Scholarly Christian Tries His Hardest To Prove Trinity

An very intelligent Christian attempts to make sense of the trinity by positing his ontological argument. This exchange brings to light that no matter how you frame it, the trinity is an impossible square to circle.
FULL DEBATE - • Speakers Corner: [11/0...

[@786carrera]

This is the reason why soo many people are converting/reverting to Islam.

[@yusuf_837]

I hope Joshua becomes a Muslim, may the Almighty guide him, he seems like an intelligent person to accept such a logic which he himself cannot understand.

[@nayeemhoque9303]

And I rate you mohammed hijab for you defending islam through intelect and muscle

[@aishaarshadalam3412]

According to these arguments Christianity is not a monotheistic religion then. It's polytheistic. They're confusing themselves. They say one thing but it completely contradicts another argument.

[@SoldierOfTheDeen]

What about omniscience? Is this not an "essential" attribute? How does he explain Matthew 24:36 where Jesus supposedly said: "But about that day or hour no one knows, not even the angels in heaven, nor the Son,[a] but only the Father." This means that both the Son and the Holy Spirit do not possess the attribute of omniscience because *only the Father knows*.

[@ayy5848]

Inshallah that josh becomes a Muslim, he seems really sincere

[@imran4968]

Mohammed's laugh is so funny. I love it. 😂😂🤣🤣

[@readthebible7429]

Interesting. But please remember that there are Biblical Unitarian Christians who do not believe the doctrine of the Trinity. We are a minority, but we are willing to ask the hard questions and deal with the reality of what the bible meant in the time it was written, not as it was twisted centuries later.

[@FormidableOne]

Joshua is intelligent however is completely lost in regards to how he explains the trinity

[@FormidableOne]

Because it is completely flawed

[@TheTechtimetech]

Trinity makes no sense at all. I think both Joshua and Andrew have left more confused then in the beginning

[@alternative2utube]

I like the brother PhD brother. The man has good adab. May Allah guide him, ameen

[@u2rocks786]

Probably the most knowledgeable Muslim at Hyde Park.

[@adammalik5654]

trinity got this phd student mashed up

[@shameemnassiree2780]

I just don't get why Christians can't answer a simple question which just take 2 seconds.

[@BURHANDAWAHMAN]

The other Christian left his friend 😂😂

[@imran4968]

Brother Mohammed is literally the Elon Musk of the Islam because no matter how smart you are you will still lose to him in a debate.😂😂🤣🤣

[@deryat.3797]

How can the question of "who is God" be that complicated. If I would be interested in Christianity and ask Joshua.. I am kind of sure that I would be out of order after 15 min. Too much information for such a simple question. InshAllah he will find the way to Islam.

[@imran4968]

I hope that Joshua becomes Muslim and brother Mohammed updates us on his statues and possible convert.

[@orphicflaneur]

May Allah guide brother Josh to Islam, He'd be a beast Maa'Shaa Allah

[@peacebeuntoyou8934]

Great content and ending. Well done. Peace.

[@thetruthseeker1234]

Honesty I did not understand the point of the debate. Br Hashim could destroy the Trinity by 5 minutes to them both. Anyway I respect Br Hijab but you need to be more active to hit the factual contradictions from the bible with the trinity concept.

[@MrTechnologyCentral]

Bruh brother Mohammed was about of die of laughter when he tried explaining

[@coolz123123]

I would love for there to be a constant update on you two and what is happening. Maybe even videos about the conversation.

[@DisruptAqib]

Masha'allah keep up the good work, brother.

[@omarhussain5382]

The mental gymanstics is unreal in this one this guy was making shit up on the spot lol and defo did not believe this before this convo

[@nayeemhoque9303]

masha'allah

[@Beeninibee786]

masha'allah for that debate, joshua is an intelligent person and very eloquent..

[@afnan923]

I am here earlyyyyyyyyy third comment!! Love your videos mashAllah. keep doing what you do

[@stubbornmeenu08]

the concept of trinity has been created by christians demslvs...d original ingeel by Allah does not have all dese concepts....there are unitarian christians who dnt bliv in trinity...dis concept is so confusing fr dem n all...

[@JUAN-wu5fp]

Well said Br

[@MohamedAhmed-xy5mk]

Andrews lips are dry as hell.. SUBAHANALLAH!!

[@africafrom6826]

Alhamdulillah.

[@Husayn_]

Both Tanks

[@offline2023aug]

Notes from this video sites.google.com/site/khaledurdawah/home/christianity

[@mog2848]

andrews on a mad 1

[@elizaj1n]

When your a father,son, brother. You make the same decision as the other