5 Reasons Why You Can't “Just Be a Good Person” (Atheism Refuted)

[@SafinaSociety]

Watch full episode: kzbin.info/www/bejne/d2SkXmyggJxlY6s Study Islam online: www.arkview.org

[@MubashirYounus]

Most satisfying answer to this question ❤ May Allah reward you

[@masonmaglio6585]

So true about the baseline of Atheistic philosophy being a giant facade, ultimately being rooted upon their own desires and false sincerity

[@AKHTIVEANDTHRUSTED]

Brilliant Allahumma barik

[@ShadmanaSami]

May ALLAH SWT reward you shaykh. Please make a video on the benefits of dhikr specifically Hawqala,Istighfaar and Dua Younis A.S too

[@fahid3342]

Intersection of Islam and philosophy is so interesting. If anyone has anything for me to read up more on it lmk

[@convinced_muslim]

if you want to learn more about Islam listen to Dr Omar Suleiman for the life of Prophet Muhammad ﷺ and Nouman Ali Khan for better understanding of Quran too

[@fahid3342]

@@convinced_muslim I’m Muslim lol

[@convinced_muslim]

@@fahid3342 doesn't matter. We're all constant learners!

[@h.parwani6521]

Great response!

[@rahimagrace5916]

Fascinating!

[@moezhamouda3248]

1. Goodness is subjectif 2. Multiplicity of goodnesses will lead to a clash ( to evil ) 3. If goodness is subjectif you can't impose it on anyone 4. We need a justification to act upon goodness that appeals to our own pleasure and pain 5. We can't plagiarise : if you go about being good on your own and giving your self the credit you are a plagiarise

[@fuzailahmad6604]

Plagiarise*

[@moezhamouda3248]

@@fuzailahmad6604 thank u brother

[@fuzailahmad6604]

Welcome. As-salamu alaikum.

[@abdullaha9906]

What about people who say “The Universe”?

[@ahbarabraham6154]

Meaning?

[@abdullaha9906]

New Agers, and their likes

[@convinced_muslim]

what do you mean?

[@abdullaha9906]

Like New Agers who say it

[@SalemPhiladelphia]

It’s shirk. I understand what you mean. Those people are unknowingly falling into kufr

[@olivermiles6416]

السلام عليكم، Can we use this arguments to convince a Hanif. I have a step father who comes from an AA background where they teach a God of your understanding. I assume you add arguments about reason for revelation and proof of Muhammad SAW as a messenger. Can non-Muslims have a relationship with God? Sometimes feel like a hanif can?

[@Zero-fh2wb]

plants have been shown to help other plants at the cost of themselves, nature is not innately selfish, things become selfish when systems and conditions reward selfish behavior. yet we as humans, and other animals, and plants, have instances of self sacrifice, and theres gratification and great reward in the feeling of self sacrifice oncr it is said an done. the world may nurture or fester/develop selfishness. I do not think this is the fitrah of human beings. innately disposed etc

[@Islam_deen_Jannah]

Assalamualikum Sheikh, Pleass for the sake of Allah, make videos on these topics in ordee to give dawah ti hindus(veg people) & christianity : 1. Why Islam allows innocent animals to kill the animals and eat ( they claim that we have the choice to choose therefore we choose not to kill animals for our taste buds but Islam is cruel) please give a logical answer to this. 2. Once I was giving dawah to a christian, mentioning about all the scientific proofs from the Quran but the guy straight away denied that all these are from satan, even the veda/ Gita or othex scriptures have some scientific proofs like bermuda triangle n all 3. Hindus claim that their religion came the first and so is the truth

[@jaisalrw3494]

This logic doesn't make sense. Defining goodness as what God commands is also subjective. You've subjectively decided that what God commands you to do is good. How is this any different from what atheists are doing?

[@TomassoTrekks]

It is because God, by definition, is Objective. Therefore, his commands are objectively good. The question one must then ask is, how do we know that the Quran is God's objective speech...etc?

[@jaisalrw3494]

@@TomassoTrekks what does God being objective mean? Are you talking about his existence? Because in that sense everyone's existence is objective. I'm not following your argument at all. Elaborate more on what "God is objective" means

[@Tazinio01]

​@@jaisalrw3494An all-knowing creator will objectively know what is good or bad. Human beings defining good or bad will always be subjective. Muslims believe the Qur'an and the Prophets are from God. So anything mentioned there is objectively true. It raises the questions of how do we know the Qur'an is from God and not man-made? How do we know a Prophet's claim of prophethood true? There are proofs for these, discussed at length. Muslims have accepted these proofs. Hope this helps.

[@jaisalrw3494]

@@Tazinio01 that's a circular argument. You say an all-knowing God would know what is objectively good or bad. But in order for a God to have such knowledge, objective morals would have to exist in the first place (obviously, how can you know something if it doesn't exist?). The point I'm making is that existence of God says nothing about whether morality is objective or not. There is absolutely no logical connection between the two.

[@TomassoTrekks]

@@jaisalrw3494 Meaning that God is all knowing and is not subject to assumptions, corruption, falsehood and or half knowledge like human beings are. When God decrees a matter, it simply is. The reality of God, is the only objective reality.