Russian Naval Strategy, Capabilities, and Prospects

[@DelimitingMeasure]

Dude this is what should be produced by news channels, this is material that gives us perspectives worth holding

[@liammarra4003]

No, becuase Americans do t have the time, nor really care, to listen and understand any of this. That's why it's on youtube. So, think tanks, whether accurate or not, can be listened to by People that genuinely care to understand anything. Though, I'll agree, I wish it were on "mainstream" access and viewing platforms.

[@darthmercur3067]

This isn't News.....so no. Highly informative & accurate yes.

[@creatorofunexplainablemess8071]

@@darthmercur3067 not very high.. all of this info is easily accessible by anyone

[@darthmercur3067]

@@creatorofunexplainablemess8071dumbass

[@creatorofunexplainablemess8071]

@@darthmercur3067 Сам на себя посмотри..

[@vincenth3267]

This management structure is still working, but on just one spare leg!! Get another "assistant"/non Mankof and you could have a flexible and effective working team!!

[@Marc_Gagne]

I looked but could not find a transcript for this presentation. Is there one?

[@Blazingspitfire]

9:50 "GAS" turbine, not Steam. One word makes a lot of difference.

[@frederickmiles327]

USN shipbuilding and industry has always been built on large production runs and standardisation. The modernisation of the Worchester, Alaska was rejected in the 1950s as with only 2/3 the lack of standardisation and volume was impractical in US thinking. The same with the consideration of the mod 2/3 Juneau cruisers - Fram 1 on them was too radical a deviation. The same progressive loss of shipbuilding and advanced naval and naval nuclear propulsion has characterized the Royal Navy since the end of the cold war. During WW2 cruiser building or 1960s Leander frigate 26 produced RN 30/34 planned. It is not just Leander/ Leander broad beam subdivision, in fact each 2/3 ships in the line is some quite significant change, in sensors.

[@GoodBaleadaMusic]

Started at 27:45

[@BeKindToBirds]

You missed a lot then.

[@BillyBoggle]

Thanks for this great, free content.

[@jeffbansos8106]

thanks sir.. from this discussion, i got lot of information for source my school project! Tegaljugend ✋✋✋✋

[@sisyphusvasilias3943]

1:12:57 Russia does NOT want to displace USA. Russia rejects Unipolar Hegemony

[@BeKindToBirds]

That is a lie, they have always thought of themselves as the protectors of Slavs and liberators of Europe. They have just not been welcomed because even brutal US cops are better world police than even worse Russian police.

[@dvergar1]

38:25 regarding sustatined funding. Yeah, I think that ship has sailed (sorry for the pun).

[@vincenth3267]

Exactly M. Kofman!! You may extend many off your arguments to the Chinese Navy to!!

[@smetchaupeter516]

Talk about Obsession!!! The contents are good enough but I don't think the Russians give a damn about the Americans and discuss about them with such passions. The Americans are obsessed about Russians.

[@internetenjoyer1044]

nah Russia is very openly engaging in classic great power completion and is signalling very aggressively, Nato is just catching up

[@elozinoemeovrode9779]

@@internetenjoyer1044 where did you read that from

[@vincenth3267]

Ah, finally someone that understands what he is doing!!

[@listener523]

Who else googled "Triz" halfway through?

[@savagemurph]

I eventually had to skip ahead. I can't stand people who act like this when asking questions to a panel.

[@marcase2003]

Great presentation and discussion, enjoyed it. Thanks CSIS.

[@AlokKumar-ng3vc]

US is Obsessed with Russia 😁😁..

[@darthmercur3067]

Russia interfered in our elections, bought off traitor Trump and attacked and occupied our friend Ukraine. Sounds like Russia is obsessed with America 🤔😁😁

[@AntPictures]

Watching this in 2022 is funny to see how the biggest budget waster in the world US is calling out Russia for overspending on ships, as well as Russia's concerns for US challenging the arctic since "US is more energy independent than ever". Have panelists ever expected that US will be energy rationing in 2022?

[@frederickmiles327]

Look at the RNZN fully armed HMNZ Canterbury and HMZS Otago to Muroroa, 2 year old and 12 year old RN T12 a/s Frigates with Mk 6/4.5 Seacat and Mk 44/46 torpedoes and high RN trained and indoctrinated a/s of fficers some actually responsible for the Leander evolution and helicopter / Wasp intergration. The RNZN officers saw the explosion of the French nuclear triggers as puny, nothing from 20 miles. 1-7kiliton trigger explosions equivalent to Nuclear depth charges and Hiroshima

[@enriquelaroche5370]

Question seems pretty simple, Peace or death.

[@frederickmiles327]

Old men forget, and few modern politicians have ever seen, a modern warship. British PM David Cameron, the diluted descendant of 500 British aristocrats and half Pitts cabinet, scrapped the RN flagship, by executive order 2 weeks after his first visit to Ark Royal the first RN warship he had ever stepped aboard. Reliable sources say Cameron, Clegg and Osborne conducted UK foreign policy and defence policy on the quality of the hotels, bar service and the wining and dining in the local Hilton and Pullman. No serious naval officer would give a direct, accurate answer to the actual state, nuclear or conventional cabability of his ship. No serious officer or navy wants to give any indication ,before they run for real.

[@jeffb3354]

rebuilding their super star destroyer, I laughed way to hard at that one.

[@НиколайСидоров-е3ж]

all this is the imagination of experts, when real changes begin, everything that has been said here will turn into dust.

[@ducaleadan39]

I Have Gave You Some Explanation About My law And Order

[@ducaleadan39]

Did You Bad Thinks . To Understand You Need To Do Research All If Them You Will know Every thing Is Existing Before Most Of Them What You Use It

[@billwest8815]

Who uhhh is uhhhhh Jeffrey uhhhh manhoff uhhhh

[@TheFMBBCBM]

Família Deus pátria liberdade Bolsonaro o melhor presidente do Brasil e do mundo inteiro!

[@turdferguson4124]

There are 2 Slavas now.

[@ducaleadan39]

The Aim A Played This Was To Know Something Was Intended To Follow Every Person Because of I Didn't Said But God Said Who Have Created You Your Self , Mother And Father And All Human beings . . You Can Reject But Every Person Has Wise Or Idea To Follow What He Looks Possible . This What Humanbeing Are Different Religion Ir Idea Every One Believes His Is Right one But No Biigerthan One What God Said .

[@ducaleadan39]

Don't Give Anything Because of My Religion. I Know You Hate My Religion I M not Waiting You Any Thing . But Fact You Will Know Other Time . If You Right or Wrong . Because of No One Can Hide God. Hide Your Death. NO one Can Hide His Death . This is God Management like So Peaple Gave Law And Order. .

[@peter.competer8200]

Russian navy is the most powerful navy in Europe

[@frederickmiles327]

Not in the surface sphere, but say in the Asian, China Sea, over say Taiwan or a sea war, , what if Russian/Chinese SSN and Kilo Songs prove unstoppable against trade, warships and carrier. Escalation or convoy war. It might we'll be the US decision to decide whether to use tactical NDB against submarines or demonstration targets. I have always doubted whether SSNs can effectively or reliably be stopped without using nuclear weapons Given silencing lack of USN, RN numbers and the impossibility of stopping medium range attack by SSNs with standoff cruise high speed missiles or long range anti shipping torpedoes That has been my view since 1982-3

[@Ermengrabby]

No. The US Navy is the most powerful navy in Europe. As it is the strongest navy in the rest of the world. That’s how navies work.

[@TorianTammas]

NATO has the most powerful Navy in Europe.

[@Ermengrabby]

The US has the most powerful navy in Europe.

[@MwoJo]

@@Ermengrabby p

[@QuizmasterLaw]

", the Russian Navy has transformed itself into a modern force capable of conducting operations beyond its territorial waters and flying the Russian flag in any part of the world. " RU serious??? Uh they have a couple showcase frigates with long range cruise missiles. that's about it. Some loud SSBNs. Oh yeah and literal piston engined bombers. WOOSH

[@enriquelaroche5370]

Sarmat is all it takes.

[@QuizmasterLaw]

Tugboat tugboat lol o lol. You are risible.

[@Liam-ly8rv]

I think the main word is "transforming" not transformed. Yes they have a new strategy, modernizing older ships (America keeps Aircraft carriers in service for decades), building newer designed warships and submarines and introducing robotics and cyber warfare to the navy. Israel is a prime example of updating older equipment and being able to use it against those using the latest tanks and missiles. Russia is doing the same with its older ships. The biggest thing they needed wasn't the ships but updating the shipyards which France helped with during the now scrapped LHD contracts. Russia is working off a smaller more capable littoral warships. Russia Naval modernization sticks out a mile to even the less intelligent casual viewer. Their navy will never equal Americas. But that isn't the point anymore. It will take time just as the Soviet Navy did. But the Russian Navy will again be a blue water fleet. I personally feel they will scrap the carrier idea and invest in submarines which represent a greater threat to the US navy than surface ships. The attitude you show is typical of those who let preconceived ideas blind them. Because 10, 20 years move fast and all of a sudden you have a well trained, equipped Russian Navy capable of sealing of the Baltic and Black Sea. Supporting China in the Pacific and the ability to put out long range submarine patrols.

[@QuizmasterLaw]

lolsharik 垃圾的海军

[@frederickmiles327]

You only have to put an old cruiser with a crew of say 600-1200 in the port of ally or strategic or regional collaborator, say the movement of a Soviet Sverdlov into Alexandria, Egypt in 1973 June war and you have complicated the situation for the United States. enormously. During the June 1973 war the greatest threat to the US major ally since the WW2, Israel, Portugal was the only ally the only Nato ally who allowed the USAF aircraft to use it's airfields for the actual resupply of Israel with ammunition, parts and higher grade equipment

[@QuizmasterLaw]

well, at least their aircraft carrier no longer needs a tugboat...

[@jimmycao985]

Russia should get rid of it and build more ships instead.

[@listener523]

Well it still needs a land based airstrip......

[@oldbagira2192]

The aircraft carrier is the last century. Waste and expensive garbage. Russia has hypersonic cruise missiles capable of destroying any aircraft carrier group anywhere in the ocean.

[@liammarra4003]

@@oldbagira2192 I'm not entirely sure hypersonic missiles arent a bunch of hogwash. Russias missile capability abilities are already well enough. Unless Russia has been able to communicate with these hypersonic guided missiles while they're actively going hypersonic speeds. Then I'm not entirely sure russia, or any State, has capable hypersonic missiles, in adequate numbers, at this time. Maybe in the future, but guided hypersonics is a relatively old tech and concept and yet have eluded many States inventory for decades.

[@frederickmiles327]

The USN has got rid of it's Frigates and halved the number of SSNs, and the new Virginia SSNs are only an incremental improvement over the 1973 (LA SSN with an inadequate top speed 29.k). The Soviet Alfa, Akula, Sierra and Yassen are faster, silenced and offer far higher degrees of automation and have lower manning levels of higher quality in greater comfort. Progressively lower USN recruiting standards progressively lowered by Rob McNamara, only briefly reversed in the late cold war under Reagan/ Weinberg/ Lehman has resulted in ghetto std USN ratings and lower grade officers that have to be supplemented by Chiefs of origins politically unacceptable to commission as USN officers resulting in USN ABM destroyers and cruisers without adequate numbers of officers to competently navigate in major harbours and close shipping areas resulting in collisions with neutral tugboats which deactivated half the USN ABM seaborne force intended to protect Israel and Saudi Arabia

[@AN-it8dp]

Just embargo duct tape ! Their Black Sea fleet will fall apart in 5 weeks

[@wingsfan1450]

Such ignorance. Perhaps the US will teach the Pacific Fleet basic seamanship.

[@Ratimir101]

So you just came to post comment to show how stupid you are and obviously didn’t even listen lecture

[@darthmercur3067]

I thought the duct tape joke was funny. But seriously, we should add it to the sanctions.