S&W 4046 vs S&W SD40VE vs Glock 23 - the battle of the 40 S&W

[@BuckeyeBallistics]

I love the looks of the 4046

[@crankygunreviews]

It’s sweet. I need more of these old Smith Semi Auto’s. I want a 659 or something similar. I have the 469 and it’s a beaut too

[@JG-xt9io]

I have 2 of the three guns you ran , always liked the third generation smith's autos. My sister picked up some blazer aluminum, but she didn't want to shoot it , so I traded her brass ammo . The aluminum ran fine in my SD40VE and my glock 23 and was the most clean ammo I have shot, not sure why . Cool slow motion shots

[@crankygunreviews]

The smiths are so well built- I have a 469 as well, want a stainless 9mm too- 5906 I think?

[@Bob.W.]

Thanks. Good enough by my reckoning. I think I'll go to the range every football Sunday - good idea.

[@crankygunreviews]

Better than watching football lol

[@nebaldeby5369]

Did you mean the SW 4046 is double action only? Beautiful guns by the way

[@crankygunreviews]

I guess I don’t know how to describe it… not really double action only because it does not cock the hammer when you pull the trigger. You have to have the hammer half cocked to make it fire- so it’s a 1 1/2 action? Or maybe 1/2 action?

[@nebaldeby5369]

@@crankygunreviews Interesting. I just looked it up it has a double action trigger pull but no second-strike capability. if it does not fire you have to cycle the slide to fire the gun instead of just pulling the trigger. Your gun reminds me of the SW 5946-which was authorized when I worked some years ago and was very popular with the troops. The 5946 was true double action only and it had the second strike capability. Heavy guns but they are built like tanks. Nice gun you have 👍

[@crankygunreviews]

@@nebaldeby5369 yeah the 4046 is weird. No safety, no de-cocker, and not a real double action. Long trigger pull but smooth

[@davidkoeppen3121]

In your video the g23 failed to lock back twice on the final round and had another failure to feed or eject based on your notation. Why did you comment on its extreme reliability at the end of the video? “It’s so reliable it’s boring”. The only gun in this review with no “hang ups” or magazine issues was the sd 40ve. IN THIS TEST the VE was the most reliable wouldn’t you agree?

[@crankygunreviews]

The failure to lock back was the mags fault, I have a lot of off-brand mags. The gun itself is reliable. The failure to extract did happen on another occasion, and it could be light loads, it could be that I put a new recoil spring in it- it’s not perfect but it’s pretty reliable.

[@crankygunreviews]

@@davidkoeppen3121 in this test the SD40VE probably did win. And I can shoot it better

[@frankbrowning328]

We are probably 2 of the very few people that don't watch sports but watch these types of videos. I always loved playing sports just not waching them. I like 40's I still have 2 of them 1) Glock 23 and 1) Glock 27. I had 4 until a couple years ago. So in this battle I'd pick the G23

[@crankygunreviews]

The G23 is pretty good, and I hate sports now. Never really cared, but did watch for several years with my brother- he moved and I lost interest

[@frankbrowning328]

@@crankygunreviews Ive got a 9mm barrel for both the G23 and the G27. Ive been ,eaning to get 357 Sig barrel for both and a 22LR conversion kit. I get it. Some things are tolerable when you're with a friend or relative but hold 0 interest if they arent there

[@crankygunreviews]

I’ve heard the 357 sig is really good, but I didn’t really want to get another caliber…

[@frankbrowning328]

@@crankygunreviews It's an incredible cartridge but I do understand the thought of yet another cartridge in the mix. It seems I am always running low on ammo yet I have thousands of rounds. The problem is I own so many calibers. In pistols alone I have ammo in 22LR, 25ACP, 32 ACP, 32 S&W, 32 S&W Long, 327 Mag, 380 ACP, 38 Special, 9mm, 357 MAg, 44 Special, 44 Mag and 45 ACP. Then its on the rifle calibers.... I bought a barrel for my Dad in 357 SIg for his Glock. I wish I'd bought one for mine too but then again there'sd be even more ammo to keep in stock

[@crankygunreviews]

@@frankbrowning328 yeah I hear you on all that. I keep saying no more new calibers, then I find something else I want lol. Just with .380, 9mm, 40 S&W, and 45ACP in my semi auto carry selection, I don’t know that I need 357 sig…

[@FlyDre-g9h]

I have the smith sd40ve it’s very reliable.

[@crankygunreviews]

Mine is reliable as well

[@gabrieldesta2113]

From the looks of this i would say your Glock 23 has a lot of recoil due to its light weight i might be buying a sd40ve i have an Sd9ve. Ever tried firing 40 out of a 10mm they say it works and some say it doesnt ive seen somebody shoot 380 out of 9mm but it tumbled out funny

[@crankygunreviews]

The SD40VE has a lot of recoil too. The Glock has a smaller grip so it’s a little harder to hold than the SD40VE

[@gabrieldesta2113]

@@crankygunreviews a grip sleeve would help with that recoil they sell them on Amazon and wish for 5 bucks that's what I did for my sd9ve a grip sleeve

[@crankygunreviews]

@@gabrieldesta2113 I hate grip sleeves. SD40VE has a longer grip that’s why I shoot it better

[@D-A-1776]

Glock 23 all day but the 4046 is nice to love those guns, just not a fan of sa only

[@crankygunreviews]

I’m not a fan of SA only either, but dang this trigger is smoooooth.

[@bikegunexpert6010]

You’re comparing budget semis to a Glock ..those smiths are trash

[@crankygunreviews]

🤣🤣 trash he says. That’s a good one. Keep thinking that.

[@GLOCKCOPG23]

@@crankygunreviews”Bikegunexpert6010” simply does not know what he’s talking about. S&W third generation autos can cycle EMPTY BRASS from the mag…try that with almost anything else if you like being disappointed. They are some of the most reliable autos out there. They are over built and will last several lifetimes. Smith stopped making them because the manufacturing cost was too high. They were basically making custom fit sidearms but charging a competitive price which they could not sustain. They are GREAT sidearms! I have quite a few and they are simply top tier in construction, fit, and reliability.

[@crankygunreviews]

@@GLOCKCOPG23 I’m aware- I picked up another one recently

[@GLOCKCOPG23]

@@crankygunreviews They are worth their weight in gold brother.

[@crankygunreviews]

@@GLOCKCOPG23 I wish- these weigh like 2 pounds

[@scott7684]

winner?glock 22 full size m f e r s

[@crankygunreviews]

@@scott7684 I now have one of those so I prob need to revisit this. Though I did an M&P40 Vs Glock 23 recently