Secrets of Rhodes (Red Dead Redemption 2)

[@HeistheA]

5:13 That would be good if people who knew Arthur could react to John wearing his hat

[@redpie32]

OMG YES imagine some speciallised voice lines for american venom too about the hat

[@prska]

​@@redpie32the game automatically makes you wear arthur's hat in american venom, so i don't see the point in "specialised voice lines" for that

[@seydou1]

6:49 there is a secret outcome for Mark Johnson nobody knows about. You can let him run away, if you do nothing at the point where he wants you to take him in. After a while Mark Johnson will say "He's showing us mercy" and will run away with his family.

[@StellaNBellaRed]

Amd the mission fails

[@HanWang-t5r]

Yeah I was a bit surprised when I failed if after I let him go, I really hoped that was an option. ​@@StellaNBellaRed

[@seydou1]

@@StellaNBellaRed i discovered this a Long Time ago but i don't remember the Mission failing, you just can roam around after he runs away with His family

[@TheOceanBearer]

​@@seydou1 Do you have to do that at a certain point? The mission fails for most people if you let him go at the beginning. MojaveD tried that, and the mission failed.

[@seydou1]

@@TheOceanBearer like i said i did this a long time ago but i don't remember the Mission failing. At the moment where Mark Johnson asks you to take him in, in front of his family i just did nothing. Just stood in front of him and his family instead of tying him up & put him on my horse like most Players do. After a while he says: "He's showing us Mercy." and runs away with his family, thats it. I don't rember a Mission failed screen or anything, after that i just could roam around like nothing happend but maybe this was patched or it indeed failed but i just don't remember it failing because Like i said, i tried/did this a long ime ago.

[@luke.thedrifter2281]

I like the veteran in Rhodes, he’s one of the few random encounters that isn’t a little weird. Plus he looks out for you by telling you about the bounty hunters

[@SpheniMoo]

7:51 Mark Johnson: Don't you believe in redemption? John: buddy......I am the redemption.....the Red Dead Redemption *Starts redemptioning the whole place*

[@AlexGTAgamer]

If I recall correctly, you can actually rescue Mark Johnson later on in the game when the lawmen are about to hang him.

[@ryancarroll9892]

Yes, you can. I always save him because he reminds me so much of John.

[@SMScorx89]

Yup. You'll lose honor, but it's worth it.

[@noorulhasan4904]

​@@SMScorx89might as well just don't do the mission

[@tonymartini6286]

​@SMScorx89 just throw some fish back and you're all good

[@TheOceanBearer]

​@@SMScorx89 You should lose honor for bringing him in, then gain honor for freeing him. This game is so backwards half the time. Same with losing honor for killing the stalker.

[@TriviaFreak]

Who DID kill the dog's master, anyway?

[@timothykalio157]

ikr he never answered it

[@steveb18]

Gavin

[@isken6593]

The camp dog

[@TheRealTerraBlade]

​@@isken6593 the legendary Rat killed Cain

[@themajesticnarwhal3273]

He kinda states his ideas as facts a lot

[@seanmmcelwain]

William Bowles is likely an allusion to Emmett Till

[@bmoney972]

correctomundo

[@zachary4670]

I thought the same thing

[@erikgilson1687]

William Bowles was the first and last victim of when the town attempted their version of The Lottery after a bad harvest

[@BigDaddyPancakes]

What is The Lottery?

[@erikgilson1687]

@@BigDaddyPancakes short story with a twist at the end, I'd recommend looking it up and reading it it's not long but it's very effective

[@BigDaddyPancakes]

@@erikgilson1687 I'll do that thanks

[@Biermeier]

Love those Videos! Keep it going

[@89Jalberts]

I like the fact that NPC’s you interact positively with as Arthur will ask about him to John

[@lazzygamerz2812]

Arthur: did you get to play with John? Players: Yes Arthur: what did it cost? Players: everything

[@aronsors2935]

I have read this in Arthur's voice 🥲

[@JadeLeaf1980]

The dog is a reference to Greyfriars Bobby in Edinburgh.

[@FezCaliph]

Didn’t know Pearson was married. That’s great!

[@AKVMA.]

Man im suprsied & love how much people still play red dead i remember when the video didnt have this level of editing.we were teens just finding out the world of rdr2

[@ceyhunozkan9919]

4:53 strangely, in my second playthrough i greeted that man couple of times as Arthur in chapter 2. Then the gang arrives clemence point, i never see that man in rhodes. He was keep telling that "you better get out here(town)" kinda things. Later i never saw him when i visited Rhodes.

[@REDACTED107]

Just got a notification from your discord that you posted a new video and I immediately pressed on it ! Keep up the good work my man👍

[@John.pork777-4]

These vids Are So good

[@mrlicopoli]

During epilogue, the grave that the dog was mourning at, and digging at....has now been dug open (or maybe broken from the inside?). There is no body in the casket! Unless the dog removed the skeleton?? And here we are 6 years after the game was made. :)

[@elementalb3m957]

I'd like to see a video investigating where Karen could have gone after she disappeared in Beaver Hollow because Tilly's letter is just a theory. Maybe there's some deleted dialogue in the game files?

[@I-Am-He]

10:29 can the remains of the gunsmith’s child be found using this drawing as a reference? Has anyone tried?

[@ahmedsafahmio3889]

When you deliver Mark Johnson , a few days later you can comeback to rescue him from hanging and he'll get back to his family

[@cattameme]

Didn't have to start it with the doggo 😭

[@Awwe12675]

1:33 in this town you will find 2 or 3 litter with 2 persons in the second floor, u need to killed them and loot them

[@NuevaCalifornia1769]

6:49 did you dress John the same to make a point about how they’re similar

[@REDACTED107]

Great detail! I didn't notice that

[@HeistheA]

Ive been waiting for it !!!

[@juanbauzafranco4284]

Every video of yours is awsome. Like the National Geographic type. Thank you sir

[@tempsitch5632]

There’s a dog mourning in Tumbleweed too.

[@sydneylocke5508]

Thomas Downes grave sight? Do you know where It is?

[@Ethan-sx3uk]

Thanks for another vid strange man!

[@JiggyStarz]

The gunsmith thing I encountered as Arthur. I tried to threaten the owner to opening the basement, but he just snoffed it off. Game bugged I guess? Few days later there was a corpse on the map. The 'boy' was dead in the basement. Nothing I could do after that.

[@emmavfarrellfrost]

You didn’t really need the bartenders words to tell that alden’s gay do you?

[@JagerLange]

I liked him in those ZooBooks ads tho.

[@colergg]

Well it was 1899 so maybe we got lucky and they hanged him

[@TPFB129]

I always saw Mark Johnson as a foreshadowing of John's future in RDR1, and I always save him after bringing him in. I get paid money for bringing him in, and I pay my moralality for busting him out.

[@amiramri3032]

1:38 Willie bowles could be a reference to an innocent 14-year-old black kid who gets executed by electric chair I forgot his name

[@redpie32]

George Stinney!

[@amiramri3032]

@@redpie32 yup

[@Raap123]

Like most things in the RDR2 universe 😉

[@SupremeOracle]

I thought it was about Emmet Till.. anyways USA has always had a fucked up history of treating minorities like this. Blacks Mexicans shit even the Irish & italians

[@derekhartenstine8545]

He wasn't innocent.

[@dislikebutton2881]

In all my playthroughs, Pearson is always wearing a winter coat and gloves while working at the store. This video is the first time I've ever seen him dressed like he's supposed to be dressed in a hot and dusty town like Rhodes

[@zebfox011]

Update the game

[@dislikebutton2881]

@@zebfox011 updated it a number of times. Pearson is still cold 😂 (It's a PC version of the game btw)

[@redpie32]

Is ur pearson always sick or something?😂

[@canalatibaiaconnection4014]

In my game too, and I play RDR2 on Playstation since 2018.

[@Cramblit]

I personally refuse to do Mark Johnsons bounty, because of the parallels with the gang, Arthur, and John. I don't think either of them would go through with it in reality.

[@Woezye]

Another banger!!

[@tonyneville4425]

First time I came across that Gavin friend was in Rhodes

[@Braintier]

The Strange Man never fails to give us new content on RDR2❤

[@puranidilip]

We need more!

[@thatgirlqt9886]

What about the church? The reverend last name was Grimshaw do you think it's any relation to ms Grimshaw? I could see that her being a house mom and all some father and daughter dispute?

[@HanWang-t5r]

Where can I see the reverends last name?

[@thatgirlqt9886]

@@HanWang-t5r when walking up to the church it's a sign hanging says Rev Grimshaw

[@thatgirlqt9886]

@@HanWang-t5r when walking up to the church it's a sign hanging says Rev Grimshaw

[@HanWang-t5r]

@@thatgirlqt9886 Thank you very much, that's very interesting. I hope strange man can explain that 😂

[@thatgirlqt9886]

@@HanWang-t5r me too 😂

[@jonathanarras1281]

I’ve been playing this game over and over again since launch and still finding new things! I did have a question, I’m trying to trigger an event in ch2. Locals come to the camp, I’ve triggered this after I read Mary’s letter but it always cuts the encounter off, even if I put the letter away, 2/10 times it triggers but the encounter is at the end…

[@normalplayer7377]

Oh Strange Man, who is so wise in life & death, what are the secrets of Rhodes, Lemoyne?

[@flyingmelon553]

YAY! A new vid!😁

[@EdnardyLial]

There is a theory that the wolf naked man is the son of the gunsmith

[@juliannevarez7]

How do you get that flower on your hat?

[@idkwhattoputhere6394]

At the trapper

[@juliannevarez7]

@@idkwhattoputhere6394 really? There’s no challenge requirement?

[@idkwhattoputhere6394]

@@juliannevarez7 yea you just need a feather to use I think😁

[@juliannevarez7]

@@idkwhattoputhere6394 gotcha. Thanks!

[@michaellopez3930]

Best game ever

[@vicvht]

Which track from the OST is being used?

[@lolspotifyfree1-ff9ld]

2:42 bro the clerk, Alden aint GAY. Just because the bartender says he “enjos company by other gentleman”, doesn’t mean that Alden is gay. Seems like you’ve missed an important part of the story, where Alden secretly informs about stagecoaches and where they’re heading, so that Hosea and Arthur can rob it. It is also mentioned that Alden frequently helps out other people with informing them about stagecoaches and he gets his share for it. Also the term “gentlemen”, i feel you misunderstand. “Gentlemen” just refers to people in general who attends business, and well fact is women don’t do nearly as much business as the man does. What the bartender is saying is that there is something fishy going on with Alden, he AINT GAY that’s ridiculous

[@jessejames2546]

Strange Man uploads, I click

[@woodlandthorns]

Does anyone know the name of the songs used in this video? Especially the one at 11:14?

[@The.Frozen.Forest]

Imagine yourself in a frozen forest

[@S1eepy0w1]

no not black ops 3

[@steezeaustin316]

I knew aiden was gay. Dude sounded zesty af 😅

[@alejandromolinafuentes5795]

How is possible to find grays on 1907

[@PrincePosey]

Do ghost train please

[@Caesar-ik9zf]

dang early love your videos

[@Hd2Exo45]

ITS HERE

[@allanbtg]

Could someone tell me the song name that starts at 8:05?

[@TheRealTerraBlade]

1:20 Why are you watching the dog pee?

[@redpie32]

Probably bc it shows who its owners murderer was. Its probably peeing on their grave bc it despises them

[@VegetaClan993]

The goat

[@amir.music2005]

8:51 😂😂😂

[@Fabiokht]

How are you strange man

[@KingKendrickTheGod233]

Please make a Kendrick Lamar video

[@Xiiki]

Knowing rodes, Willie probably died due to a race fuelled attack

[@louieo.blevinsmusic2011]

Didn’t even realize that about Mark Johnson. You sure it’s a “bad”version of John? Cause Rhodes gunsmith Jasper Feeney is another version of Arthur Morgan as well considering both have 12 lettered names, (6 in the 1st/6 in the 2nd) and they both lost their boys as well as their lives. Looking a the “son’s drawing” it sure does remind me of Arthur fishing with Jack….could Jack be Arthur’s son? Hmmmmm

[@simonster-9094]

Arthur went fishing with his son, as he mentioned to Jack during their fishing trip.

[@damienc2199]

💛🔥

[@chrishelbling3879]

When Arthur bought a whiskey in 1899 for 50 cents, that was $15.68 in today dollars. At the fancy bar in St. Denis, where he was shocked by a $1 whiskey, that is $31.36 today. Yet, John's $2 whiskey in 1911 is $66.22 for a shot today. Thanks, Biden.

[@Smasho8000]

LGB!

[@Towwanieberlin]

I love suburban white people getting mad over inflation which is normal and blaming it on presidents

[@CollaborativeDataAccounts]

"I Did That!"

[@noorulhasan4904]

I don't think you understand the red dead economy

[@chrishelbling3879]

I suppose, if all your money is stolen, by murdering people, then it doesn't matter how much a whiskey costs?

[@Rexyy_606]

Alden said he had a wife

[@simonster-9094]

Ah yes, his wife who's never in town and who "he buys clothes for". 😂

[@seekprateek8]

The Settlement that Madam Nazar was talking about was the outcast black community. Due to the well known history of Rhodes.

[@imnotoula]

I knew he was gay that aldeni knew it

[@baslanofficial925]

r u real?

[@bigdj29]

When she says a wide river it could be the strange man's house

[@TAKEmoneyARTHUR]

I view and comment ❤❤❤❤

[@KMZPutra]

It seems like the content this time is not very detailed, what's wrong with you?

[@FrankMartorana-vh1ot]

So Mark Johnson is like John Marston, does that mean his son was also fathered by another man?

[@psychictrauma]

is pearsons wife black????

[@mk71618]

What makes you think that? If it's his actual wife, it'd be impossible for her to be black since marriage between whites/non-whites didn't become legal in the US until relatively recently, in 1967. Before that, it was a felony punishable with a 5+ years prison sentence I believe, depending on the state.

[@tpbrcombo]

Than’k you. I could swear her voice was provided by a black actress.

[@L4ftyOne]

Another video of your personal theorys without evidence

[@MQN_123]

Some of these are literally in the game. Don’t tell me you prefer MrBossFTW over Strange Man…

[@philaufan6]

*theories

[@kabeljager6645]

Dude it's a video game who gives a F if it's fact or theory

[@tpbrcombo]

Ah the guy who’s fun at parties is with us

[@simonster-9094]

Which part of the video do you think is a theory?

[@gumbyshrimp2606]

Find a voice actor to read the lines

[@RikDebruyne-pu7tj]

No, this is perfect, just game sounds and text

[@REDACTED107]

He once added a voice, and no one liked it, personally, I dont mind it. But he removed it after the comments telling him its bad.

[@gumbyshrimp2606]

@@REDACTED107 if it was a bad AI voice I understand The best storytelling channels have humans speaking

[@RikDebruyne-pu7tj]

@@REDACTED107 it just felt wrong tbh

[@REDACTED107]

@@RikDebruyne-pu7tj Indeed

[@StRANGEMANRDR]

stop posting copies of my videos