angeles Chargers
Рет қаралды 357 М.
Yay😃 Let's make a Cute Handbag for me 👜 #diycrafts #shorts
00:33
LearnToon - Learn & Play
Рет қаралды 117 МЛН
БУ, ИСПУГАЛСЯ?? #shorts
00:22
Паша Осадчий
Рет қаралды 2,9 МЛН
I thought one thing and the truth is something else 😂
00:34
عائلة ابو رعد Abo Raad family
Рет қаралды 7 МЛН
"KARMA" | Revenge Moments in Rugby!
7:43
Andrew Forde
Рет қаралды 287 М.
Most RIDICULOUS Moments In Women Snooker..
9:38
SNOOKR
Рет қаралды 8 МЛН
10 Minutes of Nigel Owens being Nigel Owens | The Referee Grand Master
10:42
Netanyahu Sends FIERCE Message After ICC Issues Arrest Warrant
5:59
Aryeh Weinstein
Рет қаралды 483 М.
HOW GOOD WAS PELÉ?
18:28
Gustavo Marques
Рет қаралды 1,9 МЛН
Top 10 Fly Halves of All Time
14:51
Rugby Buzz
Рет қаралды 76 М.
South Africa: The Undisputed Kings of Rugby?
4:31
The Rugby Rundown
Рет қаралды 33 М.
WORLD RUGBY AWARDS | THE CLASS OF 2024
15:54
Eggchasers Rugby
Рет қаралды 70 М.
Yay😃 Let's make a Cute Handbag for me 👜 #diycrafts #shorts
00:33
LearnToon - Learn & Play
Рет қаралды 117 МЛН