Habsburg Catastrophe: The (Staggering) Siege of Mantua 1629 | Thirty Years' War

[@SandRhomanHistory]

Recently, our videos have become so time consuming that we can’t keep up with making the same number of videos without them paying parts of our bills. So, we created a Patreon account. If you think our work is valuable, then consider donating a small amount to help us out. Link: www.patreon.com/sandrhomanhistory

[@nameunavailable1330]

SandRhoman History have you thought about also uploading your videos to BitChute?

[@TechnologicZb]

Just signed up.

[@HistoryDose]

The research/editing struggle is real! It's actually even hard for us to stick to our monthly post schedule!

[@rujikin]

I do really enjoy the animations on this channel. They make it stand out from every other channel.

[@bobsbigboy_]

Why tho? Get a job

[@vortac4995]

god this channel is criminally underrated

[@stardustcrusaderno.7426]

It's still a young channel, that explains the low number of views.

[@clintmoor422]

they re going to blow up soon i think, enjoy the community while it's still small

[@WalterWhiteFootballSharing]

11,000 in the first day which its only 7pm. People with many interests, subs, and only an hour or so to watch a day might take 4-5-7 days to get to a new video. Myself; Between Science, football, all the various eras of military history, we're talking 100 new videos a day, easy. And a backlog of saved playlists....Not underrated; properly rated, but it takes a long time for everyone to see suggested videos that make them click, explore and subscribe.

[@skizzik121]

I put this channel up there with Invictus History Civilus and Kings and Generals. It's just young that's all. It will get the multiple hundreds of thousands of subs like the older ones

[@Sam-xd9xt]

@@skizzik121 I personally place this channel above those. Feel this is more academically orientated. Less sensationalism and information bias than Kings and Generals. With more detailed writing than History Civilus. Though I really enjoy those channels as well.

[@1987MartinT]

Córdoba: "I have a letter from the Emperor saying you have to let me in." Garrison Commander: "Can I see it?" Córdoba: "Curses! You outsmarted me!"

[@sethheristal9561]

This has something of a Jojo feel to me

[@johncasy5212]

Seth Heristal You thought it was from the Emperor, but it was I, DIO!!!

[@ragnarrahl]

A letter from the emperor, to this gentleman, at this time of year, at this time of day, in this part of the empire, localized entirely within your pocket? Yes. May I see it? No.

[@Peristerygr]

Αnd then Cordoba tried to blast his way in.

[@markhenley3097]

''Can I see it?'' ''Uhhh, no.''

[@mr.personhumanson6871]

I can understand bringing a large number of men in order to deliver an important letter safely, but a canon?! that's not suspicious at all

[@BuildingCenter]

Mr. Person Humanson It's their best shot at airmail.

[@midshipman8654]

Aleksa Petrovic this. They only kept firing because the defenders never picked up the parchment taped to each cannon ball.

[@devs.4254]

I absolutely LOVE your style of storytelling with the animated drawings. So much better than shots of a Total War game or simple squares on a map (you have those too, but they're not the primary way of telling the story), and it really helps you picture how the war looked. Such great work, please keep it up!

[@JayzsMr]

The squares are legendary

[@TheSoonToBePurgedJackMeHoff55]

Thanks for letting us know you lack any kind of imagination

[@gabrielvanhauten4169]

Actually a quarantine refernce that makes sense. Thanks for not blowing that up! The neutral swiss ey ;)

[@TechnologicZb]

I really appreciate the work you do to bring light to this overlooked era.

[@rantymcrant-pants9536]

He said forgetting many a popular story is set in exactly this era.

[@zamirroa]

That is because anglo world ignored this period

[@napoleonibonaparte7198]

Always annex Montferrat in the start

[@hashimbokhamseen7877]

post made by eu4 gang

[@sauronmordor7494]

:)

[@thegrantkennedy]

No, first you have to call the diet, seize crownland, pick your rivals, THEN annex montferrat

[@Gokaes]

I always Annex Ferrara at the start Monteferrat second

[@MasonGreenWeed]

Then coalitions called upon you

[@trajanic3623]

In my humble opinion, out of all the "military history" channels on KZbin, this stands out as probably the best. The content is informative and relevant and is detailed. I welcome too, the effort of listing the Bibliography for each episode, although I note not always listing all the sources used. I would like to see more content from @sandrhoman_history albeit same quality but if it takes longer to publish then so be it. I prefer quality over quantity any day.

[@paulredinger5830]

You’re kidding? It’s about the siege of Mantua, and we’re half way through the video. So far nothing about the siege yet. All the junk about why is irrelevant to the actual siege itself.

[@ryneboy3845]

@@paulredinger5830 a siege is only as important as the reason for the siege. Honestly why care for history if you don’t want to know the real details?

[@robbier6389]

Wow, more people probably died in the conflict over Mantua than actually lived there...

[@besacciaesteban]

@David McConville Welcome to the grinder, Buddy.

[@kaloarepo288]

It was during the siege of Casale that cardinal Mazarin(Mazzarino) acting as a diplomat for pope Urban VIII demonstrated his diplomatic skills and preventing a bloodthirsty battle by pretending a truce had been arranged already but it had not thus saving many lives!Subsequently Mazarin entered the service of Richelieu and Louis XIII succeeding Richelieu as chief minister and becoming the de facto ruler of France.

[@marru6977]

Hey, I'm italian and from Mantua, and let me tell you, the Minchio River at 10:15 (only italians can understand) really got me there 🤣🤣🤣🤣. Great video btw👍👍

[@orimoreau3138]

damn, this channel seems to be an absolute gold mine for entry level history nerds like myself, thanks to Paradox and EUIV I got Interested in the history outside ww2 and thanks to this channel I will actually absorb some fascinating, real events that happened, smooth voice and cute little animations included, and all for free. Internet can be kind of cool sometimes subbed, cheers

[@mariushunger8755]

Amazing comprehension of two very intriguing sieges! Love that

[@oliverc.2385]

I stumbled upon your channel today. As a student of history, I applaud your narrative skills, visual representation and historical accuracy! This channel is very underrated imo and deserves a lot more praise and subs! You've gained yourself a subscriber. Keep it up! You should be very proud of the content you've created so far! Much love from Flanders, Belgium!

[@ArtilleryAffictionado1648]

Just read about this yesterday!! in a book called Thirty Year's War: Europe's tragedy. It's a heavy book and without previous knowlege of a shitload of stuff a regular person just won't get it. But it's a joy for me and seeing this particular chapter in a video explained with pictures is so damn cool. Altho i think you underplayed Charles II and his prank of epic proportions of taking the city without anyone's authority and self proclaiming himself duke of Mantua. He was a nobody in France and just went on to pull this stunt. Thank you again, love your work!!

[@Harrassmus]

The last time I was this early, central Europe was all aflame in the thirty-years war

[@clintmoor422]

u one of them funny one aren't u

[@5th_decile]

I want to congratulate this channel with its interesting content. Also, bringing renaissance-style paintings in motion is truly an artistic untapped market and your channel does a marvelous pioneering job into opening this up!

[@nestorvaccaro5047]

This story Is also reported in a very important Italian book "I promessi sposi" of the Italian writer Alessandro Manzoni

[@raptorjesues1445]

dont remember me...

[@nestorvaccaro5047]

@@raptorjesues1445 why? Don't you like it?

[@samiamrg7]

Broke: Mexican Standoff Woke: Italian Stalemate

[@ShahjahanMasood]

The Italian Wars are extremely interesting. It was a literal battleground.

[@Apokalypse456]

thats the case with 99.9% of wars in history. they had battles. on the ground.

[@ChevyChase301]

@@Apokalypse456 much of Portugal, Spain, France, and Sweden would not have seen war in centuries at this point.

[@istvansipos9940]

04:09 after some videos and all the battle experience from them, you, sir, have a tough as nail veteran badass, just firing from the hip. I loved that. And the video, obviously.

[@jonahpool3610]

Your analysis of sieges is so well done. I am enthralled. Thank you!

[@colwem]

You say “the city was already well prepared for a siege...” and list all these little things done to improve the fortifications but just completely ignore the most incredible piece of defensive engineering of diverting a river so that it practically engulfs your city creating the mother of all moats! It’s like an inland Venice! Holy shit!

[@washubrain]

Great video! I'd say the history of the North Italian Dukedoms is fascinating and underrated.

[@noemiekramer7699]

I love the sound design of this one! The music really underlines those arcs of suspense!

[@stanleysmith7551]

It's nice to see detailed videos on lesser known conflicts. Some ideas for the future: the Cleves succession, Brandenburg/Prussia's Rhineland territories. French annexation of Lorraine/Lothringen, the Saxon-Polish personal union in the 18# century...

[@stephanrichard7006]

Best video yet! Keep up the great work

[@benjiunofficial]

Garrison Commander: "If you were sent here by the Emperor, where's your letter?" Córdoba: "Letter? We don't need no letter. I don't have to show you any stinkin' letter!"

[@brainyskeletonofdoom7824]

You are nailing almost all of the pronunciations! Well done!

[@pierreardisson7551]

0:13 is that the castle of Fénis?

[@clintmoor422]

those bois were fancy AF back then.

[@stevencooper4422]

Cavalier

[@leiferikkson2616]

whizz1der Lmfao 😂😂

[@justme6094]

@whizz1der y are u geh?

[@justme6094]

@whizz1der u thicc?

[@justme6094]

@whizz1der who sehs am geh?

[@heinswanepoel651]

Absolute banger as always

[@Markfr0mCanada]

I have to admit, I lose track of who is who in these descriptions. I think some sort of visual reference would be useful. Even just a stack of flags or portraits on either side of the screen depicting who is on which side.

[@cesareborgia6431]

I love these videos about little known battles/wars/sieges

[@salocin9695]

Your videos are awesome and very well made! Thanks!

[@felipedasilva8722]

*I live in Mantua, called Mantova now, amazing city* 🇮🇹

[@philRminiatures]

Once again, superb illustration efforts, whether in the animations or in the family tree, useful to follow the complicated game of alliances and magnificently done...😍😍😍

[@SandRhomanHistory]

Once more: thank you for the kind comment. I'm super happy the content is well received!

[@crazzywasp]

Those "...entered the stage" animations were amazing!

[@alexhatfield4448]

These videos are so good it's alarming.

[@hamarbiljungskile8953]

Well Crusader Kings it is for today.

[@Dayvit78]

It's such a Crusader Kings' situation, but it's an EUIV timeline.

[@alblaka8852]

Hah, I just linked this video in our Discord that plays CKII and EUIV, because this story perfectly encapsulates how warfare (and diplomacy) worked back then.

[@gabem3251]

Looking at the defenses of Mantua in the 17th century makes me respect Napoleon’s siege of it even more.

[@jagpack18]

New favorite channel

[@Jack1rules]

A few centuries later and it’s no longer an island

[@matthewconradi1840]

Yeah I was wondering about that, turns out that was partly artificial from redirecting rivers, so they later decided to reverse that to get some more space

[@antonvernooy6186]

Just found this channel I really like your style and the unknown battles and people.

[@raffarafano]

Wow, finally someone speaking about my hometown and its history!

[@brianoneil9662]

Ah yes. Grapeshot. The Germans discovered how unlovely that fruit tastes.

[@matteoaievola8643]

This happened to in the American Civil War in a important battle where the union turned two cannons into shotguns and dessimated the troops of the confederacy

[@Nyx_2142]

@@matteoaievola8643 It has happened in just about every conflict including cannons in close range.

[@Chrononauts]

New Video at last! Great Job Guys!

[@invinciblemindset6609]

Your research is so accurate because you realy on actual facts and historian.

[@j27340]

@sandrhomanhistory ... does your map of Spain include Portugal?

[@mynamejeb8743]

imagine being a real estate agent at this era. "as you can see this is a fertile piece of land, you can grow crops, turn it into pastures and its currently below the market price, since the Spanish and French Crown has claim on it, so should we proceed?"

[@kamelmeddah9074]

Another amazing video as usual

[@napolien1310]

8:28 The swag of the guy who hold a spear with one hand behind

[@ardalla535]

Seemed interesting to me that Venice did not get involved in this conflict. It would seem natural for Venice to want to absorb the Duchy, but, apparently, they had no interest. Venice was not even in a war with the Ottomans at this time, so who knows? A search revealed nothing.

[@shawnbeckett1370]

Awesome as always

[@andreattafabio]

interesting topic.. vids are getting better with every upload.. fantastic work brother!

[@jameskelman9856]

Well done ! Thanks !

[@uncle1839]

Song at 10:24 ?

[@oldsongsnew8797]

There's the substantial ruins of a bridge/damn in Villaggio Sul Mincio ,I believe was built to deprive Mantua of water....not sure if it was involved during this siege or something else...still fascinating history around this area of Veneto

[@joetanaka6446]

Excellent story well produced 🎬📽🎙

[@pekoro70]

Mincio river! (Mincho): Minkio sounds like Dick river in Italian. Also, treaty of Kerasco. CH is always like architecture in Italian

[@SandRhomanHistory]

thanks. My Italian classes were back in middle school (only 1 year), I guess I forgot everything.

[@Blazetoamaze]

This is great, extremely clear

[@TheSharadwaador]

Love this channel

[@SB-129]

-5:54 -"Is there someone else up there we can talk to?" -"No, now go away or I will taunt you with basic scrutiny a second time..."

[@movingwater7312]

Claudio Monteverdi lived and composed in Mantua under the patronage pf Vicenzo Gonzaga. around this time.

[@seanmcmullen4274]

i love the animations in your videos

[@oliviermosimann6931]

Yeah, the title deserves the word 'staggering'. I was unaware of this siege. It is now on my personal 'epic list'.

[@MemeMand1996]

If you're Italian and had to lough when you heard 'minchio' river like this comment :')

[@arx3516]

it's a dangerous river, it is inhabited by the ferocious padulo fish!

[@carta8399]

@@arx3516 Ah the dangerous padulo, he will always do bad things to anyone passing by

[@tigrecito48]

I think I remember watching an old movie called Louis & the Huguenots it has skeletons & a cyclops...

[@robertofrascari3048]

Great Job

[@DolanOk]

Love your videos!

[@2ears1mouth786]

Fascinating!!! God, these people lived different lives. Some of this is straight out of the D'Artagnan books, when they went to battle. Same era. Wow.

[@Fieramosca492]

Italian Fortresses are always a spectacle to see!!

[@CeBagutte]

anyone else bingeing these episodes?

[@LykanosAquilae]

Thanks for this video on the story of my city 💪🏻

[@gasmonkey1000]

Have you done other videos featuring Ambrogio Spinola?

[@SarudeDanstorm]

What is the music you used in the end - fading into The Hapsburg Catastrophe? Great video by the way, I have a personal love for history, and this is the one era of warfare in history I have never gotten to know much about.

[@Lodov]

Cool, Fénis Castle. i visited it last year

[@kets4443]

Could you do more actions of this era, such as some actions Thirty/Eighty Years' Wars after 1635, and more colonial campaigns?

[@lukeaspa5664]

Why do with have the history channel, THIS IS THE REAL HISTORY CHANNEL!

[@cortexavery1324]

I love how in every videos, when they repair, they're not hammering nails but screws...

[@pikeshotBattles]

A complicated situation within a complicated situation...

[@SandRhomanHistory]

hey, shoot me an email, if your interest in a collab. I commented on one of your videos but i haven't heard anything yet. i can find an email of your on your page, that's why I simply commented. My email is displayed in the info tab! cheers!

[@Uncle-Smart-Alec]

Those poor soldiers on both sides fighting and dying for which family member would triumph.

[@samsonsoturian6013]

People back then would support politicians all the same as they do today

[@pandookrb]

Where have I heard this music before?

[@Peristerygr]

Cordoba: "I have a letter from the Emperor" Garrison guard: "May I see it?" Cordoba: "Of course. There you are. Canons, fire at will!!!"

[@giacomo2661]

couldnt help myself from laughing when heard "minchio river" which sounds a little bit like "dick river". try with "mincho" where cho sound is the same as in chobany

[@steveclapper5424]

With those outfits on it's really hard to take them seriously.

[@peanutwars]

2:01 look at this Silly guy using a pistol on the battlements

[@artcz8109]

Please do about the Swedish Military Reforms

[@gudea5207]

The walking animation makes sense with normal soldiers but it’s so creepy with the noblemen.

[@bypyros1933]

Now I want to see a video about the Miracle of Empel, the siege of Amberes or the siege of Breda.

[@abbba2007]

Just add either quarantine or plague into the title. The video is great, I'm really sad how little views it received.

[@karolykiszely300]

STAGGERING STAGGERING STAGGERING!

[@donkdump8807]

That Mantuan fortress looks insane

[@codynasty7511]

Just a small historical correction, Spain actually did want to involve itself in the war because it’s de facto leader, the Count Duke of Olivares, believed that annexing the disputed lands would open up “The Spanish Road” which would be a route for easier reinforcement to his soldiers in the Netherlands from Italy. So Spain’s involvement was an aggressive policy on the part of its leader. (Source: The Count Duke of Olivares: Statesman in the Age of Decline, Jon Elliot) Spinola actually argued against this policy vehemently, citing the Dutch War, but Olivares won the debate.

[@CCCW]

how does this channel have only 71k subs??

[@invinciblemindset6609]

Could you make about medieval bathhouse?

[@gg_gameryt]

Because of this siege in italy we now have fo study all of Manzoni's Promessi Sposi, rip

[@marcobagut]

Was Maria a bit bold?

[@marcusaurelius830]

Umberto Eco's The island of the day before is why i am here.He tells much about the Siege of Casale in this book.