Scheduled Caste आरक्षण में Muslims और Christians को हिस्सा क्यों नहीं?

[@desistarktm7270]

They left Hinduism because they feel it made them backward. If they feel so empowered by militant or missionary faiths, why do they still need quotas at the cost of high Merit Hindus.?

[@adma7298]

Religion is matter of belief. Ethnicity, caste, social class is reality. Thats how others treat us accordingly. Religion can be changed. Ethnicity caste social class can not be changed.

[@adma7298]

Caste tribe lineage are permanent so quota should be permanent

[@desistarktm7270]

@@adma7298 sorry bro this is Hindustan not Pakistan.

[@knowmore4964]

​@@adma7298no it can't be

[@adma7298]

Please please listen to me. Reservation on religious basis will eradicate castism, which hindu muslims Christians Sikhs Buddhists are denying as part of their religions. Everyone will be happy happy

[@MrDragoo1]

Hindus have caste.. Muslims don't..so why caste based reservation for Muslims??

[@sreyanshuchaterjee3962]

90% OBC reservations are taken by Muslims.

[@gardeningmatters555]

Dumb Muslims too have caste

[@sreyanshuchaterjee3962]

@@fusion7837 by religion muslim and by culture hindu?

[@ChandranPrema123]

​@@fusion7837if Muslims want Reservations let they reconvert to Hinduism . Any way Hindu Re Converts have no Caste

[@adma7298]

Caste base reservation should be removed and covert it to religion base will resolve all problems

[@adj33]

If they're leaving the dharmic fold they don't need reservation.

[@arthuravalon914]

That's not for hindus to decide.

[@tushar-lf8eu]

@@arthuravalon914 thats what hindus will decide go and cry

[@biggdaddyy]

@@arthuravalon914only hindu decides in this country , ok ? So go and cry

[@adj33]

@@arthuravalon914 ofcourse it is. Christianity and Islam were also ruling classes, so no they don't get reservation.

[@sparta5018]

​@@arthuravalon914 Its like you started fucking someone else but still want your ex to feel sorry for you, provide for you, and put your need first. No boy, Once you started fucking outside you are not my concern.

[@sparta5018]

One question for all of those converted people demanding reservation- Who is Greatest between Baba Saheb BR Ambedkar and Muhammad or Jesus for you guys?

[@Anup_BHU]

मैं जाति से ब्राह्मण हूं, इस मुद्दे पर मैं अपने दलित भाइयों के साथ हूं, मुस्लिम और क्रिस्चियन को दलितों का हिस्सा नहीं मिलना चाहिए जय भीम भारत माता की जय वंदे मातरम ❤ दलित हमारे भाई हैं ❤ दलित भी हिंदू ही हैं

[@Soldierl8c]

क्यों नहीं मिले जरूर मिले इसी झोल झल से खत्म होगा आरक्षण

[@vip129870]

No one talks about violence on Hindus whether it’s in India or within Pakistan or Bangladesh. Hindu society needs to reform and attract converts.

[@uttamsingh6705]

Dilip mondal tryed bring hindu scriptures etc without citing and significant one which can be found in hindu households because there was no one to check him but arvind set the context very clearly, awesome

[@mohammadinamullah9380]

Muslims mein Untouchability hai lekin ye Untouchability SC, ST, aur kuch low cast Muslims ke khilaf hai. Kuch high cast Muslims to Brahmins ko bhi Untouchable samajhte hain.

[@studentknowledge123]

जो दलित हिंदू से सिख, बोध, जैन बने हैं उन्हें भी तो SC आरक्षण मिलता हैं । बोध, जैन, सिख में भी तो जातिव्यवस्था नहीं है । तो मुस्लिम , ईसाई को क्यों नहीं मिलना चाहिए ।

[@Rajeev_Bauddh]

Thanks both ❤️ Arvind sir and Dilip sir♥️♥️💙💙💙💙✍️✍️

[@Hawks_Eye69]

Islam and Christianity do not discriminate on the basis of caste. A large number of the untouchables were observed into Islam n Christianity in the pretext of eradicating untouchability and improving their socio-economic conditions. Over the years, their claims have proved to be empty vessel. Appeasement for muslim will be detrimental to BJP.

[@drprabhatjaiswal542]

Intelligent discussion 🎉🎉🎉

[@VijeDerm]

Amazing insights and observations. Muslim and christians are a caste less religious entities. These communities are about 25 crore population of India and imagine the consequences of these religious communities usurping the SC/ST reservation. SC ST reservation is for the deprived class in the “broader” Hindu society

[@MihirS84]

ST reservation is already being given to tribal people who have been converted in staggering numbers by Christian missionaries

[@rahulranjan1338]

​@@MihirS84vhi to sabko bas fayda dekhna hai

[@chitranjankumar-lb3nl]

Despite partition on the basis of religion by nehru and Gandhi Muslims remained in India to create new Pakistan and voices are being raised in their support in such a way that no other religious people live in India except them

[@adma7298]

Remove caste base reservation and implement merit and equality

[@pboy6670]

​@@adma7298muslims can get out from here

[@leonelmessi9631]

​@@adma7298why

[@adma7298]

@@leonelmessi9631 it is the root cause of communalism and division. The same reservation in bristish time resulted in partition. People think their birth right for jobs despite merit and eligibility

[@leonelmessi9631]

@@adma7298 caste remove first

[@Shrvp]

A deeply worrying scenario is, if under pressure from European and Islamic countries and from "left Liberal secular" diaspora, Muslims and Christians are included in SC and ST list, its signals death of Hinduism. Even after conversion the reservation is maintained then we will witness mass conversion. Of the scale not imagined. Money pouring in from these rich countries will make Hindu political minority and irrelevant and balkanization of India will not be far off. This is beginning of destruction of Hindu faith, culture and society.

[@Endrumpf]

True

[@amitdutt9911]

dalit muslim ko reservation Dene par unhe dohra labh milega ek minority ke taur par aur dusra scheduled caste ke taur par

[@amitdutt9911]

koi Dalit dalit isliye hai kyonki woh cast system ka shikar hai. cast system ka relation Hinduism se hai. agar dalit convert ho jata hai toh uska claim ST quota par nahi banta becoz woh toh Hindu raha hi nahi. convert dalit ka claim ATI pichhda warg mein banta hai

[@mdsalimrampuri5460]

प्रोफेसर रविकांत और प्रो बद्रीनारायण अरजाल मुसलमानों को अनुसूचित जाति का दर्जा देने का समर्थन किया है। जय अरजाल।

[@PrakashKumar-uz1hi]

इनके हिसाब से जिन्होंने Sc St discrimination एफ आई आर दर्ज करवाई हो और साबित हुआ हो कि उनके साथ डिस्क्रिमिनेशन हुआ उनको ही रिजर्वेशन मिले।।

[@RealKingOfCricket]

बहुत ही इन्फॉर्मेटिव वीडियो मंडल सर। उम्मीद है आप फेसबुक और ट्वीटर पर भी ट्रोल का रोल छोड़कर हमें पढ़ाने-समझाने का काम ज्यादा करेंगे।

[@mergoobalam217]

If a hindu dalit converts to muslim how can be snatched his reservation rights while he is still a dalit . His faith may be anything , but you cannot excluded him from dalit.

[@mdsalimrampuri5460]

अरविंद कुमार अनुसूचित जाति का दर्जा के विषय में गोलमोल बातें कर रहे हैं।

[@Chetukundu]

जब तक हक नहीं मांगा तब तक इस्तेमाल किया , भाई बोला और जब हक मांगने लगे तो मुसलमान दुश्मन हो गए? गद्दार हो गए ? जय भीम जय मीम का नारा लगाने वाले कहां गए ? कुछ तो लाज रखी होती भाईचारे की ।

[@ApolloGemini11]

Arvindji rocks!

[@anilgautam393]

Kitni asani se aap samjhate ho arvind sir

[@anilumale6966]

At present majority of Dalit Cristian used their old Hindu identity for schedule cast reservations why not do legal to their practices because they are Hindu in certificates and Cristian in society 😢😢😢😢😢

[@sanjivgupta1418]

Because Islam and Christianity claim to be casteless religions.

[@dogaredeemer2711]

professor saab is missing one point- reservation not based on religion but is based on a historical fact of discrimination. my question - is muslims community now a discrimated group. and on the basis of discrimation should they qualify

[@TheJediPrince]

The Principle of Caste Reservation is basis on Casteism in Hinduism. Islam and Christianity claim they don't have caste and convert. Then how can you ask for Reservation based on Caste.

[@Shrvp]

Fascinating discussion. Insightful and well researched. Unbiased. Special thanks to Dilipji for conducting one of the best analysis of this complex, vexed and multi layered issue. Dilipji never interuupted the flow, asked difficult questions and encouraged the flow.

[@anilumale6966]

Need to study 📖 why many cast wants schedule cast and schedule tribe status 😅😅😅😅😅

[@vip129870]

I think India will reach above 100% reservations with its ridiculous politics 😂

[@Amitparashar14]

Why do you bring hinduphobic Dilip,he is biased.

[@rishiraaj.580]

Biggest Share Of Conversion Budget Come To India. This Is Alarming. 😮

[@---RAHUL]

अगर कोई दलित क्रिश्चियन बनता है तो उसकी जाति क्या रहती होगी जाति में तो क्रिश्चियन नहीं लिख सकता है क्योंकि वह क्रिश्चियन तो धर्म है यानी वह जाति से दलित ही होगा। वह दलित क्रिश्चियन ही कहलाएगा पर उसे आरक्षण नहीं मिलेगा । दलित आरक्षण लेने के लिए हिंदू होना जरूरी है

[@amanahlawat7170]

fruitfull episode

[@anilsaras2879]

Professor Dilip mandal my Hero

[@HR45Indri]

Such a waste of time, if want reservation reconvert

[@rishiraaj.580]

Do More Episodes With Arvind Kumar Sir 🙏

[@chitranjankumar-lb3nl]

I think only sc and st people should get reservation and other people should be removed from the list

[@neilbhatt7096]

And yet brahmins excel in all fields without any reservation or benefits.

[@ajaysingh-fn4xe]

Muslim aur Christian hamarey harijan bhaoyon ka haq marna chahti hai taki conversion asani se ho jaye , bahut hi acha discussion raha aap dono ko bahut bahut sadhuwad

[@Rockstar.68]

No it shouldn't be

[@rishiraaj.580]

Sabse Jada Convert Hinduo Ko Kia Jata Hai. This Should Stop Permanently Now. 😐

[@inderjeetsinghmehra381]

Sir you are doing Excellent work & good explanation by Prof. Dilip Mandal Sir , Try to listen, educate yourself and all. Best wishes 🙏🙏

[@fullaranag]

Another question, how will a myslim or christian prove that he belonged to untouchable community before his ancestors converted?

[@killeridea1685]

Religion change karne se cast change nhi hoti.. Eg hindi me teli cast or muslim me bhai teli cast hai.. . Or untouchability cast based hoti hai religion based nhi..

[@fullaranag]

@@killeridea1685 I thought Islam and Christianity are so mahan.... casteless and classless... as a minority you enjoy enough benefits... why do you need further reservation... Those should be reserved only for those who, despite hardship,were true to their society and remained in the Hindu fold.

[@parvadhami980]

Then why convert in the first place?

[@PrakashKumar-uz1hi]

जब हिंदू शब्द टेरिटोरियल है इंडियन क्रिश्चियन एंड मुस्लिम को एड करने में क्या दिक्कत है, ई डब्लू एस में सभी को एड किया है, इनको भी एड करो।। ये एक्स बुद्धिस्ट है फिर एक्स हिंदू, इंगलैंड से थोड़ी आए है।

[@desistarktm7270]

If you give quotas to militant and missionary faiths, Hindustan banega Pakistan. With full support from liberals & foreign funds, Militant and missionary faiths are ready to swallow Hinduism if there's no resistance called Hindutva.

[@anilumale6966]

Many Hindu 🕉 community members belongs to schedule cast in one state and obc in other states for example Dhobi cast comeing in schedule cast in Bihar and obc in maharashtra 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢

[@sunilkumarsharma8002]

Shandar

[@nazaimohamammdi5488]

अरविंद foreign से PhD कर रहे हैं। इनकी pronunciation बहुत गलत है। यह कही से PhD research Scholar नही लग रहे हैं।

[@pritamkumar-wy2uk]

Sir we should come out from the house and oppose coming decision. Jai bhim 🙏

[@grishmaraj25]

इस जरूरी मुद्दे पर चर्चा करके ज्ञान वर्धन करने के लिए दोनो महानुभावों का बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद 🙏

[@wastetime2]

Schedule cast ke aarkshan me sare hindu including rajput,bhumihar, brahmin, Yadav sbko include karna chahiye 2:03 economic basis pe

[@seekervinod]

For that EWS quota is there

[@wastetime2]

@@seekervinod that is nothing compared to sc st reservation.

[@MahendraKumar-vl3sj]

Well said

[@SAGARKUMAR-dm2he]

ये गलत है आंदोलन होगा 💪💪💪💪💪💪

[@farzanshameem4782]

धोबी, मोची, नट, हलालखोर(भंगी) ये जातियां हिंदुओं व मुसलमानों दोनों में हैं, मुस्लिम castes OBC & हिन्दू, बुद्धिष्ट SC status रखती हैं, बाक़ी ईसाइयों में converted लोग हैं mostly.

[@HAFIZGULAMSARWAROFFICIAL]

इनको कुछ भी ज्ञान नही है SC में केवल अछूत नही हैं, धोबी कभी अछूत नही थे

[@rajjarhi1749]

दिलीप मंडल जी जिन्दाबाद

[@mukeshmatre2793]

Véry good debate jai bhim

[@HAFIZGULAMSARWAROFFICIAL]

अरविन्द कुमार जी की सारी बातें संघ की सोंच पर आधारित है हर जगह ग़लत व्यख्या कर निकल रहे हैं और आख़री में कांग्रेस पर आरोप मढ़ कर निकल रहे हैं मोदी सरकार ने भी कमिटी बनाई है तो?

[@Abul-l5h]

The man is defending undefendable

[@ayushmandubey7417]

Ye dilip Mandal apni baat ka contradiction hai. Ye kehta hai ki jaati sirf Hindus m hai or kisi religion m nhi . Toh isse Muslim or Christian ke liye Dalit status kyo chaiye. Dr.Ambedkar ne SC/ST reservation se Muslim or Christian ko bahar rakha tha. Agar aap Hindu dharm tyag na chahte hai toh Dr.ambedkar ke raste par chal kr Buddhist ban jao. Ya Sikh , jain ban jao reservation bhi rahega or Mann ki shanti bhi. Lekin ye Muslim and Christian supporter hai inka kaam bas Hinduo ko Christian, muslim banana hai kyonki uske liye hi inhe paisa milata hai. Arre Bhai Buddhist ban jao. Jaroori hai Muslim hi banna hai. Koi competition hai kya nhi hume bas Christian or Muslims hi banna hai.

[@shashibhushan2992]

Helpful

[@prafullaingole6122]

I asked youtube not to recommend this channel due to its apparent divisive agenda.

[@akhilmehta7875]

Sc reservation toh nhi milega...bol Dena apne baap ko

[@9963589175]

Reservation for sc st in muslims and Christians is nothing but it's just encourages the religious conversions ... actually who ever are converting into Islam or Christianity but kept away from sc st reservations because im those religions their are no caste system ..

[@audiblebooksvideo7340]

TIME TO DO GHARWAPSI FOR RESERVATION .

[@Abul-l5h]

If schedule cast do not have full freedom of religion?.it is objectionable to limit their choice of religious freedom.

[@goldajet4309]

Aarakshan khatm hona chahiye chahe kisi jati ka ho ! Logo ko unki jatiyo ke anupat me hissedari de deni chahiye ! Isse bharat me har tarah ka jhagda khatm ho jayega. !!!

[@anilsaras2879]

❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@dogaredeemer2711]

per professor sab ideology even poor brahmins now shud get reservation

[@contactrelatives9848]

Hinduism have caste discrimination so why should muslim get reservation

[@Abul-l5h]

He is talking illogical.if people from other communities join sc communities there reservation may be increased fro 15% to 20% what is the problem.

[@sunilKumar-mo8fo]

We are missing you arvind sir on Facebook.

[@mdsalimrampuri5460]

Muslims have also castes discrimination and untouchable.

[@sandipkumar2251]

Sc category Wale ko schoolarship nahi aati new rul ke anusar 40 % State government de deti uske baad kendar sarkar se nai milti hai es Kylie koi Idea

[@malasinha6978]

Christen St list me hai. Muslim me Dalit nahi hai ,muslim obc me listed hai.

[@triratanshivsharan4841]

The।great deskshn।jiy Bhim jiybhart Bspjidabad ms

[@knowledgekey4298]

Nat, dhobi ,halalkhor, mehtar, etc caste same muslim me bhi hai inko to sc ka labh milna chahiye

[@akashpriyadarshi9318]

Very educating discussion, gently conducted! Thank you!

[@mohitanand1844]

Muslims and Christians also deserve it. Kehne se kya hota hai ??

[@akhilmehta7875]

Nhi denge...sadak par aa jayenge

[@Abul-l5h]

Land holding, social status past pe depend karta hai,tokiya religion badalne se past badal jaye ga land holding education back ground badal jaye gi.logical nahin hai.reservation badhao but sab ko include karo.

[@AdityaSharma-dk3sq]

If by dear heart the proviso of Constitution which provided for "upliftment" for backward class and Ensure minority rights in such a way to mainstream them in Economy & such other stream drop all the bogus debate of "Dalit Musalmaan" or "Dalit Christian".

[@mdsalimrampuri5460]

Arbindra kumar लिए about SC status.

[@bobbyaxelrod3242]

Why no jain and parsi community in scheduled cast list?

[@sparta5018]

Because they are not Jihadi

[@sparta5018]

Jains are from this land. Parsi are the best performer and contributing people for this country and also they are very few in numbers .

[@bobbyaxelrod3242]

@@sparta5018 allamdulila

[@Victor-y9g1w]

kyonki mulla aur christian mein to koi caste hota nahi.

[@Dost9921]

आप लोग अघोषित रूप से हिंदुत्व को प्रमोट करते है ,और मोदी के caa में और आप में कोई फर्क नही है ,आज तुम्हारे साथ कोई छुवाचूत होता है किया ? केवल तुम्हारे पूर्वजों के साथ छुवाचुत हुए थे उसका फल आज तुमको मिल रहा है लेकिन पहले उन लोगो के साथ छुआछूत होता था जिसके तंग आकर इस्लाम या ईसाई धर्म अपनाना तो किया उनका पूर्वज और अपना जिस्म बदल दिया है !

[@VinodKumar-us7hr]

St convert to islam then their caste status ????

[@relaxmind7826]

🎉🎉🎉🎉👍🏿👍🏿👍🏿👍🏿👍🏿👍🏿👌🏿👌🏿👌🏿

[@tankadhartandi2970]

Sir it is elections essues. Article 25 is to righte rlg N reservations is representative in democracy......

[@tennisonchristopher861]

In order to avoid such complications reservation should be made on proportionate basis of all caste and communities. Both the speakers are promoting a biased narrative on false premises

[@Endrumpf]

Lol. Rice bag... Be happy with rice bags... Reservation only Sanatanis

[@raviprakashbajpai196]

Good discussion. Biggest obstacle in mass converstion of sc/st to islam or christianity by external powers is reservation.

[@MahiraMahira-bf2rk]

To musalmano ko bhi teritorial identity milni chahi kiyunki converted muslim hain

[@arifansari-m9p]

Sir, जरा ये बताइए की कोई दलित अगर मुस्लिम या इसाई बनता है तो, क्या सवर्ण जाति उसे अछूत नहीं समझेगा ? आखिर उसे रहना तो उसी जातिवादी स्वर्ण के बीच। इंसान धर्म नही समाज में रहता है, इसीलिए मुस्लिम और ईसाई के लिए reservation जरूरी है।

[@uddhevhm919]

Agar Savarn Achhut samjhega to phr wo Muslim, Christian bana kyu ? Agar wo Muslim, Christian Society me equal he to phr Savarn jo samjhe use kya matlab ? Wo mandir to nehi jaa raha. Wo masjid, church jayega.

[@arifansari-m9p]

@@uddhevhm919 sawal church masjid janeka nahi hai ,. Sawal chhua chhoot ka hai jo use religion change karne bad bhi face karna padega ....

[@uddhevhm919]

@@arifansari-m9p Uske baad jo chhua chhuth hota he wo religion ki vajah se hota he. Koi Hindu kisi muslim ke sath khana pina mana he. Kyunki non Hindus ko Mlechha mana Jata he. Usme caste angle nehi rehta. Kyunki unko Muslim ya christian ki tarah treat kiya jata ge

[@riyazansari5651]

Kya mazak hai

[@चमेलीबाईनाच्या]

Whole muslim and khrishchan should add in schedule caste. All navbaudh and dalit should convert in to khrishchan.

[@ambition9460]

Ghantol pahle Christian likhna seekh Aur tum jaise Navsanatunni batayenge ki Bhartiyon ko kya karna hai jinka itihaas khud 9th century ke bad astitiva me aaya hai 😜

[@lokanathdigal4335]

Sab scheduled caste logokan jeeban saili saman hen .dharam parivartan se caste parivartan nehin hota hen

[@mdsalimrampuri5460]

Muslims have also castes.

[@akcreation9113]

Ni mile nai to sab convert ho jar ge

[@goldajet4309]

Musalmano ko unki aabadi ke barabar hissa kyo nahi mil raha h. ! Musalman bhi bharat ke nagrik h na ki pakistan ke ! Agar musalmano ko unke % ka hissa koun kha raha h jo unko unke % ki hissedari nahi mil Rahi h. !!!

[@RP-it1zp]

In my opinion it is more appropriate to advocate & endorse the idea of Caste census and proportional representation in all sector including Private sector…i guess it is devious plan to keep engaged masses discussing on who will go where within OBC/SC/ST…so that UC keep enjoying their hegemony & privileges.. We need to be careful from such people…

[@arifansari-m9p]

अंबेडकर ने partition of India में लिखा है, कि मुस्लिम में भी दलित जैसी जातियां हैं। अध्याय 10 मे लिखा है , आप तो अपने मार्गदर्शक को ही नहीं मानते है।

[@arifansari-m9p]

@@RDGaming217 apko challenge hai Qur'an me koi bhi baat inhuman dikha de, or baat social justice ki hai ......

[@uddhevhm919]

@@arifansari-m9p To ap ye bata rahe he ki Muslim Qur'an ko nehi man rahe. To ye religious mamla he.

[@akhilmehta7875]

​@@arifansari-m9pex muslim ko jakar padh le debate Kar Le......hum nhi mante kisi aasmani kitab ko....Ar Nahi kisi messenger ko....HARRIS SULTAN KO DEKH LE Jaha mohd peda hua vaha Saudi Arab m human right m sabse picche hai ....jaha majority m ho desh Barbad nai....

[@arifansari-m9p]

@@uddhevhm919 kaise ye religious mamla hua, insan samaj me rahta hai ye samajik mamla hua...

[@arifansari-m9p]

@@akhilmehta7875 Michael h hart apni kitab me best person me Muhammad saw ko 1 rank or khud ke aradhya ( Jesus ) ko 2 rank par rakha hai ...... Tu bas ex muslim ko sunega jaise ye koi philosopher ho ..... ambedkar ko padle .....