Will Democracy Repair Under Modi.3?

In this episode, Harsh Mander speaks with political scientists Neera Chandhoke and Niraja Gopal Jayal and journalist Pamela Philipose.
The discussion is around the prospects of repair of democracy under Modi.3.

[@user-ux3zq8di5f]

It seems these people are very much satisfied with great democracy in Pakistan, Bangladesh, Afghanistan, Kashmir, Bengal, the Jihadi killings of kanaiyalal, Umesh kolhe, Prashant pujari, love jihad going on everywhere in India. Galloping increase in population of muslims specially in slums. But democracy is in danger due to elected government by the citizens of Bharat.

[@shankerram6076]

Ha ha ha 🤣😂🙃

[@sharma5462]

They would not speak anything They seems it as good Don't focus on these doble standard rascals They will keep on weep till their death

[@cuteyrahul]

How come no left liberal ever criticize Mamta Banerjee?

[@rc2k22]

Correct ❤

[@naganandnileshwar8828]

That requires guts and presence in India.

[@user-wv9tk3wx9o]

Absolutely.. u can see there shallowness and bias

[@sajucv]

Instead of generalising MEDIA, it is important that individuals , channels and media owners are called out by name.

[@vijay-1]

Total silence on fate of minorities in pakistan, kashmir etc. shame on this selectivity

[@user-yy4eo2hi3w]

Ecosystem started working..😂😂😂

[@Trials_By_Errors]

Harsh Bandar and the foreign funded ecosystem owned india for 10 years. Was that constitutional ??? This is the ecosystem which ruled India for last 80 years. This is just beginning of true Democracy in India.

[@karunavenu]

Urban naxals

[@rameshkarnik2502]

Meltdown of Urban Naxals; your time is over; Nehruvian Secularism is dead; long live Hindutva, Modiji ki jai, Bharatmataki jai😂😂😂

[@space-time-somdeep]

Best part of this program is nuance disagreement among panalists.. very rare now a days in public and media sphere. I know this kind of discussions will not be watched by huge number of mass, but please continue..

[@kunalk662]

any comments on emergency imposed by indira gandhi....?????????????

[@rak4215]

Thanks Mr. Harsh Mander for inviting such stalwarts. An enlightening discussion. My profound regards to all.

[@auxxin.]

😂 BUSLIM

[@sharma5462]

This harsh mander is pakistani born Chuslim

[@harryd5893]

Excellent excellent discussion! Thankest!

[@All360Tube]

Harsh why not you make such debate on democracy in West Bangal, Punjab, North East where actually "democracy" vs chnage in demography. Is it need to repair?

[@user-wv9tk3wx9o]

Please explain to youngsters how democracy was killed by Congress in 1975

[@rak4215]

Neerja Ma'am's view on the young generation reminds me of a speech by Mao to the youth - "The world is yours as well as ours but in the last analysis it is yours. You young people full of vigour and vitality are in the bloom of life like the Sun at 8 or 9 in the morning."

[@user-wv9tk3wx9o]

There is no threat to democracy under Modi. We should be worried of Congress. Remember 1975 emercrncy

[@srinivasanm.v475]

Wow ! Intellectuals! None of them have read Ambedkar.

[@user-kv9es3hj5z]

Indian Fragile Democracy in trouble..

[@rajeshbhagat863]

@5:45 - Democracy was in shambles during Emergency, not now; quick question - how many times did the CONgress govt. imposed center's rule in the state during their reign and how many times did BJP govt do it...? Bharat had the dubious distinction of being called as a member of 'Fragile Five' not long ago, 'policy paralysis' had become the buzzword and the world was thinking of replacing the 'I' in BRICS with Indonesia. @ 8:57 - 'Do not barter your liberties' - does this apply to Nehru's era also, what Abut Indira's tyranny - what liberty or locus standi did she have on behalf of the entire country to decide that Bharat wants to be a Secular country -did she conduct a survey/poll? or she had it passed it 'democratically' in the parliament? @ 28:27 - Was the Constitution not hollowed out during Emergency? @11:50 Was the Institution ( Judiciary) able to hold the Executive in check during Emergency or there after during CONgress tenure? @22:32 - I totally get it ' How much the power the state had for the good'... Remember the 'National Development Council' that worked as a 'Super Cabinet' during SoGa's tenure which you Harsh was a part of.

[@pankajprakriti3499]

Tough, tongue twisting Language does not mean, these are intellectuals. They have just one side of opinion, highly biased individuals.

[@user-un1bm8wi7l]

Democracy is in danger we saw it the Lok sabha and Rajya sabha in last few days. We saw how the opposition was not allowed to speak.😊😊

[@naganandnileshwar8828]

Certainly. It has been in danger since INDEPENDENCE. The founders compromised on every aspect of DEMOCRACY to their convenience of interpretation and continued the British policy of DIVIDE AND RULE. This continues even today.

[@shantanusapru]

Short answer: No. There, I saved everyone's 1+ hour! 😂😂😂

[@hareshmehta1772]

Thanks so much.

[@shantanusapru]

@@hareshmehta1772 😆😆

[@hareshmehta1772]

@@shantanusapru 😂😂😂I mean it honestly!

[@shantanusapru]

@@hareshmehta1772 🤣🤣🤣👌👌

[@kasturiswami784]

Modi and democracy in one sentence? Not possible.

[@shobhitdagur1086]

But DMK and separatist can match

[@jayantilal5407]

Who defines democracy? What a bunch of jokers.

[@kasionline]

Secular is an ideology, never practiced.Why not you remove religion, caste etcet

[@Dadasahab1234]

Only known Congress bhakts on the panel. 😢😮😅

[@siddhartha5186]

Modi promised anhilation

[@maniganapathy4595]

Any of them is fit to talk on democracy ?

[@MrPharu500]

The demagogues speak! Democracy is alive and kicking, you replicas from Macbeth!

[@auxxin.]

If there was no democracy then these budhiya can't openly criticised modi😂

[@veteranas5564]

The very first few remarks displays the ignorance or/and BIAS of the participants. It is obvious that the moderator has ensured that he gets together a coterie which is willing to tow his line. This group belongs to the era of Romila Thapar who has now been proved wrong in most of her “research” work done by her. The world has moved on and these oldies who support an ignorant guy called Rahul are out of sync with reality. If at this time, Congress was to come to power, they wouldn’t have lasted for even 6 months. BJP has set a standard of governance which these guys can never ever emulate. Corrupt leaders have ruled this country for too long and guys Mander have benefited hugely because of their misgovernance. Very sad conversation.

[@jaspaldhillon8311]

All rascals.

[@abhisheksutradhar9502]

Ms. Roy ,,, the snake 🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍,, why she is not arrested?? We argue to govt to arrest this snake 🐍🐍🐍🐍🐍