SA Jobs Emergency | Discussion | 'Don't blame foreigners' - Numsa

Numsa says foreigners must not be blamed. Spokesperson, Phakamile Hlubi-Majola explains. #eNCA Courtesy #DStv403

[@zwelithininxumalo9232]

Why should ordinary south African be the one's going after the government if we have unions who allow the corruption and did nothing to prevent the the job losses

[@more2much696]

they actually cause job losses

[@mduduzindlovu5196]

I think the gvt is to blame, they are corrupt, the issue of privatizing SOEs is also a big issue coz it means the employees get retrenched, private businesses don't have an obligation to fingt unemployment but theirs is to make profit. Borrowing money from IMF (71billion) in six months To fund their lifestyle and political party structures is just ridiculous. How will they pay it back?

[@mduduzindlovu5196]

@@Sky-dv8mj I think most businesses are largely owned by foreigners, however, the problem is the type of foreigner, people have issues with poor foreigners but will hide their tales when it comes to rich ones who control the government, as for me I am really not concerned about the location of poor foreigners. But I would like you to focus even on the processes of running a business, right now blacks can't imagine running successful businesses, all that we can think of is graduating and getting employed, that will go on forever unless people realise that the gvt isn't doing anything for blacks. The same rich people before apartheid are richer today. Why? Because the status quo supports them. Look at the criteria of tenders, forget about the corruption going on, the fact is no black man can apply and get the tender unless some regulations are eased. Some will want you to have millions to fund the project then u get paid after a certain section is done, that means even if you are skilled, already thousands of blacks are cut out.

[@more2much696]

@@mduduzindlovu5196 we want a foreigner that hires South africans

[@rainbowtrust6347]

@@more2much696 exactly what I've been saying all these years. Whenever union poke its nose into worker's business, they don't address it the way it should. They'll insist on increasing to their own interest than helping employees and employers, until it gets to the point where retrenchment is the final decision. Unions are also a problem in this economy.

[@natalieruss599]

I THINK I'M BLESSED BECAUSE IF NOT I WOULDN'T HAVE MET SOMEONE WHO IS AS SPECTACULAR AS EXPERT AVA LIO I THINK SHE IS THE BEST BROKER EVERYONE SHOULD BE PROUD OFF

[@mavelldenis307]

Yes I'm also a living testimony of expert mrs ava.

[@mavelldenis307]

Crypto currency and NFTs will outsmart the banking system in the nearest future serving as a global fiat. Already making over 85% money online with her.

[@kevinbrian9332]

@@mavelldenis307 Often times we just look for what to invest in and usually encounter this problem it's either the money is too huge for he/she have to invest or it could required more than expected. Cheers!!

[@Vivian-vp9ft]

@@kevinbrian9332 People are scared of investing because of the high rate of scammers.

[@marann1065]

@@Vivian-vp9ft I'm from Indiana i have been an investor with ava in cryptocurrency for over 4years now.

[@TheZuluman7]

Brilliantly and explicitly explained Nomsa .This is exactly what i have been saying all along ,South Africans are projecting their anger at the wrong people .

[@jimmycaleni4642]

The botswana government fight for its people by saying local first lately now Nigerian government told the foreigners that own business in Nigeria to live the Nigeria even Ghana said Ghanaian first only in South Africa that allows this nonsense is because of your stupidity

[@codingtutorials1047]

You can't think. Don't look at just direct foreigner-employment relationship. That's being narrow minded. My brother slept on the floor in a hospital because all beds were occupied by mostly foreigners. My tax could help them, but not my brother. That's rubbish. You your brains.

[@JuxtaposeZA]

I'm sure here's more than 10% foreigners in SA. 4% is BS!

[@beautylolowya1059]

@@JuxtaposeZA she is really blatantly liying.

[@tafadzwakasere7742]

Wonderful brother

[@ayandambatha3591]

No one is blaming foreigners for unemployment, what people are saying that with unemployment so high every job especially low skilled jobs should be prioritized for South Africans. Every one was up in arms when the government got Cuban engineers. South Africans can't even sell tomatoes 'cause there's hundreds of Zimbabweans already filled up the streets. Zimbabwe announced last year that informal sectors will only be reserved for Zimbabweans but in SA it's supposed to be a free for all. We can't tell poor South Africans to make their Government responsible when you not telling the foreigners to hold their own Governments to accountability instead of crossing the borders.

[@IamBarati]

That's true but they as usual want to play stupid and act like they'd don't see the problem

[@truegospel1607]

I wish i could give you hundred likes

[@mduduziMavundla7242]

@@truegospel1607 Amen to that

[@King_Imani]

Yea talk about the 4% when 46% of the population is unemployed... Quality of education amongst POC and the demography of wealth holders are the real causes of job insecurity in SA

[@chrismakmak9571]

Stop talking lies everybody use to say foreigners are stealing ur jobs now u r refusing 😂,y u r denying this truth kant? Kkkk aibo yekan manga webantu

[@kingsleycobbinah-gyapong796]

Great and brilliant answers 👏. I spoke to lady yesterday at Amazon prime helpline to help me fix problem at the USA and to my amazing that lady was a South African living in USA with a brilliant job position. After assisting me, I asked her where she come from and she said from South Africa, Durban. South Africans are equally occupying big jobs positions outside South Africa so let us leave our foreigners to do their jobs. Moreover most these jobs are created by the foreigners themselves.

[@codingtutorials1047]

1. Legal south Africans occupy good jobs in countries that have stable economies that can support their own citizens first. 2. Literally anyone anywhere in the world can work for Amazon from the comfort of their own home if they have internet, I know a few people.

[@alicegauteng2358]

This a different issue all together. I am South African living in Canada. I am a social worker at a department of social services. Yes its a good position. The difference is that I came to Canada LEGALLY and I also don't get involved in illegal activities. I can't say the same about foreign nationals in South Africa

[@normantshokotshela5290]

@@alicegauteng2358 I fully agree with you, different topic all together. Legal vs illegal.

[@victoriadhlamini1516]

I believe that South African is legal in USA.

[@victoriadhlamini1516]

ANC is sitting there because of you people you vote for them they didn't put themselves.

[@gedb5451]

All facts, props to her. It's about time we stop the self hate, and tackle the source of the problem.

[@2dbp2dbp91]

All facts ? Really ?

[@williamngozo3299]

True

[@dikeledijane8186]

When people start saying self hate just know that he/she is a foreigner

[@gedb5451]

@@dikeledijane8186 when people lack arguments, know they're foreigners, right?

[@tmanman6785]

@@dikeledijane8186 100%

[@mrsoshadabaadman]

Blame za ANC who couldn't sort out the problems of the locals. But invited the whole world to come struggle with us.

[@samuellegodi2754]

She just made my day. She just admitted that NUMSA has failed to play a role to put South Africans first.🤠

[@headhonchotheone9041]

She's a clown 🤡

[@Mrdjwhoknows]

NUMSA has become useless, they were actually the last ones left after NUM and the other sellouts.

[@wandiledlamini2591]

@@headhonchotheone9041 facts

[@edmorehamandawana3430]

This lady is brilliant, this is how I have been expressing my arguments around this issue . I like "you cant go harass a lady selling sweets at Bara hoping to create jobs in such an action" . It makes me extremely sad to see the poor fighting the poor with one accusing the other of causing their poverty.

[@luciasdiaries4596]

True

[@masedil8990]

We know all of u illegals will say she's brilliant

[@doremi131]

@@masedil8990 My point exactly. Because the likes of Phakamile started by emforcing that other people can block jobs in their own provinces and go and occupy more jobs in other provinces and the locals of thar province have no jobs. North West yone ba e telletse hampe ebile.

[@doremi131]

@@luciasdiaries4596 So you are saying that someone gets A WORK PERMIT to come and sell sweets at a school gate in a foreign land?

[@chileshemulenga8790]

@@doremi131 the husband gets a permit or perm res and selling those sweets can be side hustling.some are selling yoni, inuka, avbob products.if you are a law abiding citizen you have the right to ask for her papers to show that she is legally hear. Those illegal immigrants must kindly go back to their countries of origin and apply relevant permits. Underline ILLEGAL because when one has a perm res or work permit and visit you country of origin you given days to visit and if you overstay you become an illegal immigrant, let us differentiate some facts and laws

[@evanselsonnene5106]

Thank you for your strong message on why I we blaming foreign nationals that are the one making South Africa lead to unemployment, Our government need to correct this before this escalate to Xenophobia against foreign nationals

[@Tafadzwa_Mugabe]

One love ❤ let's join together and feel alright 👍 xenophobia won't bring food in yo house keep your head up

[@marthakagumbate5538]

Ichokwadi

[@jeremiahmasole3170]

This is how unions are a problem: they advocate for overtime and that overtime is a time that could be used for another person to put something on the table so unions are also contributing to state capture and low employment in this country

[@rainbowtrust6347]

Unions have been no 1 destroyers of this country. They must just shut up. They are fat with workers money and put them out of employment

[@simphiwerini9652]

Unions have been ighting black factions... Dudula has embarrased all politicians ... cought them with their pants down. The only way citizenz get heard is to be an active citizen outside political formations... fees must fall had no political authority or flag... why is she angry when didula is driven ny ordinary citizens... that the solution. Lets remove our votes from organisations that are obsessed with old ideas n factional battles they are the ones in the tripatite... MUMSA is actually a beneficiary of tripatite over the years n did fokol but still sing socialism.. This president they are fighting comes from them. Numsa has big investments.

[@88motho]

Yes ,They are Correct. Don't blame this poor Foreigners for SA Problem , ANC can't create Jobs let alone PROVIDE Services. I am a Black South African who left South Africa 20years ago to go abroad to look for work because there was Nothing in South Africa, this was in 2001, look how long that is and the problem is still there, can't go away, Now l am working very hard to Bring my Sisters abroad as well, after they study and still can't get Jobs in SouthAfrica. The same route l was in 20years ago in SA , of struggling to get a work after Studying, my Sisters are in it as well. As long as ANC govern, forget about Employment, SA people especially the Youth, You have 2 choices, Leave the Country to go find Proper Job somewhere or go vote for someone else when Election comes to create Jobs and save future Generations from the same headache of Unemployment in SA. Foreigners are not the Problem, You're taking your anger to the wrong people. Our Opposition are also a Big Problem, l wonder who owns this Parties . PITY INDEED.

[@dollainbreunissen2978]

Well said and its the truth.

[@Sky-dv8mj]

Foreigners are big problem here, come to Cape Town where Zimbabweans and Somalians are invading the land as Malema gave them the rights. They are owning shacks in these invaded lands Go to Bellville taxi rank it's Zimbabweans and Somalians, same in Cape Town Taxi Rank. All the places we were respecting as citizens they are in. We were chased by law enforcement officers but Foreigners foreigners are there occupying everywhere. In towns the fire to braai anything was not allowed but today our towns turned to something else. Take example outside the Malls all over it's them. Go to restaurants in Seapoint, Camps bay, Water front and Century City it's only Zimbabweans. More especially Debonairs, starting from their cashier to the motorcycle courier guys. Debonairs is 100% employing Zimbabweans, we need to boycott that company as black South Africans. We are the ones supporting them more than any race

[@preciousisiguzo2052]

I left too ngeke and I never worry about job since I moved to Scandinavia I am also planning to bring my family members and my child

[@dollainbreunissen2978]

@@preciousisiguzo2052 good for you. What are chances of finding employment there and age restriction?

[@lesleymakunde4755]

@@Sky-dv8mjlook at it this way. Zimbabweans or Somalians do not enforce by-laws in Cape Town or ranks that you are going on about it's the local authorities job to do so. Failure on their part is what you need to open your eyes to and chanel your criticism to. Debonairs or whoever, when their recruitment is flawed there are arms of government who should enforce if there's a violation. Sadly at times it is easy to blame others for the problems in our own lives. What is stopping sky from excelling? Maybe that is what you need to address first. If all foreigners leave SA would you wake up with millions of Rands in your pockets 🤔

[@arciliaodiegwu5665]

I have been overseas worked there I know how this feels.please let's treat our brothers and sisters well it's not easy being in a foreign country

[@codingtutorials1047]

Were you illegal and were you paying taxes?

[@ntagu5744]

@@codingtutorials1047 How can an illegal migrant take your job to the extent of rendering you all jobless up to 46 percent of the population?

[@ZettMamp]

@@codingtutorials1047 do these Dudula guys ask this question of legality?They just see a black foreign national and that's it.Lets be realistic here.If these undocumented foreign nationals were actually documented imagine the positive effect on the GDP.Most of these guys actually don't want to work but start businesses so imagine if those businesses paid tax

[@codingtutorials1047]

@@ZettMamp How would you enforce taxes? Every village has Pakistanis selling counterfeit goods and thriving. They pay 0 taxes. They use our hospitals that we fund with our taxes. I believe our anger is very much justified.

[@billyamanimutambala6472]

God sees everything. Thank you sister🥰🙏 at least they're still some people in South Africa who have understanding...

[@khuselamadlanga5198]

understand shit, she's rich this that's why she can't feel our pain

[@alicegauteng2358]

JUST GO BACK HOME!

[@l0ve127]

I’m convinced some of the people on these comments did not even listen to this lady. Just so many people filled with hate towards foreign nationals and redirecting their anger instead of addressing the elephant in the room .

[@naideneknife3867]

It's easier to bully the little guy one side rather than the big kid on the playground

[@ZettMamp]

@@naideneknife3867 very true.I have never come across a protest against a white foreign national or a Chinese person yet I have seen a Chinese family that can't even speak any South African language,including English but they were living large here in Johannesburg.To us black people these are not to be touched.They can occupy prime commercial land and mines while we fight for spaza shops and sweet stalls

[@naideneknife3867]

@@ZettMamp honestly heart breaking that we fight for the crumbs yet there's a feast prepared .. But I gets its just how the system has messed with our logic..

[@kellymatshoba2697]

I salute u gal..so South Africans that are working in America must b chased away also..well said sissy

[@rainbowtrust6347]

America can chase few thousands of SAns, but SA will be chasing over 200000 Americans, 5 million excluding undocumented ones of Zimbabweans, over 1 million of Nigerians, and more millions and thousands of each country of the 53 countries of Africa, Chinese that are living in SA, And SA will be still going better than now, because it was much better before the influx of poor people than investors. SAns from the continent if there are, at least few hundreds of them will be valuable back at home and everybody won't lack jobs, and will be like before the flood of migration. Things will go back where they were as SA didn't depend on the continent. It is the other way around. Whether there'll be a difficulty along the way but the strain of living a lie that is okay to be manipulated to please others while the suffering increases. And that SA is responsible for the millions of millions of poor people of the 54 countries of Africa is an abuse. That's why government like Zimbabwe, Malawi don't even try to care for their citizens and countries and it's unfair. We've never been so poor in SA, thanks to ANC, EFF, COSATU mainly and thanks to African governments.

[@sergioozar9696]

South Africans, if your problem is about money, pack up and come to USA, Canada...Australia and nobody will Blame you for stealing jobs from Nationals. You need to be inquisitive and open- minded, because the world does not only revolves around South Africa, you could do well Somewhere else. A saying goes like" nobody can be priest in his own land". You have a wonderful country, blessed with tones of natural resources,but because of " This is time to eat" This is the result. Please, stop blaming Foreigners.

[@wandiledlamini2591]

The problem is illegal immigrants not foreign nationals we don’t have a problem with people coming in legally

[@sergioozar9696]

@@wandiledlamini2591 I agres with you. You, Guys, need to clean the house. South Africa is a nice country and its people as well and it is *African visitor's Room* and it males me só proud! Count on us. From Angola 🙏🙏🌹

[@mannetjie3248]

Thank you NUMSA!!! SA's unemployment problem is due to government's inability to govern competently. Foreigners are not to blame for our problems. The ANC is!!!

[@trayway3014]

Yes the ANC, is not patriotic

[@Coco-kw3iv]

Foreigners must go. Full stop!

[@headhonchotheone9041]

@@Coco-kw3iv thank you but only if they are undocumented plain and simple .

[@mannetjie3248]

@@Coco-kw3iv Xenophobia is so intellectually lazy and primitive, really now...

[@bonginkosimnkandla4730]

@@Coco-kw3iv u lake education dear I will all of you South Africans in other countries can be deported as well

[@francismhlanga5081]

Wow she was just spitting Facts.God bless Africa.These are the leaders we need but in Africa they will never lead

[@Elpatron242]

Does 4% affect 46% NO!! , THIS LADY is really STRAIGHT FORWARD on her facts

[@Sky-dv8mj]

4% where is she getting that?? That's rubbish.

[@LibertyFilmCritic]

@@Sky-dv8mj Then how much is it, Genius?

[@tmanman6785]

She's definitely talking rubbish. Even if it was 4 percent its still a lot.

[@headhonchotheone9041]

4 percent does affect 46 percent judging by your name you are a foreigner

[@judithzimheni1700]

She is correct

[@jordanmuviyi8926]

I truly love this girl❤️🤞🏻. She’s the only South African who has said something that makes sense since this whole foreigners saga. She’s backing up her claims with valid facts.

[@alicegauteng2358]

What facts? Just go home and stop interfering in South African issues. We obviously have our own problems and we don't need your illegal opinions

[@zamajamile2728]

Yes bhuti that's correct

[@jordanmuviyi8926]

@@alicegauteng2358 I can’t argue with uneducated people Sis, go and study first, then we can talk.

[@dumisanindlovu5766]

This lady is brilliant and talking the truth no all foreigners are doing bad things . Yes they should feel safe wherever they work . I like your straight talk Phakamile

[@senkwelemichael3953]

It is so painful to see a South African taxi driver saying a Zimbabwean Doctors are taking jobs for them and it is painful to see a South African drug addict saying a Zambian common trader is take their job while we South Africans forgot where we come from and always want to get thing for free though we don't know where they comes from...I am very sorry to offend any South African who think is wise but saying a black man is a foreigner

[@sbukubheka4009]

My question How do you see an illegal foreigner with an eye and a legal foreigner and does that mean all those foreigners working are illegal foreigners. How do SA companies hire illegal foreigners.

[@lulumbele8733]

Re buelle hlubikazi 👏👏👏👏👏👏🇱🇸🇱🇸🇱🇸🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🙏🙏🙏 this is the Brain,Khotso, Pula, Nala. Watching from Maryland USA. 🕊

[@meteorhail5021]

Let Phakamile jump the border into Botswana, and go sell sweets in front of Princess Marina Hospital - I want to see something.

[@marilynmukome5845]

So what kind of a job has been stolen if someone decides to sell sweets what qualifications are needed to do that.

[@meteorhail5021]

@@marilynmukome5845 you've questioned and answered yourself 🤷🏽‍♂

[@realsteel2188]

I once didn't have any hope of finding a job after seeing all the negative news reports of companies closing... I printed 3 CVs and went to the first company where I heard an angle grinder, offered my CV and started a permanent job the next day

[@hlanganazulu3327]

Good for u..

[@realsteel2188]

@@hlanganazulu3327 Steal with your eyes and grow in skill if you missed the opportunity to get that education they say you need and put yourself out there... I work with the most enthusiastic disaster ever😂 he knows so little but is so determined that now he is able to do his own little project.

[@clintonzuma680]

It's funny how as South African's we never deal with the source of the problem, we always divert our anger to the wrong people. This lady is my hero and her statement should be what operation "Dudula" should be about, directing our anger to the government rather than the "the lady selling sweets in Bara".

[@zamajamile2728]

Excellent

[@claudkaligwenje6062]

Now God has started fighting fo foreigners.

[@kgomotsomashugane5731]

God does not fight for cowards who ran from their home forever because of disunity...

[@claudkaligwenje6062]

@@kgomotsomashugane5731 which disunity are you talking about.U mean if iam foreigner I'm a coward should be treated unfairly by u.Ur comment lacks coherence .qGod is not u

[@jebrilabdulazeez]

Even if you have good concerns regarding illegal immigrants,you should consider the harm that can come from such operations that are carried out by the people. Mob justice always ends up in oppression&injustice.

[@suelane1350]

Dont blame anyone but yourself, you plot your life. Education is the key.

[@Motswako]

So many South Africans have degrees and they are being overlooked because Caucasians want to exploit foreigners.

[@thembangwenya8112]

Let's be honest, education has done nooooo thing for most qualified individuals, in fact the youth has resorted to using their little capital into modern day investments such as foreign exchange, digital currency and standerdised stocks(Easy equities)... Business owners find it easier to take in foreigners because they care not for conditions, but just money

[@user-ie4jw8hp8q]

Education is key 👌 Self education ...

[@lulamanjuza]

This would make sense if there were no unemployed graduates

[@Sky-dv8mj]

With over 27 universities in SA, every year I'm seeing thousands graduating, so what kind of education are u talking about??? Don't talk rubbish here

[@gideonbreeedt7359]

Tru. 100%tru. It's anc to blame. No one els

[@LeratoM98]

The thing is, there's high unemployment so if SA was prioritizing its citizens, they'd be focusing on jobs for SA firstly. Yes, we can't blame foreigners, but government, for creating this mess and creating an environment where immigration system is being annihilated.

[@sfisobsto2506]

Nawe uyanya

[@headhonchotheone9041]

True

[@headhonchotheone9041]

@@Vincent-ll7ov we cant all be entrepreneurs

[@headhonchotheone9041]

@@Vincent-ll7ov illicit finacial flows and the disruption of tax money are the biggest cause of poverty not only in africa but globally.

[@headhonchotheone9041]

@@Vincent-ll7ov what I mean is that the government is not using our tax money to provide basic services they are using most of it for their own financial gain .

[@thabisandlela838]

we as southAfrica some of us are at Australia working so lets not take ourself like we are better than others

[@BeautysTv]

Everywhere not just Australia

[@thandobheka6371]

I blame UNIONS not the government or foreigners

[@dorothythoane6957]

And me too ,einklik I blame the unions and the ANC cronies ,don't stop fighting ,she is also not representing the people of South Africa ,she represents ANC government ,ANC unions not everyone ,only the chosen few .

[@jomothindisa5208]

#Voetsek Numsa, cutting my membership of Numsa. Protecting your foreign members,

[@khaleaspa9014]

We don't blame foreigners just the Government Put South Africans First in their country of birth Period!

[@yebosuwa]

Who’s we! Have you not seen foreigners being kicked out of their properties my South African citizens? If you don’t blame the foreigners, why not go fight the government. Make it make sense mhan!

[@jeremyphilander8833]

Employ people in the immediate area....that would elevate many problems. It will reduce transportation cost. And get traffic reduced. Plus unnecessary taxi ranks.

[@fortunetshabalala3388]

That’s a very bad idea and it would never work as it has a potential of causing even more unemployment.

[@gladwinmohlamonyane4033]

That would just promote migration and the need for cheaper housing, which would ultimately concentrate economic activity to specific regions of the country. Would def make the situation a lot worse

[@jeremyphilander8833]

I disagree with both of you. You are using a capitalistic approach. Instead of growing from within. Thats the Jewish system. You 2 are really foolish, dragging your thoughts behind rich folks.

[@gladwinmohlamonyane4033]

Nah, we need to diversify our investments. Focusing economic activity to small regions and making sure it's only available to residents of those regions will yield detrimental results at best. Migration is inevitable, but you need to make sure that opportunities are available in more places than just Gauteng and the Western Cape. Additionally, I was only talking about a single point you made and that was about limiting work opportunities to the residents of a certain area. Your point was that it would eliminate the need for travel and stop us from using taxis. Please, oh wise one... inform me. What work would those who operate our broken (yet vital) transport system do? Would they have work suddenly appear before them? The problem that we face with unemployment is far more complicated than the location that work is granted in.

[@jeremyphilander8833]

It's like the COVID 19 lockdown system in the beginning. It was on or off. Then it grew into 5 levels. The same applies to creating work from the immediate residential area. Not difficult if you ask me.

[@activeplumbing1766]

Thank you sister for taking sence we need at least 50%of South African pple like you don't just act before you think.

[@henryhondo8421]

Makes a lot of sense, even if we inflate the percentage of foreign nationals to 20% and make an unrealistic assumption that all the foreign nationals are working there is still about 26 percentage points of unemployment left unexplained

[@glitchh4004]

During the great depression, an economist had this brilliant idea to encourage employers to employ temporary workers, to increase their output and also create jobs. The last Labour law signed by Ramaphosa made it very difficult to employ temporary staff. I am worried, because we are focusing our attention on the wrong places to fix problems intentionally created. Very good interview from both sides. Thank you for bringing such good news coverage to SA.

[@normantshokotshela5290]

The problem in South Africa is, you become Temporary ten years without benefits. Greed from businesses is creating this problem that forced the government to made it difficult to employ temp staff.

[@washingtonncube6665]

So are the South Africans saying they will rather work for foreigners and not work with zim foreigners and yet they is foreigners from all corners of the world it's strange

[@darlingtonrusike2943]

This lady she knows what she's talking abt thank u

[@cobuscoetzee9948]

She is correct. What she should add is that the governing party open the borders for foreigners. Secondly our people are forced to belong to a union and foreigners just want to work. Last comment don't blame apartheid for the incompetence of the ANC.

[@jimrasakanya8459]

Apartheid is far more than racism is a an evil spirit.Those who practiced it where inspired by the devil.That thing is a spiritual force.Even if we can take 100 years in democracy it will still show its mark clearly.The way apartheid is deep rooted in us some of us think is nature.While is apartheid. This thing of foreigner that foreigner that is apartheid africa is one.So i am not justifying failures of ANC i am just talking about the impact of apartheid.Apartheid had made its victims to loose the identity how many black people who leave like whites.Apartheid had destroyed black nation. 😶

[@cobuscoetzee9948]

@@jimrasakanya8459 I personally agree with you. What we ( you and me) can not control is the politicians. They are stealing everyday, and every minute forgetting that they have to look after the poor.

[@Sky-dv8mj]

@@cobuscoetzee9948 how many billions did your forefathers stole from this land?

[@cobuscoetzee9948]

@@Sky-dv8mj I wish I new. Then we can take them to jail aswell. One thing that our forefathers did was that they offered us infrastructure like clinics and hospitals, roads railway lines, schools that was well maintained. Since 1994 we believed in the rainbow nation but looked what happened thereafter. It is so sad to see this country broken to the bone.

[@sandilengubo3382]

@@cobuscoetzee9948 You're making valid points sir...

[@ezzymarketingagency9477]

It's also so sad that Home Affairs government have made their laws and policies so complex that even an immigrant who is legally here can live up to more than 12 years with proper updateted documention yet still failing to attain permanent residency when they apply and as time goes by they are forced to become illegal residents due to expiration of visas and passports Being this difficult Does NO GOOD for the country other than promoting CORRUPTION and bribery This Issue MUST BE ADDRESSED! IMMEDIATELY & SERIOUSLY

[@BeautysTv]

God bless you.

[@ntagu5744]

correct

[@portiahill5991]

This minister he is the one causing corruption in this country weaker minds blame so if all foreigners go they will be Jobs.now corruption is toooooomuch in home affairs the minister is contributing to the downfall of South Africa 🇿🇦 then blame is on outsiders.all south africa across the world must come back home

[@amabhohlela.3492]

Go back to Zimbabwe,don't be like ur South African.

[@mashallvuma5086]

very true

[@wandiledlamini2591]

Aren’t these the same people were vandalising Local businesses

[@sylvestermondhlane957]

Your ✅ comrade. Any failure turn to blame a foreigner for whatever including unmarried man justify it by saying" they take our women"!!!

[@mbusovilakati6020]

Indians and other races own most shop here...but we think the African selling sweet s and cigarettes in the streets is the problem...Are you also fighting to sell sweets in the streets?... Think big...

[@nicholasgigaba2779]

Don't forget the drugs they sell to our kids in townships.

[@loratomaimane9137]

How did they open business when they haven't qualified and our porous borders are an issue as well, the Anc is 2 blame for this.... SAns should be protesting at Luthuli house and remove the Anc or stop voting for them.... Misguided anger... She is right.... The Anc has failed SAns.. Labour immigration laws weren't followed.

[@more2much696]

how many people vote?

[@edmorehamandawana3430]

Please kindly define a porous border and validate what you are saying by tangible proof. If I may ask, have you even ever been to any of the borders before you parrot heresy that you just get from ppl who want to control your mind to think in a certain way.?

[@thobekashangase1452]

What's this 4% is she talking about, is it documented immigrants or undocumented immigrants? She needs to make this clear.

[@majestic4124]

4% is every non South African living in South Africa

[@fonelo2215]

so you are not listening?

[@philad1439]

What she says is nonsense 4% of foreign nationals in South Africa are the ones with legal documentation and able to be counted, what does she says about the millions that are not documented or illegal which are also the ones that are being employed by the South African business?

[@12thpls]

Where did you find the millions figure? If you can't prove it then its make believe.

[@valenciam125]

And there's 18 000 duplicate ID documents. Foreigners using SA ID to occupy jobs

[@philad1439]

@@12thpls I have no energy for ur comment

[@12thpls]

@@philad1439 all I'm saying the foreigners can leave tomorrow but the joblessness will continue and probably even grow

[@DokoloCity]

Thanks, NUMSA... We have sane people who can articulate the real issues... 2 bn rands was stolen during covid ... how many jobs could that have created..

[@willemmcalpine9040]

Julius invited them here now he want them to go back ha ha

[@zodwamhlanga8797]

Mandela said we must stay here before even Malema was born

[@confidencesibanda7841]

4% of all foreign nationals is taking all jobs kkkk yet unemployment rate is 46% when I buy tomatos I don't ask where do you come from I just buy, so this thing of foreign nationals are taking the space is crazy. just go to the market and buy your tomatoes and resell don't blame people for your laziness Phakamile well said

[@jstmoosedj6096]

Including the illegal immigrants?

[@thatgirluNothile]

Go back to zimbabwe sibanda we don't have sibanda surname in south Africa nkwerekwere

[@kgomotsomashugane5731]

4% documented foreigners the rest who make up 15% are illigal... they don't know how many foreigners are in S.A.

[@elelolo6225]

Truth is always bitter to swallow...well said sister

[@azmachtsegay1444]

May God bless you behalf of all foreigners

[@tvprospernews]

Well said Sister. The problem is that only 4% of South Africans can understand what this brilliant Lady is saying.

[@no.commonsense]

How long we wanted and were waiting for this brave lady to come forward and speak the TRUTH U HAVE OUR SUPPORT NOMSA we then employ foreingers who are serious and are hard working with no complications finished and done

[@realsteel2188]

Growing up we were told to have a great life, we must get education, pass at school to get a good job. This has locked our mindset that makes us depend on a faulty employment systems. I believe that we should become empowered with skills to create our own opportunities that will also create opportunities for others who are don't have the capacity to lead but to serve...

[@kadimaalain2658]

The idea that South Africa will develop itself independently of the continent is a lie … South Africa by now should become a manufacturing country shipping its goods on the continent and this is not happening because your people are so narrow minded that they don’t see opportunities in other lands within the continent … us Congolese go buy goods in China and Dubai when we could clearly get them from SA vendor but your xenophobic spirit is blinding you even more

[@Sky-dv8mj]

@@kadimaalain2658 when did we get that chance to breath??? Please put yourself in our possession, we were colonized all the year, we only got relief in 1994. Tell me what did we know compared to u who has been hustling long ago, u know what I'm talking about. U've been around, u have all the experience and we don't. So u are listening to this previlage lady who doesn't know what we are going through as under previlage citizens. I'm one of those who are in pain on the ground level, I'm not talking what they say I'm talking from experience. I was born in 1978 in deep rural of Transkei, I know how the black nations went through. It was a previlage even to ware a panty while at home, one or two were kept for church and school only. I'm highlighting our history so that u continue to blame and undermine us knowing what took place We were going through thick n thin Take example in an instance where your neighbors have been having all and u have nothing but the day your time comes, they are already all over the place to grab every opportunity. So it's tough

[@michaeldaniels8582]

thats true south african lacks practical skills and some don't want to learn from foreigners on how they operate their business

[@thembi9645]

@@kadimaalain2658 when did we get our independence coz u were free long time . We supposed to be buying from Congo, not the other way around. Get your facts right. Don’t rush to bash South Africa. 300 or not 400 years of slavery Nd 27 years of trying to undo the damage of 300 years imagine brohh Haay don’t crucify SA like this plz be realistic man haybo

[@tseposenatsi7527]

@@kadimaalain2658You don't mention which country you are from...... Since you are not narrow minded, are you manufacturing and distributing food in the continent?

[@fabianpillay860]

South Africans 1st end of story.this topic is about 15years late

[@PRENTERTAINMENTSFMRADIO]

100%

[@mzwandilethulasizwe7838]

True

[@fabianpillay860]

It's hard but we must try to give South Africans jobs 1st.i want to paint my car my friend told me about 15k .foreigner told me 9k I'm not rich but i have to play my part an give my bro the job because I'm feed up of give them my money

[@livistoncube7732]

This is the most common sense thing l have had. The issue of immigration is a division from land issue and sponsored by the w-elite who have sponsored action SA. How does someone self-employed taking yo Job 🤔?

[@Dupedupedean]

She is brilliant and well spoken! 👏

[@benchleyb]

Well said Numsa! Don't scapegoat the poor migrants!

[@siphombingo6545]

I live here in America I can’t work if I don’t have proper documentation is not because the people are xenophobic it’s the law so why should South Africa be different rule of law. I couldn’t work here in America until I had my documentation has anybody realized that they are quick to throw the xenophobic word each and every time this is discussed I wonder why?

[@lukwaheritier3371]

Maybe u not understand bro there is home affairs that not documented people

[@livingfaith9189]

You are very confused. Obviously there is an unsure number of illegal migrants. That 4% she is talking about are documented migrants. Some south africans want documented africans to leave as well...

[@jasonMB999]

Work hard and you will never have to blame foreign people.

[@colmfortmutembwa6922]

you are a good leader my sister and your points are valid . you are a profound leader . thank you

[@luyandachamane2093]

Absolutely correct 🙌🏾🇿🇦❤️

[@farayichakuvinga867]

Intellectual, factual,real........ you have my full respect young lady.

[@alicegauteng2358]

You sound Zimbabwen. Go home!

[@MrMalgul]

Slowly, surely, the right people are getting into the right places...Well said Phakamile.

[@xonganichauke3011]

It`s good to have a backup plan just incase you can`t find employment. The politicians must also STOP saying they`ll provide jobs, we all know that it`s BULL. We should all aspire to be employers not employees.

[@rockmaposa3109]

The people believe what is good for them to hear and they decide to not think. Is like to promise a girl friend to buy her a train and she very excited without thinking where this guy can find money to buy it . 🤔

[@PM-pt9rg]

Brilliant. This smart lady spitting FACTS.

[@oupamathole524]

The main goal for the ANC was to have more black people in S.A so that they will be voted in power forever by majority 'blacks Africans' but the strategy is now backfiring

[@mohammadaftabafridi1180]

Your absolutely right no one can take your job if you want to work she hot a very valid points thumbs up for you

[@abigailncube3142]

How can a foreigner come all the way from Zimbabwe and get your job??? Has anyone ever been removed from their work?? Foreigners go out and look for jobs and they find them!!

[@realsteel2188]

Also, I believe that there are alot of untapped work opportunities. Some companies I have seen from experience do not advertise positions, even if they have openings... You just have to be relentless and knock on doors... You will be the answer to an employers prayers...

[@shaibuabdallah8878]

Madam Phakamile, there's more Women that can lead this nation to the other levels with Love and Patriotism

[@dumisanindlovu5766]

Good thinker Phakamile, we have South Africans working overseas no one victimise us

[@dumisanindlovu5766]

May God protect u for telling the truth , ngiyabonga Phakamile Majola . I pray that you won't be victimised. If God is for you who can be against you .

[@b6universal64]

I never expect if in South Africa can exist a such smart lady

[@malibongwe3491]

Clearly you understanding South African women

[@pulengmathiane2505]

The 4 percent she is talking about its a random number that come to her mind hence she is also talking about documentation which contradict the random 4 percent. Why document if she knows its 4 percent mybe its 40percent. Latina lena di Educated fools

[@b6universal64]

@@pulengmathiane2505 always try to defend what is not there

[@aubreydebliquy8051]

If you have no borders you have no country. If government allows 250,000 immigrants into the country no matter their race whether they are legal or illegal then where is the policy for one new school every day to accommodate the pupils with a constitutional right to education? Where is the school to which every parent has a legal obligation to send their child? Government cannot have it both ways. Open borders are fine if government is honest about building of schools to meet the demand of every child within our borders.

[@chileshemulenga8790]

Are they attending schools for free or they pay school fees, what of those at private institutions is it free or they pay, its like saying foreign nationals get social grants how???? or saying noe locals come to get food from RSA the question is are they getting the food for free or buying, if buying then it intra trade

[@evrardkambou9786]

Typical white Man divided and conquered. Do you really care about Black South African?.because their is so much more to do to redistribute the wealth. A comment coming from a foreign national

[@khanyisilencube3108]

Europe has no borders yet they are living in peace and they have jobs exceeding the amount of people they have yet here they are inforcing boarders in Africa so they can continue stealing from African resources - what does Division bring besides conflict and unhealthy relations with the next country so we can focus on fighting each other while they steal - that's how we were colonised and you want us to stay colonised - Wake up.

[@reznikboris5]

I NEVER KNE SOUTH AFRICAN HAS THIS TYPE OV SMART LADY BIG U 2 U

[@ndayishimiyeshabani5056]

Well done Sisi. I follow u from France. People are frustrated because government don't deliver their promises. I lived in SA for 10 years I know how it is.

[@mashegotom4497]

She says 4% ....if I have millions of rands in my house 🏡 but my bank account have thousands rands..how the bank knows I'm a millionaire..Same as this problem of llegal migrant workers n illegal migrant workers...

[@marcusmagagula9081]

True, its not 4 percent

[@menzorams9702]

We are talking about illegal immigration nothing else. Do not mix issues and give examples of South African who are working legally in other countries. We want everyone who is in Mzanzi to be legal in orders to have control. We have so many illegal immigrants. People are suffering, being killed raped by unknown people and the police are unable to arrest them. You are so comfortable if one of your friends or family members can go through what poor citizens are experiencing. You will come again and sing a different tune. Be sensitive sister.

[@Dude-1689]

I also had the same approach just as the lady here until I actually listened to uNhlanhla and realized that 'Dudula' is but ONE of the issues that He is bringing to our attention. His message is quite broad and directed towards the youth. It's a call to be hands on and to recreate our state that the ANC failed to manifest. Confusing as it is for most, we also need to adopt that he's not leading a political movement but rather sounding the alarm on what South Africans ought to call a working democratic government. Ultimately, we have all been robbed of our freedom through the manipulation of resources. If we disregard the 4% now, what do you think will happen after 15 to 20 years 🤷‍♂️! It's not like South Africans have options afterall! As the youth, What exactly do we have to share ???

[@senzyandndivhu]

Viva numsa insimbi ayigobi that's why am proudly a numsa member even though am from Zimbabwe l will die a numsa comrade

[@veronicafredericks997]

We should salute this lady..so true what she is saying..These politicians like the PA AND EFF SHOULD STOP PLAYING POLICEMEN..

[@lindabrown3787]

Thank you for speaking the truth👏

[@davidchimwemwe5069]

Well spoken from sister Nomsa... You can't attack a lady selling sweets aiming that she's taking your citizens jobs.. How come.. Scapegoat indeed

[@judysthabilempofu9424]

Very true sister my the good Lord bless you for telling the truth ,and may the Lord protect you always

[@afrikawewant5390]

Our unemployment is not 46%

[@HelloWorld-th9vb]

First all give us the stats of all undocumented immigrants in South Africa, tell us how you did your calculations, We want facts

[@londekazulu6462]

Waze wa khuluma kahle sthandwa senkosi💯agree with you. The government is busy fighting for power kuphela. We are left to fend for ourselves. Foreigners are even exploited and paid even less because some are illegally here and desperate for jobs so companies use that to their advantage. Of course as a South African citizen you won't stand for this because you know your worth but even so some of us work for a lousy R3500 for the whole month. There are too many factors at play to just single out foreigners especially black Africans. If we are complaining about foreigners all together than we must think about foreign lectures and doctors etc who in this argument/case are stealing jobs while citizens behleli with their degrees. Another important factor here is that countries like employing foreigners, e.g. If a South African goes to Canada they have a better chance of education and a job where as natural citizens may struggle vs versa when foreigners come to South Africa. Look at the Chinese people who have been expending businesses left right and centre. In Durban alone I don't know how many moonlight stores have opened. While foreign people join together in our country to build businesses we as citizens continue to lack support and collaboration in business ideas ngoba sinobona kanti futhi siyawisana cause of Ubuntu bethu is not the closest thing to mind anymore. So like usisi has said Direct the same energy to the right people. It's easy to fight and blame the easiest of targets while the big goons watch you destroy each other thus serving their purpose. Kanti sizovuka nini, I thought this generation was woke ngathi siwoke ezintweni ezibhedayo nje kakhulu.

[@hopes9451]

I guess foreigners should also blame their government's for turning them into illegal immigrants in other countries.😂😥

[@wayzenthefighter6542]

Our South African government and labour department are doing nothing useless I can say..so our people are doing a good job 💯

[@Kingofsouth_godchoosen]

It's wish of every foreign to be documented but again the home affairs is failing. They are saling document with a very high price . It's has become a business for individuals.. as for the borders. Blame home affairs again

[@thelondonbridge6605]

I am in EU and there are alot of South Africans women working illegally.

[@bhekashosanya8594]

Thanks sthandwa sam this ppl they don't know tht they have sisters and brothers in foreign countries, how would they feel if they attacked their own fellow south african ppl, thts not gud they always take law into their own hands ,which is bad, I always feel hurt and bad seeing all this happening in South Africa ,am in overseas and no 1 or non immigrants has ever treated me the way they treat their on fellow african brothers and sisters its highly time government and fellow south africans to fix this mess and hatred towards their own fellow black Africans let the be peace in our land.

[@thembi9645]

Haay my fellow South Africans she’s 100% right. Our government has failed us dismal shme without a doubt Nd it’s SAD, all these foreigners that are here their government have all these policies put in place for their citizens to ensure they benefit it’s citizens, but with SA it’s benefiting them not SA citizens, what a vise versa 🤷🏽‍♀️

[@teek1860]

But you are missing the main point here, she is saying there are 4% of foreign nationals, of which we can assume that they are all employed which is unlikely, Unemployment is at 46% if you take away the 4% foreign nationals, you are still left with 42% unemployment, who will we blame then? Because unemployment at that rate is still very high, so the focus is misguided, you are still focusing on the wrong thing . Government is failing to create jobs or an environment which allows for job creation. It's faluire to implement policies to prioritize locals is one issue but it is not the real crux of the matter because 4% blame is little to solve unemployment problems.

[@dianasekatane6045]

Numsa is part of cosatu, what do they do to create jobs for the citizens?

[@bravomoviesofficial5265]

Well said

[@kurumanrenalcare1717]

Well articulated Nomsa, thumbs up for you. Letthose with ears hear the facts you just highlighted

[@davidmapitle9801]

How did she come to these figures because illegal foreigners are not documented. Where does she take the figures????