EVERY DOCTOR DE-REGENERATES (Doctor Who's Broke Canon)

#76. The resuscitation of Broke Canon.
Find my lovely contributors here:
‪@MrTARDIS‬: / trilbeereviews
‪@JayExci‬: / jayexci
‪@ProtagonistIvy‬: / protagonistivy
‪@Joe_Brennan_‬: / joe_brennan_
‪@anawfulpodcast‬: t.co/tWWg5E1j00
Drop a tip to support me & see new videos if you'd like more! ko-fi.com/samd...

[@maryautumn7922]

at any point the doctor could turn into troughton and it should be used as exclusively as an intimidation tactic

[@plantainsame2049]

Why not turn into an unholy fusion of all his Incarnations Like one column baker arm One peter capaldi one A purtwee leg and a mcoy leg

[@littleredruri]

​@@plantainsame2049 Column Baker: 🏛

[@creed8712]

@@plantainsame2049he gets the eyes of hurt, they eyebrows of Capaldi and the Chin of Smith

[@plantainsame2049]

@@creed8712 The teeth of tom baker

[@creed8712]

@@plantainsame2049 what appendage does Jodie get? It would be easy to say the breasts but maybe the lips

[@tarponpet]

THIS IS NOT A DRILL! BROKE CANON IS BACK!

[@Private-Potato]

We’re back, Babay!

[@PL3223]

YESSSSS!!!!

[@firetarrasque4667]

“I haven’t even talked about Iris Wildthyme!” “Is she in it?” “It’s her book.” Ah! Well, that explains everything.

[@timrob12]

I kinda wish that Big Finish had accepted one of my short stories, not only because it was an homage to my grandfather, but also because it would canonize the Third Doctor nearly being hit by a bus upon landing in Belgium.

[@tom-0ton408]

Where do I sign the petition to help get this made?

[@timrob12]

@@tom-0ton408 I'm afraid there isn't any.

[@mikhaeldarriens3810]

"Something a lot more literal. I like [the idea that] all the incarnations of The Doctor still live inside them. And can be brought out. Like Ben10." - Samuel Davis, 2023

[@deaderontheinside6871]

Paul magrs' books and iris exist as a camp counterbalance to faction paradox. And we love him for it.

[@theonewhowatches869]

Minor correction, the Doctor actually does change into 12 during Once and Future. Its broef but he's the 'final' future Doctor they turned into to get out of that cell. Apprently he was literally just counting faces until they reached thirteen

[@ThePsycoDolphin]

Following the last specials, i think broke canon is actually the leading guidebook for Who.

[@HexToTheWorld]

The Jo gaslighting with 4th wallbreaking injokes about bad effects is done to 6 in Trick or Treat by the Toymaker too. He claims he keeps meeting the daleks because they're his fav

[@plantainsame2049]

How did six react considering that one and four broke the fourth wall occasionally

[@timthememer2785]

It's nice to be reminded Verdigris does, in fact, exist and I didn’t imagine it. The UNIT supermarket and cutout Mike Yates are truly things.

[@Enshohma]

So happy to see the Broke Cannon back! Some of the insane wackiness this series of yours shares is delightful!

[@Chubby_Bub]

Does reading Verdigris this much constitute substance abuse

[@shshyie]

I remember playin that k-9 game, utter peak childhood moments

[@mathieuleader8601]

Fun fact: Sydney Newman when 6 quit wanted Throughton to replay the Doctor for one whole series.

[@koslaulskusthegreat9050]

LET'S GO! MY FAVOURITE KZbin SERIES IS BACK!

[@ghostlygooze]

this is the real doctor who content we all missed

[@bookswithike3256]

This is somehow the most unhinged episode of Broke Canon yet.

[@xavierwalko4175]

RTD saying every Doctor has gone through Bi-Generation should be thrown into here. At least that explains most of Big Finish lol

[@edwardrizer8505]

RTD meant that in different Universes, as away to explain how the Doctor’s are always old in MultiDoctor stories.

[@plantainsame2049]

I thought that was already explained by the universe attempting to compensate​@@edwardrizer8505

[@firetarrasque4667]

@@edwardrizer8505This is Doctor Who, canon is a lie if they ever let me write this shit I’m going to do everything in my power to make it worse

[@eccremocarpusscaber5159]

@@firetarrasque4667Thanks Chris.

[@ItsButterBean1020]

Oh yeah, it splits the timeline each time apparently

[@najawin8348]

btw, you all have heard about the "canon" (not canon) Eighth Doctor smut book, but have you heard about the ACTUALLY CANON Faction Paradox bodice ripper?

[@matthewbarker9134]

Spill it then, what's the title?

[@sacrificiallamb4568]

It's canon. They both are. Nothing is. We've gone over this.

[@najawin8348]

@@matthewbarker9134 Erasing Sherlock.

[@najawin8348]

@@sacrificiallamb4568 Nah, the issue with The Stranger is that it didn't have the rights needed. If it's "canon" so are fan films. (But yes, the entire usage of the word "canon" is silly.)

[@sacrificiallamb4568]

They referenced it in other works. Also, the fan films are canon. Downtime, fanfilm, Kate Stewart. Cyberons, fanfilm, expanded universe media. That one with Pertwee, they used footage from that numerous times in licenced work when they wanted Pertwee and the trailer for it was on an official BBC DVD so it counts.@@najawin8348 But yes, canon is pointless. (Sidenote, why do you think only Ghostbusters still uses the Lucas model? It's very weird and hurtful to me that they usurped the better format with a far worse continuation. And they didn't even do a sequel to the reboot.)

[@Entertainer13]

It took me a WHOLE YEAR to get the canon back together, and now you broke it! The nerve! (Glad to see this series back.)

[@councilmanbanks6528]

I love it when it just seems like Doctor Who writers are just high

[@OkMakuTree]

So happy this series it back! I look forward to trying to parse out DAVIS’ opinions on the recent specials through his offhand comments in future videos 😂 Also glad to see Jay, hope they’re doing well!

[@jeffmoo9235]

Just as I fall back into the doctor who hole it grows ever deeper. Welcome back Broke Canon

[@richardbourton4523]

RIP Richard Franklin

[@pious83]

4:42 Not enough, is the answer.

[@katokianimation]

And Hartnell and Hurt and Smith just died at old age imediately. So the next Doctor was linked to a corpse.

[@almighty9539]

the Union forced Renegade Time Lords to degenerate, not really because she wanted to experiment on it, but only for 1. Make them feel how she felt with having regenerative dissonance and 2 using the degeneration energy radiating from her victims, so she can use it to suppress her previous personas.

[@fletcheragenda6014]

it's so good to be back. this one is a certified hit.

[@hunterharmak]

Season 4 HYPE!!!

[@Sharkpowder]

The Doctor is an Eternal Champion in Micheal Moorecock's Multiverse, this ties his memories in with Jerry Cornelius, Elric of Melninboné, and loads more anti-heroes!

[@olivergaither]

When The Master turned The Doctor into Dobby the House elf his ability to regenerate was disabled so he couldn’t change his face

[@CulturePhilter]

The best Doctor Who series on KZbin returns! , now, get me in to do some of those readings 😁

[@StevenHouse1980]

What was the first Brakeing of TV Cannon? So Iris Wildthyme joined Sisterhood of Karn, but if she is not a real Time Lady from a one of the Timelord house's that have seats in the High Council. Perhaps she was only a lower class Shobogan that got transformed into someone who could regernerate due to a situation involving all those potions the Sisterhood made to triger the regeneration of The Doctor. All those potions had to go some where after that point in the Timewar. Also it's not as if Iris Wildthyme is the secret love child of Rassilon and Tecteun, then again with pearants that bad I would hide as well.

[@SamyulDavis]

There's definitely no intended answer, but that secret lovechild of Rassilon sounds suitably scandalous, so imma go with that

[@plantainsame2049]

​@@SamyulDavisDoesn't he have descendants like isn't he currently living in the " body" of one of Them And that's how they resurrected him

[@junecasadilla]

I know I just found this channel but I was sad to see there wasn't any new broke cannon for awhile and glad ther's a possible 4th season starting

[@jeckjeck3119]

Broke canon is back, WAKE UP THE KIDS! Oh wait, singing goblins ate them... well, more for me~

[@plantainsame2049]

I have been avoiding spoilers for some reason But when I first saw the picture of one of those guys I Thought that it was gonna be the demon magician From an old tv comic with john and julian Where the demon magician tried to ruin christmas

[@CaptainKitchener]

Benni a while hasn’t it ❤

[@horrorstew3577]

"this old body is wearing a bit thin...... Oh wait, no.. I'm fine" 🤷🤦

[@einplaysbad]

I've been rewatching all of Broke Canon for the past three days so I guess I just summoned it back????

[@hey_cupcake]

Funny how the Master reacted at the kiss with Jo when later on he proceeds to marry Tegan and get her a matching dress too

[@MrSimpleton]

I am very happy to see this series return!

[@jedisalsohere]

Have you done a Broke Canon about Muldwych yet? The ginger future Doctor who was Merlin and had a few short stories? If you haven't, you totally should. There's also that one time that a movie company prosecuted a director for making an adaptation of one of the Doctor's adventures that wasn't accurate enough to the source material.

[@plantainsame2049]

He thought he was the last one The artifact was a body Grandfather half ling was in the city of the save And the curator seems to have mystical abilities Since from my understanding, he doesn't regenerate as much as he just does look like different doctors I have a theory on how all this connects Muldwych Dies His body becoming the artifact His mind, however, becomes father halfling in the city of the save since it's an after life And if I understand eventually due to the death of compassion who contains the city Everyone inside is resurrected And this would lead to the curator But that's just a theory based off my half remembered bits of decades of lore

[@TimelordRick]

AT VERY LONG LAST, THE MATRIX HAS OPENED TO US!

[@ms.antithesis]

Oh it's yellow now....

[@nightowl8477]

This was so good! Got to be one of the best edited, no? How can a video over a year in the making still be relevant?

[@richardlyth]

Broke Canon is finally back? WELL THAT'S ALRIGHT THEN!

[@timecontroller8800]

BROKE CCCAAAANNNNOOONNNEEEE IS FUCKING BACK BABY!!!!!!!! Life has meaning again

[@charlestownsend9280]

If we're being objective, I'd take once and future over whatever that was we got on TV for the 60th,

[@aidanwhite2637]

ITS BACK. THE GREATEST SERIES ON KZbin BABY

[@jedisalsohere]

oh man i have MISSED THIS

[@neilshenton1834]

Oh my giddy aunt, I LOVE Broke Cannon! 😍 Continuity is for squares, man... ✌️😂👍

[@goosephillip3892]

YEAAAAAAAH!!!!!!! New broke CANOOOOOOOON!!!!!!!!

[@soldierfordavis8615]

Broke cannon 😎

[@DanisThoughts]

great video as always

[@Concreteowl]

Paul Magrs is a genius.

[@slateoffate9812]

12:06 Why does everyone think the Timeless Child is a god? The Mouri are more godlike than the child. The Doctor is just older than even they can imagine and a protagonist, not a god. I wish the Timeless Child wasn't so hated on. It's better than the Doctor being Leela's kid sent back in time. Edit: I'm out of spoons to give, so if you're going to harass me for liking the Timeless Child then kindly ZIP IT. I've heard it already, and I'm sick of the oversaturated hate.

[@najawin8348]

No, it's substantially worse than The Other. Genetic determinism is bad.

[@slateoffate9812]

@@najawin8348 I'm not following? Genetic determinism?

[@slateoffate9812]

@@najawin8348 Okay, looked it up and it's basically Nature Vs. Nurture on the side of nature? Is that right? I don't see what that has to do with the Timeless Child.

[@najawin8348]

@@slateoffate9812 The Timeless Child is literally genetic determinism all the way through. The Doctor is a hero because they're a hero. They keep being a hero, no matter how many times their memory is wiped. It's not their actions that make them special, it's their genes. It's the most disgusting approach to the character that we've ever had in the show, truly.

[@slateoffate9812]

@@najawin8348 That's not genetics, that's the Doctor being a protagonist, and there's many versions of the Doctor who aren't good, not just the Valeyard.

[@quintencrook6068]

Oh no...my Canon...it's broken....

[@willgillies5670]

Paul Magrss version of Doctor Who is ....yes ....it needs to be experinced

[@StarsInYourMultitude]

Woo! Some Iris Wildthyme, let's go!!

[@toast99bubbles]

Oh wow, you invited the hottest guy on Facebook to the Verdigris reading. Exciting.

[@Spider8Crak]

LITERALLY YESTERDAY I WAS ASKING THIS TO COME BACK, LET'S FUCKING GOOOO

[@jorge9285]

Broke Canon! I needed this!

[@NoButIGotCheezWhiz]

I knew. I knew it would be back after this last episode.

[@PapaLuge]

LORE TIME 🎉🎉🎉

[@samedmonds2239]

LOVE this so much

[@group2gaming]

This video made me search through my collection and im happy to say i do in fact have Verdigris. Ill be reading that now, thanks for the reccomend.

[@AWW8472]

I'm sure you'll make a video about how RTD STOLE YOUR IDEA FOR MAKING THE DOCTOR SPLIT IN TWO! Maybe not exactly what you envisioned, yet. I am expecting Tenant's Doctor to do a heel turn and become the Valeyard, at least for the next season finale.

[@plantainsame2049]

They said the same thing about the other david tenant clone It's not like There's only one doctor copy There's literal dozens of him Just like there's dozens of the final doctor[ Your merlin's curators ect] My personal head cannon on that second thing. Is that the doctor just after A while is just constantly like no way. I'm leaving this alone and just assumes that he's going to die next time constantly

[@slateoffate9812]

I liked the Timeless Child reveal, and don't harass me over it! I've heard them all!

[@creed8712]

Which one was that. The reveal that the doctor was important to ancient time lord history or the reveal that the time lords are scumb bags. Never thought either were particularly groundbreaking

[@slateoffate9812]

@@creed8712 So? I still like it better than the Other, and I'm a sucker for protagonist trauma. It also solves the regeneration problem in the long term.

[@keit99]

​@@slateoffate9812yeah the one definite good thing coming from it

[@TheDanishGuyReviews]

It's a Christmas miracle! I thought Broke Canon was only coming back next year!

[@PuppetSquid]

I love multi-doctor(who commentator) episodes!

[@Alphadanielmon]

When the Whoniverse most needed him... the writer of the 60th anniversary specials "Davis" has returned

[@abbieboswell2318]

Here day 1 of BC back. Waiting on a full rundown of faction paradox

[@endme1654]

a time lord called Savar switches regenerations at night in the novel The Infinity Doctors

[@Lone_Cyberman_Productions]

I literally bought Verdigris after watching this video and it arrived today, cannot wait to read it

[@activatehalo7763]

Yes!!! Doctor Who needs Broke Canon more than ever!

[@MultiverseMediaSpace]

Na, I missed you! Good to hear from you again. ^_^

[@tommarsdon5644]

"more snakes on a different plane"

[@dsdots]

And I'm sure the book has a perfectly reasonable explanation for Iris looking like Jo, this is Doctor Who after all, in what world would something be confusing

[@sacrificiallamb4568]

Oh, no, that was a completely different thing, I think they finally mentioned it in a Big Finish? She didn't look like Jo then, from what I know.

[@plantainsame2049]

Why does the second doctor look like salamander Or the word doctor like john hurt There have a multiple references to alien And he's mentioned by name In torchwood

[@sacrificiallamb4568]

The Doctor doesn't like the idea of Alien, clearly they saw it. Regenerating into War, who wanted to distance himself from The Doctor, chose to be an actor from Alien? I don't know. Maybe War got bored and started acting halfway through.@@plantainsame2049

[@derianimp]

WE ARE SO BACK

[@group2gaming]

4:10 makes me wonder, what if radiation doesnt technically kill the doctor but just makes him fast-forward to the next incarnation?

[@TheSenateOfficial]

IT’S BACK

[@neet2083]

return of the king

[@stanley5745]

Petitioning for a Joe Brennan Whotrack, I think he's one of the only collaborators that hasn't got one yet

[@rogergibson8925]

This was hilarious. I was always overjoyed to see a new book by Paul Magrs, who went to ludicrous extremes to entertain Doctor Who fans, and for me was one of, if not the best Doctor Who BBC author. Read his books, everyone. Just be prepared for insanity 😆

[@akshaytrayner1960]

Finally it’s back

[@malloyka]

BROKE CANON IS BACK !

[@steve-0493]

Dobby, the house elf.. 🤣😂🤣😂🤟😂🤟😂✌️🍻

[@adamntcaponewholikesbigcoo1749]

So, if we take timeless child gage thing as canon sort off And it deposited the doctor as a baby or whatever Does that mean that a alien device actually did what it did Gave the doctor superpowers technically He/ They is doctor who I don’t know the Ben 10 lyrics

[@plantainsame2049]

Well, there is no cannon and I'm pretty sure. The child just fell through a magic space hole I personally like to think they intentionally went into the magic space hole because it's the same old story that you were some powerful being in another dimension and decided. Fuck that and ran away Then they grew up to be a founder of time Lord society said. Fuck that and ran away They were reborn as a time lord noble said fuck that and ran away They were Eventually well respected and actually enjoyed their time on Earth as a part of tunit. But even then they couldn't stay so they ran away The doctor stays somewhere becomes Is super important and then gets bored and runs away

[@TheNerdstalgicPodcast]

Im completely excited to see broke cannon back! ❤ I've missed this series, also where can i read the book you mentioned here? 😀

[@Stephen-Fox]

...You referring to it as de-digivolved caused me to crack up more than it had any right to.

[@GeneralSpooda]

Well not legal substances often result in mental images like cover of verbatis and the timey wimey stuff does feel like broke cannon

[@riolusx2926]

I’m at 8:21 and did this guy try to pull a umineko?

[@codibooker5091]

BROKE CANON BABYYYYYYYYYY

[@aaronchidester806]

If they wanted to bring back the 2nd Doctor in the show, who do you think they could cast to do Troughton justice?

[@lucasparadox6823]

Honestly, i don't think anyone could match that man's comedic gremlin energy. That Doctor was about to be executed, and was chill once they said they'd let him choose what he looks like next...

[@SamyulDavis]

Matt Smith. Seriously, I think that'd be an unfair role. You watch 2 to see which unpredictable choices Troughton will make scene to scene.

[@b4billy27]

Not enough times. Thats how many times troughton has been the doctor

[@danb8243]

The three doctors but the three who-tubers

[@charlesjunior5087]

0:29 what comic is that??

[@gerrardjones28]

My only problem with this is, what will the Doctor's that don't have their companions left which is most if not all of them apart from 14 do, obviously go and find some more but must be hella confusing for them

[@plantainsame2049]

I mean usually with degeneration they eventually revert back to them current doctor This bigeneration seems to be the only time one has split off not counting the meta crisis

[@abbieboswell2318]

JAY EXCI FUCK YES!!!!

[@paleoleft]

oh shit ive just been reqatching broke canon :3

[@DWboy14]

6:20 AMONG US