Honda Civics and Toyota Corollas You Shouldn’t Buy

Honda Civic vs Toyota Corolla, Which is Better, DIY and car review Scotty Kilmer. Car comparison. Who makes the best compact car. Honda Civic vs Toyota Corolla. Toyota Corolla review. Honda Civic review. Is Honda better than Toyota? Are Honda Civics reliable cars? Are Honda Civics worth buying? Are Toyota Corollas good cars? Car Advice. DIY car repair with Scotty Kilmer, an auto mechanic for the last 53 years.
⬇️Scotty’s Top DIY Tools:
1. Bluetooth Scan Tool: amzn.to/2nfvmaD
2. Mid-Grade Scan Tool: amzn.to/33dKI0k
3. My Fancy (Originally $5,000) Professional Scan Tool: amzn.to/31khBXC
4. Cheap Scan Tool: amzn.to/2D8Tvae
5. Dash Cam (Every Car Should Have One): amzn.to/2YQW36t
6. Basic Mechanic Tool Set: amzn.to/2tEr6Ce
7. Professional Socket Set: amzn.to/2Bzmccg
8. Ratcheting Wrench Set: amzn.to/2BQjj8A
9. No Charging Required Car Jump Starter: amzn.to/2CthnUU
10. Battery Pack Car Jump Starter: amzn.to/2nrc6qR
⬇️Scotty’s Top DIY Tools:
1. Bluetooth Scan Tool: amzn.to/2nfvmaD
2. Cheap Scan Tool: amzn.to/2D8Tvae
3. Professional Socket Set: amzn.to/2Bzmccg
4. Wrench Set: amzn.to/2kmBaOU
5. No Charging Required Car Jump Starter: amzn.to/2CthnUU
6. Battery Pack Car Jump Starter: amzn.to/2nrc6qR
🛠Check out the tools I use and highly recommend ► goo.gl/rwYt2y
🔥Scotty Shirts and Merch ► goo.gl/pTAeca
Subscribe and hit the notification bell! ► goo.gl/CFismN
Scotty on Social:
Facebook ► / scottymechanic
Instagram ► / scotty_the_mechanic
Twitter ► Scottymechanic?la...
This is the people's automotive channel! The most honest and funniest car channel on KZbin. Never any sponsored content, just the truth about everything! Learn how to fix your car and how it works. Get a chance to show off your own car on Sundays. Or show off your own car mod on Wednesdays. Tool giveaways every Monday to help you with your own car projects. We have a new video every day! I've been an auto mechanic for the past 50 years and I'm here to share my knowledge with you.
►Here's our weekly video schedule:
Monday: Tool giveaway
Tuesday: Auto repair video
Wednesday: Viewers car mod show off
Thursday: Viewer Car Question Video AND Live Car Q&A
Friday: Auto repair video
Saturday: Second Live Car Q&A
Sunday: Viewers car show off
►Second Daily Upload Every Afternoon of Live Car Q&A videos as well!
Scotty Kilmer is a participant in the Amazon Influencer Program.
#savagescotty

[@scottykilmer]

I Got a Stolen Honda Civic (Cops Called): kzbin.info/www/bejne/qnrTmGOCp6iqZ6s ⬇️Scotty’s Top DIY Tools: 1. Bluetooth Scan Tool: amzn.to/2nfvmaD 2. Mid-Grade Scan Tool: amzn.to/33dKI0k 3. My Fancy (Originally $5,000) Professional Scan Tool: amzn.to/31khBXC 4. Cheap Scan Tool: amzn.to/2D8Tvae 5. Dash Cam (Every Car Should Have One): amzn.to/2YQW36t 6. Basic Mechanic Tool Set: amzn.to/2tEr6Ce 7. Professional Socket Set: amzn.to/2Bzmccg 8. Ratcheting Wrench Set: amzn.to/2BQjj8A 9. No Charging Required Car Jump Starter: amzn.to/3i7SH5D 10. Battery Pack Car Jump Starter: amzn.to/2nrc6qR ⬇️ Things used in this video: 1. Common Sense 2. 4k Camera: amzn.to/2HkjavH 3. Camera Microphone: amzn.to/2Evn167 4. Camera Tripod: amzn.to/2Jwog8S 5. My computer for editing / uploading: amzn.to/301tYt9 🛠Check out the tools I use and highly recommend ► goo.gl/rwYt2y Subscribe and hit the notification bell! ► goo.gl/CFismN

[@nubwieg]

Beans and burgers

[@youarerightboss]

Toyota>honda

[@kingcraven8056]

@@josephfitzgeraldnsw5794 Thats a Mazda.

[@jingo325]

Honda Civic Type R

[@kingcraven8056]

I have an EG hatch with a N/A K20 so I'm bias. Great little urban gocart.

[@1anthonybrowning]

I think this is the most calm I’ve ever heard Scotty.

[@davejenkins6896]

Yes I really like Scotty much more when he is not shouting

[@MammothBehemoth]

you deserve more likes! ahahaha

[@jzoz]

He's whispering.

[@DuhShazey]

hes usually calm in any video that you do not see him. I like to call them Scotty Documentaries.

[@S3nzubean]

@@DuhShazey scottimentaries

[@Reedom]

Starts from 8:30.

[@GatorPride7]

Thank you!

[@carlbech6047]

I bought a 2009 Corolla brand new, a model that Scotty reports being one of the worst models. To tell you the truth, I have now over 450k miles on it. I change the oil myself, and take good care of it. Now imagine if I had bought a good model LOL 😂

[@josephpuchel6497]

Hey you got the 1 in a million Built on a Wednesday lol

[@goombah_]

ive got 280k on my 2010 lol

[@timothytaylor8082]

That's good to know as a new owner of an 09 with 87k. A lot of the issues it has are not exclusive to it, and being a redesign year it's going to have its quirks. Once the recalls and concerns are taken care of it should be plenty reliable especially if you have the 1.8L engine.

[@zacelkins4516]

I had a 2003 Corolla S and the battery blew up. The car still ran even with a blown battery. One of the most bullet proof cars out there in my opinion.

[@Chazz_US_Marine]

I'll take either one. I have been a loyal Honda customer for 10 plus years, and I'll have no issues owning a Toyota. I still want Honda and Toyota to make one model car together. Honda can do the engine, Toyota can do the transmission, and they both can do the body style and accessories etc...

[@titanjake8640]

I agree!! Acura NSX engine + Honda Tranny or Beefed up Lexus LFA engine + Toyota Asin tranny. You can't go wrong either way

[@garchafpv]

Get Tesla to do the accessories and Ford to do the body style. And you are set

[@drewx420]

Imagine if Toyota had a partnership with Honda instead of Subaru in the late 2000s so the FRS/86 They could have used Honda & yamaha Cylinder head technology and possibly made an even better K series. I can only imagine :(

[@kwadwofrimpong1055]

This will be a fantastic combo!

[@adamgroszkiewicz814]

You think that the Civic and Corolla have equivalent levels of interior/driving ergonomics? Gonna disagree if so, and that's a huge point for long term ownership. Honda transmissions are vastly superior, both CVT and Manual. Haven't driven a tq converter auto of either since the 90's, and auto's were all dog doo doo back then anyway.

[@goldwolf0606]

When are they going to make the Honda Scotty and Toyota Kilmer? 😂

[@raymondreiff8170]

SOON I HOPE 🤑

[@fernandorangel4679]

If Toyota or Honda actually make a car on scottys name that would be the best thing ever

[@fernandorangel4679]

If Toyota or Honda actually make a car on scottys name that would be the best thing ever

[@omnilife6660]

it must be Standard with fuel economy...very stock like scotty kilmer and when cranking it up it must sound like the shelby gt

[@fernandorangel4679]

@@omnilife6660 upon startup the speaker will play with scottys voice “rev up your engines”

[@vulturecat3378]

I bought my 2004 Corolla at 160k miles, and I'll admit, I've abused the hell out of that car. I've not always had the money needed to keep up with the repairs, and I finally start earning some decent money and it gave out on me. It just passed 250k miles and I'm needing to replace the engine due to rod knock. And the funny thing is that it's been so reliable the past five years I've owned it, even when I've not put in the time and effort into maintaining it, that I'm probably going to end up putting another engine in it. It's gotten me through several road trips and is surprisingly fun to drive. If I do end up doing the engine swap, I'm going to maintain it to see just how long I can keep it going, even if it means spending another 5+ years with this car!

[@jmfn6092]

How's the corolla now dude ? Any update?

[@vulturecat3378]

@@jmfn6092 well, I did the engine swap. Got an engine from Japan with only 60k miles on it. The shop who did the swap did a good job replacing the engine, but a bad job making sure they didn't destroy any wiring when they did it. So now I have a perfectly running engine but electrical issues. The wiring to the speed sensor must've broken somehow, because I no longer have a working instrument cluster. Currently trying to find a shop that specializes in electrical where I live because all the swap shop did is replace the speed sensor and that didn't do anything to fix the issue.

[@MultiClassof2010]

@@vulturecat3378 dang that sucks. Hope you find someone. Keep us in the loop

[@Kevinleehiltonjr]

I'm interested to know if you ever got your wiring fixed

[@vulturecat3378]

@@Kevinleehiltonjr yes! It was the strangest thing that unfortunately took about 3 different mechanics to figure out. But for some reason, my automatic transmission would only fit a speed sensor for a manual transmission. The mechanic that figured it out tried one for an automatic and realized it didn't sit right, so he tried one for a manual and its been working ever since. No clue why it worked, but it did.

[@catrenatownes490]

The first car I bought was a 2005 Honda Civic LX, which I bought new. Lasted me for over 16 years and put almost 207,000 miles on it. Issues I had was a bad alternator and starter. Replaced my brakes twice. No problem with the AC. I probably could’ve driven it for another year or so but the head gasket went bad and the cost to fix it wasn’t with it. Before I got my Honda I was planning on getting a Toyota Corolla. In January 2021, I ended up buying a 2021 Toyota C-HR as I got a better deal than 2021 Honda C-RV. I will always have a soft spot for my Honda Civic. Both great car companies!

[@dave-d-grunt]

We bought one in 2000. Great car. Some guy ran a light and T-boned it!

[@SK-tr1wo]

@@dave-d-grunt howd u survive a tbone in a 2000 model. You would’ve been dead

[@wajeehbukhari7595]

The kinda history I’d like to learn in school🤧

[@razvandobos9759]

They need to teach this in school. Stuff that’s actually interesting

[@aquilesnlmb2874]

Sadly only the car enthusiasts care for this

[@aquilesnlmb2874]

@@razvandobos9759 one can dream right

[@manibajwa9094]

Consider you still in school ;)

[@r.d.9399]

20 more years the Honda Civics and Toyota Corollas will be over $45,000. The end of the car industry and car culture as a whole.

[@janmcguire5268]

I’m a loyal Toyota lady, having owned many. I currently have a Corolla and I love it. Both my sons also drive Toyotas. If I didn’t have a thing for Toyotas, Honda would be my next choice. They are both good reliable vehicles.

[@abbyhenderson9574]

I went with the civic but I'd be happy to look at Toyotas when I'm in the market for another car. They really are great cars.

[@peacebewu]

what gen of corolla would you recommend?

[@someguywithmtndew5691]

yeah my house is full of toyotas

[@janmcguire5268]

@@peacebewu I’m currently driving a 2015 model and have been very happy with it. My son is not fond of its continuously variable transmission because it sounds “different,” but it has performed quite well and I like it’s smooth hum.

[@mercpindi5522]

Toyota anyday. Honda is second choice

[@kyleramirez2826]

I’ve had about 5 corollas in my life and just bought my 6th one used it’s a 2007 at 160k miles. The fan is louder than other models I’ve owned but runs like a dream. Gotta love cars owned by seniors who just don’t drive anymore yet still changed their oil every 6 months lol

[@Gforu81]

Truth. Those are the best cars to find!

[@rickymahoney6664]

CarFax should start giving the age of the person who owned the car lol

[@paigeheartly8936]

Yup. Just bought a 2003 Toyota Corolla from an old lady. That thing is in mint condition it’s impressive

[@josea2735]

Incredible video, going to be getting my first car and am looking Pre owned so this helped narrow down the years I want to focus on. Thank you so much!

[@Tpj4682]

I'm kind of disappointed I didn't get yelled at by Scotty this entire video

[@KeliBaB]

Couldn't make sense of the video without his hand gestures

[@SnarkyRC]

Smoke weed everyday

[@user-zx5xw4yw2e]

@@SnarkyRC 😄

[@c.h.u.d]

You flounder heads really are a BORE lol "gEeEe ScOtTyS yElLiNg"

[@jeffreyjeziorski1480]

Scotty skipped his coffee

[@MC-bw5fc]

#1 great history lesson.

[@aquilesnlmb2874]

That's a fact

[@Catbus2009]

My first car was a 1991 CRX Si and ever since then I fell in love with Honda. In highschool, I fell in love with the EP3 Civic and now own one (2005 Blue). They are a fun zippy commuter car with a cool rally style shifter. Recaro seats are pretty neat as well.

[@LechonPark]

Good overview of the history of Civics and Corollas. Surprised you didn't mention the infamous peeling clearcoat issue that the 8th gen Civics had. It got so bad Honda got hit with a class-action lawsuit.

[@carloswithac]

Gen 7 Corolla driver here. I'm currently at 299.5k miles.

[@H.E.M.]

Gen 8 civic driver here. Currently 119k miles. Gonna give it to my future kid 😂

[@marcalvarezps4]

99 Corolla here and 100k miles.

[@user-mx1fq6qm6i]

That's just insanity

[@yaroldimanzano2199]

@@user-mx1fq6qm6i Insanity just save you money...

[@GodFootDaddyG]

I have an 03 Pontiac Vibe, which is just a Corolla with a hat. Odometer stopped at 299,999 but ive been keeping count, currently at 315k

[@ronaldpoole3273]

I’ve owned several civics dating back to 1981. They have all performed well and I put over 100,000 miles on each one.

[@andrewscasualmtb]

100k isn't that much.

[@erik7747]

2016 Honda Civic is a lemon I owned one! A/C compressor broke 4 times in 3 years!

[@civicstyle01]

I honestly like the 88-91 gen Honda Civic had a 91 back in high school got well over 350k miles out of it before selling it to my friend for $900 😎

[@erik7747]

@Sean Giampietro My 0 to 65k miles on 2016 Civic had 4 A/C compressors go out and 2 front computer screens replaced from pulling dash sooo many times 2 fix compressor! LEMON NO OTHER WAY 2 EXPLAIN MY SITUATION! My 2014 Toyota Avalon I bought with 100k miles 2 years ago now has 150kwith ZERO PROBLEMS!

[@liberationpocket6435]

That's it? My 2007 Corolla has almost 400k and has never had any major repairs.

[@sarashann]

Currently well pleased with the used 2018 Corolla XSE I purchase a year ago. 26K miles when I bought it. Now at 48K and going strong. Just a great car! Appreciate all your info and hard work Scotty!

[@AnhadDeo]

same

[@frankrizzo7975]

"Now at 48k and going strong" - is this supposed to be a joke?

[@Blue-jn1ph]

​@@frankrizzo7975fr lmao

[@tl8320]

hahahahhaha

[@agreen182]

This is amazing content. I bought an 06 corolla last week, glad to see I didnt screw up!

[@Aaron-eo7ev]

Got an 04 one here.

[@ryanboodhoo3512]

Camry and accord next make it happen scotty we love this content so keep it comeing

[@kramronyam7765]

2007 Corolla 1.8L 225k still going strong !👍

[@devyncordova4284]

I gotta 2005 corolla LE with the 1.8 at 186k and going strong. Love it

[@JesseMgala]

My 07 Corolla, bought from a colleague almost a year ago was made in Cambridge Ontario. It had 136,000mi then. I put on 12,500mi since.

[@andrewsamanthamadison3320]

07 civic 1.8L 242,000! Not to one up ya. Auto tranny too!

[@lionheart93]

no issues at all? u drive long distance?

[@jurti19]

We had a 2005 Corolla CE with over 267,000 on the odometer. Still running strong. No issues what so ever. Had to get rid of because subframe was rotting out due to us living in the rust belt. Would love another Corolla.

[@haroldsmyth6685]

Corrodea

[@Hustler3]

Hi Scotty.I watch your videos all the time.I recently purchased a 2016 Toyota Corolla S and so far I like the way it drives!My only issue was I had wet floors caused by a loose clip on the A/C Drain hose.But it was a quick fix.Other than that no issues,and the car runs fine!

[@vicespiritu]

This was awesome, really enjoyed it!! The 2013 Civic had no recalls. So in my books makes it one of the best models.

[@nocheesable2345]

Probably had Takata airbag recall at the very least,

[@djkasdjkasdjdjdj]

I think recalls should actually be a good indicator of how manufacturers r responsible and admitting they have issue to fix

[@Shakerhood69]

I believe recalls are safety issues determined by the government

[@tomasnokechtesledger1786]

My 2001 Citroen C5 never had a recall too.

[@sebastianzapata7690]

I ride a 2012 Civic LX riding 112,000 and only have a small rattle when the engine cold starts, not a car guy but that’s my only complaint. I think it’s a great car

[@Nestle245]

For some reason I see more new new gen Civics than Corollas.

[@johnfizzelo3443]

@Dominic I am genuinely thinking about buying a new Honda Civic Hatchback for the looks alone

[@johnfizzelo3443]

@Dominic how does a roommate change warrant a new car

[@82dupont]

The Civic is nicer than the Corolla, including the interiors. I’m currently looking at both cars and I’m leaning towards the Civic.

[@82dupont]

@Dominic ….I’m not interested in anything that’s turbo though. I’m looking at strictly non turbo motors. Wish you the best on your search.

[@johnfizzelo3443]

@Dominic I test drove one a few weeks ago. They really are nice.

[@Mikino1976]

I owned a 2005 Corolla Sport Manual. It was insane how reliable it was, especially compared to the American cars I grew up with. The Takata airbag recall was a major pain though. They notified me that because of the danger, no one should ride in the passenger seat until the replacement became available (15 Months later). In the meantime, I had to drive three kids to school and stuff them all in the back seat. At 6 am 🤨

[@fridgemagnet9831]

How for away was the school?

[@nostradamus7648]

First world problems 😂

[@chance6057]

Just picked one up today one owner with 124000 miles on it. Looking forward to many miles on it

[@Brett235]

​@@chance6057they're great cars, you won't be disappointed.

[@hotfudgecake]

Omg. Same. I took had to take mine to dealership for the airbag issue. Yep, my two teens sat in the back. Really reminded me how small the interior is lol . I'm still driving mine , 223k miles

[@mattmattmatt8984]

Quality content STILL serving us well! Thanks, Scotty!

[@iamgiocasino]

8th gen Civic gang ❗️🔥

[@choysum2508]

My 8th gen Civic, done 250 thousand km. Soooooooo reliable!

[@dee_2330]

Yessir 👍

[@acutehandle]

09 civic 160,000 miles third owner 💙

[@GF-mf7ml]

Best Civic Type R 😍

[@Ruxify]

Just hit 150,000 miles on my 2011 civic today.

[@akshat20021996]

I've got 2020 Corolla SE sedan... Loving it soo far... The physical 1st gear really helps with acceleration with combi of 169 HP engine... It gets really good gas milage as well... The best ever I got on my trip meter was 4.2l/100 km on a 200 km trip Overall it's a good combo of power and mileage...

[@wajahat558]

When it comes to reliability then only 1 name is in mind that is Corolla

[@mondobizarrro5468]

I love my 2014 civic lx. I just got it as my first car back in feburary. I cant thank my family enough for helping me cover it.

[@Blue-moon12]

I had two Toyota Corolla GT Twin Cam 16v. I had a 1985 and a 1987. What great cars they were.

[@rvilla4257]

And now it's super hard to find one.

[@Blue-moon12]

@@jimmyboyles2868 this was 20 years ago when I was 21!! And one was stolen/recovered.

[@Blue-moon12]

@@rvilla4257 Yes very hard.😓

[@ChrisBrown-pz2gu]

Did you deliver tofu?

[@Austin-ok5wu]

how do you have time to pump these out on vacation ?? youre an animal man

[@njad3]

He’s unreal

[@engrishsheep]

"Do what you’ll love, and you’ll never work another day in your life.” and that's really apply to this case here...

[@spaceexplorer6636]

Because he’s not on vacation, he’s making videos on location, big difference. He Doesn’t work! His only Job is KZbin and he makes money every video. You really think he’s trying to help anyone, lol, he’s lining his own pockets. Your only a like on a computer screen, wake up Morons.

[@LastNineBreaker]

@ryt ryt81 So are you shitting on him for being a capitalist of the good ol’ American dream?

[@KevinChinn88]

@@spaceexplorer6636 he actually IS helping us more than you know.... which is WHY his pockets are lined, and they SHOULD be. This is what happens when you provide a good service or product. You can do it too! It’s not “just for Scotty.”

[@meanmistermustard2485]

I'm currently looking for a preowned car, and these two are my choices (and the CRV and RAV4)... you have made my decision making much easier..... to be honest i was considering a Jetta, but after watching your video about ir, you made me RETHINK my choices! all your videos were REALLY A BIG HELP! BIG THANK YOU!

[@billk5255]

Get a CRV. smoother drive.. Engine will last!

[@brianhealy1016]

Scotty your channel is great. Just got a 2011 Honda Civic.

[@kdsanchez2433]

Excellent video, short but with lot of great content. I ask myself, how Scotty can still make quality video on vacation time? Well, he love his job, that’s why he’s the best.

[@andrewshepherd2041]

Civics are just such a good car Scotty is such a good guy

[@backflipdud5445]

Agreed

[@njad3]

Only type R

[@PremiumUserUltra]

Youre such a good guy too

[@PremiumUserUltra]

Dont listen to njad3, he drives a mirage g4

[@andrewshepherd2041]

Lol

[@pfflyers1]

I bought a 2000 Honda Civic LX brand new in May of 2000 and I'm still driving it. No Major issues and extremely reliable. I had to replace the radiator 3 times. All 3 times it leaked from plastic top of radiator

[@ryansanchez5673]

I love when scotty makes like vids like this about history of cars and brands

[@dennisheadley4408]

I've only owned Toyotas and they have been great. I have friends who own both and their advice on which to buy is, "flip a coin."

[@stefanlal3060]

I owe both as well and they couldnt of been more right. !

[@peter7582]

If you want manual, get a civic. For auto, corolla.

[@josiew.8383]

My husband and I just got a Toyota Corolla Hybrid. Love it

[@eugenegolden4174]

I got one last Saturday myself. Seems like it is going to be a great car. My first Hybrid but have driven a number of them.

[@_allandiaz]

I enjoy this type of video layout, do more of these please

[@onetrueangel1672]

My girlfriend is looking at a 2005 Toyota corolla and then I found this video and glad to see it is a very good year for the car so that makes me happy seeing she will be getting a great little car

[@Ishudinho]

Bought a Honda Civic 8th Gen after seeing one of your videos 3 years ago. Best car I've ever owned.

[@archerjohnson7910]

As always with Scotty, this is an excellent video with useful information. I especially like how Scotty is factual and impartial when comparing these two outstanding vehicles. Personally, I think Scotty's car videos are the best overall- complete with a little humor.

[@josephpuchel6497]

Hey purchased used 93 Corolla no issues Later sold to my sister who had it for 23 years. Infrequent oil and trans fluid changes. Lot of rust . It finally blew up and went to salvage with little over 300,000 miles. It was a very forgiving vehicle.

[@gionova1]

I'm so glad I have a 2006 Toyoda Corolla LE. It has worked perfectly besides an intake gasket that needed replacing and it's a great car to modernize. I already installed a new android radio and am working on installing a dash and rear cam.

[@mikehendrick7910]

My dad swore by his 1985 Civic GL. Sedan. He bought it brand new when it was released and owned it for over 10 years until July 1995 when he hit a deer. He thought it was an amazing car to drive and was solid and reliable. It was the one car he wished he could have rebuilt and continued to drive.

[@juanap2230]

You are such a "great Teacher"I truly enjoy your channel.

[@ambiguousambassador]

Dad owns a 2006 Toyota Corolla back when it first came out. It’s a manual and he never had to change the clutch and much haha. Barely burns oil and runs great today at 300k+ miles!

[@codycraven1465]

Just got the base model 2024 Toyota Corolla LE. Brand spanking new with 4 miles on the ODO. Starts up with a key and drives like a dream. 30+ miles per gallon is insane! I plan on keeping this vehicle for 10+ years if it will let me. I plan on 5k oil changes (despite the dealer recommending 10k). I’ve never been more proud of a purchase. I know Scotty would be proud too 😂

[@kathym6603]

I'm so glad that the same thing that makes Scotty rich and famous makes the world a better place. ❤️ Yesterday in a parking lot there were 4 cars parked next to each other with the same "window slant." All Honda's. America has voted!!

[@courtneylovesjordan9519]

Is that a bad thing? What is wrong with the window slant?

[@kun534]

Being a civic fan.. i had a 5th gen civic , several 6 gens , 8 th and 9 th gen civics. From coupe , hatch , sedan and estate version in uk.. all of them never missed a beat..

[@kunstderfugue]

I'm going to be honest, I hadn't watched a video of yours since 2019 and I'm super happy with the improvement in production value and video editing. This is super engaging content even though I do think the thumbnails are a little sus, if you know what I mean xD

[@boondoggle4820]

My first car as a teenager was a Toyota Tercel, and the Corolla kind of reminds of that. It’s a sturdy, reliable car, but it seems like a young person’s first car. The Honda Civic has more edge and seems more stylish which is why I prefer it, even though the Corolla likely has the slight edge in reliability.

[@Dngrov257]

I have owned both (91 TC and 02 Civic). Both were great with few repairs. You really cannot go wrong with either. I just traded my 2014 Accord for a Corolla Hybrid, which I will pick up next week.

[@acematthew7283]

Love this video at least he’s showing that these guys aren’t always perfect

[@ggzgpg]

My daughter’s first car that she bought on her own was a 2020 Honda Civic. Even though it is still under warranty, she has not had 1 problem to date with it. They are reliable and I feel safe with her driving it.

[@adamgroszkiewicz814]

Former Volvo technician here. I've owned 3 Civics in my life & my fiancé has owned 2 Corollas. The difference in maintenance cost, dealership experience, long term durability of parts, and especially interior/driving ergonomics all dramatically favor the Honda Civic regardless of generation. Oh, and ride quality is dramatically better in the Civic's as well. I mean Toyota was still using torsion beam rear on Corollas in 2018! A dealership shouldn't be charging $1000 to "clean the valve & head" on an MPFI (not DI) system during a 60k service either, but Toyota does that too. Based on my own experience as an owner, and as a professional auto technician I'd recommend Honda Civic any time given equivalent engine setups, years of production, & option levels. This is not a commentary about the current Type R vs GR as those are highly niche cars. I am talking the primary sales trim levels.

[@scottmcleod1470]

Thank you for this insight! I’m looking to buy either a new civic or new Corolla for my wife. My ultimate goal is to make it last as close to 20 years as possible. You recommend the civic will hit that goal more likely rather than the Corolla?

[@alextatkin1026]

@@scottmcleod1470 So, whatd ya get?

[@RG615]

My first was 1987 Corolla FX. Then I have a 1990 corolla which I still own (256000 miles) and own also a 2017 corolla SE. Love my Toyotas. #1 all the way!!! 😄

[@aac8033]

civic gang. 2008 EX - 214k Miles , no serious issues

[@spsasi123]

Wow..!! That's good detailed comparison ever I have seen.!! Also good info on the Used car purchase..!!👍

[@matthewsanders6499]

Scotty needs his own tv show. He's a legend.

[@YoureNowOnTV]

He had his own TV show years ago. 😉👍

[@PhantomCookie87]

He did and he hated it.

[@bchandler81]

I’ve owned both & favor the Toyota hands down. My Toyota’s have never spent a day in the shop. My Hondas’s have very expensive repairs (transmissions, a/c, power steering pumps etc.) & the paint didn’t hold up. I will be a Toyota customer for the rest of my life.

[@ln5747]

Anecdotal evidence. 01 Landcruiser with 273k miles, complete rust bucket, all doors need replaced. 07 Civic 192k miles not a spot of rust.

[@marykennedy1992]

Solid !!!

[@jayflores3947]

Wow!

[@nocheesable2345]

@@ln5747 rust protection on civic much better

[@sal9805]

I are with you. Paint chipping in my 2019 Honda and I even had clear coat protection

[@wendywright5486]

Just bought a 2020si stick shift 3wks ago and I love it!

[@Dr.AnthonyFraudcheat3499]

How much was your total out the door price?

[@reggierizaev]

Great video, and what a calm voice!

[@gumpster66]

I remember those tiny civics. A friend had one in high school. I'm talking about the early 80's, great vid, thanks.. :)

[@trillcollins7847]

Hope you're having a good one, Scotty! You inspired me to buy a Honda Civic SI after owning three Subarus.

[@aquilesnlmb2874]

Ayeee not gonna be disappointed brodie

[@corymiller7412]

I was actually looking at getting the Acura ILX with the 6-speed manual transmission. I had driven the TLX on a test drive and they were unbelievably comfortable seats.

[@CC_Marauder]

We'll still know you're a lez+be+in

[@noels9727]

But a Toyota Camry or Corolla instead.. they are better

[@corymiller7412]

@@noels9727 I have a Corolla I love it. I had a 2005 Camry. I loved that car too. I wanted something a little smaller and sportier

[@Megaloryan]

The best looking Corolla's I think were the Gen 4, 5 GTS and 6. The 3rd Gen civic wasn't too shabby either. Still, for all their dependability, driveability, bringing reliable motoring to the masses, which are good things, more recent models are such dull things to look at.

[@fargouberguy]

I just bought a new 2022 Civic Sport last Wednesday. Really love the car and the mpg. I had no idea it was a CVT transmission, I thought it was a smooth shift, realized Honda's CVT is just that good. This civic generation will probably be one of the best. The interior is also beautiful looking. Love my Civic.

[@joemiester31]

Just grabbed a 22 civic sport as well. Yours held up nice over the last year?

[@rickymahoney6664]

I love the new design of the 22 hatchback. I really wish i could get one

[@drewodessa2483]

2006 Corolla LE. 372K miles. No issues. 30 MPG highway/city.

[@evanprice7967]

Very informative! Do more like this. Camry and Accord, Lexus and Acura, etc. Very helpful.

[@greggc8088]

I had a 2001 Civic bought used to drive 140 mile round trip to work daily. It was a rare base model. No A/C and a stick shift. It didn't give any trouble and got 44 MPG if keeping the speed under 70. Rode like a wagon though. Beat me to death and wasn't very stable on the road over 80. It did get awesome gas mileage though and didn't break down.

[@howardthompson5403]

My wife has a 2013 Corolla and is rock solid as far as mechanical. My only real gripe with it is the road noise even with a good set of tires designed to ride quieter. These type of cars are not designed to be performance cars so I don't see why they won't go ahead and put plenty of sound deadening in them. It's the only reason we won't take it on a road trip is because of the road noise. We take my F150 instead.

[@ericdulyon4601]

I have a 2006 Toyota Corolla. The ninth generation Corolla is absolutely insane reliability. I have 319,000 miles on mine and I've had no major repairs. Just change my original alternator. No work done on AC, no work done on transmission just a freaking tank. I am about To change my at least left CV joint that is original. Why can't every car be like this

[@skiplazauski1497]

Excellent as per usual!!! Question: That Sony wiring coating can you give us a list of all manufacturers, makes and models that use it? regards

[@heatherbeck1]

Proud 4th owner of a '06 Civic, with some issues that i've dealt with, only thing left is AC needing fixing, but still love it! It's my first car, but I wouldn't say no to owning a Toyota at some point :) overall I really like these 2 brands, they are very reliable. Also side note for Scotty-- the mice chewing on the cables was adorable hehe.

[@DrRyan82994]

my first car was also a 06 civic that the AC died on. i was the 2nd owner and i sold it to the third. 5 speed lots of fun

[@seyntwyatt2578]

Great Vid, sir! Both are very reliable cars if you want a speedy reliable car, go for the civic. If you want a calm reliable one, go for a corolla.

[@fernandorangel4679]

Me watching this as I got a 2016 Honda Civic coupe two weeks ago. They did fix the a/c before selling it to me so this makes sense 😢

[@frederickfernandez1510]

Yes i was going to buy a 2016 untill i saw the problems with the condenser air compresor and the electrical wires.

[@fernandorangel4679]

@@frederickfernandez1510 oh well at least it’s better than most other cars lol

[@frederickfernandez1510]

@@fernandorangel4679 yes for sure is a great car the engine is very good also and the cvt tranny is also good on that model. Maybe since they fix your a/c you will not have any problems

[@fernandorangel4679]

@@frederickfernandez1510 agree overall a great car! Good luck on finding a good car! I’d reccomend the 8th gen Camrys those are my dream cars

[@crubio94cr]

I had a 2016 civic I never knew about this issue with the a/c mine never failed and it had 45k when I traded it in lol

[@repentantsinner665]

Just bought an 03 corolla le with only 78k miles on it about a month ago, getting close to 80k now from me and I'm LOVING the car so far! Can't believe how nice the interior is and how well the paint held up for it being 20 years old almost , Toyota has my sold now ! Bought the Corolla as a daily driver because of ur videos

[@1Mannco]

My mother bought the '03 Corolla new with the modern 9th gen look, now only 80k miles. She got a good deal on a paint job and looks new again. Interior still looks new, never has had a problem, very solid car. Great gas mileage, great for somebody looking for an affordable dependable car.

[@rickymahoney6664]

I'm nervous of buying a used car that is that old and so few miles on it but sounds like you had no issues. I'm currently looking at a 16' Civic Coupe but was hesitant cuz it has less than 20k miles. I defiantly don't want to buy something with alot of miles but I also don't want a car thats been sitting for years. I wish I could afford a new one to avoid any issues.

[@tamaraking4368]

I'm considering trading my 2016 Honda Civic due to uncomfortable, low sitting seats and steering wheel sticking issue. After a little research, I see the sticking steering wheel is a common complaint in the 2016 models.

[@goddessbrya888]

Ugh and to think I was lookin on carbs a and they’ve got a whole bunch of 2016 civics I thought I’d hit a lick

[@robb15033]

I own a 2008 Corolla and love it. Minor maintenance and it keeps going.

[@raymondreiff8170]

My wife really likes her new 2020 Civic sport sedan 2.0l 6speed manual 😎 She still has her 2005 civic special edition ex but wants to drive it only in the winter so her new car doesn't start to rust anywhere because Central Wis loves the Salt- Calcium chloride for melting Ice 🤔

[@bretthansen8166]

The 2.0 naturally aspirated motor and 6 speed manual transmission is definitely the most reliable way to buy a Civic. You two bought the right one 👍🏻

[@jamesflynn10]

A good oil undercoat will go a long way to protect from rust. I live in NH and use a product known as NHOU (New Hampshire Oil Undercoat). Like any other product, people will argue to no end which is best. I’ve used the clear formula on a new F-150 before it ever saw salt and treated every year. It gets sprayed inside the panels and frame as well as coating everything else underneath. Years later, the difference is clear when compared to similar models were were obviously never treated and exposed to winter salts. If it’s an older vehicle, it will still help, but not as much since any rust that has already started will continue to cause damage, but a thorough undercoat will slow it down considerably. The shop here is reputable and will do the inside/outside treatment for about $200 if you can’t do it yourself, but the cost compared with repairing the frame or body is much more. Once a year is typically all you need, usually the fall is a good time for that.

[@gordearl207]

Just bought my daughter a 2021 Toyota Corolla Nightshade edition in black... What an awesome little car!

[@jaymzmeh4595]

Your daughter needs to get a job and buy her own car...sorry not sorry

[@ilikechamomile4502]

This was a really good informative video we need more like this 👏🏾👏🏾

[@michaeld2085]

I think the 10th gen Honda Civic is a beautiful looking car. I had a 2018 Si, then moved on to another one in 2020 to avoid the condenser issue and picked up a volume knob. I don’t like the front end on the 11th gen civic, so I think I’m keeping the 2020 for awhile.

[@johnloupis2347]

I agree 100%. I have a 2019 EX Coupe I was leasing. I ended up buying it before the end of the lease when I found out they were not going to make the coupe anymore. I've owned 5 BMW's and a Lexus. All new. No doubt the Honda is the best value. Great driving and smooth motor.

[@bigwacha7410]

I will take whatever has a manual thank you very much.

[@mustansir2581]

Buy a tesla then

[@devanhall9051]

@@mustansir2581????

[@Mustansirtaher6]

But an R34

[@q0p338]

idk about you guys but, i have had two 8th gen civics in the past year and love them. i had a sedan ex with 313k miles and it kept going strong. i eventually bought a sedan si with 243k and i love it

[@smallqwaro]

If you're not here for a history lesson then start at 8:35

[@aronr.4636]

My 1999 Corolla is a tiny beast! 260,000+ miles and take it to work going 90mph Monday through Friday and hasn’t missed a beat 👍🏻🔥❤️

[@drakkus13]

I would go for the Honda civic. I drive the 2006 Honda civic 1.8 FD automatic 5 speed. Almost 300,000 KM on it. And it hasn't been any problems with it.

[@Deschain-um7jz]

I love my 2019 Corolla Hatch XSE. Your options are limited these days if you want a manual transmission and this was a good purchase.

[@abdulhadi344]

Very nice documentary 😍😍 2009 Corolla also had engine heat up issue

[@comradecrawford3318]

2013 civic si with 115k miles. Only thing that has been wrong with it was the MAF sensor went out. Other than that, great car. Getting 25 city, and 32-36 highway.

[@robs905]

I dare say that your right foot is made of lead....

[@comradecrawford3318]

@@robs905 I guess. It's also a 2.4L which runs only on premium. I'm lucky I'm getting those numbers, especially since the MPG Honda rated the car for was 20-22.

[@robs905]

Just joshing. I drive like a very old man that stays in his lane and uses turn signals when called for.

[@MannyQuacioua]

How would you guys rate the 2002 Civic

[@lorensims4846]

Here in Central Ohio were all about Honda. I and my family have owned a lot of cars over the years but well more than half of them were Hondas. They really can't be beat.

[@TheDalitis8]

I have always wanted a Honda but for one reason or another I spent a decade and a half with an average French Renault Clio. Recently bought a DC5 Type-R and it's immense. I can't wait to buy my next Honda. It will either be an S2000 or the FK8 Civic Type-R.

[@mariolimas5226]

@@TheDalitis8 good luck with that s2000 are so nice bro

[@davejenkins6896]

A review I read on Honda's a few years ago described the Honda as being almost aircraft build quality which for me is just about as good as it gets

[@nocheesable2345]

Isn’t there a Honda Plant in Ohio?

[@lorensims4846]

@@nocheesable2345: Yes, ever since the ‘80s, in Marysville just one county over from us.

[@bmwmaw]

Evening Scotty! Keep up the great videos

[@scottykilmer]

evening and thanks will do!

[@bmwmaw]

It would have to be a Civic for me. Currently have a 2009 accord coupe manual trans. Thinking the next car might be a Civic sport or si manual.

[@davesax11]

Nice review Scotty. Love my 2018 Civic Si. We like to row. no problems to 36K. Also loved my 2007 Ex Coupe manual. No problems to 90k when we sold it.

[@JonathanSilva-yp1cm]

I love your videos I have a 2006 Toyota Matrix still running strong