서바이벌 프로그램에 대한 솔직한 생각

[@FOXBEAR]

저희는 이렇게 생각해 봤습니다. 여러분은 요즘 넘쳐나는 서바이벌 프로그램에 대해 어떻게 생각하시나요?

[@charinabacalso97]

Many foreigners like me like MIXNINE of course because it's produced by YG and we all know that YG only produces REAL TALENTED KIDS,, its just other Koreans dont know how to see like this

[@charinabacalso97]

PLEASE SUPPORT MIXNINE!!!

[@FOXBEAR]

Koreans seem to be tired of the competition programs that are getting too many these days. But I still love YG and I support Mixnine :)

[@FOXBEAR]

of course! :)

[@truejs4492]

방송 다 끝나고 조회수 높은 공연보고 나서 비교해가면서 방송하시는 것도 좋을 것 같습니다

[@jypnggstraykids3238]

Stray Kids rap-line is very different from every JYP's groups. They are a strong and legit rappers. Changbin and Jisung and Chan. 3RACHA.

[@natnut2008]

I actually disagree with the 20 something male reviewer : the rookies and trainees of Mixnine are more skilled and talented than the veterans of The Unit. So far the performances of Mixnine have been more impressive than those on The Unit.

[@blinkblink9297]

natnut2008 yup. I agree. The mix nine contestants have raw talent. I wish them success

[@eennzz915]

Definitely agreed to this. People kept on bashing YG. But he is not called a good producer w/o nothing. He has really good taste for talented people. He may be rude sometimes but that is how he motivates people. Look at his artists. Those people are not afraid to tell the public that YG ia really harsh to them but they still love and respect him. The show may not be that popular in SK but believe me, it'll rise and those trainees will be more popular in the future not only in SK but internationally. YG is known globally, that's a fact. They may criticize YG, but accept it, kpop has been known worldwide because of known YG artists.

[@FOXBEAR]

Thank you for your good feedback. We are so nice to have other comments :)

[@yana9342]

Definitely agree to this. I've watched both The unit and Mixnine performance, but the mixnine performances of My House and Love In The Ice cover left a huge impression on me. Amazing

[@savorymiso939]

because the performance on mixnine is categorized based on vocal, dance, and rap so they can focus meanwhile mission for the unit is to cover that song. just for you to know, the unit is 100% live without backtrack. they didn't even go to recording. and some of the contestants on the unit is incredibly talented but not shown such as yeoun melody day (the winner of masked singer I forget the eps), feeldog dance (you can see it on hit the stage), kanto (member of troy) I guess he is still the most talented rapper if he participates on mixnine and much more. so I guess it doesn't fair if you compare the unit skill and mixnine only based on those performances^^

[@littlethings7778]

Straykids for the win

[@jeremaea6288]

though StrayKids is kind of a survival program, but its definitely not an audition program. The members were formed by themselves/leader by their standards and not the company(JYP); hence, they made this program to evaluate this debut team

[@수달-h4r]

스트레이키즈는 멤버들끼리 경쟁을 하는 프로그램이 아니라 애초에 멤버가 짜여있고 박진영이 심사를 해서 실력이 부족한것같은 사람들을 탈락시키는 프로그램임. 한마디로 박진영 맘에 들게끔 멤버들이 같이 연습을 하고 팀워크를 키워나가는 과정을 담은거임 ㅇㅇ 난 솔직히 믹스나인이나 더 유닛보단 스트레이키즈가 더 재밌었음. 애초에 서로 경쟁하는게 아니니깐 가족 같은 분위기가 오히려 난 좋게 느껴지던데.. 스트레이키즈랑 더유닛, 믹스나인은 다른건데 여기서 스트레이키즈가 더유닛과 믹스나인에 단점만 모아놓았다고 하면 안됨. 스트레이키즈는 트와이스 했던 식스틴처럼 한 기획사에 있는 연습생들이 같이 팀을 짜고 그 멤버대로 데뷔를 하느냐 안하느냐인데 더유닛이랑 믹스나인같은 서로 경쟁하는 프로랑 같이 비교를 할 수 없음. 애초에 다른 목적을 둔 프로기때문에

[@jae_xx9296]

In mixnine, i think boys are more talented than girls...they are not many girls that stand out with talent when i watch the show (my own opinion)..the boys are way more talented and i can remember many of them. For yg harsh comments toward the contestants...i think it's not that harsh , it's normal for me...maybe bcuz i'm yg stan so i'm used to it

[@blinking4blackpink291]

International fan here and I only watch mixnine :) I love the "drama and happy ending " story of the program and the participants' showcasing their talents. Despite the drama, I can see they all looked happy, healthy and performed so well.

[@yenakwon4980]

스트레이 키즈가 오디션 프로는 아니지만 개인적으로 제일 의미있게 진행되는것 같고 애들이 넘넘 짱인것 같음

[@hxpewxrld]

I wish Mix Nine would fix their editing, the contestants are all crazy talented. They deserve more recognition!

[@amiwu517]

Personally i like mixnine more😊 because the contestants have good raw talents and they can explore that more in the show😊 but i hate their editing, it's such a mess! But thankfully it get a little bit better this last episode, even it still a mess.. i would disagree about people who said yg being a dick and said many mean comments to the contestans..i think it's just from the way you look at it😊 well, his comments kinda true tho! He just said what he saw and thought at that moment about the contestants and it mostly right and good for them to be better next time😊 i think he more like simon cowell or gordon ramsay when in terms judging people, they more in straight forward style, just like gordon said, " if its good, i'll tell you it's good and if its shit, i'll tell you it's shit!" No need to sugar coating anything, just sraight to the problem.. i think that's better for them, as they will, someday, enter the more harsh world with more harsh people and way more mean comments- idol world😊 ah, i must kinda disagree with you when you compared stray kids with other two shows because even though the three of them are survival shows but stray kids is more like mix&match and no mercy for me..

[@miacchumiacchu5687]

stray kids ❤❤

[@HabibAh-iz3dm]

stray kids 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

[@FOXBEAR]

stray kids 👍👍

[@dayortega6255]

The Cover song... Love in The Ice... Wonderful🎶🙌 In mix nine! 2 pm dance... I love❤️❤️❤️😍

[@fff_lee]

믹스나인이 참가자들 매력과 퀄은 좋은데 170명이나되서... 탈락자 생긴후에 더 볼만할듯 송한겸 김효진 응원함!!

[@FOXBEAR]

맞아요 유유님 말씀에 공감! 지금은 참가자들이 너무 많아서 거기에 한명한명의 캐릭터를 보기 어려운 거 같아요~~!! 이제 점점 더 볼만해지지 않을까싶네요.

[@a_lost_staysider]

stray kids elimination was more heart breaking and the the others tho cuz its only focusing on 9 kids so we see every single thing they want to show and they cant get bad editing cuz well they arent against each other they are only fighting the company. we get to know each member one by one, their personalities and talents which is why we end up being attached to stray kids.

[@oncetwice3039]

성격 비슷한 프로그램끼리 묶어보면 믹스나인, 더유닛 => 프로듀스101, 슈스케, 케이팝스타 등 스트레이키즈 => 리얼다큐 빅뱅(빅뱅), 열혈남아(2PM, 2AM), 위너(WINNER), 믹스앤매치(iKON), 노머시(MONSTA X), 식스틴(트와이스) 등

[@FOXBEAR]

맞아요!ㅎㅎㅎ 프로그램 성향을 정확하게 말씀해주셨네요! 하지만 저는 더 거기적으로 넓게는 서바이벌 오디션 프로그램이다라고 봤습니당 가볍게 재밌게 보셨길 바랄게요♡

[@eennzz915]

You're wrong! PD101 was not the first survival program. WIN was first aired than PD101. Then followed by MiX and Match.

[@FOXBEAR]

We talked about 'PD101' as the program that started to become popular in recent survival audition program in Korea.

[@arianabalqis6257]

eennzz915 your right

[@ronnnmmm]

Bigbang Documentary is the first tho

[@user-pl9jr8vu4r]

스트레이키즈는 서바이벌 보단 멤버끼리 다데뷔하려고 뭉쳐서 하는거여서 서바이벌에는 거리가쫌 먼거같네요.. 갠적으로 스트레이키즈팬이여서 살짝 마음이 좀상했네요...

[@DulcisAbsentia]

Personally, as i am a YG stan, i really love MIXNINE💞 the contestants are really really talented (as expected from YG) even though most of them are trainees they have a really bright future ~🌸 The only thing that i appreciate of The Unit is the fact they give 2nd possibilities to unknown idols but as a show it's boring,the judges don't really "judge", while StrayKids can't be even considered a survival cuz no one (as expected) got eliminated and this too is boring. I love more YG's survivals cuz he doesn't sugar coat words and keep on being objective like in BIGBANG documentary,WIN and MIX&MATCH

[@kryshalee4528]

Mixnine! Because i can see a real talent in that show! Fighting Mix nine!!

[@vivimimi4064]

I'm inter fan... I like mixnine form YG... because I think so fun I don't like unit because have many drama 😀😀

[@polly705]

I'm an international fan & i've only watched all episodes of STRAY KIDS - prolly because i'm a JYPE stan & I just love 3RACHA's songs (which compose of Chan, Jisung & Changbin) they are just so talented to be composing, writing & producing their own music. I was just enjoying the ride of the show & their growth b'coz I had the feeling they'll debut as OT9 despite eliminating 2 persons along the way (& really like the premise of the show w/c is to strive debut all together so yeaaah) For the Unit & Mix 9 i just watch a couple of video performances here on youtube but not really watch the whole show. I just enjoy some videos here & there but I dont really like to invest my time watching both shows knowing how heartbreaking it'll be & the disappointment if who i'm rooting for wont be able to make it.

[@sih314]

To be honest you don't have to compare stray kids to mix nine or the unit Mix9 and the unite both are survival shows with lot of already debuted groups members Lot of companies Lot of competition and drama Members that competing have already fans that brought them with then to watch the show JYP didn't even try to compete with those shows cuz it's just really different aspect Stray kids is just a process of debuting JYP new boy group with completely unknown trainees 9 members that have no competition between them just trying to debut together And JYP pushing them to the limit so they can give more So for sure won't compete with those full scale survival shows with Huge amount of participants from different companies

[@looyee27]

I've been watching The Unit and Mixnine, and I have to say that they're not that great. I maybe prefer Mixnine out of the two. Its just that the formats seem to be so similar. The one thing that i will find annoying about Mixnine is that its probably almost certain that a boy group will come out of the show because of the high female audience within kpop in general.

[@FOXBEAR]

We thought that only Korean fans think so. You've seen foreign fans like that. I totally sympathize. The team that girls support is inevitable. In fact, I do not want to have a problem with program planning. I am interested in watching a little more. Thank you for watching this video :)

[@욯깅]

I only pressed for the prince in the thumbnail~~~ However to give my thoughts ..I think Stray kids >> Mixnine >> The uni+ . Mixnine editing at first used to be *horrible*, but it's gotten better now ~

[@paraengcakhita766]

What unsuccessful? Wow how could u be so cruel (boy who wear school uniform), u should know theyre really work hard for this show, if u know u will cry!!! And lets see, i believe oneday Stray Kids (they will) become the top BB, bcs theyre so talented!!! tx

[@youngjinim7899]

스트레이키즈는 애초에 제왑내에서 하는 신인 보이그룹 런칭 프로그램에 가깝기 때문에 서바이벌 프로그램들과 같은 선상에서 비교하는 것은 좀 무리가 있는 것 같습니다.

[@FOXBEAR]

네 용진님 그 말씀도 맞습니다만 요즘 프로그램이 많이 변형되고 결합되고 있기때문에 저희는 스트레이키즈의 기저에는 서바이벌 프로그램의 느낌이 깔려있다고 보았고, 거시적으로 넓게 보고 묶어서 이야기 나눠보았답니다 :) 가볍게 재밌게 저희가 진짜 하고싶었던 이야기를 한번쯤 생각하며 보셨길 바랄게요♡

[@youngjinim7899]

그렇게 분류될 수도 있겠군요. 답장 감사드립니다. 항상 동영상 잘 보고 있습니다ㅎㅎ

[@FOXBEAR]

네 용진님! 이렇게 댓글로 이야기나누니 좋네요 고마워요 자주 봬요 :)

[@SARANGE2]

다시 되돌림 될거 같네요.. 지금은 서바이벌 프로그램을 해서 인기를 얻었고 데뷔한다 치더라도 결국엔 그화력을 끝까지 유지하면서 가지는 못할거 같아요.. 인기는 언제든 식기 마련이니까..ㅠ 지금 아이오아이 멤버들은 각자 인기가 있지만 개별 소속사에서 데뷔한 걸그룹이 아이오아이 만큼 인기를 얻고 있지 못하니까ㅠㅠ 또 그 걸그룹들속에서 인기를 얻지 못한 멤버가 서바이벌프로그램에 다시 나오겠죠..

[@FOXBEAR]

쭈꾸리님 오셨네여! 맞아요 공감해요~~!!! 아이오아이였을 때 그렇게 인기가 많았음에도 개별 그룹으로 돌아가니 그 돌풍을 이어가는게 참 어려워보이네요. 프듀 이후 오디션 서바이벌 프로그램이 너무나 많아져서 이제는 관심도도 집중되기 어려운 거 같구요~~!ㅎㅎ

[@user-ck2tl1dw2d]

I really like jyp survival show Stray kids 👍

[@97kuroneko]

As 1 of the Intl fan who watch 3 of them, what I can say are: -MIXNINE: I don't know how YG planned the show, because it's really messy. The MC, camera work, screen-time, too much dramas, favorable picks, harshness everywhere, it's a total mess. The only thing that keeps me to watch this show is only 'the contestants'. -The Unit: it could be a perfect 'no-controversies' survival program, unless they didn't accept a trainee / an actor to the show. Their intention is too give second chance to idols, accepting someone who never debuted before is really breaking the rules. But putting that aside, everything is 'acceptable' to watch -Stray Kids: I really like this program bcs I'm a JYP Stan and really anticipated how the trainees are. And I was so glad that they said there will be no elimination, but.............yeah, it would never be a 'survival' program if they wasn't supposed to survive. But they should never 'lie' since the start.

[@FOXBEAR]

Wow ... I read good opinions well !! I admired you.

[@utamed9311]

Mixnine is not that messy the knly messy episode is 2-6ep and the rest are not . YG is YG she motivated the contestants to do better because they can and look at them now aleays slaying the performance every mission

[@nadyadevi1288]

sorry for my opinion, because i never see the unit before. I think i like Mixnine because their contestan is talented and this program can be place to improve their skill. Mixnine also give a chance to show the story how the contestan survive, not only a popular also the hidden contestan. Beside a bad editing i wish its be better. People's hate the bad comment for YG i thinks its normal, because so many korean youth make their dreams to be an Idol but their skill cannot be compare. from that, i think they can realize and so fast to find another way. in other way, i still dissapointed about online Voting, especially for Shin Ryujin And Jinyoung. I think they are too popular. the Voter must be more objective, to see talent, another contestan also show a great talent and performance. like Choi Hyunsik and Kang Minkyung 😍 he should be consider to be The debut Contestan. lastly, I want to ask, Can an International fans also participate to vote? #Thanks..

[@mrRiddle12]

i love Stray Kids the most. and can't wait for their debut!!!

[@chisato931]

from international fans view, many people actually watched all 3. Except stray kids, The Unit vs Mixnine is actually more relevant to discuss here. Intl fans seems to be like Mixnine >> The unit. But the editing of both are so messy !

[@FOXBEAR]

Aha! International fans look like that. I sympathize. The real two programs are too dirty to edit. I am afraid that the talented and possible trainees will be consumed. And do international fans usually cheer for boy groups? Or are you cheering on a girl group? I am personally curious.

[@chisato931]

personally we kind of cheering for both. but we will spend more money for boy group ( concert, album, merchandises ). so thats why Wanna One fanmeeting ticket sold out in just few hours ( Malaysia fanmeet). Wanna One popularity is so amazing, so i think boygroup will benefit more.

[@FOXBEAR]

i See. I was relieved of anxiety. Thanks for the friendly answer :)

[@MANDAE8298]

영상 나오신 분들 아무래도 영상 촬영 날짜가 세 프로그램 시작한지 얼마 안된거 같아 '스키즈' 잘 모르고 제일 폭망이라 하시던데.... 프로그램 중 가장 적은 제작비 쓰고 제일 잘된게 스트레이키즈. 헬리베이터 조회수 현재 1200만회. 어지간한 인기 남돌도 3달안에 이정도 조회수 내기 힘듦. 해외에서 반응 폭발적인거 맞음 그리고 학생분이 다른건 다 꿰고 잘 말하시는데 하나 잘못 지적한게, 더유닛 믹나의 단점을 다 갖춘게 아니라 그 두 프로의 장점을 다 갖춤. 실력 좋은 더유닛+뉴페이스인 믹스나인. 더유닛 믹스나인처럼 일회용도 아니라, 데뷔하면 더 잘될수밖에 없음. 그것도 알아야 함. 워너원 끝나면 이제 그 팬들 어디로 갈까? 전성기 찍고 슬슬 내려오는 2010년대 초반 데뷔한 남돌 팬들이 어디로 빠질까? 스키즈는 지금 데뷔타이밍까지 기가막힘 페북 봐도 생각했던거보다 국내팬들 많음. 그리고 확실히 3사 남돌이라 관심 엄청 많더라. 거기에 믹스나인 신류진 대박나서 사실상 JYP 이득ㅇㅇ

[@수달-h4r]

JMT Kor. 와 내가 하고 싶었던말이다 ㅎㅎㅎㅎ 한 기획사에 새로운 팀을 뽑고 그 멤버대로 데뷔가 되느냐 안되느냐를 결정하는 프로그램인데 믹스나인이랑 더유닛같은 서로 경쟁하는 프로그램들의 단점만 가졌다는건 좀 아님ㅋㅋ

[@쟁안]

솔직히 서바이벌은 프로듀스101 이 제일 괜찮고 신선한듯..? 프로듀스101이 화제되고 서바이벌 프로그램이 너무 많아진 느낌..

[@FOXBEAR]

프듀가 참 말도 많았지만 재밌었던 거 같아요ㅎㅎ 갠적으루 그 후에 이제 프로그램들이 너무 많아지고 다양해지다보니 좀 관심도도 자연스레 분산되고.. 프듀가 끝난지 그렇게 긴 시간이 지나지 않다보니 지치는 것도 있는 거 같구요ㅎ

[@jypnggstraykids3238]

I don't even understand every single words for this video but most of international fans supports STRAY KIDS!!!! 😍😍👏👏👏❤💚💜💖💞. I just hope Koreans will appreciate the talents that Stray Kids have. They deserve it. 👏💪💪❤💚💜.STRAY KIDS FIGHTING!!!

[@FOXBEAR]

Thank you for supporting 'Stray Kids'! And thanks for watching this video! :)

[@jypnggstraykids3238]

I appreciate every videos you've made. You guys did a good job!!! 👍👍👏👏👏. Keep up. ☺💪💪

[@martinamartins9595]

Lee Felix IloveYOu..

[@RaulAzreen]

as an international fan whom watch both the unit and mix nine.. iwould say mix nine contestant especially the one who made in debut team is slightly talented than the unit.. the only reason i watch the unit at the first place is because i am rooting for jeup of imfact..started to notice him and cheered for him when he is a contestant in i can see your voice..his rendition of wild flower by park hyo shin is damn good.. while for mix nine i suddenly wtach itbecause of i found the first episode at youtube..then i followed the program,and then i found donghun from a.c.e that also join i can see your voice..now i am a.c.e fan..haha.. the editing is weird,the way they rearrange the story,with blurring the face of contestant, then when the real competitionstart..damn the contestant were really good..now i am rooting for the success of all debut team of mixnine the boys..

[@유하나-c9c]

일단 믹스나인은 계속 보는데 참가자들 이름이 기억이 안나는게 캐릭터를 못 잡아요 오늘 150분을 방영했는데 기억에 남는 참가자가 없어요그리고 더 유닛은 남자 여자 최종 9인에 들면 뮤뱅이나 광고 등 보상이 확실한데 믹스나인은 양현석이 워낙 말을 너무 바꾸니깐최종합격 해도 위너 아이콘처럼 프로듀싱 해준다고 하고 1년후 내보내는거 아닌가 모르겠네요

[@FOXBEAR]

네 하나님 말씀대로 참가자가 너무 ㅁ낳아서 그런 거 같아요. 이제 좀 탈락자가 생기면 한명 한명 좀 더 스토리도 알고 이 사람이 어떤사람인지 알아가는 기회가 있기를 저도 매주 보면서 기다리고 있어요ㅎ

[@eliskaprouzova2215]

Out of these 3 the only show I watched till end (I started to watch all 3) was Stray Kids. I didn't like Mixnine because I think YG should take good care of his own artist And not to create another group which will be disbanded in the end anyway. For Unit I thought IT was good idea but I don't like that there is so much similarities with PD101 (which I loved) and because there is so many constentants and So unfair screentime that you don't really have chance to see their true talent. Stray Kids is really different- only 9 members- you get chance to know them, they are not formed by company, they are not singing covers of another artist songs (ok accept ep.1 H.O.T song and ep.7 battle with YG- Blackpink song) but they produce their own songs and they write their own lyrics. Its about team not about who is 1st place or 9th place. And there is no elimination in the end :) we all knew that JYP Is gonna bring 2 "eliminated" members back :)

[@mellowmell497]

lee rubin on the thumbnail and i click

[@레벨업레베럽]

스트레이키즈 재밌는데.... 애초에 대형기획사 아이돌런칭 자체가 꿀잼

[@FOXBEAR]

맞아요ㅎㅎㅎㅎ 이때부터 응원하는 팀이 잘되면 어찌나 기분이 좋은지!

[@강유찬너만보현]

에이스 멤버가 믹스나인,더유닛에 출현했어요! *믹스나인* _김세윤 김병관 이동훈_ *더유닛* _박준희 강유찬_ 에게 관심을 가져주세요 여러분!

[@FOXBEAR]

맞습니당ㅎㅎ 에이스 응원합니다 ! 실력도 모두 좋고 꽃길 걸었으면 좋겠어요 저도 응원하겠습니다!!

[@강유찬너만보현]

FOXBEAR) 감사드려요!

[@caratplli1031]

더유닛..... 리부팅 프로그램이라고 해서 괜찮다고 생각했었는데.... 처음 부팅도 안한 사람을 뽑았어서 실망한..... 보이프렌드 동현, 유키스 준, 전 헬로비너스 윤조 많이 투표해주세요ㅠㅠ

[@FOXBEAR]

ㅠㅠ 더유닛...... 조금 아쉽긴하지만 열심히 응원을..!

[@withfia]

Thanks for showing korean perspective to international fans.. As International fans, i love Mixnine more than The Unit and Stray kids tbh. We understand that YG has his standards and capability to create good team with his experiences as CEO. But i do agree about sometimes he is really harsh toward the trainee but behind that he still give them last chance. And about the manager things i think he just said that he know the person and used to be YG composer or manager... he also like that with their artist .. so he is consistent and i like that approach better than encouragement from other program that i think cant help anything. They should be triggered by something.. And theres no something like drama in mixnine i think. Even like birthday party and others filmed in behind the scene.. They showing team practice, the show, and result... As for the unit, lately i also become their fan cause of their skills. But i think they should work harder like Rain said. This is their last chance. They are not trainee but pro .. and because of i know a lot o name already like Feeldog, Yang Jiwon, Euna Kim, Hansol, etc, watching them is less thrill than mixnine but still interesting tho.. As for stray kids. I hate JYP for eliminating Felix hhhha... thats all.. hhhha

[@janTH-bo1jb]

Stray Kids😘😘💕

[@ewhlsxk]

idk other but, mixnine is way better than the unit mixnine is about skill, and the unit is about popularity

[@ruthuliangelina3518]

I was confused on how they mediaplay or advertise stray kids program before its started. At first I thought there wont be any eliminination because they have to debut together as 9 member group. However iirc JYP said that he will eliminate members if they're not on par with other trainees in the show, but maybe many viewers not really took his words seriously that's why we really shocked when jyp eliminate minho, then felix. But in the end it's still jyp vs trainees

[@더쿠틴]

더유닛 흥하자 유앤비❤️

[@mydungong8470]

The only reason that makes me watch Mixnine is Lee Rubin :)))))))

[@아토영]

서연언니 ㅜㅜ 콘서트 부럽습니다 ! 20대분들 , 이찬오빠 ? 다른분들도 // 설명 너무 잘하셔요 💨

[@이찬주-u5f]

13 개 의 보 석 들 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ저는 이찬주랍니다!

[@아토영]

이찬주 글쿤요 이런

[@FOXBEAR]

설찬주..?

[@FOXBEAR]

10대 삐약이 서연 양 , 찬주 군 이번에 멜뮤에 다녀왔다는! 다들 열씨미 덕질하기 바쁘네요ㅎㅎㅎㅎㅎ

[@utamed9311]

Mixnine is the best dont include stray kids because that different between the unit and mixnine

[@zz-be2cp]

나는 스트레이키즈가 제일 재밌음ㅋㅋ그리고 이거 서바이벌아님. 자생리얼리티형식임.

[@FOXBEAR]

그렇져~~~! 거기에 요즘 서바이벌 프로그램이 유행하니 좀 넣었을뿐! :)

[@마유나-e5f]

썸네일 이루빈❤️

[@sone2028]

I personally like The Unit more, I feel more comfortable watching The Unit especially because I hate listening to YG’s mean comments...etc I like how in The Unit, the idols are put into teams where they must work together to perform perfectly so they can win

[@FOXBEAR]

The Unit is also a good program. It feels so good that you cheer. I hope to support them in the future :)

[@romat2596]

Sone #CatchGG so basically you just said the exact same format of Mixnine lol

[@ss-nu8gq]

스트레이 키즈는 투표로 통해 탈락된것도 아닌 데뷔하기에는 실력이 부족해서 탈락을 시켰던거고ㅠ 다행이 9인조로 완전채 데뷔를 했슷니당😍

[@savorymiso939]

-The editing, camera work, and the concept for the unit is good but I think they didn't pour that much money to this survival because the stage is just basically the backscreen/? and the outfit for performance is not that good:(( one thing that I hate is they pass actor and trainee it's not fair -mixnine actually have much potential to trend but the camera work and editing really sucks and they don't give the screentime between boys and girls the same amount plus all the drama about yg (yg have more screentime than trainees is not fair) -straykids ahhh I think they will not eliminate the boys!! (missing minho and felix) but it's really fun to watch esp the jyp vs yg thing~ and they are all talented haha guys let's not fight about who is more talented they are all equally talented it's just those survival which didn't show their talent properly sincerely, survival and underrated boygroup trash p.s. thankyou for using rubin as thumbnail!! it's really clickbaiting for me

[@태정태세문단속-o4r]

세 프로그램 다 보지 않지만 프로듀스 101 시즌2를 본 사람으로서 이런 서바이벌 게임은 결코 좋다고 생각되지는 않아요. 이목을 끌게되면 연습생들은 데뷔하기 전부터 인기를 누릴 수 있고 데뷔하고 나서 주목받지 못했던 사람들에게는 재조명되는 좋은 기회가 되겠죠. 하지만 좋던 나쁘던 시청자들은 심사위원의 입맛대로 내린 평가와 연출자의 입장에서 보여지는 참가자들의 모습만으로 그들을 판단하기 때문에 참가자들은 이미지만 소비당하게되고 대중들에게 제대로 된 평가도 받지 못하는 경우가 많을거에요. 얼마나 간절하고 얼마나 노력하는지, 실력과 발전가능성이 전부 노출되는 것이 아니기 때문에 대중에게 그다지 중요하지 않을 수도 있죠. 소비하는 사람이 있기에 계속 이런 프로그램이 나오는 것이겠지만 시청자들도 이런 단점은 고려하며 봐야한다고 생각돼요:)

[@FOXBEAR]

정말 공감합니다. 이런 이야기를 좀 나눠보고 싶었어요. 진짜 좋은 댓글 먼저 감사드려요. 많은 사람들이 조남(?)님 처럼 서바이벌 프로그램을 다시한번 볼 수 있는 계기가 됐음 좋겠네요.

[@태정태세문단속-o4r]

FOXBEAR 으엣 댓글 감사합니다! 다음 2편에서 어떤 이야기를 나누실지 기대되네요:) (그리고 조이입니다ㅎㅎ)

[@FOXBEAR]

아하~!!! 그렇군요 띠딩ㅋㅋ 2편은... 30일에 라이브를 기획중인데 그때 잠깐 이야기나누던가 해야겠어요! :)

[@user-dengdengjajinmori]

더유닛은 한번 실패한 아이돌에게 기회를 한번 더 주고 남여 둘다 재데뷔하는 착한프로그램이고(더유닛 1회앞부분 참고)아이돌 이였던 분들인지 춤하고 노래 잘해요!악마의 편집도 없데요! 믹스나인은 연습생 대상으로 한 서바이벌이라서 프듀나 다름없죠 프듀랑 다른건 양형석이 직접 소속사마다 가서 캐스팅하고 남,녀가 같이 한 프로그램에나와서 남여 자존심 대결인 것 뿐이에요.제가 듣기로는 악마의 편집이 좀..있다고..ㅠ 스트레이 키즈는 뭐..인기얻자고 하는거고..홍보용으로 쓴거라서 신경은 않쓰이네요 ㅎㅎ 결론:저는 더 유닛처럼 연습생 대상으로 새로운 그룹 만드는 것보다는 기회를 한번더 주는 서바이벌 프로그램이 더 좋아요~

[@user-dengdengjajinmori]

더유닛 1회 앞부분에서 비가 이 프로그램을 선택한 이유를 꼭 봐주세요

[@minhotaurs]

가운데 학생분 상당히 예리하시네여 ㅎㄷㄷ

[@FOXBEAR]

헉 민호타우르스님 직접 이렇게 댓글까지ㅜㅜ 어제 연락처를 미쳐 주고받지 못해서 아쉬웠는데....! 페북 친구 신청을 살포시 보내봅니다. 항상 잘보고있어요!!

[@이찬주-u5f]

민호타우르스 헐ㄹ민호타우르스님ㅜㅜㅜㅜ 셀럽께서 제 칭찬을 해주시다니ㅜㅜㅜ 아직 너무 부족한데두 이쁘게 봐주시니 감사합니다ㅜ

[@shofasalsabila3762]

Mixnine👍👍👍👍

[@fromsouth9980]

I watch mixnine. For editing i can say is kinda flat. Maybe because they really want to show the talent not the drama. I like that. And from what i see. Trainee in mixnine much better than the unit. And the original song for competition really really great. Its like the song that you can put in album. Anyway not only mixnine who broke the rules. The purpose of the unit is rebooting idol. But why can young girl & rookie actor be part of that .

[@ohduhree7342]

Some people are saying they prefer mixnine because it's a YG show and for sure the chosen ones have real talent. Well, way to put those idols down. Just because they're not in a YG show doesn't mean they don't have real talent. I'm a follower of The Unit but I never felt the need to bash mixnine or its participants just to promote my preference. I know The Unit has its own mess and shortcomings but heck we can't discount the fact that the show gave those idols another chance. I bet a lot of people following this show were also able to appreciate other talented idols they never noticed before. It's no small feat. Just sayin'

[@Soso69110]

Mixnine is my favorite show at the moment ! ^^

[@윤범진-r3l]

서바이벌 프로그램 단점 뭔가 짜고 하는듯한 연출이 많았고 예능학교 라는 프로그램 같은 경우는 이미 대뷔할 사람이 정해져 있어서 억지로 연출 시키는게 단점입니당ㅎ

[@leeyejin55443]

더유닛은 나쁘지 않고 스트레이 키즈는 재밌게 봤는데..

[@eyekingjinsung]

Lee Rubin😍🔥♥️

[@user-uy3od9tl4t]

요새 한창 잘보고있어요ㅎㅎ다음영상도 기대하겠습니다 ..너무나 재미있게 보고있어용 :)

[@user-uy3od9tl4t]

서바이벌프로그램을 많이 해서 신선하지 못하고 재미가 없어지고 딱히 흥미가 없어져요 ..

[@FOXBEAR]

하율님 고마워요. 이런 댓글 한마디에 힘을얻어요! 멤버들과 함께 재밌게 만들어볼게요 :)

[@FOXBEAR]

맞아요 저도 너무 많아서 그런가 흥미가 안생기더라구요 완전 공감합니다ㅜㅜ 이제 지치네요 이런 서바이벌 프로그램이 신선하지도 않구요!

[@심유민-n7s]

가운데 남학생 정말 똘똘하게 설명한다

[@FOXBEAR]

심유민 그쵸 유민님! 찬주군 완전 똘똘!!

[@호호오-l1w]

ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 배경이 소년24 때 해준이라 호다닥 들어옴... 루빈 왕자님 사랑행

[@user-so7qr2uh3z]

잉 표지 루빈이다!!!!!!!! 루빈이였어 역쉬 존잘이다ㅠ

[@igot7oncemydayjyptrash505]

Stray kids jjang

[@wjjun]

1:27 WHAAAAT?! ARE YOU DEAF AND/OR BLIND?!

[@MANDAE8298]

아쉽게도 지금와서 보니 예측 실패했네요. 더유닛 믹스나인 시청률 처참하고 신류진 말고는 대중적 화제 인물 아무도 없죠.... 반면 스키즈는 유튜브 조회수 1400만 넘었고 프리데뷔 초동 만장에 페북 유명 페이지에서 몇몇 멤버들 굉장히 핫하더라고요. 이 채널 보면서 느끼는데, 패널분들이 아이돌을 전반적으로는 잘 아시는데 깊게는 모르시는듯

[@FOXBEAR]

네 믹스나인은 역시 예상대로 초반의 흐름을 이어나가지 못한 거 같아요. 후반에도 탈락자가 생기면 더 보기 좋아질 거 같았는데 이미 많이 떠난 거 같더군요. 저같은 경우도 초반 기획사 돌때말고는 한편도 보지 않았거든요. 스키즈는 은근 반전이었습니다. 앞으로가 개인적으로 기대되네요! 추가적으로 개인적으로 당시의 대중의 시선은 영상과 같았다고 봐요. 근데 영상 촬영이 끝나고 업로드가 일주일 지나고나니 점점 기울던 믹스나인은 더 기울고 스키즈는 점차 상승했다고 보네요 :)

[@muichirotokitotokito6819]

stray kids my fav

[@안졸리나-f5b]

프로듀스 훠~얼신 전에 빅뱅ㆍ위너ㆍ아이콘ᆢ 모두 이런씩의 과정으로 데뷔했음 말하자면 그걸 범위를 넓힌느낌? 인원이 확 줄어들수록 좀더 개개인의 케릭터가 돋보일거 같음 더유닛ㆍ스트레이? 딴 프로는 재미가 없어서~별관심이 없음

[@잡덕잡덕-n7m]

근데 솔직히 믹스나인,스트레이키즈,더유닛 순으로 인기인듯

[@hanumkhirid6570]

I LOVE STRAYKIDS

[@astiraoktaviani3032]

Ilike mixnine ❤❤

[@ygrrr820]

애초에 스트레이 키즈는 그렇게 접근하는 게 웃기지. 그건 한 회사에서 데뷔할 아티스트를 위한 리얼리티 프로그램이지 믹스나인이나 더 유닛처럼 방송사 차원의 서바이벌 프로그램이 아닌데. 그리고 결국 믹스나인, 더 유닛 나온 확립된 소속사도, 색깔도, 정체성도 없는 어중이떠중이들 보다 스트레이 키즈가 훨씬 잘 나갈 거다. 기획사 틀에서 내는 런칭 프로그램 말고 방송사 차원에서 돈욕심으로 애들 볼모 삼아 하는 저런 서바이벌 프로그램 존재 자체가 문제임. 특히 프로듀스 같은 거.

[@꿀정-u6d]

믹스나인이 자극적인 것 도 있지만 재밌는 거 같다.

[@FOXBEAR]

댓글이나 언급지수보면 확실히 믹스나인이 조금 더 인기 많은가봐요~~!

[@정채원-c6n]

믹스나인은 재미있기도 하고 우리 애들 나와서 봄

[@FOXBEAR]

믹스나인 확실히 재밌다고 생각하네요! 이제 출연자들이 줄어들면 더 괜찮지 않을까싶어요 :)

[@jasminvazirovic5662]

Stray Kids♥️♥️♥️🔥🔥🔥

[@마골-q8x]

전 믹스나인 밖에 안봐용~

[@FOXBEAR]

마골님! 믹스나인 보시는 군여! 저도 실은 믹스나인을 제일 재밌게 보고 있어요ㅎㅎㅎㅎ

[@마골-q8x]

FOXBEAR 넵 ~~ 우태운 개인적으로 제일 좋더라고요 ㅎㅎ (우태운=지코형)

[@FOXBEAR]

아 마골님두?? 저도 응원중인데 생각보다 노래도 잘하고 잘하더라구요! 저도 갠적으로 자신의 꿈을향해 도전하는 우태운 응원하고있어요!

[@황윤영-t3d]

여러사람의 의견을 보는거 같아 좋긴하지만 스키즈 데뷔전팬인 제가 볼때는 스트레이키즈는 폭망이다 노잼이다 이런말들만 계속 하니까 기분이 좋을수만은 없는 말들이 많아 보는데 썩 좋진 않았던것 같아요

[@FOXBEAR]

네 그래도 자연스러운 의견이다보니까요 :) "아 이렇게 보신분들도 있구나!" 정도로 봐주심 감사드리겠습니다!! 날 더운데 시원한 하루 보내시길 바라요 댕댕님~~~!!

[@ki-jingchoi418]

연습생들 내보내는 건 상관없는데 왜 데뷔 한지 얼마 안되는 신인들을 내보내는 건지 모르겠음 그리고 믹스나인은 그렇게 편집하면 연습생들을 어떻게 투표 하라는 건지 모르겠음

[@farhiyoexo-l9512]

stray kids🤛🤛

[@빛희-p2d]

썸네일 보고 옴 아 루빈아 존잘

[@martinamartins9595]

Honestly. I prefer The Unit i love the concept giving chance to idols who failed but in terms of performance MixNine is better though the editing sucks and I dont like the Boys Vs Girl concept. Please support Eujin of BigFLo in The Unit, ilike this guy and Jun of Ukiss.

[@홍영표-b1c]

더유닛은조명받지못한멤버에게뜰기회를주는첫기획처럼진행되길바라고개인적으론믹스나인이더재미있는데연습생들이악마편집때문에이미지가상하지않을까걱정~띄워주는연습생이너무눈에뜨임

[@FOXBEAR]

그렇죠 영표님. 계속같은 패턴의 서바이벌 프로그램이랄까요. 프로그램이 너무 많기도하고 뻔하게 다가오는 게 있는 거 같아요.

[@leeantoniooo]

양현석만 없으면 완벽한 믹스나인... ☀️믹스나인 김국헌,김상진,신준섭에게 관심을 가져주세요 여러분☀️

[@djavfosm194]

1ovely _soon : 양현석이 없으면 애초에 님이 응원하시는분들 티비에 나올수가 없었을텐데요..ㅡㅡ양싸 좋아하진 않지만 믹스나인 자체가 양싸가 하겠다고해서 만들어진거임..

[@FOXBEAR]

전 초반에 신선하고 와이지의 존재감에 재밌게 봤는데 여러 잡음과 현재는 출연자가 너무 많아서 누구를 응원하려 선택하기에는 좀 어렵더라구요 ~!

[@leeantoniooo]

djavfosm194 제가 응원하는 애들 이미 올해 7월에 데뷔 해서 티비 나오고 있었던 갓신인 애들이에요 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ ㅠㅠ

[@djavfosm194]

1ovely _soon : 누군진 모르겠지만 응원 많이하세요~^^

[@leeantoniooo]

djavfosm194 넵 화이팅^__^!

[@sunblee88]

믹스나인 꿀잼

[@FOXBEAR]

칠성님은 믹스나인 재밌게 보시는군여! 후후 저도 좀 인원이 많은 부분을 제외하면 재밌더라구여 특히 초반부!

[@마성의귀요미]

더유닛 믹스나인 둘다 재미없게 봤음. 더유닛은 예빈 솜이보는 재미로 보긴했는데 사실 둘다 거기서 거기. 프로듀스나 한번 더 봅시다

[@skyy1436]

But i like the unit and mix nine 😄

[@mellowmell497]

i watched both mixnine and the unit...... in my opinion.... mixnine contestants r more tallented .... but the unit kinda like better.... cos mixnine seems to criticize the contestants alot like hurting their pride while the unit inspires them alot.......i think yg doesn't seems to care about hurting others feelings.....for me i think treating others like low lives is kinda hard to watch but they surely have my fav contestants so i just keep watching.....anyway since the unit r failed idols and mixnine r trainees and so on,,,ummm.....i think,,,,mixnine r youthful,fresh and tallented.....while the unit is mature and inspire the failed idola alot,,,,,i think it's an important thing to boot up failed idols cos many groups used to debut alot in a year and only one to two idol groups will be recognized by people...... small and unsuccessful companies also pay alot and gave their all to debut a group even letting them perform at a music program already needs lots of money.... sometimes i used to wander while watching music programs how hard it would be for them while we r just sitting infront of out tv thinking 'i don't really like this group,,i like exo twice etc'.......it would be really hard for them......so i think what the unit tries is such a good theme..... all just my personal opinion😸😸😸anyway fighting

[@taehwa72]

근데 YG에서 나오는 그룹들 그러니까 빅뱅 투애니원 위너 블랙핑크 등등 이런 그룹 좋아하거나 YG스타일을 좋아하는 사람들은 믹스나인이 더 좋을꺼고 더유닛는 자기가 좋아하는 그룹이 거기 나와서 보는 사람이 대다수임 스트레이키즈는 뭐 할말도 없고 . 그러니까 정리하면 YG스타일을 좋아하는 사람이면 믹스나인 , 경쟁 그러니까 연습생들이 기싸움하는 게 재밌으면 더유닛 뭐 스트레이키즈는 추천하지 않음

[@djavfosm194]

Taehwa Lee ㅇㅈ..

[@FOXBEAR]

네 다양한 취향대로 선택할 수 있는 프로그램들 같아요~! 근데 우리 멤버들과는 다르게, 저는 개인적으로 점점 서바이벌 프로에 지쳐간달까요?ㅜㅜ

[@taehwa72]

저도 보면서 너무 진부하다고 느껴졌어요 ㅠㅡㅠ 그래도 좀 나은건 믹스나인이였어요

[@FOXBEAR]

그쵸? 저도 다른 프로들은 영.. 흥미가 안생기더라구요 그나마 믹스나인은 프듀를 좀 더 발전시킨 느낌에다가 초반 다른 기획사 찾아가는게 재밌어서 봤네요!

[@박동규-v1q]

데뷔조 버스는 식스틴이 더 먼저였을텐데

[@0태식-x2h]

실력믹스나인이더좋은데

[@bjs4166]

mix9 is the worst survival program made by YG if compared to WIN / M&M im not watched the unit and stray kids soo idk..