Into the Pit BREAKS The Timeline!? | FNAF Theory

[@RyeToast]

Go to tryfum.com/RYETOAST or scan the QR code and use code RYETOAST to get your free FÜM Topper when you order your Journey Pack today.

[@emeraldqueen1994]

Looking forward to getting my SECOND that plush (I have the YouToos one) in the mail 🥰 they’re going to look great sitting next to each other!

[@kittythegamer2537]

Don’t sell me vapes

[@brandonm5159]

​@@kittythegamer2537It's not a vape. It's literally just sucking air over flavor-soaked fibers.

[@GuitarOfTime0116]

​@@brandonm5159thats still inhaling concentrated non-air. does it matter whether the irritants are vaporised or aerated?

[@jaydena6297]

​​@@GuitarOfTime0116did you listen to a single goddamn word that was said during that advertisement, or just go and check research yourself instead of being a f****** idiot who spouts random bullsh*t off on the internet.

[@courtney.p.s.]

I always laugh at myself as I’m 38, and got into FNAF because of my children. And here I am, watching FNAF videos because I’ve come to be too involved lol.

[@RyeToast]

That's so valid though lmao

[@basedmuscleman6539]

that is so fucking cute dude

[@pentagonyx]

okay but if my dad one day was like "Hey son, who do you think did the bite of 87" i would die

[@rejectfalseicons]

@@pentagonyx this is literally the type of conversations i have with my dad. he just quoted jerma at me today. Get your parents into your interests its funny my mother keeps naming her animals after fictional characters

[@cooperjordan1554]

God I wish my parents were awesome like that when I was kid

[@Dual-Process-Theory]

Literally every day I remember that Scraptrap is missing an arm and the Man in Room 1280 isnt - Connie

[@Viewtiful_J]

He had to pass those 30 years somehow...

[@majesty_viry]

hello lovely people

[@RFDN0]

Only option I can see to counter that would be that the body is Michael's. I don't agree with the idea because Andrew has massive issues for me.

[@KirbyFan-h9y]

@@RFDN0 they straight up call him William Afton in the epilogue so that’s not true Hell the only time Mike actually appears is in your the band

[@nou4410]

His heart beats in fnaf 6 He can re grown himself 👍

[@lostlordleafus]

Hi, I just wanted to make people aware: Do not buy füm products. They are essential oil inhalers. Essential oils should not be directly inhaled, ever, as they can cause irritation of the airways and a row of other stuff. Smoking isn't good, and i am not endorsing it. But switching to inhaling corrosive oils is not really a healthy alternative. If you're trying to quit smoking, get some nicotine gum, patches, spray, or something, but don't buy this, useless at best, product.

[@Gallarday]

I'll look up deeper into it, but I had my doubts from when I sad you tubers advertising it. Anything other than air inside your lungs tends to be bad, it sucks that now this is being advertised.

[@wakkaseta8351]

I hear a lot of people wean themselves off nicotine by eating cold turkey.

[@insidious_indigo]

@@wakkaseta8351that’s not true. It’s call quitting cold turkey lmaooo . It’s a common phrase they don’t actually eat it

[@gault6546]

@@insidious_indigowhat did cold turkey ever do to deserve being quitted 😭😭

[@xephyregaming7744]

@@insidious_indigo methinks it was a joke

[@serkeru2689]

8:05 No worries, we’ve been having this issue in transformers for a long time. Everything is canon, but each character may act slightly different depending on who is playing with the toys.

[@shadowmarauder6033]

Yeah, as a tf fan I concur this is the case, especially in the aligned continuity. Its name is very ironic once you try to piece it all together.

[@treebotreviews]

Haha!! You get it!!!!

[@ediblefredible]

this has ALWAYS been the case, not just with tf but literally any franchise! there's a million different interpretations of batman for example, but everyone just accepts and understands that different universes with the same characters can exist and coincide and borrow from each other while not being in the same timeline. idk why in the world this completely average thing has become such an enormous fight with everyone suddenly when it comes to fnaf, it's so unnecessary it's crazy

[@treebotreviews]

@@ediblefredible exactly.

[@jeremymorris345]

Frights being canon also means you have to explain Burntrap and how the Puppets mask got back to the Tangle. Not to mention, people say it's canon to Tales because of the Eleanor connection so, if one isn't in continuity, neither is the other. Unless you call the Eleanor thing an Easter Egg.

[@sakurafujimori]

Although I agree the puppet mask is contradictory, burntrap does not need to be explained if you just don believe burntrap is afton, after the recent content we've been getting, more and more evidence pile up that burntrap is not afton

[@FroststormFrenzy]

Eleanor never actually appears in Tales. A pendant that she used in Frights shows up, but the pendant appearing doesn't mean Eleanor is canon. The logic required to say Frailty confirms StitchlineGames would be the same as saying Ella confirms the Charlie Trilogy takes place in Stitchline, which would debunk StitchlineGames. Both use the presence of one object, which can exist under different circumstances in other continuities, to claim two book series share a continuity.

[@jeremymorris345]

@@FroststormFrenzy That's why I said it's probably just an Easter Egg until proven otherwise.

[@firewings9954]

The Puppet being there is not contradictory.

[@firewings9954]

@@FroststormFrenzy It's different because Frailty is literally a sequel to Eleanor's storyline from Frights. TalesGames is (let's be honest) basically confirmed, so StitchlineGames should also be nearly proven.

[@bobmasters9871]

I really need to commend you on your scripting abilities. There's so much information in this video, it's almost overwhelming, and yet you managed to keep the video under 30 minutes AND make it all make sense. Phenomenal job

[@RyeToast]

Thanks so much! That means a lot because that's one of my biggest questions going into videos like this. How much do you explain every little detail so its followable without getting too overly explainy

[@SluggishVee]

The serious talking followed by “Anyways… Five Nights at Freddy’s.” is a perfect encapsulation of how I’ve been coping this past week. 👍

[@maciejayne28]

Fnaf has been my go to for comfort watching over the years so definitely agree on this

[@bleedmagic88]

Haha yep same. At least we’re all in this together :’)

[@bartholemeowthefirst]

My genuine, authentic, thoughts: "I just want to be very clear about some recent events" Oh no, what happened? Did someone die? How did I miss that? "This community will always be a welcoming space for the left." Oh, that. Of course.

[@razzmicberry4793]

Casually blocking out the trauma 😂

[@bartholemeowthefirst]

@@razzmicberry4793 No, not really. I suppose the feeling is like forgetting your High School football team won and walking into the waffle house next to the school you won against that night to order a coffee, and the host offers their condolences.

[@lastchance848]

@@bartholemeowthefirst that's a great way to put it. i may have to use it >.>

[@Kelso_Belso]

OH, well at least im not confused now

[@commanderponds8308]

I really don’t think that segment was necessary. Wish we could keep politics out of fnaf of all things

[@Merione]

I think there's a fourth option that you didn't consider at the end. ITP (the game) is not exactly like the ITP (the story). It's an expanded remake, with its own quirks and peculiarities. That makes it entirely possible that one is in continuity and the other is not. Scott also mentioned in the most recent interview with Dawko that they're considering adapting Fetch as the next game after ITP. Key word: adapting. This would mean that the books give us a "blueprint" for where this story is headed, but not everything is exactly in continuity and they can always tweak stuff while making the games (which instead ARE in continuity). I guess we'll know more if and when the game about Fetch and the new interactive novel about ITP come out.

[@elishuster5943]

but it seems so purposeful to include Golden Freddy in the Fetch minigame that it has to be telling us something

[@TartiMaarti]

@@elishuster5943I think the implication is that things about the Fazbear Frights stories are being slightly changed with their game counterparts so they fit better into the games timeline. Like maybe the big difference is simply Andrew’s name is Cassidy in the games

[@elishuster5943]

​​@@TartiMaartiI had also thought about that and I think it's reasonable but that doesn't change how fetch and golden Freddy can be possessed at the same time. Maybe it's meant to show that Andrew is golden Freddy

[@fenrirslip]

@@TartiMaarti Idk if this theory still holds up, but I remember John (FuhNaff) released a theory about how there could be two spirits within the Golden Freddy suit and that it's sort of an in-game parallel to the Stitchwraith and that Andrew is the vengeful spirit and Cassidy is the equivalent to Jake and is the one able to see and control the suit and Andrew is just there unable to do anything.

[@sarahcatherine5497]

Agreed.

[@fazzoplugzz5891]

Not gay buh I love all my toasters 🐐

[@ryguystudios64]

@@fazzoplugzz5891 based as hell.

[@TheUnkGamer]

same bro

[@TheToasterLlama]

👍

[@CXSbunny]

Based

[@KirbyFan-h9y]

Imo: Scott is doing a reboot/retake of the frights books/ stitch line story to make it fit more in line with the games Into to pit game and a success is going to lead into a reboot of most of those stories. Since the next game is fetch we’re likely going to get a couple of mega cat games. So maybe Into the pit Fetch Step closer? Larson game (I guess) As for we’re into the pit takes place. I definitely believe it’s before Fnaf 3

[@WilliamAaronTheYapmaster]

Technically,the past sections are before FNAF 2.

[@anidiot192]

​@@WilliamAaronTheYapmasteractually, they might not considering you could just be traversing a memory of the MCI thanks to agony.

[@WilliamAaronTheYapmaster]

@@anidiot192 I personally don’t believe that but it is a possibility

[@anidiot192]

@@WilliamAaronTheYapmaster that's why I said they _might_ not be before FNAF 2 and that you _could_ just be traversing a memory.

[@WilliamAaronTheYapmaster]

@ Yes

[@DDDabber44]

Seeing people arguing in the comments about politics is really funny to me. Like, he literally said this is a safe space for communities that are repressed, and he said far right, not the entirety of the “right”. The reason I use quotations is because the political system in the States is VERY polarizing, in the eyes of many, if you support one side, you’re immediately against the other. Moral of the story, this is a theory channel, so talk about Fnaf, whether it’s constructive criticism or praise, just keep it civil. Also, please don’t start a war in the replies, I don’t want more unnecessary debates.

[@MegaGoaty3895]

You won’t get a war outta me. thanks for sayin this!!!

[@alexanderflores-MazterDestiny]

man, as someone that isnt even on the u.s. the left is literally the devil the one censoroing, the one trying to steal livelihood from people, the one denying HURRICANE HELP to people, the one bullshiting people that is saving other countries (bukele) the one who tried to kill the presidential candidate, the one who is saying that if you family voted the other way,; you should stop interacting with them, the one who cal the other nazis and that should be locked up, and also, the left has done so much shit around the world, every country that is left is going shit; honduras, france, the nordic countris, venezuela, cuba, brazil, nicaragua, great britain, spain.

[@grantdaily9662]

It's the "Hit Dogs Holler" Logic, if you feel the need to defend yourself from critique about a faction you claim not to be apart of, you might be apart of it

[@austinhite2684]

Yep exactly

[@TheDogeOfSarcasm]

Meanwhile I'm still trying to figure out what recent events hes talking about cause I live under a rock.

[@YalitoMelito]

I think I found something. The exact date of the carnival fire was a lunar eclipse, as hinted in HW2, which gives us a very close range of dates among 1970 and 1985, specially there was a TOTAL eclipse on FALL 1979 (SOTM year).

[@crimer_doppler]

Tbh, I've never bealived that the Frights were in continuity to any degree, but knowing that the Into the Pit game isn't really that close of a reteling, then I could bealive StitchlineGames if we're gonna get an actual Stitchline game series that retcons most of the inconsistencies

[@Tara-Sarabi]

And what if Cassidy and Andrew are BOTH making UCN? Andrew being inside William's body, he could literally help Cassidy, who's not, because he's inside Golden Freddy. Andrew could be the link.

[@truegamer7760]

Perhaps Andrew is OMC, sense Andrew states that he doesn't want to torture Afton forever.

[@Tara-Sarabi]

@@truegamer7760 Oh yes I thought about it too, while he has a gator mask.

[@vizzzyy190]

the only way i can think of having andrew be canon to the game timeline and be the vengeful spirit is if there were 6 kids killed in the MCI, but due to circumstances, one was never reported. since they never found any bodies, they had to rely on families and loved ones telling the news and others that their kids went missing. but if, say, one of the children was an orphan, no one would report them. meaning there is room for there to be another victim

[@elishuster5943]

but then if Andrew possesses Golden Freddy that leaves Cassidy with nothing? and if Cassidy possesses Golden Freddy then Andrew isn't possessing anything and I feel like it only makes sense for all of the MCI's to possess something

[@vizzzyy190]

@elishuster5943 i mean, im a firm believer in 2 spirits in golden freddy, so itd still work in that framework. imo, i think they wouldnt have introduced stitchwraith as a concept if it wasnt something to look out for in the game timeline

[@elishuster5943]

​@@vizzzyy190so then you don't think that Dave is in golden Freddy or do you think there's 3 spirits in there?

[@vizzzyy190]

@elishuster5943 tbh i think that dave and cassidy are in GF, and that andrew isnt in the game timeline at all. if he is in the game timeline, then honestly, i think that shattered dave is most likely, but that starts to get really complicated 😅

[@MusiciansRule07]

Living Well is the Best Revenge. Not succumbing to despair and continuing to live as our authentic selves hurts them more than anything else. Common Rye W and I'm glad to be part of your community! As for the FNAF timeline, I'm going with The Multiverse Idea turned Cliche and calling it a day. It's like when Star Trek rebooted back in 2009 and introduced us to the Alternate Original Series. It's a variation on a theme and I like all of them. Occam's Razor.

[@aaronenglish2330]

Just so long as you avoid being brain damaged from the potential threat of forced medication if forced institutionalization returns, be safe.

[@spark.stream]

Calling it revenge doesn’t feel right, it makes it feel like it’s a fight, something you have to win. Violence only causes more violence so please act how you want to act because it’s only the real way to act but don’t hurt or bully or be mean to them back because that doesn’t make you any better than they are.

[@commanderponds8308]

Idk man maybe keep your politics out of the silly bear video

[@catdownthestreet]

​@@commanderponds8308 It's not political at all... Literally what is political about saying "you're safe here" to a group that is anxious about the future right now

[@RainyCarnival]

@@catdownthestreet It’s political because the “recent events” are the elections

[@WitheredCircle]

Oh boy, seeing FrightsFiction in the video chapters has me convinced this one's going to be a doozy. I'll edit this with my thoughts when I'm done!

[@bendrowned8506]

dang you been watching this for five hours?

[@Personian]

hey man didn't realize this video would take six hours to finish

[@WitheredCircle]

@@Personian sorry that I have other stuff to do

[@Crisjola]

“Because someone would have mentioned that.” Man, I hope they would. Just ‘hey, isn’t that Fredbear?!’ would have been great comedic timing, I think.

[@Parallelvision.tv.official]

The cat is probably insanely traumatized from how much fnaf he has to put up with ❤

[@shacharlem4424]

It's stated in the early synopsis of the "tales of the pizzaplex" books that the stories are set in the world of the "newest games." The "Fazbear frights" and interactive novels are what I believe is "some are, some don't, I'm sure you can figure it out" while the original novel series trilogy was "those specific events didn't happen in the games but we have clues for you to decipher the games".

[@Vezdekhon]

but what if Cassidy AND Andrew are in GF, and they BOTH do UCN? I doubt it, and there's probably tons of evidence against it, but what if?

[@kays4290]

If Afton's agony can control multiple things, then why couldn't Jakes? All that would be needed is for his blood to touch the object correct? So I don't think the fetch mini-games is a disqualifier. He could posses both simultaneously.

[@truegamer7760]

I think the final epilogue shows that Jake may be able to, sense he can force the stitchwraith animatronic despite it being in critical condition.

[@Spencycle]

The Stitchwraith touching his master and instantly killing him reminds me of Edward Scissorhands. Also, I wouldn't know how to feel if it turns out we live in a world where Sea Bonnies and Faz-goo are real things that exist within the continuity of the Fnaf games.

[@sebay4654]

I personally currently believe in Semi/Psudeo Stitchline games, which is basically stichline games but with the assumption that the version detailed in the books takes place in the book universe entirely with some characters having different names then in the games timeline (basically Andrew is the vengeful spirit in the books timeline whilst Cassidy is the vengeful spirit in the games timeline)

[@darktrapv.1384]

Game timeline there secret victim keep William alive Scott created the man in room 1280 to know vengeful spirit ucn is not Cassidy Cassidy there yes we see Cassidy left

[@stick7962]

Yknow Consider: the reason golden freddy appears in the Fetch minigame is because it’s not about the Fetch story. It’s set in the 1985 JEFFS PIZZA, compare the maps. This is not a retelling of anything, thats why we are getting a Fetch standalone game. Andrew is never meant to be GF, nor is GF meant to be behind UCN

[@WilliamAaronTheYapmaster]

I actually thought it fit in pretty well,few years after fnaf 6 and then in 1985. As for how the dead bodies of MCI kids show up when the MCI were killed separately? Ghosts. The ghosts are making an image of their own bodies to try to tell people what happened. Personally,I took it as “these events/characters exist in the games but they aren’t 1 to 1. Millie was killed by Funtime Freddy but she was a victim of Rentals,not a Funtime Freddy found in a dump that was fixed up by her Grandfather”. I think the sixth kid is the puppet kid from HW2,the final death. Also,the interactive novels definitely feel like they belong in universe. The vibes are right in a way the other 3 book series just aren’t to me,personally. And,trust me,I’d love TFTPP to be in continuity because it would just provide me more evidence against Mimic being Glitchtrap or Burntrap but I doubt it is

[@thomasfan8889]

You know, having listen again to all the vengeful spirit lines in UCN, I actually think there is more than one spirit we attribute those lines to. We already know that Charlie and OMC seem to be able to enter UCN, so it’s not out of the realm of possibility. Specifically, Fred Bear’s spirit voice seems to have a very different vocal direction than the Mediocre Melodies additional voice, even if they’re the same voice actress. Now, the question is: is that GF’s spirit or CC? If happiest day is about CC, that wouldn’t make sense. Maybe Cassidy and Andrew do both coexist somehow

[@PartTimesPlums]

1:01 Thank you Rye truly, I love you videos it's been quite rough these past days and your videos had always been the highlight for me

[@TWEAKINFINGRZ]

Why is everyone saying its been rough

[@emoclowngirl]

@@TWEAKINFINGRZour rights are majorly in jeopardy. if u can’t see how scary that is u need to educate yourself.

[@rohamcsigusz]

​@@TWEAKINFINGRZthe new government (republicans and trump as president) have promised in the past multiple times that they will do project 2025. The document is.... Well, it is hostile to anyone not already swimming in big oil money.

[@avo.avocado]

@@emoclowngirlDont be so rude bro

[@TWEAKINFINGRZ]

@ or maybe you need to take a chill pill

[@Freshbutter57]

Am I the only one who dislikes the books being canon to the games? The survival Logbook and The week Before both are fine.But, Tales and Firghts?

[@Cladhat]

Yeah it’s so wacky and kinda doesn’t make sense

[@chlorisc6078]

They're actually canon 😭this is gonna be weird

[@__darsoyea5149]

Just got out of bed and was greeted to this video, today will be a good day!

[@RyeToast]

Morning lol

[@deathbow555]

How i see it: The books either range from canon to the games (the week before specificaly is very canon), semi canon to the games or a different continuity. Its almost like a multiverse. There are infinite ways that William becomes Springtrap. Theres versions of Charlie that isn't The Puppet, ect.

[@anvilmania]

great video! i agree with this completely. honestly, my biggest hangup with this game existing with the current games' continuity is the layout of jeff's pizza. the layout of the building is the exact same both in 1985 and present day, and neither are like the FNAF 1 location (this is assuming that FNAF 1 is a reopened MCI Freddy's location, as it has the safe room with Spring Bonnie). TWB does tell us the building has gone through remodels and many rooms are closed off, but FNAF 1 takes place between the MCI and ITPG. it would make no sense for the building to be like it is in 1985 ITP, remodeled to freddy's in FNAF 1, and then back to its original layout in ITP jeff's pizza. you can't even look at the jeff's pizza map and fit the FNAF 1 map in there in any sense, whether it's a smaller or bigger version of the full layout seen in 1985. (not to mention that fnaf 1 doesn't have a ballbit anywhere, but i can at least look past that). this is such a clear inconsistency and i never see anyone bring it up; i don't know how this game can be in continuity with the mainline fnaf games this way.

[@kotobuki4168]

I still can't not burst out laughing at the moments from into the pit when the words "see you" are portrayed as C U. I'm Brazilian and in portuguese these letters together in that order mean butthole as the body part. It's soo funny to me that only Portuguese and spanish speaking people will find that hilarious and unintended detail. Ksksskk

[@DJBurns-jq8mn]

Into The Pit can work with supporting Stitchline games, this is because of the theory that the Frights and Tales books are in game books in the FNAF Universe. This theory is based off of what Scott and the autors said about the canonisity of the books. They said they were stories "directly connected" and the Tales books were said to take place within the Game Universe. What if this is literal. Think about it, HW tells us the original games were games in the FNAF universe to cover up the past so whats stopping Fazbear Entertainment from making books poking fun at the stories. There are freaking arcade machines with Frights characters on them for crying out loud. But obviously, just like the original games, they are more or less real events in the FNAF Universe. So I feel the basic understanding is that if Stitchline is confirmed by Into the Pit then the relevant Frights stories (the Stitchwraith Stingers and all relevent stories) need to be explained and i think i got it. *Into the Pit* has no evidence for being after FNAF 6 nor does some of the other Frights stories (not all, just some as stories like *Man in Room 1280* must take place after FNAF 6. Sure it's implied but the stories that are basically the origin of Stritchwraith itself ( like *Fetch* and *The Real Jake* for example) have no concrete set date to happen. Theres nothing stopping some of the stories to take place long before the Stitchwraith. Ones like Out of Stock, *1:35 A.M.* and *Step closer* obviously all happen after Stitchwraith as we know they collected the pieces of the animatronics and stuff. But the stuff like Eleanor creating the Plushtrap chaser (which we know that it existed for a while since people repeatedly kept sending it back to the store) and terrorising people in *1:35 am* , *Step Closer* , *Blackbird* and *Hide-and-Seek* don't need to be around the same time as Stitchwraith. I'm just saying there can be time jumps in between stories. Like: *Room for one more* obviously takes place before Sister Location which has SnackSpace from *Into the Pit* mentioned in it *Prankster* has Glitchtrap in it so its after Help Wanted was in development. *What We Found* is basically a retelling of FNAF 3 *Room 1280* says William has been there for a long while after FNAF 6, all these are years apart from eachother so stories can happen at any point in the canon. So *Into the Pit* ,*Fetch* , *The Real Jake* and all the stories where Eleanor was involved with creating things like *To Be Beautiful* can happen years before FNAF 6. Eleanor and the Stitchwraith can do there own thing for a long while from when they are created And then the stories like *Room 1280* and everything we know the Stitchwraith is connected with can happen after FNAF 6. If Into the Pit is indeed canon to the games then it can make sense when you consider there is a gap in time between the stories. This explains how and why we see *Fetch* , *To Be Beautiful* and *Count the Ways* can be in the game, because they happen before Oswald goes in the pit. *Here's addressing some possible contradictions:* The Easter eggs are not canon as the developers said and the Stitchwraith can appear in Oswald's window because they do exist at that time. I know you guys will say no because Andrew went into Fetch after William exploded in the factory but his spirit was split across many things when that happened and nothing really says Andrew was in Fetch during *Fetch* and could easily of latched to Fetch as it would of had agony from being beaten up like what happened to the Mimic. Fetch can just be a faulty product, it may be a lame answer but not everything can be great (Fazgoo and Springtrap pregnancy anyone). Eleanor is still a mystery but if she is indeed and agony creature created after either Elizabeth’s death, the agony collected from the kids William experiments with in his bunker (my personal belief) or just is Shadow Freddy like people have theorised before, nothing is stopping her from existing for a long time until we see her in the Stitchwraith stingers. What do you all think?

[@SoulsSix1985]

In defense of the Fetch minigame: I believe it's likely that Andrew's body is, indeed, stuffed inside of Golden Freddy, but his spirit is able to roam, exactly like we see in Follow Me. This is probably caused by Give Gifts Give Life, since the Puppet doesn't give Golden Freddy a spirit; he sorta just... possesses it on his own, but isn't trapped? I also don't think we play as the kid from Fetch in that minigame. The events and character design don't match up at all. Therefore, I believe it's possible that we play as some poor victim that broke in before the events of the story, Fetch, take place. So if Andrew is in Golden Freddy and is the One You Should Not Have Killed, then boom! We have our answer. But then we're back to square one with Cassidy, because that sixth victim has gotta be SOMEWHERE, right? Those are my thoughts on the matter.

[@v1ct0rygames32]

gonna throw out an idea: the OMC cutscene in UCN shows Golden Freddy talking to OMC. he tells him to "leave the demon to his demons" and he complies. he drowns in the lake, freeing whatever spirit is inside (likely Cassidy). whether Andrew is TOYSNHK or just Frights' stand-in doesn't matter because we can still use him as framework for TOYSNHK's motivation. TOYSNHK - if given that choice by OMC - wouldn't comply, unlike what the soul inside Golden Freddy does

[@TheWizardMus]

You're missing some context of the original OMC quote it's "Come and Sit With Me a While, leave the Demon to his demons" choosing to drown in the lake isn't sitting with OMC, it's refusing to leave the Demon to his Demons

[@firewings9954]

@@TheWizardMus Drowning in the lake leads to Happiest Day. This is confirmed in FNaF World. Drowning in UCN does rest your own soul and leave the demon to his demons.

[@TheWizardMus]

@firewings9954 The Clock Ending(the one that leads to Happiest Day) and the Drowning Ending are two completely different ending in FNaF World

[@firewings9954]

@@TheWizardMus An interpretation of the Clock Ending is that we're setting up the minigames for the person to play them in FNaF 3. It does not lead to Happiest Day, stop spreading misinformation.

[@firewings9954]

@@TheWizardMus The Drowning Ending leads to an image titled 'Happiest Day'.

[@dredgengam4610]

Have fun on Bluesky... I will NOT be touching that cess pit.

[@ThaliaXIII]

It is sad to see Rye shit talking on socials about fans who ask him to not bring up politics. I dont care who voted for what hate just grows more hate and its sad to see.

[@fanof5950]

There's a 4th option. Into the pit (the game) is cannon to the games, but the book (and other stichwraith stories) are being used as references. Like how remnant/agony is first mentioned in the silver eyes, then used throughout the freights books.

[@Hidhsnakdkci]

It could just be that the stitchline book stories aren’t in continuity, but but the into the pit game, potential upcoming fetch game, and return to the pit all tell similar stories with changes made to keep them in continuity

[@cjaawesome616]

7:41 I love how you say that you are going to mixe up the words and then right after you mix up the words lol

[@tyruku18]

For the answer of mine in the beginning of this video: I have no qualms as long no one tries to forcibly change my ideology or shame on it with having slightly different ones.

[@catdownthestreet]

Yup! Glad to have you here, fellow FNAF fan

[@AliceInWyrmland]

there should be shame when voting for things that will unequivocally harm others

[@RainyCarnival]

⁠​⁠@@AliceInWyrmland Funny how this sentence is believed by both extremes of the spectrum…

[@AliceInWyrmland]

@@RainyCarnival fair

[@cliffeside0730]

Rye, you have the perfect tone and speed of speaking to keep me focused on the video without needing to 2x speed it, thank you very much 🫡

[@kingwuxavyx1631]

I keep trying to look up your channel and for some reason, haven't the slightest clue, it just keeps showing me bread

[@andrewcogdillcole3826]

I didn't know that Andrew wore an alligator mask. Maybe Monty Gator is the mimic programs way of copying the vengeful spirit?

[@firewings9954]

Well Monty and Andrew both hate a rabbit.

[@noodrasan]

Don't forget we find DJ music man in the ballpit and "they thought i was you" since Jeff turns purple when he dies in the bad end

[@according_response1799]

one bit of evidence in favor of evidence in favor of stitchlinegames that i didn't see mentioned was Frailty from TFTPP, and how it implies that (If TFTPP is in the games continuity like you suggest), Eleanor must be in the games due to the main character of Frailty being in possession of a heart pendant made of remnant (shown when she uses shavings from it to heal patients), and suffers the same fate as Sarah from To Be Beautiful

[@bentoncozzi612]

I'm 100% in the camp of ITP being in the books timeline, separate from the games, and if we get more Fazbear Frights games, they'll follow suit with zero connection to the specific story of Michael, William (although he's consistent across almost all of em), Jeremy, Vanessa, Cassie, and surely more.

[@elliemo22_2]

W rye toast 0:41

[@RoxasisVentus]

I’m just saying but I got banned from his discord server for asking for sources on the claims being made and that’s all I wanted a source for where they found the information that they were saying and wanted to look into it myself to form my own opinion but apparently I got banned for asking for a source

[@IrishGamerJG]

​@RoxasisVentus yeah people don't like it when you fact check them cause when you do they are always wrong

[@JinxeBlaq]

@@RoxasisVentus​​⁠​​⁠Yea, they’ve said before on a stream that they’re very far left, very much dislike right leaning people, and don’t care if they form echo chambers around their opinions, so I’m not surprised ya got banned for asking too many questions in their personal discord group. Like I love them as a creator, but I gotta say I disagree with how they go about discussing politics. I do understand that being on the left is a large part of their life though. I’m mainly centrist with a left lean, so I can’t blame them too much. I just stay for the theories and the charm lol

[@austinhite2684]

@@RoxasisVentus what sources are you pretending you can’t find?

[@regulargoat7259]

@@IrishGamerJG the right wing constantly refuses to provide sources and often shows outdated or straight up incorrect info. Don't throw stones when you're living in a glass house. Also, it is very common for the right wing to simply ignore any sources given and ask questions in bad faith so i dont blame them for deciding it's not their job to educate you on something political

[@0celot8]

Have you listened to CHROMAKOPIA? Its a really good album. Kinda random but im really loving it rn and wondering if anyone else in this community listens to that type of music.

[@PansathePanda]

I know this is gonna be a good video when i see a cat

[@GendoRokabundi]

I think the answer might end up as GoldenDuo, but it’s Andrew and Cassidy. Andrew being a 6th MCI victim, the ‘missing’ missing child does fit with the little we know about him. He doesn’t remember being loved. To go missing but no one reports it? That’s an unloved child. Perhaps he was homeless, a runaway, etc. Regardless, his death is never associated with the MCI. Andrew’s anger could partially be his being forgotten. It explains why It’s Me is relevant. He’s the forgotten child screaming out for anyone to acknowledge him. It’s possible he was the first of the MCI, killed with Golden Freddy via a springlock failure. Maybe he had broken in to find a warm place to sleep for the night and Afton caught him. He might have been able to dump the body without getting caught. It might have inspired William to further MCI murders, just by allowing him to discover that he enjoyed it, even when it isn’t personal (if Charlie died earlier). He could also be the ‘last’ MCI victim. If he was trapped in the test chambers, like Rory, perhaps having been kidnapped around the same time as or before the MCI, he might have been down there for years. When William next had a chance to interact with the animatronics (FNaF2 presumably) he might have springlocked Andrew then. Or if William was never the one tied to the crimes, he could have springlocked Andrew during the period between the MCI and the closure. This does require the pit being agony/remnant memories and therefore conflating different story elements. It already does with depicting the MCI all occurring in a single day and being discovered immediately. I think that both Andrew and William at different points in time, end up understanding the power of Agony. What we see of Golden Freddy in the week before, and the first game, he is perhaps influencing the rest of the gang, trying to get them to stuff guards into his suit to collect more agony, to be powerful enough to stop William. After FNAF3, Springtrap might have sought out the Golden Freddy suit as a source of extra agony he could add to himself. That explains some of Scraptrap’s design changes and gives Andrew the opportunity to jump in with William. If whatever process was used for creating remnant to be injected into the funtimes, it’s possible that he basically separated the remnant from the agony. We know fire can destroy remnant, but we don’t really know if the same is true for agony. If the FNAF6 fire destroyed all remnant, leaving only agony we have: ScrapBaby’s remaining agony becoming Elanor, William (and Andrew’s) remaining agony becoming the Man in room 1802, the agony of the MCI becomes the tangle, and the agony of Charlotte (if any existed) perhaps being what all those nightmarrionnes are about. Even Henry and Micheal’s agony could have echoes in the pizzaplex. (More Micheal, you might have had agony from his first death, but Henry and Mike walked into their ends willingly in FNAF6, so perhaps created no new agony. It’s also possible that any agony that would have been in Micheal was taken by Ennard when it left.) As for the Fetch minigame, Golden Freddy being there could have multiple explanations. 1. Andrew is shattered so he can be in multiple places at once. 2. GoldenDuo, so it’s actually Cassidy keeping an eye on Andrew 3. It’s Andrew’s consciousness being represented by Golden Freddy, showing he’s inside Fetch. The actual animatronic is likely not actually there, Golden Freddy appears in other Frights stories. But not fetch. So if it’s not a physical suit, it’s a manifestation. And Golden Freddy is able to manifest. So possibility 4 is Andrew’s spirit within Fetch trying to manifest as Golden Freddy, but being so weak as to only be able to observe, nothing more.

[@ethbeatthem4836]

I think it’s somewhere in the middle between FrightsFiction and Stitchlinegames. That Fazbear have alter the story and add unnecessary details but they are base on events. They just aren’t one to one version of the events due to Fazbear meddling, and game versions might be more closer (even if they are still not 100%) versions of the real story. It just sharing this get written off as it most people see it as me going one side or the other and that side clearly wrong and you don’t know FNAF. (Edit this is because as good as Stitchlinegames is there are just some things that contradict the other games and having Fazbear change the story to seem like all the Stitchline stuff was fictional hiding the truth by changing and adding thing that doesn’t make sense work, also explain why the other stories are there to make everything seem fictional)

[@ethbeatthem4836]

Oh yay about Andrew, I can explain but it’s complicated and as seen by my other ideas, wouldn’t be taken lightly by other theorists. All I have to say is Andrew shares similarities to another character, too many.

[@KeithMack-y7d]

Happy Thanksgiving to Ryetoast family hope the spooky season was filled with more treats than tricks love the videos keep up with all the great work

[@TheStrangestLad]

3:56 Isn't that a second springlocking? I swear he already has springlock scars in the first book.

[@TheWizardMus]

Yes but there really isn't a first springlocking that we know of in the games timeline. As far as we know Afton only got got once by a bunch of meddling ghost kids. Then he got got a lot of times but that's not really what we're discussing atm

[@aoife2386]

0:57 AH RYETOAST QUOTING MY FAV MCELROY OUT OF NOWHERE? insane clashing of content-worlds for me

[@holdingontohope23]

Whoa hold up!! I dunno what happened previously (considering political views) but as someone who’s a right supporter,I respectfully agree to disagree. And I don’t hate anyone that thinks differently,believe and love whoever you want. As long as you don’t hate on my beliefs,I’m cool with you. I’m so sorry over these previous events. I love FNAF and I’ve loved it since my early 20’s. And everyone else who also loves FNAF,I think you’re awesome.

[@catdownthestreet]

Hey there! Just letting you know that you're not who he was talking about at all. You're not using your political leanings to be mean to anyone here, so you're not the far right he's excluding. Also, hi, you're awesome too! FNAF is for everyone, and I'm always happy to hang out with fellow fans.

[@capuzdepenix210]

Yeah, in my humble opinion, I agree that Into the Pit is a standalone game. I know this is more of a meta analysis of the stories and not actual evidence, but I really doubt the character of Eleanor would be canon to the games. She really feels more of a paralel to Circus Baby than something that could exist on itself, and I really doubt two Babys would exist in the same universe.

[@0127sasuke]

I feel like into the pit the game can still be canon without including all of frights/stitchline. The minigames can just be easter eggs. Well have to wait for return to the pit and the possible fetch game before deciding anything though. Cuz these could still contradict either the main timeline OR the book events ALSO. There is one fix to this if we dip our toes in dual process theory. "Cassidy" could be CC/"Dave" and golden freddys place in UCN could simply be a reminder of Afton's greatest mistake/failure. Freeing up the vengeful spirit to be Andrew instead of Cassidy or Mike. BUT that might not line up that well.

[@dumbly-stupid]

Could be that Cassidy is kinda like a in-between of Charlie and Andrew she's also vengeful but she wants Afton dead while Andrew wants him to suffer and she's also caring to CC like Charlie cares for the MCI.

[@frankieslittlediary]

i think it is another thing entirely, which is that elements of the books do exist within the games continuity, but not exactly as they appear in the text. like Silver Eyes, they give us an alternate understanding of something Scott wants us to look for within the games

[@Syndicate_LS]

Okay so first thing first: thank you for clarifying canon bs continuity. I see it so often and it muddies things so much more, so I’m glad you addressed this head on. Second: plz don’t support that company ;-;

[@8onnie8oyz]

What's wrong with this one? Whenever they get a sponsorship, the comments always seem to have some backlash.

[@Syndicate_LS]

@ it’s bc while it’s not directly a vape it directly encourages such in the end.

[@diminie_chimket]

​@@Syndicate_LS Vaping isn't bad lol it's better than smoking cigarettes and getting lung cancer 😂😂

[@Syndicate_LS]

@@diminie_chimket well no duh it’s better than smoking. Doesn’t make it good?

[@Cosmic_KW]

I love your Fnaf lord videos, especially when it comes figuring out more about the characters and also the lore

[@Unknownplayer31305]

Am I really not welcome in this community My political beliefs lean mostly to the right. I am not racist, homophobic, xenophobic, sexist, or any of the things people say the right are. Say what you want, I am confident in the person I am and believe political beliefs shouldn't be the be all end all on whether or not someone is accepted into a community, especially when it comes to video games/books.

[@fatdinosaurfood8059]

This is a safe space for everyone. As long as you aren’t outright rude or discriminatory, you good

[@WhenLUX_Does_Covers_and_More]

Your political beliefs are a continuation of your morals They're really not just opinion. They can harm everyone in the nation, or help everyone

[@commanderponds8308]

Yeah it was so strange to put that in a video about fnaf of all things. I’d rather not hear about someone’s politics in my silly bear community. Besides let’s not forget who tried to cancel Scott just for supporting republicans

[@catdownthestreet]

You ARE welcome here. The problem only comes when right-leaning people decide they don't like being in the same community as POC, LGBTQ+ people, or left-leaning people. You aren't doing anything wrong just by being right-leaning. But I do have to ask whether or not you actually listened to that segment. He was only talking about bigots on the far right who hate certain groups and make a lot of people feel unsafe and unwelcome here. You aren't one of them just because you're right-leaning. Also, why is saying that hatred of those groups is unwelcome here "political?" It's not political at all to state that this is a community for everyone to just be themselves and talk about FNAF. Anyways. I hope you have a lovely day. We're all tired here, it's best not to argue about politics in this safe space.

[@catdownthestreet]

​@@commanderponds8308 yeah that was pretty ridiculous wasn't it

[@codydocile8120]

Scott literally said (at least with silver eyes trilogy) that the books are a separate canon that we are suppose draw parallels from to solve the games

[@GJames-Legend101]

Things I think. 1. I have this thought perhaps the books themselves aren’t canon to the games but Scott is taking certain Ideas and Concepts from the books and Altering them enough so that they can fit in the games (much like how the memory drawing idea from the Fourth Closet was put in the Movie). 2. Maybe Scott could change stories and ideas in the books so that they can fit in the Games and be Canon. 3. I’m a personal big fan of the Fazbear Frights books and I would love for them to be Canon to the Games but their something that I feel stops that from being possible, in the The Man in Room 1280 the story seems to take place after the fnaf 6 fire but the thing to remember is that during that William as Scraptrap was missing his left arm and I’m pretty sure the William in the books had both his arms. 4. I think the Interactive Novels are gonna be the Books that could possibly connect both Fazbear Frights and Tales From The Pizzaplex being Canon. 5. Perhaps only Certain Fazbear Frights Stories along with thr Stitchline Epilogues are only Canon to the Games, meanwhile the other stories are just kinda like filler. 6. I think Into the Pit game could possibly be a in Universe game due to the 2D artstyle made by Fazbear Entertainment as a way to discredit the rumors of the company 7. What if the Silver Eyes trilogy is canon to the games, but not in the way you think, what if Fazbear Entertainment made them actual in universe books about Charlotte and Henry as a way to make people believe they weren’t actually real people but just book characters.

[@dumbly-stupid]

Wit Afton having 2 arms it's possible that it's either remnant healing like how he healed his skin back in FNAF 6 (those aren't bone ears) or it's just a inconsistentcy from the writer which happens a lot in these books like Edwin's age and Ralph never taking his daughter to Freddy's

[@bgcustoms3124]

Bro we just watched a 26 minute video to get zero answers and 20 more questions 😂😂😂

[@UltimateGamerX-bo4ih]

Can the fnaf timeline be saved?

[@RyeToast]

I think so!

[@bff4l09]

The sound of.metal clashing for the fight of Eleanor and Jake is everything 😂

[@RogerMollet]

I think all the world ending and noncanon stories are frightsfiction and that stitchlinegames theory is right.

[@karliekrossover3928]

I do have a question, I’m sorry if it is kinda dumb. Have we gotten any other proof or heard the name Cassidy somewhere else? I’m curious because in other things we’ve gotten confirmation about names like Susie and Jeremy, like Rye said in this video. However, we could consider that the name Cassidy isn’t completely cannon. What do I mean with this? I mean, If Michael Afton used fake names through the game series why wouldn’t the victims do the same? I know it’s weird but let’s consider 2 things: 1 we know for a fact that if someone or yourself doesn’t discover your body you’d be wandering around with figments of your memory, some things could be twisted and some completely forgotten. Maybe the spirit within golden Freddy just has present the name Cassidy (or it could apply to also Andrew) and therefore believes that’s their name. 2 And least weird, maybe the spirit didn’t fully trust Michael and presented themselves with a fake alias so Michael could have a way to refer to them. I know this isn’t a great theory, my bad really, but I think it could be something to consider as well. After all, if we think about this perspective, Micheal’s POV is the most prominent, and there’s a chance that he doesn’t know the real names of the victims so any name would be enough for him to believe. And the names that we can consider cannon are known by other people but Michael, like the phone guy for example.

[@karliekrossover3928]

Also, I’ve been thinking. Are we all sure that Andrew’s body is in Golden’s Freddy suit? We learnt that if anyone finds the body of a wandering ghost, the ghost recovers their memories. A guy did find that body, but Andrew seemed so lost and confused and forgetful. Are we sure that is actually his body?”

[@Thuselessone]

0:37 god, I know I’m going to be hated for this but no! Not all republicans hate people of color, lgbtqia+ people, or anybody! My family doesn’t! I live in a very conservative town and I don’t know anybody who’s racist or sexist or homophobic! I know I’m not making a clear point with just speaking off my personal experience, and yes there are some horrible people out there, but THEY ARE NOT THE MAJORITY! I don’t want them part of the Republican Party either! Nobody does! Being a republican or a conservative doesn’t mean you have to be a bigot, it just means you want less government control, (not no government control) and to conserve the country’s resources! (Hence why some of us are considered “conservatives”) no I do not think the KKK should come back. Nor do I believe lgbtqia+ people should die. In fact, I’m friends with many! (Which I get, yeah it’s not the best argument but I thought it was still relevant) but the rhetoric being spread that all republicans are racist, sexist, homophobic monsters is slander. I’m a person too! Don’t you think I get hurt every time someone calls me something I’m not? Don’t you think I feel pushed down every time I’m called something horrible just because I believe differently than you? I know it’s different for so many people, and my anecdotal evidence wouldn’t hold up in a court of law, but not all republicans want to destroy diversity or pride. Donald trump does not want to destroy diversity or pride. Please, next time you want to call someone horrible just for being a republican without knowing anything about them, just remember that they are people. They have feelings, too! After all, you wouldn’t want me to call you a baby murderer just because you support abortion, would you?

[@iopdev]

Im fine being called a baby murderer cause I know it doesn't apply to me. Hit dogs holler, he said far right, not republicans in general. If you feel offended, even if he wasn't talking about you, reflect on why that is.

[@catdownthestreet]

I agree with you, but nothing about his statement said that all Republicans are far right. He was talking about the people on the far right who would rather take away someone's right to exist freely than accept that someone is different from them. Not you. Your statement makes sense, but it isn't applicable here. You're welcome here too, no one is excluding you unless you exclude others. All the best.

[@Thuselessone]

@@catdownthestreet I know he wasn’t mentioning specifically towards me, but I still wanted to give my two cents because I believe this is a large problem, and I haven’t been able to express this sentiment anywhere else. I know it probably wasn’t the wisest to say everything, but I just wanted to go on a rant about it. Sorry!

[@AliceInWyrmland]

not all rebublicans want to harm the lgbtq, but its the rebublican politicions doing all the anti-lgbtq policies. By voting for Trump you are saying you want less govenrment control and are fine with people dying to get it.

[@williamrogers2981]

I love fnaf. I dont think politics belong in it regardless of which side you lean. Im here for FNAF.

[@catdownthestreet]

What's so political about stating that the RyeToast channel is a safe space for people who are stressed right now?

[@seanflores4718]

@@catdownthestreetwell why are they stressed? It’s likely due to recent political events. Not too difficult to figure that out

[@seanflores4718]

Amen, I’m never the biggest fan of creators sharing their political opinion because the majority of their audiences never watch them for it

[@williamrogers2981]

@catdownthestreet he specifically says a safe space for "The left" that's pretty political. I don't think anyone was questioning if this was a safe space, and it feels really forced.

[@oskarbergkvist980]

0:42 You guys are such babies.

[@LionPKrono]

Fetch, Ralpho (from Bunny Call) and Ella appear in arcades of SB, which indicate that they are canon in the timeline of the games (rather FrightsFiction, StitchlineGames or FrightsGames). Another thing to add, Andrew's agony could've end up in the suit, as his spirit attatched to William, maybe, as one of the multiple agony alteration stuff that the ball pit does (agony rat and the paper pals) maybe Andrew's agony ended up in Golden Freddy, I don't think that Andrew replaces Cassidy, but rather that things go something more like- - William kills Cassidy and Andrew - Andrew's corpse is left in the ball pit and Cassidy is stuffed in Golden Freddy - Andrew's soul attatches to Wiliam and Cassidy possesses Golden Freddy - Andrew's agony makes the ball pit do weird stuff and create Eleanor How is Andrew connected to GF? I'm really not so sure, but of what I'm sure is that he is somehow, maybe he was stuffed in the suit, yet he didn't possess the it unlike Cassidy and blah blah blah, to make it worse, other outside stuff connect TOYSHNK to Plushbear (yes, that doll of CC), indicating that TOYSHNK isn't anyone but someone on the doll, which uhh, would indicate that it's rather some sort of Agony or just BV, which is heavely unlikely and practically debunked. Maybe Andrew is connected to Plushbear because of the Nightmare Chambers? IDK it's really confusing, but what is for sure, TOYSHNK being GF is just the tip of the icebearg of what TOYSHNK is, and I'm not sure how it all ties up, it's deffinitively not cassidy, cassidy is a girl and TOYSHNK is a boy, but it's somehow connected to GF and Plushbear?

[@p.b.and.jay13]

Happy to know you're a safe space 😁 please be safe as well, Rye!

[@EvilParagon4]

I was a fan when Scott released the first book, and I still go off what he said back then. The books are not canon, but they are their own continuity and can inform us about the games. So that makes the books low tier canon. They are canon until the games override them, if the games do not touch on something that the books do, for instance, Agony, then Agony is canon to the games universe too. So there is a fourth option to your problem at the end. 4. StitchlineGames is true, but Andrew is not related to UCN or Golden Freddy, he is a book character that the games have overridden.

[@OctopusOdditySango]

Thanks Rye, I needed to hear the beginning

[@MegaGoaty3895]

🩷💙🤍

[@mimicball-q6u]

as soon as you told me to love myself, it made my day! you and matpat are wonderful people

[@TylerG797]

I like your content but not when you bring controversies into it. It’s literally not that deep.

[@catdownthestreet]

What's controversial about saying that his channel is a safe space for people who need it right now? There's literally nothing wrong with saying "you're free to be yourself without judgement here." It's not even a political statement, just recognition that some people in his audience are really anxious right now. Reassurance is a nice thing to have in times like these.

[@seanflores4718]

@@catdownthestreetit’s not that deep

[@karliekrossover3928]

This might sound random but I kinda wish Return to the pit also has Jeff’s POV. Because I think that no matter if you see it from the game or the novel, Jeff has to deal with the leftover body of a yellow bunny XD

[@Daisy-mb8kt]

Guys….as a person in the right, a good 98% of us don’t hate you or wish bad upon you. I just feel it needs to be said as often as we’re made out to be the enemy in so many of the fandoms we partake in for political standings. I’ve never met another person on the right that holds a “we hate them and hope they suffer” mentality. Many times it’s the opposite where we just hope we can all find common ground as people politics aside.

[@WhenLUX_Does_Covers_and_More]

The thing is you cannot really say that while actively the right introduces bills that hurt children, the queer community, make inconsistent medical guidelines, and more Yes you yourself may not think you hate the minorities, but if you vote for someone who does/will harm minorities that's a reflection on your morals

[@commanderponds8308]

Yeah it seemed really unnecessary to me. Like just keep your politics out of fnaf of all things

[@diminie_chimket]

​@@commanderponds8308 sorry, but considering what Scott experienced because he dared to have his Christian values....no it is necessary. If you don't like it...just ignore it

[@commanderponds8308]

@@diminie_chimket what are you trying to argue?

[@Daisy-mb8kt]

@@WhenLUX_Does_Covers_and_More the only thing most of us advocate for is for children not to undergo transgender surgery. We don’t really care what you do when you’re an adult the choice is yours, but minors should wait until they are 18 or older

[@Maniacbob]

Is it possible that Into the Pit the game could be canon but Into the Pit the short story isn't canon. The two are similar but not the exact same. I cant remember if it was Rye or ID's Fantasy that was making the case that the change in depiction of the past and the interaction between them changed the nature of the events, time travel vs hallucinations/agony visions. It seems to me that if they're so different that the fundamental events may be completely different then it changes the canonicity of the two things. Maybe I missed Rye discussing that in the video, I did zone out for a bit.

[@thebonyboi]

I love you Rye and your content, but as a person who leans right in politics, I find it very bold and disrespectful to say that every person on the right hates certain groups on the left. I myself have nothing but love for all those people. I do not hate you or anybody in the LGBTQ+ community.

[@rannynihilius8481]

Not assuming anything about who you voted (if you even live in the US or voted at all if so) but i think this remark from Rye about the right goes out to everyone who has voted for Trump, who is actively trying to take LGBT and women rights away. So i really hope you didn't vote for Trump or any other right leaning faction in another country that is actively going after people like this when you say that you don't hate them because actions speak louder than words. I'm bisexual and my country's right wing opposition party wants to ban homosexual marriage and i'd say that i wouldn't want anyone who voted for that party to be considered as a friend, ally or just anything humane at that point when i'm also just getting dehumanized by those policies someone like that would have voted for.

[@Hayloskien]

You're going to get a lot of that boney, just let them vent. You have the same middle road, love everyone thoughts that most of us do. The more you try to defend yourself, the deeper you sink. Unfortunately, no side has been entirely right in a long time and those of us caught in the middle get chewed up, so we might as well do what sounds better at the time and let it go. Because we'll be the bad guys regardless.

[@chlorisc6078]

yeah

[@chlorisc6078]

@@Hayloskien 100% agree

[@commanderponds8308]

@@rannynihilius8481Trump isn’t gonna do that buddy

[@AYoshiVader]

Yipee, more evidence for what I argue so now I shall say it. Here are the facts we do know: 1: TOYSNHK is the one who creates UCN 2: A spirit possessing Golden Freddy is the one who creates UCN (from UCN itself) 3: Cassidy possesses Golden Freddy (process of elimination + Survival Guide) 4: Fetch is one of the objects affected by Agony in The Man in Room 1280 So, the theory I want to discuss is Cassidy=TOYSNHK, what evidence is there against it? A: TOYSNHK uses male pronouns while Cassidy is implied to be a girl (could be using the animatronic pronouns for some reason, there is a work around). B: Andrew=TOYSNHK being possibly true. This one noticably is just a "Mutual Exclusivity" where if the other one is proven true this one is automatically proven false. So now it all depends on whether Andrew is TOYSNHK or not, and that relies on StitchlineGames, and here you showed that there are only 2 possibilities for StitchlineGames to be true: 1: Yes, and Andrew made UCN, but Golden Freddy was not involved. This contradicts fact 2 and also begs the question of where Andrew is through out any of the previous games. 2: Yes, and Andrew possessed both Golden Freddy and Fetch at the same time. This contradicts fact 4, as The Man in Room 1280 happens after PizzaSim and UCN, at which point Golden Freddy is no more. And that's ignoring other issues from StitchlineGames, mainly: 1. Funtime Freddy has no Bonbon 2. William has both arms in The Man in Room 1280 when Scraptrap only has one. 3. Eleanor. (Why does she look like CB yet is so different at the same time) This one is more of something that annoys me but it's fine. And more importantly for me, it renders Cassidy irrelevant, TOYSNHK position is already filled by Cassidy in the games, Andrew=TOYSNHK just takes it all over with another character who literally appears from nowhere, not only that it implies both Afton and Charlie, the two main targets of the Pizzeria Simulator Fire, stayed in their animatronics/corpses after it, which renders the fire obsolete and that's just not good. I do want to bring up the 6 victims. As far as I can tell, the games (excluding Into the Pit) never specify all 6 children went missing at once, and so when the 6 missing children are involved (notably in Help Wanted 2 where the death order is brought up), Charlie is the 6th missing child, allowing for one of the crucial pillars of StitchlineGames, Andrew being an MCI victim, to not be true. In conclusion, StitchlineGames cannot be true, meaning Andrew=TOYSNHK, unless given a way to be true without Stichline (which is literaly bringing a character out of nowhere to fill a gap that can already be filled by another character) can also not be true, and therefore Cassidy=TOYSNHK is the only available option. I rest my case, good luck theorists.

[@goofyah99]

0:28 w bluesky, also w video dude

[@RyeToast]

Thank you!

[@goofyah99]

@RyeToast yw man

[@_KaiTheGamer_]

Best side-effect of Twitter dying is FNaF Twitter's vitriol slowly VANISHING hahahahahaha Now I can engage in FNaF fandom on social media in peace without seeing annoying hot takes and explosive emotional "arguments" about pizza bear.

[@RollandGamess]

Bro, i really respect you going for the bag, but füm isn't it

[@luisv.7428]

Could do without that beginning segment either. Here for the theories not whos side you're on

[@MxMothra]

@@luisv.7428he literally just said that he loves and respects people. Why is does that bug you?

[@8onnie8oyz]

​@@luisv.7428Try commenting this on the main comment section.

[@originality6345]

Well, tbf, it was a bit much to say everyone on the right hate you for living as yourself when voting for the left guarantees the continuation of the genocide in Palestine.

[@Alkeeros]

​@@luisv.7428if someone says "let's be welcoming" and someone says "he's declaring sides!" It sounds like one of the sides might not be welcoming. That's an odd thing to admit out loud

[@Moleoflands]

I feel like the only way the game is 'Cannon' is this is a second MCI, but because of Oswald the killings don't actually happen

[@jeremyhodgkins7005]

Do you welcome right leaning people to your channel too? Not extremists, but normal people on the right.

[@catdownthestreet]

I'd assume that's the case! You're not trying to bully people so you're definitely safe here, too :D

[@m0002856]

I think the point of the message is that the channel is being explicitly stated to be a safe space for people who might be marginalized, but that doesn't mean it's an attack on anybody else specifically. I think the point is that there's no room for hatred here.

[@pained.anomaly]

Hey Rye, just a quick tip on getting Oswald out of BG images quick: Have him stand on either side of the screen, take SS, then do the same on the other side. Crop half of each of the photos out, the side where Oswald is visible, and stitch the remaining two halves. Funnily enough, you don't need anything more advanced than Paint 3D to this lmao I only really wrote this because seeing Oswald in the BG while other things are being displayed on screen, it's hard to ignore his presence. idk if its my ADHD or what, but when I see him on-screen, it's hard not to visualize him in the setting with the other characters there. :')

[@spudkin564]

I just want to say, as a straight, white, Christian male, that your message at the beginning of the video was really heartwarming. I've been devastated to see how much damage people that share my demographic are doing to completely innocent and marginalized people. It brings me happiness to see you guys banding together in solidarity instead of giving into their hateful words and actions. And you did it in a way that didn't make me feel like I was unwelcome. Class act, friend, and keep looking out for the little guy. I support you all too

[@kingZombait2]

FNAF is so crazy. Fazgoo, Ligma, illusion discs, Agony, Mimic, there’s too much to keep track of.

[@HappyAxolotl24]

0:20 wait what happened

[@AlriikRidesAgain]

Trump won. And Cawthon has historically supported Trump.

[@devilishsnuggy9697]

Not gonna act like I'm 100% certain but probably the US election

[@mushroom_gal490]

Yup, Presidency, Senate, and House all went Republican. It's gonna be a doozy

[@arthurmartin4616]

Possibly election related considering who the owner of "twitter" sided with

[@Viewtiful_J]

A lot of people are leaving X for BlueSky since X has let up a lot on moderation/discrimination rules. So it's becoming the 4chan of social media sites

[@derpius3]

15:36 loving the gigantamax garbador with the springtrap face on it

[@Gront517]

The 18th rule of time travel is that it always breaks the timeline in one way or another.

[@leftygurl]

personally i think the simplest answer to this problem is that fright, the into the pit game, and the primary game timeline are all separate. fewer steps to rationalize, fewer caveats and asterisks, it just feels like the cleanest answer to me.

[@Sk-wc3mx]

Not to get political but you’re welcoming to everyone except half of the US population, ah yes, very inclusive of you, i love the feeling of getting excluded and hated bc of my beliefs 👍

[@megav1022]

good

[@WhenLUX_Does_Covers_and_More]

Ever heard of the tolerance paradox (i think that's the name correct me if I'm wrong) Essentially you cannot be tolerate to intolerant people because it leads to them harming others. It's the same thing here

[@Sk-wc3mx]

@ I have friends who hate my beliefs and we get along just fine, one of them is my best friend. It hurts when the ppl I love watching outwardly bash what I believe and for why? To make me and others with my viewpoints feel like shit? I’ve put up with it for so long and I’m honestly tired, can we just agree to disagree and not hate each other?

[@WhenLUX_Does_Covers_and_More]

@Sk-wc3mx Yes, you should feel bad if you're harming people... if you aren't, then you wouldn't, but hit dogs will holler There's a difference between disagreeing on a favorite food and voting against someone's right to have full control over their body.

[@megav1022]

@@Sk-wc3mx i think we got past the "why cant we all get along" phase like 4 years ago. I really dont get how you can expect people of the opposite side to "just get along" with you when the side your on is one that built itself on hate, lies and fearmongering. Im sorry but uou reap what you sow ig

[@neko1538]

The music in the background sent me reeling. I could practically see the sonic adventure 2 knuckles gameplay